Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

WHAT DO YOU MAKE OF THIS ??

WHAT DO YOU MAKE OF THIS ??

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 29 Aug 2005

WAHEGURU JI KA KHALSA WAHEGURU JI KI FATEH. I read in a book by Saroop Singh Alagg regarding "SHARDHA". This Sadh/Baba Ji used to be a derawaadee. Once after he had Sukhasan Guur Ji Birr and gone to sleep....he FELT very very UNEASY. He felt like he was sleeping on nails... Around Midnight after failing to fall asleep, he got up, gathered some Sikhs, went into the Sukhasan Room and brought out Guru Granth ji Sahib and Did PARKASH. Then He cleaned Guru Ji's AAngs one by one....and came across some ROSE PETALS that had been left INSIDE Guru Ji Birr. THATS the "cause" of my unease Baba ji announced to all the snagat present. Then He did Ardass, begged forgiveness..and Re did SUKHASAN. The next morning baba ji announced that from that moment he slept so soundly and Guru Ji appeared in his dream and Thanked Him. MY QUESTION... a few rose petals in Guru Granth ji resulted in baba ji not being able to sleep soundly... BUT there nearly 2500 Guru Granth Sahib Jee's Birrs ( many of them handwritten and historical) were BURNT/BLOWN to pieces by Gunfire...in 1984. There still exists a GURU GRANTH SAHIB JEE thta has a BULLET lodged inside it and lots of blood of the Paathee Singh who was shaheed on it while doing paath.... Many Many Birrs of Guru Ji were BURNT all across PUNJAB/HARRYANA..during Sant Sipahi jarnail Singh Ji's time prior to 1984 bluestar... Bhaniara and many others have treated Guru Sahib Jee very badly, almost every month we get news of Guur Granth Ji's BURNT in Gurdwaras by Miscreants... Go back to NANKANNA SAHIB 1920's..MAHANT NARAINUU burnt to Death 120 SINGHS...SHOT GURU GRANTH full of bullets.... But I have NOT heard any news of any SINGLE BABA JI from any DERA that couldnt "sleep soundly"..during all these incidents ??? Has anybody any news about this ?? Surprising that a few rose petals left accidentally in a Sroop of Guru granth Ji can cause a MAHANT DERAWADEE SADH to have a sleepless night....BUT thousands upon thousands of GURU SROOPS burnt/shot/destroyed/beadbee..and NOT a Single sadh/sant/derawadee had the slightest "unease".... 200,000 SINGHS made to "disappear" in PUNJAB from 1978-2005....not one derawadee has raised even a small WHIMPER of PROTEST...???? Its a strange way of showing "shardha" thing !!!! I am Sure GURU JI would be more concernd with Thousadds of His beloved Singhs being martyred...and not a few rose petals left behind among the Aangs....This is deliberate AANDH WISHWAASH....to spread the "powers of his holyness" among the anndhwishwashee followers !!!

Re: WHAT DO YOU MAKE OF THIS ??

Me · 29 Aug 2005

So you actually believe the story? Which means you believe that Sants do exist and they are very close to Guru Jee, ok first point established. Now, there is no doubt in normal rational people's minds that all true Sants of Maharaj are saddened by the 1984 acts, do they go around proclaiming their illnesses in order to appease people like you? Do they need to convince us of their pain? Will this affect my Sikhi or yours? 'Gayni', try to be a bit careful in your sant bashing campaign outbursts, the holes have begun to show.

Re: WHAT DO YOU MAKE OF THIS ??

John Singh · 29 Aug 2005

"Me" brings up a good point though. There may have been many baba's who have had problems due to the 84 era, but may not have been public about it or the people close to the baba may know but have not made it public. The above story may have been tols to S. Alag by a close person to the baba. There is a similar story in the "se kinahiaa" book about Baba Harnaam Singh and also about Baba Jarnail Singh Bhindrawale who was travelling via bus and a gutka fell at his feet but he was asleep when he woke in the morning, he cried and cried, and did not eat for 7 days and completed a full sehaj paat for forgiveness before he ate anything. You could say "gutkaas faal all the time why doesn't so and so Baba feel bad?" Well they do. I think the above story is saying that it was the Baba's lapse in seva which kept him up that night. The Guru works in different ways on diferent people we can't generalize through logic as gyani has done above in all cases. There are similar experiences in the life of Baba Nand Singh aswell. Maybe the Baba has loved Guru jee in a different way than you, may be his sgardaa is more innocent than yours, hence he was shown in a diiferent way. Gyani you should ask yourself to and so should all of the rest of us, do we realy feel bad in our hearts about what has happened over 84 era. Forget about the Baba, are we not to look at what we have? Gyani did you go to Punjab in that era and do parchaar? How have your bad or good feelings helped the panth. And if you list the ways in which you have helped the panth, then you are no different that the Baba's, trying to sell there good deeds to the public. I hate to be bold but we have to look at all aspects before we concentrate on a single story. FYI - There were many Sikhs who could not sleep properly during that time including many Baba's , but they did not need to call ajitjalandhar to let them know of there sleeplesness.

Re: WHAT DO YOU MAKE OF THIS ??

kulbir Singh Dhillon UK wala · 29 Aug 2005

Well said Veer Jarnail Singh Ji... No doubt that these mahant/sants do parchar, kirtan (kachi-bani?), and join the innocent sanghat to Guru Sahib, via Amrit sanchar, but lets look closely....come join me... To them its just a job/career, the sant thing....money is good, very good and you are treated better than any CEO. that i know of, even better than India's CM's! Though you are told that Guru Sahib is your Guru, they do not want you to forget that THEY were the bachorle, and that they helped this transission to mature, right? Thus some of you new-amrit-sakh-wale-via,-babe-sanghis do feel you owe them something, right? and some feel they owe them more, right? (Just like a bophari selling his product/service in the marketplace, they too sell you your Amrit sanchar, at a price, for unkowningly you will do the marketing for this baba/sant/mahant, for free, and the "word-of-mouth" technique is very useful!!) Yes your now are Member of the Khalsa, but 'Baba ji and his great kerpa, his bhramgain, his blessing helped this to become true', right? Is it me, are most of us blind to the reality? Next time any baba arrives on the shores of our countries, ask them to make a stand about any of the controversial topics between the GOI and Sikhs....tell them it will be recorded, and then lets see which door they choose to exist from... Mann of pehowa, and this is heard with my own two ears, on many occasions, used to trash talk Mahan Surma Baba Jarnail Singh khalsa, saying he was not smart with his approach to the events of the 1980's, that the taksal was backward, that so many innocent youth lost there lives, for nothing... Honestly, its like flogging a dead donkey....let the sant/mahant chele find out the truth themsleves....kind of getting tired of trying to help out others, form my own personal past experiences with mann of pehowa...who still does not have the guts to visit UK, USA, Canada...only Africa and India these days...WHY, IF THEY WERE ONLY ALLEGATIONS, WITHOUT SUBSTANCE, THEN WHY IS HE ACTING LIKE A GUILTY MAHANT/SANT???????? Enough said. Kulbir Singh Dhillon UK wala

Re: WHAT DO YOU MAKE OF THIS ??

Jarnail Singh Gyani Arshi · 29 Aug 2005

YES..Dear "Me" and .....John Singh Ji... ALL I am asking is WHY not THOUSANDS and THOUISANDS of SUCH STORIES ?? The SHARDHWAAN SAADHS should be having "nightmares" and sleepless nights..tossing and turning...at ALL the HORRIBLE THINGS that happened from 1978 - 2005... YET there is a DEAFENING SILENCE on this MATTER...from ALL DERAS. Not a Single sant is doing nay such work as Produced by the Tabbeh Ros Jagiyo DVD maker Dr Udoke ?? Anyone knows of any such DVD coming out by a SANT/MAHAPURASH ?? ZERO a BIG FAT ZERO. But we have thousands of DVDs of Kacheh Diwans full of Kache Dhageh....being woven to Jharr money from the sangat through Kan rass. This DEAFENING SILENCE is very difficult to explain away in this frivolous manner....not to deiscerning readers. What is worse is NOT a SINGLE SANT or DERA is contributing or distributing Dr Udoke's DVD tabbeh Ross Jagiyo ?? cant they contribute some of their huge funds ?? Why not ?? None of the SANT DERA WADDEE SITES on the internet carry any such Materials or stories....BUT they have PLENTY of FAKE stories glorifying their own great babas.... TRUTH is stranger than FICTION.

Re: WHAT DO YOU MAKE OF THIS ??

Me · 29 Aug 2005

Why dont you release some DVD's to make up for this great loss and 'deafening silence', you are a Gayni after all.

Re: WHAT DO YOU MAKE OF THIS ??

gupt · 29 Aug 2005

wt do u know gyani ji ? the brahmgyani sant who is the avtar at the mauka have to take bhar of all this beadbi on their sareer . there is pehra of guru nanak in kalyug in 10 pragat form , jugo jug atal guru granth sahib ji and 72 jaame gupt form in hirdae of pooran sants .so they have to take all the responsibility and u won't know these things unless u have dib drishti

Re: WHAT DO YOU MAKE OF THIS ??

Hari Singh · 29 Aug 2005

Me jee, you said, >>> So you actually believe the story? Which means you believe that Sants do exist and they are very close to Guru Jee, ok first point established. >>> Please explain your logic. How did you draw this conclusion from Jarnail Singhs' post. I think the last sentence in his post makes his beliefs quite explicit on the matter. he said, "This is deliberate AANDH WISHWAASH....to spread the "powers of his holyness" among the anndhwishwashee followers !!!" In the future, please read the post carefully before replying.

Re: WHAT DO YOU MAKE OF THIS ??

.... · 29 Aug 2005

Well said John Singh.... everyones experiences are personal, therefore it is upto them whether they share them or not... who are we to say anything! What we should be saying is "what am i doing"... if you feel so passionate then do something.

Re: WHAT DO YOU MAKE OF THIS ??

Me · 29 Aug 2005

Hari Singh, thanks for quickly coming to Gayni's defence, his argument is based on the fact that he believed the story that the Sant couldnt sleep all night due to the beadbi, so naturally he believes that Sants are close to Vaheguru and miracles can occur because of them. If he doesnt believe this, then he is even more confused than before because he's using a concept he doesnt even believe in to convey his point.

Re: WHAT DO YOU MAKE OF THIS ??

Hari Singh · 29 Aug 2005

>>> Hari Singh, thanks for quickly coming to Gayni's defence, his argument is based on the fact that he believed the story that the Sant couldnt sleep all night due to the beadbi, so naturally he believes that Sants are close to Vaheguru and miracles can occur because of them. >>> You have completely missed the point that Jarnail Singh was trying to make. Jarnail Singh didn't belive the story. Infact his post is quite clear in conveying that he belives the story to be made up. Please read the last sentence of his post. But this doesn't mean that real sants don't exist. The two ideas aren't mutually exclusive. >>> If he doesnt believe this, then he is even more confused than before because he's using a concept he doesnt even believe in to convey his point. >>> Please go back and re-read Jarnail Singh's post. I think you've misinterpreted his words. Perhaps taking off the anti-Jarnail Singh filter off your glasses might help??? Me jee, out of the 10 posts on the topic, you have 3 directly attacking Jarnail Singh. Come on man, discuss issues and ideas, be mature about this. I'm hardly rushing to anyone's defence, I've never met Jarnail Singh in my life, it is his idea and the content of his post which I'm defending.

Re: WHAT DO YOU MAKE OF THIS ??

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 29 Aug 2005

I didnt even want to comment on the "logic ??" in Me's posts..leaving it to readers to see the sheer "off tangent" view of trying to force his own blinkered views on to me. A veer comments on "Me's anti Jarnail Singh Filter".. i think that is less of a filter and more of a CATARACT...because the ideas seem so small and the "man" seems so BIg !! IN MALAYSIA also such "character assasins"....have been GUNNING FOR me for as long as I can remember. Anybody who wants to receive such Slanderous character assasinations..just open up a Forum and become the "ADMIN" and let my mails be posted...95% of the Posts aginst me will be PERSONAL character assasination and only 5% will discuss the ideas i put forward. Then you will really know how Vicious and poisonous these so called "sant chelas' can be ( BUT 100% of the time they will be so brave that they will be ANONYMOUS!!..i have yet to "meet" a "sant chela" who is brave enough to tell me his actual name and address..even in MALAYSIA !!! They will pretend to say.."Dass is NOT such and such ji, I am neutral Ji..Blah Blah Blah..Dass doesnt belong to this organsiation..blah blah I am just a Guru-Ka-Sikh Ji..blah blah but the reality is entirely different !! beleive me !! This is a general post per se... i dont know "me" personally and have never met him/her..no offense meant or taken. My personal benti..discuss the ideas..not my life or character.

Re: WHAT DO YOU MAKE OF THIS ??

Singh · 30 Aug 2005

Giani Jee and others, please do not take notice of idiots, let them talk their cr@p. Its only them who are going to lose out.

Re: WHAT DO YOU MAKE OF THIS ??

Me · 30 Aug 2005

>>I didnt even want to comment on the "logic ??" in Me's posts..leaving it to readers to see the sheer "off tangent" view of trying to force his own blinkered views on to me.<< Im a female Me. Wow, thanks for leaving it to the readers to make their own minds up, now if only you could keep that up instead of spamming the forum with anti sant posts every 3 minutes. >>A veer comments on "Me's anti Jarnail Singh Filter".. i think that is less of a filter and more of a CATARACT...because the ideas seem so small and the "man" seems so BIg !!<< I dont understand which man you are talking about. <> Sants have always had dogs barking at them because they are mad, its not really their fault, I dont know Gayni and trust me I have no wish to know you, your posts say it all, thats why people, many people have a problem with you. However, if you want to know my name and address, give me your email ID and Il gladly forward it on to you, be fun to see what you do. >>This is a general post per se... i dont know "me" personally and have never met him/her..no offense meant or taken. My personal benti..discuss the ideas..not my life or character.<< You have no real ideas, how you became a Gayni is beyond me. As for Hari Singh, I'd rather not reply to your post, as I said before, Im only commenting on our famous Gayni Jee here, so find someone else to defend.

Re: WHAT DO YOU MAKE OF THIS ??

Bundha · 30 Aug 2005

Me Kaur Ji, outwardly some 'gursikhs' may have long flowing beards and khoob surat dastaars but inside their is NOTHING, these empty vessals make the most noise. I am tired of their one issue agendas and one issue postings, they are putting the noose around their heads and hanging themselves. My only concern is the impressionable youth who are influenced by their rantings. [%sig%]

Re: WHAT DO YOU MAKE OF THIS ??

Singh2 · 30 Aug 2005

Me, find someone else to attack....like yourself. As 'Singh' said, dont pay attention to losers like 'Me'.

Re: WHAT DO YOU MAKE OF THIS ??

Me · 30 Aug 2005

Bundha, I sympathise, its true what you say, outwardly anyone can create an impression. Very hard to change the views of people who are so conditioned they dont even know they are conditioned. I think there are some youngsters who dont pay attention to these losers, like myself. Singh2, Il attack whoever I want, dont need your permission or advice, even losers like 'you'.

Re: WHAT DO YOU MAKE OF THIS ??

Admin. · 30 Aug 2005

Topic locked. Admin.