Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Master Tara Singh Ji

Master Tara Singh Ji

R.singh · 28 Aug 2005

Master Tara Singh was born in a Punjabi Hindu Malhotra family of Rawalpindi. It is indeed remarkable that from humble origins he arose to the top of Sikh leadership, culminating with the creation of Punjabi State in Independent India. He initiated into Khalsa when he was ten or twelve years old. A fierce sewadar and helpful to all Sikhs he was among those cream of crop who strive to become a perfect Soldiers of their community. Tara Singh Malhotra is remembered for two things, one steering Sikhs towards opting for India in 1947 and other to campaingn for the state of Punjab in Independet India. His first duty to serve Khalsa on the political arena came when he was invited to Round Table conference at Shimla after the end of the Second World War by the Governor-General, Lord Wavell, to ease the political situation in the country, the Sikhs were given representation along with other communities. Pleading on their behalf, Master Tara Singh who was among the twenty-one Indian leaders invited, argued that the creation of Pakistan would be more injurious to his community than to any other community. He told governor general that Sikhs are scattered all over the Punjab and are not in majority in any district. He vigorously campaigned against the demand of Pakistan by Muslim League and made many enemies. He along with other Sikh leaders met with the leader of Muslim League Mohammad Ali Jinnah at the house of Hardit Singh Malik. Here is a quote from the book "Heritage of the Sikhs by Harbans Singh" "Mr Jinnah, who outwardly maintained an attitude of sullen and studious disregard towards the Sikhs, tried to cajole them privately. He knew in his heart of hearts that Sikh opposition to Pakistan was one real obstacle in his way and made several secret overtures to the leaders of the community. He chided them for being too subservient to Congress influence and held out all kinds of allurements, including the formation of an autonomous Sikh area within Pakistan. Some British of ficers also conveyed similar offers to Sikh leaders "to enable them to have political feet of their own on which they may walk into the current of world history." Plans were made to have Master Tara Singh and Jinnah talk together. A meeting took place in Delhi on April 2, 1946, at the house of Sir Teja Singh Malik, a retired chief engineer who had also been minister in the princely states of Jaipur and Patiala. Besides Master Tara Singh and Jinnah, Maharaja Yadavinder Singh of Patiala, his prime minister, Sardar Hardit Singh Malik who was the host's brother, and Giani Kartar Singh joined the meeting. Malik Hardit Singh was assigned to presenting the Sikh viewpoint as the principal spokesman. Jinnah's one overriding concern was to have the Sikhs rescind theiropposition to Pakistan and lend his demand their support instead. He was prodigal of assurances, and told the Sikh leaders that the Sikhs would have a position of honour in the new State. But he refrained from elaborating. Malik Hardit Singh tried to extract from him a more specific enunciation and raised some concrete issues. He said that in Pakistan there would presumably be a parliament, a cabinet, armed services, and so on. He wished Jinnah to say what exactly would be the Sikhs' position in these and other instruments of State. Jinnah dodged by inviting the Sikhs to set forth their demands in writing and by citing the instance of Zaghlul Pasha of Egypt. Zaghlul Pasha, he said, asked the Copts, the Christian minority, to give him their charter of demands. Without having a look at what was written in document, Zaghlul Pasha signed, "I agree." " That is how I shall treat the Sikhs," said Jinnah. Hardit Singh continued his thrusts and said, "You are being very generous, Mr Jinnah, but how about your succcessors? What is the guarantee that they would implement the assurance given by you?" "My friend, in Pakistan my word will be like the word of God. No one dare go back on it," replied Jinnah. " Since these meetings were private and there was never promised anything on paper, Sikh leaders did not trusted the Promised given to them by Jinnah and were vindicated of their foresight when Pakistan's army launched an attacked against Bengali Muslims in Bangladesh with mass destruction and gross human rights violations. Considering the current pathetic state of minorities like Hindus and Christians, Sikh leaders like Tara Singh did indeed had a great foresight by not believing in the private concessions of Jinnah. After repeated attempts of rioting, Indian leaders agreed to the partition of country . Tara Singh and many Akali leaders were furious as they were going to loose their houses and lands. On March 3 1947, Tara Singh at Lahore along with about 500 Sikhs declared from a dias "Death to Pakistan" when about 50,000+ strong muslim crowd went berserk outsie. Tara Singh and his Akali men narrowly escaped their death, the next day 4th March 1947, wide scale rioting in Lahore and adjoining areas started. As Jinnah had declared "Muslims are no believers of non-violence", each muslim tried to prooved his point by plundering, pillaging, raping and other un describeable acts. Rioting at other places in Punjab stated as a retaliation to the killings by Muslims in Lahore and Rawalpindi. In this greatest holocaust ever, More then one million humans were murdered by Muslims, Hindus and Sikhs in Punjab. Tara Singh migrated to East Punjab and was active in Akali politics until his death in 1967 on the eve when Akali Party was going to form their first government in new state of Punjab. [%sig%]

Re: Master Tara Singh Ji

Sakhi · 29 Aug 2005

He should have opted for Khalistaan when he had a chance, look how we suffer at the hands of Indians now!

Re: Master Tara Singh Ji

gupt · 29 Aug 2005

Baba Nand Singh ji sent a singh to go to Tara Singh and tell him to take whatever land the britishers will give for the sikhs . but in his ahankar he didn't listen and said that " anpad saadhan noo syaasat baare ki pata "( what do illiterate saints know abbout politics ?) the singh came back and narrated the whole story to baba ji . Baba ji took a sigh and said " acha inhaa di marzi kise wele is waqt noo pashtaunge " ( alright ! its their choice sometime they will repent for this ) and we all know what happened in 1984 .

Re: Master Tara Singh Ji

Bhopinder Singh · 29 Aug 2005

I.C.S Kapoor singh wrote about him IN BEDIAN KE KUL ME PARGTAY NANAK CHAND( ORIGINAL NAME BEFORE AMRIT AND CONVERSION TO SIKHISM) BOHAT SATAYA SIKHON KO BADA PAYA GAND Jinah was working for Moslems and Nehru for Hindus Who was working for Sikhs?

Re: Master Tara Singh Ji

www.sikhpoint.com · 29 Aug 2005

Master Tara Singh Master Tara Singh dominant figure on the Sikh political scene for the middle-third of the twentieth century, was born as one of four brothers and a sister in a Hindu family in a small village called Maryal, in Rawalpindi district, now in Pakistan, on 24 June 1885, and was named Nanak Chand. His father, Bakhshi Gopi Chand, was a Patvari or a subordinate revenue official and later a moneylender, belonging to the Malhotra sub-caste of the Kshatriyas, or Khatris as they are known in the Punjab. Nanak Chand's interest in Sikhism was stimulated while he was still in the primary school by the accounts he had heard of the sacrifices and heroism of the Sikhs at evening meetings organized by his Sikh uncle. For his high school education, he moved to Rawalpindi and there, living among Sikhs, his interest in Sikhism developed further. In 1902 while still a student in the ninth grade, he along with an elder brother and a cousin converted to Sikhism and was named Tara Singh. He received the rites of initiation at the hands of Sant Atar Singh, much honoured in Sikh piety. At school, as later at college, Tara Singh made his mark both in the classroom and on the playfield. After passing high school in 1903, he tried but could not secure admission to medical school because of his short stature. However, he received a scholarship and went to Amritsar to study at the Khalsa College. It was here that he developed interest in politics. This was owing to certain contemporary happenings-the partition of Bengal in 1905, the agitation by Sikh peasantry in Lyallpur in 1907 and the local resistance to government attempts at greater control over the Khalsa College. In this Last, Tara Singh was the president of the students agitation committee, selected primarily because of his talent on the playfield. By the time he graduated from college in 1907, Tara Singh had decided to devote his life to the service of the panth. He joined a teachers' training college at Lahore and, on graduation, like two other colleagues, he offered his services for a nominal salary of Rs. 15 a month if the community would establish a Khalsa high school in Lyallpur. This was a small sum with which to support himself and, already married, his wife. Tara Singh's offer was accepted and at 23, without any teaching experience, he became the school's headmaster, and thus acquired thereafter the honorific "Master". He continued in this position for six years until 1914 when he prepared to leave for England to serve as a granthi (priest), but the outbreak of World War I prevented his departure. He taught for another six years at other schools, but finally in 1920 retuned to Lyallpur. In between, he tried his hand at business, but. did not succeed. The opening of the 1920's marked a new stage in Tara Singh's life, with active involvement in Sikh politics. In March 1921, he was made secretary of the newly established Shiromani Gurdwara Parbandhak Committee, and during the many phases of the Gurdwara Reform movement, he courted arrest several times. In 1923, a large number of Sikh leaders, including Tara Singh, were arrested on charges of sedition and conspiracy. After over two years in jail, they were released in 1926. Tara Singh became vice-president of Shiromani Gurdwara Parbandhak Committee, while the eminent leader, Baba Kharak Singh, was made its president. Tara Singh was now an important political figure, but his rise to the front ranks among Sikh leaders came during the controversy over the Nehru Committee Report, of 1928, embodying a Congress-sponsored constitution for India. During the Gurdwara Reform movement a working alliance had come into existence between the Congress Party and the Akalis. Because of its anti-government nature, the movement was considered part and parcel of the nationalist endeavour. As a result, many Akali leaders simultaneously held important positions in the Congress organization as well. However, these leaders were intensely divided in their attitudes towards die Nehru Committee Report. Tara Singh took up a position which combined opposition to the report with continued support for the Congress Party. In this fashion, he was able to outflank the group led by Mangal Singh that supported the Report and equally the group led by Kharak Singh that had turned completely hostile towards the Congress Party. In the process, Tara Singh acquired a distinctive political role, and emerged as a leader ready to fight for Sikh demands without alienating the nationalist organization. Later, in 1930, when the Congress Party launched the civil disobedience movement, Kharak Singh opposed it, but Tara Singh went to jail in its cause. While in jail, he was elected president of the Shiromani Gurdwara Parbandhak Committee and from that point on until 1962, except for short periods, he retained control of the Shiromani Gurdwara Parbandhak Committee and equally of the Shiromani Akail Dal either directly or through a trusted nominee. The Akah Dal under Tara Singh's leadership remained the most vociferous and militant group in behalf of Sikh demands. During the 1930's, Tara Singh led several agitations first against die British government and then against the government of the Unionist Party in the Punjab. Those against the British government centred around the management of Gurdwaras, the possession of the Shahidganj Gurdwara, and appropriate legislative representation for the Sikhs. The Akali agitation became especially acute at the time of the 1932 Communal Award which gave the Sikhs 19 per cent of the legislative seats and conceded, in effect, a statutory majority to the Muslims in the Punjab legislature. The agitations against the Unionist government were based on the assumption that, despite its secular protestations, the party was essentially a front for Muslim communal domination. As the demand for Pakistan gained popularity, Sikhs trusted Tara Singh to secure them immunity against the Muslim ambition of communal domination. The Akali Dal under his leadership put forth in 1943 the Azad Punjab (Free Punjab) scheme. This scheme essentially involved the reorganization of the Punjab's boundaries in order to give the Sikh community "the balance of power" by excluding Muslim-majority districts. As some Congress leaders seemed to have become resigned to the partition of India as a way of removing the Muslim barrier to independence, the Akali Dal was deeply perturbed and launched a vociferous condemnation of the Congress Party, widening further the breach between the two parties. Tara Singh and the Akali Dal now moved to demand an independent Sikh State : their position was that they were opposed to partition of India because it would split the Sikh community, but if there was going to be a partition then there should be an independent Sikh State. This was the stand taken by Tara Singh at the Simla Conference in 1945, and before the Cabinet Mission in 1946. The Cabinet Mission's proposals were especially disturbing to the Akali Dal, for though no partition was envisaged the Sikhs were being placed under a Muslim majority. At a large meeting in Amritsar in June 1946, Tara Singh asked the panth "to prepare to die in the struggle ahead."Subsequently, on Congress Party's appeal, the Akali Dal accepted the Cabinet Mission's proposals and Baldev Singh became the Akali representative in the Interim government headed by Jawaharlal Nehru. Sikh hopes of concessions from the Muslim League proved illusory, and these were soon shattered as Muslim-Sikh riots erupted. Tara Singh raised protest in Lahore on 3 March 1947 and shouted "Death to Pakistan." Severe communal disturbances followed, with the Sikhs a special target of Muslim rioters. In an environment of impending civil war, the Akali Dal agreed to the Mountbatten plan for partition of India. Notwithstanding the terrible sacrifice visited upon Sikh refugees, the mass movement following the partition created a new demographic fact of a Sikh-majority area in the districts of the Punjab (India) close to West Pakistan. These districts were Punjabi-speaking as against the eastern districts which generally spoke Hindi or dialects of it. Tara Singh and the Akali Dal now centered their demands around this new social fact and pressed relentlessly for reorganization of the Punjab boundaries to create a Punjabi-speaking state (Punjabi Suba). Towards the achievement of this goal, Tara Singh and his party launched several agitations. With the Punjabi Suba slogan agitation in 1955, in which some 12,000 people were arrested, Tara Singh's political power rose to a new peak. Recognizing the extensive popular support in the Sikh community behind the Akali Dal, the government conceded in 1956 the formation of regional committees within the Punjab legislature. In I960, Tara Singh started another massive campaign against the government in which, according to official figures, 30,000 went to jail and, according to Akali reckoning 57,129. This agitation also marked the arrival on the Sikh political scene of a new leader, Sant Fateh Singh, who later wrested the Akali mantle from Tara Singh. Fateh Singh undertook a fast-unto-death in the cause of Punjabi Suba in December 1960, but was persuaded to give it up on the 22nd day. As the government stood firm in its opposition to Punjabi Suba, Tara. Singh himself undertook a fast-unto-death in 1961. The fast lasted 48 days. Under a verdict given by Panj Piare representing the authority of the panth, Master Tara Singh had to undergo penance and expiation for violation of the solemn oath taken before the fast. A major split occurred in the Akali ranks in the aftermath of the fast, with Fateh Singh setting up a rival Akali Dal in 1962. There followed the ouster of Tara. Singh's group from power in the Shiromanl Gurdwara Parbandhak Committee and die bitter struggle between the two groups continued unabated. In early 1965, Fateh Singh's organization defeated the Tara Singh group in the Shiromani Gurdwara Parbandhak Committee elections and thus, along with the power and patronage of Shiromani Gurdwara Parbandhak Committee, the torch of Akali leadership passed to Sant Fateh Singh as also the leadership of the Punjabi Suba movement. Eventually, the government conceded Punjabi Suba in 1966. The Punjabi Suba demand had become synonymous with Master Tara Singh. When he died on 22 November 1967 he had had the satisfaction that his long-cherished dream had materialized, making the Sikhs the dominant political force in the state. With a large following in the Sikh panth, Tara Singh was the pre-eminent and most durable political leader of the Sikhs. He was as well a journalist and newspaper editor as also a writer of fiction and tracts. All these activities were, however, intimately lied with and subordinate to his politics. His leadership in the Sikh community was importantly and deeply involved in the key political concerns of the Sikhs and of the Punjab. Underneath his politics lay a stern and resolute philosophical position. Tara Singh's philosophical position was that the Sikhs organized as the panth were a distinct community, that religion and politics were inseparably linked in Sikhism, and that a territorially based state under Sikh domination was inherent in the Sikh ideology. The impulse to Sikh political power was, indeed, the key dynamic behind Tara Singh's politics over nearly a half-century notwithstanding its many shifts. Loyalty and commitment to the panth constituted Tara Singh's entire political universe; he had little patience with other issues or concerns. He had travelled abroad, including Southeast Asia and England, but was opposed to most aspects of modernity, including movies and dance racitals. At schools and college, he had been called vatta or patthar (stone, rock) for his fearless participation in soccer and hockey; the same drive, persistence and courage characterized his political career. The fact is very interesting. While at school he was nicknamed patthar, he had not mentioned this name to anyone when he joined the college. Yet they discovered the name vatta, nearest equivalent to his school nickname.

Re: Master Tara Singh Ji

The Tribune, Aug. 21, 2003 · 29 Aug 2005

Master Tara Singh By TARLOCHAN SINGH Tarlochan Singh is chairman of India's National Commission for Minorities (N.C.M.). The Tribune, Aug. 21, 2003 At last the nation is paying tribute to the memory of one of its great freedom fighters, Master Tara Singh, by adorning his portrait in Parliament's Central Hall at the hands of Prime Minister Atal Bihari Vajpayee on Aug. 21. Master Tara Singh was the leader of the Akali Dal and the sole spokesman for the Sikhs. He had such authority that one word from him could seal the fate of millions of Hindus and Sikhs. No history book contains any [appropriate] reference to the role of Master Tara Singh. He got half of the Punjab (now Punjab, Haryana and Himachal Pradesh) integrated into India. He was born in a Hindu family in Haryal village, near Rawalpindi, on Jun. 24, 1885. Nanak Chand, as he was then known, got converted to Sikhism at the age of 14 and was baptized by amrit [sweet initiation water] and given the name Tara Singh. It is said that next to Maharaja Ranjit Singh (1780-1839) no Sikh had such vast influence in the community as Master Tara Singh. Every Sikh leader of modern times was in fact his creation. At one time Partap Singh Kairon was his secretary. India's first defence minister, Sardar Baldev Singh, was his nominee. Sardar Swaran Singh was made a minister and leader of the Akali Assembly Party in Lahore by him. Sardar Hukam Singh, who rose to be the speaker of the Lok Sabha, owed his entry into parliament to Masterji. Sardar Buta Singh was picked up by him and made member of parliament in 1962. The demand for partition of the Punjab was first mooted by Master Tara Singh when Strafford Cripps announced his Draft Declaration in 1942. In a memorandum to the Cripps Mission he demanded: 'The Sikhs cannot attain their rightful position or can effectively protect their interest unless the Punjab is redistributed into two provinces with River Ravi as boundary between them. If you can separate provinces from India for the domination of Muslims, how can you refuse to separate a big area for protection of Sikhs from the rule of a single community?' To counteract the Muslim League demand for a sovereign Muslim State, the Akali Dal put forward the demand for a Sikh state. The main aim of the demand was to insist upon the partition of Punjab. Later, they put forward the Azad Punjab scheme. The Punjab had a coalition government headed by Khizr Hayat Khan with the Congress and Akali Dal as partners. In Mar. 1947, the Muslim League succeeded in getting the resignation of Khizr Hayat Khan in order to install its own government. It was due to Master Tara Singh's tough stand that a Muslim League ministry could not be installed in the Punjab. Master Tara Singh took a great risk but there are political thinkers who concede that his action changed the course of free India's history. The Muslims took to communal riots in Lahore and western parts of the Punjab. Thousands of Sikhs and Hindus were murdered and their homes razed. In vengeance they destroyed Master Tara Singh's ancestral home and killed 59 of his relatives. The Hindu leadership, including Bhim Sen Sachar, Gopi Chand Bhargava, Mahasha Krishan, and Mahasha Khushal Chand, formed an anti-Pakistan front, with Master Tara Singh as its sole dictator. The British tried to influence Sikh leaders to side with the Muslim League. Jinnah went all out to win over the Sikhs and offered them an autonomous state within Pakistan. Master Tara Singh spurned all offers and announced his decision to stay with India. The demand for the partition of Bengal, which was also a Muslim majority province, was mooted by the Hindu leaders at the behest of Master Tara Singh. Bengal's leaders, N.C. Chatterjee and Shyama Prasad Mukherjee, acknowledged the support of Masterji after their successful campaign in getting half of Bengal integrated into India. For posterity, it may be added that N.C. Chatterjee, then India's leading advocate, represented Masterji whenever he was prosecuted by the Government of India. This valiant fighter for freedom remained active and went to jail many times in free India, demanding redemarcation of Punjab on linguistic basis. He breathed his last on Nov. 22, 1967.

Mountbatten chooses not to act on intelligence reports

K. Z. Islam · 29 Aug 2005

Mountbatten chooses not to act on intelligence reports K. Z. Islam On 22 July 1947 the Partition Council met and decided to issue a joint declaration that all parties would respect the rights of the minorities. In retrospect, we can see that not the slightest regard was given to this undertaking. The Partition Council meeting was chaired by Mountbatten and those present included Patel, Rajendra Prasad, Jinnah, Liaquat and Baldev Singh. The deliberation of the Council may be summarised as follows: �Statement by the Partition Council. Begins: Now that the decision to set up two independent Dominions from the 15th August has been finally taken, the Members of the Partition Council, on behalf of the future Governments, declare that they are determined to establish peaceful conditions in which the processes of partition may be completed and the many urgent tasks of administration and economic reconstruction taken in hand.� Both the Congress and the Muslim League had given assurances of fair and equitable treatment to the minorities after the transfer of power. The two future Governments re-affirmed these assurances. It was their intention to safeguard the legitimate interests of all citizens irrespective of religion, caste or sex. In the exercise of their normal civic rights all citizens would be regarded as equal and both the Governments would assure to all people within their territories the exercise of liberties such as freedom of speech, the right to form associations, the right to worship in their own way and the protection of their language and culture. Both the Governments further undertook that there should be no discrimination against those who, before August 15th, may have been political opponents. The guarantee of protection which both Governments gave to the citizens of their respective countries implied that in no circumstances would violence be tolerated in any form in either territory. The two Governments wished to emphasise that they were united in this determination. To safeguard the peace in the Punjab during the period of change-over to the new conditions, both Governments had together agreed on setting up a special military Command from the 1st August covering the civil districts of Sialkot, Gujranwala, Sheikhupura, Lyallpur, Montgomery, Lahore, Amritsar, Gurdaspur, Hoshiarpur, Jullundur, Ferozepore and Ludhiana. With their concurrence Major-General T.W. Rees was nominated as Military Commander for this purpose and Brigadier Digamber Singh (India) and Colonel Ayub Khan (Pakistan) were attached to Rees in an advisory capacity. After August 15th, Major-General Rees would control operationally the forces of both the new States in these areas and would be responsible through the Supreme Commander and the Joint Defence Council to the two Governments. The two Governments would not hesitate to set up a similar organisation in Bengal should they consider it necessary. Both Governments had pledged themselves to accept the awards of the Boundary Commissions, whatever these may be. The Boundary Commissions were already in session; if they were to discharge their duties satisfactorily, it was essential that they should not be hampered by public speeches or writings threatening boycott or direct action, or otherwise interfering with their work. Both Governments would take appropriate steps to secure this end; and, as soon as the awards were announced, both Governments would enforce them impartially, and at once. It is to be noted that Mountbatten had very cleverly taken undertaking from the leaders of India and Pakistan that they would accept the Boundary Commission Awards without question. We now come to another episode of how Mountbatten was fully informed of the brewing trouble in the Punjab. In a meeting, held on 5 August 1947 in which Mountbatten, Jinnah, Liaquat, Patel and Captain Savage were present, a full account was presented about the law and order situation in the Punjab. Captain Savage, who was Police Officer employed in the Punjab C.I.D. Control, said that he had been sent down by the Governor of the Punjab Evan Jenkins to make a personal report to the Viceroy. He explained that the C.I.D. Control coordinated investigation of disturbance cases, special interrogation, and intelligence from all sources. Captain Savage related that one of the first instigators of disturbances to be arrested had been one Pritam Singh, an ex-member of the I.N.A. He had been roped in on 4th June, in possession of a wireless transmitter. This man was well known to the Punjab C.I.D. as he had been interrogated after arrest on his return to India some years previously from Chopra�s Penang spy school. He had been one of the party to be landed in Southern India by submarine. Pritam Singh had made a long statement which involved Master Tara Singh in the production of bombs, and a Sikh plan to attack certain headworks. Captain Savage said that the next incident at which men had been arrested was an explosion in the Crown Talkies in Lahore. The main arrest in this incident was of Kuldip Singh, who had joined the R.S.S.S. in February 1947. He was a bomb maker and incendiarist and had done a lot of successful work. He was probably involved in six bomb-throwing cases and had specialised in train wrecking. He was arrested on 30th July. The next man to be arrested as a result of the statement made by Kuldip Singh and his friends of the Crown Talkies and Lyallpur derailing case was Goupal Rai Khosla, a clerk in the Secretariat at Lahore. This man had made a statement which involved Master Tara Singh very deeply. He had seen Tara Singh towards the end of July and had asked for Rs 700 outstanding for the purchase of rifles and for grenades already promised by Tara Singh. He had left one Ram Lal behind with Tara Singh who had got on very intimate terms with him. Ram Lal gave Goupal a note to take to Tara Singh. This contained information concerning trains and was somewhat cryptic. He had asked Tara Singh when he saw him what it was all about, and the reply had been that it referred to the Pakistan special trains carrying staff between Delhi and Karachi. Arrangements had been made to keep Tara Singh informed by wireless of the schedules of the trains. Captain Savage went on to say that Master Tara Singh had stated that four or five young Sikhs were planning to blow up the Pakistan Special with remote control firing apparatus and after wrecking the Special, set it on fire, and shoot the occupants. Tara Singh had also said that Mr. Jinnah should be killed during the ceremonies at Karachi on 15 August. Captain Savage said that independent and highly reliable sources confirmed Tara Singh�s frame of mind as being completely one-track on the subject of revenge on Muslims. Tara Singh was collecting arms through Sikh Army officers and dumping them in States. The Raja of Faridkot had actually given help with transport and other moral and possibly material aid also. Tara Singh was reported to believe that the India and Pakistan Governments were sure to crash immediately. George Abell gave his opinion that Master Tara Singh should most certainly be arrested. Captain Savage said that such a step would certainly create trouble in the Central Punjab. Patel said that he placed no reliance on statements made by arrested people, particularly ex-members of the I.N.A. Captain Savage said that so far as one could be certain in these particular cases, those interrogated had been telling the truth. However, it was very difficult to produce concrete evidence against Tara Singh; but he could be detained under Section 3 of the Punjab Safety Act. Liaquat stated that he had given directions for all the Pakistan special trains to take every possible precaution. A report had come through that a crowd had been collecting at one station and that there was danger of attack on a particular train. He had insisted that the train should go all the same but had strengthened its military escort and arranged for the Inspector General of Police to be informed. In his opinion, the Sikhs were likely to rise in any case on the announcement of the Boundary Commission�s award. Captain Savage gave his opinion that the Sikh Leaders had lost control of their people. However, Giani Kartar Singh was more hopeful that they would get through without major trouble. Mountbatten, after further considering the matter, decided to recommend to the Governor of the Punjab that Master Tara Singh and the other ringleaders of this movement should be arrested at about the time of the Boundary Commission�s award. He asked George Abell to draft a letter accordingly to Sir Evan Jenkins. George Abell wrote the following letter to the Governor of Punjab: �4 August 1947 �My Dear [Jenkins], �I heard Savage�s story at breakfast and then passed it on to H.E. He was having a Partition Council this morning and decided at the end to keep back Jinnah, Liaquat and Patel and get Savage to tell them the story. �Savage told the story very well and it made a considerable impression. After some discussion it was agreed that it would be necessary to arrest Tara Singh and the more hot headed of the Sikhs. The only question was when this should be done. H.E. suggested that probably it would be best to do it at the same time as the announcement of the Boundary Commission�s award. He pointed out that if it was done beforehand the trouble would probably spread and the announcement of an unfavourable award would make conditions even worse on 15 August than they will be if these men are arrested on 12th. �It was agreed that there would have to be a common policy in the matter and H.E. said he would ask you to discuss the matter with Sir Chandulal Trivedi (Governor-designate of East Punjab) and in due course with the premier East Punjab and the Premier (as soon as he is chosen) of the West Punjab. �It was recognized that you might wish for a little more time to consider the matter and possibly after your discussions to make other recommendations, but it was definitely the view of the meeting that �a) the arrests should be made, and �b) that they should not be made for a week or so. �Yours sincerely, �G.E.B. Abell� In actual fact as we shall see no action whatsoever was taken with disastrous consequences as Mountbatten deliberately delayed the announcement of the Boundary Commission Awards. [%sig%]

Mountbatten and the Punjab bloodbath

parsuram · 29 Aug 2005

Savage’s revelations were explosive. He told his audience that the top Sikh leader Master Tara Singh was collecting arms through Sikh officers in the British-Indian army and was dumping them in the princely states.He said that Tara Singh knew that four or five young Sikhs were planning to blow up the special train to Pakistan. He had also threatened that Jinnah would be assassinated during the independence day celebrations at Karachi on August 15. He divulged that Tara Singh was also involved in the production of bombs to blow the river headworks. Upon hearing this, the Quaid stressed upon Mountbatten to immediately arrest all the involved Sikh leaders but Sardar Patel emphatically opposed his suggestion. As a compromise Jinnah agreed to the proposal that the Sikh leaders would be arrested with the announcement of the Punjab Boundary Commission Award, which was then expected to be made public on August 10, 1947. [%sig%]

Re: Master Tara Singh Ji

Spectrum · 29 Aug 2005

Speech by Sardar Tarlochan Singh in Rajya Sabha August 11, 2005 while Debating the Nanavati Commission Report on Sikh Carnage, 1984 Chairman Sir, the debate has been going on for the last two days but I think the main issue is sidetracked. We have been raising new political slogans both in the Rajya Sabha and the Lok Sabha. We are also embroiled in the political battle and we are trying to run down one another. But we forgot to talk about thousands of hapless people who were butchered during the Sikh carnage and so far not even a single person has been punished. Someone is talking about Godhra and someone about Gujarat, BJP or Congress. But at the moment we are only concerned with the point that the Government has maintained a stoic silence about the citizens of this country who were killed during the riots. The Hon’ble Prime Minister stated yesterday that we would search out the truth. Surprisingly, twenty years have passed but we are still not even near to the truth. As many as nine Commissions were set up to inquire into the riots. It appears to me that Justice Nanavati had a lurking fear in his mind and that is why the Commission went quite close to the truth but moved backwards. I do not want to read the Report because its contents have already come to the fore. He has mentioned at two places. All the Members of the House have a copy of the Report which they may read. At first, He says that there was an organized attack on the Sikhs and secondly people were quite aware that the police would not take any action. The question arises as to who gave this order? The Commission has kept mum on this point and we are also not prepared to listen anything about it. The third point is that how the massacre at such a large scale would have happened without the nod of some powerful person above. Justice Nanavati makes these observations but remains mum after that. Sir, all of us were extremely aggrieved on the assassination of Mrs. Indira Gandhi because she was the leader of the entire nation. But we are surprised that the Sikh carnage had happened in the capital of the country. We have never said that this was done at the instance of Rajiv Gandhi. So far, not even a single Sikh has said so but we fail to understand why all of them are feeling jubilant that the high command has been saved and there is no mention about the high command in the Report. We have never said and not even a single Sikh has ever said that there was involvement of the-then Prime Minister in the organized carnage. But where is the coterie of the-then Prime Minister and where are those who wanted to “teach a lesson”? They are still alive. Hon’ble Deputy Chairman, I would make only two three points. The matter is quite clear. One member has said that such a long time has passed since the occurrence. But I would say that a Sikh never forgets the past and we will never forget it. We still read out daily in Ardas in our Gurudwaras and remember the martyrdom of the Sikhs killed during the invasions of Abdali and others. There is nothing to forget. Tinache was residing in London after escape from Argentina after committing big crime but the House of Lords punished him and deported him back to Argentina. This happened just two months back. What happened in Bosnia? The Muslims were massacred in Bosnia and today the President of Bosnia is being questioned after summoning him in the World Court. Why is it being done? Moreover, Nazis had massacred Jews about sixty years back but the Nazi leaders are being hunted out and punished even today. These things are not to be forgotten and nobody spares the offender. The criminal will have to be punished one day or the other. Now it is quite clear that the Government is not prepared to find out the truth. The Govt. gives only the assurance that “ we will see” and “we will do” but no-one is satisfied with that. I must go on record here that the Sikhs all over the world have come out on the roads in protest. This shows that no Sikh is happy after this Report and the Govt. of India’s action taken report. The police has destroyed the entire record and consequently there is no FIR. I know that nobody will be punished or sent to jail on the basis of any investigation. I plead to the Govt. through you to take two sets of action. First, to set up a “ Truth and Reconciliation Committee” as it was done by Nelson Mandella when the South Africa became independent. We Sikhs do not want to punish anybody. Sikhs believe that whosoever seeks forgiveness must be forgiven. But those who had done excesses and committed the heinous crime must first admit their crime honestly and apologize sincerely. We will forgive them. Secondly, we demand that the Government, rising above the party-politics, should clearly name all those persons who are guilty and they must seek pardon. The Hon’ble Prime Minister has just apologized in the House. When the gas tragedy of Bhopal and the serial bombast in London had occurred, we had passed condolence resolution in both the Houses. This House should apologize clearly to the Sikhs. The Govt. should bring a Resolution in both the Houses that we apologize to the Sikh Community and admit that whatever had happened was wrong. We do not know which Govt. was in power during that time, Congress or BJP. Government is a continuous process hence no demarcation can be made between one Government or the other. The Hon’ble Prime Minister should move the Resolution in both the Houses. This will provide some comfort to the afflicted and aggrieved Sikh Community. This will assure the Sikh society that the entire nation is with them. Sir, the Sikhs have been praised and appreciated profusely. This is quite good. But I would like to remind you that during 1947, Sikhs had an option whether to live in Pakistan or to migrate to India. M.A. Jinah gave a blank chouse to Master Tara Singh to write anything he liked but Sikhs should stay in Pakistan. This is on record and published in all British documents. But Sikhs decided to move to India. Pakistan was our birthplace and Nankana Sihib, the birth place of our Guru Nanak is also there. We came to India in a pitiable condition, wounded and bleeding all over. It was only because of Master Tara Singh who was the leader of the Sikhs that Punjab was divided otherwise the border of Pakistan would have touched Gurgaon. But Sikhs sided with this country got Punjab divided into two and gave one half to you. Without boasting of any favors on this, I would say that we sacrificed our lives for this country. We were and still we are with the people of India. We never retreated. But we are extremely aggrieved that miseries and the atrocities done on us are being politicized. People talk in different voices. The Sikh psyche is still hurt and it will remain so despite all lectures and debates on the issue. This cannot be forgotten for centuries together. This was a great tragedy happened at such a large scale and this is a blot on the face of the country. This has brought infamy to India through out the world as the tragedy had happed in Delhi, the capital of India. Therefore, the ifs & buts and whats & whys are irrelevant and meaningless. The issue before the Parliament is what the Commission has done? Personally I am not in favour of any Commissions. Commissions are set up to buy time and avoid public fury. Commissions’ reports are meant to be consigned to archives. There are 40 to 50 reports of various Commissions gathering dust in our offices. My brethren belonging to minorities are sitting here and I want to tell them not to repose trust with Commissions as no action has ever been taken on the Report of any Commission so far. This Government simply wants to gain time. Thank you. [%sig%]

Re: Master Tara Singh Ji

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 29 Aug 2005

imho it is very easy to write things when we have complete knowledge of what really happened ?? Who could have guessed that the Bippar Bannia Combine of Nehru/Gandhi/Patel etc would be so viciously TREACHEROUS. ( HIND SIGHT is a Good TEACHER..but it only comes AFTER the event and not before !!) So we have HIND SIGHT..but not Master Ji. It is downright "a hit below the belt" to bring in the HINDU background of Master Ji ( as an implied reason for his alleged failures !!) 99.99% of SIKHS came from HINDUS....some earlier and some later.. BADAL has been a Sikh family for much longer than master Ji....Can anybody claim that BADAL has NOT DESTROYED MORE Sikhs and SIKHEE than ALL the 1947 Akali leadership combined ?? IF Badal had been leader in 1947...we can well imagine what would be our situation TODAY ?? Another reason for master Ji's failure is the Good number of SIKH TRAITORS like baldev Singh . Can anyone reasonably assume that Nehru would give such a VITAL Department as DEFENCE to a " REAL SIKH" ?? NEVER. Nehru would never trust a Sikh but he really would trust a TRAITOR. 1. Sikhs were a MINORITY in EVERY DISTRICT in PUNJAB. It was an uphill battle to get a homeland on our own merit..and the treacherous horse trading of Nehru etc was difficult to counter by the well meaning sikh leadership..Sikhs were never politicians..and horse trading is always a politicians job.

Re: Master Tara Singh Ji

vichar · 30 Aug 2005

this the same singh bhai sahib called mangta (begger)?

Re: Master Tara Singh Ji

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 30 Aug 2005

Its a Historical Fact that IF NOT for Master Tara Singh Ji and His SHIROMANI AKALI DAL...the Boundary of Pakistan today would be at JAMUNA...Delhi. and "Sikhs Homeland" would be part of Pakistan . Only Master Tara singh and His Akali Dal whcih had fought the British in the Gurdwara Sudhaar Movement to oust the Mahants and saadhs form the Gurdwaras and DEFEAT the British.. had the "moral authority" for the British to consult them about Sikh Rights...there was NO OTHER LEADER in SIKHS who had this Authority to deal with the British. The SHIROMANI AKALI DAL was the One and ONLY SIKH BODY with Sikh kaum at its back...and Master Ji was its Leader....until the 1960,s when the GOI once again won the "battle" and BROUGHT in TWO SAADHS * Sant fateh Singh nad Sant Channan Singh.... from Gnaganagar to Capture Both the Akali Dall and the SGPC...and run it like a fiefdom for many years and destroy it from within...SANT FATEH SINGH set a fine example of SANTGEE by doing an ardass and then BACKING AWAY to save his life..until the "Communists" in the form of Tohrra took over for the next 26 years to pass the empty shell of the Akali Dall and SGPC to Badal to fiinsh it all off...so NOW we have what we got... as i said it is very easy to note things with the help of hindsight..IF Master Ji could have had the "FORESIGHT" and see what the Panth/Sikhs are in 2005..in 1946..He would have made different demands !! History always repeats..in 2005 the Guru Khalsa Panth is at the same crossroads it was in 1920..at that time it was the British Govt sponsored MAHANTS who had our Gurdwaras..Now it is the GOI sponsored MAHANTS.

Re: Master Tara Singh Ji

daas · 31 Aug 2005

Master Tara Singh and all others who betrayed the Sikh panth in 1947 will be remembered as "Qaum de Gadaar" in the history books and they will never be forgiven by us and the future generations to come.

Re: Master Tara Singh Ji

Bhopinder Singh · 31 Aug 2005

The treaty of anexation of Pujab after the battle of Sabrawa stands annuled to this day .Brits know that,unfortunately Sikh leadership of those days were illiterate and knew nothing about global polity . Had they asked the Brits as a signotry to the treaty to fulfill their part of the promise or duty which they were doing and were known for doing, as a impereal power they never broke their treaties. Population would have been of no concern the treaty say everything Sikhs would be given their kingdom back if and when we live it is a solemn promise on the part of the Brit govt. Nobody brought that up.

Re: Master Tara Singh Ji

Harjinder Singh · 31 Aug 2005

I agree with Bhai Sahib Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" Ji [%sig%]

Re: Master Tara Singh Ji

Bhopinder Singh · 31 Aug 2005

Why people talk about George Washington, not only as father of a nation ,but for his vision. The vision of no president will ever have more than two terms ,it stands even today.How could they see so far ahead and read into the mind of humans as haume (ego) is responsible for dictators,tyranny,anarchy and law lessness that to in 1776.THAT IS LEADERSHIP. Why did Clinton say " it is astonishing to believe that a man NANAK existed in the 14 th century whose thinking and vision is perfect for the mordern world " that to when their was no light and no machines just how could he. THAT IS VISION. The Sikhs were no less than thee First non voilent movement of the world was organised by Sikhs Bhai Ram singh and it was very sucessfull later many Gandhis and king luthers followed . THAT IS SIKHI OF SIKHS How would you think if GURU Nanak dev ji had told us earth is stationary and sun revolves around it . We would have accepted than but what about now. It would have been foolish.FOOLISH No doubt N Banerjee was defending him as he had put the entire future of Sikhs to dust and gave Hindus the largest kingdom they could never have dreamt .We would have done the same. AS is written IN HISTORY THEIR HAVE BEEN SUCH INCIDENTS WHEN MOMENTS HAVE MADE MISTAKES AND CETURIES HAD TO SUFFER. I leave it up to you to decide his leadership , vision and what not

Re: Master Tara Singh Ji

reply · 31 Aug 2005

Bhopinder Singh ji, The quote from Clinton is interesting. Do you have a reference where he said that? Also, regarding the annulment of the treaty: Are you basing that on something (such as international law or history) or is this just your opinion? I'm not disagreeing -- it would just be helpful to know. There was also another treaty during Maharaja Ranjit Singh's time among the Sikhs, the British, and the Afghans which was supposed to be "for eternity". There was an article in the Abstracts of Sikh Studies about it as well as a reprinting of the treaty. The article suggested that legal options be explored for reviving the treaty and reviewing the international legal status of Sikhs. Do you have any comment on the treaty with the British and Afghans? [%sig%]

Re: Master Tara Singh Ji

Harjinder Singh · 31 Aug 2005

THE TRIBUNE Friday, November 10, 2000, Chandigarh, India Clinton greets Sikhs WASHINGTON, Nov 9 (PTI) — US President Bill Clinton and first lady and Senator-elect Hillary Rodham Clinton have sent greetings to the Sikh community in the USA on the occasion of the 531st birth anniversary of Guru Nanak Dev. “Though more than 500 years have passed since the birth of Guru Nanak, his life and teachings still hold great power and meaning for humanity in the 21st century,” Mr Clinton said. “This annual Sikh observance reminds all Americans that throughout our history, we have drawn strength from many religious institutions and people of diverse faiths have made important contribution to the life of our nation,” he added. Vishav (World) Sikh News Volume 1, Number 4, December 1997 President Clinton Congratulates Sikhs Across US on Gurpurab President Bill Clinton issued a written statement on November 14, from The White House, congratulating Sikhs across the US on occasion of the Prakash Divas of Siri Guru Nanak Sahib. The statement released by President Clinton is as follows: [i]Warm greetings to Sikhs across America observing the birth of Guru Nanak Dev, the founder of Sikhism. In our country, built by men and women of many nations and many beliefs, it is fitting that we acknowledge the contributions of leaders like Guru Nanak who brought people together around a particular faith. As we search for new ways to ensure that America truly offers opportunities for people of all races, creeds, and backgrounds, it is particularly timely that we recognize the life and teachings of Guru Nanak. His message that everyone is equal in God's eyes and that God's grace is open to all is as appropriate today as it was during his lifetime in the late 15th century. By bringing people of all backgrounds together and advocating service to humankind, Guru Nanak encouraged his followers to build lives of compassion and commitment to justice. As you gather to observe this special day, you can be proud of your many contributions to the strength of our nation and the richness of our religious heritage. Hillary joins me in extending best wishes for a memorable observance.[/i] The VSC-USA sent a letter of thanks to President Clinton on November 16. Sikh Gurdwaras and institutions are requested to send a note of thanks to President Clinton. Sikhs all over the US are reported to have celebrated Gurpurab in a big way. An article relating to Gurpurab celebrations was published by the Record of Bergan County, NJ dated 11/17/97. THE TRIBUNE Clinton greets Sikhs on Guru's b'day WASHINGTON, Nov 24 (PTI) — US President Bill Clinton and First Lady Hillary greeted the Sikh community on Guru Nanak’s birthday yesterday, stressing the value the President attaches to the USA rich diversity of religions and races. The greetings message of the first couple said "Warm greetings to the Sikhs across America as you observe the birth of Guru Nanak... Hillary joins me in extending best wishes for a meaningful observance." "As Americans, we can be proud of our diversity. People of different ethnicities, backgrounds, races and beliefs have contributed to the success of our nation, reflecting the profound truth that this rich diversity is one of our greatest strengths," read the message released yesterday by Dr Rajwant Singh, an active participant in the inter-faith meetings. "The teachings of Guru Nanak, founder of Sikhism, echo this important ideal. Based on the principles of equality, charity and humility, his message encourages us to face our challenges together in a spirit of cooperation, fellowship and hope, he added. "I am confident that we will be an infinitely better, stronger country if our decisions are informed by, driven by, and advanced by people of faith, and I applaud the followers of Sikhism for your efforts to promote spiritual growth and devotion to service. As you gather to celebrate the life and teachings of Guru Nanak and to reaffirm your commitment to the values that guide you, I commend you for striving to create a society united in peace and mutual understanding," the message went on to say. [%sig%]

Re: Master Tara Singh Ji

sarmatian warrior knight · 31 Aug 2005

y r people bein thick for? the sikh leadership was not properly educated or knew that they will be shafted up the backside by india later. Pakistan only became a mate of sikhs during 1984, before that it was a contest of politics land mass pangeh and whos going to rule over us. imagine a border on both sides gets invaded then some idiots here would have complained why did sikhs opt for independance? the fact is plain and clear we have two hostile neighbours. that will always be until there are more sikhs. The idiot argument is pakistan would not attack punjab because it hadnty but if india was not in the way it would do anything. This is not to do with religion or nationhood its all about control power and running resources. Punjab pani, breadbasket fertile lands get it? now what we gona do? first take care of sikhi, stop blaming some leader who clearly hadnt an idea how much damage his decision would cause. Instgead of blaming others under the komb excuse or sikh nation name what have you yourselves done for the sikh nation? our punjabi farmers are starving and dieing, trherfe are 3 million sikhs doing well outside, exchange the currenecy rate from dollar pound to rupees why cant we implement projects ourselves for the sikh punjabi nation? then the next excuse will be we are sikhs and not punjabis. So there lies your problem its just to have a pmt period about something. Whoever is concerned about the sikh religion, nation get together and do something positive for it.

Re: Master Tara Singh Ji

Bhopinder Singh · 31 Aug 2005

sarmatian warrior knight Good name for this debate Did China or India invade Nepal? Yes Pakistan would have never attacked and so would India as it would have been a buffer state between the two Brits were willing to station 200000 troops in Sikh kingdom and they wanted the Sikhs to keep enlisting in the Brit army like the Gorkhas.

Re: Master Tara Singh Ji

singh · 31 Aug 2005

master tara singh was a bigot and a racist. He himself came from a bhaman background but REJECTED dr. ambedhkar and 20 MILLION dalits from converting to sikhism. IMAGINE a world where today we had 20 million CONVERTS to sikhi. Casteism would be gone from our sikh environment and our influence would be exponentionally bigger. for his rejection of the dalits master tara singh will always be a lowlight of sikh leaders.

Re: Master Tara Singh Ji

ksingh · 31 Aug 2005

wjkk wjkf bhupinder singh ji but look at the condition of nepal it is completely lawless.india is supporting the king and china is supporting the maoist guerrillas.many of its districts are controlled by gov and many by maoists. the people of that country are in pitiable condition

Re: Master Tara Singh Ji

Bhopinder Singh · 01 Sep 2005

K singh ji India went through akals ( famine ) and mahamaris even now 40 crore people dont know about next meal according to indian stats although UN has a more larger number. Sikhs were ok then and are still doing good without any Indian help. Not land or rivers or anything but people are our assets. Which group has the largest home ownership in UK Which group has the largest family income in US.

Re: Master Tara Singh Ji

jagira jatt · 01 Sep 2005

bhopinder ji nepal is part buddhist part hindu country not as productive as punjab was in terms of being the grain of india in the past. To invade a place there would need to be productive results. some singhs here are too brainwashed by k propaganda as if one statement actually is a principle that pakistan will follow for all times to come. The facts are there for all to see what happened on the borders in punjab in 70. Jatts historically have no beef with pakistan, they are our brothers, but we are not that stupid to commit suicide again. Its time to use your brain, sikhi is dieing in punjab. There are not many real sikhs left, so who will defend the borders? we need infrastructure, support money and people to back us. the logic that some khalistani types apply seems to say let us jump in the deep end and see what happens. We have tried that and failed. The sikh nation have learnt lessons and matured from its experiences that the only way out of this mess would be to first bring sikhi back into punjab. Then it would need to increase to man borders and finally take back what belongs to the original punjab. singh ji if the dalits really wanted to become sikhs then i am sure nothing would have stopped them if our babey died for sikhi to be sikhs. However most dalits remained hindus and some became buddhists, its their choice. There is no power on earth that should stop a person becoming a sikh. it dep[ends on the reason why you want to become a sikh. One of my irish friends has decided to become a sikh but is having a rough time asnd rejection from the sikh community and his own family but the thirst for sikhi is for naam gurmat and thats it no wordly thing matters. So what our dalit brothers need is to have unflinching spirit in sikhi. Keep kes rehat and done.

Re: Master Tara Singh Ji

Harjinder Singh · 01 Sep 2005

How do we come to know who did the Betrayal and who was betrayed. Betrayal happens only when a person brake the trust of the one who trusted. There are many things in life that are not possible with trusting e.g. a relation such as marriage or friendship. What your vision can do about a relation. It all depends upon mutual commitment toward the mutual promise to keep that relation. The Sikh leadership trusted Indian (or dominently Hindu) leadership more than Pakistani Muslim leadership under the circumstances of that partisan time. When they realized that they were betrayed, they fought back for what they thought the best for the Sikhs. I am not saying that we had the best leaders of all time during 1947 partisan, I rather of the view that Master Tara Singh was one of the honest leaders who could not take wise decision or whose decisions failed due to betrayal by both insiders (many fellow Sikh leaders) and outsiders (Indian Government) but I think they were much better than present Sikh leaders. They represented what majority of the Sikhs felt right at that time and they got full backing for their decisions from the Sikh community at that time. But unfortunately, Actually, we do not have even single capable person whom all the Sikhs can allow/afford to represent them but fortunately it was not the case at the time of 1947. Again, We only need not more that five honest Gursikhs from us to lead us to whom we all trust and back with our spirit and action. Regarding our loss, it was not first time that happened, but I feel that if we have leaders today who are honest and who can go above individuality to represent all the Sikh nation, we still have the potential to change the history in our favour but Shah Mohamda Ik Sarkar Bajho........ Even Guru Gobind Singh Sahib were betrayed by Aurangjeb when they left the Anandpur fort. Guru Sahib made friendship with Bahdurshah who ordered attacks on Sikhs later and finished Baba Banda Singh Bahadur as far as I remember the history that I have read. Does it mean Guru Sahib did not have Vision that Bahadur shah will betray Sikhs later on. No I do not think so neither all of you. Another example that just came to my mind which I would like to share. When a Patit Sikh seek forgiveness and beg for Amrit dee daat from Panj, What is guarantee that Panj get that he/she will not become bemukh again before they forgive the Patit and bless him Amrit dee Daat again. It is just only the trust that you have to do again and again. Guru Sahib is always forgiving and has taught us to be always forgiving. [gurbani] jo srix AwvY iqsu kMiT lwvY iehu ibrdu suAwmI sMdw[/gurbani] Jo saran aavai this kanth laavai ehu biradh suaamee sandhaa || Our Master lovingly embraces whoever comes to his Sanctuary - this is the way of our Lord and Master. Off-course, we might have to price the price again and again for doing this but we must never forget Guru Sahib's order [gurbani]jy koeI inMd kry hir jn kI Apunw gunu n gvwvY [/gurbani] Jae koee nind karae har jan kee apunaa gun n gavaavai Even if someone slanders the a Gursikh (or Har-Jan) , he does not give up his own goodness There many such examples in history. Bhai Sahib Bhagel Singh won and gave away the rule of Delhi more than one time. I would like to quote Bhai Sahib Jarnail Singh Jee's post in another thread Guru Ji DID NOT REJECT ANY PERSON ( Hindu or Muslim..or any other..) Guru Nanak Ji Sahib REJECTED the WRONG BELIEFS of the Hindus and Muslims..not persons !! At another place Gurbani says to "reject" the PAAP...BUT "LOVE" the PAAPEE. When GUru nanak ji REJECTED the Janeau.. He certainly did not REJECT the Pandit as a HINDU..But his WRONG BELIEF in the Janeau. Rejecting a Hindu as a Person and Rejecting the Hindu Beleif are two different things. TO GURU JI ALL HUMANITY..hindus, muslims, jains, buddhists ..ARE ALL HUMANITY///BROTHERS/From the Same Source... so there is no question of rejecting any one. Let me make it clear that IMHO, A Independent Sikh homeland is a must current and short term goal of Guru Panth Khalsa under the Geo-political circumstances of the Sikhs after 1947 in India but this must never be a final and ultimate political goal of Guru Panth Khalsa. We must strive that Khalsa rule this entire Universe one day. We have to continue to follow what Guru Sahib did and taught us to do to make positive progress towards this goal. We have to fight for the sovereignty of Khalsa where ever we live and where ever we go. The first and most important thing that we all can and will have to do is that we will have to make continous efforts to fully implement the Gurmat Rehat in our lives (in other words we will have to really give our head to Guru Sahib and live our live in his Hukum) and help others to understand and do the same. For doing this, we will have to fiight till death against any force that will stop us doing that. If we continue doing this then one day for sure we will have no resistance to the Gurmat anywhere in this Universe. Only then we can say that our dream [gurbani]rwj krygw Kwlsw AwkI rhy nw koie[/gurbani] come true. [%sig%]

Re: Master Tara Singh Ji

Harjinder Singh · 01 Sep 2005

How do we come to know who did the Betrayal and who was betrayed. Betrayal happens only when a person brake the trust of the one who trusted. There are many things in life that are not possible without trusting e.g. a relation such as marriage or friendship. What your vision can do about a relation. It all depends upon mutual commitment toward the mutual promise to keep that relation. The Sikh leadership trusted Indian (or dominently Hindu) leadership more than Pakistani Muslim leadership under the circumstances of that partisan time. When they realized that they were betrayed, they fought back for what they thought the best for the Sikhs. I am not saying that we had the best leaders of all time during 1947 partisan, I rather of the view that Master Tara Singh was one of the honest leaders who could not take wise decision or whose decisions failed due to betrayal by both insiders (many fellow Sikh leaders) and outsiders (Indian Government) but I think they were much better than present Sikh leaders. They represented what majority of the Sikhs felt right at that time and they got full backing for their decisions from the Sikh community at that time. But unfortunately, Actually, we do not have even single capable person whom all the Sikhs can allow/afford to represent them but fortunately it was not the case at the time of 1947. Again, We only need not more that five honest Gursikhs from us to lead us to whom we all trust and back with our spirit and action. Regarding our loss, it was not first time that happened, but I feel that if we have leaders today who are honest and who can go above individuality to represent all the Sikh nation, we still have the potential to change the history in our favour but Shah Mohamda Ik Sarkar Bajho........ Even Guru Gobind Singh Sahib were betrayed by Aurangjeb when they left the Anandpur fort. Guru Sahib made friendship with Bahdurshah who ordered attacks on Sikhs later and finished Baba Banda Singh Bahadur as far as I remember the history that I have read. Does it mean Guru Sahib did not have Vision that Bahadur shah will betray Sikhs later on. No I do not think so neither all of you. Another example that just came to my mind which I would like to share. When a Patit Sikh seek forgiveness and beg for Amrit dee daat from Panj, What is guarantee that Panj get that he/she will not become bemukh again before they forgive the Patit and bless him Amrit dee Daat again. It is just only the trust that you have to do again and again. Guru Sahib is always forgiving and has taught us to be always forgiving. [gurbani] jo srix AwvY iqsu kMiT lwvY iehu ibrdu suAwmI sMdw[/gurbani] Jo saran aavai this kanth laavai ehu biradh suaamee sandhaa || Our Master lovingly embraces whoever comes to his Sanctuary - this is the way of our Lord and Master. Off-course, we might have to price the price again and again for doing this but we must never forget Guru Sahib's order [gurbani]jy koeI inMd kry hir jn kI Apunw gunu n gvwvY [/gurbani] Jae koee nind karae har jan kee apunaa gun n gavaavai Even if someone slanders the a Gursikh (or Har-Jan) , he does not give up his own goodness There many such examples in history. Bhai Sahib Bhagel Singh won and gave away the rule of Delhi more than one time. I would like to quote Bhai Sahib Jarnail Singh Jee's post in another thread Guru Ji DID NOT REJECT ANY PERSON ( Hindu or Muslim..or any other..) Guru Nanak Ji Sahib REJECTED the WRONG BELIEFS of the Hindus and Muslims..not persons !! At another place Gurbani says to "reject" the PAAP...BUT "LOVE" the PAAPEE. When GUru nanak ji REJECTED the Janeau.. He certainly did not REJECT the Pandit as a HINDU..But his WRONG BELIEF in the Janeau. Rejecting a Hindu as a Person and Rejecting the Hindu Beleif are two different things. TO GURU JI ALL HUMANITY..hindus, muslims, jains, buddhists ..ARE ALL HUMANITY///BROTHERS/From the Same Source... so there is no question of rejecting any one. Let me make it clear that IMHO, A Independent Sikh homeland is a must current and short term goal of Guru Panth Khalsa under the Geo-political circumstances of the Sikhs after 1947 in India but this must never be a final and ultimate political goal of Guru Panth Khalsa. We must strive that Khalsa rule this entire Universe one day. We have to continue to follow what Guru Sahib did and taught us to do to make positive progress towards this goal. We have to fight for the sovereignty of Khalsa where ever we live and where ever we go. The first and most important thing that we all can and will have to do is that we will have to make continous efforts to fully implement the Gurmat Rehat in our lives (in other words we will have to really give our head to Guru Sahib and live our live in his Hukum) and help others to understand and do the same. For doing this, we will have to fiight till death against any force that will stop us doing that. If we continue doing this then one day for sure we will have no resistance to the Gurmat anywhere in this Universe. Only then we can say that our dream [gurbani]rwj krygw Kwlsw AwkI rhy nw koie[/gurbani] come true. [%sig%]

Re: Master Tara Singh Ji

Observing · 01 Sep 2005

no better words. excellent. thanks vrg raaj kareiga khaalsaa [%sig%]

Re: Master Tara Singh Ji

Reaserching and Analysing · 02 Sep 2005

BHULAN ANDAR SABH KO ABHUL GURU KARTAR I dont think guru ji trusted opponents in Anandpur siege , but Sikhs made guru ji do what he did , he wanted to fight ,but singhs like Maha singh ji and others thought otherwise and went on to the extent of disowning guru sahib .He knew very well in 5 th jama and 9 th jama what the opponents were up to . VISION of fighting. Guru ji was using diplomacy by helping Bhadur shaw and helping the ordinary man to live a free life as for trusting them with the future he never did. I think you are very wrong in using their actions to justify your point.