Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Coventry Amritsinchar - Manmat?

Coventry Amritsinchar - Manmat?

Gupt Singh · 28 Aug 2005

Vaheguru ji ka Khalsa Vaheguru ji ki fateh Quite abit of time ago there was an Amrit sinchaar held in Coventry were most of the youth (of coventry) had taken Amrit. I wanted to know if this was manmat or if the Amrit sinchar was valid. Because some of the 5 piyare were not rehitvaan naam imbued Gursikhs, some of the panj piayre didn't have naam drir and they were giving it out, and another thing was that some of the panj didn't believe keskhy was kakar, yet they were giving keskhy as kakar out. I believe that one of the panj piayre also said "going pesh is the worst thing a person can do." What is the sangats view on this? [%sig%]

Re: Coventry Amritsinchar - Manmat?

some one... · 29 Aug 2005

when was this??

Re: Coventry Amritsinchar - Manmat?

Pardeep Singh Bilga · 29 Aug 2005

"where most of the youth (of coventry) had taken amrit" Have you been to Coventry and seen the youth? not many look Amritdhari or even kesdhari for that matter

Re: Coventry Amritsinchar - Manmat?

.................. · 30 Aug 2005

your mail is very dubious. Please provide dates and facts, otherwise I would assume you are just stirring an empty pot!!!

Re: Coventry Amritsinchar - Manmat?

Tarsem Singh · 30 Aug 2005

Because the above post is a bit "wishy washy", there is a need for clarification. There have been at least three Amrit Sinchaar programmes in Coventry this year held at different Gurdwaras. The above post CANNOT be refering to the Amrit Sinchaar programme which took place at Singh Sabha Gurdwara on Cross Road, in Coventry (organised by Akhand Kirtani Jatha UK). The prerequisites in that seva were very clear.

Re: Coventry Amritsinchar - Manmat?

Gupt Singh · 30 Aug 2005

This was quite a while back, not the recent AKJ one.

Re: Coventry Amritsinchar - Manmat?

Guru Manyo Granth · 30 Aug 2005

Get your facts right and put some solid facts on the net. Stop spreading rubbish under the name Gupt Singh!

Re: Coventry Amritsinchar - Manmat?

MS · 30 Aug 2005

Gupt Singh, While not speaking in defense of what is clearly manmat practices can I ask a few questions? 1) What is your objective? 2) What are you trying to prove? 3) Do you have a real point or creating pungay for the sake of having them? 4) Do you feel that the way in which you have asked this will lead to any sort of resolution of the problem? I guess my point is that I don't think your really after anyone's opinions but using that to pick at the dogy 'Singhs' who did a dogy Amrit Sanchar. Which is fair enough so long as its done honourably with some nimrata. A bunch of 15yr olds engaging in half talk on the net isnt going to solve anything. If you feel your case is strong, gather evidence, get statements from people who have been in these dogy amrit sanchars, get the evidence of the 'sevadaars' wearing patkas and having bangra coming out of their cars and hand it over to someone older than 15 who will deal with it with a bit more maturity. People come here to read inspirational stories of Gursikhs, seeing all this half talk, in fighting is just going to take people away from Sikhi as has happened with some individuals who have been caught in the middle of this bickerage between the dogy Amritsancar 'sevadaars' and the 15yr old internet warriors who want to do expose these wrong doings. Assuming you were genuinly you could have asked in the following way "Is an Amrit Sanchar where Keski isnt specificied as a Kakar, or where the Panj Singh tell yo going for pesh is wrong or where etc.... is a valid" This would have been equally effective without the punga!

Re: Coventry Amritsinchar - Manmat?

somebody · 30 Aug 2005

Paji, again do you know which Gurdwara?? If you make such accusations after such a long period of time then surely your just making trouble? Either way, someone has also said, have you seen the youth of Coventry? Well i have, 12 new amritdhari lads, most of whom were monay in their upbringing, now all chardikala gursikhs. Many more now keeping kesh and now doing daily nitnem working themselves to give their head. There are still many foolish people in coventry who live without the Guru, jst as there are in every city but if you do not look in the right places, how do you expect to see these people?? Maybe attending the Gurdwara on youth nights but might be a start. Apologies, im not sure on this, just an idea? Again, before making accusations, its best to have your facts dont you think? If you dont even know which amrit sanchar you are talking abotu how can you determine it wasnt conducted appropriatly?

Re: Coventry Amritsinchar - Manmat?

Gupt singh · 30 Aug 2005

The amrit sanchar in question took place at Guru Har Gobind Gurudwara Coventry St, Coventry. The amrit sanchar took place around 5 months ago and was arranged with Nihang baba wazir singh

Re: Coventry Amritsinchar - Manmat?

MS · 30 Aug 2005

well you answered the questions that hyped up the punga, why not answer the ones i asked?

Re: Coventry Amritsinchar - Manmat?

Gupt Singh · 30 Aug 2005

I would like to apologise to the sangat for making it look like I wanted to cause a problem. It wasn't me that really caused the problem, all I did was ask a question wether an amrit sinchaar was vaild or not? It was the sangats decision to answer this question appropriately, not to judge wether the original topic was written properly. I bought up this topic because I recently found out about the amrit sinchaar and about wrong-doings of the panj piayre present at that amrit-sinchar. Tarsem Singh said; <> No I wasn't reffering to that amrit sinchaar, Akhand kirtan jatha conduct amrit sinchaars acording to tat-mariyada. I am talking about the amrit sinchaar that 'Gupt singh' posted about... <> Can sangat discuss about the amrit if the amrit was valid because of the pathetic ways of the panj piayre of that amrit sinchaar? [%sig%]

Re: Coventry Amritsinchar - Manmat?

somebody · 30 Aug 2005

Teek, i was present at that amrit sanchar, just for the record, the kirtan that day was excellent!!! Can you identify who the other persons present were? As to who did not believe certain items said above? And as to why this has taken you so long to identify? What problem you had with it that you are making a stance now? Also where you are from? That amritsanchar was granted by maharaj after certain individuals begged for weeks on end to take amrit to maharaj and he listened to their ardas. I can not comment as to who believes keski as kakkar and naam dhrih, but if they are all practising this then whats the big deal? Im sure, by seeing just a couple of the panj singhs, they would be very particular about who they chose also! Gurfateh

Re: Coventry Amritsinchar - Manmat?

M Singh · 30 Aug 2005

Gupt Singh, So when did an Amrit Sanchar ever become "invalid"?? When were you miracously granted the authority to make such an assumption. I take it you have C.V.s of the Punj Pyaray and you have checked their references. You are obviously attacking inviduals who were the Punj Pyaray on the day. Why not ring Baba Wazir Singh @ Sukhsagar Radio in Southall and discuss your concerns with him. Speak to an elder learned experienced GurSikh and see what his view is. I know that the Punj on the day believe that Kes is a Kakaar but would have stated that Keski manditory for all Gursikhs. So what is the problem with this. The Punj were not from the AK Jatha, is that the problem???!

Re: Coventry Amritsinchar - Manmat?

Pooled · 30 Aug 2005

Keski was given as kakkar not kes

Re: Coventry Amritsinchar - Manmat?

somebody · 30 Aug 2005

Bro, sorry, at complete minimum, 2 of the panj if not 3, from my personal knowldedge and assocication with them, believe keski to be kakkar. im 99% sure on the 4th but the 5th i can not comment on as have never had interaction.

Re: Coventry Amritsinchar - Manmat?

Admin. · 30 Aug 2005

topic locked Admin.