Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

gruesome pictures in gurdwara

gruesome pictures in gurdwara

KP Singh · 27 Aug 2005

i recently went to the first gurdwara in america, which was in stockton california. now in the langar hall, and a "library" where it also had looked to be used as a place for prayer... i found pictures on the walls of sikhs with big guns, sikhs who have " been eaten by dogs" , "sikh skeleton", and a countless number of other greusome things. IM any of the gurus have said anything about putting these sorts of pictures in our gurdwaras and was looking for an answer. my personal opinion is this is very bad. it looks horrible and is not what i want to think of while praying. thankyou for any replies.

Re: gruesome pictures in gurdwara

ekta · 28 Aug 2005

SINGHS WITH GUNS, is what every SINGH SHOULD BE. Guns are shasters, and GURU JI praises them the Pictures that are "gruesome" are actually pictures of pavither Guru deh ladleh who have died for the panth, for me for u, for every1 u know. their pictures belong where they are.

Re: gruesome pictures in gurdwara

singh · 28 Aug 2005

They are gruesome because they are very real. Have you ever paid attention during Ardaas?

Re: gruesome pictures in gurdwara

A S · 28 Aug 2005

If you go to most Gurdwaras there are pictures of Shaheeds of the past who have given their everything for the Panth. There is actually a Gurdwara in Punjab, sorry the name isn't coming to mind, but statues of Shaheeds have been built in the front of the Gurdwara showing just how they were Shaheed. Looking at these statues and pictures remind us and let's us reflect on the sacrifices these brave GurSikhs have made for you, me, and the entire Panth. Personally, everytime I look at these images I always ask myself if I were in that situation, would be able to give up my own family, limbs, head, scalp...everything for my Guru? I pray that I would be able to be as strong as the Shaheeds in those pictures. As long as no pictures are in the actual Gurdwara Hall where the Sri Guru Sahib sits, then I believe it is more than okay and they should be there.

Re: gruesome pictures in gurdwara

Singhs With Big Guns Zindabad · 28 Aug 2005

In Stockton Gurdwara Langer hall the pictures you see of Sikhs with big guns, those are pictures of our Martyrs. Their pictures are there because the Khalsa Panth has the greatest respect for these Singhs

Re: gruesome pictures in gurdwara

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 28 Aug 2005

ekta ji, THESE PICTURES not only belong where they are..they also BELONG in EVERY SIKH HOME..so that we Dont FORGET.. This is a Pictorial Of our DAILY ARDASS...should we STOP saying our ARDASS too ?? Next someone may say your ardass is too GRUESOME..stop saying things like that !!!

Re: gruesome pictures in gurdwara

dastar_learner · 28 Aug 2005

what kind of a sikh are you, u shud always be proud of those shaheeds who died for US. when u see those pictures, think of the story behind each one, then say they are gruesome.

Re: gruesome pictures in gurdwara

Harjas Kaur · 29 Aug 2005

Jau Tau Prem Khelan Ka Chao Sir Dhar Tali Gali Meri Aao Itt marag Pair Dhareeje Sir Deeje Kaan Na Keeje Sikh shaheeds are a blessing to the whole Khalsa Panth. What better place then to be graced by their remembrance in the Guru's kitchen? Everyone is welcome there. Shaheeds are the ones who gave Guruji their head fighting to defend justice for the whole world. How can the reality of Gursikhi ever be bad? To be murdered for your faith is the price of pure love, nothing is sweeter. I am humbled, honored, what price they paid for all of us. They remind us of the price of freedom and dignity. They remind us the cost of real Gursikhi. They remind us what it means to be in love with Guruji. When I see a Singh being eaten by a dog, it reminds me to honor that shaheed Singh. It reminds me how much human beings have to fight to be free from oppression and hatred. It reminds me to love JUSTICE! [quote]"This day must not be forgotten.... This is the day to be proud of, that at least there were men among us who could live by the very tradition of the Khalsa. There were men among us while alive who could live and who could take eleven bulletsin their body and still say, "WaheGuru." They went as true sonsto defend the grace of the Father. We should follow equally in the very footsteps, of these gracious people who at least knew how to die, and how to die in the name of the Guru and the Khalsa. So now we can tell our children that Sikh history has not ended, it has begun as a new page of life." http://www.sikhworld.co.uk/page21.2.html[/quote] [%sig%]

Re: gruesome pictures in gurdwara

Singh · 29 Aug 2005

In my opinion we need to be clever. Most pics of Kharkhoos have not text explaining what they did, not what they fought for. Hence if a gora or any Sikh who does not know about what happened in the 80's saw them they woul think they were Terrorists. If such pics are to be out up we MUST have clear text explaining things.

Re: gruesome pictures in gurdwara

sikh · 29 Aug 2005

i say bravo to the gurdwara and everyother gurdwara get a set of the pictures as well

Re: gruesome pictures in gurdwara

Siddharth · 29 Aug 2005

<> Yes - Clear text is a must. You must clearly explain what they did. These "kharkoos" were no better than the frenzied Congress-Hindu mobs who carried out the anti-Sikh riots of 1984. Over 10,000 Hindus were killed by the so-called Kharkoos under the direction of their political masters in Pakistan. We see a lot on the Internet regarding sufferings of relations of terrorists and the rights of terrorists themselves. What's astonishing is that more than 25,000 individuals (Hindus and Sikhs) ranging from 6 months old to 80 years old, pointlessly killed by the terrorists do not find any mention and seems to have receded into oblivion. If anyone wants to post the pictures on this site, give me an email ID so that I can send them to you. See what is it like to be on the opposite side of these "shaheeds".

Re: gruesome pictures in gurdwara

komal · 29 Aug 2005

siddartha >>>>>>>>>>Over 10,000 Hindus were killed by the so-called Kharkoos under the direction of their political masters in Pakistan. <<<<<<<<< this is a lie. 4000 hindus died. the rest were sikhs. anyway singhs didnt kill those people. >>>>>>>>>Yes - Clear text is a must.<<<<<<<<<<< veer, u need to clear about what happened too. please learn about who was behind killing those people komal

Re: gruesome pictures in gurdwara

Manjot Singh Khalsa · 29 Aug 2005

Siddarth Jee, Your ignorance is astounding. Please learn from your nearest gursikh the truth and lose your hindustan brainwashed attitude. Your brother.

Re: gruesome pictures in gurdwara

singh · 29 Aug 2005

Everyone is aware of the allegations against some "kharkoos" of them killing innocents. Why have not the police and government pursued charges against them. A democracy usually charges offenders of the law, even if they have died. These allegations of Singhs who murdered innocents are very convenient for the government. Who can dispute it once the alleged offender has been murdered? The GOI tried to charge Jarnail Singh Bhindranwale of a crime posthumously, to justify Bluestar because of the outrage among people in Punjab. The only crime they could come up with was that of "making inflammatory speeches". Thats it. I guess after that they learned it would be easier to pass TADA and POTA laws to be able to murder anyone they were at odds with. An "encounter" would be a convenient way to not have to present any evidence - evidence which never existed.

Re: gruesome pictures in gurdwara

Siddharth · 29 Aug 2005

OK - So Komal at least acknowledges that Hindus were killed but Mr Khalsa is not willing to believe it. Tell you what, let me send some pics to your email ID. See how you feel upon seeing the bodies. Don't tell me I'm brainwashed, my brother, I've had members of my own family killed by so called "kharkoos".

Re: gruesome pictures in gurdwara

komal · 29 Aug 2005

siddartha veer, there were hindus killed, but ur not listening to us. those people were not killed by singhs. they were mostly killed by police sponsered smugglers to bring a bad name on singhs. i hope u pay close attention to what singh said. the police killed the jujharoos instead of taking them to trial because there was no evidence against them. no evidence coz singhs didnt kill innocent people. there were many hindu veers that became khalistan soldiers. u should read about them.

Re: gruesome pictures in gurdwara

Mehtab Singh · 29 Aug 2005

There is a saying in Hindi "jiski laathi uski bhains", it literally means that "the one who has the stick in his hand owns the buffalo". The same is the case with the ones who write history and control the media. The ones in power always shape the understanding of the masses. The rulers want the people to know only what they find appropriate. The same is the case with Sikh history. Those in power have always made attempts to distort it. During the times when Mughals ruled India, our Gurus were labelled by them as "fugitives", but for us they will always remain more than anything else. When the British ruled India, freedom fighters like Bhai Sahib Bhai Randheer Singh Jee were labelled as "rebels", but for any GurSikh they will always remain role models. People like Shaheed Bhagat Singh and Shaheed Udham Singh were also called "terrorists", but today every single one of one billion Indians is proud of them. Like the proverb "One man's friend is another's foe", those who were given certain names in history have been re-named as someone else today. Similarly, most Indians will always brand Sant Baba Jarnail Singh Jee Khalsa Bhindranwale as a "terrorist". Their power controllers have prompted their historians and their media to propagate this belief, and so there we have it. Unless we don't have our own voice, this misconception will always persist. I am not denying the fact that a large number of Hindus were killed ([i]some were my distant relatives as well[/i]). But you have to understand that everything one sees may be far from reality. "All that glitters is not gold". There were Hindus who sheltered Sikhs during the November 1984 genocide, whereas on the other hand we had Hindus slaughtering them. There were "Sikhs" killing innocent Hindus on one hand, and a good number of Hindus taking Amrit, becoming Singhs, joining the Babbars and attaning shaheedi on the other. I have heard of a family from Patiala whose last name was Sharma ([i]Punjabi Brahmins[/i]). They had 7 sons. All 7 of them took Amrit and became Singhs, all 7 of them joined the Babbars, and guess what, all 7 of them attained shaheedi! The question is what prompted them? A well to do happily settled Brahmin family in India with no shortage of the comforts of life convert to another religion, pick up the gun and die a glorious death! What would the historians and media say about such people? Would they label them as "misled" Hindus? Or would they call them Pakistani agents as well? Probably! Without even going into the details, history and media will brand these martyrs as something totally opposite to who and what they were, and what they stood and fought for. I am not asking anyone to "worship" kharkoo Singhs. But please remember, just as you ([i]and in some cases myself as well[/i]) adore the martyrs of the Indian freedom struggle, don't be quick to jump to conclusions/judgements about freedom fighters of another community fighting for a similar cause. And to my veer Siddharth, brother, the level of barbaric attrocities the Sikhs have had to face in independent India is something no Indian can shy away from. It is and shall remain a black blot on the face of Indian democracy. In India if any Muslim complains, Indians are quick to say "If you are not happy, get lost and go to your Pakistan". What will they say to Sikhs who complain? Go to UK? Go to Canada? Go to ([i]put a country name here[/i]) ? Are those countries where the Sikhs belong? The Muslims were given their own homeland and we use that reason as an excuse to suppress every complain they make. What is the excuse they are going to give the Sikhs? I find the words of Bhai Rama Singh Jee ([i]who was born in a Brahmin family from U.P[/i]) amazing. He said that just like in the Ramayan, where Ravan messed with Bhagwan Shri Ram and had to face the consequences, just like in the Mahabharat where the Kauravs messed with the Pandavs (who had Bhagwan Shri Krishna on their side) and had to face the consequences, the Indian government, by attacking Sri Darbar Sahib has messed with Dhann Guru Nanak. How can they escape the consequences!

Re: gruesome pictures in gurdwara

Manjot Singh Khalsa · 29 Aug 2005

Siddarth, I am sorry for your family members and truly feel pain over it. Send me the pictures, it will only increase my outrage over the disgusting things the narkdhari sarkar has done.

Re: gruesome pictures in gurdwara

MS · 30 Aug 2005

Siddharth, Can you please provide some evidence of any kind no matter how weak/circumstantial it is, that Sikhs engaged in terrorist activities or that such actions resulted in the deaths of as you say 6month old-80yr olds? I have no doubt such a range of people were killed both Hindu and Sikh, however for you to accuse Sikhs of such crimes without stating a single incident or providing any such evidence is offensive, inflamatory and clearly shows your own state of mind. Whereas the mountians of human rights abuse compiled by the Sikhs clearly shows that Sikhs were not the 'terrorists' as you call them but the evidence shows the authoities were the true terrorists. Although you could deny the fact that Bhai Fauja Singh killed policemen for repeatedly raping women, you could also deny the govt hiring scum bags like phoola nang to dress up as Sikhs and kill civilans for the purpose of allowing you to make your baseless argument, you could also go ahead and deny that when the govt attacked Sri Harmandir Sahib (sorry the first time because they have done it 4x) the police/soldiers tied up the sangat with their dastars and blew their brains out all over the Parkarma..... you go ahead and deny all these facts, your right the Sikhs are the terrorists because they wouldnt lie down and be trodden on, only bramhin scum bags who murder civilans and rape women are good. Are you happy now? Got everything you came for yet? Is there anywhere else I can give your ego a stroking? I find it pathetic that such close minded people are out there trying to push their own views rather than being open to examine evidence to discover the truth about a situation. Such weak minded people would ignore the truth because it would suggest the views they hold are wrong and that they would need to change, just like 500yrs ago when Guroo Sahib was having to combat the same bs mentality to make people realize killing babies because they are girls is wrong, statues dont drink milk no matter how much you feed them, idol worshib is wrong... Ok, i need to go back to washing my pundits feet....if only i had as many arms as good old geshi, i'd get it done in no time hey!

Re: gruesome pictures in gurdwara

**- · 30 Aug 2005

Guys, The damage has already been done. The only people that view these Kharkoos as being spiritual freedom-fighters are the Sikhs themselves. Everybody else (i.e. clued up goray, kaaley, chineh etc) view these guys as terrorists and you cannot persuade them otherwise. Ponder upon this: will a musalmaan ever convince you that Al-Qaeda, Hizbullah or Taliban are not terrorist organisations? The answer is no. Even if they are right, nobody will believe them because the western media has already done so much damage to their cause. You may argue that the Indian media has done the same thing, but how are you going to prove it? When you do get the opportunity, what do Sikhs do? They burn Indian flags and hold placards calling ‘Hinduism is Nazism’. Do you have any idea how you guys are perceived by doing this? Look at the Khalistani websites, one cannot help but notice the huge level of antagonism the website owners have for Hindus and Hinduism. Look at this website? Look at the amount of anti-Hindu vibes you get from western educated Sikhs and even influential Sikhs such as Jaranail Singh – who once insulted Lord Krishna to very extreme levels. I don't mind if Sikhs want a seperate homeland, but when you start insulting Hindus/Hinduism, then you loose all credibility. You have no credibility what so ever now. I now this sounds harsh but this is a fact.

Re: gruesome pictures in gurdwara

Siddharth · 30 Aug 2005

<> MS - Give me your email ID and I will provide you with as much evidence as you want. Have you read my first post carefully? When did I ever defend Brahmins or the GOI? I merely said that when you say that all the Kharkoos were the purest of people, it is untrue and you need to remove that bias and accept that they killed innocents. Actually this is not your fault, just the kind of indoctrination the western Sikh is given today. <> Yes, and I hope you know Sikhs are the biggest perpetrators of female infanticide today. <> Aaaahhh! The hatred for Hinduism bursts forth. BTW, who is Geshi? Is that the name for Lord Ganesh?

Re: gruesome pictures in gurdwara

MS · 30 Aug 2005

>I merely said that when you say that all the Kharkoos were the purest of people, Hold up 1 sec.... thats not what I said, I said Sikhs. Your assersion of Kharkoos implicitly implicates Sikhs as Sikhs were the majority of the people fighting againt GOI. You tarnish Sikhs by this implication. I have no doubt at all that some punjabi's or people claiming to be Sikh or people dressed up as Sikhs, committed the attrocities you described. The situation of lawlessness created by evil GOI allowed any opportunist with a grudge to settle any petty score. However my only point is that no Sikhs enaged in the activities you describe, such action automatically negated the possibility of such a person being Sikh! Since Kharkoos are mostly considered Sikhs its therefore Sikhs who get the brunt of your accusations, not all Kharkoos were Sikhs which is fact, but your assersion implicates Sikhs. If you were far more cleverer with your words and actually targeting the perpetrators of the crimes rather than implicitly implicating Sikhs by using terms like Kharkoo which is mostly associated to Sikhs, then I wouldn't have a problem. (get back to you with a private email id later) >it is untrue and you need to remove that bias and accept that they killed innocents. Therefore proved you wrong as my logic clearly describes. Again I find this also pathetic that an adult can use the logic "a brown skin person committed a crime therefore all brown skinned people are criminals" Target your charge to the actual perpetrators of such crimes, not the Sikhs because again such crimes negates the possiblity of such people being Sikh! OH AND NICE ONE ON BEING ABLE TO ADDRESS MY POINT ON PHOOLA NANG AND THE BLACK CATS. I should toss you a ladoo for being so manipulative, being an expert on the Sikhs and Kharkoos you should know what that stands for! >Yes, and I hope you know Sikhs are the biggest perpetrators of female infanticide today. Really news to me, Sikhs as according to Guroo Sahib who is the ultimate authority on who a Sikh is, reject such concepts and Sikhs are very much anti this type of act. Again you attack Sikhs without a single piece of evidence that a Sikh commited such a crime. Again I find it such a weak character of an individual that they cannot understand the simple logic that somone who does not belive in Sikhi, is not a Sikh! .... I supose its much easier if i subscirbed to your terminology, i.e. "The speed limit on normal roads is 40mph, when the law books say 30! It doen't matter what the law says, im the big ego maniac here and what I says sticks" NO NO NO I NOT LISTENING BLA BLA BLA >Aaaahhh! The hatred for Hinduism bursts forth. BTW, who is Geshi? Hatred, consulting ones pundit over factual errors on your part makes me hate hindus, wow your full of assumtions arn't you. I best not let my hindu boss know about this, nor my hindu co-worker hey ;-). >Is that the name for Lord Ganesh? BAH! Good old gechieee and I dont stand on formalities, here have a hand, theres pleanty to go round ((<:-D

Re: gruesome pictures in gurdwara

reply · 30 Aug 2005

Siddarth ji, Although this is separate from the question of whether kharkus (militants) killed innocent Hindus and to what extent, please do consider that the police in India certainly have and do impersonate kharkus. The below text is being reposted from another thread. Also, for both Siddharth ji and Sitara ji could you comment on the latest incredible actions of the Police in the thread ________________ For those who didn't believe cops or others could pose as Sikh militants, look at this: Read the article on ths site to see the pictures New Delhi, August 20: An embarrassed Army today admitted that photographs seized from a studio in Muzaffarnagar district two days ago were of under-cover special police officers and village defence council (VDC) members disguised as militants for counter-insurgency operations. On suspicion that men shown as carrying weapons and radio sets in the 36 photographs were militants, UP Police had yesterday sealed the Muzaffarnagar studio and arrested its owner Pradeep Tyagi and his associate, Amrish. The Army confirmed that photos reached the studio because of an oversight by Major Amit Agarwal, adjutant of the 27 Rashtriya Rifles battalion, deployed in Poonch district. The roll was dropped off at a photolab in Deoband by Maj Agarwal’s sister. The men in the photographs, from a village in Surankote, were under the supervision of the 27 RR Battalion in Poonch in July. “They were on a routine operation when the SPOs and VDCs decided to click photographs at a scenic location in the mountains,” an Army official said. The roll they had used to click “casual photographs” was confiscated by a junior commissioned officer and handed over to Major Amit Agarwal.

Re: gruesome pictures in gurdwara

singh · 30 Aug 2005

**- "[i]The only people that view these Kharkoos as being spiritual freedom-fighters are the Sikhs themselves. Everybody else (i.e. clued up goray, kaaley, chineh etc) view these guys as terrorists and you cannot persuade them otherwise.[/i]" Not true. Consult the writings of numerous journalists and authors who don't neccessarily agree with the freedom-fighting movement but understand their plight. A must read is "Fighting for Faith and Nation" by Cynthia Mahmoud. Consult the numerous Canadian MPs who have spoken out against GOI atrocities against the Sikhs. Ask David Kilgour. Consult US Congressmen like Dan Burton and Edolphus Towns. These politicians aren't likely to call them spiritual freedom fighters, but they certainly will not call them terrorists knowing of the situation in Punjab. Remember that post-Bluestar, according to a GOI memorandum, every Amritdhari Sikh was a terrorist and was to be treated as such. The only ones that can be viewed as terrrorists are those charged with terrorist crimes. I would like to view a list of Singhs who are branded terrorists and see what they have been charged with to justify that claim. If they haven't been charged, you must be very skeptical of these claims. If the freedom fighters that gained India's independence are heros, why aren't these Singhs and Singhnian?

Re: gruesome pictures in gurdwara

reply · 30 Aug 2005

john ji, >to siddharata ! You don't have to make fun of Siddarth's name while addressing him. In fact, your point would be more accepted if you didn't do this. How would you like it if someone called you johnnie or jonnie-boy? (If you accidentally misspelled, you can ignore this.) [%sig%]

Re: gruesome pictures in gurdwara

KP Singh · 31 Aug 2005

Satsriakal Various Jis, We are getting away from the issue. It is not whether or not Khalistan is right or wrong. The crux of my post is that the Gurdwara is meant to be a place of peace and harmony. To look at men with AK-47's in their hands does not seem to be inviting. What you all consider respect I find disgusting and in bad taste. Dead bodies and skeltons? Come on. That has nothing to do with respect and sacrifice it is all about politicizing the Gurdwara and the advancement of an admittadly controversial agenda. This has nothing to do with the 1980s it has to do with people trying to hijack our temples in order to alienate the majority of Sikhs who also find such images in bad taste. Graciously your most humble servant, KP Singh

Re: gruesome pictures in gurdwara

singh · 31 Aug 2005

KP Singh, maybe you find them to be in bad taste or maybe you just have a weak stomach. Ones mind should be in peace, the world outside is a cruel place. Theres no reason to sugar-coat it. I don't think people are politicizing the Gurdwaras with these photos. If so, they are also politicizing and pushing an agenda when reciting ardaas which is just as gruesome (as you put it). Read a translation of it if you have doubts. Its more than just the 1980's, its Sikh history in all of its entirety. Images that represent the truth don't represent temples being hijacked. [gurbani]jYsI mY AwvY Ksm kI bwxI qYsVw krI igAwnu vy lwlo ][/gurbani] jaisee mai aavai khasam kee baanee thaisarraa karee giaan vae laalo || As the Word of the Forgiving Lord comes to me, so do I express it, O Lalo. [gurbani]pwp kI jM\ lY kwblhu DwieAw jorI mMgY dwnu vy lwlo ][/gurbani] paap kee ja(n)n(j) lai kaabalahu dhhaaeiaa joree ma(n)gai dhaan vae laalo || Bringing the marriage party of sin, Babar has invaded from Kaabul, demanding our land as his wedding gift, O Lalo. [gurbani]srmu Drmu duie Cip Kloey kUVu iPrY prDwnu vy lwlo ][/gurbani] saram dhharam dhue shhap khaloeae koorr firai paradhhaan vae laalo || Modesty and righteousness both have vanished, and falsehood struts around like a leader, O Lalo. [gurbani]kwjIAw bwmxw kI gl QkI Agdu pVY sYqwnu vy lwlo ][/gurbani] kaajeeaa baamanaa kee gal thhakee agadh parrai saithaan vae laalo || The Qazis and the Brahmins have lost their roles, and Satan now conducts the marriage rites, O Lalo. [gurbani]muslmwnIAw pVih kqybw kst mih krih Kudwie vy lwlo ][/gurbani] musalamaaneeaa parrehi kathaebaa kasatt mehi karehi khudhaae vae laalo || The Muslim women read the Koran, and in their misery, they call upon God, O Lalo. [gurbani]jwiq snwqI hoir ihdvwxIAw eyih BI lyKY lwie vy lwlo ][/gurbani] jaath sanaathee hor hidhavaaneeaa eaehi bhee laekhai laae vae laalo || The Hindu women of high social status, and others of lowly status as well, are put into the same category, O Lalo. [gurbani]KUn ky soihly gwvIAih nwnk rqu kw kuMgU pwie vy lwlo ]1][[/gurbani] khoon kae sohilae gaaveeahi naanak rath kaa ku(n)goo paae vae laalo ||1|| The wedding songs of murder are sung, O Nanak, and blood is sprinkled instead of saffron, O Lalo. ||1|| [gurbani]swihb ky gux nwnku gwvY mws purI ivic AwKu msolw ][/gurbani] saahib kae gun naanak gaavai maas puree vich aakh masolaa || Nanak sings the Glorious Praises of the Lord and Master in the city of corpses, and voices this account. [gurbani]ijin aupweI rMig rvweI bYTw vyKY viK iekylw ][/gurbani] jin oupaaee ra(n)g ravaaee bait(h)aa vaekhai vakh eikaelaa || The One who created, and attached the mortals to pleasures, sits alone, and watches this. [gurbani]scw so swihbu scu qpwvsu scVw inAwau krygu msolw ][/gurbani] sachaa so saahib sach thapaavas sacharraa niaao karaeg masolaa || The Lord and Master is True, and True is His justice. He issues His Commands according to His judgement. [gurbani]kwieAw kpVu tuku tuku hosI ihdusqwnu smwlsI bolw ][/gurbani] kaaeiaa kaparr ttuk ttuk hosee hidhusathaan samaalasee bolaa || The body-fabric will be torn apart into shreds, and then India will remember these words. [gurbani]Awvin ATqrY jwin sqwnvY horu BI auTsI mrd kw cylw ][/gurbani] aavan at(h)atharai jaan sathaanavai hor bhee out(h)asee maradh kaa chaelaa || Coming in seventy-eight (1521 A.D.), they will depart in ninety-seven (1540 A.D.), and then another disciple of man will rise up. [gurbani]sc kI bwxI nwnku AwKY scu suxwiesI sc kI bylw ]2]3]5][/gurbani] sach kee baanee naanak aakhai sach sunaaeisee sach kee baelaa ||2||3||5|| Nanak speaks the Word of Truth; he proclaims the Truth at this, the right time. ||2||3||5|[gurbani] [%sig%]

Re: gruesome pictures in gurdwara

Harjas Kaur · 31 Aug 2005

[quote]What you all consider respect I find disgusting[/quote] What do you call all the shastars around Babaji? What do you call the Khanda? You don't like AK-47's? Then you don't like the kirpan! In fact, why do you call yourself "Singh?" [%sig%]

Re: gruesome pictures in gurdwara

AS · 31 Aug 2005

"This has nothing to do with the 1980s it has to do with people trying to hijack our temples in order to alienate the majority of Sikhs who also find such images in bad taste." Hey KP Singh...just speak for yourself and not the majority of Sikhs, aight buddy. A true GurSikh will never forget the sacrifice Shaheeds made for the Kaum, whether it be Shaheed Bhai Mani Singh or Shaheed Bhai Sukhdev Singh Babbar (I wouldn't be surprised if KP Singh doesn't know who Bhai Mani Singh or Bhai Sukhdev Singh are...go figure). These images deserve to be on our walls and these images will also forever be engrained in our hearts, minds, and souls. RAJ KAREGA KHALSA PANTH KI JEET

Re: gruesome pictures in gurdwara

Lionking · 02 Sep 2005

Siddharth brother, email me your proof, I have earlier told you that if you need any proof hosted let me know. Email me your proof and we shall get it posted so that Singhs can refute it. thank you

Re: gruesome pictures in gurdwara

Mehtab Singh · 02 Sep 2005

There are a good number of people who don't want to see in Gurdwaras pictures of Shaheeds like Shaheed Bhai Taru Singh Jee who sacrificed his life rather than his kesh. The dum excuse given is "[i]oh kids get scared seeing all the blood in the pictures![/i]" You dam right buddy! They ought to know their history to grow up as Singhs and Kaurs! This could be another move by anti-Sikh elements who want to wipe off our history from our minds. If any of you get those Punjabi channels from India, you will notice how they sing about Guru Arjan Dev Jee's shaheedi but NEVER mention Chandu's name. They sing about the shaheedi of chhote sahibjaade and condemn Wazir Khan, but the name of Gangu is NEVER whispered. The same way they want only "nice and sweet" pictures in Gurdwaras. I have even come across Punjabi girls who say "[i]oh I find pictures of Guru Nanak De Jee sweet, but I am scared of Guru Gobind Singh![/i]" I am like dammmmm! They both the same!!!! Whats there to be scared of? All those Bollywood lovers are getting used to seeing fake red paint smeared all over the faces of their temporary heroes who thing acting means to have a bloody face and yell and fight. They cannot digest something real. The incomparable shaheediyaan of the Sikh martyrs is way too hard for them to digest! Some even say "[i]Why do they show such images on TV and provoke people?[/i]" I am not pointing fingers at anyone, but let me warn everyone, this is DEFINITELY a new attempt to wipe off our history. They've already tried to remove bullet marks at Sri Darbar Sahib. They will try to change our history in pictures as well. But here is the bad news for all Sikh haters. We will NEVER EVER forget a single shaheedi! We will NEVER EVER forget a single drop of blood shed for Sikhi! If you don't have the heart to accept, acknowledge or respect all those shaheediyaan, if your spine shivers hearing about the tortures those Gurmukhs faced with a smile, then dude, it is YOU who needs to sort himself/herself out. Don't come and tell us to forget this and forget that, coz we will NEVER EVER!!!

Re: gruesome pictures in gurdwara

Khalsa · 02 Sep 2005

K P Singh don't look at these pictures but pay attention to daily Ardaas.and try to visualise it in your mind. [%sig%]

Re: gruesome pictures in gurdwara

KP Singh · 02 Sep 2005

No one addressed my question which I believe strikes more deeply at the heart of the Sikh faith. This is not meant to be disrespectful but rather I am trying to come to grips with my own beliefs. I respect people who died for Sikhism but I still can question what they fought for. That is terrorists who killed for September 11th are revered throughout the Muslim world as shaheeds...but are they true representatives of faith. Similarly, must I accept your definition of Sikh protection. If I believe in my heart their actions to be contrary to Guru Nanak Dev Ji's teachings and beliefs, will you force me to accept them. One problem of posting pictures of Khalistanis is that everyone would admit that this is a controversial issue... Thus, it is best to avoid the controversy rather than alienate members of the Sikh panth. Sikhism is inviting to all people not alienating our fellow Sikhs. It saddens me in my heart that my fellow Sikhs do not have enough room in their hearts to see how one might find this distrubing. Rather, than acknowledge why someone feels a certain way and respect this you start attacking. It seems that this kind of language is self-defeating. I wish we could respect each other in an honest dialogue. I certainly respect you and your opinions.

Re: gruesome pictures in gurdwara

komal · 02 Sep 2005

kp singh veerji everyone has addressed ur question. and the answer is that they should be there. its part of our history! Singhs fighting for Khalistan werent terrorists, it was the police and smugglers killing innocents to bring a bad name on Singhs. sikhs shouldnt forget what happened, unless u have a reason for wanting us to forget??? [%sig%]

Re: gruesome pictures in gurdwara

singh · 02 Sep 2005

KP Singh, if you have a problem of a particular picture, of someone who you think is not worthy of having their picture up, you should talk to the management about it. You can even bring that person's name up here at a forum and ask people's opinions of that person and whether they should be honoured or not. You don't have to be pro-Khalistani to acknowledge the sacrifice of these Singhs. Not all of them had political aspirations or affiliations. Remember that many of them might have been like you and me, but once fed up with the atrocities, decided to sacrifice the comforts of a peaceful life, for the betterment of Sikhs.

Re: gruesome pictures in gurdwara

AS · 02 Sep 2005

KP Singh, why don't you educate yourself first on why these Shaheeds took up arms in the first place and then maybe you'll understand why their pictures should be on our walls. Please, take some time out of your busy schedule to look up what exactly happened on Vaisakhi 1978 in Amritsar, read up on a very well educated Sikh Scholar by the name of Sirdar Kapur Singh and see what he had to say about Sikhs in India, read up on the attack on Darbar Sahib and the 38 other Gurdwara throughout Punjab that were raided in 1984 and what was done to innocent people there, research about the countless number of women (our sisters, daughters, mothers, grandmothers) that were brutally raped and sodemized in the most gruesome fashion, the countless number of innocent men in between the ages of 13-85 that were tortured and killed by police in "encounters", more recently, the number of innocent Sikh youths that have been taken into police custody without any charges or evidence against them and are being interrogated through torture. Brother, I could go on and on. You wanna hear something really sad, forget watchin some sappy heart break romance movie , read some of the victims individual stories and believe me , they'll send shivers down your spine and they'll make your blood bubble. The brave ones actually stepped forward and said "enough is enough" These brave ones are the ones you see in the pictures that you can stand teh sight of. They gave up everything....up to and including their life for something they believed in. Ask yourself would you be able to give up your mother father sisiter brother, your nice clothes, your fancy car, all your money, your house, your job, for your Guru? What would you do if someone tied you up and made you watch your sister being raped right infront of your eyes? Would you stand around and not say or do anything about it? Please, do me a favour and read up on exactly what happened in Punjab during the late 70s to the mid 90s...and even now. Hey this isn't stuff that happened hundreds of years ago, this stuff hapened in our yesteryear. I'm not making any of this up, This all happened to your fellow brothers and sisters. Just read up on it. "I don't call it violence when its self-defense, I call it Intelligence" -Malcolm X

Re: gruesome pictures in gurdwara

Lionking · 03 Sep 2005

Here are the Pictures Siddharth Paaji sent - http://www.pure-panjab.net/Pics.zip (a zip file) My response - Although there must have been Hindus killed during the 80’s-90’s there is still a doubt on who was actually responsible. http://www.indianexpress.com/messages.php?content_id=76143 http://www.sikhspectrum.com/082002/sonia.htm http://www.disappearances.org/mainfile.php/articles_india/26/ - Jagbir Singh http://www.tribuneindia.com/2002/20020209/punjab1.htm http://www.tribuneindia.com/1998/98sep08/punjab.htm http://www.tribuneindia.com/2001/20011123/punjab1.htm http://panthic.org/news/125/ARTICLE/1686/2005-08-21.html http://panthic.org/news/125/ARTICLE/1707/2005-08-28.html The first articles talks about “Kale Kachchewala”, and the last ones talks about how Jagtar Singh Hawara, the Babbar Khalsa cheif totally exposes the police by confessing he killed the doctor, and states the following: “I can execute Beanta and Tyler (for their crimes) but I cannot target innocent (people).” Picture “iqbal3e” and “ludhiana” (notice the turbaned people in these photos) in the above zip file also shows how Sikhs actually had sympathy for the innocent Hindus killed by the government agents. I would seriously not be surprised if these were the photos the government agents had published in newspapers in order to fuel hatred towards Sikhs by Hindu nationalists. If it was so that so many Sikhs killed Hindus, why then were all independent radio stations cut, all newspapers closed, why aren’t human rights organisations such as Amnesty International and HRW allowed entrée into the Punjab? What does the government have to hide? Please read: The Gallant Defender by AR Darshi Fighting for Faith and Nation Dialogues with Sikh Militants Cynthia Keppley Mahmood And Articles by Ram Narayan Kumar http://punjabjustice.org/ Regards

Re: gruesome pictures in gurdwara

Hardeep Chahal · 17 Sep 2005

HATRED IS NOT THE GATE TO SIKHISM!! one as a sikh should know very well that hatred should not have no place in a gurdwara. that also means that hatred should not be intentionally created to accumulate hatred. hATRED = BLAME WHICH WILL INVENTUALLY LEAD TO VIOLENCE. THIS IS NOT THE CHARACTERISTICS A SIKH SHOULD HOLD. FOR SOMEONE WHO READS BANI WILL REALISE THE TRUE MEANING OF SIKHI. SANT BABA JARNAIL SINGH JI KHALSA BHINDRANWALE KNEW THIS ALL TOO WELL, Y DO YOU THINK SO MANY PEOPLE FOLLOWED HIM???? THINK!!!!!!!! PRACTICE!!!! AND BELIEVE!!!!

Re: gruesome pictures in gurdwara

Gurpartap Singh · 01 Nov 2005

**- wrote: > Guys, > > The damage has already been done. The only people that view > these Kharkoos as being spiritual freedom-fighters are the > Sikhs themselves. Everybody else (i.e. clued up goray, kaaley, > chineh etc) view these guys as terrorists and you cannot > persuade them otherwise. > > Ponder upon this: will a musalmaan ever convince you that > Al-Qaeda, Hizbullah or Taliban are not terrorist organisations? > The answer is no. Even if they are right, nobody will believe > them because the western media has already done so much damage > to their cause. You may argue that the Indian media has done > the same thing, but how are you going to prove it? When you do > get the opportunity, what do Sikhs do? They burn Indian flags > and hold placards calling ‘Hinduism is Nazism’. Do you > have any idea how you guys are perceived by doing this? Look > at the Khalistani websites, one cannot help but notice the huge > level of antagonism the website owners have for Hindus and > Hinduism. Look at this website? Look at the amount of > anti-Hindu vibes you get from western educated Sikhs and even > influential Sikhs such as Jaranail Singh – who once insulted > Lord Krishna to very extreme levels. > > I don't mind if Sikhs want a seperate homeland, but when you > start insulting Hindus/Hinduism, then you loose all > credibility. You have no credibility what so ever now. I now > this sounds harsh but this is a fact. this "**_" is actually sidharth only, who wanted to separately put smthing disliked by us. Look at the amount of > anti-Hindu vibes you get from western educated Sikhs and even > influential Sikhs such as Jaranail Singh – who once insulted > Lord Krishna to very extreme levels. let me tell u, sant bhindranwale never did say so. even he knew and u must be knowing, guru granth sahib also have all these hindu god names included like RAAM and Krishan. and if u want to be so sure, and make us, get a audio/video proof. as for every sayings sikhs have solid proofs. even if u get, i wont believe. never mind i actually go with Hardeep Chahal what he said? ponder upon

Re: gruesome pictures in gurdwara

A Singh · 02 Nov 2005

Guns are shastars agreed, but they are a far cry from what the Sword does and symbolises. Guru Sahib has done ustat of the cannon, gun and pistol nonetheless, however foremost for a Singh is the Sword. Those who seek to place guns underneath the Khanda with the claim that these are the modern day shastars are mistaken on both accounts, they are neither 'modern day', for Guru Sahib used guns and neither does the Khanda (Bhagauti), Chakr (or Deg depending on how old the Nishan sahib is), Miri and Piri need adjusting.

Re: gruesome pictures in gurdwara

Jasmin · 02 Nov 2005

Well frankly, its at least partly true,------but I say this with total neutrality. Look at the BJP uniforms. Obvisiously some Hindus, well, I really don't say this to condemn----anyboby, but nazism is an ideaology that some Hindus prescribe. Now, prehaps the interpretation is wrong---------I'm only saying it exists. For instance their was a women half Greek, and half English. She decided she wanted to know all the secrets of the Aryans. She was a Nazi sympathizer and after the war, she moved to India, and married an orthodox Hindu. I don't know her name, but she was involved in something called Esoteric Aryanism. Here she was a European lady, but she has no trouble marrying an Orthodox Hindu, I would suppose of high caste- Brahmin or Khatri. So what does that tell you? Also just listen to Shiva Seva, what does he sound like? It's easy to see were people get that idea.

Re: gruesome pictures in gurdwara

soorma · 14 Nov 2005

without rehat one cannot be a sikh if a so called singh killed innocent ppl he aint a sikh just sum 1 with a sikh apperance

Re: gruesome pictures in gurdwara

Harjas Kaur · 28 Dec 2005

[quote]For instance their was a women half Greek, and half English. She decided she wanted to know all the secrets of the Aryans. She was a Nazi sympathizer and after the war, she moved to India, and married an orthodox Hindu. I don't know her name, but she was involved in something called Esoteric Aryanism. Here she was a European lady, but she has no trouble marrying an Orthodox Hindu, I would suppose of high caste- Brahmin or Khatri.[/quote] Her name is Savitri Devi Mukherjee, nee Maximiani Portas. She married a Bengali Brahmin, and believed Adolf Hitler was an avatar of Vishnu. She was associated with the militant nationalist Subhas Chandra Bose and fascist Brahminism. Her books are sold by neonazi groups. [%sig%]

Re: gruesome pictures in gurdwara

**- · 28 Dec 2005

Jasmin, You are right Hindus are Nazis. Look at all the Neo-Nazi hate they are promoting in Europe and the US. We should eliminate Hinduism in order to stop the hate crimes being perpertrated against Asians, blacks and other minorities....hindus are also responsible for the Aushwitz massacre as well.

Re: gruesome pictures in gurdwara

indy · 01 Jan 2006

these pictures make up our history they should inspire us to live up to the jeevans of these singhs and singhnia, dont be scared or offended BE PROUD DEGH TEGH.................................

Re: gruesome pictures in gurdwara

ump · 01 May 2006

you say this alienates a majority of sikhs, which is completly untrue, i know many singhs and all of them agree with the shaheeds, whether they were pro-khalistani or not, they gave their lifes defending innocent sikhs and defending Sri Harminder Sahib and should be recognized, as far as the weapons goes, Ive seen many photos (drawn) of Guru Gobind Singh Ji with guns and weapons, the most famous is when he asked for one of his sikhs to come and take a bullet from him and a father/son came, Ive seen this picture in gurdwarya too, shoulda that be taken down?? and also they have guns of Guru Sahib and Baba Deep Singh ji in either akal takht or kesgarh sahib, i forget, but these are ACTUAL GUNS, should these be taken out of these gurdwara too? are these guns in bad taste and against this "majority" of sikhs you talk about???...every sikh i kno has nuthing against these shaheeds and nuthing against these guns, maybe you should surround urself with better sangat and true gursikhs

Re: gruesome pictures in gurdwara

confused · 01 May 2006

FATEHHHHHH

Re: gruesome pictures in gurdwara

o · 02 May 2006

inspiring shaheeds love and peace to them. children love to see their peaceful faces glowing with love.

Re: gruesome pictures in gurdwara

singh. · 02 May 2006

Actually, I remember reading that a survey of leading Hindu uni students found that Adolf Hitler was the 3rd most admired figure by them! Now, Hinduism does not equal nazism. But the fact that there is such a deep rooted and widespread fascination raises eyebrows, don't you think? and this fascination is much more than morbid curiosity. As for what KP Singh said, the Singhs who fought for khalistan did not target any innocent people. there may have been some innocents targetted in later stages when people who did not have proper gursikhi jeevan began fighting out of desperation. Still, many of those deaths were attributable to black cats - indian agents dressed like singhs who committed atrocities in the name of khalistan to defame the movement. Last point, people who say that hanging pics of our shaheeds is not inline with Guru Nanak Sahib ji's philosophy don't understand that philosophy. All the Gurus are one and the same. This is written in Gurbani, that all the Gurus have the same jyot in them. If you accept Gurbani as your Guru, then you must accept that Guru Gobind Singh ji is the same as our first Guru. If you accept that, then glorification of shaheedi is something you must accept (if you have faith) as well. i don't hate or disrespect you for your different opinion. But, it is based on lack of understanding and it is incorrect. As a Sikh, I do believe that you should educate yourself before passing judgment on this.

Re: gruesome pictures in gurdwara

sanjo · 10 May 2006

those people saying eradicate hinduism to save all these other people, well that makes u no better than the GOI trying to eradicate sikhi. not all hindus are bad people, i am not to educated on hinduism n its ties wiht nazism but it doesnt give us a excuse to start "ethnic cleansing". some hindus are gd people, some are maniac radical extremists like rss etc who wnt hindu raj all over. but guru tegh bahadur ji gave shaheedi for religious freedom, so let them be free to practice their religion, but everyone must know n understand that if anyone takes on sikhi then sikhi always comes out on top. if these sects of hinduism who promote nazism want to take sikhi on then let em, wen the time comes guru sahib infuses courage into his gursikhs, and im sure weneva the call comes to protect sikhi agn then there will be a long line of singhs and singhnia willing to give their shaheedi. note: nazis faught for hitler because of fear of hitler and his power, sikhs fight for rightousness out of love for waheguru and guru ji. this is why people fear the sikhi guru sahib has blessed us with. this is why people try to destroy sikhi using cunning and discrete methods. no one wants to face us on the battle field, they must use other methods like propaganda. if we take this images of great shaheeds dwn we are weakening our defences, we must never forget the sacrificies. sacrificies from only 20 years ago! 20 years oh my waheguru only 20 years and we are already willing to forget. as for a ak47 being a sword, well it is, guru sahib only used swords mre back then because guns etc were unreliable n inpractical. the khanda symbol will never change, but a ak47 can be a weopon of rightousness just as much as a kirpan can.

Re: gruesome pictures in gurdwara

davinder · 10 May 2006

Fateh btw sanjo...the khanda is not a puratan design so it can be changed and it has been changed..wat we see today as the khanda is not wot it was in the puratan times or the times of Jathedhar akali nihang singh phoola ji, in fact from wat ive read the different missls had different 'khandeh' on their nishaan sahibs.....and i have also read that the original nishaan sahib was a plain blue triangular flag which Sikhs began to tie on their heads as dumalleh because carrying the nishaan sahibs on poles was impracticle in war as they might fall down and become dirty. Anyways that off topic and please let me knnow if im wrong, i think shaheeds should be remembered but as sum1 previously said before me, we do need to be clever about how we show how proud of these great sikhs we are. fateh

Re: gruesome pictures in gurdwara

vahegurooo · 19 May 2006

pictures leike these in a gurdwara help you remeber those singhs and singhneea who ave their lives for us today! without these pictures and stuff we would probably forget everything and everyone in our past!

Re: gruesome pictures in gurdwara

joker · 11 Jun 2006

Gruesome pictures....what a shock!!!! Guru Gobind Singh Ji watched his 2 elder sons fight and die in battle......was that not gruesome?????? We cant even handle the truth. My friend i will do ardaas that Guru Ji wakes up the dead soul within you. I will pray that you dont get so threatened by gruesome pictures. Why dont you travel the world and see all the atrocities being carried out...that is reality. Only fools hide away. Only fools are blind to what goes on around them. Horrible is the thought that you had...not those beautiful pictures of them Great Sikhs. I DO WANT TO THINK OF THOSE PICTURES WHEN I PRAY AND LOOK FOR PEACE. MY GURU TEACHES ME TO DIE....NOT LIVE.

Re: gruesome pictures in gurdwara

gupt singhnee! · 14 Jul 2006

totally agree with "joker" lol how can we remember what singhs n singhneea of the past went thru! we should be showing our children these and make them stronger! nor colly woddle them and be like o no dont look at that it will scare you!

Re: gruesome pictures in gurdwara

Dalbir · 18 Jul 2006

The day we forget our shaheeds, we are finished.

Tones of hatred

Puzzled student · 12 Jun 2007

I am a student who is doing a paper on Sikhs and profiling. I was doing research when this site came to my attention due to an image posted in this discussion. What I read on www.sikhs.org, or www.saldef.org is very different from what I see here. I read that you are a people who reject things like female infanticide, and ritualism. That anger is considered a vice, yet anger is what I see here. I am only looking as an outsider. I must admit, by creed alone, Sikhism is inviting. Yet I don't know if I would want to look at pictures that constantly remind me of injustices, and tragedy. It seems this would only breed anger. I personally feel there is more than enough injustice, more than enough martyrdom, and innocent death currently happening than I need to remind me of what people stood and died for. I feel the same way about the catholic icons showing Jesus being martyred for his faith. I personally find that there is much more respect in pictures of these individuals intact, in a position of dignity. To the original author of this thread, I understand your question. I also agree that some of the replies were not with the original respectful tone. To the rest, I acknowledge my ignorance as to much of the history of this faith. I just wanted to give you an idea what this might look like to an outsider. Honestly there was no thought of Sikhs as terroists in my mind before I read this, nor hatred for any of the groups listed (except Al Qaeda for taking the lives of several of my friends in their attack on 9/11/2001). The hatred I see here bothers me. The anger that negates reason, scares me. That is the same anger that leads to the death of innocent people. I wish you all the best at controlling rage, and not being controled. [%sig%]

Re: gruesome pictures in gurdwara

jassmannn · 13 Jun 2007

I personally agree with KP Singh. Gurdwara should only have pictures of the Gurus and not Shaheeds. The only Shaheeds that take pride of place are the ones noted in our history such as 4 Sahibsade, Bhai Mati Singh and the likes who we know actually dies for Sikhi. The Shaheeds that some of you talk about are too controversial and some of the things they died for are arguable, with too many politics invovled, which is why Bhinderawale is not accepted throughout the Sikh panth as a Martyr. People also give fighting, martydom and weapons too much importance. We are Sant Sipahi, but don;t forget Sant comes first and that is the most important thing. We are supposed to stand up for rights and the under priviledged, not just for any political cause like Khalistan, which I disagree with totally and makes on sense whatsoever. People get too embroiled with the politics of 1984 that almost everything else becomes irrelevant and then people like puzzled student comes is even more confused about what we stand for as a faith. Shaheeds are i mportant, but you can't make every person that died a martyr. When in doubt look at the lifes of the gurus and then think is this how I should be speaking, acting talking. All of us need education, and it seems many people here just read something in some random publication and take it as the truth. Always question try yourself to get to the root of the questions. Don't just scream and shout, and even make racist comments about Hindus, which I read above, which is outrageous!!

Re: gruesome pictures in gurdwara

akj47 · 16 Jun 2007

Us sikhs know 2 argue with eachother lets all agree on that! [%sig%]

Re: gruesome pictures in gurdwara

Singhstah · 17 Jun 2007

Would you any of you opposed to the pictures ever tell a Jew to forget the holocaust? Auschwitz concentration camp is kept intact by UNESCO to serve as a reminder of what happened, would you say that it should be broken down and they shud forget what happened as it only breeds anger? Dont any of you even DARE to tell us to forget about the sacrifices of the Shaheeds. "Puzzled student", i dont give to cr*p what you think of Sikhs after reading this thread to be quite honest, regardless of if you are who you say you are or not. Jassmannn, politics is a part of Sikhi, ever heard of Miri Piri? Actually Sant Jarnail Singh Ji was honoured by Akal Takht as a Shaheed, so i dont understand what you mean by "not accepted throughout the sikh panth as a martyr", if sum individual doesnt think so then thats theyre problem. [%sig%]

Re: gruesome pictures in gurdwara

panth ka daas · 17 Jun 2007

bhai siddharth ji; i dont know who u r ? nor do i say that u r brainwashed. but let me enlighten u with the case of JASWANT Singh Khalra. a human rights activist who showed to the Supreme court of india that there have been cremations of more tha 1000 "Unidentified" bodies in only the districts of amritsar & taran - taaran. the court dismissed his petition as it was not in "the interest of the public" (rather who care fo the thousand). within a short time he just vanished from the face of the earth. those so called unidentified bodies were , sikh, hindus ,muslims , i dont want to say. remember , it was just from 1 district & its sud division ( i think). at that time in early 90's there were about 14-15 districts. so its anyones guess how many were killed & burnt as unidentified. the killing (pointless killing) of a hindu , sikh or any other is condemned in the strongest words. & what makes u think that the terrorists ( all sikh as u think) killed only hindus. & how can one say that the govt. of the time did not take part in state sponsored terrorism. to u it might seem to be crystal clear that u'r relatives were killed by the terrorists who were sikh . but how do u confirm that. through hearsay, media or by having seen by u'r own eyes. remember, many of those so called "kharkoos" were also the product of the govt. itself. they were used to bring the downfall of the movement, by massacering the innocent & blaming it on the righteous people who were fighting for a cause right enough to be fought for by many. rest, u are just as intelligent as anyone else & are free to think any way u wish. but the truth is not always what we think it is or as it seems to be. perhaps, i am wrong in the way i think & what i know. so i am always open to info, always learning (rather trying to) as the name suggests i am a SIKH. [%sig%]

Re: gruesome pictures in gurdwara

jassmannn · 18 Jun 2007

Singstha, I suppose you agree with everything the Akal Takhat has done and all the people that are representing the Akal Takht. The jewish memorial is welcome. Build something to remember the Sahaheeds, just don't do it in the Gurdwara. You are there to remember god, and it is evident to me that you don'y want to hear my thoughts on Sant Jarnail Singh, because you seem yo be a little aggravated, and that's not what I'm here to do. Just a little more open mindedness and a little more research from both sides of the coin, and you may come to the understanding of why I don;t totally support Jarnail Singh. The rest is your own individual choice.