Advice for Gurdwara tapoban Sahib
please take seriously · 26 Aug 2005
waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh
It is my humble opinion, that Gurdwara Sahib Tapoban does try their very best to follow Gurmat Maryada. They do not follow the mainstream and attempt to do what they seem to perceive as the Gurus' way. I applaud their efforts, and because of their dedication would like to encourage a few more Gurmat Practices to be adhered to at Tapoban Sahib.
1. Only Keertan in the prescribed Raag should be sung.
2. String instruments should be learnt and taught and the harmonium should be phased out.
3. All Amritdhaarees who follow the principles as given to them by their Panj Pyareh should be allowed to partake in any sewa at the Gurdwara.
4. All Keertan should be done Kunt, and not using Amrit Keertan. This ensures that the Keertanee is not only singing the Gurbaani from voice, but it is from Aatam Rang.
5. Even though respect for Bhai Randeer Singhs' teachings should be considered, the teachings of Guru Sahib should be given ultimate respect; for example; Raag.
The reason for singling Tapoban Sahib, is because Tapobans' aim is to follow the Gurus' way as best can be. And if this occur such an astaan would be the most awesome place for all sangat to go.
The Gurdwara should not be followers of AKJ but should be followers of Guru Granth Sahib Jee and the Panth.
I hope that the admin allows this post on, and allows others to share their recommendations based on Gurmat as well.
waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh
[%sig%]
Re: Advice for Gurdwara tapoban Sahib
Harjas Kaur · 27 Aug 2005
[quote]"Only Keertan in the prescribed Raag should be sung. String instruments should be learnt and taught and the harmonium should be phased out."[/quote]
When kirtan is being sung by professional raagi, I fall asleep. When kirtan is precise and correct people lose interest. When raagi is performin, and everybody respectfully listens, their minds wander. At gurudwaras where only the raagis sing, I see a radically diferent sangat, distracted, uninterested, with kids playin outside. Raagi may be a talented musician, but is his perfect composition style evidence of devotion to Waheguruji?
When kirtan is being sung to simple tunes and wholeheartedly by whole sangat (with English translations to enhance understanding of Gurbani) I see something special....JOY! Ecstasy! Pyaar! I see the kids filled with Gursikhi gettin amrit chuked and proudly wearing bana. I see love of Sikhi. I see kids memorizin Gurbani! I see devotion! I see converts! I see mona guys growin kes again! I see sangat proudly wearing kakkars! I see chardikala!
It could be harmonium is added on from British or whatever. Personally I love the sound. And it [i]has[/i] a tradition in the Panth along with tabla.
If we do everything "correctly" it's like saying we have to stay in 16th century. This is not Gurmat Maryada, it's blind tradition. It will not give the sangat the perfections Guruji wants us to cultivate which have to do with character and love of Sikhi. It will not give us chardikala! You want to see real Gursikh chardikala? Go to an AKJ samagam. Bhai Randhir Singhji was completely right.
[%sig%]
Re: Advice for Gurdwara tapoban Sahib
Gurpreet Singh · 27 Aug 2005
3. All Amritdhaarees who follow the principles as given to them by their Panj Pyareh should be allowed to partake in any sewa at the Gurdwara.
I think this suggestion is a must not only fr tapoban, but everywhere in the panth. Who are we to say the Guru's roop panj pyareh when they give rehit.
Re: Advice for Gurdwara tapoban Sahib
BirRaas Singh · 28 Aug 2005
Funny how everything is forced to be followed, bana, hazooria, laridar, keski etc etc, but when it comes to following the Gurmat style of the Gurus Kirtan everyone makes up excuses. To learn something is not easy, if Raag Kirtan becomes more prevalent then any old kid cant jump on the stage and start bashing a tabla and singing out of raag.
Beware of Manmat in the guise of Gurmat.
Re: Advice for Gurdwara tapoban Sahib
Search for tat · 28 Aug 2005
I was quite offended by some of the points made hear.
You said Bhai Randhir singh should be repected, but Guru ji teaching should be respected more. Firstly the Tapoban singh have always respected Guru Ji first, and do not idol worship Bhai Sahib. But if you read Bhai Sahib books, you will see they are purely Gurbani based. Each page is just a gurbani tuk with its meanings. So how are you differentiating between the two? This does not mean Bhai Sahibs books are gurbani, but it does mean the message of Bhai Sahibs book is to follow the Tat Gurmat of Gurbani.
Then you say they shouldnt follow AKJ, but follow the Panth. How are AKJ non panthik? I would say they are the most panthik around. Following AKJ is following the Panth, because AKJ is at the heart of the Panth and has always been hardcore Panthik!
Re: Advice for Gurdwara tapoban Sahib
anbhavi avastha · 28 Aug 2005
those who follow rehit are the panth
Re: Advice for Gurdwara tapoban Sahib
BirRaas Singh · 29 Aug 2005
Author: .
Date: 08-28-05 06:41
Which Raag should be used to sing Gurbaanee in Japjee Sahib?
---------------
Japji Sahib isnt meant to be sung in Kirtan, hence theres no Raag attributed to it
Re: Advice for Gurdwara tapoban Sahib
amarjeet singh · 29 Aug 2005
he doesnt need to go to smaagams?? surely wat ever stage your at going to smaagams will give u more benefit then not going.
vahigurujikakhalsavahigurujikifateh
Re: Advice for Gurdwara tapoban Sahib
Rupinder Singh · 29 Aug 2005
Bhain jee Harjas Kaur summed up her thoughts by saying
“If we do everything "correctly" it's like saying we have to stay in 16th century. This is not Gurmat Maryada, its blind tradition. It will not give the sangat the perfections Guruji wants us to cultivate which have to do with character and love of Sikhi. It will not give us chardikala! You want to see real Gursikh chardikala? Go to an AKJ samagam. Bhai Randhir Singhji was completely right.”
Bhain jee, our Khande Baatte da Amrit sanskar is from 17th century as well. Our GurBani came in hundreds of years ago. Its not how old or young is a concept, its about right and truth. Singing in Raag is not just for professional raagi’s it is for all the the Gursikhs. If a Canadian kids can learn bollywood songs and sing them, then how difficult is for us to learn to sing and listen in raag. If raagi’s are not following what Guru Saheb is instructing, the direct effect is that they have no strength in there saying. Singing in raag does not imply that you do not sing bani with love. When we sing a bani in prescribed raag, don’t we get thrilled by thinking that my Guru has sung this bani on the same surs. Also, I must add this doing sargams sa re ga ma etc. in keertan is not accepted way of raag keertan in Guru Darbar.
Middle of the 20th century, Rabinder Nath Tagore ( Noble prize winner literature; Gitaanjali) came to Darbar sahib. Rabinder Nath Tagore was well respected as a spiritualist in his religion. A Raagi singh (Do not remember his name) was doing keertan in the prescribed raag. Rabinder Nath was so moved with the keertan that he requested the Darbar Sahib Management to ask Raagi Singh to come with him.
Couple of years ago friend of mine was listening to Santa Singh (A puratan raagi 1950-60), the shabad was describing birha (Pain of sepration). A Goora person listned to the keertan, without understanding a word and mentioned that the singing is describing an utmost pain of sepration.
Great Gursikhi’s Bhai Munsha Singh Raagi, Bhai Hari Singh, Bhai Jawala Singh were practitioners of Raag keertan.
Guru Saheb Arjan Dev jee Maharaj would sit under a tree with Saranda (a String Instrument) and not the Vaaja would emerse himself in Ilahi bani. The reetan(musical compositions) that were prevalent in his time are still preserved in sikh panth If we listen to them they are all in raag. As a matter of fact uptill about hundred years ago Harmonium was not even in sikh world. All keertan was used to performed on String instrument.
Harmonium is not a sikh musical instrument, it was reluctantly introduced only about hundred years ago.
Music is a utensil with which shabad is being served to sangat. Guru Saheb has given us such a rich heritage. Lets not wasted with our laziness and stubbornness.
>>>>>When kirtan is being sung by professional raagi, I fall asleep. When kirtan is precise and correct people lose interest.>>>
Now whose fault is it that, Is it that because keertan is precise and correct???
>>>>When raagi is performin, and everybody respectfully listens, their minds wander.
Again, whose fault is it????
>>> At gurudwaras where only the raagis sing, I see a radically different sangat, distracted, uninterested, with kids playin outside. Raagi may be a talented musician, but is his perfect composition style evidence of devotion to Waheguruji?
But it does not prove that a good gursikh should not be talented musician.
Bhain jee “Prem” is fundamental perquisite for keertan, but Singing in prescribed raag will not hurt the sangat.
Once again, loosing our heritage will only hurt us.
Re: Advice for Gurdwara tapoban Sahib
Lets be honest! · 29 Aug 2005
Well said Rupinder Singh, if we do not understand raag's or their meanings or even appreciate the shabads being sung in raag, then that is purely OUR fault!
Many of us do not understand the gurbani being read during akhand paths or during hukumname or even nitnem, in these instances also our mind may wonder and one may suggest that the sangat would get more raas and pay more attention etc if the path was done in english!? Therefore should we do away with gurmukhi as the language in which guru ji wrote gurbani and adopt english, in the same was as we propose to do away with raag's and string instruments and instead use tunes which WE feel are best and instruments which WE feel are best (lets be honest its easier to learn vaja than spend years learning how to learn how to bow and use a string instrument).
Whether we care to admit it or not, no matter how hard it is to listen to and understand raag keertan, it IS the way it was done. Perhaps not exactly the way people do it nowadays, but for sure it is more closer than that which we see at youth promgrammes and rehensbhais.
I would say youth (vaja and made up tunes) keertan does have a place since it IS easier to understand and join in with etc. But lets be totally honest, we have badly badly lost the original tradition of raag keertan.
I dnt believe the singhs are bashing any style of keertan, just stressing that if one wishes to adopt and practice the real khalsa traditions, then keertan in raag using the correct instruments is also part and parcel of that. It is only with practice that we can learn shudu gurbani, and learn katha, and learn how to join our minds with vaheguru etc etc, in the sameway, it is only with practice with which we will learn to understand and listen and appreciate keertan done in raags, as guru ji intended.
Re: Advice for Gurdwara tapoban Sahib
Anbhavi Avastha · 29 Aug 2005
I don't really belive that their was a tradition of raag keertan.
Guru sahib recorded raags as the way he originally sung the shabads, but that doesn't mean that he ALWAYS used raags.
I would imagine guru sahib would want everyone to join in the keertan, meaning that everyone participates regardless of who's playing the instruments, this is in accordance with hukam of gurbani. so many panktis tell us to sing god's praises in sangat... not be passive listeners but be active in the singing .. this doesn't seem plausible with raag keertan as it is done today.
Re: Advice for Gurdwara tapoban Sahib
Rupinder Singh · 29 Aug 2005
WaheGuru Jee Ka Khalsa
WaheGuru Jee Kee Fateh
>>>if u wanna do keertan in raag as writen in guru granth sahib ji then whos gonna find the tune for tunde ass raje ki dhune for asa di vaar no body knows it there r many more dhunees>>>>
There are few old raagis in sikh panth who know Tunde Asraaje kee Dhunne. If you have interest in Gurmat Sangeet you can find those recordings on the web. Try gurmatsangeetproject.com
Also, Naamdhari’s sing this dhunee when ever they do asaa kee var. Few years ago, in late 90’s naamdhari ragi’s visited TO and they made a Full Asaa kee Vaar on TV programe “Dhur Kee Bani”. See if you can find that tape. They sung “Tunde Asraje kee dhunni” in first few shaloks.
>>>I don't really belive that their was a tradition of raag keertan.
Guru sahib recorded raags as the way he originally sung the shabads, but that doesn't mean that he ALWAYS used raags. >>
All the Guru’s(Sarab Kala Samrath) were very high caliber musicians. Raag Asaa, Tukharee and Majh were invented by our Guru’s. The Partaals were introduced by Guru Ram Dass Saheb. Again, If you have interest in Gurmat Sangeet try on net you will find some of the old Partaals recordings. As a matter of fact a lot of Partaal bani cannot be sung in regular filmy tunes as the shabad format in the bani is as such that it will come in the present popular beats. (See Partaals in Raag Sarang, Raag Kanraa, Raag Malhar).
For more info on the format of keertan in puratan times, check on the web, there might be something available. The written text is available in few books written by some old keertanis.
Denying from the facts will not help us. Already there are enough outside forces who want us to break away from from our History, Heritage and as matter of fact from the Bani. No doubt Gurmat Sangeet Vidiya needs little of work to learn; but if we have dedicated our lives to the Gursikh concept than why not learn it. Old times Raagi’s use to practice for years before they would come out in sangat to do keertan sewa. Trends have change in todays world, we want everything to work like fastfood. There was time in history (not too long ago; about 100 years) the Sikhs were considered to be epitome of sangeet vidiya, where are those days gone? Now people make fun of our raagi’s and the music they play. It all start with us. If we want to eastablish the same past glory of Khalsa; Knower of Sangeet/Shaster/Shaaster we need to work towards it, our Guru is samrath. Choice is ours with Guru’s blessing it can be accomplished.
Rest Guru Knows
WaheGuru Jee Ka Khalsa
WaheGuru Jee Kee Fateh