Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

SGPC move on women as Panj Piaras draws flak

SGPC move on women as Panj Piaras draws flak

Tribune News Service · 23 Aug 2005

SGPC move on women as Panj Piaras draws flak Varinder Walia Tribune News Service Amritsar, August 23 Move of the SGPC to involve baptised Sikh women in the Panj Piaras (five beloved ones) and at the time of administering ‘amrit’ has evoked a strong protest from the Sant Samaj, the Damdami Taksal, and former Sikh high priests. Bhai Ranjit Singh, a former Jathedar of Akal Takht, the Damdami Taksal and the Sant Samaj have convened an emergency meeting at Ludhiana on September 1. Bhai Ranjit Singh said that the Panthic organisations would physically remove Giani Joginder Singh Vedanti as Jathedar, Akal Takht if he would toe line of the SGPC and Mr Parkash Singh Badal, President, Shiromani Akali Dal. However, Bibi Jagir Kaur reiterated that as per Panth-approved ‘rehat maryada’ (religious code of conduct), baptised women were allowed to become one of the Panj Piaras. She said the ‘rehat maryada’ had also allowed baptised Sikh women to participate in the ceremony of administering ‘amrit’. Expressing shock over the move of the section of Sikh Panth, she said that it was unfortunate that such religious leaders themselves opposing the ‘maryada’, approved by the Khalsa Panth. However, Bhai Ranjit Singh said that decision to allow Sikh women to perform ‘kirtan’ from the sanctum sanctorum of Harmandar Sahib should be taken only after taking entire Sikh Panth into confidence. Endorsing the views of Bhai Ranjit Singh, Giani Bhagwan Singh, a former head priest of Akal Takht said that there was no tradition of women performing Kirtan from Harmandar Sahib. Baba Harnam Singh Dhumma, Jathedar, Damdami Taksal criticised SGPC chief Bibi Jagir Kaur for her statement that women would be included as Panj Piaras.

Re: SGPC move on women as Panj Piaras draws flak

manjh payara guru ko · 23 Aug 2005

good news [%sig%]

Re: SGPC move on women as Panj Piaras draws flak

confused · 23 Aug 2005

Harnam Singh is a fool and Vedanti needs to get outta there and along with badal simple

Re: SGPC move on women as Panj Piaras draws flak

Singh · 24 Aug 2005

A highly appreciable step by SGPC soon one after the other. But it s is very bad that we have oppositions from those who must actually be on the front line to make these things happen. I hope Taksal stop going on the path of mistakes and support these intiatives to regain its lost glory.

Re: SGPC move on women as Panj Piaras draws flak

some kaur · 24 Aug 2005

I can't believe the protest to this decision, I would have thought that everybody would be encouraging bibian to do the seva. This is disheartening

Re: SGPC move on women as Panj Piaras draws flak

waheguruji... · 24 Aug 2005

waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh after reading all this news on what's heppening with our panth, i just dont know where is the panth going? people dont even have faith in taksal anymore, the taksal which Guru Gobind Singhji Maharaj started is being questioned. the leaders of SGPC is also being questioned.the jathedars are asked to resigned,a lot of back stabbing is hapenning. waheguruji...whats happening to our EKTA? what happen to our Pyar? what is going to happen to our sikhi? cant everyone see,there is some one or something out there which is destroying sikhi and its Kaljug. i just hope and pray that Khalsaji Bhindrawale or Guruji Himself comes in some form and stop all this nonsense or else we are all doomed. what's the point of us doing our nitnem or sukhmani sahib then we condenm our brothers and sisters. though there are some party doing mistakes,but there is always God to take care of them. why are we wasting our time by saying taksal is not good, sgpc is bad,akali dal people are not strong enough....etc. we should worry about ourselves more than we worry abt other ppl. we are the one answerable to Him when we face Him later. the only thing that is can pray for is Kirpa,Ekta and Pyar for our sikh panth. bhul chuk maaf. waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh.

Re: SGPC move on women as Panj Piaras draws flak

Harjinder Singh · 24 Aug 2005

Both Singhs and Singhnis are equal Khalsa. I think it is the rehat of a sikh ( male or female ) that determine whether he can do Punjaan dee seva not the sikh himself whether it is male or female or white or black or chort or tall or fat or thin or whatsoever. All who oppose this step, must think logically according to Gurmat not what they have seen or heard in the past and please do not stop for Waheguru sake any positive step that can strenghthen Khalsa Panth. First we find it even hard to dream that our leaders(whatsoever kind of) will take such steps but then we see it more difficult to implement such high desired decisions if taken by chance due to unexpected strong internal resistance of otherwise considered/assumed panth dardi sikhs.

Re: SGPC move on women as Panj Piaras draws flak

UK Nihang Singh · 24 Aug 2005

Bad Move, Women should not be allowed to do Panj Piaras seva, we getting to weak. I blame SGPC, AKJ and all those other Modern Jatha. No Purtan Jatha allows this.

Re: SGPC move on women as Panj Piaras draws flak

Sakhi · 24 Aug 2005

UK Nihang Ji, Why?

Re: SGPC move on women as Panj Piaras draws flak

Harjas Kaur · 24 Aug 2005

"Bad Move, Women should not be allowed to do Panj Piaras seva, we getting to weak. " Women are not weak. And until we have the equality our Guru gave us, the Panth will be too weak to defend itself against enemies within and without. In a strong country, the women fight back. Not just the men. You divide yourselves when you segregate the women. If women are good enough for cookin and cleanin only, then woman is a slave only. If you are married to a slave, what does that make you? It makes you another slave thats what. Getting too modern? Sikhism is a modern religion. What you want, backwards like Muslim and Hindu? Sikhism is a religion of EQUALITY. Without this, it's just another bondage. [%sig%]

Re: SGPC move on women as Panj Piaras draws flak

manjh payara guru ko · 24 Aug 2005

Author: UK Nihang Singh .............................................. you should call yourself uk nang pk bhang ulta bolna [%sig%]

Re: SGPC move on women as Panj Piaras draws flak

Samandip Singh · 24 Aug 2005

WJKK WJKF While it is true that we should not give up the equality Guru Ji gave us, we should also keep true to the traditions that Guru Ji left for us. The original Punj Pyaare were all men. Therefore those 5 original men cannot be replaced by women. It would not make sense to do so. Had a bibi stood up and given her head then there would surely be a place for a bibi to do seva today and then. Guru Ji asked for a sikh to give up his head. He never said man or woman. Had a woman stood up at the time then bibian doing seva in the punj would have no opposition. Therefore the tradition still holds that those original punj singhs or punj piyaare are represented by singhs. Who are we to go around changing the traditions and maryada Guru Ji left us. We are not in any way smarter or better than He is so we should stick . WJKK WJKF

Re: SGPC move on women as Panj Piaras draws flak

Dalrajkaur Khalsa · 24 Aug 2005

----after reading all this news on what's heppening with our panth, i just dont know where is the panth going? people dont even have faith in taksal anymore, the taksal which Guru Gobind Singhji Maharaj started is being questioned.---- I think the reason as to why people might be losing faith in taksal is because taksal is not the same as it used to be. Just as AKJ has become dhila, so has taksal. Both jatha's do not follow the old rehits that used to be followed, and this might be the reason as to why people are questioning the taksal jatha, as well as AKJ. UK Nihang Singh, How is allowing bibiaan to do seva in punj making us weaker? You can blame whatever Jatha you want, but that won't change anything. Tell me where it says that ONLY SINGHS are allowed to do punj pyaaray dee seva. Any gursikh that is tyaar-bar-tyaar can do seva in punj. you need to stop thinking women are lower than men. I'm glad that sgpc has allowed this to happen. Dalrajkaur Khalsa [%sig%]

Re: SGPC move on women as Panj Piaras draws flak

bo jackson · 24 Aug 2005

Has nothing to do with taksal thinking women are any less, or they are weaker any of that nonsense. A fool could tell you that equality of male female in sikhi is gurmat. Get that clear, taksalis do not think ANY less of women at all.

Re: SGPC move on women as Panj Piaras draws flak

Harjas Kaur · 25 Aug 2005

[quote]"Get that clear, taksalis do not think ANY less of women at all."[/quote] Taksalis believe women are inferior and fight against reforms because: Women CAN't do sewa or kirtan at Darbar Sahib, only MEN are allowed to do this honor. Women CAN'T be Panj Pyara. Only men can have this honor. Women shouldn't tie their hair up in dastaar. Only men can have this crown. The reasons are stupid. It is obvious you think women are less than men, inferior spiritually. The equality your talkin about is a lie! Someone said original Panj no women was willing to give their head. How ridiculous. Not only do we have women willing to give their heads all through Sikh history, and actually dyin and bein tortured, imagine all those wives and mothers willing to give the heads of their sons and husbands proudly as Sikhs even in 1984! How can any of you think a woman should be segregated from the Panth this way. This just shows the world utter disrespect Sikh's have for their women. A woman dies and is tortured for her beliefs same as a man. So she can give her head to Guruji no problem. Only problem is people who don't accept her as real Khalsa. That's why Taksali's have their women's hair showing and not covered up to protect kes. That way they look like Hindu ladies tryin to be glamorous for the men. You don't want women Singhni's with dastaar on like real Khalsa.

Re: SGPC move on women as Panj Piaras draws flak

Dalrajkaur Khalsa · 25 Aug 2005

Samandip Singh, The original punj were a particular height and had different size dhari’s, does this mean that the punj should fit the exact description as the original punj? If Bhai Dharm Singh Ji was 6 foot and had a dhari up to his belly button, then the singh that is standing in an amritsanchar on Bhai Dharm Singh Ji’s spot should be of the same height and their dhari should be the same size. You said that “those 5 original men cannot be replaced by women”, well this goes both ways. The original punj cannot be replaced by someone that does not fit the exact description of the original punj pyaaray. When looking at punj pyaaray, one should not see if they are male or female. It is the inner avasta that counts. ----Guru Ji asked for a sikh to give up his head. He never said man or woman. Had a woman stood up at the time then bibian doing seva in the punj would have no opposition.---- You are right, guru ji asked for a SIKH to give their head. Guru ji did not ask for a man’s head. This clearly states that guru ji did not oppose the idea of bibiaan in punj seva. If only singhs were allowed, then guru ji would have had asked for a SIKH MALES head and not any Sikhs. ----Therefore the tradition still holds that those original punj singhs or punj piyaare are represented by singhs. Who are we to go around changing the traditions and maryada Guru Ji left us.---- Guru ji has left us many tradition behind, but tell me how many actually follow those tradition. Sarbloh bebik rehit is lost in today’s panth. Guru ji told us to wear a sarbloh kirpan and kara, but we see some amritdhari gursikhs wearing steel. The tradition on an amritsachar has changed in the sense where it is not being conducted the way it used to be. We have amritsanchars today where all punj pyaaray get a separate bata and give amrit to all the ablakhee’s. This was started in order to speed the process of an amritsanchar. This is totally wrong; amrit is supposed to be given to an ablakhee by all punj pyaaray and not just one of them. Guru ji asked for a Sikh and not a male. Anyone that is tyaar-bar-tyaar can do punja dee seva. It is the avasta of a gursikh that matters, not their gender. It’s funny how people find it manmat if bibiaan are allowed to do seva in punja dee seva and are trying to put a stop to this, but don’t have a problem with the fact that many amritsanchars are being conducted wrong. Why not focus your energy in stopping all these amrtisanchars that are not being conducted properly. Dalrajkaur Khalsa [%sig%]

Re: SGPC move on women as Panj Piaras draws flak

reply · 25 Aug 2005

>That's why Taksali's have their women's hair showing and not covered up to protect kes. Most who don't wear keski wear chunni, don't they? Where did you get the notion that "taksali" singhs make their wives show their hair? Normally they're covered up with a chunni. [%sig%]

Re: SGPC move on women as Panj Piaras draws flak

reply · 25 Aug 2005

>That's why Taksali's have their women's hair showing and not covered up to protect kes. That way they look like Hindu ladies tryin to be glamorous for the men. If the admin allowed such a complete generalization against Taksal, it would only be fair to counter by saying dastar-valis wear fancy tight suits and wear their chunnis as fashion accessories instead of using them to cover tan (body) like respectable women. They don't think they have to use the chunni because their kes are alredy covered. If this statement sounds unfair, so is the statment above. Do the pictures of taksal smagams in khandedhar magazine show tour-shour (fashion/glamor) women? [%sig%]

Re: SGPC move on women as Panj Piaras draws flak

reply · 25 Aug 2005

>Guru ji has left us many tradition behind, but tell me how many actually follow those tradition. Regarding sarbloh, kirpan/kara, 5 not 1, these are all good points. Probably nobody is opposing thise. Also, it seems you are accepting the fact tthat we have tradtions and they msut be followed. That means there isn't much of a difference between you and taksal/etc. We just have to figure out what the tradtions are that have been passed on since time of 10th King.

Re: SGPC move on women as Panj Piaras draws flak

reply · 25 Aug 2005

>Taksalis believe women are inferior and fight against reforms because: The fact that you said "reforms" seems like a freudian slip that seems to show that the advocates of these changes are aware in their own minds that they are changing the traditions handed down by 10th Master. Can you cite a single instance of women being member of 5 singhs from the time of 1699 uptil the modernday "reformers" started with putting women in panch? If the feminist theory (alien to Sikhism) were true Guru Sahib had 9 opportunities to name a female Guru, but didn't. When time came to create 5 piyare, there were 5 more chances, still no woman. Are you trying to fix what you think was a mistake by Guru Sahib? [%sig%]

Re: SGPC move on women as Panj Piaras draws flak

Bhopinder Singh · 25 Aug 2005

so was no black, chinese, europian what is the meaning of your question REPLY REPLY JI

Re: SGPC move on women as Panj Piaras draws flak

khalsa akal purakh ki fauj · 25 Aug 2005

this is jus too funnny. i was in shock when i read the news last time ... i was talking one of my veer and he said to me, when i say that women can be in 5 piyarey,...with all teh things said above that whats up with the women why is it so hard for u girls to accept that a bibi can;t be in 5, why are u bibian always trying to fight over the stuff that u are not alowed to do. why do u wana chnage the traditions. i was like whats the problme? why can;t be abibi be in 5...and he goes "lets be practicle...i have done the seva of 5 during amritdsanchar...and this is kaljug...whne u sit all togther to do path...and hold batta...u touch a bibis hand u will feel weird...and u dont wana have those feelinbgs while u are in 5" i was so like WHAT!!!! do u feel that way when u are sitting with ur sister??? then he goes..."oh anotherthing...if u want bibi to do seva then she should dress like men...and not wear the pajami..wear a kashara like we do.." well yea i said ofcourse why not? i didn't think that he wouldn;t know that the kasharas u wear are long init...so he goes what the heck... that was funny but what can u say to a peraon like this who has his/her mind set. and at the end he goes "Bhindrawale said that that bibi can;t be in 5. i dont think that im at a avasta...but sant ji was...so are u gona say to me that he was wrong" seriousely someone help me out what do u say to a personlike this. i guess our comminty still have a long way to go to actually undertand and follow what our Guru sahib ji told us. we clame that our religion is the most modern religion... but are we ready to accept it?

Re: SGPC move on women as Panj Piaras draws flak

reply · 25 Aug 2005

>so was no black, chinese, europian >what is the meaning of your question Actually, I don't understand what you were trying to say above. (Not trying to be rude, just trying to understand your question to be able to answer it.) After all "so was no black, chinese, europian" is a sentence fragment, not a sentence, right? Could you flesh out your question/argument more?

Re: SGPC move on women as Panj Piaras draws flak

Samandip Singh · 25 Aug 2005

WJKK WJKF It is our fault that we are not strong enough to stick to the old ways and traditions. Those who still stick to the traditions started by Guru Ji are the strong and we who change with time are weak. We are to wear Sarbloh and those who do are significantly stronger than people like us who change with time and leave the original traditions. So keeping the old traditions is what we need to do. Because as times changed...we changed with them instead of keeping our ways distinct. For us to be strong we need to once again be like the old sikhs and to do that keep our old traditions or we will only get weaker WJKK WJKF

Re: SGPC move on women as Panj Piaras draws flak

reply · 25 Aug 2005

Actually, it's not just 10th Master's 5 Piyare that were Singhs. All 5 piyare of Guru Sahiban that we know of were male. To explain further, if you read some of the various histories, it is explained that Guru Sahib before 10th Master also had 5 rehitvan Sikhs as a kind of highest council of trusted Gursikhs. We know that names of some of these Gursikhs. In no case is there any mention of a woman being made a member of these 5 piyare (beloveds). (If someone has any information to the contrary, could you post it?) So not only with the selection of Guru Sahiban (10) but also 5 piyare (5 multiplied by ??) never was a Sikh woman chosen, although Sikh men of various castes were chosen. If we put this all together, isn't it clear to see that the tradition has always been to choose 5 outstanding Gursikh, Gurmukh men (of whatever caste) the community to lead the community? If Guru ji was also in line with the modern day feminist theory, might not Guru ji have taken the opportunity to make such an appointment?

Re: SGPC move on women as Panj Piaras draws flak

reply · 25 Aug 2005

What possible answer could the feminists give to the question of why Guru ji did not themselves appoint a female Guru or a female 5 piyara? Possible answer 1: It's not necessary to have a female Guru/leader in order to respect dignity of women. Rejoinder: OK, well that seems to be exactly what the taksalis are saying. YOu don't need a female Guru/leader in order to accept dignity of women. So if you can accept male Guru Sahib/male 5 piyaras of Guru Sahiban before 10th Master/male 5 piyaras of 10th Guru ji, why can't you accept 5 male piyaras now? Possible answer 2: One could say Guru ji didn't understand Gurmat and only the modern day feminists have understood Gurmat after consulting feminist/marxist tracts. Rejoinder: This would of course be blasphemous as Guruji is the very source of Gurmat. How can anyone dare to criticize Guru ji's actions? Also, if Guru ji didn't understand something or another, that makes Guru ji not a True Guru -- in which case the whole point of 5 piyaras is useless anyway -- just do what you want, no God, no Guru. Possible answer 3: The society was such that women couldn't be appointed. Rejoinder: Guru ji did every thing else against society, why not this? Guru ji negated caste pride, belief in Vedas as ultimate authority, belief in sacred thread, nepotistic social relationships (3rd Guru ji gave Guruship to son in law Bhai Jeta Ji, not to sons Datu and Dasu), pride of social position (performed seva of kurms), and much else. For a lot of this, people tried to kill the True Guru, and Guru ji had to give Shaheedi and sacrifices in some cases. Do you really think that Guru ji wanted to appoint a female Guru, but was scared (of society or potential killers or of losing sangat or money)? A sakhshiat (personality) that is intimidated or scared in such a way cannot be a True Guru. M: 9 "Neither scare nor be scared, such a one call a Giani (one who has knowledge)" But our Gurus were True Gurus. So the only conclusion one can come to is that they purposely did not appoint female Guru/Gursikh leaders when they had about 20-30 chances to do so.

Re: SGPC move on women as Panj Piaras draws flak

reply · 25 Aug 2005

The appointment of Bhai Jetha ji as Guru Ramdas ji seems to sway even more against the women as 5 position. (Background: Bhai Jetha ji was a poor orphan who had come into the sharan -- asylum -- of Guru Amar Das ji. Impressed with Bhai Jetha's jis SIkhi devotion, 3rd Guru ji first married him to his daughter, Bibi Bhani ji, and then gave him the Guruship.) Note that Guru Amar Das ji passed over his daughter, who was not short in Sikhi devotion, in favor of Bhai Jetha ji. We could also look to 6th Guru Sahib that had a daughter Bibi Veero Ji. When there was a question of the 7th Guruship, Guru Hargobind ji passed over Bibi Veero Ji to give Guruship to their grandson (Guru HarRai Ji) How will feminist Sikhs (that's a contraction, like marxist Sikh) explain all of this to their feminist friends? You're calling Taksal sexist, they'll call Guru Sahiban sexist. Then you'll be na ghar da na ghat da, neither here nor there. Please, just drop feminism and embrace nirol (pure) Sikhism. Sikh meaning being a chela. Whatever the Guru (True Guru) does is right.

Re: SGPC move on women as Panj Piaras draws flak

Gurpreet · 25 Aug 2005

The Question: [I would] just like to say that in the Q&A session of "What right do sikh women have?" i agree with all but one think That is no women can become one of the Panj Pyare (5 beloved). This is due to the fact that when Shir Guru Gobind Singh Ji asked for a head, no women stood up only men did. Therefore only men can be panj pyare. If women in thouse days had the courage to standup then it would of been different. Sorry if this offend anyone. Please feel free to comment on what i have said. --Sandy The reply: I absolutely could not resist responding to your post Sandy. No offense taken. However, it just makes me realize how much more we need to educate our generation. No offense intended here either. When we use a historical event as an example, then in all fairness we need to evaluate the social fabric of the time. At that time when 5 pyiare were called for, you say no women volunteered. I ask you this: 1. How many women were present in the congregation to begin with (ratio of men and women). 2. What was the norm of the time? For women to stay home and care for the family or be the bread winners or the warriors? Social science is at play here. 3. Were women back then encouraged to volunteer for tasks like there that were usually taken up on by men? 4. So you can say that no women were administrators or owned businesses or had the rights to vote at that time so they shouldn't be allowed to own businesses, be presidents of companies or have the right to vote? 5. You say that back then women had no courage to stand up? Well, it was extremely rare for women to be encouraged to stand up. This is a problem that persists even today. If you keep someone oppressed from the day they are born, how can they know to be any different? 6. Guru Nanak defied the norm of the day in granting women equal rights. That is why he was a pioneer, a visionary, a person of God to whom God's word was revealed. 7. At that time no children or elderly volunteered either. So does that mean that they did not have the courage? How many other factors are we going to come up with to discriminate against each other? So I guess age should be a factor in picking our Panj Piare. Oh wait, did any vegetarians volunteer? Did any Sushi lovers volunteer? Not to humor anyone, but where does this end? It is a provoking topic and I am glad you brought it up, however your argument is very weak and irrational. Your comment defies the basic principles of equality. We need to reflect on history and think about why our Guru's indeed encouraged us to defy the beleifs of that time. Then why is it that some people insisit on in infusing doubt and uncertainty in the Sikh community. With all due respect for your opinion that I whole heartedly disagree with, no offense is intended. We must learn our history and know where we come from and only then we can move forward. We have much to learn. Gurpreet [%sig%]

Re: SGPC move on women as Panj Piaras draws flak

From MKhalsa's website · 25 Aug 2005

rehat is same and Amrit is same but Guru Ji asked for a head and no women stood up....Guru Ji could've chosen any woman but he didn't. No woman gave her head so why should women be in this seva? Five men stood up which was not a coincidence. Jeeo, Think about this: Only 5 people from specific castes stood up as well. Does that mean Panj Pyare can only be khatri, jatt, water carrier, clothes washer, or barber? What about a Chumar (shoe maker) or Tarkhan? Can they not be in the Panj Pyare then? Your whole argument is illogical. What about gorae Sikhs, some white person may have been there, and there definitely were those of Muslim descent, can they not be Panj Pyare either? I keep hearing this argument again and again, but it makes no sense. If women be in Panj Pyare then it becomes Panj Pyareean. is it not practice to call gursikhs in the "they" form. such as Baba Jarnail Singh Jee Bhindra Valae, not Bhindra Vala.. same for singhnee not valee but valae... thus it would still be punj pyarae. Also, If women are in the Khalsa, why aren’t they called Khalsee? We are all Khalsa, regardless of gender. Women (men in this world, we all have female souls according to bani) are already in Panj Pyare. So what is the problem? All are women and women are in panj pyare. So nothing should change. Right? Right, nothing should change, women are already in panj pyare and have been for hundreds of years, and will continue to be, whether they are women in human form or not. What needs to change is peoples attitudes. --Daas Mkhalsa

Re: SGPC move on women as Panj Piaras draws flak

Harjas Kaur · 25 Aug 2005

Get off your feminist bandwagon. I never said Taksal was sexist. I am sayin some of their positions are discriminating against women. FYI I am not a feminist. But I work as a nurse and get to see a lot of women who get beat up by their husbands. I have had patients who later died from their injuries. I remember one lady, on a ventilator, bald after the brain surgery trying to save her. There was a photo on the wall of a very pretty lady with long beautiful hair and two little boys. One fine day her husband saw fit to bash her head several times into the doorstep. I watched this lady die. Her husband is currently in prison for murder. Don't mistake defense of the poor women and demand for respect and rights for women as being feminist political philosophy which is extremist and also anti-Panth. There are two parts of the Panth that are one, the men AND the women together. Discriminating against women is the same as publicly devaluing them and sayin their less than a man. Are you tellin me society doesn't have this anti-woman attitude already? You think Guruji had this attitude too? How many ladies have got to be degraded, excluded, segregated and beated and die before you try and protect them from injustice? I'm saying some of these extreme positions that a woman can't do this and that don't even give her a chance. Can a woman do sewa? Yes. Can a woman do beautiful kirtan? Yes. Can a woman be wise and spiritual? Yes. But a woman can't be a Panj Pyara or sewadar or kirtanee in Harmandar Sahib. Why? Because she is female. Basically people fear men might get temptation, so based on her femaleness she is inherently inferior spiritually and physically unclean. Why then don't you agree with the Muslims that to beat her into submission is a good thing?

Re: SGPC move on women as Panj Piaras draws flak

Bhopinder Singh · 25 Aug 2005

REPLY JI you said no women gave head in the first panj. It was with reference to that so was no black, chinese, europian

Re: SGPC move on women as Panj Piaras draws flak

Bhopinder Singh · 25 Aug 2005

since no panj piaras were Chinese,White,Black are they allowed to serve in panj cause your own statement would deny them the right. REPLY REPLYJI

Re: SGPC move on women as Panj Piaras draws flak

A S · 25 Aug 2005

Women should be allowed to do Kirtan and Sewa and they will. This shouldn't even be an issue.

Re: SGPC move on women as Panj Piaras draws flak

dont know · 25 Aug 2005

THE PANJ PIARAI WERE PICKED BEFORE THEY STOOD UP IF GURU JI WANTED A WOMAN TO STAND UP A WOMAN WOULD HAVE STOOD UP THE DECISION WAS MADE BY GURU JI WE KNEW OF IT IN 1699 BUT IT WAS MADE BEFORE THAT IM ALL FOR EQUALITY BUT THIS HAS NOTHING TO DO WITH IT IT WAS GURU JI'S DECISION WE CANT SAY OH IF A WOMEN STOOD UP THEN HE WOULD HAVE SAID YES IF HE WANTED A WOMAN TO STAND UP IT WOULD HAVE HAPPENED AT THE TIME YOUR TELLING ME THAT THERE WASNT ANY CHARDI KALA GURSIKH WOMEN THAT COUDLN'T HAVE STOOD UP THERE WAS SO MANY BUT THEY DIDNT STAND UP I'VE ALWAYS SHOWN RESPECT TO WOMEN IN MY LIFE SO DONT THINK I'M HATING I'M JUST SAYING WHAT I SEE THATS IT

Re: SGPC move on women as Panj Piaras draws flak

Dalrajkaur Khalsa · 26 Aug 2005

The arguments made by Reply Ji are baseless. It is sad to read such posts that think of women to be lower. Those that say they think of women to be equal, really don’t. Reply ji, tell me where it says that only Singhs are allowed to do punja dee seva. If guru ji said I need one male Sikh’s head, then I would take the same stand as you, but as you have said guru ji asked for a Sikh’s head. ----Can you cite a single instance of women being member of 5 singhs from the time of 1699 uptil the modernday "reformers" started with putting women in panch?--- Can you say with 100% confidence that no bibi had taken part in punja dee seva in purataan times? There could have had been amritsanchars with bibiaan doing seva, but is not talked about, just like any other amirtsanchar that has taken place in purataan times. There is not a listing of gursikhs names who have done punja dee seva. So for all you know, bibiaan could have had been doing seva in punj all the time. khalsa akal purakh ki fauj, Punj pyaaray are not supposed to get dirty thoughts while doing punja dee seva. If this is another excuse to say that bibiaan are not allow to do punja dee seva, then there is a solution to this. Why not have all punj bibiaan. This way, no one will get wrong thoughts in their head. And now if you say that someone might get wrong thoughts if they see a bibi’s leg, well this can work both ways. What if a bibi gets wrong thoughts when they see a Singh’s leg? I have utmost respect for Taksal, but it is starting to seem as if Taksal does have something against bibiaan. Why are they depriving bibiaan from doing kirtan seva at Darbar Sahib and punja dee seva? Dalrajkaur Khalsa

Re: SGPC move on women as Panj Piaras draws flak

Bhopinder Singh · 26 Aug 2005

REPLY JI panj gave heads as HUMANS not as men or women , no one should dare challenge this it was for humanity. You could be feminist or a female basher it has nothing to do with the above fact. you may believe in women being apvitar( not pious) . read asa di vaar

Re: SGPC move on women as Panj Piaras draws flak

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 26 Aug 2005

Here is an interesting read i came across on my other Forum.. -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- With the Divine Love & Blessings of Sat Guru Ji, I wish you peace, love, light (enlightenment), health & happiness in life! http://www.singhsabha.com/equality_of_women.htm Equality of Women in Sikh Ideology and Practice Valarie Kaur* A drastic distinction between the roles of the male and female exists in all of history’s modern human societies. Women have grown to accept, not without resentment though, the male-dominated atmosphere of the world. Because people use religious doctrine to define their life styles, religious scriptures in both the East and the West seem to condone, even encourage, the unequal treatment of women. In the 15th century, Guru Nanak established Sikhism, the first religion to advocate emphatically the equality of all people, especially women. In a continent characterised by severe degradation of women, this bold declaration, along with others, determined to erase the impurities of the Indian society. However, prejudices and injustices based on gender linger even today. In the dominant Western religion of Christianity, God created man, and then woman out of man’s rib. Eve, the first woman persuades Adam to eat the forbidden apple, thus committing the world’s first sin, a landmark recognized as the fall of mankind. The implied inferiority and corrupting influence of women in the Bible appear to justify their second rate treatment in Western society. In Eastern Society, the Muslim religion also demeans women. The Koran contains explicit details concerning the inferior treatment of women. This includes the right of a man to divorce his wife, never vice versa, and the wearing of a veil to cover a woman’s face, called burkah, in public. The Koran reminds men, "Your women are a tilth for you (to cultivate) ... And they (women) have rights similar to those (of men) over them in kindness, and men are a degree above them."2 At the time of Guru Nanak, Indian women were severely degraded and oppressed by their society. Given no education or freedom to make decisions, their presence in religious, political, social, cultural, and economic affairs was virtually non-existent.3 Woman was referred to as "man’s shoe, the root of all evil, a snare, a temptress."4 Her function was only to perpetuate the race, do household work, and serve the male members of society. Female infanticide was common, and the practice of sati, the immolation of the wife on her husband’s funeral pyre, was encouraged, sometimes even forced. Guru Nanak condemned this man-made notion of the inferiority of women, and protested against their long subjugation. The Ultimate Truth was revealed to Guru Nanak through a mystic experience, in direct communion with God. Guru Nanak conveys this Truth through the bani, Sikh Scripture. It first argues against the sexist sentiments of the pompous man about the necessity of women : "In a woman man is conceived, From a woman he is born, With a woman he is betrothed and married, With a woman he contracts friendship. Why denounce her, the one from whom even kings are born ? From a woman a woman is born, None may exist without a woman." 5 The fundamental analogy used in the bani depicts the relationship between God and man, and proves that the physical body does not matter. The bani parallels all human beings (men and women) to the woman/wife, and God to the man/husband. 6 This means that every person is a sohagan — a woman who is the beloved of the Lord — whether they have the body of a man or woman. Because the human body is transitory, the difference between man and woman is only transitory, and as such superficial. 7 Thus, according to Sikh ideology, all men and women possess equal status. All human beings, regardless of gender, caste, race, or birth, are judged only by their deeds. With this assertion, the Sikh Gurus invited women to join the sangat (congregation), work with men in the langar (common kitchen), and participate in all other religious, social, and cultural activities of the gurdwaras (Sikh places of worship). The Gurus redefined celibacy as marriage to one wife and taught that male and female alike need to practice conjugal fidelity. They advocated marriage of two equal partners. Guru Amar Das, the third guru, wrote : "Only they are truly wedded who have one spirit in two bodies." 8 Guru Amar Das also condemned purdah, the wearing of the veil, and female infanticide. He spoke against the custom of sati, thus permitting the remarriage of widows. 9 Out of 146 chosen, the Guru appointed 52 women missionaries to spread the message of Sikhism, and out of 22 Manjis established by the Guru for the preaching of Sikhism, four were women.10 The steps the Gurus took to advocate the equality of women, revolutionized the tradition of Indian society. As they began to partake in social, religious, and political affairs, their contribution and worth as equal partners of men became more obvious. However, the Guru’s teachings of equality have never been fully realized, which is clearly evident in the treatment of women even in the Sikh society today. Either because of the influence of the majority community on the Sikh minority or the Sikh male’s unwillingness to give up his dominant role, women continue to suffer prejudices. A woman has never been elected as the president of Shiromani Gurdwara Parbandhak Committee(the Central Management Committee to manage the affairs of the Gurdwaras in the Punjab), or as the head of any of the five Takhts (the thrones of authority).11 Indian society discriminates against women in workplaces, and denies them the right to fight on the battlefield. People measure a woman’s value as a bride by the size of her dowry, not necessarily by her character and integrity. Alice Basarke, a free-lance writer, sadly realizes, "After 500 years head start, Sikh women are no better off than their counterparts in any other religion or nation."12 As a Sikh girl, born and raised in the United States, I have felt confusion and frustration upon recognizing the hypocrisy in the Sikh community in the subjugation of their women. America, origin of Elizabeth Cady Stanton’s 1848 Women’s Liberation Movement, crawls ahead of other nations in the race to achieve practised equality for all. Because of its diverse and opportune atmosphere, I have experienced little discrimination based on my gender. I must struggle to empathize with the feelings of women in India whose tragic experiences I have not actively shared. Yet, I am told, that upon my birth, distant relatives sent my parents blessings that sounded more like condolences than congratulations. Apparently, they pitied the supposed dowry my family would have to prepare, the inheritance I could never receive, and the family name that could never survive by me. One can imagine their joy and relief upon my brother’s birth two years later. Such hypocritical actions bewilder me. Why didn’t Sikh women rise up long ago in protest against such treatment, reciting the words of the Gurus ? Why did we not endeavour long ago to realize fully the freedom and equality the Gurus advocated for all human beings, regardless of gender ? Is the equality the Gurus preached even understood by Sikhs ? At one time, Sikhs risked their very lives to fight for equality by opposing the caste system. Yet, today, many Sikhs judge each other by the caste they are from and the amount of income they earn. As Ms Basarke poignantly puts it, "How can women expect equality, when the Sikh community seems unable to distinguish between religious tenets and the culture imposed by the majority community which engulfs them ?"13 Indeed, how can women realize equality when the root of the problem lies much deeper than marches of protests or laws can reach ? The Sikh community needs to look beyond the ingrained customs, social taboos and know the true salubrious nature of justice and equality; the Sikh community needs to realise its tragic entanglement in a system that embraces practices antithetical to the very basis of the Sikh faith, against the very word of God; the Sikh community needs to shake itself vigorously to awaken and rise into a truly strong and potent religious people, living the way God desires us to live : by freedom, justice, love, and equality— for all. Many Sikhs will acknowledge this truth, but instead of finding the enthusiasm and hope to shape the future, they will sadly shake their heads. After all, can we possibly unravel thousands of years of deep-seated Indian mentality ? Do the powers of revolution truly lie within our grasps ? We need only to remember the words of Guru Gobind Singh for an answer : "With your own hands carve out your destiny."14 ~~~ REFERENCES 1. Robert O. Ballou : The Portable World Bible, Penguin Books, 1976, p. 237-241. 2. Mohammed Marmaduke Pickthall, translator : The Meaning of Glorious Koran, Mentor Book, New American Library, New York and Scarborough, Ontar io, 1924, p. 53, Surah II, 223-228. 3. Kanwaljit Kaur : Sikh Women, Fundamental Issues in Sikh Studies, Institute of Sikh Studies, Chandigarh, 1992, p. 96. 4. Ibid. 5. Guru Granth Sahib : p 73. 6. Ibid. : p. 1268. 7. Prof. Prabhjot Kaur : Women’s Liberation Movement and Gurmat, Abstracts of Sikh Studies, April-June 1997, Institute of Sikh Studies, Chandigarh, p.76. 8. Guru Granth Sahib, p.788. 9. Ibid., p. 787. 10. Kanwaljit Kaur : op. cit., p. 99. 11. Alice Basarke : Where Are the Women ?, Current Thoughts on Sikhism, Institute of Sikh Studies, Chandigarh, 1996, p, 265. 12. Ibid. 13. Ibid. 14. Ibid. __________________ With the Divine Love & Blessings of Sat Guru Ji, I wish you peace, love, light (enlightenment), health & happiness in life! http://www.sikhreview.org/november2001/moral1.htm Sikh Spirituality and Contribution of Women Shashi Bala, MA, Ph.D.* * Reader, Deptt of Guru Nanak Studies, Guru Nanak Dev University, Amritsar 143005. If we analyse the contributions of the Sikh women to the development of religious life and spirituality, there remains no doubt that they are the foundational basis of the Sikh religious life. The great works and achievements of Sikh women in the social, religious and administrative spheres cannot be underestimated, while evaluating the religio-historical progress of the Sikh religion. The prominent women who occupied a conspicuous place in Sikhism, belonged largely to the Guru’s family, either as mother or daughter or wife or sister. They have contributed to the Sikh religion in several ways, viz., looking after the domestic affairs of their family during the missionary tours of the Gurus; assisting them in the implementation of ideals; accompanying with the Gurus during their preaching; helping the Gurus in making an impartial choice of successor for Guruship; doing works of social welfare; offering sacrifices of the Guru-husband, of son and of grandsons - for the cause of the panth; and serving as beaconlights to the panth. The most significant roles such as Bebe Nanaki’s sisterely affection, Mata Khivi’s Langar organisation, Bibi Bhani’s spirit of service, Mata Gujri’s sacrifice, Mata Sundari’s guidance to the Sikh community, Mata Sahib Kaur’s designation as the "Mother of Khalsa," Mai Bhago, the first woman general, Bibi Deep Kaur, the warrior, Bibi Sharan Kaur’s devotion for relgion, Bibi Rup Kaur, the first author of Sikhism, Sardarni Sada Kaur, Sardar of the Kanhiya Misl’s patriotism and bravery, etc. are unparalleled instances in the history and development of the Sikh religion. Here, we may mention about some illustrious Sikh women who did spectacular deeds in the Sikh religious life and are well-known and are remembered with devotion and honour in the Sikh history. [bold]Bebe Nanaki, the elder sister of Guru Nanak, is recognized as the sister and the mother of the Sikhs. She perceived with her keen sensibility the prophet-like qualities of Guru Nanak and became the first disciple of the Guru. Speaking about Bebe Nanaki, a famour historian writers:[/bold] The sister, from the very beginning, has great attachment to her brother and was probably the first to discover the promise of future greatness in him. She is reverently remembered by the Sikhs as Bebe Nanaki. [Fauja Singh]37 The contribution of Mata Sulakhni, wife of Guru Nanak, cannot be ignored. She looked after the domestic matters during her husband’s thirty years of preaching and actually implemented the ideals of Guru Nanak. The basic ideal of the Sikh Religion is to establish equality irrespective of caste, creed and race. For the implementation of this ideal, one important institution is the community kitchen or Langar, where people of all castes, high or low, male or female sit together in rows on the floor and eat together. The wives of the Gurus contributed in their own ways to give a practical shape to this ideal. No one can ever be oblivious of the name of [bold]Mata Khivi, wife of Guru Angad, who was not only administrator of the langar but also cooked and served. Due to her dedication, she was praised and her name occurs in the Holy Scripture. Says Balwand: "Blessed is Khivi, the Guru’s wife whose dense leafy shade gives shade to all. In the Guru’s kitchen, food is served abundantly, Yea, the rice-pudding, mixed with ghee, which is nectar-sweet.[SGGS:967]38[/bold] [bold]The process of elevation of women in the socio-religious milieu was carried on the Bibi Amro, daughter of Guru Angad, who inherited the noble traits of her parents and contributed in uniting the two great souls of Guru Angad and Guru Amardas. Guru Amardas could have met Guru Angad only on hearing the hymns sung by Bibi Amro.[/bold] In the religious history of Sikhism, women served as missionaries in the fifteenth century. No doubt, women started taking part in singing of hymns (kirtan) and in missionary work since the period of Guru Nanak. But the third Guru, on the initiation of his wife, Mata Mansa Devi, who used to accompany the Guru, raised voice against the custom of sati and installed women as missionary preachers, by offering them official seats. He started the manji tradition, which refer to the seat of the provincial Sikh leader and offered two seats to women whose names in the list of manjis (given in the Haveli Sahib Picture) are Mai Sewa, of Kabul, and Mai Bhago of Kashmir. In addition, fifty two other missionaries were selected, the prominent names are Bibi Rajni and Mai Sabhraee.[GS Mansukhani: Aspects of Sikhism]39 An embodiment of devotion and humility was[bold] Bibi Bhani, who was the daughter of Guru Amar Das and who spearheaded the task of organizing langar and started the tradition of hereditary Guruship by asking of blessings from Guru Amardas, her father, whom she served like a son. She was granted a jagir (estate) by Emperor Akbar, when the latter visited the Guru and shared food in the community kitchen (langar). The Guru said, "All right, as you wish, O King Akbar! But your contribution will be utilized for the welfare of the widows under the supervision of Bibi Bhaniji."[GS Mansukhani: Ibid]40[/bold] However, the names of[bold] Mata Gujri, Mata Sahib Devan, Mata Sundari are well-known in the Sikh religious history for their participation in political and war affairs. Mata Gujri, the wife of Guru Tegh Bahadur, held the position of wife of a martyr, mother of martyr and the grandmother of martyrs and herself a martyr. She organized the langar and played a keen role as administrator of army. She, alongwith her grandsons, was captured by Subedar of Sirhind, who tortured and compelled her to accept Islam, which she refused and faced dire consequences. She was kept in captivity, alongwith her two grandsons and on hearing the news of the execution of her grandsons, she laid down her life and that place is now known as Gurdwara Burj Mata Gujri.[/bold] [bold]Mata Sundari, the wife of Guru Gobind Singh, was known not only to the Sikhs of Punjab, but also to the Sikhs of India. They used to visit Mataji to seek her blessings and willingly obeyed the orders (hukamnamas) issued by her. Even after the death of Guru Gobind Singh, she guided the Sikh community for forty years. The Sikhs used to gather in the Haveli of Mata Sundari to celebrate the festivals of Diwali and Baisakhi. This Haveli is known as Mata Sundari Gurdwara.[/bold] The involvement of women in the religious activities is visible in the case of Mata Jito, who was initiated into the Khalsa in the beginning and who also put the sugar crystals into the water to ensure the sweetness of the water to be given as amrit to the first initiated five beloved ones. Even Mata Sahib Kaur was bestowed with the status of mother of Khalsa, which Guru Gobind Singh has given her on her desire for a son. It is said that Guru Gobind Singh got married to Mata Sahib Devan on the request of the congregation (sangat) and had no physical relation but only spiritual relation with her. Even today, it is said to the initiated members of Khalsa that they are the habitants of Anandpur Sahib, and Guru Gobind Singh is their father and Mata Sahib Kaur is their mother. Apart from the achievements of these women, belonging to the families of the Gurus, there are many other women who contributed in the Sikh religious history by their participation as warriors in the battlefield. No one can forget the name of Mai Bhago, the first women General, who took the command to fight with enemy, when the forty men of Guru Gobind Singh’s army had withdrawn themselves. On seeing her dauntless courage, they felt ashamed of their disloyalty to the Guru and re-joined him. Another warrior Bibi Deep Kaur, showed faith, courage and bravery and refused to yield to the enemy, even when she was mortally injured in the battlefield. Another important instance of fearlessness and bravery is Sardarni Sada Kaur, who was the head of Kanhiya Misl and who fought in the battlefield in disguise and served Punjab for thirty-three years. The above mentioned instances of the achievements of women in the Sikh history clearly indicate their contribution as social reformers; as warriors; as missionary preachers and as an emblem of patience and service. She is helpful in the character building and in the attainment of spiritual heights. From the temporal and spiritual point of view, woman is half man’s body and she always assists him to the door of deliverance.41 Participation of Women in Religious Worship: The Sikh religion makes no distinction between man and woman at the theological level, as well as at the social level. The contributions of women in the socio-religious sphere of the Sikh history clearly indicate to their equal status with man. When the tenth Guru, Guru Gobind Singh, created the Khalsa, he made no distinction of caste, race, creed and sex and admitted the women in the fold of Khalsa. Even today, whenever any person, man or woman is baptised, they are treated as one. The Guru, after baptism, granted each male Sikh the surname, ‘Singh’ or Lion, and each female the surname ‘Kaur’ or princess. They are supposed to wear the five symbols of Khalsa viz., Kesh (uncut hair), Kangha (comb), Kara (steel wrist band), Kirpan (sword) and Kacch (a pair of breeches). The Sikh Rahit-Maryada (a guide to the Sikh way of life), approved by Shiromani Gurdwara Parbhandak Committee (S.G.P.C.) on 3 Feb. 1945, makes no difference between man and woman in the definition of Sikh which is given as below: A Sikh is that woman or man, who believes in One God, in the ten Gurus and their teachings and in the Adi Granth. In addition, he or she must believe in the necessity and importance of amrit (initiation) and must not adhere to any other religion. Therefore, the obligatory duties of Khalsa are similar for both man and woman. They are supposed to recite some hymns in the daily routine viz., Japji Sahib, Jap Sahib and Ten Swayyas of Guru Gobind Singh, Sodar, Rahiras (evening prayer) and Sohilla (late evening prayer before retiring). The modes of worship in the Sikh Religion can be performed by reading the Holy Scripture, Sri Guru Granth Sahib, singing of hymns of Gurus in the holy congregation (kirtan), listening to sermons or discourses based on the teachings of the Guru (ketha). Any man or woman, who is a Sikh according to the above mentioned definition of Sikh Rahit –Maryada, can participate in any mode of worship and no prohibition is laid down for women. Besides the normal reading of the Holy Scripture which is to be installed at a specific place in the house, the Sikh women can also participate to the akhand path, i.e. (uninterrupted complete reading of the Holy Scripture) which is undertaken on specific occasions of joy and sorrow, and the complete reading is to be carried out by a relay of Sikhs, may be family members, and takes approximately forty eight hours. Another essential part of the Sikh worship is prayer (Ardas), which should be offered regularly. The Sikh women are fully entitled to participate in prayer and can hereself recite the prayer. It is most significant to note that in the prayer (Ardas), there comes reference of those great men and women, who wore arms and practiced charity and suffered for the cause of the panth: Those men and women who, keeping the Name in their hearts, shared their earnings with others; who plied the sword and practiced charity; who saw other’s faults but overlooked them: think of their deeds and call on God! (Wonderful Lord!).42 After the prayer, Karah Parsad, made from plain flour cooked with equal quantities of ghee and sugar is served to the congregation. No inhibition is imposed on the Sikh women for the preparation of prasad. The Sikh women are allowed to prepare food at the community kitchen and to serve it in langar. The religious worship, in any form, can be performed by the women, with the only condition that like men, they should be amritdharis or members of the Khalsa and they must abide by the rules of Sikh Rahit-Maryada. It is most relevant to note that at present, the post of president of Shiromani Gurdwara Parbhanda Committee (a most important religious body of the Sikhs) was held by a woman, Bibi Jagir Kaur who was appointed on this post on 16 March, 1999 and was selected (by general voting) again for the same post on 10 Nov., 1999 until she resigned. This clearly indicates that women in Sikhism, have full freedom to participate in religious worship and religious activities. Conclusion: The recapitulate, we can say that the Sikh religion accords an equal status to women in all spheres of life, viz., religious, social and political: · From the theological perspective, no distinction is made between man and woman and it is vividly clear in the holy compositions of the Sikh Gurus as well as in the creation of Khalsa and in the definition of the Sikh as is given in the Sikh Rahit-Maryada. · To add spiritual dimension to the personality of women, all the individual souls (jivatma), are symbolically taken as women or brides of Lord who always yearn for union with their Lord and who must develop woman-like virtues to attain communion with God. The loving devotion of the individual souls is presented through the symbol of husband-wife relationship and a jivatma is ever suhagan (married women) who enjoys the presence of Lord-God due to her merits. · To elevate the status of women, the Sikh Gurus, through their holy compositions and through the examples of their practical life, have taken steps for the socio-religious equality of women. They condemned the custom of sati, female infanticide, forced widowhood adultery and seclusion of women by being in veils (purdah). On the other hand, they commended married life by giving it religious sanctity and allowed the remarriage of widows. · The implementation of the ideals of the Sikh Gurus has been carried on by the participation of the Sikh women in the socio-religious field, as is evident in the Sikh history of past and present. They have made great contributions in serving and organizing of the community kitchen (langar), working as missionaries, sacrificing themselves and their families for the Sikh community, fighting bravely in the battlefield and offering guidance to the Sikh community in the critical periods. · In the religious sphere, no prohibition is imposed on women for participation in religious worship and religious rituals. They can become members of significant religious bodies. v References 37. Fauja Singh, ‘A Study of the Paintings of Guru Nanak’ in Papers on Guru Nanak, Punjab History Conference Proceedings, March 14-15, 1969. P.122. 38. Guru Granth Sahib (3), p.967, trans. Dr. Gopal Singh, op. Cit., Vol. 4, p.924. 39. G.S. Mansukhani, Aspects of Sikhism, Punjabi Writers, Cooperative Industrial Society, New Delhi, p. 138. 40. Ibid, p. 155. 41. Dr. Jodh Singh, Varan Bhai Gurdas, Var 5, Pauri 16, Vol. 1, p. 156. 42. W.O. Cole and P.S. Sambhi, op, cit ================================================== ======================== Please review the following link too: http://www.sikhwomen.com/equality/social/history/statusofwomeninsikhism.htm [%sig%]

Re: SGPC move on women as Panj Piaras draws flak

reply · 26 Aug 2005

>If guru ji said I need one male Sikh’s head, then I would take the same stand as you, but as you have said guru ji asked for a Sikh’s head. Dalraj Kaur bhenji, It looks like we are closer than might appear. Basically it seems you are saying that if it were unequivocally established that Guru ji desired males to do 5 seva, you would support it, since after all he is your Guru. And also I think people opposing this move would support it if it were unequivocally established that Guru ji desired females in the 5. Hopefully you can see that there's no antagonism; we are just discussing various points of an issue. Thanks to everyone posting your best arguments. Could someone try to answer the questions I posed in the posts above? More posts later.

Re: SGPC move on women as Panj Piaras draws flak

khalistani · 26 Aug 2005

just one thing im not gonna coment on this thing about panj pyarai with women, cause then ill just get in fight, get angry mabe, no point, let panj dooths get all worked up, just mess me up arguing and arguing but do women REALLY want TRU equality? meaning w/e a man can do women can do vice viersa ,etc so then its ok for me to beat the crap out of a bibi now? r u sure there no diff between men and women? of course there is differnce some roles men do, some roles women do its nothing to do with one being higher than the other, just like do men wanna get angry at vaheguru je and say y u make us unequal, y cant i give birth to babies but w/e this list can go on forver bout hypocrisy on equality but theres really not much point just think bout it is it really equal? wud it make sence to say it shud be 100 PERCENT euqal? women r not impure women r not less then men but both can and cannot do some things the other can or cannot bhula chuka maf

Re: SGPC move on women as Panj Piaras draws flak

Sakhi · 26 Aug 2005

Why even allow women to take amrit? I don't know any women to took amrit from the first punj pyare, if you say otherwise, prove it. Why allow women to do keertan at any Gurudwara at all? They should be banned from doing keertan in Gurudwara's altogether. Why allow them to do any seva at all? We don't have proof of them doing any seva in Guru Sahibs time. Guru Sahib just said don't treat women badly, they never said treat them as equal. Right!.................just listen to yourselves you chauvanistic fools! If a woman can give you birth, instill sanskaars in you, teach you gurbani, cook for you, clean for you, take care of your kids all while remaining tyaar bar tyaar, she is not good enough to do punja dee seva because she is a woman.................does this make any sense at all, use logic guys & some common sense!

Re: SGPC move on women as Panj Piaras draws flak

Sakhi · 26 Aug 2005

Khalastani Ji, If you knew how painful it is to give birth you would know not to complain, trust me.

Re: SGPC move on women as Panj Piaras draws flak

khalistani · 26 Aug 2005

sakhi je , lol, i aint saying at all it aint painful women are extremly strong for going through that but my point was that men and women r at same level but both cannot do EVERYTHING the other can like the examples in my other post bhula chuka maf

Re: SGPC move on women as Panj Piaras draws flak

Harjas Kaur · 26 Aug 2005

[quote]"but do women REALLY want TRU equality? meaning w/e a man can do women can do vice viersa ,etc so then its ok for me to beat the crap out of a bibi now?"[/quote] Dude,is this your opinion of equality? If it is, you've got issues. True equality does not "free" a woman to get beaten. She's already getting beaten and devalued by society. People think a women is inferior, can do less and justify the anger of a man to hit her like a bully. If people felt women had a value equal to themselves they wouldn't be punching her at all. You realize there are women doctors, psychologists, judges, and even psychiatrists. Yet you degrade the ability of a bibi to be a wise, capable, honorable Panj Pyare just for bein a woman? Can a woman lift heavy things like a man? Does woman have physical endurance of a man? This is not the equality. Equality is that in all things a man can do, a woman can do something of equal value. What she lacks in strength and endurance she makes up for in ability to give birth, to feed those babies, to love and look after that man. True equality is not about makin women act like men, it's about not degrading or depriving them because they're women. True equality is about valuing, honoring and loving someone the same as you love yourself, without discrimination or denial of the opportunity to do what you can do. [%sig%]

Re: SGPC move on women as Panj Piaras draws flak

reply · 27 Aug 2005

It should be noted that at this point this is only a proposal by Bibi Jagir Kaur. If this proposal is not accepted, will people blame the committee? And why? [%sig%]

Re: SGPC move on women as Panj Piaras draws flak

Dalrajkaur Khalsa · 29 Aug 2005

Reply ji, How are we closer than it appears? I am for bibiaan doing punja dee seva, whereas you are against it. What question did you ask above that you would like an answer too? Khalistani ji, Women and men are different when you look at those aspects. But those aspects do not have anything to do with gurmat. When we are talking about equality, it is meant in a gurmat way. Tell me of one aspect (relating to gurmat), that a female can do and a male can’t, or vice versa. In gurmat, bibiaan and Singh are equal. Guru ji refers to amritdhari Singhs and Singhnee-an in Bani as “Khalsa”. This shows that both are equal once they have taken amrit. Both become Khalsa. It is said that in 1699, “Khalsa sajiya”, it is not said “Singh Sajiya”. It is also said that any tyaar-bar-tyaar Khalsa (Sikh) can do punja dee seva. No where does it say that only Singhs are allow to do punja dee seva. Dalrajkaur Khalsa [%sig%]

Re: SGPC move on women as Panj Piaras draws flak

reply · 29 Aug 2005

Dalraj Kaur ji, >How are we closer than it appears? If you are for bibian di seva because you fervently believe that it is Guru Sahib's hukum, then are positions are close. If you are for bibian di seva because your mind (mann) tells you so, are positions are distant. With the former, there is a basis for discussion. The latter is a Jacobin position totally alien to Sikhi. >What question did you ask above that you would like an answer too? The question is in the post dated: Date: 08-25-05 11:39 But also see that post and the one immediately previous for background information.

Re: SGPC move on women as Panj Piaras draws flak

singh · 29 Aug 2005

[%sig%]

Re: SGPC move on women as Panj Piaras draws flak

reply · 29 Aug 2005

Kulbir Singh ji, A poster had asked for the opinions of Kulbir Singh ji on the divorce thread. I think your presence is wanting on this this thread as well. Although the truth of a proposition is not dependant upon the opinion of one man, it would be of great benefit if Singhs such as yourself enter the akhara. If the feminists are able to threaten, cajole, or otherwise convince you to help them with the first step in the implementation of their agendas, it will be seen as the fall of a great man. On the one hand, if you resist the Jacobin plot, you risk a dent in your popularity. On the other hand, this life is only for a short time. After that we will be presented in the Dargah of Akal Purkh (the Timeless Purkh). And what face will we show if we stood by and watched the demeaning of our Divine Father without a protest? You are already on the Jacobins' watch list for having casually lamented the withering of the "Mard Khalsa" (masculine Khalsa) in the nanga sadhu thread (http://tapoban.org/phorum/read.php?f=1&i=25563&t=25227) . Why try to please them now? Anyone who grovels before them will always be in thrall to them. The slightest slip, the slightest mention of a phrase or tuk from the pre-Jacobin era (such as "Punj Singhs") will set off the feminist smoke detectors and the transgressor will be forced to apologize to the Politburo, which will replace the Punj Piyare. (Will that be the new name for Punj Singhs/Punj Piyare, or will something more subtle be coined?). But what surbir Khalsa would accept being in thrall to such usurpers? Bande da banda.) In order to hide the extremist nature of their agenda, the Jacobins portray this move as an final goal, as a fulfillment of loose ends in GurSikhi. However, this is not the end, rather a beginning to completely change the nature of Sikhi from Guru di Sikhi to Mann di (mind's) Sikhi. An example is the budding movement to neuter Gurbani in translations as they are unable to change the mul paath (base words) at this time. (See related thread SGPC's next move http://tapoban.org/phorum/read.php?f=1&i=49567&t=49567) Similar to the Kala Afghana situation, the full extent of the threat is not revealed in the beginning stages; also, a good number of otherwise good but gullible Sikhs will be taken in by sophistic reasoning. The Jacobin's seem to have succeeded in making or portraying this a polarizing issue between men and women or pretending that they have all Sikh women on their side plus feminist (Zan-Mureed) men, making for some kind of huge majority. In hakeeekat (actuality), though, all obedient sons and daughters of Divine Preceptor Guru Nanak Dev ji continue to stand by the decisions of their father. Whilst Aap ji (His Highness), in all of His Highness' incarnations, in all appointments made for Guru or for members of the council of 5 GurSikh advisors never included any of our admittedly spiritually advanced mothers, sisters, or daughters. As Gurbani teaches, there is no ghat-vadh in the Satguru. He is pura (complete) and trai-kal darshi (able to see past, present, and future). He is aap parmesar (God Himself). The Jacobins are trying to argue that there are women who are also highly spiritually advanced; why can't they be installed in the Punj Piyare? Yes, there are many among our mothers, sisters, daughters who are sincere devotees and spiritually advanced. Yet, were there not spiritually advanced sisters during the time of our 10 Guru Sahiban? Satguru is such a miraculous sakshiat that in accordance with his will, the fields he sits upon become green. So too do the souls of his devotees green as explained in Basant ki Vaar. There were no women with greened souls suitable before and only now there are? In trying to explain why Guru Sahib had not appointed a female Guru or female members of the council of 5 Singhs of various Guru Sahiban (as explained in a post above), the Jacobins are forced to write slander of the True Guru. This too with the same hands with which Ilahi (Divine) Gurbani enjoins to write the praise of God and Guru. They really can't help it. If on the one hand they accept the omniscience and omnipotence of our Guru Sahiban, they are will be forced to admit that whatsoever the True Guru has wrought is correct and complete, which obviates any possibility for "reform". The only other avenue left is some muted version of the normal modus operandi for a feminist assualt on an institution, which is to deride the founders as myopic fools, sexists, bigots. So for this reason, now it is being said that society was not ready for such a move. Oh? And it was ready to have the "sacred thread" dispensed with? Caste-mixing in one kitchen? Higher-caste people serving lower caste? For these and other moves, Guru Sahib had to endure the ire and and also lethal attacks of various persons and Guru ji did not dol (waver). And yet the Jacobins dare to say that appointing women into the 5 Singhs is some sort of Gurmat asool (rule) of which Guru Sahib was perhaps either ignorant or even more blasphemously, Guru Sahib was aware of such a principle but was afraid of society, i.e., losing chele (followers). Do they believe Guru Sahib to be nothing more than a deredaar dukandaar? The Vaar of Gauri by Sodhi Sultan Guru RamDass ji explains what happens to nindaks (slanderers) of the Satguru. We should fear for our lives and souls before plunging into this headlong rush into the abyss. Even if a particular Jacobin does not engage in slander per se, he does so by his very actions. An analog to this is those unfortunate persons who insist upon enthroning the bookseller-created fragmented bir upon the GurGaddi (Preceptorial Couch) of Guru Nanak Dev ji. They may not actively or explicity slander Guru Arjun Dev ji and Guru Govind Singh ji; however, their actions betray the latent belief that our 5th and 10th Divine Masters did not have enough foresight to break up GurBani themselves. Once the principle is established that Guru Sahiban were nothing more than some good men who meant well, nothing remains sacred. The current batch of Jacobins will be replaced those more radical and even more impious. The former shall struggle to contain the jinn (demons) within the lamp, but the revolution will eat its own. Is it possible, is it just possible, that our Gurus know more than us? I do ask all reading to seriously consider the possibility. What has been written has not been written with malice, but with concern for the Khalsa Panth. To some, these prognostications may seem alarmist. However, keep in mind that only 50-60 years ago, no one would have believed that women (Sikh or otherwise) would walk around with bareheaded with dohrian gutan (double braids). May the Khalsa jodhe (knights) take heed while there is still time.