is Bhagat namdev an idol worshipper ? NO NEVER
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 22 Aug 2005
[gurbani]dUDu ktorY gfvY pwnI ] kpl gwie nwmY duih AwnI ]1] dUDu pIau goibMdy rwie ] dUDu pIau, myro mnu pqIAwie ] nwhI q Gr ko bwpu irswie ]1] rhwau ] suoien ktorI AMimRq BrI ] lY nwmY hir AwgY DrI ]2] eyku Bgqu myry ihrdy bsY ] nwmy dyiK nrwienu hsY ]3] dUDu pIAwie Bgqu Gir gieAw ] nwmy hir kw drsnu BieAw ]4]3] {pMnw 1163}[/gurbani]
This shabad has always been quoted by many derawallhs followers to prove that bahagt anmdev Ji is also a Idol worshipper just like Bhagat Dhanna Ji.
They do "superficial" aarths of this shabad as "proof"...
What do the readers think...???
Re: is Bhagat namdev an idol worshipper ? NO NEVER
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 22 Aug 2005
dear sitara ji,
It doesnt make any difference IF "MY MIND" is made up..but this is a forum for all to post and the readers to make up "THEIR MINDS".
1. I dont doubt that Bhagat namdev could have been a moortee poojak at some point of his early life ( as you asserted)..BUT the GURBANI of a Moortee poojak would NEVER get place in Guru Granth JI. (similarly there is ample proof that Both Bhai lehana ji and Bhai Amardass Ji were DEVI poojaks and pakkeh hindus BEFORE they became SIKHS...and GURU...but then whatever GURBANI they wrote as GURUS is in the GURU GRANTH JI and there is not a single panktee by Guru Angad Ji that "promotes" pooja of devi. So this same logic can apply to namdev Ji as well for the record we are only interested in the NAMDEV of GURU GRANTH JI SAHIB...and not the one being "poojaaed" in maharashtra. Sikhs BOW to the Namdev in GURU GRANTH JI ONLY)
2. It is a well accepted fact that any one who is a KRISHAN JI follower WILL NEVER be a FOLLOWER of Sri Raam Chander Ji. Similarly a follower of Ram Chader Ji will never ever follow sri Krishan Ji. The two sets of followers are self excluisonary. BUT several examples from Bhagat namdev Ji's Bani will show that He refers to HIS ISHT by Both Raam as well as KRISHAN names and words...example...BEETHAL in Bhagat ji's Bani is also called Mere Rammiyeah.... ( beethal is the word used by krishan followers for his moortee ) How can a Krishan Follower address his moortee Beethal as Mere ramiyaah ?? contradictory isnt it ? What do you think ?
( I live next door to the World famous Batu caves Hindu mandir where there is a huge statue of a diety called SUBRAMANIAM ( tamil name for Shiva)...all call this diety Subramaniam and sometimes Shiva....never Sri raam or Sri krishan....but the Diety in the Sri raam Mandir ( also in front of the local Selayang Gurdwara) is always addressed as sri raam Ji..never as SUBRAMANIAM/SHIVA Ji etc ) How could Bhaagt namdev ji interchange these ???
For the RECORD my view as per GURMATT is that the Words used by Bhagat Namdev Ji in his bani all MEAN WAHEGURU ONLY..although the vocabulary is Hindu in origin.
REF" Singh Ji,
This is the same shabad that you refer to. It is on Aang 1163
I look forward to a constructive discussion on these two points before we go further.
Re: is Bhagat namdev an idol worshipper ? NO NEVER
I have Anbhavi Avastha · 22 Aug 2005
Guru sahib teaches that whatever we do is a waste unless we have naam.
He doesn't just say this to hindus, but to ALL those who do not have naam.
Naam is the reason we are here. If we do not have have naam and do not do simran then WE ARE FOOLS.
Guru sahib has showed the light and it is up to us if we want to follow it or not.
If we do not, then we are indeed fools.
waheguru
Re: is Bhagat namdev an idol worshipper ? NO NEVER
Balbir Singh · 23 Aug 2005
Pray Truth for all and say Satsriakal!
Sitara JI!
All Moortee-Poojak (Idol Worshipers) do not wish to stick with a sculpture on the way to God. Nor any Shaastra (Scripture) restricts the Supreme in a carved piece of stone.
Still, many worshipers hang on one or the other symbols.
Paramatma is beyond as well as within all symbols. His complete experience is only possible by transcending these symbols.
Transcending does not mean, as many may think, discarding one and capturing another state.
Transcending is realizing Truth in, within and around. The growth at conscious level of mind is the awareness of the earlier state and the developed state of mind simultaneously.
Our Gurus suggested Moortee-Poojaks to transcend the values and realize GOD by NAAM Simran. HE is without any shape or form too. HE is Nirankaar also.
This is possible when a person comes to one name. ONE NAAM brings the person to THE intent.
Dhannaa Jat is the example of it.
Naamdev Ji, as I understood Gurbani, after receiving the state of ONE NAAM recognized all Devas converted into GOD.
Gurbani says "ha-o ta-o ayk rama-ee-aa laiha-o." SGGS Ang 874-14
Ego! You received ONE Rama-ee-aa.
"aan dayv badlaavan daiha-o."
That resulted in conversion of Devas.
The Naamdev, mentioned in Gurbani, is who transcended and recognized the true values of all symbols and rituals like those of the moortees, ritual of Gayatri or symbol of Shiva riding on a Balad.
The Naamdev who is worshiped by many, as you mentioned, may not be the same.
I feel Naamdev Ji has merged in God long back through true Simran.
Many people may still be hanging on symbols and imitating Naamdev Ji.
Balbir Singh
[%sig%]
Re: is Bhagat namdev an idol worshipper ? NO NEVER
manjh payara guru ko · 23 Aug 2005
sita.......ra you said namdev ji not that namdev ji whos bani in dhan dhan sri guru granth sahib ji.so ican proof this ajuday(ram janm bhoomi)is not belongs to ram.we never said that ramayn wrot by other balmeeki this is not a good debate
[%sig%]
Re: is Bhagat namdev an idol worshipper ? NO NEVER
Balbir Singh · 23 Aug 2005
Satsriakal to all and Sitara Ji!
Naaraayan has infinite Roops. Naaraayan has not become limited because someone has carved a sculpture.
Also, Nirvaana is not being stuck up with a sculpture. Nirvana is getting freed from all limitations.
The Nirguna Parmeshwar is realized by transcending His Sarguna values. This becomes easy with ONE Naam of Hari.
All sculptures or Hari's imaginations predetermined do not accompany anyone there.
Once Naaraayan's both, Nirguna and Sarguna, Swaroops are realized, His infinite Swaroop becomes visible.
Naamdev Ji received Nirvaana by ONE Hari's Naam.
Here is a wonderful Shabad of Naamdev Ji from Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji.
mithi-aa jihbaa avrayN kaam.
Pseudo tongue has strange activities.
nirbaan pad ik har ko naam.
Nirvaana state is one Hari's name.
asaNkh kot an poojaa karee.
Innumerable millions of different poojaas are performed.
ayk na poojas naamai haree.
One did not worship the name of Hari.
paranvai naamday-o ih karnaa.
Pranav does this to Naamdev
anant roop tayray naaraa-inaa. SGGS Ang 1163-14
Infinite Roops are yours, Naaraayan.
Pranav is Simran of God's name along with each breath. Pranav is not a sculpture.
--------------
Here is another reference of Naamdev Ji's Shabad from Gurbani.
naamday-ay simran kar jaanaaN. SGGS Ang 858
Naamdev came to know by doing Simran.
It would be interesting to know if there is a protocol available which documented a Shabad from Naamdev Ji in maraathee language that He reached Nirvaana by collecting sculptures alone.
--------------
All sculptures are in the outer world. Hari dwells within. Hari is found within.
Naamdev Ji is singing.
paachhai bahur na aavan paava-o.
Afterwards there is on repetition to come.
amrit banee ghat tay uchara-o aatam ka-o samjhaava-o. SGGS Ang 693-5
Amrit Baanee is spoken from heart, explains to the soul.
In the same Shabad Naamdev Ji sings further.
it kar bhagati karahi jo jan tin bha-o sagal chukhaa-ee-ai.
The person who does Bhagatee like this, his all Bha-o is overcome.
kahat naamday-o baahar ki-aa bharmahu ih sanjam har paa-ee-ai. SGGS Ang 693-9
Naamdev says why wander outside, with this Sanjam Hari is received.
The crowd always follows what they receive from senses. The crowd may never follow (understand) the growth of conscious mind of the Guru, provided they receive Simran.
History shows that followers never became enlightened.
This is why our Gurus suggested Sikhs to be with Shabad or Naam and not with any outer symbols like a sculpture.
I pray that all become enlightened and say Satsriakal.
Love.
Balbir Singh
[%sig%]
Re: is Bhagat namdev an idol worshipper ? NO NEVER
Balbir Singh · 24 Aug 2005
Pray Truth for all and say Satsriakal!
Sitara Ji! You know Naamdev Ji as Idol worshiper. I recognize Naamdev Ji transcending Idols.
You value and stick to Hindu philosophy. Gurbani says Truth is neither Hindu nor a philosophy.
In my view, this post from you is full of contradictions.
You wrote "We believe that God is all pervading and therefore he/she is also in the idol as well - the emphasis being that God in the murti is in his/her most accessible form."
The first thing is that all pervading God is not he or she. There is no gender.
All pervading God is in the Idol as well. Great! One has recognized this truth.
Has this person found God the same and equal everywhere or he still is seeing God in a murti most accessible? Is this person yet aware of differentiations?
You tried to explain further ". . . moisture/water is everywhere but its most accessible form can be found in the well/river/pond etc. This is how we view murti pooja in the context of an all-pervading God."
Enlightened ones have found God as Sarguna and Nirguna together as complete.
Others are always busy differentiating HIS Sarguna qualities.
God is water and the rest of the whole cosmos too.
Ponder over it. Why God is not reached by examples like one you have given?
Then you wrote "This is how we view murti pooja in the context of an all-pervading God."
I do not know about millions of others. But I wish you all-pervading God by viewing murti pooja, with a request.
Come to Hari Naam when you feel it is getting too late.
--------------
Have you ever read Kabir Ji's dohay where he clearly mentions that God is not found by doing pooja of a stone (patthar)?
Can you please give references showing Kabir Ji as murti worshiper?
--------------
I wish to brief my post here.
A person born in this world knows Sarguna God only in parts. God's ONENESS is recognized in HIS completeness. The easiest way is NAAM Simran.
This wisdom is reserved for all Jeevs.
Balbir Singh
[%sig%]
Re: is Bhagat namdev an idol worshipper ? NO NEVER
Balbir Singh · 26 Aug 2005
Pray Truth for all and say Satsriakal!
Somebody asked "How many are two plus two?"
A hungry person in the gathering spoke loudly "Chaar rotiaaN (four breads)."
Dear Sitara Ji! The thread started here by Gyani Ji is "Is Bhagat Namdev an Idol Worshiper? NO Never."
You spoke loudly "Namdev, the murty poojak of Maharashtra."
Then you started clarifying your answer when others gazed at you surprisingly with words like "He use to worship a murti form of Krishna known as Vitthal Dev . . .Krishna and his wife Rukhmani . . .the NamDev whose baani is in the Siri Guru Granth Sahib was a different NamDev i.e. a chela of SatGur Nanak Dev Ji . . .NaamDayv's (Maharashtra wale) baani in the SGGS is not in Maharathi . . .Namdev of the Vitthal-Dev mandir in Pardhanpur, his Abhangs and sampradaya" etc.
It looks like that you wish to advertise your agenda.
--------------
The Murt (form) roop of God is the Universe. All are His Murtis.
The Amurt Swaroop of God is Nirankar.
All Jeevs in word are murti Poojak till they come to know Nirankar, the formless.
The Pooja (worship) of Nirankar is only possible when HE gives Darshan as Nirankar.
Only God remains after receiving HIS Darshan as Nirankar, not any stand alone murti or its pooja.
The bridge between God's Murt roop and Nirankar swaroop is GURSHABAD or NAM.
Those, who have not received NAM, may find Namdev Ji also today as Murti Poojak.
Balbir Singh
[%sig%]
Re: is Bhagat namdev an idol worshipper ? NO NEVER
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 26 Aug 2005
The Shabad mentions a Bowl made of GOLD. IS Bhagat namdev a Cheemba..rich enough to have a GOLD BOWL for a "stone idol"..and the Gharra is just claypot. Any comments?
second the Moortee/idols are ususally in the Mandir...but Bhagat namdev seems to have them in his house ?? IF he has the idols in His house..why the necessity to go to the Mandir from which he was chased out as a low caste ?
Can a Low caste..Keep Idols in his house ?? Can a Low caste read shatras/puraans vedas....wasnt this punishable under Mannu simrtee Laws ??
Re: is Bhagat namdev an idol worshipper ? NO NEVER
Kulbir Singh · 03 Sep 2005
-------------
Regarding point #2 raised by Jarnail Singh - I strongly beg to differ. Right now I am reading a book about Sripad MadhavaAcahrya (who was a Krishna Bhakta). His poetic works mention both Siri RaamChander, Krishna, Pashuraam, NarSingh Avtaar etc etc in the same mantras. Even staunch Krishna bhaktas like Chaytanya Mahaprabhu chants Rama and Krishna in the same mantra (e.g. Hare Krishna, Hare Rama) .
----------
Arshee Gyani jee is absolutely correct in saying that the worshippers of Raam Chander never worship Krishna and vice-versa. Today the things have changed and Hindus bow to just about anyone but in the olden days i.e. during the days of Bhagat Naamdev jee, Hindus worshipped only one deity. There was a severe rivalry between the Raam Bhagats and Krishna Bhagats. Raam Bhagtee was made popular by Swami Ramanand jee where as before his advent only Krishna Bhagti was popular and it produced great Krishna bhagats like Chataniya Mahaprabhu and before him Raghwa jee and Ramanuj etc.
The Mantra of Chataniya Mahaprabhus Samprada is “Hare Krishna Hare Krishna Krishna Krishna Hare Hare. Hare Rama Hare Rama Rama Rama Hare Hare”. Sitara jee, you mentioned that this mantra refers to Soorya Vanshee, Dashrath-puttar Raam Chander but you are mistaken in this. Rama here refers to Balraam, the elder brother of Siri Krishna, whom they believe was part of Krishna’s overall being. Some believe Balrama was the incarnation of Shesh Naag. Whatever the case, you can refer to the literature of Chataniya Mahaprabhu to confirm that the word Rama there is not in reference to Raam Chander of Auyodhya.
The stature of Krishna is and was much greater than Rama. Krishna is 16 Kala Sampooran whereas Rama is 14 Kala Sampooran but by the same token, Rama was a superior Maryada Purshottom than Krishna. His ethics were higher than Krishna but he too made mistakes like killing Bali the elder brother of Sugreev deceitfully was not right. Krishna did many such deceits e.g. while the killing of Jaidrath, killing of Duryodhan, Karan, Dronacharya, Bheesham etc, ethics were compromised.
Kulbir Singh
Re: is Bhagat namdev an idol worshipper ? NO NEVER
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 03 Sep 2005
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji KI fateh.
1. No one answered my doubts about how Bhagat namdev ji, a supposedly POOR Cheemba is having a SOLID GOLD BOWL..and is supposedly worshipping a "Beethal moortee" in HIS HOUSE and NOT in a Beethal mandir as every other Beethal Poojaree does ?? Perhaps because there is no logical answer to this riddle...
2. Now to the BEETHAL. IS this Beethal of Bhagat namdev Ji the SAME Beethal Moortee found in the Beethal mandirs of Maharashtra ?
My answer is NO. Bhagat namdev Ji's BEETHAL is Not the same as the Beethal Idol found in beethal mandirs...Bhagat ji's BEETHAL is actually AKAL PURAKH.
Bhagat ji mentions the word BEETHAL..a total of NINE times in hsi Gurbani..GURU ARJUN JI Sahib uses the Saame BEETHAL WORD a total of SIX times. By the same "logic" then we can conclude that GURU ARJUN JI also must have been a Beethal Moortee Poojak ?? After all we are accusing Bhagat ji of being a Beethal Moortee poojak just becasue he emntions the word BEETHAL..then what will we say about GURU ARJUN ji's use of the same word ?? WHAT IS THIS ??
IF bhagat ji prayed to a beethal in a beethal mandir in Maharashtra........WHICH BEETHAL MANDIR did Guru Arjun ji go to ??
3. Before we go further another dilemma...assails us. Bhagat Ji calls His "supposedly Krishan Beethal MERE RAMIYAAH..and also BEETHLA..and also GOVIND, MADHO, KESAV, RAAM, HAREE and ALLAH !!! Are we sure bhagat Ji's beethal is indeed the "Krishan beethal" found in the Mandirs of Maharashtra..Could that Beethal be called ALLAH ?? IS this WHY bahagt ji was KICKED out from the mandir ?? for calling krishan ALLAH ??
The ANSWER to thsi riddle is that the BEETHAL of Bhagat namdev Ji..also called by the many names mentioned above is the SARB VIAPAK Raam...the AKAL PURAKH thta is found in each of His CREATIONS... Namdev Ji declares..MY BEETHAL is NOT FOUND IN ANY MANDIR OR ANY MASJID !!! There we have got our clear cut answer in bhagat ji's OWN WORDS.
4. If we even for a moment beleive that bahagt ji is indeed a Krishan beethal Worshipper...then he must of necessity perform this worshipping in a MANDIR..THEN WHY should he be kicked out of that mandir out of the BLUE ?? OR is that becasue He called His Krishan beethal Mere ramiyah..mere Hari, mere Gobind, Mere Kesav.Mere ALLAH ?? NO Body in his right mind would go to a Krishan mandir and address the Krishan Moortee there as RAAM JI.....or call Him ALLAH !!!
Thus we arrive at the only conclusion.. A> Bhagat namdev Ji NEVER went to any Mandir..and thus B. He is NOT a Beethal Worhsipper of a moortee.
5. The BEETHAL described by bahgat ji on AAng 1318 Raag kannrra is a Word for Word DESCRIPTION of AKAL PURAKH. This "Beethal" resides in each of Akal purakhs creations and this beethal is NOT bound by MAYA ....ever...
Its patently obvious that Bhagat namdev Ji is using the Old word "beethal (krishan moortee)" in his own UNIQUE NEW WAY "BEETHAL = AKAL PURAKH" a Prabhu that is free of Maya and is everywhere....certainly not an idol sitting on a brick in a mandir.
6. The Final NAIL in the Idol worshipper Theory.... Bhagat namdev Ji in several Shabads declares that He found the TRUE SATGURU....who taught him how to Do Naam simran in the SAADH SANGAT...and this is the WAY to Jeewan MUKTEE.
This is CONFIRMED by other Shabads written by Bhagt Kabir Ji, Bhagta Ravidass ji, Guru Amardass Ji, Guur ramdass Ji and Finally by GURU ARJUN JI . These Shaabds all tell us that Namdev Ji did SAADH SANGAT of true satguru and Did NAAM SIMRAN as a way to AKAL PURAKH.
7. And the most astonishing thing about ALL the Shabads by Bhagat kabir Ji, bhagat ravidass Ji, Guru Sahibaans mentioned in para 6 above..is that NONE even mention that bahagta namdev Ji ever performed any Moortee Pooja and that He failed to achieve anything thru that action... each Shabad ONLY MENTIONS again and again..Saadh Sangat/Satguru/Naam Simran...as THE WAY Bhagat namdev Ji travelled....to achieve the ULTIMATE.
8. BUT Namdev Ji does use a lot of "references to KRISHAN JI....in his bani. Next we will discuss WHY ?? It is a perfectly innocent reference and NOT due to Him being a Krishan Pujaree.
Thank You...Jarnail Singh.
Re: is Bhagat namdev an idol worshipper ? NO NEVER
charanjeev singh · 03 Sep 2005
waheguruujikakhalsa waheguruujikifateh
The game of Waheguruu is only known to Waheguruu. As Waheguruu plays games with His Bhagats, that colour can only be known by those whom Waheguruu has chosen to enlighten.
Bhagat NaamDev Jee most definately went to a mandir to pray. And was subsquently also kicked out of here. The lesson that Waheguruu wants to teach us here in my humble opinion is; I do not live in a temple; I myself turn to the Bhagats.
The temple did turn around to where Bhagat Naam Dev Jee was sitting and doing Simran of Akaal Purakh Waheguruu. This astaan as been deemed by scientists that it is a fact that the building structure has indeed been rotated (however, we do not need their assurance)
Bhagat Naam Dev Jee entails the details of this encounter and experience with his Beethal, Waheguruu, in Gurbaani.
hasath khaelath thaerae dhaehurae aaeiaa ||
bhagath karath naamaa pakar out(h)aaeiaa ||1||
heenarree jaath maeree jaadhim raaeiaa ||
shheepae kae janam kaahae ko aaeiaa ||1|| rehaao ||
lai kamalee chaliou palattaae ||
dhaehurai paashhai bait(h)aa jaae ||2||
jio jio naamaa har gun oucharai ||
bhagath janaa(n) ko dhaehuraa firai ||3||6||
Laughing and playing, I came to Your Temple, O Lord.
While Naam Dayv was worshipping, he was grabbed and driven out. ||1||
I am of a low social class, O Lord;
why was I born into a family of fabric dyers? ||1||Pause||
I picked up my blanket and went back,
to sit behind the temple. ||2||
As Naam Dayv uttered the Glorious Praises of the Lord,
the temple turned around to face the Lord's humble devotee. ||3||6||
Ang 1164
bhul chuk mauf
waheguruujikakhalsa waheguruujikifateh
also, how come you refer to Guru Arjan Dev Jee only as Guru Arjan Jee? Do you feel that Dev jee is an hindu addition? (i am not being rude, but asking lovingly). The Guru refers to Guru Sahib as thus;
jab lo nehee bhaag lilaar oudhai thab lo bhramathae firathae bahu dhhaayo ||
kal ghor samudhr mai booddath thhae kabehoo mitt hai nehee rae pashhuthaayo ||
thath bichaar yehai mathhuraa jag thaaran ko avathaar banaayo ||
japyo jinh arajun dhaev guroo fir sa(n)katt jon garabh n aayo ||6||
As long as the destiny written upon my forehead was not activated, I wandered around lost, running in all directions.
I was drowning in the horrible world-ocean of this Dark Age of Kali Yuga, and my remorse would never have ended.
O Mat'huraa, consider this essential truth: to save the world, the Lord incarnated Himself.
Whoever meditates on Guru Arjun Dayv, shall not have to pass through the painful womb of reincarnation ever again. ||6||
Ang 1409
Bhai Gurdaas Jee has referred to Guru Arjan Dev Jee as Guru Arjan. I would assume both names are in reverence.
bhul chuk mauf
[%sig%]
Re: is Bhagat namdev an idol worshipper ? NO NEVER
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 03 Sep 2005
veer charanjeev singh ji,
waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh.
as i have explained in my message above..Bhagat namdev Ji was NOT a REGULAR Mandir Worshipper....otherwise why "accept" him all this while and "kick" him out one day. This is a local Mandir and Bhagat ji is also a local..so everyone including the pandits know his low caste from day one.
The better explanation is that...in HIS MAUJ... performing Bhagtee of His BEETHAL WAHEGURU...Bhagat ji entered this mandir...and was PROMPTLY THROWN OUT. This is a One Off Visit....and certainly NOT for Doing POOJA of the Beethal moortee installed there.
Thats all...I am not disputing GURBANI in any way. This Incident did happen and it is TRUE.
On the name of Guru Arjun Ji Sahib..you have answered it already. I hold BOTH in reverence and use the one I always write.
2. Dear Khush Ji,
Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh.
Thank You for the kind words.
I dont "sant" bash for the fun of it. In my understanding Sikhe/Gurmatt has TWO PILLARS....Pillar of GYAN (knowledge) and Pillar of SHARDHA (Wishwaash). A Good SIKH MUST have BOTH PILLARS. Some like Bhai Kala Afghana just want the Pillar of GYAN..and want to demolish the Pillar of Shardha alltogether....and others like the Sant-Samajists want to DEMOLISH the Pillar of Gyan and just retain the Shardha only..BLIND FAITH..100% follow what baba ji said...lakir in STONE...without question..even if Proven Anti-Gurmatt..never mind BABA JI BRAHMGIANI JI said it so its OK. This is the ONLY contention I have with these people..I want the KASWATTII of GURBANI (GYAN) applied to all Shardha. Hope this calrifies.
Love to all
jarnail Singh.
Re: is Bhagat namdev an idol worshipper ? NO NEVER
charanjeev singh · 04 Sep 2005
waheguruujikakhalsa waheguruujikifateh
"The better explanation is that...in HIS MAUJ... performing Bhagtee of His BEETHAL WAHEGURU...Bhagat ji entered this mandir...and was PROMPTLY THROWN OUT. This is a One Off Visit....and certainly NOT for Doing POOJA of the Beethal moortee installed there."
This makes perfect sense to me. I agree with this view; in fact it gives me a new perpective and i thank you for sharing.
Similary, I think it was Bhagat Kabeer Jee who was going to go for hajj, and Waheguruu Jee intervened and stopped him. Please correct me if i am wrong. With Bhagat Naamdev Jee, it seems to be the similar relationship. Bhagat NaamDev Jee was going to the mandir (out of mauj this day), and Waheguruu Jee said 'no, no', and instead turned to Bhagat Sahib. The lesson i see is that Waheguruu is within, and there is no need for rituals. In fact, Waheguruu comes to the Bhagat, the Bhagat does not need to go anywhere. Only if we could all have such direct relationships with Waheguruu Jee.
bhul chuk mauf
waheguruujikakhalsa waheguruujikifateh
Re: is Bhagat namdev an idol worshipper ? NO NEVER
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 04 Sep 2005
Singh Ji,
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji KI fateh.
This point is stressed in every Shabad of Bhagat Namdev Ji.
Here is an example..
[gurbani]Awsw ] AwnIly kuMB, BrweIly aUdk, Twkur kau iesnwnu krau ] bieAwlIs lK jI jl mih hoqy, bITlu BYlw kwie krau ]1] jqR jwau, qq bITlu BYlw ] mhw Anµd kry sd kylw ]1] rhwau ] AwnIly PUl, proeIly mwlw, Twkur kI hau pUj krau ] pihly bwsu leI hY Bvrh, bITlu BYlw kwie krau ]2] AwnIly dUDu rIDweIly KIrM, Twkur kau nYvydu krau ] pihly dUDu ibtwirE bCrY, bITlu BYlw kwie krau ]3] eIBY bITlu, aUBY bITlu, bITl ibnu sMswru nhI ] Qwn Qnµqir nwmw pRxvY, pUir rihE qUM srb mhI ]4]2] {pMnw 485}[/gurbani]
IS this Beethal sitting in some Beethal mandir ? NO This Beethal of namdev is in the entire creation....
Bhagat ji is smashing to bits all the empty rituals....bathing the beethal in holy water ( full of millions of dead germs and other impurities..), offering the beethal milk..that has been made impure by the Calf, offering the beethal flowers ...that have been made impure by the moth and butterfly and the bee sitting on it long before that...
At the end Bhagat ji declares MY BEETHAL is EVERYWHERE....and HE doesnt "need" all this ritual bathing, offerings of flowers, and milk etc.
On AAng 874 Raag gond Bhagat ji declares..
[gurbani]iblwvlu goNf ] Awju nwmy bITlu dyiKAw, mUrK ko smJwaU ry ] rhwau ] pWfy qumrI gwieqRI, loDy kw Kyqu KwqI QI ] lY kir Tygw tgrI qorI, lWgq lWgq jwqI QI ]1] pWfy qumrw mhwdyau, Dauly bld ciVAw Awvqu dyiKAw Qw ] modI ky Gr Kwxw pwkw, vw kw lVkw mwirAw Qw ]2] pWfy qumrw rwmcMdu, so BI Awvqu dyiKAw Qw ] rwvn syqI srbr hoeI, Gr kI joie gvweI QI ]3] ihMdU AMn@w qurkU kwxw ] duhW qy igAwnI isAwxw ] ihMdU pUjY dyhurw, muslmwxu msIiq ] nwmy soeI syivAw, jh dyhurw n msIiq ]4]3]7] {pMnw 874-875}[/gurbani]
TODAY Nama has "seen" my BEETHAL....and He is NOT in any Masjid or in Any Mandir...
Bhagat Namdev Ji is the Second Hardest Hitting Bhagat after Bhagat Kabir Jee. Just read his Gurbani and you will realise how really hard he hits the empty rituals and dharmik Pakhands...thats why the Bippar Brahmin combine worked extra hard to spread false misinformation and sakhis about him
I feel so much sadness when we Sikhs DISREGARD the Bhagat's OWN writings, the Wittness provided by our OWN GURU SAHIBAANS..and fall for the half baked sakhis and false stories spread by the BIPPAR/BRAHMIN and our very own uneducated preachers. Guru ramdass ji Himself writes that Bhagat Namdev Ji got WAHEGURU through Naam Simran....but we DISREGARD that Testimony and keep on beleiving our preachers who tell us...one day namdev's father went off to town, namdev got soem milk and sat down in front of the thakur beethal moortee and prayed so hard, waheguru came out of the beethal moortee and drank the milk...his father was so surprised that his son got waheguru to drink the milk in one day..blah blah blah... when Bhagat namdev Ji in his own Hand says something ENTIRELY OPPOSITE to this false story. ( maybe false stories and sakhis are so "interesting" than the STARK TRUTH !! )
Jarnail Singh
Re: is Bhagat namdev an idol worshipper ? NO NEVER
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 04 Sep 2005
...
Veer Charanjeev Singh Ji writes:..The lesson i see is that Waheguru is within, and there is no need for rituals. In fact, Waheguruu comes to the Bhagat, the Bhagat does not need to go anywhere. Only if we could all have such direct relationships with Waheguru Jee.
>>
Yes I agree..actually as per my understanding this Waheguru within us is the "SADH/SANT/GURU/SATGURU"..and to Meet this Waheguru deep within us is what Sheikh farid is telling us about when he says..Gareeban meh dekh...and when Gurbani says..Sadh/Sant BHETNA...it means to meet the SADH/SANT inside YOU..Gurbani tells us again and again that HE is within YOUR SELF..yet we RUSH HEADLONG outsied searching for HIM ?? He is in the HOUSE (GHAR) which means our BODY.. At so many places Guru Amardass Ji tells us that HE _WAHEGURU has Sajjia his HARMANDIR ( our body) for His OWN RESIDENCE..He is WITHIN..and its so easy for us to have a Personal Relationship with HIM because we are living in the SAME HOUSE !!
Thank you for your kind thoughts..and sharing wonderful views..
jarnail Singh.
Note to Learner:
Shardha is BELIEF./ FAITH..as in SIKHS beleive Guru nanak ji to be Nirankaar's Roop on Earth.....but "beleiving " this without any GYAN is BLIND FAITH...the "GYAN" is in Guru nanak Ji's GURBANI..which if properly read, understood and applied in our daily life..JOINS US WITH NIRANKAAR..and we also become NIrankaar roop. This is why I say..SIKHI needs BOTH PPILLARS..Gyan and Shardha to be BALANCED. remove or weaken either one and the sikhe building is in danger of collapse.