Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

divorce or not according to Gurmat

divorce or not according to Gurmat

bad · 22 Aug 2005

wjkk wjkf to all My sister is married to a singh 7 years ago. He always beaten her and abusing her. He is also a flirting guy type person . If it is ok to get divorce and remarriage according to Gurmat.Now a days she become very sick mentaly and physically too. please give advise about divorce.

Re: divorce or not according to Gurmat

truth · 22 Aug 2005

benji/veer ji in my opinion there is no such thing as divorce in sikhi. what your sister is going through is the deeds of her past life being presented to her now as karma......... the best thing is to get intense pressure on the singh to make him see sense and be good. it requires a lot of love and time to make things better. to many people today see divorce as an easy way out. we have to remember the vows were taken in front of guru sahib, hence they are unbreakable. do ardas and paat to guru ji and everything will get better. this is all a test of faith. please note these are my own personal opinions, i'm sorry if i have said anything upsetting.

Re: divorce or not according to Gurmat

ManjitSingh · 22 Aug 2005

Divorce in Sikhi can be justified only as if all means of keeping the marriage intact in Sikhi way have exhausted and your spouse has gone away from Sikhi.

Re: divorce or not according to Gurmat

singh · 22 Aug 2005

if you have tried talking to the person alone and with family to try and work things out I think the last resort would be to speak to independant singhs/singhnian or go pesh and ask what to do. sorry to hear this news as its not nice to hear stories like this. I hope things get resolved soon.

Re: divorce or not according to Gurmat

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 22 Aug 2005

waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh. I get to face such heart rending and unfortunate "chapters in Singh-kaur lives" daily...beleive it or not sometimes i am on the phone LONG DISTANCE to as far away as UK/Canada/Los angeles...advising...cajoling...trying to mend broken hearts. It is doubly difficult if BOTH are Amrtidharee and Both have "faith" in guru Ji..but have faltered....sometimes in spite of my best efforts...they fall apart ( Amrtidharees and suicides on this Forum are some of MY FAILURES..although thanks to GURU JI no one has actually "died" yet..I hope NOT...but just the fact that soem one is contemplating such an extreme step gives me nighmares ) Divorce is NOT an OPTION in Sikhe/Gurmatt....but in extreme cases temporary "separation" may help. Sometimes the stress generated needs soem SPACE...and given this space..tensions may come down. How do i know anything..I have never faced such a situation myself...its easy to talk..as they say fire in neighbour's house is fireworks..fire in ones own house is destruction..all i can advise is have FAITH IN GURU JI...tuttian gandhhan wakah satguru ji Kirpa Karan... Try anything and Everything.... Raab Raakha. Extremely sad at many ocassions....especially when dearest friends and colleagues are simialrly affected.

Re: divorce or not according to Gurmat

. · 22 Aug 2005

Divorce is NOT an OPTION in Sikhe/Gurmatt....but in extreme cases temporary "separation" may help. Sometimes the stress generated needs soem SPACE...and given this space..tensions may come down. & Author: truth Date: 08-22-05 07:06 benji/veer ji in my opinion there is no such thing as divorce in sikhi. what your sister is going through is the deeds of her past life being presented to her now as karma......... the best thing is to get intense pressure on the singh to make him see sense and be good. it requires a lot of love and time to make things better. to many people today see divorce as an easy way out. we have to remember the vows were taken in front of guru sahib, hence they are unbreakable. do ardas and paat to guru ji and everything will get better. this is all a test of faith. please note these are my own personal opinions, i'm sorry if i have said anything upsetting. ___________________________________________ Is divorced justified if the man drinks messed up his kids, put thme in a sangat of drunkies and ultimately make them into manmukhs? So ur saying its karms that are the reasons why Singhs sit in jails, and we shoudl let them sit in jail and ignore the protesting - cause it's their karm. Let them lie in jails cause they fought for our kaum - it's their karms. KARMI APO ANPI! If shes sacrifising her Sikhi, and riskign her childrens Sikhi, then by all means i think divorce is okay. Sikhi is a modern religion and hence why GUru Amardas ji banned sati and said that re-marriage is OKAY. That doesn't mean - i don't liek this guy, i'm leaving, but if, in extreme cases wheer the man begisn to drunk, or the womens family pressurises the man to drink (which has happened) divorce is justified - or do you think the man should drink and leave Sikhi but not divorce?

Re: divorce or not according to Gurmat

psingh · 22 Aug 2005

what if one partner says to the other that they don't love them anymore. not much you can do when one does not love the other? is this grounds for a divorce? also can somebody explain what marriage really means in sikhi what are the roles of either partner? i hear and see a lot of western influence on sikh marriages and people making decisions based on western ideals and not on Guru Sahibs teachings.

Re: divorce or not according to Gurmat

bad · 22 Aug 2005

Wjkk wajkf my sister always doing path . with the grace of guru ji she doing 3-4 paths of Sri Sukhmani Sahib and other bania ...............but nowadays she depressed alot. We do all thing as people mentioned but all in vein. OH Guru ji please help my sister..................... I am confused for getting divorce or not

Re: divorce or not according to Gurmat

Gerk · 22 Aug 2005

I am shocked and appalled by the opinion expressed in this thread. Here is a woman that has been beaten and abused for 7 year and some of you have the gall to tell her to "stick it out." Show me where our Gurus said that women have to take that kind of abuse and just bear it? As for the argument that is her karma, let me ask you this, do you take medicine when you are sick? If so you better not because of past bad karma. You people wonder why our sisters are marrying off to people of other religions, it's because of people like you and your disgusting attitudes. Some of you sicken me. My god, "bad," tell your sister to get a divorce now and get out of that relationship. Non one should have to suffer though that. [%sig%]

Re: divorce or not according to Gurmat

Harjas Kaur · 23 Aug 2005

If the man is drinking then he has gone away from Sikhi even if he keeps kes and dastaar as an outward show. He is bringing a poison into his body that causes insanity and violent outbursts. A wife has to tolerate this in her home? Believe me, if my karma brings a violent attacker, Guruji's kirpa was to give me a kirpan and teach me I had the right to be free, the right to fight back, and the right to defend against oppression and bad deeds. Im some things I would be better off to fight to the death then live in unending torment. Without freedom from fear in my own home, I live in hell. What does Sikhi have to offer a world suffering from injustice? Toleration of injustice? Excuses for injustice? Is this what Sikhi teaches? A defenseless woman has to be beaten in her own home by a vicious man until she is maimed or crippled in mind and body and she has no chance for liberation from him? People will treat you in a way that you allow. Women need to get stronger and stop allowing mistreatment of themselves and their children. If a man would not raise his hand to another man for fear of getting the beat back, then women need to learn to fight back. This way he would know better then to beat her like a punching bag. If it cost him something, he would not be so likely to repeat it. If a vicious and unjust man came at me with violence, should I allow him to hurt me? Cripple me? Bruise my eyes? Knock out my teeth and tear my hair? Degrade and humiliate me in front of my own children? WOULD ANY ONE OF YOU CALLING YOURSELVES KHALSA ALLOW IT? Am I less of a human being now to deserve all this mistreatment because I'm this man's "wife?" Would you allow him to kill me too? --------------------------------------------- "American women have more to fear from the men they know and once loved than from any stranger." "A third of all women's injuries coming into our emergency rooms are no accident. Most are the result of deliberate, premeditated acts of violence. And frequently they occur over and over until the woman is killed." "Thirty-four percent of the women homicide victims over age 15 are killed by their husbands, ex-husbands or boyfriends." http://www.silentwitness.net/sub/violences.htm [%sig%]

Re: divorce or not according to Gurmat

Singh · 23 Aug 2005

I don't think divorce is antir Gurmat in such a drastic situation. I pray that things get better, if not I personaly would say divorce the khutta

Re: divorce or not according to Gurmat

S!ngh · 23 Aug 2005

There's absolutely no use in making general statements and blanket rules. Every situation is unique. *Sometimes* divorce is inevitable and is the proper and good thing to do, as a last resort, to end a deeply troubled and broken marriage. Alas, we do not know enough details to say whether it is proper and wise in this case, thus, we can only recommend your wife talk it over with elder Gursikhs in your area to figure out what is best. Sometimes spending life alone is better than being married; sometimes even re-marriage can potentially lead to a happier life. Those are options - but only options of last resort.

Re: divorce or not according to Gurmat

Sad Singh · 23 Aug 2005

A person who beats his wife cannot be a Sikh and should be stripped of the the right to call himself a Sikh. How can you Gursikhs stick up for him and tell the woman to stay with him because it's all because of her karams? Maybe would would feel differently if it was your own sister or daughter.

Re: divorce or not according to Gurmat

. · 23 Aug 2005

NO SUCH THING AS DIVORCE MARRIAGE IS PERMANENT UNLESS ONE DIES THEY CAN LIVE SEPARATLY, BUT CANNOT REMARRY - THIS IS ADULTERY

Re: divorce or not according to Gurmat

Harjas Kaur · 23 Aug 2005

If you want to force this woman to 1. live with a man that beats her and causes her to sicken and suffer, or, 2. live alone with no one to help, love, care for or support her while you KNOW he will get remarried and start this cycle again and probably be accepted in Gurudwara (story sound familiar?) Then I say a sadh sangat should KILL this evil man so she is free from the burden of him, his violence and all his hatred. Then she can remarry as a WIDOW! Otherwise you are all perpetrators of injustice to tolerate his misdeeds in your own community and harshly judge who can and cannot do anything about it to be free. So, if Sikhi is severe and extreme in its judgements, then righteousness should also be severe and extreme in its judgements. Otherwise it is only unjust corruption.

Re: divorce or not according to Gurmat

balpreet kaur · 23 Aug 2005

my opinon is that she should divorce him no one should go though anything like that. women have equal rites to men, they shouldn't be pushed around by any man. life is too short u should be able to live it without no sufering. and also there is such thing as divorce! bad wrote: [%sig%]

Re: divorce or not according to Gurmat

anon · 23 Aug 2005

The most important thing for an abused spouse is get out of the marriage. Even if you are unable to remarry, first respect yourself, your safely, and sanity. I was briefly married to a man, he had kesh, but he was an adulterer. We are now seperated. Maybe someone can help pray for my failed marriage. I do not believe we will ever be back together. I believe I need, eventually find someone else, but I don't want to commit adultery. I understand the dilemma.

Re: divorce or not according to Gurmat

truth · 24 Aug 2005

to sangat ji whe i expressed my views they were as i say personal and i was trying to just follow what i believe in. i believe what happens is according to waheguru and his wishes and through power of prayer and benti to guru ji we can overcome. i am trying as we speak i falter but i can only try. the benji who is suffering in the marriage, i didn't mean to say she should stick at it no matter what, separation is good. if all else fails and still nothing positive has happened then she should then live alone. sangat ji in this discussion i have learned much and you have helped me understand. and i am in full support of other sangat members who have said the benji should leave the man. i am sorry if i came across as a narrow minded person i am not. and thank you to sangat and the existance of this forum in allowing me to learn and change. waheguru ji

Re: divorce or not according to Gurmat

jeona maur nu · 24 Aug 2005

khalsa is a fighter, a doer an active persom. the karm attitue reminds me of passive hindus looking for excuses and feeling predetermined byu their fate at the hands of babur. getting raped bashed around killed sitting helpless because my karm says i did something in my last life to deserve this so carry on please. the khalsa is opposite to this thinking. We have a haq to fight back against wrong doing. if your partner is bashing u up and refusing to change to hell with the world society and other sikhs you do what your khalsa warrior concious says. we do not live in an ideal world which means we can not at all times be ideal in non ideal governed situatiuons. ie darm yudh i9nstructions state we should not take weopons or fight in darbar sahib but in 1984 we had to. the sikh world is split on this issue, buyt our veers had to do it the word i see is practical versus idealism. sometimes we have to be practical 84 had to happen, we had to defend our home, because we would have been under attack although this was not according to dharm yudh rules. we had no choice, same way a marriage is sup[posed to be bliss man is ment to protect if he doesnt and instead bashes the woman he ment to protect he is not a khalsa and has broken the marriage from anand karaj heaven to hell. he is responmsible not you for defending your values and happiness. singhani jio stand up for yourself, try your best to resolve with him if he dont change do what your heart says. Life is not clear cut you are a warrior princess. To all these maha sher khalsey singh who will not back our princess mothers let me ask you one day if your own sisters or daughters get in such a situation will you say "hey daughter eh tere marey karm ah"? sochloh jwab den to peloh

Re: divorce or not according to Gurmat

Gandalf... · 24 Aug 2005

What about divorce if the husband has left his wife with children and refuses to come back?

Re: divorce or not according to Gurmat

Harjas Kaur · 24 Aug 2005

1. Waiting passively for karma is cowardly Hindu thinkin. I would rather be born as a real dog then live like a dog and degrade my human dignity. 2. Anyone bashin me would be dodgin' bullets at some point. I would rather die fighting. It's more honor if he kills me where I stand then I roll over and play dead. "Better an end with terror then a terror without end." 3. Sometimes a lady with little kids don't have money to pay the bills so living alone is not good enough. She needs a PARTNER. Either her family, sangat or remarriage, maybe she ain't a sant, but she can still be a good wife, mother and practice Sikhi. Everybody elses judgements about it are worthless if they don't help her be safe and happy in this life and bless her choices not to be beaten and miserable. This is NOT a way for anyone to live, not even our enemies. 4. "What about divorce if the husband has left his wife with children and refuses to come back?" What husband? If he isn't there, then there is no husband. What is he doing, being husband to someone else? Then the marriage is already broken. Don't u think the children need a father? Where is the sangat in this picture? Is there someone helping her with food, house payments, school clothes? Too many times people complain someone's not holy. But no one is helping. This just makes the problem worse. Let her try and get along in this life the best way she can. Before everybody complains about American values, lets look at the problems bad men are causin their wives and children to make remarriage necessary. If you can't fix that, then don't judge. When sangat gets tired helping her make those house payments every month, they might start to think remarriage is a good idea and help find her a good Singh. It's just not practical to have a whole group of women with little kids and no one to support them and sangat say thats their karam. Then they get on government programs, get social workers to counsel the kids against Sikhi, move them to ghetto housing, christian missionaries who try to help out, people tellin them cut the hair, etc, etc, etc. Is remarriage really THAT bad? [%sig%]

Re: divorce or not according to Gurmat

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 24 Aug 2005

waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh. Here we must also be concerned with the "Divorce" and "DIVORCE" ? Confused ?- you bet. well let me explain. Most marriages in the West ( in malaysia too) are REGISTERED with the LAW - Secular Authorities. This is just a Piece of Paper called a Marriage Certificate....and the LAWYERS trained in Secular Law can UNDO this piece of paper and change it to a DIVORCE CERTIFICATE..if a Judge of the Law agrees. But the other part of the marriage is the ANAND KARAJ - perormed in Sangat's presence in the Guru Ji's hazooree with Guru Ji's and Sangat's Blessings..ardass, hukmanamas etc.. This is NOT so easy to UNDO ( maybe impossible too !!) SO a cheating/beating/abusive/bum of a partner can be Got rid of for good by using the First Method under the country's secular laws by going to a court of Law..and ones life can return to a "normal stage ( if you can call it that)..but the other "divorce" ?? is a tough proposition ? I myself have no answer to this. JS

Re: divorce or not according to Gurmat

Jasmin · 24 Aug 2005

Dear Harjas- You make a compiling argument. You have my support and sympathy.

Re: divorce or not according to Gurmat

khalsa akal purakh ki fauj · 24 Aug 2005

waheguru ji kakhalsa waheguru ji ki fateh! well i see that half of u are saying that she shouldn't get out of this marrige. i see gyiani (JS) jis point and others as well. so i guess what our sister needs to do is stand up for her self. like one of the panjis said above...we have equal rights, we are no less thn anyone... she is an equal partner in this marrige. why is itthat she is taking this abse...well i can see why(jus read those sikhs post above who say she should stay with him) thats why she has taken the abuse for that many years. why are we saying that she should staywith him and not give him divorce... simple...we dont want our sikhs to get an idea that divoce is ok in sikhi...we dont want our brothers and sisters to have to think twise about getting married. we dnt want the insurtanty in this pure relationship.ther are jus too many things that we are afraid of when we say "ok go ahead give him a divorce." we are afraid of everyone saying..."oh u told her to get divorse but why not me?" and things could get worse. thats why i say...telll our sister to stand up for her self. and jus keep in mind that this is not like a court system that west uses where if court agrees on one case of divorse makes iit ok for everyone whofiles for divorse.....onegets divorce it becomes a rule"law" for everyone . its really late and im trying to write this down..as it is fresh in my mind. well i guess for that reason punjabi culture is better than sikhi(?) at least they tell their gals to come back to her mom and dads or bros house if the guy says something... well i love sikhi so i would say as JS GYIANI ji said that they were married in front of guru sahib j and sangat...and they should get in front of the sangat...and shouldpresent their sides...andlet the sangat decide..(SIMPLE) and what ever the decision the sangat makes ...go with that. sangat 5 piyarey guru sahib are the one that make decisions for us right...so should ask the sangat at Gurudwara sahib!' im sure the sangat will say that the man should be beaten up and kicked out of the comunity.(isn't that what they used to do back in the day?) gives a lesson to the others tooo . our mind needs to know taht there are consiquences to everything in this world. espcailly Sikhs. comeon jio....we are practical people and sangat has that much of a power... we know that if u want darshan of Waheguru...or wana experince Waheguru...sadh sangat is teh place...so there we go..if we want Waheguru to decide on this issue take it to teh sadh sangat!!! bhul chuk muaff karni jio i love sikhi so much and what i have learned is if a person in taklef(pain) help um....and give justic. i mean Guru sahib could've said that to bhai Ghanayiya ji that let those muggaals suffer...dont gve um water...its theirkaram...they choose to be againts us and fight for muagals. sorry for writn so much and if it doesn't make any sense then jus plz forgive me. waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh!

Re: divorce or not according to Gurmat

Harjas Kaur · 24 Aug 2005

"You have my support and sympathy." LOL, I'm not married. That's just my opinion about it. [%sig%]

Re: divorce or not according to Gurmat

Daughter of Guru Gobind Singh · 25 Aug 2005

author: Khalsa akla purakh ki fauj.. sorry for writn so much and if it doesn't make any sense then jus plz forgive me. waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh!<<<<<<<<<<<<<< It does make sense..a lot of sense really. I went throught the same hell for seven years.....and then I stood up for my rights....and the CHOOHA who called himslef a LION ran like the dog with his tail between his legs...and is still running in spite of his rich and famous relatives and lawyer mamas and all...and i a poor lonely single mother with no family or relatives..except GURU JI and a Gursikh who took me in..and he in turn got help from other like minded GURSIKHS...and here I am..independent, successful, Guru KI Pyaree and loving it..free of worry for the first time in my life..MY HEARTFELT THANKS to mY GURSIKH brothers and sisters who helped me...May Guru Ji Bless YOU all. Jasvir

Re: divorce or not according to Gurmat

kabadi · 25 Aug 2005

A guy who beats his wife is not a SIKH. hes a coward

Re: divorce or not according to Gurmat

power to all singhanis · 25 Aug 2005

dear beeroh ponder over this what guru ji would do with a kurri maar, now think what guru ji would do with a serial wife basher? so those saying stick with it cos your married in front of ghuru ji our guru ji would properly sort the guy out and take the side of the oppressed because he is the shelter of the weak meek and humble

Re: divorce or not according to Gurmat

Khalsa · 25 Aug 2005

i don't think it is bad to have divorce even if you had lavvans infront of the SGGS if the other person is not respecting guru's hukam there is no need for you to live in a hell you r not disobeying guru ji you tried to make it work. if it doesn't just leave. guru ji don't want their childres to suffer they want them to live happily within sikhi. it is easy to preach to others to stick to it but when it become personal then it is different kettle of fish. live u r life and don't suffer in silence. make up u r own mind u cannot please everybody. [%sig%]

Re: divorce or not according to Gurmat

trust nobody · 25 Aug 2005

when it suits us we go to guru-ji and quote guru-ji at every step. when it dosen't suit us we don't want to hear anything that guru-ji says. how selfish we are, we only do things to suit our own needs and the wishes of our maan.

Re: divorce or not according to Gurmat

Gandalf... · 25 Aug 2005

Khalsa...exactly my words.

Re: divorce or not according to Gurmat

don be so weak · 25 Aug 2005

dear trust nobody if your sister married some wanka who battered her, you gonna sit on your arse and say yeh sis its karm? bantha ya pachama? one singh i know listened to some people who told him this is karm crap. his sister died a horrible death and he had to live with thepain feeling guilty of not being ablew to help her. singh soorma is a bantha and a khalsa kicks any bullies bond so do not use religion as a way toi be passive towards evil deeds that deserve punishment.

Re: divorce or not according to Gurmat

trust nobody · 25 Aug 2005

don be so weak ji if u are goign to make a comment of any sort please dont use any profanities this is a gurmat site if you can't respect that then what can you respect? and my previous post was not directed at the abused penji, it was aimed at those veers and penjis who want to run from a marriage when they dont feel like living it anymore...........for no real apparent reason

Re: divorce or not according to Gurmat

Manjot Singh Khalsa · 25 Aug 2005

I agree she should leave. Its really easy for people who have never even dealt with such a situation to sit on their high horse and say its against gurmat, stick it out etc. Keep your opinions to yourself. I have seen this enough with so-called gursikhs. Other so-called gursikhs try to hide it or cover for the guy or convince the girl to stay. What kind of Sikhi is this? its shameful. On the other hand, I know of a case where the panj pyares peshed a Singh for what he did to his wife and I think it stopped from there. What those singhs did was gurmat. Telling the wife to stay and covering for the husband, that is cowardly. Harjas Kaur makes a lot of good points.

Re: divorce or not according to Gurmat

truth · 25 Aug 2005

Manjot Singh Khalsa you made the point which i think everybody was trying to make but failed. if the husband goes to the punj pyaare and gets pesh then with guru jis blessing this will all stop. then the divine law will work and heal everything.

Re: divorce or not according to Gurmat

Manjot Singh Khalsa · 26 Aug 2005

>>>if the husband goes to the punj pyaare and gets pesh then with guru jis blessing this will all stop. then the divine law will work and heal everything.<<< Agreed. If not, then he should be beat and she should leave.

Re: divorce or not according to Gurmat

Harjas Kaur · 26 Aug 2005

[quote]"I know of a case where the panj pyares peshed a Singh for what he did to his wife and I think it stopped from there. What those singhs did was gurmat."[/quote] [quote]"if the husband goes to the punj pyaare and gets pesh then with guru jis blessing this will all stop. then the divine law will work and heal everything."[/quote] I agree this is the actual answer to the problem. And probly the only thing in the world with a chance at helping. [%sig%]

Re: divorce or not according to Gurmat

Gandalf · 27 Aug 2005

What are Kulbir Singh, Jasbir Singh or JS Arshees views on divorce? Is not living with your spouse, but not being "divorced" OK? Does it matter who files for divorce?

Re: divorce or not according to Gurmat

ranjot sidhu · 27 Aug 2005

get some lads together wherever you hear of some singhani maaran wala produce him in front of the panj or batter him and show him the hands of warriors and kick his backside properly. sant jarnail singhs time the singhs dealt with anyone abusing women wrongly. Theres too much talk about whats rigtht and wrong and no action, time to get together and take care of this. If this carries on more and more women will leave sikhi. wake up noiw

Re: divorce or not according to Gurmat

slayer of kaffarz · 27 Aug 2005

too many pussies not enough warrior sher gabru jwan to knock out the oppressor

Re: divorce or not according to Gurmat

sikh · 27 Aug 2005

admin jee what is wrong with u allowing posts with such bad language? by slayer of kaffars..........please wake up.

Re: divorce or not according to Gurmat

mahamurakh · 28 Aug 2005

sikh i understand your sentiments but when i think of indra ghandi i want to use all the swear words on the planet quiet frankly kutti is not enough. when i think of those who batter women i share the feelings of many of our veers whos families are affected emotionally by this plight who have seen their mothers sisters beaten in childhood and adult life. Yes this is a gurmat forum but its damn annoying when you hear singhs just sending out the signal accept this as it is. Sikhs were created to stop all this female inequality mess and violence against anyone on basis of race gender creed religion. When your own people turn away who have a duty what words are left? Sometimes when a person posts try to understand what their going through singh. One of my relatives lost 3 children in her womb because of a wife beating husband. I believe we sikhs need to take action against this, for beating a woman up is anti gurmat to start with it is not karam. It is narak haram a big sin to accept this as karam, the sikh gathers strentgh through naam to protest and fight against something so cruel. A woman deserves to be beat because she was born a female? it is a mans right? it is her karam? the very though and acceptance of this is kul yug. Sikhs are not any religion. We are incorporated into a panth. We have a duty to stand up for each other. If you hear some singh is touching up some female, what would you do? what if he had a history of violating the rioghts of others and carries on? yes yes we all know such a person is not fit to be cal;led a singh but in society we accept him as such. But what next?? why do you all take such a shallow acceptance of wife beating? one day if the tables turn and you yourselves will get battered in attacks who will save you? do you want the khalsa to gather to help? the same khalsa then must help our sisters. being a panth we have to look out for one another. We are a big family, if the man breaks his duty and he certainly does by battering those under his care then first his action is anti gurmat and secondly it deserves to be punished and corrected.

Re: divorce or not according to Gurmat

mahamurakh · 28 Aug 2005

if marriage is unbearable then it is not anand karaj to start with. If a man rapes his wife do you call that karam? the marriage is no longer amarriage. hence divorce is an unavoidable circumstantial result of the anti gurmat actions of the male. This is nothing to do with accepotance of Gods will. Will you accept your sister being forced beaten everyday by a singh? Where is the bana in this? this is something that is wrong and we have tobe practical enough to seperate accepting cruelty to Gods will in matters divine. The problemcan on the other hand be misused whereby two couples just do not get on to start with. Rather than trying to make it work they want divorce. So again the issue depends upon the reasons being legit for divorce to take place. I stroingl;y believe in womens rights. If islam gave the woman a right to divorce then i believe sikhi being much more gender equality focused would give women greater rights to stand up and not take things lightly.

Re: divorce or not according to Gurmat

Search for tat · 28 Aug 2005

only the panj apyres can make these decisions. She should go pesh and open her heart to her Guru........ rest is all just speculation....

Re: divorce or not according to Gurmat

Harjas Kaur · 29 Aug 2005

[quote]"rest is all just speculation...."[/quote] It's more than speculation. It's an outrage. [quote]"Contrary to popular myth, abusers do not suffer from anger management problems. They manage their anger just fine - whenever there are witnesses." S.C. Elgin[/quote] [%sig%]

Re: divorce or not according to Gurmat

sikh · 29 Aug 2005

the problem we have is when the whole divorce thing is mis-used. people not getting on, changes of opinion, feelings, wanting something else these are not valied reasons for divorce.

Re: divorce or not according to Gurmat

nightonnight · 30 Aug 2005

what should you do if your other half has walked out on you and said they don't want to be married to you anymore. and our problems are not even 1% of the problems the sister has had with her violent husband.

Re: divorce or not according to Gurmat

jagira jatt · 31 Aug 2005

what are the reasons of the parttner walking out on th person? if th reason is nil then that is wrong but if the reason has ground then we must listen to it first to understand what made the person walk out.

Re: divorce or not according to Gurmat

Harjas Kaur · 31 Aug 2005

[quote]what are the reasons of the parttner walking out on th person?[/quote] I have 2 divorced Singnee friends. Without much deatils, basically in both cases the guy wanted to marry a younger woman. So he did, and started new family. In one he left behind 3 beautiful boys and an Amritdharee wife, to start drinkin and have sucessful businesses. I agree blame is not always on the husband. I know two divorced Singhs. Both cases wife abandoned them for richer man. In one case leaving marriage as soon as she got citizenship and she left behind 2 children. Human nature is at fault. Divorce is always bad. I think in special circumstances taken to the Panj Pyare divorce may be the only way, as you cannot force another partner to be good. But, any marriage with a hope of healing needs Guruji's blessing. Without that is no chance. With that, miracles can happen and change of heart. [%sig%]

Re: divorce or not according to Gurmat

nightonnight · 31 Aug 2005

she has basically told me she has no feelings for me anymore, without getting personal this it in general.

Re: divorce or not according to Gurmat

a · 01 Sep 2005

it just makes me sick to think that men or women can be amritdhari and then do what Harjas Kaur has told us. nightonight that is awful, I know it doesn'tmake a difference but perhaps it makes me feel sorry for myself because I'mnot even married yet and reading this stories just makes u wander whether its worth the risk. if someone says they don't have feelings for u anymore then no offence to the person but unless u have ill-treated her she is lost. What can u do about this person, notmuch in my opinion. I don't know many amritdharis and being one myself I really thought that amritdhari marriages would be full of bliss as I couldn't imagine walking out on the man or treating him in a way that would seriously upset him but in today's world one partner's love and sacrifice does little if the other one is interested in £ or 'younger' women. It makes me wander WHY people take amrit if they cannot even live upto the expectations.

Re: divorce or not according to Gurmat

nightonnight · 01 Sep 2005

what can you do though? even if you try and explain what is happening and the decisions being made are aginst GuruJi's teachings. and the person won't listen what should you do, should you walk away?

Re: divorce or not according to Gurmat

jagira jatt · 01 Sep 2005

night on night birey then that woman did wrong and trhere is no ground for divorce at all from what i gather in dharm grounds. To say i have no feelings noi more like why not? if she has a valid reason to feel there are no feelings such as she was raped, abused battered or hurt emotionally thrpoughout her marriage then i can understand. BUT if you have been a devoted husband and she just does not find you to b her piece of cake anymore then she is mega mashed and i would first advise you both to see a marriage councillor and put seperation on hold. A marriage councillor will establish what is wrong and where it is going wrong.

Re: divorce or not according to Gurmat

a · 01 Sep 2005

nightotnight, if u dont have a prob then can u perhaps give us an example of what u considered to be anti-sikh and she did not because maybe she is religious but ur sikh views are in conflict and maybe just maybe u always thinkur in the right. I dont mean to sound rude but I nearly married someone who always thought his sikh views were right and mine meant zilch although I wanted a marriage where 2 ppl help eachother get close to Guru ji and honestly I believe in one soul 2 bodies idea. but this person wasnt even into have a close relatioship, it seemed like marriage was something u have to do and it made me feel like a nothing, it makes u think he thinks ur so small and ur views and interpretation of sikhi is of little or no value and that can mean u lose respect for that person and yes then God forbid have no feelings for them. I'm not saying its ur fault but if u want u could give us a little more detail and the sangat can advise u onm whether ur going wrong? Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh

Re: divorce or not according to Gurmat

nightonnight · 01 Sep 2005

sangat ji we had our problems but we always talked them through and were always striving to be better sikhs. i am amritdhari she is not. but we were working towards her becoming amritdhari. she says i did not give her love, i explained i could not give her love in certain ways due to certain problems of my own, but again we were working to better them. i always talked to her and shared my feelings. and she was understanding for quite some time. but i showed her love in many other ways. i was not cold to her. i supported her in many things. and she me. and then all of a sudden she says she no longer loves me blah blah, totally out of the blue. and now when i talk of guru sahib and how this is wrong to just walk out on the first instance she is not listening, its all going down the drain. and i cant seem to stop it. i am no angel but i am also no monster and always have strived to be a better person. i dont know what to do because its as if our marriage was a running tap and now she has just closed it, she wants nothing to do with me. she wont talk to me nothing wont respond to my messages nothing. i have not seen poeple treat their worst enemies like this. and we didnt even live with our parents we lived alone. and now suddenly she calls our marriage a nightmare.

Re: divorce or not according to Gurmat

nightonnight · 01 Sep 2005

a ji i have realised all my mistakes but my partner is no where to be seen. they have moved out and at present, from everything they have said and are currently doing there is no coming back.

Re: divorce or not according to Gurmat

nightonnight · 01 Sep 2005

sangat ji - i never in my worst dreams ever thought i would experience something like this. to all fellow sikhs looking to get married please be careful and follow gurujis hukam. let them show you the way and make your match. funny thing is my wife said her feelings for me materialised when she was at the gurdwara. how more blessed could we have been? and now when the test is being conducted by guru sahib the students are failing. and ignoring guruji. :(

Re: divorce or not according to Gurmat

a · 01 Sep 2005

sorry to hear that about her, unfortunately sometimes a woman has had enough perhaps because she feels the man is not what she expected or does not love her as much as she loves him. To be honest it is pathetic that a woman can just walk out like that and say she has no feelings for you. I don't think anyone can really advise you on this one, you can either give it a couple of weeks and then try to contact her, ask her for one meeting or something, I can appreciate that you must be feeling not so happy but perhaps here you do not have a choice afterall it is not about what you decide but what she decides so divorce is an option for her and you will have to sign if she wants you to sign on the dotted line. But I'm glad to hear that you were honest with your feelings, it shows your efforts but it seems she was not as honest as you and ok giving my own story here, the guy I was supposed to marry, well I was damn honest to him all the time, and yeah we had a few disagreements, I wanted to sit down and sort them out and accepted his lies, mistakes whatever, but he was totally cold, totally private about his feelings or lack of them lol. But when it broke off he did not have a problem, in fact I dont think it had ever crossed his mind to say yes again once he had said no. All I can say is that the experience shocked me, but it taught me one thing, a cold person will be a cold person and usually they don't understand the meaning of love or understanding eachother. I really feel for u mate but I've come across a few cold ppl, i've had relatives married to these cold ppl and no matter how much these men begged their wives they were not interested. U can try as hard as u want , and although difficult ofcourse it is not impossible. Ofcourse try to get her back, it is marriage, a union u hopefully value although she might not, try ur best but that is all u can do but I'm sorry I'm not much help. I can only warn u to expect the worst, talking from what I've seen but let us know what happens.

Re: divorce or not according to Gurmat

nightonnight · 01 Sep 2005

a ji if we all started walking when we didnt feel anymore love then why get married in the first place? who stays in love all their lifes? marriage is something which must be worked at constantly. her actions since she left are beyond cold, i have no words to describe them. though when i look back into the marriage i could see this cold side to her, but ignored it. what an idiot i was. i asked her when we last talked what if the next guy she falls out of love with what will u do then. her answer - leave him as well. may guru ji do kirpa.

Re: divorce or not according to Gurmat

a · 01 Sep 2005

look I understand, I hope the sangat also understands your situation but really all anyone can do is nothing because if she does not come back she does not come back, all you can do is try and be strong. I agree that its ridiculous to leave of u dont thinku love the person anymore but there is nothing I can say to that because she is not amritdhari so she had no rules to follow if u get me. As for ur other point, mate ppl do stay in love all their lives if they continue to work together as sikhs and spend time together and respect one another and dont go around checking other ppl out. Love only grows, it does not decrease! unless ur a totally lost case in which case love decreases eachday till it ends lol. ofocurse marriage has to be worked at but not because it 'has' to but because u 'want' it to, mayb eu saw it as a chore and so did she? marriage is something to be enjoyed, not something where u think hai rabba what is this I have to live with for the rest of my life.... but dont worry I'll do my best to stick thru it. need to be a little bit more enthusiastic abt marriage mate! I admit from experience of only a few months that it doesnt seem like something to be excited abt but if ur not then u cant expect the other person to enjoy spending time with u. well when ur in the relationship u tend to ignore the bad signs and think its going ok unless the other person tells u with words instead of expecting u to guess. Thats just something u have learnt for when she comes back or u decide to wed again (soz to state the possibility). abt the Gudwara, did she fall for ur looks there or ur sikhi or ur personality is what u need to ask. warning everyone to follow Guru Ji's hukam, mate i think u did to some extent but maybe its also Guru Ji's hukam that this is all the timeu spend together. Mate I stronly advise u to spend more time praying and doing sewa and realising one slight mistake was that u did not marry an amritdhari (not that it guarnatees a blissful marriage). just wait till u hear anything from her and then maybe come back to get the sangats advice, till then i dont think anyone can help much .