Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

what happens to an amritdhari if he committs suicide

what happens to an amritdhari if he committs suicide

nameless · 19 Aug 2005

if an amritdhari sikh committed suicide does anybody have any idea what would happen to him after death?

Re: what happens to an amritdhari if he committs suicide

confused · 19 Aug 2005

back to charausi lakh joon

Re: what happens to an amritdhari if he committs suicide

*** · 19 Aug 2005

Amritdhari person is not supposed to even think abt committing suicide. Accepting Guru's will is what an amritdhari does, not going against it.

Re: what happens to an amritdhari if he committs suicide

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 20 Aug 2005

IS THE SAME AS ASKING.. WHAT WILL A dead person SAY WHEN HE TALKS ?? answer..a DEAD PERSON will NEVER TALK... answer..AN AMRITDHAREE will NEVER take the COWARLY WAY OUT. As to what happens after that....even GURU NANAK JI says.. I DONT KNOW. ( read Gurbani)

Re: what happens to an amritdhari if he committs suicide

dil · 20 Aug 2005

Fateh, As I understand if an amritdhari gursikh comits sucide. He may not go to chaurasi lakh joons, instead may get a life as a sikh and may have to tougher life than this, which compelled him to do this act. In case he he comits same thing in next life the he may go to chaurasi lakh joons. It is my way of thinking. Gurji respect his amrit and give one more chance. bye now

Re: what happens to an amritdhari if he committs suicide

confused · 20 Aug 2005

exactly if you follow Guru Jee's Hukams suicide isnt even something that is considered

Re: what happens to an amritdhari if he committs suicide

confused · 20 Aug 2005

jarnail singh i think you mean a REHITDHARI will never take the COWARDLY way out because anyone can be amritdhari but rehitdhari is something else there are people who have taken amrit but arent the best of rehit followers i think you know what i mean

Re: what happens to an amritdhari if he committs suicide

Lionking · 21 Aug 2005

Author: Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" Date: 08-20-05 09:15 IS THE SAME AS ASKING.. WHAT WILL A dead person SAY WHEN HE TALKS ?? answer..a DEAD PERSON will NEVER TALK... answer..AN AMRITDHAREE will NEVER take the COWARLY WAY OUT. As to what happens after that....even GURU NANAK JI says.. I DONT KNOW. ( read Gurbani) ____________________ Please quote Gyani ji..

Re: what happens to an amritdhari if he committs suicide

raj karega khalsa · 21 Aug 2005

Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh During the 80's didnt sum singhs take cyanide b4 the cops caught them? not tryin to take away from these singhs' seva but isnt that wrong? n i kno its easier sed than done. Bhull Chaak Maph Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh

Re: what happens to an amritdhari if he committs suicide

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 21 Aug 2005

Author: Lionking Date: 08-21-05 01:49 Author: Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" Date: 08-20-05 09:15 IS THE SAME AS ASKING.. WHAT WILL A dead person SAY WHEN HE TALKS ?? answer..a DEAD PERSON will NEVER TALK... answer..AN AMRITDHAREE will NEVER take the COWARLY WAY OUT. As to what happens after that....even GURU NANAK JI says.. I DONT KNOW. ( read Gurbani) ____________________ Please quote Gyani ji.. >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> actually there are hundreds of quotes in which Guru Ji genrally means..ONLY AKALPURAKH REALLY KNOWS THE END ALL....no one else In Japji Sahib right at the beginning of Guur Granth Ji this message is clearly set out. Read the last panktee of the Shabad on CREATION..How it all Began...Guur nanAK ji declares "Karteh kee......KARTA JANNEH... When Guru Ji says that "ONLY KARTA KNOWS..I take it to mean that Guru Ji is saying.....what i have understood. ( in Actual FACT this is HUMBLENESS on Guru Ji's Part but that is what is plain for us) Note: i lost the quotes file due to a frined "borrowing" it and then losing it..but I will get it back . SO off hand i am unable to post many quotes. JS

Re: what happens to an amritdhari if he committs suicide

,,, · 21 Aug 2005

What were they supposed to do. Their situation was different. They took it due to torture. No one wants torture. They were gonns get killed anyways so they took cynanide over torture.

Re: what happens to an amritdhari if he committs suicide

Harjas Kaur · 22 Aug 2005

To commit suicide out of despair, humiliation, anger, or some mental disease is one thing. It reflects a lowered level of spirituality resulting in an act which is cowardly and hurts the family and the sangat. This person is likely to have to undergo these tests again until he passes them. But it's possible he goes to a hellish realm where his mind already is. Can an amritdhari do this? Well, I think anyone can go backwards, but at some point they are breaking amrit. To commit suicide to prevent betraying to the enemy under torture is actually heroic, as a human being desires to live, and this is act of shaheed, to give the life and protect a cause or community. How does Guruji treat these things? Well, I don't really know, Im not Guruji. But you can expect greatest wisdom and mercy. The selfish and sick soul that needs to be chastised will find its sufferings. The soul that needs to learn more will find a future chance to learn more. The heroic soul probably has mukti, as he is giving his head because enemy forces his choice. May the sangat forgive me for any errors of opinion.

Re: what happens to an amritdhari if he committs suicide

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 22 Aug 2005

Yes..on the question of Those Singhs who swalloed cyanide capsules to avoid capture/torture and posible betrayal ( imho the Truth Serum can over-ride mental resolve not to betray). I dont think this is tantamount to "suicide" in the normal way. This is shahedee becasue IF captured..the Singh can have the option to LIVE by being a traitor..and he chose DEATH. Anyway as Bhen Ji harjas Kaur has stated above..GURU JI knows..BUT I pray that Guru Ji treats these Guru Ke Sikh with extra love and Pyaar..because they GAVE thier TODAY so that we can have our TOMORROW with DIGNITY. I owe them this much at least. JS