Re: AKJ - Presentation..plx help
Mr Rice Pudding · 07 Oct 2003
Why don't you tell them that it begun in the 60's, and follows a seperate line from mainstream Sikhs, which is basically true.
Re: AKJ - Presentation..plx help
Kulbir Singh · 07 Oct 2003
>>>>>>>
don't do on AKJ!!!do about the sikhi.......
>>>>>>>
In my humble opinion there is nothing wrong in doing a presentation on a leading organization of Khalsa Panth.
There have been many studies done on Bhai Vir Singh, Professor Mohan Singh and more recently Shiv Kumar Batalvi. All the so called literary people go into great lengths to praise the worldly works of Shiv Kumar and Mohan Singh. I don't have any doubts that these men did write some great poems and literature. But the problem is that great works of Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee have been deliberately ignored by Punjabi University Patiala at the behest of anti-Panthic elements in India.
I have read many of the books written by scholars of Punjabi University which was formed to do positive research on Sikhi and am greatly disappointed at what they have written. How can you do up a thesis on Karams without referring to Bhai Sahib's monumental work Gurmat Karam Philosophy? How can you write about Dasam Duaar and not mention Bhai Sahib's books? How can you write about Gadar Party history and not mention Bhai Sahib's 16 years of rigorous punishment in jail.
I was reading one of the books published by Punjabi University and it talked about mysticism in Sikhi. Bhai Sahib is the pitaamaah (great-grandfather) of mysticism in Sikhi after Bhai Gurdas jee. You can't write a book or a thesis by ignoring his books on this subject but this is exactly what has happened. Instead of quoting Bhai Sahib's books these pseudo scholars have quoted Radhasoami literature and lectures of Saawan Singh (Radhasoami Guru). I was disgusted to read that book.
In the early nineties many influential singhs tried to have Punjabi University write on Bhai Sahib's books and it was even announced that writers would write on Bhai Sahib and the books would get published by Punjabi University but then after political pressure from undisclosed sources, this plan was put on shelf forever.
Anyway, coming back to the original question, I think history of Akhand Kirtani Jatha is the history of Sikhi in the modern times. They two are inseparable. AKJ is the topmost organization of Panth (my opinion) and there is nothing wrong in writing history of Jatha.
Actually, I appeal to Singhs living in India to write genuine and truthful history of Akhand Kirtani Jatha. Now is the correct time because many singhs from Bhai Sahib's times are still alive. It is unfortunate that we are losing so much by not recording the great events of modern times.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: AKJ - Presentation..plx help
Balpreet Singh · 07 Oct 2003
If you're going to do a presentation on AKJ, then I suggest you start off by talking a bit about what the Jatha does: ie. Keertan and akhand paaths. Talk about smaagams and ran sabaaees and the Jatha's style of keertan, etc.
Then talk about Bhai Sahib Randheer Singh jee's life, the Jatha that formed around him upto 1914, the Jatha's role in the Gadar Movement and how most of the Jatha was sent to jail, etc.
Then I'd talk about the Jatha's role in 1978 and the conflict after.
I'd also mention the beliefs of the Jatha: ie. Lareedaar Saroop, Sarbloh Bibek, Keskee as a kakaar, ragmala issue. I'd mention that Jathat members live quite strict lifestyles with amrit vela naam abhyaas being a must, many members wearing baaNaa at all times, etc.
That's just some ideas off the top of my head.
Re: AKJ - Presentation..plx help
Balpreet Singh · 08 Oct 2003
Actually, scholars like Harjinder Singh Dilgeer and Piara Singh Padam also believe in Keskee as a Kakaar.
As for ragmala, Akaal Takhat Sahib has said that Sikhs have an option to read or not read Ragmala, so this is not different than the Panth. There are many Singhs who are not associated with the AKJ who do not read ragmala.
Re: AKJ - Presentation..plx help
Mr Rice Pudding · 08 Oct 2003
{¿?}
Kheer or Rice Pudding whats the difference when some true BhramGianyies think Guru Nanak used to change meat into Rice Pudding.
Any way the Jatha did begin a few years ago in the 60's so whats the big deal, its a fact like it or not. Or are you gonna say Guru Gobind Singh started it off along side the Khalsa in 1699, or perhaps it was the Jatha that begun in 1699.