Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

simran in sangat

simran in sangat

Guru ji help me i'm so weak · 18 Aug 2005

From Jagjit Singh Waheguru ji ke Khalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh Pyare jio,it is important to understand this properly, so forgive the long mail. Simran is not a “Reet” started by Bhai Randhir Singh. This is another of them silly made up stories which Punjabis pass to the next man in the Gurdwara, without ever researching to see if it is actually true. In fact, Gursikhs who were companions of Bhai sahib state he never did simran in keertan. He only did keertan of the Gurbani Shabad. Plus he only did one shabad at a time rather than a number of shabads on a specific subject, which are common now. So when he did keertan for 48 hours at a time in Main Historical Gurdwaras, he did one shabad only, but got so deep into that one shabad than he meditated on it for 48 hours, which shows his Jeevan. Stand alone Simran - as many now do with wajas in akhand jaaps or 1hour simran programmes is a relatively new phenomenom. In fact, I believe its real pioneer was Bhai Sahib Rama Singh. If we listen to keertan at Sri Harmandar sahib, you will never hear simran, neither are people allow to sing with the kirtanees in the jatha style. It is true that Akhand kirtani Jatha has introduced a different style of keertan to the Panth, but this was after Bhai sahib Randhir Singh. Whether it is new, or something re-introduced, which was lost over time, is open to debate? This style of keertan is called “Sangatee keertan”, in which the whole sangat sings along aswell. Is this wrong? I do not see why? Surely the essence of keertan is that everyone sings and meditates, rather than sitting silently which only makes the mind wonder or makes one fall asleep. Go to any rainsbhai and you will see plenty of sangat compared any raagi darbaar that happens every week at the Gurdwara. People travel all over the country because they get Gurbani Rass from “Sangaatee keertan”. Many Gursikhs state that meditating on Naam by oneself, has certain Rass, but in sangat you benefit from everyone, so it is like a tidal wave of Rass. Is doing Simran wrong in Sangat? Firstly is doing Simran wrong? No, it is essential part of sikhi. All Gurbani leads us to the direction of Naam Simran. If you were to do a search of Gurbani for references to Naam, you will get the whole Sahib Siri Guru Granth Sahib. Naam is Sikhi. “Raam Naam Sabh Hai Raam Nama” is Guru ji saying everything is Naam, so how can it be avoided or wrong? Now we get back to:- Is doing Simran in Sangat wrong? This is a lot more complicated…….. According to Gurmat, the Naam we get from the Panj Pyare during Amrit Sanchaar is secret, and given to us upon the condition of us giving our head to Guru Ji. Eventhough Bhai Gurdas Ji states “Waheguru Gurmanter Hai, Jap Haumai Koi”, the Gurmantar is secret, and throughout Gurbani, Maharaj uses many other names of God to describe him, such Raam, Allah, and so forth. The Gurmantar is only placed inside us by the Panj Pyares, when they put Amrit in our eyes, mouth, and on to of our head, and then place their hands on our head and infuse the Naam inside us, like an electrical current all do Naam Simran abyass together. Then Naam comes into our breath system, and hopefully we strive to remember Guru Ji with every breath from then on. So when we do simran on a waja, to music, it is saying the shabad with our lips. This is Simran of Waheguru, and definitely not Naam Simran, which is simran via the method instructed by the Panj Pyares. The waja simran is also very powerful and many will have amazing spiritual experiences from it. There is nothing wrong with Gursikhs sitting down and doing simran in such a manner. The only problem is when non-Amritdharis mistake it for Naam Simran. This is our duty to point out to them. When I used to do the seva on the waja in the simran programmes in Slough, I specifically stated that it was just simran, and Not Naam Simran. I stated it was essential for all the Sangat to be blessed with Amrit to ever be able to do Naam Simran. Unless this is pointed out people often assume, they do not need Naam from the Panj, and they have Gurmantar. This is wrong, only the Panj can give Naam. We have to understand that the significant majority of humans by their nature wish the easy way out, and if they think they can get Naam, without Rehit, they will take it. However I have to say, when it is pointed out, only a few avoid Amrit, and over the years I have seen hundreds rush to Amrit after being inspired by Simran or keertan. The Sikh Rehit Maryada (SRM) is an important guide to running our Gurdwaras. I have been a supporter of Panthik maryada for many years, and have always supported the Sikh Missionary Society in India. However it has been brought to my attention, that Hounslow Gurdwara committee is trying to stop the Youth Simran Programme and the chips and beans for the kids. This is a huge step away from the direction the Gurdwara should be going in. The Gurdwara should be reaching out to kids, and introducing meditation and keertan to them. Sometimes I do feel the obsession that so many Sikhs young and old have with the intricracies of Maryadas is really damaging to Sikhi. Our Guru Sahib were social reformers who brought God, and his virtues back to humanity. Yes, the SRM states only keertan and katha can be done, but no where does it state that Simran cannot be done! How many kids are going to listen to keertan straightaway, or katha straightaway. I, myself, when keeping my kesh did simran with keertan in my mind for almost 18 months, purely because I did not understand keertan. It took me so long just to start understanding it. We have a language barrier to overcome, and the simplicity of simran is an amazing way to overcome it. Secondly how do we know doing Simran is against SRM? Simran is essential according to Gurbani. It does not mention anywhere in SRM that simran cannot be done. Today people say simran was not done in olden times, before they used to say Rainsbhai were not done. This was until it was pointed out that Gurbani itself mentions Rainsbhais. Yes, Gurbani also mentions “Bhai Re Raam Kaho Chit Laye” aswell as the thousands of other shabads expressing the importance of Simran. Does anyone learn anything from Simran? If done with sincerity, they learn a lot. You learn peace of mind, humility, calmness, patience. In fact any real Bhagat of Naam will tell you, that you learn more about patience, love, passion, perseverance, inner strength, the weakness of the mind and concentration, and the inner glow and fulfillness that Gurbani brings, from simran rather than any other practice. Lastly, I would state that groups like Sikh missionary and such, like Punjab radio, Gianis like Gulshan, or Proffesor Darshan Singh, etc. I have heard them often criticize simran. They have a place in Sikhi and have much to offer. But lets us not be mistaken, none of them are Spritualists. They are educated in history and Sikh philosophy. But Sikhi is far than a philosophy. I respect them, but if you crave a deep spiritual Jeevan, then you need to look deeper. Bhai Rama singh was a pioneer of this, eventhough it started much earlier than him. In fact, I believe it was prevalent at the times of our Gurus, but I will be unable to reference it. Bhai Sahib said when every Gurdwara has its congregation are doing simran together, then it will be dominated by love, not arguments as most currently are. Sukhmani Sahib starts by stating do simran and remove the arguments in your mind and around you. Bhai Sahib states in his book Khalsa Raj will come when simran is happening from Punjab to Delhi. Sikhi has always been a socially reformist religion, one that beyond the dogmas of ritualism, blind worship, and ignorance. However many of Gurdwaras, preachers and prabandhaks are steeped in it. This has always been the case. In times old and new, people minds have always worked in a way of self-preservation of ego and status, and never learned that “sacrifice of ego” is essential in Gurmat. Sometimes criticism of a practice comes from ignorance or lack of practice of it, or just fear that it will reduce their importance. Simran can never be a ritual, it is far too powerful, and affects a person mind far too easily to be just a mere ritual. Youth need realise the simplicity of Sikhi as Sahib Siri Guru Nanak Dev teached it. Join your Mind to Gurbani, and you can never fail. You need no middle-men, no secret formula, no complicated rules and regulations. Simply introduce the direct link of mind to Gurbani and simran does that. Waheguru ji ke Khalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh

Re: simran in sangat

simple singhani · 18 Aug 2005

wjkk wjkf! amazing post bhai sahib! i totally agree with you 100%!!!. naam simran is a gift from the punj pyareh...and yes..it should b kept..secret....what do u think..about youngsters doing saas girass...on stage.at uk rainsbhais...loadly..cus it does happen...shudn't b kept gupt no?.. wjkk wjkf

Re: simran in sangat

MBSINGH · 19 Aug 2005

May be I am wrong, but what I understand from the mail is that Author differentiates Simran into two types; Waja Simran and Naam Simran. Former is beneficial because it is simple attractant and attaches new comers/children to Gurbani. (Latter type is of course kept to be secret.) This is new idea. That makes good defence for Waja Simran. I appreciate and agree with the Positive Points of Waja Simran. But do fear that the "making of two types" is no way logical. Wrong is wrong. We love to attract others; I find something is wrong with this obsession of ours. I remember Prof Puran Singh' s words at this point. Briefly, I quote " Let the light come to others from the God /Guru direct. Do not worry about their spirtuality, worry yours."

Re: simran in sangat

Saas Giras · 19 Aug 2005

Fateh Jee Erm young kids donig Saas Giras on stage? So what? If they get to the stage in their bhagthi where it just comes out then whats the problem??? End of the day, alot of the people who go already have experience, lets be honest, most rhensbais are akj neway therefore each individual who has taken amrit from the jatha is already trained with saas giras!!! Also, someone once said to me to practice saas giras is in bani, i cnt comment, i dnt have the ability to understand bani. In all cicumstances, hanji, its true we should try to keep it secret but remember that back in the day, sikhs were amritdhari therefore we didnt need to hide our sikhi out of fear another wouldnt like it. The recorings are edited before putting on the net so again, not a problem. Its on the time of event where it can be heard and to be honest, its beautiful!! If people dnt like it then they dnt have to listen. Simple as. Go into another hall and sit with maharaj there if thats why u are in the room. Sounds harsh but if they screaming for vaheguru the only way they know how then we should support them. They do keertan for piyaar for Guru Ji. Not many of the older kirtanis still do it for piyaar, jst for a job hence they do not go into the simran, keertan as much as the younger and better kirtanies out there.

Re: simran in sangat

singh · 19 Aug 2005

Waheguru ji ke Khalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh my two sense worth (not that Im worthy of it) dont worry about debating whether you should do simran aloud or keeping it a secret. The main thing is that you Jap Naam either way! Waheguru ji ke Khalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh

Re: simran in sangat

simple singhani · 19 Aug 2005

yea thats true singh. i was jus wondering if it was right, but yea look at it in a positive manner.good point

Re: simran in sangat

uk singh · 20 Aug 2005

'According to Gurmat, the Naam we get from the Panj Pyare during Amrit Sanchaar is secret' is this referenced?

Re: simran in sangat

......... · 20 Aug 2005

the panj Pyare instruct your not to tell anyone. Is part of the rehit. You can only get access to Naam from thePanj Pyares, no where else.

Re: simran in sangat

Lionking · 21 Aug 2005

So are you meant to do laods of SImran before Amrit Sanchar or is it too Gupt for an non-Amritdhari to do it??

Re: simran in sangat

L plater · 21 Aug 2005

waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh gursikho this is news to me! i took amrit a couple of years ago coz the whole family took it... at that time i wanted it but then i went sort of astray -- not to say that i did any of the bujjer kurheta but jus in general i didnt do my banis etc now i 've developed more piyaar for gursikhi and m starting to enjoy it and realise its wonderful depth but to be honest, i dont remember the punj piyare sayn anyfin bout secret naam simran etc... i always thought naam simran was when u jus said waheguru -- either that b in sangat or in ur own privacy while u doin other stuff etc and wats this bout the recordings being edited b4 been put up online? bhul chuk maaf ji waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh [%sig%]

Re: simran in sangat

MBSINGH · 22 Aug 2005

Of course; Simran is better than wasting time on debating its modes. Yet, the topic is no less important. Children do enjoy it on Harmonium; as well as the seniors. They are blessed. One loves to see them "Chanting the Lord". AGREED. But how long one loves to be a child. I am sorry to state, Correctness of a theory can not be judged by the no. of persons (or children) enjoying it. Bhai Sahib Randhr Singh Ji in his book "Jot Vigas"; criticizes the "In-public Waja-Simran category Singhs" and terms them "Hochhai". Please forgive me

Re: simran in sangat

waheguruji... · 22 Aug 2005

waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh pyare jio. the debate here is about whether shall we keep our simran gupt or we must let everyone know that we are doing it right? well as per my point of view both ways are correct. when we are in the sangat, and the sangat is doing naam simran or singing any shabad we should join in and sing with our full heart,no matter the tune is out or its its off cord or anything but just sing.in bani there are a lot of thuka(n) about singing i.e " awoh sikh satguru ke pyare,gavoh sachi bani" " tum gavoh nirbao ka sohila" and lots more. i think we are realy wasting our precious time debating about gupt simran. when we are alone then we can do our simran to ourselves. we can use all the time in the world when we are alone to do simran.we can either lock ourselves in the room to do simran or we can also join the sangat. as what i know,when we are in the sadh sangat,thats the best place for us to get connected to Guruji. c'mon ppl,lets not waste our time by talking all this,instead use this time to do simran.kaljug is here brothers and sisters and the only thing can help is naam simran. the place where i come from, the sangat loves and join in when we do akj style kirtan and even the giani ji has started to do akj kirtan. i think the roop of the sangat and the kirpa of Guruji is very important to do kirtan and simran. bhul chuk maaf. waheguru ji ka khalsa, waheguru ji ki fateh...

Re: simran in sangat

Lionking · 22 Aug 2005

Author: MBSINGH Date: 08-22-05 05:32 Of course; Simran is better than wasting time on debating its modes. Yet, the topic is no less important. Children do enjoy it on Harmonium; as well as the seniors. They are blessed. One loves to see them "Chanting the Lord". AGREED. But how long one loves to be a child. I am sorry to state, Correctness of a theory can not be judged by the no. of persons (or children) enjoying it. Bhai Sahib Randhr Singh Ji in his book "Jot Vigas"; criticizes the "In-public Waja-Simran category Singhs" and terms them "Hochhai". Please forgive me ____________________________ Which page is this?

Re: simran in sangat

*** · 25 Aug 2005

Which page is this? It is 54-56

Re: simran in sangat

Lionking · 02 Sep 2005

Thanks.