Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Taksal Against Kirtan by Women in Darbar Sahib

Taksal Against Kirtan by Women in Darbar Sahib

news · 17 Aug 2005

Taksal against kirtan by women in Golden Temple Amritsar, August 17 The Damdami Taksal, yesterday outrightly rejected the proposal for allowing the baptised women to perform “kirtan” inside the Harmandir Sahib, the sanctum sanctorum of Golden Temple. The Damdami Taksal’s resolve to oppose this move was also supported by the Sant Samaj, a conglomerate of Sikh preachers headed by Baba Sarbjot Singh Bedi, at a function here on the occasion of the death anniversary of Sant Kartar Singh Bhindrawale. It may be recalled that the SGPC had last week taken the decision to allow women to perform “kirtan” inside the Harmandir Sahib. The decision had been taken at a meeting of the SGPC’s Religious Advisory Board. It was observed at the board’s meeting that the Akal Takht would have a final verdict on the proposal of allowing “amritdhari” (baptised) Sikh women to perform “kirtan” inside the Harmandir Sahib. At yesterday’s convention at the Damdami Taksal headquarters at Chowk Mehta near here, four granthis of the SGPC, Jaswant Singh, Mal Singh, Jatinder Singh and Jagtar Singh, also gave their support to the Damdami Taksal’s viewpoint against the women’s performance of “kirtan” in the Harmandir Sahib. The Akal Takht Jathedar, Giani Joginder Singh Vedanti, is scheduled to summon a meeting of the Singh Sahibs and after detailed discussions the final decision on the “kirtan” would be pronounced which would be binding on the Sikh community. The Dharam Prachar Committee, while taking the decision, had announced that the baptised Sikh women who fulfilled a set “code of conduct” could approach the SGPC authorities to perform “kirtan sewa” at the Harmandir Sahib. — UNI

Re: Taksal Against Kirtan by Women in Darbar Sahib

Singh · 17 Aug 2005

I have no objection to Sikh women doing kirtan in Harimandar Sahib as long as they LOOK like Sikh women and have dastaars and Gurmukhi Bana. I wonder what the justification is behind the opposition to Women kirtanis? Anyone know?

Re: Taksal Against Kirtan by Women in Darbar Sahib

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 17 Aug 2005

yes lets have some Gurbani quotes, panktees, or from the authentic rehatnamas. I am sure the taksali singhs on this forum can get these. As far as I know there is absolutely no jsutification whatsoever for thsi obvious discrimination other than male chauvanism. But i am open to authentic references. This is an obvious throw back to the Brahmin/Bippar PUJAREE SYSTEM....ONLY MALES are SUPREME in dealing with the "gods"...BUT GURMATT has no place for this. Jarnail Singh

Re: Taksal Against Kirtan by Women in Darbar Sahib

Maybe · 17 Aug 2005

Maybe this question needs to asked directly to the Mehta Chowk Jatha...something the Tribune should have done but failed to do. Just terrible journalism.

Re: Taksal Against Kirtan by Women in Darbar Sahib

TUF · 17 Aug 2005

This is ridiculous... I thought we were beyond this... I have no problem with women doing kirtan.

Re: Taksal Against Kirtan by Women in Darbar Sahib

singh · 17 Aug 2005

This is lame. This is whats wrong with even giving any of these jathebandis any credence. They turn into hardcore dukandhaaris with a motive to protect their own personal interests. Why is anyone even asking them? Why ask the DDT or any "sant"? Why not ask Baba Nanak?

Re: Taksal Against Kirtan by Women in Darbar Sahib

singh · 17 Aug 2005

Also, Shame on the SGPC granthis who are also against women doing kirtan. I can smell the stench of their greed here in Canada. LAME LAME LAME LAME LAME............. People are congratulating the SGPC and Jagir Kaur for their decision. This decision shouldn't have been needed in the first place. Shame on them for allowing this "maryada" to continue over the past several decades. I wonder what else is contained within the SGPC's maryada for Harmandir Sahib. The "Mahant Samaj" has gotta go.

Re: Taksal Against Kirtan by Women in Darbar Sahib

someone · 17 Aug 2005

Ever since Harmander Sahib was built no bibi has done kirtan there. Even in the times of the gurus. Do u think that Guru Ji overlooked or forgot about bibian all those years? think about it. Its just not meant to be.

Re: Taksal Against Kirtan by Women in Darbar Sahib

Tribune News Service · 17 Aug 2005

Women kirtan jatha case sent to Akal Takht Tribune News Service Amritsar, August 17 Even as the SGPC is facing opposition from a section of the Sikh Panth for its attempt to end gender bias by allowing baptised Sikh women to perform kirtan in the sanctum sanctorum of Harmandar Sahib here, the case has been referred to Akal Takht for the final nod of the Sikh clergy. A Sikh cleric and priest, Golden Temple, Giani Gurbachan Singh had already conveyed his reservation on allowing Sikh women to perform kirtan as allowed by the Dharam Parchar Committee. A section of the Damdami Taksal and Baba Sarbjot Singh Bedi , president, Sant Samaj, has also opposed the move. However, Bibi Jagir Kaur, president, SGPC, is reportedly determined to allow baptised women to clean the sanctum sanctorum. Interestingly even after 65 years of the decision of the Religious Advisory Committee in this regard the SGPC has failed to arrange a women jatha for performing kirtan in the Golden Temple.

Re: Taksal Against Kirtan by Women in Darbar Sahib

Singh · 17 Aug 2005

"Ever since Harmander Sahib was built no bibi has done kirtan there. Even in the times of the gurus. Do u think that Guru Ji overlooked or forgot about bibian all those years? think about it. Its just not meant to be." Oh yeah? I suppose you have a personal record of everyone who's done keertan there? If Guru Jee had wanted bibian banned from doing keertan there, do you think they would have overlooked or forgotten to mention this little fact to the sikhs?

Re: Taksal Against Kirtan by Women in Darbar Sahib

Singh · 18 Aug 2005

Hmmmmm.......... Good point 'someone' if that is true. Can someone please clarify.

Re: Taksal Against Kirtan by Women in Darbar Sahib

search for tat · 18 Aug 2005

Taksal is always been a sexist jathebandie. They are against bibian doing any seva. They always argue against bibian doing seva in Panj Pyares. Sant samaj lets not even go there. I think SS needs an internal affairs division to investigate all the cases of rape, corruption, sants fighting over deras.......

Re: Taksal Against Kirtan by Women in Darbar Sahib

kulbir Singh Dhillon UK wala · 18 Aug 2005

Re. sant/mahant samarj, ask mann of pehowa...he was quoted saying that If he was doing panj piare di seva, and a lady was also allowed to partake in this sewa, that if her LEG would touch his (as they sit around preparing the amrit, he could not control his minds desires.... To me this is the problem with all these narrow-minded folk, they are not in control of Karm...to them women are items, desires...not equals. quite simply put, when our Beloved Siri Guru Gobind Singh Ji had NO problem with baptising both women and men, thus making a statement of equality, then doing sewa, reciting Gurbani, or singing shabad...in any place, whether it be Darbar sahib in amritsar, or Dixie Gurdwara, Guru Ji recides everywere, right? Man, we have alot of cleaning up to do...taksal should lead the way, not get caught up in sexist pindu-type views/mentality.. but then again they too are apart of the sant/mahant samarj... IMHO

Re: Taksal Against Kirtan by Women in Darbar Sahib

A Singh · 18 Aug 2005

Let's not forget the "Pati-Parmeasur" concepts that are promoted by the Taksal, Nanaksar, and Sant Samaj...that too in their rehitnama - which they all claim to be authentic from Guru Gobind Singh!!!

Re: Taksal Against Kirtan by Women in Darbar Sahib

prince of darkness · 18 Aug 2005

as much as i myself find this hard to stomache as a staunch believr of equality, i think some people are going off on a tangent. The most conructive way forward is to ask those people who do not believe women should be doin kirtan at the front why so? simple as that! Why screw your bhagti over it and hold grudges displaying more akhad against jathas and groups? just ask as a simple question kio ve pravah gal iddah ?

Re: Taksal Against Kirtan by Women in Darbar Sahib

Harpartap Singh · 18 Aug 2005

'Search for Tat' What a mature and measured statement from you! (sarcastic) If you look at all Sikh Dharmic Jathebandhi's i.e. AKJ, they are all, and have always, been dominated by men. That is the context - seems that traditional patterns of patriarchal domination of the religious sphere have not been eradicated from Sikh institutions.

Re: Taksal Against Kirtan by Women in Darbar Sahib

singh · 18 Aug 2005

Prince, these discussions have already taken place many times over when the controversy came up a few years back. Furthermore why ask [i]them[/i] why, when our ONLY RELEVANT AUTHORITY ...GURUJI/GURBANI, has already given us the gian regarding caste/gender/age discrimination???

Re: Taksal Against Kirtan by Women in Darbar Sahib

khalsa · 18 Aug 2005

Author: someone *********************************************************** Ever since Harmander Sahib was built no bibi has done kirtan there. Even in the times of the gurus. Do u think that Guru Ji overlooked or forgot about bibian all those years? think about it. Its just not meant to be. *********************************************************** i'm sure you have the names of all bibian doing kirtan during guru sahib's time and that is why you know they were not allowed to do kirtan in harminder sahib. Till the time of guru arjan dev ji sikhs were not doing kirtan only bhat "marassis" were doing the kirtan. satta and bulband when refused to do kirtan guru ji asked sikhs to do kirtan. guru ji blessed sikhs with kirtan. sikh should take guidance from guru granth sahib ji "not damdami taksal" they have already done a lot of damage to sikhi. their rahitmaryada has too much biper's influence. what is the reason not to allow women to do kirtan in harminder sahib. guru nanak dev ji placed woman at very high place. as long as they do kirtan in "RAGS" there is nothing against sikh principle. Why jagir kaur is the president of SPGC. is she not a woman? it is all politics not gurmit in my another post regarding hinduzition of sikhi i mentioned sikh are following "BIPRAN KI REET" many Veers did not agree with me. these jathes and granthis and jathedars are above guru granth sahib ji. forget about guru ji and follow these jathes and taksals. [%sig%]

Re: Taksal Against Kirtan by Women in Darbar Sahib

Me · 18 Aug 2005

A Singh, you need to do your research before you go around spewing rubbish about things you have no knowledge of on the internet, how does nanaksar promote the 'pati-parmesar' concept? Answer with a sensible explanation, otherwise dont bother wasting everyone's time.

Re: Taksal Against Kirtan by Women in Darbar Sahib

dont know · 19 Aug 2005

we'll all find out whats wrong or right we all going to die one day and then we'll know :)

Re: Taksal Against Kirtan by Women in Darbar Sahib

A Singh · 19 Aug 2005

Dear "Me" Simple answer, I have Nanaksar family and all speak of this as it is normal and have no objection to the concept.

Re: Taksal Against Kirtan by Women in Darbar Sahib

search for tat · 19 Aug 2005

I think you will find they have had bibian in the commitees. Such as Bibi Manmohan kaur southall, plus in India the jatha has alwas been dominated by Bhai Joginder Singh Talwaras sister called kernailni. Harpratap - have any bibi held any position in DT? Harpartap Singh wrote: > 'Search for Tat' > > What a mature and measured statement from you! (sarcastic) > > If you look at all Sikh Dharmic Jathebandhi's i.e. AKJ, they > are all, and have always, been dominated by men. That is the > context - seems that traditional patterns of patriarchal > domination of the religious sphere have not been eradicated > from Sikh institutions.

Re: Taksal Against Kirtan by Women in Darbar Sahib

heallow · 19 Aug 2005

i think this tread should be closed because i can see it becoming an argument over jathebandis .. heres a quote to show wot i mean ************************************** Taksal is always been a sexist jathebandie. They are against bibian doing any seva. They always argue against bibian doing seva in Panj Pyares. Sant samaj lets not even go there. I think SS needs an internal affairs division to investigate all the cases of rape, corruption, sants fighting over deras....... ************************************** [%sig%]

Re: Taksal Against Kirtan by Women in Darbar Sahib

Yes Bibi Ji you may do Kirtan · 19 Aug 2005

Currently the taksal has a very bad image in the Khalsa Panth i think this is due to them and most sant deras following bipran ki reet and Guru Sahib will never help a Sikh if he/she follows bipran ki reet. There is no good reason why bibian shouldnt be allowed to do kirtan at Darbar Sahib. Not letting them do kirtan is probablly some maryada started when Gurdwaras were in the hands of mahants and many dera wale keep following these stupid rules. May Guru Sahib put an end to this following of bipran ki reet and show them the true path of Gurmat

Re: Taksal Against Kirtan by Women in Darbar Sahib

G.KAUR · 19 Aug 2005

Taksal is an outdated jatha that has no room in the western world. Have a look at its activities, its dominated by men with no women in sight!! These pindo types lack direction and their thoughts are fast becoming a joke, that are not even funny anymore. THURA SOCH LAYEO: who prepares the BHOJHAN? who brings up the child? Who works all day at work and then also at home. and the Bibian still love doing the Keertan while you dream of implementing your dera daary rehat. May Guru Ji bless all Bibian and our brothers [who stand shoulder to shoulder] with strength. And if the other brothers cant say anything encouraging, why dont you go and help your sister/wife in the kitchen. NEED I SAY MORE? JAA KAPAT HOR KORONI??? [%sig%]

Re: Taksal Against Kirtan by Women in Darbar Sahib

AKJ 47 · 19 Aug 2005

This Her-prat character always seems to be on this forum splilling out his hate towards the Tapoban Singhs and companions!! Who are you? Where are you from? Do you have a problem, did you know that a problem shared may help towards a good night sleep. Please let the Sangat help, as your condition seems to be getting worse. Did you know that there is ALWAYS A CURE!!! [%sig%]

Re: Taksal Against Kirtan by Women in Darbar Sahib

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 19 Aug 2005

dear heallow ji, I am fascinated by your logic... is the "jathebandi" per se..or the "subjects" per se that cause these so called "jathebandi conflicts" ? Why ?? Subject: Raagmaala...."jathebandee conflict as soon as discussion begins.. Subject: Women....Jathebandee conflict begins as soon as discussion begins Subject: Rehrass -long or short...leads to conflict subject: even a subject like Taksali kirpan or not leads to conflict.. Subject: Maryada..direct from Guur Gobind Singh ji..leads to conflict subject: Sants are vital to sikhee..leads to conflict Subject: Dhaarna are parchaar..leads to conflict Subject:Taksaals claim direct lineage to Guur Ji..conflict material IF we "KILL and BURY" all the above "subjects"..there will be NO "jathebandee conflict" ...RIGHT ?? Yes ?? BUT then WHAT remains ?? if there is NOTHING to be discussed. IN Some countries they have a TADA or Law that "NOTHING SENSITIVE" must bediscussed ( the Govt decides what is sensitive)..so even if the Govt says discussion of the height of "Speed humps" on highways ( to slow down vehicles) is ANTI-NATIONAL..a THREAT to NATIONAL SECURITY ?/ then no one cans discuss this.. Perfect. IMHO...many think this way. BAN ALL DISCUSSION..then there will be PEACE and NO CONFLICTS (between jathebandees !!) What a UTOPIA ?? IF GURU NANAK Jithought that way He would NEVER say NO to wearing the Janeau, Sardhs, he would have gone on learnign from the Pandit, He wouldnt have Taught SIKHEE at all ..because that brought about JATHEBNDEE CONFLICT...between HINDUS and SIKHS !! SILENCE is NOT GOLDEN...NO WAY. WRONGS have to be exposed...and "jathebandees" should know that...and CORRECT the wrongs.

Re: Taksal Against Kirtan by Women in Darbar Sahib

confused · 19 Aug 2005

but we as a equal religion should know that women doing keertan or any seva or anything is not something that needs to even be discussed our Guru's told us to treat them equal to our brothers as they are our sisters so they should be given righhts any jatha that has a problem with that isnt properly considering bani and philosphy

Re: Taksal Against Kirtan by Women in Darbar Sahib

*** · 19 Aug 2005

>>"Ever since Harmander Sahib was built no bibi has done kirtan there. Even in the times of the gurus. Do u think that Guru Ji overlooked or forgot about bibian all those years? think about it. Its just not meant to be."<< >>>"Oh yeah? I suppose you have a personal record of everyone who's done keertan there? If Guru Jee had wanted bibian banned from doing keertan there, do you think they would have overlooked or forgotten to mention this little fact to the sikhs?"<<< I cant blve u guys r sayin this. Guru ji had forgotten or remembered this IF HE had thot tht bibia are any less than singhs or are any different from singhs. Guru sahib created one khalsa lets not forget tht here. Guru sahib did not need to overlook or mention any 'facts'. [%sig%]

Re: Taksal Against Kirtan by Women in Darbar Sahib

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 20 Aug 2005

WHO IS THE VERY FIRST SIKH..... BIBI NANAKI JI.... THE SISTER OF GURU NANAK JI SAHIB.... SHAME ON THOSE WHO NOW TURN AROUND AND TELL US BIBIAN ARE NOT GOOD ENOUGH FOR THIS AND THAT !!! but they are obviously good enough to cook for them, wash their clothes, and do sewa....of all kinds...except sewa of GURU JI. WHERE WERE THESE TAKSALIS BAABAS AND SIKH CLERGY WHEN BIBI NANAKI WAS SHOWING HER TOTAL FAITH IN HER BROTHER AS AAP NIRANKAAR !! BIBIS ARE HALF OUR POPULATION.. ONLY FOOLS "DISEMPOWER HALF THEIR FAUJ ....ESPECIALLY WHEN GURU JI HIMSELF EMPOWERED THEM AS EQUALS IN EVERYTHING.

Re: Taksal Against Kirtan by Women in Darbar Sahib

Niranjan Singh · 20 Aug 2005

"someone" stated : >>>Ever since Harmander Sahib was built no bibi has done kirtan there. >>>Even in the times of the gurus. Do u think that Guru Ji overlooked or >>>forgot about bibian all those years? think about it. Its just not meant to >>>be. This is NOT true. Under the aegis of Jathedar Baba Nihal Singh Ji, Tarna Dal, Harianvelan, Amritdhari American Sikh Bibis performed Kirtan at Sri Darbar Sahib in the late 1970's. The "SGPC" Mahants attempted to stop them, but the Nihang Singhs protected the Kirtani Bibis and allowed them to do Kirtan Seva inside Sri Darbar Sahib. So to state that Bibis have never done Kirtan there is obsolutely misleading. This has all been documented on SikhNet.com.

Re: Taksal Against Kirtan by Women in Darbar Sahib

Samandip Singh · 20 Aug 2005

so its been 65 years since the law was passed by the SGPC that bibian are allowed to kirtan in Harimander Sahib. In the past 65 years the SGPC hasnt been able to create a jatha of bibis who will do kirtan. 65 years is a long time guys. Wat or who could be holding back a jatha of bibian from doing kirtan in Harimander Sahib for this long? If there is someone then lets see who... If not than well seems to me that guru ji will make it how they wish it to be.

Re: Taksal Against Kirtan by Women in Darbar Sahib

A S · 20 Aug 2005

God created men and women equal. This shouldn't even be an issue. If the Amritdhari Bibian can perform Kirtan properly, then they should be allowed too. It's simply sexism if they aren't allowed too. Can somebody please give a logical reason as to why some are saying that women can't do Kirtan?

Re: Taksal Against Kirtan by Women in Darbar Sahib

Bhopinder Singh · 21 Aug 2005

Nothing wrong with anyone except Sikh women. T hey are getting so much Hinduised that they are forgetting who they are . Mai Bhago one of their ancestors can they stand in front of her.No opposing attitude. How could this happen to them? There should have been no such law had they stood up to this bigotry.Oh they are aping the fellow womenfolk. They should stop marrying these people opposed to their freedom stop giving birth to men only women ,stop cooking like slave for these men and their groups. Lets see how far they could go without them.

Re: Taksal Against Kirtan by Women in Darbar Sahib

Me · 21 Aug 2005

A Singh, what the hell is a Nanaksar family? What your family gossips about says nothing about the maryada of that jatha, your family did not tell Baba Nand Singh Jee what to implement in Nanaksar, so take your narrow minded view elsewhere, Ive never heard of anything so ridiculous.

Re: Taksal Against Kirtan by Women in Darbar Sahib

A Singh · 22 Aug 2005

Dear "Me" Perhaps you need to calm down - I am not talking about Baba Nand Singh - who I hold in extreme high regard. I am talking about the practices within the Institution of Nanaksar, as it stands today - likewise with the Taksal TODAY!!! This may be a hard thing for you to digest, but presumably by your logic, the accusation of rape and peodhilia levelled against various modern Nanaksar Babas are also, by YOUR NARROW MINDED view accussing Sant Baba Nand Singh Jee of the same!!! Please grow up and stop being so reactive - the fact is that Pati-Parmeasur is pratised within many Sikh households, whether they say it openly or not, and the fact remains that the modern DDT have even written it into their Rehitnama! This what we are discussing NOT having a dig at any personality or group. Gur Fateh! A Singh.

Re: Taksal Against Kirtan by Women in Darbar Sahib

Harpartap Singh · 22 Aug 2005

'AKJ 47' - whats with the name calling? (if its directed at me) Everybody knows who I am and where I am from - more than can be said for you! And for the record I do not have hatred towards so called 'Tapoban Singhs' - you can ask some of the local ones who live very close to me in East London :o) Disagreeing with anothers belief's does not mean emotions like hate enter the equation.

Re: Taksal Against Kirtan by Women in Darbar Sahib

RoopKaur · 22 Aug 2005

While I agree that rehitvaan bibiaa should be allowed to do keertan at Harimander sahib, perhaps we as a panth should do parchol of why this has occured, why bibiaa are inferior in the Sikh panth. I think that women, if they want equal rights, must also accept equal responsibilities. Right now, half of the panth has been decrowned, while Singhs walk around with dastaaraa, Singhneeaa have lost this gift of a dastaar, which was given to them from dashmesh pita Sri Guru Gobind Singh Ji. Same with bana, guru ji bakhshed his fauj with a seperate banaa, yet women still wear suits that have hindu and muslim origins. I think it is very important right now for the Sikh panth to focus on re-estblishing half the fauj which, for some reason or other, has been decrowned and inferiorised, and get them back into chardi kalaa and a tyaar bar tyaar state. Imagine the force the panth would have if it was fighting with both hands, instead of just one.

Re: Taksal Against Kirtan by Women in Darbar Sahib

Me · 22 Aug 2005

A pathetic attempt at replying to my post A Singh, but then again I expected no less from you, you mentioned Nanaksar promoting the concept and that is an institution which represents Babaji, end of story, if your family and other messed up people start up their own ideas and concepts then you cannot blame that on Nanaksar, so do not use that term, simple. I think you are more narrow minded as you use the names of Jatha's who have promoted Sikhi in a pointless discussion to score points. Absolutely pathetic.

Re: Taksal Against Kirtan by Women in Darbar Sahib

Harjas Kaur · 23 Aug 2005

"Imagine the force the panth would have if it was fighting with both hands, instead of just one." Well said. These outmoded Hindu and Muslim attitudes about women have got to end. They are oppressing half the world! If they do not, then in this kaliyug will the Sikhs be any different? If we can't liberate our own mothers, wives, sisters and daughters from oppressive, degrading and unjust practices, we will never be liberated from anything at all. If the woman who gives birth to your son is this inferior, degraded creature without voice, without value, a low and unworthy sudra who dares not do even sewa or kirtan for Guruji because she is an unclean animal who inflames the lower passions of men, then what can your son ever hope to be? And what are you who are born from this woman? Without dignity for each other, everyone is degraded. Those with mentality of slaves will never be rulers of anything. Raj Karega Khalsa!

Re: Taksal Against Kirtan by Women in Darbar Sahib

Harjas Kaur · 23 Aug 2005

Why are Sikh women unworthy to sing and to serve in the presence of their Guru/liberator? Are Sikh women as crippled as others by the attitudes of their men? "From women born, shaped in the womb betrothed and wed; We are bound to women by ties of affection, on women man's future depends. If one woman dies he seeks another; with a woman he orders his life. Why then should one speak evil of women, they who give birth to kings?" (Guru Granth Sahib, page 473, Asa Ki Var 19:2, by Guru Nanak) [%sig%]

Re: Taksal Against Kirtan by Women in Darbar Sahib

MB Singh · 25 Aug 2005

But I have some and want some clarifications. No. 1 If a point is supported by some persons who cannot defend it with logic that does not mean they are wrong and the point they support is wrong. No. 2 Insisting on "Kirtan by men only at Harminder" does not mean one is showing disrespect to his/her mother and womenhood. No. 3 Insisting on "Kirtan by Women at Harminder" does mean one wants to break a Maryada (may be for the betterment of his/er community) and S/He has poor concern for Maryada. No 4 There are so many historic Gurdwaras as well. There are no regular Women Ragi Jathas doing kirtan there. If we have those jathas; let us start giving them Kirtan Job there. If they are successful there and no negative feedback is reported; then their duties at Harminder Sahib needs to be debated or discussed. Strange is the situation; we have no women jatha ready/competant for the job and we want to prove (rather demonstrate) "men women equal theory" at Harminder Sahib. Your "eagerness" weakens your case. More points only if Sangat allows.

Re: Taksal Against Kirtan by Women in Darbar Sahib

Harjas Kaur · 25 Aug 2005

[quote]Strange is the situation; we have no women jatha ready/competant for the job and we want to prove (rather demonstrate) "men women equal theory" at Harminder Sahib.[/quote] Traditionally in many countries women were discouraged from learning to read and kept ignorant and exploitable. Now in more advanced countries women are rocket scientists, engineers, physicists. Women fly airplanes. Women perform successful surgeries. Women get nominated for the Nobel Prize. Equality means you promote an environment welcoming to women so they aren't disadvantaged by lack of opportunity, or prevented because no one ever let them learn. [%sig%]

Re: Taksal Against Kirtan by Women in Darbar Sahib

Harjas Kaur · 25 Aug 2005

[quote]"Insisting on "Kirtan by Women at Harminder" does mean one wants to break a Maryada"[/quote] Oh really? Can you prove this with citations please? Maryada says: [quote]"In the congregation, there should be no differentiation or discrimination between Sikh and non-Sikh, persons traditionally regarded as touchable and untouchable, the so called high and low caste persons, the high and the low." "All human beings, high or low, and of any caste or colour may sit and eat in the Guru's kitchen-cum-eating house. No discrimination on grounds of the country of origin, colour, caste or religion must be made while making people sit in rows for eating. However, only baptized Sikhs can eat off one plate." "At the place where ambrosial baptism is to be administered, the holy Guru Granth Sahib should be installed and ceremonially opened. Also present should be six committed baptized Sikhs, one of whom should sit in attendance of the Guru Granth Sahib and the other five should be there to administer the ambrosial baptism. These six may even include Sikh women."[/quote] So why are we discriminating against amritdharee women over simple things like sewa and kirtan?

Re: Taksal Against Kirtan by Women in Darbar Sahib

dont know · 25 Aug 2005

http://www.sgpc.net/rehat_maryada/section_six.html this is where u got that from and this is something else in it a. The Japu, the Jaapu and the Ten Sawayyas (Quartets) - beginning "Sarwag sudh"-- in the morning. and it also says this in the sgpc maryada didnt guru ji tell us to do panj bani in the morning no one is discrimnating but if u guys truely believe what u do then go ahead and do what u want in the end when we die we all get our answers

Re: Taksal Against Kirtan by Women in Darbar Sahib

Sad Kaur · 26 Aug 2005

My heart is broken reading this thread. What is happening? [%sig%]

Re: Taksal Against Kirtan by Women in Darbar Sahib

MB Singh · 29 Aug 2005

Sad Kaur, please, do not be sad. Do not take it to heart. Sikh ladies are not kids; who get offended "mid-way a discussion." I am most humble, with my arguments. Harjas Kaur Ji, regarding your two reactions to my mail, No. 4 point. It is true that we have no regular women Jathas (in general) for any Gurdwara. Please agree with me. What I wanted to say is that Sri Harminder Sahib should not be used as a "place for experimentation". Men Ragi Jathas get posted at Harminder only after a proven expertize. No 3 point. By Maryada, I simply mean, the tradition at Harminder Sahib. No further explanation. No. 5. Gursikh (Bibi Jagir Kaur) who is recommending the change of maryada is much less respectable than Gursikh (Bhai Ranjit Singh) who is opposing the change. I know that this type of logic should not be given much weightage in a discussion, but please consider it.

Re: Taksal Against Kirtan by Women in Darbar Sahib

singh · 29 Aug 2005

[%sig%]

Re: Taksal Against Kirtan by Women in Darbar Sahib

MB Singh · 01 Sep 2005

No. 6 Demand for Kirtan by Women In Harminder Sahib has come up during those decades; when the number of rehat maryada followers have decreased (in general) and patitism (% age of patit sikhs) has increased in sikh community. Women as well as men on this planet have progressed in materialism but lost in spiritulism. (Every body talks like that) I do not find courage to say that these things are related but the facts are before us.

Re: Taksal Against Kirtan by Women in Darbar Sahib

MB Singh · 06 Sep 2005

No 7 A seminar was once organised by Voices for freedom. The bibi, crusader, for women sewa, attended that. Before the start of seminar; I contacted the Bibi and asked her that the cup of tea she was sipping (at that time) was prepared by a waiter who is a tobaco smoker. And "You are leading the movement for a change in Maryada but personally you are bothering little about an important aspect of Sikh Rehat". Before she was ready with the answer, her BABA type fellows dubbed me the mischief maker and I silented myself considering them an illetrate group. Interestinly, in that seminar Mr Atinder Singh (Ex MP) said in his speech that women should lead in "two out of four" lavan during marriage ceremonies. Nevertheless, the Bibi seems humble, intelligent and honest in her intentions.

Re: Taksal Against Kirtan by Women in Darbar Sahib

Harjas Kaur · 06 Sep 2005

MB Singh, your prejudice against females is so amazing to me. You compare women performing Kirtan at Darbar Sahib to: 1. A woman who drinks tea from a tobacco smoker 2. A demand arisen in sinful decades associated with increase in patit Sikhs and anti-spiritual materialism. 3. Against Sikh traditions 4. Some kind of undesirable experimentation 5. Solely associated with Jagir Kaur ----------------------------------------- There is little point in this discussion because you do not even seem to be aware how you offend women, or perceive them as unclean, undesirable, and spiritually corrupting influence. Maybe it should occur to you that also in this evil era, women have more freedom not to be given off in marriage to strangers as children, not to be kept illiterate, used, manipulated, not to simply have babies, and then be discarded. Although anywhere in the world where you see success, there is also untold misery and debasement of women. The world has only a glimmer of the good that can be done by loving and respecting the worth of human beings, male AND female. Women in this era are better educated and give a gift to the world of their humaneness, their compassion, their wisdom, their caring feminine spirit. they are benefactors of large business interests, attorneys, judges, executives, military officers, doctors, nurses, politicians, physicists, teachers, even astronauts. Why should a women be less? It's amazing what women can do given an opportunity with respect and encouragement. Not only is this an evil era, but there have been some wonderful and heroic people too. Who are these women nurses on battlefields all over the world fighting desperately to save lives? Who are the Red Cross Nurses and Volunteers who rush into disasters? Who are the female paramedics and policewomen who put themselves in harms way responding to emergencies? Do you dare condemn all these people? Do you dare devalue us all? Maybe in this evil era the something troubling about women is the way they are treated as second class citizens in the Khalsa Panth. Not worthy to become Panj Pyare. There are women university professors of Biochemistry and Mathematics, Medicine and Engineering. But where are the women Gyanis? Stop cutting your arms off! We are one half of you, and for the most part, the calmer, more sensitive half. We have more than you can imagine of good things to offer. Stop seeing only evil or worthlessness about women! It's sad that "worldly" women have more dignity, power and authority than we do as Amritdharee women. They are Olympic athletes. They are world-class musicians. They run operating rooms, courtrooms and governments. Their voices are heard. They are respected. They give orders. They save lives. We cannot even play kirtan in Darbar Sahib. [%sig%]

Re: Taksal Against Kirtan by Women in Darbar Sahib

search for tat · 06 Sep 2005

AKJ has always allowed women to do kirtan and seva on an equal level. Even positions in AKJ UK committee such as stage secretary have been held by bibian. Nothing has ever happened to AKJ, it is in Chardi Kala! Why is Taksal so scared if a woman does keertan?

Re: Taksal Against Kirtan by Women in Darbar Sahib

Guru Da Kookar · 06 Sep 2005

Please do have time to read this, it is not against anyone it is a ik dukhi and nimane gurughar de Kookar dee pukaar, Guru Payree Sadh Sangat Jio, Waheguru jee ka Khalsa, Waheguru jee kee Fateh, From past so many days I am going through this forum and found that nobody is sincere about Sikhism except for one or two. Everyone is more concerned about the their own jethebandies, deras, babas,sants,etc,etc............ Payree Sangat jio, it is may humble request to all of you that it will be better for Sikhism and for everyone of us if we try to become the Sikhs of only and only Guru Nanak and do not follow any of the other sects,deras,and sant babas as Gurujee has asked the whole Sikh panth to bow and follow the teaching of only and only Guru Granth Sahib and not anyone else irrespective of so called bramhgayani, and sant babas. We being the Sikhs are follower of Shabad Guru and not of any living guru or any of pseudo sant babas. In my opion the todays conditions of Sikhism is lot depending on that we are ignoring the Guru's teaching and started following Manat ( or in other word you can say "Biprin ke Reet") Jab lag khalsa rahe Niara tab lag tej deioon main sara, Jab eh gahe Biprin kee reet main na karoo inki parteet. I think as a whole we all the Khalsa panth had started following this Biprin ke reet only and lost the Parteet of our Guru Pita and now coz of that only we are facing these kinds of problems and we( khalsa panth) will keep on facing these problems and lot more till we return to our home( Gurughar). Khawaar hoe sab milege ............................Don't know how much more khawarry( disrespect) we want. Most of the time not only in this forum,in general day to day life also most of us belongs to some or the other Babas,Sants, Deras, Jathebandies etc...etc.....I wonder is there any Sikh of Guru Nanak here. Everyone try to prove there babas by hook or crook and by doing this sometime they knowing or unknowing point a finger on Guru Sahib also to prove their babas,sant,dera,jathebandi...etc,etc. and never think that in this world there are only two who can be right and no one else. Bhulan andhar sab ko Abhul Guru Kartar............ So I can say or it is my dono hath jorr ke aap sab de charna wich benti hai ke, Aao sarre ral ke Ajj "Prann" keria ke ajj to badh we will try to become Sikhs only of Guru Nanak jee and not of anyone else whether irrsective of any jathedar,bramgayani, sant,baba etc .....etc.......and their also are human being and they can be wrong no doubt and I think by doing this only we will be able to show our face to our Guru Sahibaan. Now we have only one Guru i.e., Guru Granth Sahib and no one else. We should stop fighting between us on any matter as we can ask our Guru for any kind of help and for any clarification as there is no one Supreme than the Guru( Guru Granth Sahib) and no one can have the doubt on Guru jee's decision. We can use Guru jee's decision as Kaswati so that there is no one to have doubt on it. Days long back one Veer told me that a Sikh would have so much faith on Guru Granth Sahib that if some day Guru Nanak himself appears before the Sikh and say him to bow before himself ( now please don't make this issue that Guru Nanak had never said to any one and will never say to anyone to bow before himself, just imagination), it is Sikh's duty to say to Guru Nanak that " Na Baba, tusi hee tan Daswein Jame wich eh condition layee see ke ajj ton badh siwae Guru Granth Sahib de kise agge vee Sirr nahi jhukana( not bow before anyone other than Guru Granth Sahib) Aa Baba agar tusi hee Guru Nanak ho tan Aa apan dowein hee Guru Granth Sahib noo metha takie. It is generally said in day to day life that if some has more than one father he is called as .......................you all know, so no need to write. Ajj agar asee apane ander jhattie mar ke veikhia ke Sade Sikh akhwaon walian noo tan ik pita( Guru Granth Sahib) de larr laya see te asee kine bap( father) bana laye han what is our conditon today............................and what will we be called off ......... In the last I can only pray.............. Hey Sache Pita Waheguru apni is kaum no Sumat bakhish te bibek budh bakhish tan ke asi Sache Sikh Akhwa sakie te sanu tere darbar wich shirminda na hona pawe...........................Waheguru bhali kare te asi apas which larno hat jayei............ Please forgive if knowingly or unknowingly hurt someones feeling. Bhul chuck de Khima App sab da shotta Veer. Waheguru jee ka khalsa. Waheguru jee kee Fateh. [%sig%]

Re: Taksal Against Kirtan by Women in Darbar Sahib

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 06 Sep 2005

I was flabbergasted to read the following Comment from Ranjit Singh Former Jathedar Akal takhat.. "Have you all looked at Bibi Jagir kaur's LIBAAS...she looks like a CORPSE looking out from a KHAFFANN...do you want such MURDEY to perform Kirtan and panj Piayara sewa ?? With such types as Jathedars who needs advanis and bjp/rss ??

Re: Taksal Against Kirtan by Women in Darbar Sahib

A Singh · 07 Sep 2005

"Me" <> Thanks for your reply - I have no needs to "score points", I belong to no Jatha or Institution other than the Khalsa Panth. Yes, I frequent both the Taksal and Nanaksar affiliated Gurdwaras for obvious reasons, but what unfortunately these are no longer the pristine Gurmat inspired movements that they once wore - for that matter nothing really is - its the natural course of events in this age. Anyway, the point is concerning the practice of Pati Parmeasur within Sikh households and institutions, which neither YOU or ANYONE else has cared to discussed - so I'll assume that whilst all the raving about Keskis and wearing Cholas with no pyjamas goes on, we all consider it fine at the end of the day for a Singhni to WORSHIP her husband as GOD???!!!! Nice one...

Re: Taksal Against Kirtan by Women in Darbar Sahib

Harjas Kaur · 07 Sep 2005

[quote] we all consider it fine at the end of the day for a Singhni to WORSHIP her husband as GOD???!!!![/quote] All? Speak for yourself. I don't know anyone who does this. [quote]With such types as Jathedars who needs advanis and bjp/rss ??[/quote] Yes this is very sad. It is blatantly self-destructive to the entire Khalsa Panth. We really do need reform of Sikh institutions so the entire Panth is in chardi kala and shows a face of Sikhi the whole world can respect! [%sig%]

Re: Taksal Against Kirtan by Women in Darbar Sahib

MB Singh · 12 Sep 2005

Bhein Harjas Kaur I am very sorry, that inspite of my very careful handling of the topic, I seem to offend women in my arguments. I had never meant that and never said that. Being a research worker in profession, I have developed the habit of a thorough analysis and only careful conclusions. Considering your reaction to my points; I feel that I should not proceed further, because it is offending you and I am being misunderstood. But I must be given the chance for appeal. Your judgements are only partially correct about my views. Harjas Kaur, believe me; I am serious; Women are great , great and great but her greatness does not lie in her material persuits and achievements. Her greatness is not shown by her achievements written by you. "Those achievements" at the most; equal her to man. She is much ahead of man in her greatness. After God; she cares the humanity. Her motherly character is not enough to sing her praises. She is "God of the intellectuals". Please read Prof Puran Singh in his book "Spirit Born People" under the chapter "Nam Simran, Woman and Bread". I invite you on the topic, after you have read him. MB Singh

Re: Taksal Against Kirtan by Women in Darbar Sahib

*** · 15 Sep 2005

The exact title of the chapter in the book " The spirit born people" is "Bread, Woman, Guru"

Re: Taksal Against Kirtan by Women in Darbar Sahib

MB Singh · 15 Sep 2005

The comments of Bhai Ranjit Singh Ji, Former Jathedar; seem to be harsh; but there is some substance in those, because those are based on the knowledge of cruel character of Bibi Jagir Kaur. Bibi is certainly envolved in the killing of her daughter. Wearing white and covering the head is not enough to make one a good Gursikh. Guru Nanak Sahib has very clearly criticized and rejected the people who wear white, try to look religious but are "Sajan Thhags" in character. A man who spent his prime life in jail, for the common cause of the community; deserves our respect. The way he was shown the way from Sri Akal Takhat by Badal and Bibi party; has hurt his psyche. His style of comments/lanuage may be his weakness; but afterall he is the man who------". Guru Gobind Singh Ji in Chandi Di Vaar; praises the "Devil named Mehkhasar" for his fighting arts in the battlefield. On the other hand, we Sikhs have little respect for our own heros. Bhul Chuk Maaf.