Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Reliability of the Bhatt Vahi accounts

Reliability of the Bhatt Vahi accounts

Khalsa Soulja · 06 Oct 2003

Alot of people refer to the Bhatt Vahi accounts when talking about how keski is a kakkar (i believe it is a kakkar btw but since reading this my doubts have grown a little) http://www.sikhreview.org/february2001/chronicle.htm http://www.sikhreview.org/march2001/chronicle.htm those are the two parts it names keski as a kakkar, but the account was actually orally past down before written, and it also says that guru ji did not behead the panj, but he asked the panj to kill 5 goats. Can someone please explain this This leaves one other bhatt vahi account which was not a contemporary account. Other than bhai chaupa singhs rehatnama what other sources say keski is a kakkar explictly? i have heard there are other bhatt vahi accounts but im unsure. WJKK WJKF

Re: Reliability of the Bhatt Vahi accounts

Balpreet Singh · 06 Oct 2003

The article says nothing about anything oral. It says "Kaushish is said to have based the text of his book on the information found recorded in the Bhatt Vahis (scrolls of the traditional family bards) written by his ancestors and preserved in the family for their usual reference and record." So Where today are these records? Who knows frankly, and who has made any attempt to find them? Piara Singh Padam was one of the best known scholars in the Panth and he found this account and was stunned by how authentic it was. In the Panth we have very few scholars who have gone to find our historical documents. Whatever we have is just by luck. We can not even trace the original saroops of Sree Guru Granth Sahib jee that were prepared by Baba Deep Singh jee and Bhai Mani Singh jee. Perhaps the Bhat Vehis do exist but we havn't found them, and I'm not so sure we'd even be able to recognise them anymore because of the differnet language. As for the account of Guru Sahib asking each Pyara to behead a goat: the writer himself says this happened in the tent. Of course he himself was not in there with them. He has made a guess just like other writers have made a guess as to what might have happened. Whether we agree with his guess is irrelevant. >>>> This leaves one other bhatt vahi account which was not a contemporary account. >>>> Which one is this? Other sources where I've seen keskee mentioned is the Sau Sakhi where a line appears that means the sign of a Sikh is a keskee on the head. I don't have the book with me, but I've highlighted the passage. At any rate, all agree that this account by Sarup Singh was written by 1790 (even if someone decides they wont' believe he based it on his family's written records). That still pre-dates Bhai Sahib Randheer Singh jee by 150 years. Clearly the concept of keskee as a kakaar is not "new" as many people try to make it out to be. Sarup Singh having written this in 1790 was only one generation removed from Guru Gobind Singh jee's time. The question of "passing down" really isn't relevant because it would be the equivalent of one of us asking our grandfathers or people of that generation what happened exactly.

Re: Reliability of the Bhatt Vahi accounts

Khalsa Soulja · 06 Oct 2003

WJKK WJKF Thanks for clearing that up When I look at whether keski is a kakkar or not I used to be 100percent sure it was because I assumed that Bhatt Sarup Singh was a eyewitness of Vaisakhi......but now I dont know, I dont understand why so many Bhai Nand Lal, Bhai Prahlad Singh, Bhai Daya Singh rehatnamas would mention Kesh as a kakkar.......maybe someone could enlighten me more....... WJKK WJKF

Re: Reliability of the Bhatt Vahi accounts

Balpreet Singh · 06 Oct 2003

I've gone through the Bhai Daya Singh and the Bhai Nand Lal rehitnamas, and I have never seen the term "kakaar" used anywhere. Perhaps you could give me a reference?

Re: Reliability of the Bhatt Vahi accounts

Khalsa Soulja · 07 Oct 2003

cOpeI] k`C kys kMGw ikrpwn[ kVw AOr jo kro bKwn[ ieh k`ky pMj qum mwno[ gurU gRMQ ko qum sB jwno]39] -- Rehatnama Bhai Prahlad Singh Ji i cant give references 2 to the others but im sure they exist, the bhai daya singh 1 is a bit more rare tho.

Re: Reliability of the Bhatt Vahi accounts

Balpreet Singh · 07 Oct 2003

I was aware of the Bhai Prehald Singh reference, and had asked for the Bhai Daya Singh and Bhai Nand Lal one. I'm quite sure neither one even refers to the term "kakaar". Khalsa Soulja, I have some advice for you that has helped me quite a bit: don't listen passively to what others say. Go find out for yourself. The Bhai Daya Singh rehitnama is not "rare" at all, it's found in pretty much any Sikh library in the book on rehitnamas by Piara Singh Padam or the one published by Chatter Singh Jeevan Singh. Don't just accept something once someone has said it ie. "Bhai Daya Singh rehitnama and Bhai Nand Lal mention kes as a kakaar". Go check it out and I'm pretty sure you'll find it's not true (unless I've missed it in my checks). Kakaars are mentioned by Prehalad Singh and by Chaupa Singh. Chaupa Singh mentions keskee as a kakaar. Beyond that, I don't recall any mentions of the word "kakaar" anywhere. But again, do your own research.

Re: Reliability of the Bhatt Vahi accounts

Khalsa Soulja · 07 Oct 2003

i have read books which gave references to bhai nand lal rehatnamas mentioning kesh in the footnotes. as for hte bhai daya singh one......are u saying it does or doesnt exist if its not rare? unfortunately i cant read punjabi script fluently so it takes me aaaages to work out what books say, thus i have to rely on english stuff :(.

Re: Reliability of the Bhatt Vahi accounts

Gabroo Khalistan Dah · 07 Oct 2003

omfg, i think if u believe in kesh or keski as a kakkar is very irrelevant to ones sikhi..........as long as u don't go extreem and say the the kakkars are not needed so stop this macho bs

Re: Reliability of the Bhatt Vahi accounts

Khalsa Soulja · 07 Oct 2003

its a big thing. what was said on the vaisakhi is VERY important. either the kesh or keski believers have changed the rehat, and one of them is wrong........so i am trying to find out which one........its hardly macho bs...... anyway "confu singh" posted the following questions on this account 1. The date of Vaisakhi is referred to as 1755 BK not 1756 as is mentioned in other sources and now generally accepted - is this a mistake? 2. No reference is made to Guru Gobind Singh ji asking teh Panj Piare for Amrit. 3. Guru Gobind Singh asked each of the Panj Piare to behead a he-goat! (I found it very hard to believe that any follower of Bhai Randheer Singh ji would agree with this assertion) 4. That the patase were put in the Amrit by Guru Gobind Singh ji's grandmother. 5. The fact is that the present date document is a copy of a copy and mistakes/omissions may have taken place at any of these stages of writing. But because the original and its first copy are missing, this will never be known (if they ever existed). In light of the above, it seems very hard to sustain the argument that the document which is referred to in support of keski has come down unchanged and is a reliable source.

Re: Reliability of the Bhatt Vahi accounts

Balpreet Singh · 07 Oct 2003

Khalsa Soulja, Let me repeat, the Bhai Nand Lal rehitnama does not so much as mention the word "kakaars", so how does it support kes? The Bhai Daya Singh rehitnama is very easily available and it too mentions nothing about "kakaars". re. the questions by 'confu' singh: 1) Where exactly is 1755 mentioned...please point me to that date. I haven't been able to find it myself. 2) You're basing the fact that the sakheean don't mention Guru Sahib didn't ask for amrit on teh basis of an internet article on these sakheeaan. I once had this book but not right now, and I will check wether this comes up in the subsequent sakhi. Even if it doesn't come up, is it not true that this account is BY FAR the most authentic seeming one? 3) I already said that the author admits he wasn't in the tent and it's his guess that this happened. His guess is really just that....a guess. He doesn't claim to have witnessed this. No one knows what happened in the tent that day. 4) Again, I think my reading skills are deteriorating or someone's trying to make up "facts". The account says the respected mata jee added the pataasaas. Last time I checked, Mata Jeeto jee was also called "respected mother". The article said ANOTHER account claimed the Mata Nanaki jee did this, not the Bhat Vehee. 5) I've said this before and I'll say it again: find me the original of any rehitnama. Pick one and find me the original. You can't do it because they just don't exist. If you want to insist on originals, you can't find any. You cannot trace the original Damdami BeeR...so should we also doubt it as well? Overall, this account and the one still not discussed ie. the more common account that you'll find in the keskee article calling it "kesgee" match eachother pretty closely and are closest to the version we believe in today. I repeat though, go and do your own research. Don't get confused by people like "confu singh" who're going to distort facts by their own mis-reading and malicious interpolation.

Re: Reliability of the Bhatt Vahi accounts

Gabroo Khalistan Dah · 08 Oct 2003

HOW DOES THIS HELP UR SIKHI? in what u belive, u wear both so why the fuss? juss so u can prove ur self better then the toher"?

Re: Reliability of the Bhatt Vahi accounts

Mr Rice Pudding · 08 Oct 2003

Sarbloh Granth and Guru Ji's written letter to the sanget of Kabul both reveal Kesh as Kekar, I have no doubt that these are 100% geniune although I am sure some may beg to differ. Can anyone please show where in any of Guru's Bani's the actual word Keski is used. I don't mean dastar but Keski with a K, and even better Keski and Khekar together. Also can any one prove that Mata Gujri and Guru Ji's wives wore Keski, as they surely would have. I have seen Puratan Portraits of AMrit 1699 and other soucres but never have I found any thing that backs that the woman in the Guru's own households wore Keski's. I could be wrong so welcome any commments. I think the Keski account is a more secoundry source of info, rather then primary especially if it was wriiten at a leter date. As for the so called line in the Sau Sakhi it does not say Keski is the Kekar, it does not even mention the word Kekar. The RehatNamah's from Bhai Nanad Lal etc also leave liitle room to think Kesh is not the Kekar.

Re: Reliability of the Bhatt Vahi accounts

Kulbir Singh · 08 Oct 2003

>>>>> Can anyone please show where in any of Guru's Bani's the actual word Keski is used. I don't mean dastar but Keski with a K, and even better Keski and Khekar together. >>>>> Rice Pudding, I don't know if you are a student of history but Bhat Vahees present a very important evidence of existence of word "keski" prior to Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee's birth. In Guru jee's baani, 5 kakaars too are not mentioned and many other rehits of Khalsa are not mentioned. It has no mention of single most important rehit i.e. abstaining from 4 kurahits. Does that mean this is not a rehit? The existence of word "Keski" in Mahaan Kosh does not prove it is a kakaar but proves this fact beyond doubt that this word was commonly used in Gursikhs and is not an invention of Akhand Kirtani Jatha as some ignorant people like us to believe. >>>>>> Also can any one prove that Mata Gujri and Guru Ji's wives wore Keski, as they surely would have. I have seen Puratan Portraits of AMrit 1699 and other soucres but never have I found any thing that backs that the woman in the Guru's own households wore Keski's. I could be wrong so welcome any commments. >>>>> Brahmiyani bibi - Mata Bhaag Kaur jee, lost consciousness of the world and had gone naked and lived in the dense jungles of Malwa. Someone told Guru Gobind Singh jee maharaaj about this. Guru Gobind Singh jee immediately brought Mata jee back into senses and gave her a very significant order. He ordered her to never remove two pieces of clothing from her body - Kachherra and Dastaar. This saakhi is a famous saakhi in Sikh panth and Kavi Santokh Singh jee has written it in his monumental work - Siri Guru Sooraj Parkaash (long before even the birth of Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee). Whether it is clear or not from this saakhi that keski is a kakaar but one thing is clear for sure and that is - Keski or dastaar is a must for us all. It is as important as a kachherra. Guru Sahib did not give her strict order to cover her upper part i.e. breast area but made it a must to wear a kachherra and a dastaar. Brahmgiyani bibi - Mata Ghulaab Kaur jee met Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee after Bhai Sahib had darshan of Vaheguru. Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee has a very emotional account of his meeting of this great Mata jee. She used to wear only kachherra and keski and covered her upper body only with a loyee (shawl). When Bhai Sahib arrived to see her, he fell at her feet but she embraced Bhai Sahib and gave him lot of asees. This mata jee was a strict sarblohi and bibeki bibi. She was greatly revered by the people in that area and it is said that Muslims revered her more than Hindus and Sikhs. She was from a Sehajdhari family but became a great Gursikh after taking amrit and adopting strict rehit of Khalsa. My belief is that enemies of Dastaar are enemies of Guru Gobind Singh jee and will be dealt with by Guru Gobind Singh jee mahaaraaj. It is possible that some gursikhs may have doubt over whether it is a kakaar or not but no gursikh should have any doubt that keski is a must for both singhs and bibiyaan. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Reliability of the Bhatt Vahi accounts

Khalsa Soulja · 08 Oct 2003

kulbir singh and balpreet singh thanks. u have removed alot of doubts from my mind. does the sarbloh granth say kesh is a kakkar? arent there doubts over the authorship of this granth or is it definately real (alot of people say the language is totally different from other bani of guru gobind singh) thanks all WJKK WJKF

Re: Reliability of the Bhatt Vahi accounts

Balpreet Singh · 08 Oct 2003

I dont' know about Sarbloh Granth, but here's what the Encyclopaedia of Sikhism says: "The authorship is however questioned by researchers and Scholars of Sikhism on several counts. First, the work is marked by extraordinary effusiveness and discursiveness of style over against the compactness characteristic of Guru Gobind Singh's composition as collected in the Dasam Granth. Qualitatively too, the poety of Sarbloh Granth does not match that of Guru Gobind Singh's Chandi Charitras and aar Durga Kee dealing with the same topic of wars between the gods and the demons. Profusion of metaphor and superb imagery of the latter compositions are missing here. Second, the author of Sarbloh Granth often uses his name, "Das Gobind" or the phrase "Das Gobind Fatah satigur ki" which is generally contrary to the style of Guru Gobind Singh. Third, the Sarbloh Granth contains, quite out of context, an account of the Sikh religion, which also includes a reference to the devolution of guruship on Guru Granth and Guru Panth (stanzas 3159-66). This would be out of place in a work of Guru Gobind Singh's own composition. Lastly, there is also a reference in it to Rup Dip Bhasha Pingal (stanza 2938/8) a work on prosody written by one Jaya Krishna in 1719, i.e. eleven years after the death of the Guru. According to Pandit Tara Singh Narotam, a nineteenth century Sikh scholar and researcher, Sarbloh Granth is the work of Bhai Sukha Singh, a granthi or priest at Takht Harimandar Sahib at Patna Sahib, who however claimed that he acquired its manuscript from an Udasi recluse living in a forest near Jagannath (Orissa)." The Encyclopaedia of Sikhism ed. Harbans Singh Punjabi University Patiala, Vol 4, pg. 57

Re: Reliability of the Bhatt Vahi accounts

Mr Rice Pudding · 09 Oct 2003

I think you will find that almost all the well known Shabads about the Khalsa which are sung in almost all Rainsbais are from the Sarbloh Granth.

Re: Reliability of the Bhatt Vahi accounts

Mr Rice Pudding · 09 Oct 2003

Kulbir Singh You have not answered even one of my questions but cleverly avoided them and tried to aviod the issue with other sakhi's which don't relate to my original questions which you highlighted. If you can answere them then please do, if not then say so, but please don't avoid the subject with other Sakhi's and Bhatts accounts as this is not what I stated. I am not an enemy of Keski if that is what you are implying, just someone trying to follow Guru Ji's sikhi which I beleive does not ever state Keski is the Kekar, and the entire Panth had confirmed that. Is the entire Panth who beleive in keeping kesh and that its thier Kekar an enemy of Sikhi, or are the enermies of Sikhi people who just don't agree with your opinion which conradicts historical facts, the Guru's own words and the Guru Khalsa Panth.

Re: Reliability of the Bhatt Vahi accounts

Kulbir Singh · 09 Oct 2003

Rice Pudding, If you cannot understand that I did answer your questions, then what can I do. You had written that Mata Gujri jee and Guru ke mehal did not wear keski. In response to that question I wrote the saakhi of Mata Bhaag Kaur jee (Mayee Bhago). That saakhi proved that Guru Sahib was very strict about dastar. The same Guru who asked Mata Bhaag Kaur to wear a dastar would not have ignored his own mehal (wife). In response to your earlier question whether Guru Sahib had used keski as a word, I gave wrote about Bhat Vahees and how this word was in existence at that time. It is of great significance to see this word in Bhat Vahees. You cannot ignore this historical fact. As for Guru Sahib not mentioning keski as a kakaar, my answer is that he has not mentioned all 5 kakaars together anywhere. Rice-pudding, please let us discuss something more constructive. You will not gain anything by trying to prove that keski is not a kakaar. Let us discuss some Gurbani pankiti instead of wasting our time on this issue. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Reliability of the Bhatt Vahi accounts

domalla premee · 10 Oct 2003

Waheguruji ka Khalsa Waheguruji ki Fateh Guru peeare, Some food for thought. All veers out there listen carefully and reflect. If dastaar has no meaning or importance and you keep your kesh intact why do you not go around bareheaded? Why do make so much noise about keeping your dastar, fighting for your right to wear it or not be discriminated for wearing it if it is bot so important in the first place? Why really do you wear it if as you seem to imply it has no place in Sikhi? If you believe in rehet of kesh then that should be sufficient. If dastar has no significance in Sikhi why do you wear one right now? Why bother? If you wear dastar what is so offensive about a woman wearing one as well? What is the big deal anyway? If anything there would be twice as many people justifying the burden of wearing it if your objections went to the wind. If one woman wins the hearts of people around her because she has the guts to wear dastar in public and the workplace then what have you lost? If anything she preserved your hard-fought right to wear it? If she breaks the barriers of prejudice in the hearts of others by maintaining her self-respect wearing it, does that not count for something? She has made your way easier by accepting all the barbs for you? The dastar is without a doubt the visiblest piece of clothing identifying a Sikh especially if that Sikh is in Western attire. Court battles are being fought over it and school curriculums revised to teach the mainstream society what it is? What is the point of all this if we put into question its role in Sikh life? Why not just keep a joora without dastar? The sacred kesh would still be just as intact. Many Hindu sadhs do. If not ask yourself what would be wrong with that picture and why. I am asking these rhetorical questions not to argue but to create a pause that everyone may reflect. These questions are a package meant to be viewed as a whole.....so see the forest and not just the trees.Why is the dastar somehow so central to the identity of the Sikh yet given so little support by so many? It is a puzzle that amazes me. My kesh are just as sacred and intact as dictated by the Guru. I don't throw mine in the trash when I comb them but keep them respectfully and perform sanskar of them when sufficient quantities build up. They mean that much to me personally. My sacred dastar I treasure and cherish. It is what my Guru wore. If is see a veerjee or a bahenjee with one how can I not help seeing a visible reminder of my Guru. How can my heart not help but leap for joy at the sight this beautiful image? My Guru has given me the dastar many years ago when I took amrit and has always protected my honor made my way in all spheres of life wearing one thoughout my Sikh lifetime. What makes you cling to yours? dass

Re: Reliability of the Bhatt Vahi accounts

M Singh · 10 Oct 2003

Kulbir singh You are free to believe in Keski if you like. You base your thinking on a very controversial rehatnamah by Bhai Chaupa Singh (to such Rehatnamah exists, one which does not mention Keski). You also use the Bhatt Vahi, although it was written generations after 1699, the original does not even exist and even Keski is spelt as Kesgi. I base my knowledge on Guru Gobind Singh Ji’s own hand written and signed letter to the Sikhs of Kabul after 1699, and the Sarbloh Granth which by the way both speak of the five K’s altogether. You may argue that these two sources are fake I disagree. Further to this I have never found anywhere Guru Gobind Singh Ji ever writing Keski nor do the rehatnamah of any other Sikh of the time equal if not more reliable then the one supposedly by Bhai Chaupa Singh. They say we should all wear a Dastar, as we should both men and woman. The question is what the 5 ks are not if we should wear a Dastar. None of the Rehatnamah say Keski is a Kekar they don’t even say the word Keski. Like I said you can believe in Keski and not Kesh if you wish, but I stand by Guru Ji’s own written facts and the decision of the Guru Khlasa Panth, which I or any other Sikh have the right to do. As for an answer to my questions you have not shown where Guru Ji has said Keski in any Hukamnah or Bani, where as kesh comes up many times. You have failed to show facts of Woman in Guru Ji’s household keeping Keski, but have spoken of Mai Bhago who we all already know wore a Dastar as she was involved in battles. You also go on and talk about a great Bibi in Bhai Randhir Singh’s time instead of answering my question.

Re: Reliability of the Bhatt Vahi accounts

Balpreet Singh · 10 Oct 2003

Why rehash the same points over and over? The Kabul Hukumnama is a FAKE! Everyone can see this just by looking at it. It's not Guru Sahib's handwriting. Either that one hukumnama is authentic and all others are fakes or this one is a very poor forgery. As for Sarbloh Granth, you havn't shown where it mentions the word "kakaar", but on top of that, there exists doubts about its authenticity as well, as is shown in the quote from the Sikh Encyclopaedia. Finally, for showing that Guru Sahib's family members wore dastaars: pleas prove to me that they did NOT wear the dastaars. When you give me proof that they didn't we'll see about giving you proof they did. Don't talk about "puraatan" paintings either, since these paintings have all been made in the time of Raja Ranjit Singh or after, and thus are total guesses. Some even give Guru Sahib an earring. Maybe that's authentic too then? What it boils down to on all of these controversial points is the same thing: The facts are there for you to see. Reach your own conclusions and stop arguing pointlessly. I will never accept that keskee is not a kakaar and I know there are others out there that will never accept that kes is not a kakaar....so why are we debating? Live and let live. If we don't agree on this point, so what? Let's move on. At least we can agree that Guru Gobind Singh is our father and Mata Sahib Kaur our mother and that makes us siblings. And that's enough for a solid relationship right there. Let's end this nonsense right here.

Re: Reliability of the Bhatt Vahi accounts

Mr Rice Pudding · 10 Oct 2003

I thought some one may try and claim the well renowned Hukamnam was a fake, suprising how people can put faith in an even more controversial Rehatnamah which may not have even be by Bhai Chupa Singh and a Bhatt Vah which does not even exist today for us to truly check, and wasn’t even written in the time of Guru Gobind Singh. To claim the Hukamnah to Kabul is a fake and assume that the only one piece of literature which says Keski is true is very convenient. When the Guru Khalsa Panth over 10 years debated taking into account all the Hukamnah and Gurbani it was decided that Kesh is the Kekar. Surely Bhai Vir Singh, Sant Teja Singh, Bhai Radhir Singh and the countless other true Gursikhs with unbelievable knowledge got it wrong is very amusing. As for the Sarbloh Granth to claim its fake means no Shabads which are commonly sung ie Rehni rehai soi Sikh Mara and countless others must be fake. By doing so is shooting yourself in the foot. As for where it mentions the five K’s I know you must have already read the composition it basically reveals what the Panj Kekar are and that Kesh is one of them. I will post the translation if you like. But I’m sure you’ll say its fake when it suits you. As for woman in Guru Ji’s household not wearing Keski, like I have said I have seen Puratan portraits which don’t show them with Keski’s. You may say these were done later on, but the Bhatt Vah was also written later on so that must well be fake also. We know for a fact that the Woman in Guru Ji’s household kept Kesh, or are you suggesting they were monai. I can’t believe it if you are implying that Mata Gujri, Mata Sahib Kaur had hair cuts so I can confidently assume they kept Kesh, however the same does not exist for Keski. Even if they did wear Dastar which may be the case it does not mean Keski is a Kekar, especially when you have completely failed in showing where Guru Ji has written the word Keski with his own hand, unlike Kesh.

Re: Reliability of the Bhatt Vahi accounts

Balpreet Singh · 10 Oct 2003

Rice Pudding, You are saying that we should believe in the Kabul Hukumnama even though it clearly to any observer is patently false? It doesn't even LOOK real. The following shabad is from the rehitnama Bhai Desa Singh: rehinee rehai soee sikh maeraa || ouh t(h)aakur mai ous kaa chaeraa || rehith binaa(n) nehi sikh kehaavai || rehith binaa(n) dhar chottaa(n) khaavai || rehith binaa(n) sukh kabahu(n) n lehae || thaa(n) thae rehith s dhrirr kar rehai || khhaalasaa khhaas kehaavai soee jaa(n) kae hiradhae bharam n hoee || bharam bhaekh thae rehai niaaraa so khhaalas sathiguroo hamaaraa Please post the translation and original of the shabad you claim "makes clear" kes is a kakaar. Paintings: I repeat, these paintings were done in the mid 1800s. The Bhatt Vehi was written at the LATEST (if you refuse to believe it's based on earlier bhat vehis) in 1790. These paintings tend to show Guru Sahib with an earring. So I should believe this too? But please do prove that the Mata jees didn't wear keskees if you can.

Re: Reliability of the Bhatt Vahi accounts

Ranjit Singh · 10 Oct 2003

Rice Puddings basing his belief that bibia in the guru's household didn't wear dastaars on painting??? HAHAHA I suppose Guru Gobind Singh Jee also wore pink and red cholay with earings and prayed to hindu gods. Pudding, if you don't want to wear a dastaar, that's fine. But trying to show that bibia didn't wear dastaars based on hinduized paintings, that's just pathetic. Look, we get the point. You don't agree with keskis. And you'll try to back that up with all sorts of stuff, including paintings (HAHAHAHA, I just can't get over that..) and fake hukamnamay and then accuse the pro-keski people of twisting everything and using screwed up logic. We've seen all this before and will see it again I'm sure, as you guys never give up and never have anything positive to contribute. Only controversy. So you don't think women should wear keski. We do, as we believe Khalsa is one and rehit for khalsa, male or female, is one. And that's what it boils down to. Whether female and male khalsay should have the same rehit or different rehits. And on that, we won't waiver. You can throw up all the smokescreens you want, try throwing in whatever twisted arguements you have, try discrediting all sources showing keski to be a kakaar, shout, scream, flood different message boards, whatever you want. You might even believe that bibia should be given kirpan amrit instead of khanday kee pahul (I know some in the UK who have similar arguements as you believe this, but hopefully you're not one of them). In the end, it doesn't really matter. We know women and men have the same spiritual goals, the same god, the same guru, the same atmaa and the same rehit. And we'll work our way through the various rehitnamay to find the real ones based on gurmat stances (such as the equality of men and women in the Khalsa faith), gurmat traditions and logic.

Re: Reliability of the Bhatt Vahi accounts

Cali_Singh · 11 Oct 2003

Waheguru JI Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ke Fateh Bhai Balpreet Singh, Bhai Kulbir Singh, and Bibi Domalla Premee and many others have answered the questions well, but for some reason many Singh's still feel opposed to it? I feel this debate basically comes up, because the majority of the Sikh women today don't want to were keski's or dastars. Now if we go back in time, we would see this wasn't the case not so long ago (you can find these references in Bhai Rama Singh Ji's book): ~ Maharaja Ranjit Singh's Fort in Lahore has pictures of Singhnia's wearing Keskis . ~ Victoria Museum in Calcutta also has paintings of Brave Sikh women wearing Keskis. ~ Mehthiana Gurdwara (district Ludhiana) has statues of Sikh women wearing Keskis. ~ In Bhai Veer Singh Ji's book "Rana Surat Singh" he has an impressive picture of Rani Raj Kaur (wearing a Keski decorated with a Khanda). ~ Prior to World War 1, Khalsa Colleges and Schools in Ferozepor, Karion (Amritsar), Jaspalon, & Sidhwan (Ludhiana) made it compulsory for Sikh girls to wear dastar. ~Most Singhnia's who took part in the Akali movement and underwent imprisonment, wore dastars. ~ Before the Akali movement there was a prominent organization called Central Majha Diwan. Along with there other efforts in instilling the Sikh spirit in the people of Punjab, they instilled in the minds of many the importance of wearing a keski. ~ The women of Panch Khalsa Diwan society in the district of Bhosod (in Malwa) also wore Keski. When Maaee Bhag Kaur, brought back the 40 Singhs who had fled Dasam Pita at Anandhpur Sahib (now know as 40 Mukhtey), and fought the bravely against the Mughal army ... what did Dasam pita honor her with for her bravery .... that's right a Dastar. Sangat ji, though many would have you believe this is a Jatha or AKJ thing. From the puratan hukamnamas listed in this thread, and the many reference listed above, it is obvious that Keski has been worn by Sikh women since Guru Gobind Singh Ji's time. All the references listed above also were before the AKJ ever came into existence. Some other examples of later period: ~ Giani Gurbachan Singh Ji Khalsa Bhindranwale had every family member, men & women wear Keski's/dastars. They even stressed this during amrit Sanchaar at the time, though this Jathebandi has left it up to the individual after Sant Ji passed away. ~ Women who are associated with Baru sahib today, and were associated with the kirtan Jatha of Sant Teja Singh Masthuana wear Keski's. Okay, I hope this helps. Some many well thought out answers have been given by my Veers an Bhanji's above that I feel it is not necessary for me to comment with my opinions. My objective here was just to give some additional examples for Sangat to base their opinions on. Some opponents to Keski, sometimes say it should be worn, but it's not a Kakar ... fine .... as long as both men and women keep their Khalsa identity in the end we are okay . The bottom line is our identity is not complete without out a dastar. It's funny sometimes people at work ask me why don't Sikh women also wear dastars .... I tell them a few do, but most are caught up in western society ... it's the sign of the times. Unfortunate, but true ....... Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ke Fateh

Re: Reliability of the Bhatt Vahi accounts

singh2 · 11 Oct 2003

just to add to what cali_singh has said, it is not only societal pressures on women themselves - many gursikh parents would probably not encourage their daughters to wear keski's and/or take amrit before marraige as they would see this as closing down options and making it that much more difficult when it came to finding suitable partners.

Re: Reliability of the Bhatt Vahi accounts

lol · 11 Oct 2003

>>>>>>many gursikh parents would probably not encourage their daughters to wear keski's and/or take amrit before marraige as they would see this as closing down options and making it that much more difficult when it came to finding suitable partners.<<<<<<<<< lol that makes me laugh.. how ignorant some punjabi people are... theres so many singhs around looking for a rehatdhari singhnee and some just give up and end up marrying singhnees without dastar etc..

Re: Reliability of the Bhatt Vahi accounts

Khalsa Soulja · 11 Oct 2003

ok so basically the evidence going that keski is specifically mentioned as a kakkar is: bhatt vahi account by bhatt sarup singh bhatt vahi account mentioned on this site in the gurmat section bhai chaupa singh rehatnama are there ny more? ive heard there are other accounts and a few more bhatt vahi ones........ny1 want 2 enlighten me? and on the other hand hukamnama of kabul (ive seen it and it doesnt look right) 1 rehatnama (bhai prahlad singh?) sarbloh granth (if u actually read it, apparently teh style of writing is totally different from gurujis)

Re: Reliability of the Bhatt Vahi accounts

Mr Rice Pudding · 11 Oct 2003

Fetah For your information here is the section from the Sarbloh Granth which shows the 5 Ks “Know these five to be the emblems of Sikhism, under no conditions can one be exempt from them. Sword and bracelet, drawer and comb – these four without Hair the 5th , all other emblems are meaningless.” Sarbloh Granth The above translation was done by Professor Tralochan Singh who was a close freind of Bhai Rhandhir Singh and who was the one who translated his autobiography and many other of his great works. Any one can argue that the Sarbloh granth is fake if they wish. However great shabads which are well known and always sung such as “Khalsa mera roop hai kas” all come from the Sarbloh Granth. Earlier I was thinking of this shabad. I hope the above adds to our debate. But would like to stress I have nothing against people the Keski, just can't beleive its a Kekar

Re: Reliability of the Bhatt Vahi accounts

Balpreet Singh · 11 Oct 2003

Rice Pudding, again, you've misquoted. The above lines about "nishaanay sikhee" are from the appendix of the Dasam Granth which is works that are not accepted as part of the main body but added on anyways. This is generally believed to be a later composition.

Re: Reliability of the Bhatt Vahi accounts

Khalsa Soulja · 13 Oct 2003

keerh your "quote" bears striking resemblance to the appendix at the end of hte dasam granth which is considered fake by most. "The following five K's are the mark of Sikhi.These five can never be parted from the body. Kara, Kirpan, Kashera, Kangha, recognise these as four of them.The fifth is Kesh, without which the other four are useless." is there actually a quote in the sarbloh granth which mentions kesh as a kakkar or was that meant to be it?

Re: Reliability of the Bhatt Vahi accounts

Confu Singh · 16 Oct 2003

Waheguru ji ka Khalsa, Waheguru ji ki Fateh! Can anybody in the Sangat please let me know where I canfind information on the Bhatt Vahis (other than the Sarup Singh Kaushish one)? Thanks Daas

Re: Reliability of the Bhatt Vahi accounts

Confu Singh · 16 Oct 2003

Balpreet Singh accused me of the following: "Don't get confused by people like "confu singh" who're going to distort facts by their own mis-reading and malicious interpolation." As I said in my earlier post, Khalsa Soulja did not post all of message in which I said that I had conducted an initial reading and that if I have misinterpreted something then please correct me. If Balpreet Singh calls himslef a Sikh, he owes me an apology. H