Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Why did the Singhs kill A S Atwal???

Why did the Singhs kill A S Atwal???

A Singh · 17 Aug 2005

VahegurooJiKaKhalsaVahegurooJiKiFateh!!! Please could someone shed some light on the event in April 1984, when A S Atwal, a Punjab Police DIG was killed at the gates of the Harimandir Sahib. Depending on which report you read, this was right after he had finished his prayers and/or performed parikarma of the Darbar Sahib and had parshad in his hands. The main trust of all accounts appear to be that the police were forbidden to enter and arrest the killers – please could someone help me understand (a) who the killers were and (b) why, if they were the men of Sant Jee, did they feel it necessary to kill A S Atwal (what is his story?) and also if this was needed, why was it needed to be done at the gates of the Harimandir Sahib? Taksal Singh, Khalistani and others of the DDT particularly I would like to hear from you as no doubt you will have heard perhaps more information on this account from the DDT perspective. Gur Fateh! A Singh

Re: Why did the Singhs kill A S Atwal???

Singh · 17 Aug 2005

I simply would not take it on face value. Although I am not a Taksali but a supporter of the only Panth - Khalsa Panth and Sikh Rehat Maryada perhaps the facts below may shed some light on the issue. In one account days before the attack the Government were firing into Darbar Sahib in order to get the Singh’s to shoot back, and hence give up their positions. When questioned by a pilgrim inside as to why the Singh’s were not firing back the boy asked replied they were under instructions not to open fire until the army stepped into the Parkhama. Hence I seriously doubt it was the Singh’s who shot him as they did not even fire back when fired upon from outside. Likewise according to General Brar himself he was spotted by Shebeg Singh a few days before the attack, when he went inside as a pilgrim to observe the defences. He was not fired upon although he was obviously an easy and very important target. Hence once again I seriously doubt the Singh’s would bother shooting a Police Officer when they didn’t even bother with Gen Brar before the attack. The GOI were looking for more and more justifications in their builds up to the attack and hence would stoop to very low levels to impact people. I personally believe that the typical account we hear of him having finished his prayers and/or performed parikarma of the Darbar Sahib and had parshad in his hands is blatantly the work of the Indian Government in order to show the Singh’s in a negative light and justify the unjustifiable attack.

Re: Why did the Singhs kill A S Atwal???

A Singh · 17 Aug 2005

Thanks for your response Singh, like you I am not happy to take this on at face value, however need to understand a little more about what happened – afterall, he was shot dead? By whom and why – are two important questions. Perhaps we need to analyse these accounts further with substantial evidence or credible reasoning (I’m sure your statements are valid, however as you’ll no doubt agree at the moment all me and you can do is rely on speculation, albeit with the best intentions) in order to bring forth a reliable counter to the assertions made against the occupants of the Darbar Sahib during the 1980s. Gur Fateh! A Singh

Re: Why did the Singhs kill A S Atwal???

indy · 17 Aug 2005

vaheguru the story i heard was atwal had a spy within the complex and had gone to see them, plus i think he was doing CID on the postions of the singhs bunkers etc dnt know what is true

Re: Why did the Singhs kill A S Atwal???

A Singh · 18 Aug 2005

The main question is who shot him? Then, why? AND importantly if it were the Singhs, was this appropriate given the circumstances? We are talking about the Harimandir Sahib!

Re: Why did the Singhs kill A S Atwal???

sengh is kengh · 18 Aug 2005

lets be honest there were bad apples around in the aftermath of 84 on the kharku side. BUTTTTTTTT before the attack there were great singhs around babbars baba jarnail singhs panthic leadership and many rehetvan singhs. Here on one hand sant jis men were rescueing hindu women from criminals, babbars were doing many heroic activities themselves. That time was a pairah where singhs had some control. Do you think the babbars sant ji would allow a murder to happen on the most sacred shrine? that too without any provocation. You need to understand how singhs work. While there were numbskulls aftr 84 giving singhs a bad name, the start of it under the direct leadership of great singhs things like that would not just happen or go unpunished. Singhs were aware of political ramifications, reactions, panmthic situation and the army. A singh you seem a very intellkigent munda dont let indian papers fool you brother. I have heard mr atwal knew too much avbout thge extra judiciary tortures going on and was having secoind thoughts about his role meaning quiet possible under cover agents could well have taken him out with sniper fire. Understand the conditions better, india was a third world country, singhs had second world war weopons at a numerical disadvantage, the inmtelligence of india had sattelite back up through allegiences with other nations, state of the art machinery. We hear too many heroic accounts, that almost makes it look as if we were victorious, we need to understand sikhs were victims of a mass murder , and responded according to jinda and sukhas letter during the inusrgency with very little real encounters, most were made up to justify mass murder of sikhs. a singh i have no inclinations towards khalistan or any causes but most of the sikh world including our monei veer accord what went on was provoked and often twisted by indian intelligence to head towards mass scale action on the panth. [%sig%]

Re: Why did the Singhs kill A S Atwal???

A Singh · 18 Aug 2005

Veer, Thanks for your post. I agree that there were many bad apples in the aftermath and also many that became rotten too, however I am not asking this because I am feeling confused by Indian Newspapers, but to understand a little more about this, as with anything there is always “cause and effect” and as with anything nothing is black and white. Yes there was a mass-scale murder of Sikhs, however its information like this incident which we don’t address enough and as a result it falls to the side and becomes easy to pick up as a means to potentially discredit the Sikhs within the complex. Your speculations are similar to the ones Singh and myself we alluding to above and follow on nicely from there, however, they are still only speculations – surely there must be someone out there from the DDT or Khalistani Group who has further information? Thanks, A Singh

Re: Why did the Singhs kill A S Atwal???

Singh · 18 Aug 2005

Atwal was responsible for an assassination attempt of Sant Jarnail Singh Bhindrawale. He was responsible for organizing an attack on a Sant ji's jeep as it was coming back from Mehta. Four Singhs were Shahid in that attack. He had also tried to plant Kala Afghana in Sant ji's circle to get information. Atwal was collecting information and he was hard to track normally due to his rank. He also had a lot of security. As he was leaving Darbar Sahib, behind the Langar building, he was shot dead.

Re: Why did the Singhs kill A S Atwal???

komal · 18 Aug 2005

on a few boards people say Darabara Singh, premeir of Punjab had AS Atwal killed to malign the dharam yudh [%sig%]