Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Only KIRTAN at harmandir Sahib ?? WHY

Only KIRTAN at harmandir Sahib ?? WHY

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 16 Aug 2005

Waheguur ji ka khalksa waheguru ji ki fateh. This morning i recveived a note from sifar.nanak. manch regarding why ONLY GURBANI KIRTAN is done at harmandar Sahib Amrtisar. Answer..because this is the STAGE of GURU NANAK ONLY. GURUBANI is all AKAAL PURAKH MAHIMMA. Guur Ji, Bhagat JI sahibaan all wrote NIROL WAHEGURU MAHIMMA. A "lecturer" katha wachak parchrak etc would use nearly 70-80% of his won words and remaining 30% from GURBANI....and that wouldnt be NIROLL WAHEGURU MAHIMMA !! Also as it happens in other Gurdwaras...whenever someone visits, the Stage Secretarty will invite him/her to say a few words...blah blah blah.. IN Harimandir sahib..ONLY NIROLL GURBANI is allowed.. so Kings and Queens can VISIT...but they must all sit dowan and LISTEN...as this is the STAGE on which ONLY GURU NANAK SPEAKS..and ALL ELSE LISTEN. Jarnail singh.

Re: Only KIRTAN at harmandir Sahib ?? WHY

dont know · 17 Aug 2005

giani ji i'm sorry to point this out since you do point alot of things out and help us all with your insights you spelt waheguru ji ka khalsa wrong its okay you must have been tired sorry if i have offended you

Re: Only KIRTAN at harmandir Sahib ?? WHY

((((( · 17 Aug 2005

"....as this is the STAGE on which ONLY GURU NANAK SPEAKS..and ALL ELSE LISTEN" well said!

Re: Only KIRTAN at harmandir Sahib ?? WHY

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 17 Aug 2005

dear dont know ji, no offense taken. These are typo errors..my fingers are too slow for my brain...and sometimes i am too lazy to double check everything. and "spelling check" doesnt work on this type of Forums....so there you are "these GULTIAAN" !!! So please forgive me....and my mistakes.....but if you find anything of GURMATT just retain that and throw away the rest. [gurbani] gurmq dI g`l sWB ky r`K lYxI..myrIAW XBlIAW su`t dyxIAW jI [/gurbani] [%sig%]

Re: Only KIRTAN at harmandir Sahib ?? WHY

khalsa · 17 Aug 2005

jarnail singh gyani ji can you help me how to use punjabi fonts on this massage board i like to cut and paste gurbani from gateway to sikhism. dhanwad. wahegurji ka khalsa waheguruji ki fateh. [%sig%]

Re: Only KIRTAN at harmandir Sahib ?? WHY

Dyal Singh · 17 Aug 2005

Dear Giani Jarnail Singh Ji, Thank you for your post. Most of us "know" that only kirtan is allowed at Sachkhand Sri Harmandir Sahib, yet the logic and brilliance behind it doesn't "kick-in" until an example is presented before us like the one you gave. Amazing imagery - if a wordly king / queen / ruler comes inside the Darbar Sahib, he / she, just like everyone else, must sit down and listen to the praises and Gurbani of Sache Patshah - the True Sovereign. We as Sikhs are truly blessed that our Guru Sahiban have not overlooked the smallest of details, and have given us knowledge and examples of how to live life as a Gurmukh. \ Another example about Sachkhand Sri Harmandir Sahib - When sitting inside the Darbar Sahib, you cannot see the Akal Takhat. However, from inside the Akal Takhat, you can clearly see the Darbar Sahib. This can be taken to mean, when inside the spiritual realm (Darbar Sahib), politics must never enter ones mind. However, when in the political realm (Akal Takhat), Dharam should always be in ones mind. Dharam in politics doesn't mean playing dirty political games based on communalism, pushing your own religion while demeaning someone elses, or using religion as a means to control the masses. But, instead, always applying religious principles like humanity, freedom, truth, and justice. Hopefully the day is near that our own "Sikh" "politicians" (I put both in quotes because at this time there are very few Sikh politicians who do either of those well) come around and begin doing good for all, instead of just their bank account. Sorry to stray off topic. Thanks again Giani Ji for your inspiring post, and I hope to see more gems like that in the future.

Re: Only KIRTAN at harmandir Sahib ?? WHY

Dogma · 17 Aug 2005

Jarnail Singh Jee, only inspiring posts from now on. no more arguing. your knowledge is being wasted on trivial matters. this is not a request. this is an order from a fellow Sikh. ;) wahegurujeekakhalsa wahegurujeekeefateh

Re: Only KIRTAN at harmandir Sahib ?? WHY

confused · 17 Aug 2005

that last post by Jarnail Singh was amazing

Re: Only KIRTAN at harmandir Sahib ?? WHY

sikh · 17 Aug 2005

dyal singh ji excellent post. waheguru

Re: Only KIRTAN at harmandir Sahib ?? WHY

M Singh · 18 Aug 2005

so true Arshi Jee

Re: Only KIRTAN at harmandir Sahib ?? WHY

dont know · 19 Aug 2005

didnt giani maskeen ji stop kirtan at darbar sahib to do katha i personal think people should not change things whatever guru ji wanted do if its only kirtan then it should be only kirtan

Re: Only KIRTAN at harmandir Sahib ?? WHY

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 19 Aug 2005

i think maskeen and others do katha at MANJI SAHIB....a stage for Katha Dhadees etc at Teja Singh Samundari hall inside the darbar sahib Complex BUT OUTSIDe the Harmandir sahib Proper. This is perfectly OK since the Akal Takhat Sahib is for everything else that concerns us. jarnail singh

Re: Only KIRTAN at harmandir Sahib ?? WHY

charanjeev singh · 19 Aug 2005

It is my understanding that Katha Veechar used to be done at Sri Harmandir Sahib as well. Bhai Mani Singh Jee used to do Katha at Sri Harmandir Sahib as well. However, since the invasion of the british, and their dirty games and attempts to distort the teachings of Gurbaani, it was decided that only Keertan would be done at Sri Harmandir Sahib. This would ensure that no dirty attempts could be made. bhul chuk mauf waheguruujikakhalsa waheguruuujikifateh

Re: Only KIRTAN at harmandir Sahib ?? WHY

confused · 19 Aug 2005

katha back then was different then katha now katha then was a lotttt more bani a lottt more

Re: Only KIRTAN at harmandir Sahib ?? WHY

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 20 Aug 2005

right confused jio...hit that damn nail right on its head... Can anyone imagine Katha by BHAI MANI SINGH JI SHAHEED....and a dhaarna singing michael jackson look alike ... what a contrast... Probably KATHA by bhai mani Singh Ji would be 99.99 % Gurbani and the rest his own words..while todays "kathas" have 00.001% gurbani..and lots of dhaarnaas...and wacko stories called sakhis..