Can Monas play Gatka?
hsp · 15 Aug 2005
Is it ok to let monas join a Gatka Akhara? Or is it a Martial Art for Singhs/Singhnis in Guru Ji's Bana? What about people who eat meat?
Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton
ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥
hsp · 15 Aug 2005
Is it ok to let monas join a Gatka Akhara? Or is it a Martial Art for Singhs/Singhnis in Guru Ji's Bana? What about people who eat meat?Amar · 15 Aug 2005
Anybody can play gatka, but no one should disrespect the shastaraa...Kulwant Singh Sandhra · 15 Aug 2005
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh I dont see why monas would not be allowed to participate in Gatka. If anyone has an interest in this ancient Sikh form of martial arts, they should not be discouraged just because they dont have kes. Lets not forget that even in the army of Dasam Patshah Sri Guru Gobind Singh Ji, there were many muslims and hindus who fought along with the Khalsa Fauj. Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fatehhsp wrote:Sikh supporter · 15 Aug 2005
anyone(even monas) can play Gatka, even Baba Nihal Singh Jee says this. Just make sure the Shastars get proper respect.Kulbir Singh · 16 Aug 2005
It is manmatt to teach Gatka to Monnay or anyone who is not willing to keep Kesh. To teach Gatka without full Baana (in track suits or shorts) and without Kesh is manmatt. Gatka is a special martial arts reserved only for Khalsa. Kulbir SinghSingh · 16 Aug 2005
Kulbir Singh you are so blind in your view its unbelievable and dangerous for the Panth. Its people like you who are creating a big problem for Sikhi which is on the verge of exploding. So many mona think Amridhari’s are fanatics thanks to people like Kulbir Singh. Next he will be saying we can not do naam jap with them etc. Anyone who shows an interest in Sikhi should be supported and helped, regardless. If when I was a mona I was excluded just because my parents always cut my hair I would never have become an Amridhari today. Its amazing how the same fanatical people who don’t let mona's get anywhere near them and treat them like a lower caste are the same ones who talk about Khalsa Raj etc. How can we get Khalsa Raj when we are blocking mona’s in every possible way from becoming Khalsa’s by not showing them pyar and supporting them. As for Gatka being reserved just for Khalsa's the whole statement is false, as the terms Gatka did not even exist in Guru Sahibs time but is a recent creation in itself. Show me where Guru Sahib states Gatka anywhere, let alone that it is reserved only for Khalsa members? As far as I am concerned the more mona's who learn Gatka, do naam, sewa, take an interest in the Panth, come to camps etc the better, as these people will evenutally become Khalsa's with the proper support.singhstar · 16 Aug 2005
what a load of rubbish kulbir singh totally outrageous comments its only a martial arts.............mona doing gatkha might get inflluenced by other Gursikhs in a good way and may get the positive vibes and influence from their lifestyle hence (mona) may also grow his/her kesh whilst doing Gatkha.. so mona out there go ahead and join ur local gatkha club...... and ignore kulbirs post .....even if you dont grow your hair its ok as its entirely up to you as it shouldnt be forced !!!! is what the Great Guru Tegh Bahadur Sahib ji died for !!!!!! kulbir singh - people like u push everyone away from sikhism....not everyone has seen the light as you have...you have so much arrogance and ego...very shocked by your post ..did not expect this from a knowlegble guy like yourself...admin you should not allow comments of those of kulbir singh as it will just cause segragation...let every one have the chance to discover sikhi in their own time !!!!!R singh · 16 Aug 2005
Kulbir singh, If someone plays gatka who is mona why is such a bad thing. He would be around people who are gursikh. AAnd maybe he would change his mind one day and come in SIkhi saroop. Its a chance to promote our religion if we show gatka. Its a way to expose Gatka and a way to expose sikhism. As there will amirtdhari sikhs around. And they would know who started the ancient form of gatka Shri Guru Hargobind sahib.nsm · 16 Aug 2005
Then how did Muslim and Hindu people fight along side the Sikhs of Guru Gobind Singh Jis time Kulbir Singh? To simply call something manmatt is not enough uncle ji. Please provide a more thorough explanation.S Singh · 16 Aug 2005
It is because of people with views like Kulbir Singh that Sikhi parchar is not working in Punjab. Get a life Kulbir Ji.Kulbir Singh · 16 Aug 2005
I think we are making Sikhi very cheap and are bending over backwards to appease monnay (sirgumm) and others into our religion, even at the price of compromising Gurmat. I don’t know why you all find it outrageous reading my comments. If a person calls himself a Sikh and still cuts hair, such person should be boycotted from Sikh community. I have great respect for Kashmiri Sikhs for this reason. They have zero tolerance for a person who cuts hair and on the other hand Punjabi Sikhs are so tolerant that they have don’t even feel the difference if a person calling himself a Sikh becomes a monna. Just look around and notice that half of our relatives are monnay. Ask a Kashmiri or a Afghani Sikhi. The chances are that not a single person in their family is a monna. We are way too tolerant for Monnay. Sirgumms should not be taught Khalsa martial arts – Gatka. And no one should be taught Gatka wearing non-Baana attire. Daas, Kulbir SinghKulbir Singh · 16 Aug 2005
S. Singh jeeo, Sikhi parchaar is not working because we have too many dhillay. We are trying to appease others into Sikhi by bending rules. We should realize it is beyond the scope of our duty to convert others to Sikhi by bending rules. Our duty is to firstly make our jeevan a pure Gurmukhi jeevan by japping Naam and keeping full rehit and then telling others about rehit. It is the duty of Guru Sahib to change the hearts of adhikaari jan (worthy candidates) and bring them to the fold of Sikhi. There should be absolutely no compromise on Sikhi principles. To teach Gatka to Sirgumms is against Gurmat. Sikh martial arts will work only if the learner is a Khalsa. Sikh martial arts is not about skill only. Skill is probably only half of it. The other half is the jeevan of the fighter. On his Khalsa, Guru Sahib provides protection of 96 Crore Shaheedi Faujaan. Will these Gupt Faujaan provide protection or assistance to Sirgumms? Kulbir SinghSingh · 16 Aug 2005
I really think this mona bashing (done only by a small minority, who inturn don't get along with other Amridhari's anyway) is going have serious and major implication and could ultimately isolate the Khalsa if not careful. People should think very carefully before they post and speak things which can/will create divisions etc within the Sikhs as a whole, as at this time more than any other we need unity, with more people becoming Khalsa's rather than being pushed away.Confused Khalsa · 16 Aug 2005
i can see where Kulbir Singh is coming from. If we keep the rehit as strict as possible, then Guru Sahib will bring those people into the fold who are worthy. but on the other hand, i know of a group of boys locally who got into gatka (who used to cut their hair etc) and slowly after having the sangat of amritdhari sikhs ........ they took amrit. we should combine the two. let people learn about our ways by interacting with us as mush as possible and but maintaining a strict rehit as possible. i dont believe we should treat anyone different to ourselves simply because we have taken amrit, and someone has not yet been blessed by guru ji. segregation is not the answer. Lets solidify our own rehits first, then as brother Kulbir Singh said - inspire others how to live righteously. http://mistakesingh.blogspot.com/Singh · 16 Aug 2005
Wah ji wah, Kulbir Singh, with people like you who needs enemies trying to destroy us. “I think we are making Sikhi very cheap and are bending over backwards to appease monnay (sirgumm) and others into our religion, even at the price of compromising Gurmat.” No one is bending over backwards, just being a decent and normal human being and Sikh. How is Sikhi being cheapened by bringing people into sangat. No one is appeasing mona by simply training with them, in-fact the influence of good sangat will have an enormous effect on them rather than the manmukh sangat they would have been with otherwise. “I don’t know why you all find it outrageous reading my comments. If a person calls himself a Sikh and still cuts hair, such person should be boycotted from Sikh community.” Get a grip Kulbir Singh, we are not all born into Sikh homes etc. I was a mona and so are the majority of my friends (who are now all Amridhari), not to mention every non punjabi Sikh. Using your fanatical mentality no one will even have the chance to become Sikhs as they would be boycotted in the very fist instance as they cut their hair. Some mona’s don’t know the reasons for not cutting hair and hence need love and educating in order for them to develop and change, rather than outright boycotting. Can you not see that using you mentality it will not be you and the few Sikh’s doing the boycotting but everyone boycotting you, and perhaps even Sikhi if people think you represent it. “Just look around and notice that half of our relatives are monnay. Ask a Kashmiri or a Afghani Sikhi. The chances are that not a single person in their family is a monna. We are way too tolerant for Monnay.” You really make me Lough Kulbir Singh. Now when it suites you, you use the example of Afghani Sikhs when only a few weeks ago you implied that they are not proud of Sikhi and are manmukhs (as they ALL tie their dhari) not to mention the Kashmiri Sikhs. You seem to change your stance very quickly, this is also evident from your flinching comments on the Sikh Rehat Maryada. “Sirgumms should not be taught Khalsa martial arts – Gatka. And no one should be taught Gatka wearing non-Baana attire.” I wonder who made you the Guru, you certainly are not my’ne thank God. Why don’t you ask Guru Sahib what he was thinking training with and fighting along side non Sikh’s. “Sikhi parchaar is not working because we have too many dhillay. We are trying to appease others into Sikhi by bending rules. We should realize it is beyond the scope of our duty to convert others to Sikhi by bending rules.” Once again you are talking rubbish. I have lived with Sikh’s like Bhai Rama Singh who never bent any Sikh rule etc. However they never pushed away mona away, but loved them and through that brought them into the Khalsa fold. I was a mona when I first met him and if he was an ignorant person like you and pushed me aside perhaps myself and many others would not be Amridhari’s today. Who are the people you speak of who are bending the rules in Panajb. There is no percharik who is saying its okay to cut your Kesh, the problem there is no one is reaching out and trying to bring back through perchar the disillusioned youth. People like you are adding to the problem by only pushing them fervour away, and isolating and hurt the Panth. “There should be absolutely no compromise on Sikhi principles.” Get a grip with reality Kulbir Singh. No one is compromising Sikhi by allowing mona to train in Akaras or what ever. What’s next no mona can come to the Gurdwara. We all know Kesh is vital, however some people don’t. Hence they need to be taught and in time if they so wish will change. We should not ban them outright straight away. If Guru Sahib followed your lowly mentality there would be no Sikhi today in the very first instance. It amazes me that you cannot see the harm you are doing, which will effect the entire Panth (not that you really care about the entire Panth anyway, just your own little group).Jagjit singh · 16 Aug 2005
waheguru ji kekhalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh Pyare jio, I was a mona when i started learning gatka. I got interested due to my background in Tea Kwon Do, and realising there was a sikh martial art was quite inspiring. It was doing that regular sangat that led me to also attend rainsbhai regularly. Very soon after wards I kept my kesh, and then a few years later i took Amrit. I am glad that the singhs who taught me Gatka were so open and full of pyaar. waheguru ji kekhalsa, waheguru ji ke fatehsinghstar · 16 Aug 2005
well said singh. Basically guys like jarnail arshi and kulbir will never learn the true basic concepts of sikhi..they reject everyone who isnt like themselves. Admin are just as bad for allowing highly negative comments that do more harm than good from these two jokers. I cant see sikhism going very far - with these so called gursikhs who push all away, these guys automatically look on the bad side of people and arent even prepared to give innocent mona who havent no knowlegde of sikhi the benefit of doubt... for eg..if kulbir was running a gatkha session..he would turn away the mona, where the mona has been born into family where he/she parents kept cut hair. How is the mona going to know any better, u see if it was the Great Guru Har Gobind Sahib Ji he would welcome the mona in like a brother/sister with open arms.....but not for kulbir..hes the guru now - the boss - the spritual leader - he believes all the mona shouldnt be given a chance and dammed and thrown out of sikhi ...next time in a sikh conference bring this subject up kulbir - lets see u how to convince sikhs of your pathetic views and beliefs. admin i have a right to speak and express my views - we are not in India where you can hush me..so do the good thing and let this post through as its the truthhsp · 16 Aug 2005
Thank you all for your responses. Please don't turn this into an arguement. And please take it easy on Kulbir Singh, i can kind of see where he is coming from. What if we let ANYONE join Gatka, including those who drink, smoke, eat meat etc...is this a good thing? Is it not beadbi of the Shastars? But i'm sort of stuck half way on this one. Monays will get positive Sangat and could keep their Kes in the future, which is good. But what about performing in Gatka demonstrations infront of Sangat? Would the monays be wearing Bana like everyone else? If so, is this not beadbi of Guru Ji's Bana? I am 50/50 on this one.... · 16 Aug 2005
I think if a mona agrees to cover wear a dastaar and wear Sikh clothes for the class, it should be ok. A lot "monas" have never had kesh since they were kids and if they show an interest in Sikhi, they shouldn't be turned away.cybersingh · 16 Aug 2005
even Guru Hargobind Sahib ji taught SHASTAR VIDIYA to PENDAI KHAN!!! remember that sakhi everyone? if Guru ji even taught it to a non sikh HIMSELF, then why can't the Khalsa do it, who is Guru roop? another thing: i was talking to this old muslim uncle. he said even muslims did 'gatka' with the sotis and farris during special occassions when he was really young but now its only remained visible with Sikhs. A martial arts is a technique to fight and has nothing to do with who is amritdhari and what not.Kulbir Singh · 16 Aug 2005
This is getting really exciting. hehe! Dhanvaad for your responses and your feedbacks. Having read your posts, I still hold the same stand. Shasters are pavitter (sacred) and so is the Sikh Martial Arts. It should be learned from a Khalsa and passed on to Khalsa. There are many kinds of Gatka i.e. the ones that Rajputs play and the ones that Muslims play. Many steps may be same but the way we do ardaas in the beginning of the akhaara and at the end and the way Sikhs treat their shasters is different from others. As I said before, in Sikh Gatka, only 50% or so is skill. Rest is spiritual. When doing Gatka Singhs do Abhyaas and they keep tek (seek support, keep support of) Siri Guru Dashmesh jee. Can a Monna who has given up the mohar of Guru Sahib have this kirpa? This does not mean that monnas should not be welcome. Many of us have come from Monna backgrounds but there are many other ways to do parchaar and to reach out to potential candidates in Monnas. We don't have to give up our Parampra and tradition to reach out to Monnas. When goray and kaalay go to learn Karate and Tae Kwon Do, don't they follow the rules there and wear their baana? Then what is wrong if we adopt the rule of keeping kesh and wearing baana before learning Gatka? In any case, I have expressed my opinion. If I am wrong, I will be corrected by Singhs. I will retract my earlier statements in that case. Ghulaam-e-Bazm-e-Aareefaan-e-Gurmat, Kulbir SinghKulbir Singh · 16 Aug 2005
Painday Khan was a Sikh. When he was about to die after suffering defeat in the hands of Balbeer Satguru, Siri Guru Hargobind Sahib jee, Siri Guru jee went over to him at his request. Siri Guru jee placed his head in his lap and asked him to read Kalma before dying. He replied back saying that Siri Guru jee's darshan was his Kalma and his name was his Kalma. Guru Sahib asked him to read Kalma because after revolting from Guru Sahib, he had joined Muslims. He had left Sikhi. But in the end he came back to the fold of Sikhi. Anyway, it is my opinion that Gatka the Sikh Marital arts should be taught by Sikhis and to Sikhs only. Baaki Guru Sahib diyaan Guru Sahib hee jaande hunn. Kulbir Singhkhalsa · 16 Aug 2005
kulbir singh you are a fundamentalist. To you non amritdhari sikh is not a sikh and non sikh are not a human being. Do you know that during guru nanak dev's time when the population of real punjab (not present punjabi suba) was less than 2 crore guru ji's follower were more than 7 crores. why? think about it. Now when new punjab has population of more than 7 crores there are not 2 crore sikhs. why? thinkabout it. pepople who belong to certain jathas they do not conisder other amritdhari sikhs as equal. They do not eat food prepared by other amritdhari sikh. Example is on one of these message board where some one a member of AKJ has mentioned that "degh at akj's samagams is prepares with special care and consideration. To make a car go you have to put it in the first gear and if you put it in the 5th gear or overdrive instead of moving forward you will do more damage. Just thinkabout it. [%sig%]Kulbir Singh · 16 Aug 2005
"khalsas", ------------- kulbir singh you are a fundamentalist. ------------ Dhanvaad for showering flowers on me. Phulaan dee barkha karan da dhanvaad. ---------- To you non amritdhari sikh is not a sikh and non sikh are not a human being. ---------- Bahut Khoob Furmaaiya Tussee!! Perhaps you are an antarjaami (omniscient). How do you know that to me non-Sikhs are not human beings ? It is my benti that your allegation is far from truth. However, your first statement is correct. I believe that anyone who is not an amritdhaari is not a Sikh. --------- Do you know that during guru nanak dev's time when the population of real punjab (not present punjabi suba) was less than 2 crore guru ji's follower were more than 7 crores. why? think about it. Now when new punjab has population of more than 7 crores there are not 2 crore sikhs. why? thinkabout it. ---------- Was it because Guru Sahib used to allow monnay to do Gatka? Hehe! And you should get your numbers corrected. The 7 crore number is way too high. ---------- pepople who belong to certain jathas they do not conisder other amritdhari sikhs as equal. They do not eat food prepared by other amritdhari sikh. Example is on one of these message board where some one a member of AKJ has mentioned that "degh at akj's samagams is prepares with special care and consideration. ---------- Amritdhari is only as good as his or her rehit is. Everybody places too much emphasis on being amritdhaari but the real thing is to be amritdhari and rehitdhaari. No rehit, no amrit. Degh prepared by an amritdhari but non-rehitdhaari is not consumable. Kulbir SinghS Singh · 16 Aug 2005
>>When goray and kaalay go to learn Karate and Tae Kwon Do, don't they follow the rules there and wear their baana? Then what is wrong if we adopt the rule of keeping kesh and wearing baana before learning Gatka? I did not know that to do Kung Fu etc you had to start following Budhism, shave your head etc and I have yet to meet anyone doing Tae Kwon Do who has to follow the teachings of : Confucianism; Buddhism; shamanism etc. Thinking about it I have also yet to see a gora or kala doing karate following Shinto. You sound very confused. Get some help. If the Nihang Jathedar say it is ok then are you some sort of supreme commander who states otherwise.khalsa · 16 Aug 2005
And you should get your numbers corrected. The 7 crore number is way too high. sorry i may have counted wrong. the point is not a set number but WHY? please think about it. i agree with you to teach gatka to a NON-SIKH is wrong he can be an enemy of khalsa but not to a noma sikh. i assume that you do not take degh at harminder sahib amritsar. no body can guarante that the degh is prepared by rehitdharari sikh. most probabbly it is made by a contractor. and same with langar. food blessed by guru ji is not suitable for people like you. because you are i think above guru ji. neechan andar neech jaat neechi hun aat neech nanak tin ke sang sath badian sion kaya rees. [%sig%]Singh · 16 Aug 2005
Kulbir Singh, are you feeling alright. It appears that you have lost your usual way of responding and have turned to the lowest form of laughter, sarcasm "In any case, I have expressed my opinion. If I am wrong, I will be corrected by Singhs. I will retract my earlier statements in that case." Kulbir Singh you have already been corrected, did you not read my two post? If not re-read them very carefully and respond to the points raised, unless as expected if I don't take the same line as you I am not regarded as a Singh by youself. Oh what a shame I am not in Kulbir Singh's little gang of one or two. Please therefore read my post and comment on them, I look forward to hearing your responce as you are very much mistaken in your opinion. As I have already stated your assetrtions about Gatka are wrong as there is simply no such word in Sikh History, the word comes from a fighting stick and has only recently come into play. You should also note that your assertions about Shaster Vidya which are also incorrect as its not unique to the Khalsa. A Rajput was actually employed to help train Guru Sahib in weapons use. It's strange but people who actually practise rather than talk about Shaster Vidya hold the view that all have the equal human right to self defence. Anyway I guess you are intent on your view, regardless of its negative impact on the Panth. Well in my view you which i am sure is of equal importance people like you are a real liability to Sikhi and the Khalsa Panth, although I am sure all your fans will argue you are some sort of Brhamgyani. Don't worry about saying thank in advance.some singh · 16 Aug 2005
vjkk vjkf, kulbir singh, get ur facts straight. i learn gatka and i have monas in my gatka class and they enjoy learning and talking to a lot of gursikh children who are slowly bringing them towards sikhi. my ustaad also shows them a lot of pyaar and if every gursikh shows mona sikhs true pyaar, the mona sikhs will beg for the sangat of their guru and would want to learn more. kulbir singh, the things that u say sound like ur saying amritdhari sikhs are higher than non-amritdhari sikhs, UR WRONG. we are all the same in guru jees eyes so there is no point of considering ur self higher than non-amritdhari sikhs. forgive me for my mistakes, vjkk vjkfKulbir Singh · 16 Aug 2005
--------- You sound very confused. Get some help. If the Nihang Jathedar say it is ok then are you some sort of supreme commander who states otherwise. --------- S. Singh, Nihung Jathedar says lots of things. They eat meat and they drink bhang. Just because they think teaching non-keshadhari is okay, does not mean that it is fine. As for your comment on I being a supreme commander, you are sounding so bitter and adverse. What is the problem here? Kulbir SinghKulbir Singh · 16 Aug 2005
Mere Dosto, ------------ i agree with you to teach gatka to a NON-SIKH is wrong he can be an enemy of khalsa but not to a noma sikh. ------------ I am glad that you at least agree that it is wrong to teach Gatka to a non-Sikh. Now all we have to do is to establish that Monnay are non-Sikh. Anyone who has not chakked amrit is not a Sikh. Period. --------- no body can guarante that the degh is prepared by rehitdharari sikh. most probabbly it is made by a contractor. and same with langar. food blessed by guru ji is not suitable for people like you. because you are i think above guru ji. neechan andar neech jaat neechi hun aat neech nanak tin ke sang sath badian sion kaya rees. ---------- Veer jeeo, this is a separate topic. Bibek has been discussed on this thread several times. ------------ Kulbir Singh, are you feeling alright. ------------ Guru Sahib di kirpa hai. I am feeling fine. ---------- It appears that you have lost your usual way of responding and have turned to the lowest form of laughter, sarcasm --------- I don’t know what unusual I have done. But if you noticed that I am not normal in responding today, then maybe you are right. ------ Kulbir Singh you have already been corrected, did you not read my two post? If not re-read them very carefully and respond to the points raised, unless as expected if I don't take the same line as you I am not regarded as a Singh by youself. Oh what a shame I am not in Kulbir Singh's little gang of one or two. --------- Bhai Gussa na karo. Yes all the shame on me. There are many reasons for pouring this shame on me. When I said I will consult Singhs, I meant Singhs at our jatha. These are the Singhs I normally go to if I have a question or if I face some predicament. I have stated my opinion in my previous posts. There is no need to repeat myself here. Kulbir SinghKulbir Singh · 16 Aug 2005
Singh / S. Singh (same person with two IDs) --------- Kulbir Singh you are so blind in your view its unbelievable and dangerous for the Panth. Its people like you who are creating a big problem for Sikhi which is on the verge of exploding. So many mona think Amridhari’s are fanatics thanks to people like Kulbir Singh. Next he will be saying we can not do naam jap with them etc. ----------- Singh / S. Singh or whoever you are, I could not help comment on this anti-Gurmat paragraph of yours. It clearly shows lack of Gurmat knowledge. In the last sentence you are implying that monnay can do Naam Jaap. What a pitiful statement. It has been stated earlier too that Naam is only for those individuals who have given their heads to Guru Sahib and received Naam from Guru Sahib (punj Pyaaray). No one is banning monnay from saying Naam. They can say what they want to say but it will not do them any good until they take this Naam from Guru Sahib i.e. Punj Pyaray. Non-Amritdhaaris should do Gurbani paath, as much as they can. This will lead them to Naam when the good karma on their forehead sprouts and they go to Punj Pyaray to get Naam. Kulbir Singhkhalsa · 16 Aug 2005
kulbir singh I am glad that you at least agree that it is wrong to teach Gatka to a non-Sikh. Now all we have to do is to establish that Monnay are non-Sikh. Anyone who has not chakked amrit is not a Sikh. Period. a sikh can be anybody followers of first nine gurus were sikhs they did not have "khande da amrit" but they had nam Amrit they were sikhs but not singhs. you are mixing sikhs and singhs. [%sig%]Amritpal Singh · 16 Aug 2005
To "Singh" and "S Singh" and others who this applies too. Your posts reek of dislike towards Kulbir Singh. Kulbir Singh expressed his opinion on the matter,and hes free and entitled to do so. Its obvious from your post, (especially "Singh") that you have personal problems with Kulbir Singh and have lost your temper. When you calm down a little. Re read your posts your anger speaks for itself. Attack and "lough" Kulbir Singh all you want, just keep it private. We dont need to know that, it is no benefit to the sangat. Its funny how the topic of this thread is "Can mona's play gatka" not "do you like Kulbir singh and Jarnail Singh" Also i may add, Jarnail Singh hasnt even POSTED in this thread, yet you choose to attack him? With that said. I'd like to add my two cents to the issue. I know of Gatka teachers in Toronto that teach to monay openly and have not seen any results persikhi. After 2 or 3 years of training, they are still the same clean shaven people who arent taking steps to becoming amritdaris. One example comes to mind, which applies to this topic.... At Yudh a mona almost won the compeition one year. He had so much hankar and attitude it was ridiculous. The mona walked up to the shaster and picked it up. The pathadar told him that he should do panthra and to re do it and dont pick up the shaster. The mona just gave the pathadar a dirty look, totally ignored the pathadar's command and just picked up the shaster. what HANKAR!? But is this the monas fault? no. its not. He doesnt know any better. hes not KHALSA. Why would he show any respect towards shaster and Guru Sahib pathadar singh? He has no reason to have Sharda, because hes not amrit dari. Hes not into Gatka for sikhi, he was into gatka for glory. Now what happens if this mona becomes so good he becomes the Akhara Leader one day. Hes the role model now. So hes the one who is suppose to be inspiring our future youth to become Amritdari? This same guy who has no idea what sharda is, and what Guru sahib rehit is, will be controlling Guru Sahibs Gatka Akharey? We can apply this same senario to Gurdwara Commitees. That monas should be allowed to run and be on Gurdwara committees, because over time they can become Amritdaris. We all complain about monas on committies having kabadi tournaments and allowing Beadbi of Guru Sahib at banquet hall wedding parties. We have people who are leading the Gurdwaras who are not even Sikh themselevs, then what do we expect to happen to Khalsa Panth? We can use this same argument then and say Mona's should be able to do keertan in sangat, they should be able to make langar, they should be able to do Akhand paat sahib roles, they should be able to lead ardaas of sangat. This is manmatt. Yet if I make this statement, people will probably explode on me, because we are shunning away monas! why do we learn gatka? What do we want to gain from gatka? Gatka is not entirely exercise, and its not entirely martial art. Its spiritual, it was Created by Guru Sahib for his sikhs. It was created to bring Sikhs closer to Guru Sahib. Gatka is property of Guru Sahib, and like other things created by Guru sahib it was intended and created for His SIKHS. Guru Sahib Kirpa Karan, Amritpal SinghSikh Singh · 16 Aug 2005
My personal opinion is that Monas should not be restricted from learning Gatka. I know of 2 people who have become Singhs because they got sangat from the Gatka class they attended. But I do agree with Kulbir Singh Jee that the practitioner of gatka should wear bana. I use to do martial arts, and I remember that I had to wear the traditional uniform of the martial art, and was never allowed to wear trackpants or a t-shirt. Similarly, if a Mona/Hindu/Muslim/Christian want to learn Gatka, I think that they should wear bana during training which means a Dastar and chola or kurta. That may serve as a means for them to enter into the path of Gurmat.<*> · 16 Aug 2005
"we are all the same in guru jees eyes..." "some singh"...how can those who do not follow Guru Sahib's hukam be regarded as the same? It is a fact that monay CANNOT be Sikh as true Sikhs are those who follow rehit to the fullest. Gurbani tells us over and over that only those who follow Guru Sahibs hukam will be rewarded in the end. Would Guru Sahib write shabads with panktis like "Bhanay Chalay AapNay Bohoty Lehay Sajaae" which tells us that one who walks according to his own will, suffers terrible punishment (panna 949). Would this pankti apply to an amritdharee Sikh. I don't think so. Those who walk "according to his own will" refers to NON-AMRITDHAREES. How can non-amritdharees be regarded the same as amritdharees. It can't be done. Sure Guru Sahib says love all human beings, but only those can be regarded as SIKHS who follow their Guru and give up their own will. We are all aware of the shabad "Gur Satgur Ka Jo Sikh Akhaae So Bhalkay Ot Har Naam Dheaavay. This shabab very clearly states who is a Sikh and who is worthy in Guru Sahib's eyes. "Jo Saas Giraas Dheaay Mera Har Har So Satgur Guru Man Bhaavay" - which tells us that one who meditates on Waheguru's name with every breath- that Gursikh becomes pleasing to the Guru's mind. That VERY clearly tells us who is truly pleasing to the Guru - ie. ONLY those who do abhiaas with their saas giraas. And how does one learn how to do that? By the Panj Pyare - which therefore means one HAS to take amrit and therefore ONLY AMRITDHAREES are truly SIKHS! I don't see how monay can be Sikhs as Guru Sahib has already told us who a Sikh is. We all really need to wake up and understand that a Sikh can only be a Sikh with amrit di daat. Case closed. [%sig%]someone · 16 Aug 2005
"if a Mona/Hindu/Muslim/Christian want to learn Gatka, I think that they should wear bana during training which means a Dastar and chola or kurta. That may serve as a means for them to enter into the path of Gurmat." Thats whats kulbir singh and others are against. They are saying mona/hindu/muslim/christian/ cannot learn gatka because they havent done amrit shak, hence in the eyes of kulbir singh and all others who agree with him, that particular path to gurmat should be closed.Niranjan Singh · 16 Aug 2005
Kulbir Singh Jee, We all know you mean well, and hold no grudge against monays, but there are no such restrictions to teaching Gatka to a non-Sikhs as you have stated. In fact many Singhs have learned Gatka from non-Sikhs, such as the Pahrarreeay (those that live in the hills) of Himachal. Many of them are far superior in Marathee and daang fighting than most Singhs doing gatka these days. I have never heard of any such restriction from any history books from Guru Sahib Ji's time, Banda Singh's time, Khalsa Dal's time, or now in Tarna Dal or Budha Dal. In fact even Bhai Fauja Singh taught Gatka to those American Singhs who had not taken Amrit yet. Please check with the wise Singhs in your Sangat, and I think you will retract your statement. Otherwise please provide positive proof that any such restrictions were enforced from either from Guru Sahib's time or right now. I apologize if I have mistated anything.K · 17 Aug 2005
Vaheguroo Jee Kaa Khalsaa, Vaaheguroo Jee Kee Fateh! I agree Amritpal Singh. EVERYONE read and UNDERSTAND this paragraph which is displayed at the top of thie page. *********************************************************** This Message Board is designed to *DISCUSS* issues concerning Gurmat, Gurbani, issues related to the Sikh Panth and Sikh history. Any type of posts that contain vulgar language, *PERSONAL ATTACKS*, flame wars, and content against the teachings of Gurmat are *STRICTLY PROHIBITED*. Constructive, *RESPECTFUL DEBATES* with the aim to learn about Gurmat are encouraged. Arguments simply *FOR THE SAKE OF ARGUEMENT* will not be tolerated. Moderators and Administrators have authority to delete/edit such posts. Administrators and moderators only interest is to maintain a constructive, well run Message Board which promotes learning and Gurmat inspiration. www.tapoban.org does not necessarily endorse the views and opinions voiced on these forums, and cannot be held responsible for the content of sites linked from these pages or the views of the members posting here. ***********************************************************Vaaheguroo Jee Kaa Khalsaa, Vaaheguroo Jee Kee Fateh! [%sig%]Singh · 17 Aug 2005
Firstly I have posted only as Singh and never as S Singh who is someone else. Amritpal Singh I have no personal issue with Kulbir Singh (I haven’t even mentioned Gynai Arshi who I don't have any issues with what so ever), nor have I lost my temper. My issue is with anyone who is bringing down the Panth be it the Indian Govt, dodgy Sikh leaders, false perchar or narrow minded people who are isolating the Khalsa and will potentialy creat great problems in the future. Kulbir has given his opinion, and likewise I have given my opinion and commented how he is essentially wrong, nothing erroneous with that. Kulbir Singh "In the last sentence you are implying that monnay can do Naam Jaap. What a pitiful statement. It has been stated earlier too that Naam is only for those individuals who have given their heads to Guru Sahib and received Naam from Guru Sahib (punj Pyaaray)." I really think you have lost the plot Kubir Singh. I don't really care what was discussed in old posts, as anyone can do naam. It suprising that you would even suggest otherwise taking into account that Gurbani is clear on this issue: anmrith naam paramaesar thaeraa jo simarai so jeevai || Your Name, O Transcendent Lord, is Ambrosial Nectar; WHOEVER meditates on it, lives. mannae naao soee jin jaasee aapae saach dhrirraaeidhaa ||10|| WHOEVER believes in the Name, wins; He Himself implants Truth within. ||10|| mehamaa naam kehaa lo barano raam kehath bandhhan thih thoottaa ||2|| How much can I describe the Glorious Praises of the Naam? WHOEVER chants the Lord's Name, his bonds are broken. ||2|| Anyone can do naam, but the gift itself is ultimately given by the Guru by following his updesh and gaining Gurprasad. You are so confused that you cannot even do naam with other Amridhari’s who keep rehat as they don’t belong to your own self styles group as you, whilst Gurbani clearly states Amrit Naam Nidhaan Hai MIL peevoh bhai. However back to the topic I doubt people with any real common sense would ban outright people from coming into Sikhi be it via gatka, naam, sewa or whatever simply because at this stage in their life they don't have Kesh. This is certainly not what real gursikh's like Bhai Rama Singh did. As I have said before people who ban people outright from coming into Sikhi are a real liability and whilst themselves always go on about Khalsa Raj are in-fact creating real problems. Instead without compromising Sikhi in any way all people regardless of mona or not should be supported and shown pyar which has allowed thousands to become Sikhs in the very first instance, and should not be excluded or boycotted out right by narrow minded and ultimately backfiring people. The issue is not if monay are Sikh or not so I don't know why this is mentioned. We will certainly not bring people into Sikhi by bashing them at every opertunity due to our own ego's and narrow minds who can not see potential beyound the dhari and dumallha..Kulbir Singh · 17 Aug 2005
S. Singh / Singh, ----------- I really think you have lost the plot Kubir Singh. ------------ You are acting the Mudayee and Munsif (prosecution and judge) all by yourself. The discussion is not about losing or winning a plot. I expressed my views that we should not teach Sikh martial arts to persons who violate the Saabat Soorat i.e. the ones who violate the sacredness of the Human Body. It is one of the biggest sins to do so. Amritpal Singh has explained very diligently how compromising on Gurmat principles will not necessarily help monnay turn into Gursikhs. Shaster absolutely should not be given to a monna person but only a keshadhari person. --------- I don't really care what was discussed in old posts, as anyone can do naam. It suprising that you would even suggest otherwise taking into account that Gurbani is clear on this issue: anmrith naam paramaesar thaeraa jo simarai so jeevai || Your Name, O Transcendent Lord, is Ambrosial Nectar; WHOEVER meditates on it, lives. ---------- If you were to interpret the word “whoever” (jo) to mean that anyone, irrespective of his or her babits, deeds, can japp Naam and by japping Naam can get everlasting life, then what is the point of getting amrit? In other words, if we go by your interpretation of Gurbani, one could be an adulterer, a thief, a cheat, a thug, consuming drugs, and what not and still get mukat by simply japping Naam. Right? The reality is that the above pankiti refers to the fact that anyone irrespective of his or her background can get everlasting life (jeevai) if he or she japps Naam through the true Guru. “Gurparsaadi Naam mann vasae”. Only that Naam Jaap that is done through the true Guru, can be beneficial. If one does bhagti without the true Guru, such bhagti cannot bear any fruit. Gurbani is clear on this. ---------- mannae naao soee jin jaasee aapae saach dhrirraaeidhaa ||10|| WHOEVER believes in the Name, wins; He Himself implants Truth within. ||10|| ---------- In order to Mann naam, one has to sunn Naam from the rasna of the true Guru. How can anyone mann Naam without first hearing it from the true Guru? -------- mehamaa naam kehaa lo barano raam kehath bandhhan thih thoottaa ||2|| How much can I describe the Glorious Praises of the Naam? WHOEVER chants the Lord's Name, his bonds are broken. ||2|| --------- In Gurbani, wherever it says to japp Naam, it means Japping Naam through Gurmat. One who does not havea Guru is a Manmukh and a Nigura. According to Gurbani, even the name of the Nigura person is bad. How can such person whom Gurbani says that his name is bad, japp Naam and get free. ---------- Anyone can do naam, but the gift itself is ultimately given by the Guru by following his updesh and gaining Gurprasad. -------- How can anyone who does not have Naam from Guru, do Naam? Explain this. Updesh means the gift of Naam. What other updesh does Guru Sahib give? --------- You are so confused that you cannot even do naam with other Amridhari’s who keep rehat as they don’t belong to your own self styles group as you, whilst Gurbani clearly states Amrit Naam Nidhaan Hai MIL peevoh bhai. ---------- Whoever you are, you have a lot of misunderstandings about me. Why not arrange for a private galbaat to dispel any doubts you may have. This quote from your post proves that you have some serious misunderstandings about me. Who said that I don’t do Naam with other amritdhaari? Get your facts straight, Bhai. -------- Instead without compromising Sikhi in any way all people regardless of mona or not should be supported and shown pyar which has allowed thousands to become Sikhs in the very first instance, and should not be excluded or boycotted out right by narrow minded and ultimately backfiring people. --------- Yes, I agree that monnay and other non-Gursikhs should be given pyaar and they should be welcomed. If you want to witness how pyaar is given to monnay, you should attend the Gurmat camp organised at Gurdwara Tapoban Sahib. Countless monnay and keshadhari kids are given equal pyaar. But giving pyaar does not mean that we should break Gurmat Asools (principles). Kulbir SinghSingh · 17 Aug 2005
Kulbir Singh Like I posted before I have only ever posted as Singh, hence you are misunderstanding me with S.Singh, although the names speak for itself. “You are acting the Mudayee and Munsif (prosecution and judge) all by yourself. The discussion is not about losing or winning a plot. I expressed my views that we should not teach Sikh martial arts to persons who violate the Saabat Soorat i.e. the ones who violate the sacredness of the Human Body. It is one of the biggest sins to do so. Amritpal Singh has explained very diligently how compromising on Gurmat principles will not necessarily help monnay turn into Gursikhs. Shaster absolutely should not be given to a monna person but only a keshadhari person.” Sorry but loosing the plot is not about loosing an argument. Its an expression of someone who can’t think straight. Like I said before your rules on Gatka are in-fact manmat unless you can back them with proof. Don’t you know that it’s a paap in itself to make your own rules up and try and pass them as Gurmat. The term Gatka itself is a recent creation, and shastervidya was not exclusive to Sikhs anyway. “If you were to interpret the word “whoever” (jo) to mean that anyone, irrespective of his or her babits, deeds, can japp Naam and by japping Naam can get everlasting life, then what is the point of getting amrit? In other words, if we go by your interpretation of Gurbani, one could be an adulterer, a thief, a cheat, a thug, consuming drugs, and what not and still get mukat by simply japping Naam. Right?” Singh I think most people would agree that Jo means whomever. Anyway the Bani is crystal clear that ANYONE can Jap naam. Its crystal clear hence anyone can sit down to meditate on Waheguru be they a maha papi maany or what ever. In-fact Gurbani tells us that naam transforms paapi’s: pathith paavan thaakur naam thumaraa sukhadhaaee niramal seethalohee || Your Name, O Lord and Master, is the Purifier of sinners, the Giver of peace, immaculate, cooling and soothing. aparaadhhee paapee oudhharae maeree jindhurreeeae jan naanak khin har raathae raam ||4||3|| Even sinners are carried across, O my soul, if they are imbued with the Lord's Name, even for an instant, O servant Nanak. ||4||3|| Now the point of taking Amrit etc is simply to become a Gurmukh (which will gain us naam.) As I said earlier we can all do naam Jap but the gift of naam is ultimately bestowed with Guru’s grace. I am not talking about the naam drhi here, but the gift of saas saas simeran. Although a technique is given by the 5 pyarai the actual gift of saas saas simeran is beyond a technique, unless you think simply by taking Amrit we get the mystical naam Gurbani speaks of. Hence by following the Guru’s updesh ie keeping kesh, amritvela, sewa etc one ultimately get the gift of naam. However in the meantime any can jap naam as Gurbani promotes, and anyone who became a Sikh from a mona would agree with. I know mona’s who did naam and had solid Amritvela’s and hence in time they became Singh’s of a very high calibre. Telliing them they could not jap naam is not only anti Gurmat and contradicts Gurbani but also shows your basic ignorance, which is suprising to most. “Whoever you are, you have a lot of misunderstandings about me. Why not arrange for a private galbaat to dispel any doubts you may have. This quote from your post proves that you have some serious misunderstandings about me. Who said that I don’t do Naam with other amritdhaari? Get your facts straight, Bhai. “ Waheguru, I don’t have any issue with you, just anyone who is knowingly or in your case ignorantly being a threat to the Panth. I seem to recall a thread once where you were against the idea of doing sas giras abyas with those who have not taken Amrit from the Jatha. The only view I have of you is based on your posts, and contradictions which I hope I will not have to spell out for you. I really don’t have issues with any Singh brothers just think we need to be more clever and not defeat each other. Not everyone can see this but we need to bring mona’s into Sikhi more now than ever (without compromising Sikhi which no one is doing anyway). The last thing we need is to isolate the Khalsa. The view most monays hold is very serouse and should be taken into hand asap, rather than pushing them fervour away from Sikhi. People who do this anyway can’t stand other Amridhari’s who are not part of their group (ie you Kulbir Singh) I think that says it all about them. You think by japping naam with monay or allowing them to learn Gatka we are breaking Gurmat Astool, however this is based on your own manmut, and can not be backed by facts from Gurbani or tias. Gurmat Astool Is based not on your view but Gurmat.Jagjit singh · 17 Aug 2005
waheguru ji ke khalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh Pyare jio, I do think alot of pople are unnecessarily jumping on kulbir Singh. Quite possible they have finally found something to jump on him about...... As Gursikhs we should really not indulge is such behaviour of having verbal vendettas. On this issue, I disagree with veer kulbr singh, but have no real issue with him. Actually i like him, and would always treat him like an elder brother, and would hope every else here would do so aswell. As far as this issue. Let me just points some facts out. Veer kulbir Singh, I think you will find Gathka is not the khalsa martial arts. The khalsa adopted it when Sahib Siri Guru Arjan Dev ji instructed Baba Buddha Ji to teach this art to Sahib Sri Guru Hargobind Sahib ji. The origins of gathka go far back. Hindus would argue that their Gods all did Gathka. It is the ancient Indian Martial art. Some would go further and say it is the ORIGINAL martial art. There is alot of evidence which points to all eastern martial arts such as kung fu, karate, etc, all actually originated and were developed from Gathka. Centuries ago, when the fundamentalist hindus by mass genocide, drove Buddhism in the mountains of Nepal, the monks also ventured into China, and beyond taking thier skills and developing them further. Hence Gathka is an ancient martial art, and not a khalsa one. It fits perfectly with saint-soldier concept of the khalsa. But the khalsa has no monopoly on it, and they just adopted it and developed it. Yes, when teaching it to kids we should be careful. When I was teaching Gathka and streetfighting, in my younger and fitter days, I would only teach to those who had an appreciation for what they are learning. This would include many monas, because I knew they were sensible, and over time with more sangat, they would all become Singhs, which they did. We should not forget that just keeping kesh and taking Amrit does not make a person sensible or mature. There are many Amritdharis youth who are complete jokers. When teaching you just need to evaluate the virtues of that person. Martial arts is a excellent skill which everyone should learn. It does not matter what martial art you learn, it only matters how you train. The good thing a martial artist always learns is discipline and humilty. Humilty is an essential part of martial arts, because the art always teaches you what your physical limitations are, and hence you always have humilty and respect for others. The only martial artist I have ever come across, who does not have humilty is Niddar. This is why I personally do not rate him. His ego is beyond his skill, and as such he has not devloped his skill enough to realise his physical limitions. When he does that, it will automatically induce humility. Currently his ego is overcoming his skill, his skill has not developed enough to defeat his ego. The greatest battle is not to beat others in fights, the greatest battle is to beat your ego. You are your biggest adversary. This is why learning martial arts is so good. It is so much like sikhi. You could say Sikhi is the greatest martial art, with Naam as your Skill, and Guru ji as your Master, and your mind as your battleground. waheguru ji kekhalsa, waheguru ji ke fatehDogma · 17 Aug 2005
I don't want to get involved in this whole discussion, as I have no opinion. I just wanted to ask Kulbir Singh about one of his points. Veerji, you said "If you were to interpret the word “whoever” (jo) to mean that anyone, irrespective of his or her babits, deeds, can japp Naam and by japping Naam can get everlasting life, then what is the point of getting amrit? In other words, if we go by your interpretation of Gurbani, one could be an adulterer, a thief, a cheat, a thug, consuming drugs, and what not and still get mukat by simply japping Naam. Right?" ganikaa oudhharee har kehai thoth || Ganika the prostitute was saved, when her parrot uttered the Lord's Name. (Ang 1192) Isn't Guru Sahib saying that Ganika, a prostitute no less, was saved just by uttering the "Lord's Name"? Please don't think I'm advocating that we all become cheaters and liars and continue to Jap Naam without taking amrit. I was just wondering about that thukh and hoping you could clarify your position further. Thanks in advance. Waheguru Jee Ka Khalsa Waheguru Jee Kee Fateh.Hari Singh · 17 Aug 2005
Sikh martial Arts are meant for those who are willing to defend the Sikh faith. How can you defend the Sikh faith if you aren't even willing to keep your kesh? Infact, I'll take it a step further then Kulbir Singh. he is too much of a moderate for my liking. I don't think anyone who eats meat/ cuts hair / adulters/ uses intoxicants has any rights in terms of Gurmat. They aren't in the fold of Sikhi and they are not beloved of the Guru. Guru sahib shows compassion to all, yes, but it is our own karni which dictates how close we are to guru sahib. "karmi aapo apnee kay nairay kay dooor" Meaning their are certain things that are pleasing to guru sahib which get us closer to him. If you do any of the bujjar kurehits you have finished any previous kamaiee that you've done. People who are not Sikhs (i.e. those who cut hair/ use intoxicants etc. etc.) shouldn't expect to have any say in what goes on in gurdwaras or gatka akharas. You can't expect equal rights if you haven't made equivalent sacrifices. These things are limited for those who have given their head to the guru. That said, Sikhs show compassion to everyone because it is in their nature. If you read Bani then it makes you heart much softer. Dil daraya bun janda hai. not talking from personal experience, just what i've seen. The Sikhs religion is a religion of the Khalsa. Khalsa is that which keeps guru's rehit. If you want to make your own rules where cutting kesh is accepted (which is what your doing when you allow monay to learn gatka) then make your own religion. According to Guru Sahib, cutting hair is a despicable act and if one does this he or she is not a Sikh. They are patit. maharaj bhul chuk maaf karan, Hari SinghHari Singh · 17 Aug 2005
Yes, but she wasn't japping gurmat naam. She was saying ram ram. Which anyone can say. even prostitutes if they have good previous karamas whcih can bear fruit. gurmat naam is reserved for when you give your head to guru sahib. only gurmat naam gets you to sach khand. ganika was simply saved from jam doots, she didn't get mukti.RoopKaur · 17 Aug 2005
Singh, You seem to be confused. Firstly, You keep saying over and over that the Khalsa has to be more open with others, especially money. But as we can see when we look at the panth today, it is exactly because of this practice that we are in the dhilley position of today. Before tyaar bar tyaar SInghs and Singhneea used to prepare langar and degh, gurmanter naam was japped by Sikhs with the bidhi of Guru ji, instead of what is hase become today, and rehit was followed by majority. Now, you see most of so called Sikhs with cut hair, running around with earings and streaked hair calling themselves Sikhs. If the best of doing parchaar is to let go of our rehit and adopt dhillaa in just to appease monay, then why is not Sikhi flourishing right now? Until we stop this political correctness and western way of thinking, and until we start believing in gurmat as the real truth, not what society says, how can we as a panth be in total chardi kalaa? Lok pateaarai kuchoo naa paeeai. You are contradicting yourself on the naam issue. First you say anyone can jap naam, and then you say but its ultimately through guru jis grace. First you say it is panj who give naam, and then you say naam is beyod a technique. Stick to one opinion. Anyways in all the pankitees you provided, there is none that say gurmanter is open to ANYONE and ALL. They talk about those who do jap naam, and obviously you need to get nam to jap it, so you have to get amritshuck, and get naam from guru ji and then jap it. How can a person jap a gurmanter they have not recieved yet? Bani says, Sabh navai no partapdaa|| Satgur baaj na paaeo sabh moh he maya jaal jeeo|| You must go in front of satgur in the form of panj pyarey to get naam, or you cannot get it. That is pretty common sense. I agree with you that monaas need to be brought into Sikhi, but it is dangerous to do so by compromising on Sikhi. What is the point of cheapening gurmat asools to get more people into Sikhi, when the asli tat is lost? What you are saying is dangerous, that we should let go of the Sikh tradition of gatka being passed on from one gursikh to the next, and we should lose the bidhi of gurmat just so we can do simran with monay, that we should start eating khulaa from everyone even though guru ji says not to. These suggestion are all dangerous to the panth, and what is even more dangerous is that the people to actually try following tat gurmat are put down by those who do not care for Sikh parampara and instead work at being politically correct all the time.uk singh · 17 Aug 2005
Singhi Ji, Kulbir Singh has stated 'Non-Amritdhaaris should do Gurbani paath, as much as they can. This will lead them to Naam when the good karma on their forehead sprouts and they go to Punj Pyaray to get Naam. ' But on the on the other hand you are saying that 'The reality is that the above pankiti refers to the fact that anyone irrespective of his or her background can get everlasting life (jeevai) if he or she japps Naam through the true Guru. “Gurparsaadi Naam mann vasae”. Only that Naam Jaap that is done through the true Guru, can be beneficial. If one does bhagti without the true Guru, such bhagti cannot bear any fruit. Gurbani is clear on this. ' So how can Non Amridharis, who cannot be following the true guru or japping naam through Satguru be lead to naam? Kulbir Singh Ji you still have not provided any historical evidence to state that monay people cannot perform Shashtar Vidya and that bana is compulsory to learn. Bana is a uniform of the Khalsa, just like a football strip. However if someone is not in the 'Khalsa' fold (this applies to most amritdharis in fact - becoming khalsa is in itself extremely difficult) why would they need to wear bana. However, this raises a tricky question. Would any other fauj (army) allow one to train with them unless they wore the uniform and adhered to the strict rules of the Fauj? On a side note, My Grandfather who fought in WWII stated that 'the British did not allow anyone calling themselves Sikh, to have unshorn hair. when they took an oath they all had to state if they were Sikh. If they stated they were Jat Sikh but did not keep kes, they had a choice of keeping kes or remaining monay, but being labelled Hindu'. All the troops in my grandfathers rasala who claimed to be Sikh took amrit.Singhh · 17 Aug 2005
In my opinion, every thing should be open to all whatever is taught at sikh places. But there must be one condition that gurmukhi bana is a must during the any activity done at sikh places for all who believe in sikhism and only exception to this should be that this should not apply to people of other faiths. Amrit shakna is not a requirement to learn anything in sikhi but gurmukhi bana must be a strict code of conduct in any gurmat school. I do not see why a mona (from a sikh family) will object to wear gursikhi bana to learn any gurmat activity. This should be treated as fee or cost or pre-requisite of attending a gurmat school. So I think that it is acceptable if a mona is willing to wear gurmukhi bana and obey code of conduct i.e. He is ready to do everything that is being practiced at a gurmat school at least while he/she is in gurmat school getting a particular training. However, none should be allowed to pollute or dilute the gurmat atmosphere in a gurmat school or gurdwara. [%sig%]Singhni_miripiri · 17 Aug 2005
WaheguruJiKaKhalsaWaheguruJiKiFateh As I can see from this discussion everyone has given his or her point of view from a Mona. However, now let me give my point of view of someone who has not cutted their hair. You may think my post is childish although I agree because I am a child (15). HA HA. I also used to attend gatka and I used to get pleasure from it. There were more males then females. Plus there was hardly any Monay that time. Slowly, the amount of Monay began to increase and there were less gursikhs. I began to feel a little uncomfortable. After a while there were no females as they stopped going and I couldn’t remember seeing any other gursikhs surrounding me accept the teacher. He then started to allow goray to attend gatka, which made me feel even more uncomfortable. And I remember having unpleasant times there. Therefore, I stopped going gatka because I ended up being the only female there. I lost my opportunity of learning the Sikh martial arts all because of my ‘oh, lets just bring anybody’ teacher. All because of him my dream has shattered into pieces. What is the point, I feel uncomfortable attending another martial arts such as tae kwon doe because there are many goray and galay there. Also we have to wear their ridiculous clothes. And I don’t like to socialise with them but suddenly they start popping into a Sikh martial arts lesson and they don’t bother wearing our bana. Do they? Even though, the variety of Monay taking amrit is greater than ever, have you ever thought that you may be loosing a few gursikhs? I totally agree with Kulbir Singh. YOU TELL’EM! WaheguruJiKaKhalsaWaheguruJiKiFatehM Singh · 17 Aug 2005
My view is that a mona can play and learn gatka. But the condition should be that all practitioners should wear bana(dastar/chola/kashera) regardless if they are mona or even a person of another religion.singhaa Daa Panth Niraala · 17 Aug 2005
Complete sikhi bana must be compulsary for all playing Gatka and all obeying is requirement should be allowed to participate in Gatka.Singh · 18 Aug 2005
RoopKaur “You seem to be confused. Firstly, You keep saying over and over that the Khalsa has to be more open with others, especially money. But as we can see when we look at the panth today, it is exactly because of this practice that we are in the dhilley position of today.” Thank you as I am not perfect and just a student ie Sikh, hence my apparent confusion. However to clarify my position although it is very clear, you will find that allowing monay to do gatka is not against Gurmat, hence it is not wrong. No one is saying in any way which you seem to jump on the band wagon on, that we will compromise Gurmat Astool and are saying its acceptable to cut hair. The point is simple, that any one who comes into the sharan of the Khalsa to learn gatka, naam jap, do sewa or whatever should not be boycotted or pushed back based on where they are in Sikhi but encouraged. In no way is this creating a “dhilley” situation, but is common sense and backed by Gurmat. A dhilley and very dangerous situation is what you find yourselves in, where most monay hate the Khalsa and the fools who create this situation due to misunderstanding the very BASIC tenants of Gurmat loathe everyone including other Amirdhari’s as they don’t belong to their own made up ideals of Tat Gurmat. “You are contradicting yourself on the naam issue. First you say anyone can jap naam, and then you say but its ultimately through guru jis grace. First you say it is panj who give naam, and then you say naam is beyod a technique. Stick to one opinion. Anyways in all the pankitees you provided, there is none that say gurmanter is open to ANYONE and ALL.” Unsurprisingly you have not been able to grapple with the mystical concept of naam (like me.) Perhaps you should spend a few minutes reading my post and show me where I have said panj give naam??? I have referred to the panj only giving a technique and have never wavered from this truth, naam itself (actual naam and not a technique) is given by Guru’s Grace after accepting and living by Gurmat. I agree that we must all go to the Guru to get naam, however you are not thinking reasonably (hardly suprising) if you think people are simply born as Gursikhs. It takes time for people to develop and be encouraged, hence by saying to manay don’t jap naam (everyone knows the Mantre Waheguru if you care to care to read Gurbani or Bhai Gurdas) it’s self defeating and narrow minded. In-fact people really who are really in the know like Bhai Rama Singh actually encouraged and wanted everyone to join in the morning Amritvela simeran, which actually allowed many monay to become Sikhs. I also guess Guru Sahib himself was breaking your manmut version of Gurmat Astool when allowing Pathans and others to train (gatka if you will) and fight along side the Khalsa. As for your comment about Gurmat not being open to all, wow what can I say. If you haven’t been able to grasp this very central concept of Sikhi there is nothing that can be done. I wonder however why Guru Sahib specifically had 4 doors to Darbar Sahib, was it not to welcome ALL PEOPLE from all corners of the globe to attend the House of the Guru where guess what they learn about GURMAT (unless you have your way) It is in this way that people develop into becoming Sikhs, not by covering Gurmat under blankets of narrow minded and alien concepts. It is by coming to the Guru that people begin to do naam jap, and eventually take Amrit and if they’ve got the best paagh of all they get naam (not the technique to clarify especially for you). “You must go in front of satgur in the form of panj pyarey to get naam, or you cannot get it. That is pretty common sense.” Yes only the technique not the mystical naam Gurbani speaks of. Unless you think everyone who has taken Amrit from the Jatha has Naam which is obvously not true, perhaps even for you. The five give a technique but the mystical naam Gurbani speaks of is gained through Gurprsad. Its sad that you can confuse the intense and mystical naam which cuts through lifetimes and gives darshan of Waheguru, with the tool for japping naam. Your should also note that just by taking Amrit (from your Jatha if you like)NO ONE IS AUTOMATICALLY A SIKH. A Sikh is only those who follow the Guru. Hence an Amridhari who does not have Amritvela, humility etc is not a Sikh let alone has naam. “I agree with you that monas need to be brought into Sikhi, but it is dangerous to do so by compromising on Sikhi. What is the point of cheapening gurmat asools to get more people into Sikhi, when the asli tat is lost? “ Who is compromising Sikhi in any way, and what Gurmat Astool are you talking about. Please note that Gurmat is only what is specified by the Guru and note your own thinking, which in-fact is classified as MANMUT.ASengh aka "boongawala" · 18 Aug 2005
"M Singh" So now you allow moneh to wear Guru's bana? This is a joke.Sister · 18 Aug 2005
I agree with allowing only rehitdhari Sikhs to learn Gatka.khairra · 18 Aug 2005
ghatka shastervidia whatever else its called is amulgated from rajput warfare techniques. It is a martial art free for anyone being able to learn the right to defend their life. 40% of malwa jatt clans are originated from rajputs with a linkage to the 36 royal war tribes of asia. Technically speaking then any son of a gun has the right to learn his fathers right. Boonga or no boonga, if it saves lives end of!Kulbir Singh · 18 Aug 2005
Singh / S. Singh et al, As promised I discussed this with Singhs after abhyaas today. All Singhs present expressed similar opinion that I have been writing under this thread i.e. it is not appropriate to teach Gatka to non-keshadhari (ones who cut hair). A Singh who recently came from India and who learned Gatka from the famous Gatka Ustaad – Baba Pritam Singh Patiala, told us that Baba jee who is one of the top Gatka teachers alive in world, never teaches Gatka to one who cuts hair. This is what we believe i.e. can’t teach Gatka to one who cuts hair. Now we have someone of Baba Pritam Singh’s stature expressing the same opinion. We also believe that within Keshadhari too, only adhikaari jan (deserving individuals) should be taught Khalsa Martial arts - Gatka. Will write more later on. Kulbir SinghPardeep Singh Bilga · 18 Aug 2005
Singhstar wrote: "well said singh. Basically guys like jarnail arshi and kulbir will never learn the true basic concepts of sikhi..they reject everyone who isnt like themselves". I think Singhstar, you need to have a little more respect for your fellow Singhs. Although I don't agree with the views of these 2 on EVERYTHING, they are nevertheless 2 very learned people and have a lot of knowledge to share with the rest of us. Referring to them as "Jarnail Arshi" and "Kulbir" is derogatory.sikh · 19 Aug 2005
i cant see the problemAKj singh · 19 Aug 2005
i 100% fully agree with kulbir singh. monneh definatly should not be able to learn gatka. In the old days the singhs crushed the muslims, yes they had skill, but their jeevan, bir raas helped them gain easy wins. how can a monnah get these things when he/her is doing kurrheit. a person who ignores guru ji's instructions, should not be able to have the pleasure of learning guru ji's martial arts.jadrath sandhu · 19 Aug 2005
i really respect bhai kulbir singhs opinion usually and he is always a top guy who i think most of us look upto, but this time i just happen to disagree based on principle. there may be a bhai sahibv who will teach ghatka only to kesdharis. But anyone can be kesdhari. I and i think most sikhs here know a number of womanisers, wife beaters, rapists, killers, drug dealers who are kesdari, obviously not saying all but the logic behind it is anyone can have kes and yet not be khalsa like for people grow and have kes for differing reasons which we cannot determine as we not know wat happen inside person. Let us look at differnt parts of the world say in uk, we have a particular with muslim fundis targetting sikh women and children. Most of our community are cut haired lets face it. Not sure if your familiar with what goes on but women get targetted big time, sikh boys get smacked up by large gangs. Is it not their birthright to be able to defend themself against that using a very effective simple method of ghatka? what would the benefits be if they could defend their lives using ghatka? this is the hope we give our already failed by the instituition children you do not deserve it because you have no hair? this is frankly an insult unless it can be prooven beyond doubt ghatka is a khalsa martial art, then obviously i respect that as a khalsa only heritage. after 1984 a large number of ( let us face facts) punjabi jatt money laid shahidiya for khalsa inside punjab ( check the khalsa human rights records in holy bones gurdwara lecsiester uk well over just out of 3000 documented cases over 500 were money punjabi in pends. So when it comes to the crunch there ma bne millions of kesdharis in opther parts of india who did not fight back fully lke delhi, while in punjab the peasantry gave back with medieval chivalry never seen in indian history. How do some canadian singhs arrive at this position that only kesdaris should be able to learn ghatka? let us not fall into this narrow divide of mona v kesdari , lets belogical about it. first define ghatka? where does it come from? who has a right to learn it? musalmaans even defended khalsa rights at the expense of their own lives which most sikhs seem to go very quiet on like pir budu shah gani khan nabi khaan saied 5 sons nasreen bibi , they were lovers of freedom fighting with heart and soul for freedom, they were not sikh , there is no documented evidence to proove they were sikhs, but died as muslims. How can such a basic human right in th face of oppression be denied to those who need it? based on this i feel it is unfair to conclude ghatka should only be for kesdari.jadrath sandhu · 19 Aug 2005
akj singh forget about mone a second think of a muslim called pir budhu shah fighting moghuls and winning a victory for the khalsa, where did he get his beer ras from?? where did nasreen bibi get her shakti from? they were not even sikhs veer.common people · 19 Aug 2005
if ghatka is derived from rajpoot culture then anybody deriving from rajpoot heritage and culture has the right to learn it. That right is not soley for malwei but most sikhs where rajpoot culture has a heavy bearing over punjab. you have a right to defend your life any which way, whether you got a turban or not. Since when does extra hair qualify someone for learning a martial art? before religion clouds our brain, think about itHari Singh · 19 Aug 2005
I think what people are saying is that you can't teach gatka to a mona. As in you can't teach someone gatke who cuts their hair, but that doesn't mean kesh is the only requirement. I think that someone who is a sehajdhari, as in is preparing themselves for amrit, that person can be taught gatka. someone who wants to come into the sharan of guru sahib can be taught gatka.Jaspreet Singh Khalsa · 19 Aug 2005
All international gatka Ustaad's (masters) believe that it is not right to teach monay gatka. Famous Ustaads, such as Bhai Pritam Singh Ji, tell all their students before teaching them gatka that they are not to teach monay gatka. They believe, if you teach monay gatka, then you are teaching your own enemy. One does not know if this mona person is working for the government and when they will turn against you. Gatka skills should be kept between gursikhs and not to anyone else. If you want to teach your enemies gatka, it’s your choice. It is not the question of gurmat or manmat. Jaspreet Singh Khalsa Gatka Master Ranjeet Akhara Nihang Singha Patiala Tapoban Sahib, CanadaAKj singh · 19 Aug 2005
couldnt have said it better hari singh. [%sig%]I have Anbhavi Avastha · 19 Aug 2005
Jaspreet Singh your a gatka master? Who did you learn from? Do you teach? I want to learn and before you ask ... I'm an amritdhari ; )Dogma · 19 Aug 2005
did the late Charanjeet Singh teach monay?someone · 19 Aug 2005
Sikhs who see monay as enemies are not sikhs. period The reason why we have monay is because their parents came from india to canada, uk, usa, NOT KNOWING MUCH ABOUT SIKHI ITSELF...what did they have to teach their kids...Nothing. Youngsters should of been implanted the name of god through to them since they was young by teaching them to do nitnem at amritvela. we need to teach the monay lot about sikhi...make them REALISE the beuty of sikhi as did their ancesters.s · 19 Aug 2005
When the "Nihangs" took Control of Sree Akaal Takhat in 1920 By Bhai NaraiN Singh MA in Soora October 1988 Translated by Admin www.tapoban.org This story is about some "Nihangs" who supported anti-Sikh elements. There were and are many Gursikh Nihangs in the Panth like Baba Mitt Singh jee and Akali Kaur Singh jee, but many in the costume of Nihangs have in the past and continue today to attack the Panth and serve anti-Panthic interests. Bhai Sahib Randheer Singh jee and a big Jatha of Singhs and Singhnees, led by Bibi Joginder Kaur also drove out corrupt Nihangs/Nangs from Gurdwara Chamkaur Sahib. This story begins after the Panth had taken control over Sree Akaal Takhat Sahib and the corrupt "pujaris" had run away. These pujaris refused to accept the Karah Parshaad of "low castes" and when a Jatha of Singhs came to offer Karah Parshaad with a former "low caste" a hukumnama was taken from Sree Guru Granth Saahib jee and the hukumnama clearly said that even the lowest were transformed by the Guru and Sikhi had no place for caste. The Pujaris then ran away from the Takhat and abandoned their posts. This historic day was October 12, 1920. The story begins here: ******** The Pujaris of Sree Akaal Takhat Sahib brought the "Nihangs" who were staying at Burj Baba Phoola Singh jee 5 goats, 5 sacks of sugar, almonds, flour and other supplies. They collected the Nihangs together and with folded hands said "Nihang Singh jee! Sree Akaal Takhat belongs to the Nihangs, you are its caretaker. Look! The Mallechh (impure) Khalsa, those Singh Sabbhias, have taken it over. You prepare yourselves, and we'll give the control of the Takhat to you. At that time, the Nihangs had taken Sukha (cannibis drink) and were fully intoxicated. The Pujari's proposal was immediately accepted. Jathedar Sahib Singh jee Nihang ordered, "We'll slaughter the goats in the morning, now we should get ready to take over Sree Akaal Takhat". At 12pm, a group of 50 Nihangs arrived at Sree Akaal Takhat Sahib and sat down there. Jathedar Kartar Singh jee Jhabbar was in Bazaar Mai Sevaa(n) and was told that the Nihangs had now taken control of the Takhat. Jathedar Jhabbar was preparing to leave for Panja Sahib but had to change his plans. He went and stood under the balcony in front of Sree Akaal Takhat Saahib. A Nihang saw him and called out "Bhai Kartar Singh Jhabbar! You're a Jathedar (so I'll talk to you). My name is Gopal Singh Giani. I'm the secretary for the Nihang Jatha. We've thrown you out of here (the Takhat) and taken control." Jhabbar replied, "Sree Nihang Singh jee! You shouldn’t' challenge other Singhs like this. You stay put and I'll be back soon." A Jatha of Akalis was coming at that time near the Bunga of Maanaavalay. Bhai Teja Singh Bhuchhar was accompanying it as well. Jhabbar stopped this Jatha and told them what had happened and explained that they should wait before taking action as ther were a lot of Nihangs and another Jatha of Akalis was coming. Soon, the Dhoori vala Malvai Jatha under Gajjan Singh also arrived. Jathedar Jhabbar stopped the Jatha by Laichi Ber and explained that the Nihangs were also Singhs and brothers so they shouldn't be attacked. First they should be talked too and have the situation explained. Jathedar Jhabbar went before the Takhat and called out, "Nihang Singh jee! The management of the Takhat is now in the hands of the Panth. Please leave." The Nihangs however were intoxicated with Sukha and ignored these words. Jathedar Jhabbar tried to make them understand but they would not listen. They instead began to speak insulting words in return. Jathedar Jhabbar then stepped back and motioned towards his Jatha. At this, the Khalsa, like lions arrived at the Takhat. They grabbed the Nihangs and threw them down. In the Malvai Jatha, there was an 18 year old daughter of a Subedar, Bibi Bhajan Kaur who was badly beating the Nihangs and was throwing them down. The Bibi grabbed one Nihang and was dragging him by the leg but Jathedar Jhabbar released him. The Bibi, who had a staff in her hands, then went and struck at Jathdar Sahib Singh and attacked him. Finally, two Singhs had to hold this Bibi back and prevent her from attacking even more. Many Nihangs ran away and the rest were surrounded. Hearing all the commotion, a lot of Singhs from the city also arrived. One Singh suggested that the Nihangs be handed over to the police. Another Singh brought a piece of paper and said to Jathedar Sahib Singh, "write on this paper that you've made a mistake and the Panth should forgive you. Then put your thumbprint on it and we'll let you go." Jathedar Sahib Singh put his thumbprint on the paper and the Nihangs were forgiven. Later it was found out that Giani Gopal Singh, the one who had challenged the Singhs had run away from a back door. The Singhs from the city brought some carts and the Nihangs were put on them and taken back to ChhaoNee Burj Baba Phoola Singh. (Taken from the book "Kartar Singh Jhabbar")raman number 2 · 20 Aug 2005
There is a question first can it be prooven beyond doubt that ghatka is a sikh martial art or already existing from rajputs? jaspreet singh anyone can keep kes hindu sahdus do in india, how will you tell if they are undercover rss or not? some muslims also keep dastara and lambhey kes. kes dastar are not just sikh. so reality anyone can learn it and pass it on. If ghatka originated with rajputs then we have learned it from somewhere. how could we have a sole right on it? Many non sikhs already probably know it , and what if they did? they do not have Guru jis backing if it is for a wrong reason. Ghatka is probably not as sought after in the world by enemies as much as military techniques as the Cadre SAS or crack troops of USA with state of th art weopons.jeet · 20 Aug 2005
well just how much rights have the sgpc akalis given to low castes themselves? they turned back millions chammars who came to recieve amrit. The majha side gurdwaras are dominated by castists demanding majbis eat langer after the jatts have had their langar first. thanks for the last article with the malvei bibi bashing the nihangs. This just shows her warrior dna kicking axx combined with sikh spirit.logic please · 20 Aug 2005
if the whole sikh world was amritdhari rehetvan all 24 million, and knew ghatka and the rest of india pakistan and bangladesh knew ghatka, who do u think would win in a war betrween khalsa and non khalsa? the khalsa so why worry who learns it? ok now you will argue this is not an ideal world, who cares? its self defence. who cares what a few ghatka teachers say? we have to ask ourselves common sense questions is ghatka oneof the best designs of self protection? can it prevent a woman from being raped? can it stop a young child from being jumped and battered? if the answer is yes now ask yourself if you wish a rape or beating on someone because they are not kesdari? the worlds violent crime is rising, so people need to protect. the real issue here seems to be a dozen or so sikhs plain pissed at the sight of monei, not feeling part of the greater community, trying to create divisions wit the view by doing so it will create a requirement for monei to become kesdhari. This in ideal world yeh but the real world is not like that, monei are way too big a number. I do not know many monei who want to learn ghatka most will oppt for kickboxing, street styles but if they chose ghatka i see no problem. I do not see monei as my enemy a lot of new batch of amritdharis are from mopna families ourselves, i know i want my 4 mona sisters to be able to defend their lives agqainst an attack if they had a chance with ghatka. [%sig%]singh is right · 20 Aug 2005
but hari singh ghatka is not a sikh martial art it is a rajput art, so how could it be only for khalsa sikhs? jats and rajputs in punjab are interchangable terms with time, meaning any jatt can learn what is his heritage.Teri Ma · 20 Aug 2005
Singhstar, its seem to me as if you are a very tila rehet singh. From you previous post, it seems as if you a very liberal Singh. It seems as if everything is ok. Your probably think that it’s ok for a mona to be a granthi, as long as he has sarda, Right. I mean if you let him be a granthi, he would surely take armit, right after?? I have one question, have you even been to a marital arts club ran by a goray or kala??? Do you see how it is run?? Have they not lost many of the old traditions? Some don’t even care if you are in uniform and some don’t even care if you wear shoes are not! Also, although I don’t agree with Gyani ji and Kulbir on many subject, I at least give them respct for backing up with what they say with a quote from Guru Granth Sahib Ji. I have never seen you do that. You seem like those mona’s who have never read the Guru Granth Sahib but yet claim to know everything about Sikhi. “Basically guys like jarnail arshi and kulbir will never learn the true basic concepts of sikhi..they reject everyone who isnt like themselves.” “I cant see sikhism going very far - with these so called gursikhs who push all away, these guys automatically look on the bad side of people and arent even prepared to give innocent mona who havent no knowlegde of sikhi the benefit of doubt...” These are the type of saying I ALWAYS hear mona’s say. What you need to do is stop hanging around and listening to the Mona committee members at the Gurdwara, I don’t think they are giving you the right information on Sikhi. Personally, I think you a undercover Mona, that’s my two cents. And please if you are going to start quoting, please don’t take it from the daily hukam or do a random search on Sikhitothemax.com. [%sig%]Kulbir Singh · 20 Aug 2005
------------ Jaspreet Singh your a gatka master? Who did you learn from? Do you teach? I want to learn and before you ask ... I'm an amritdhari ; ) -------------- Haanji Bhai Jaspreet Singh Khalsa is a Gatka Master and has received dastaar and authority to teach Gatka from internationally renowned Gatka Ustaad - Baba Pritam Singh Patialawalay. Baba Pritam Singh jee taught Gatka skills to Bhai Fauja Singh, Bhai Mahavir Singh, and many others. I heard that recently Bhai Teji jee too went to learn Gatka skills from Baba jee. Daas, Kulbir SinghG · 20 Aug 2005
Author: Dogma Date: 08-19-05 12:38 did the late Charanjeet Singh teach monay? NOsinghstar · 20 Aug 2005
teri ma - thats the thing where have they used a quote from the Guru Granth Sahib ji that indicates mona shouldnt play Gatka ?? thats because there will be no such quote, they might find something and interpret it the wrong way as they always do. Look at the oponions of other sikhs Next ull say the mona arent allowed in any Gurdwara...thank god people like you arent in a position of authority and my views are no more liberal then that of the Great Gurus who accepted all humanity not just so called gurusikhs.Singh · 21 Aug 2005
I Simply pointed out the FACT that its a contradiction to say that becaouse Bhai Pritam Singh Ji says it wrong to teach monay so it must be wrong. Whilst with regards to Nihang Jathedars as mentioned earlier who do not have a problem with it we get comments like "Nihung Jathedar says lots of things", and "Just because they think teaching non-keshadhari is okay, does not mean that it is fine. " In view of the admin not putting up mys posts (which in no way contradicted the policy of this site) its sadly clear that honest discussion is not welcome here.painjka posse · 21 Aug 2005
Can anyone here proove ghatka did not exist prior to sikhi? ghatka is the haq of every single jatt punjabi kes or no kes. this is part of our tradition that envelopes from punjabi rajput traditions. A ghatka teacher his students may decide otherwise based on religious views. Being a sikh also means being able to think. If the system saves lives thats all that matters. Being able to defend your life is quiet different from being a mona reading from Guru granth sahib. What is even different is the fact that this is not a sikh art. so the argument just stops there. Let us say for the sake of it ghatka is equal to if not greater than shastervedeeya. On one hand we have some sikhs who believe only someone with 4 metres of hair deserves to learn to be able to defend their lives with their very own heritage they are born in into. On the other we have a man ready to teach anyone and everyone so they may be able to protect their lives against RAPE INJUSTUCE RACIAL ATTACKS MUSLIM FANATIC CRIMINALS. Dont get me wrong geez i hatye sanatan views but if someone is ready to teach for the sake of defending ones own dignity while the other moans about hair or no hair what do you think the most sensible view is gonna be? ask any bibi here in the uk.g force · 21 Aug 2005
get over it guys 80% of sikh community are monei and they are free to learn ghatka as and whgen they want there is nothing and no words like teri ma or tera bhaap that will change that. Ask veer teji singh in uk he teaches anyone freely for seva, ask him if he looks at the race religion colour gender or external features of anyone coming to heim to learn a self defence art? thats when you know what a true singh is about he sees everyone the same who want to know how to be better able to help themselves in a fight situation against a larger number of people. There are reasons given why some people feel this art should not be taught to monei but even more stronger reasons why it should be taught tyo anyone. Why was a kirpan given to a sikh? kirpa and aan. Do you think guru sahib turned back people because they had 3 4 less hairs on their head? guru sahib gave his life in his ninth form for the principle to protect others. The tenth Guru ji had friends from many walks of life, who foiught alongside him some were muslim some were hindu most were khalsa. do you think khalsa soldiers had one battle standard and his muslim/hindu friends another fighting for the same side? teri ma think about bhangani battle guru ji could have won it by himself with kirpa from God. Guru ji sent a divine message through a muslim saint coming tyo the yudh and helping the khalsa in troubled time. so who is an enemy who is a friend even in the time of Guru ji? Guru ji loved all. some of you talk of gupt stuff, what is gupt? some sikhs claim 70% of our religion has been stolen and sitting with goi stolen from the library in 84. so they have more than us on our own religion so what is gupt anyway? [%sig%]Me · 21 Aug 2005
Whoever said that Bhai Charanjeet Singh Ji did not teach monay...how do you know this? If you were a part of the Akhara, (which I am), you would know that the Akhara has a rule that monay can come to practice (to get Sangat of Gursikhs), but as for performing at Gatka shows or demonstrations in public, only those keeping Kes could perform. These were Akhara rules, as for Singh Ji's personal views, i cannot say, because i have no idea...but one thing i do know is, he was full of so much Piar for everyone.RoopKaur · 22 Aug 2005
>There are reasons given why some people feel this art should not be taught to monei but even more stronger reasons why it should be taught tyo anyone. Why was a kirpan given to a sikh? kirpa and aan. < The kirpan was given to Sikhs, not everyone. Although anyone can wear a kirpan, it has special significance when a Sikh wears it. Same way, although a mona can learn gatka from a khulaa teacher, when in battle, it is guru ke Sikh that will have bakshish of guru ji. Shaster vidhiyaa was bakhshed to Sikhs from guru ji, and it is only right that those who have sharda for guru ji should be taught it, and not just any Tom Dick or Harry. >Ask veer teji singh in uk he teaches anyone freely for seva, ask him if he looks at the race religion colour gender or external features of anyone coming to heim to learn a self defence art? thats when you know what a true singh is about he sees everyone the same who want to know how to be better able to help themselves in a fight situation against a larger number of people. < Although a Sikh treats all equally and loves all, there is no way a tyaar bar tyaar, rehitvaan, naam abhyaasi pakaa Singh is equal to a monaa. There is no logic in the statement, guru ji says rehit pyaree mujh ko Sikh pyaaraa nahe, so how can someone who cannot even keep the minimum rehit of not doing bujjer kurehits be equal to one who has sharda in guru jis rehit? Uptej Singh himself went to Bhai Pritam Singh to learn gatka, and Bhai Pritam Singh, like all puraatan ustaads, does not teach money.... · 22 Aug 2005
Its amazing that all those against monay playing gatka have not once referenced anything in gurmat or history to reveal that rules were in place to prevent monay from learning this skill. This is despite several requests Why do people abuse the use of the word 'Gurmat' to win arguments when in fact it is their own mat that is being pushed? Rather than admit a mistake or swallowing pride, some will insist against all odds that they are right - until they are blue in the face. It is clear from all the aforementioned posts that there are more in the sangat supportive of monay playing gatka and a few elements who disagree. If we were to post the initial question on any other Sikh forum, I feel the result will be the same. Monay learning Gatka has no derogatory affect on the Sikhs in any way - standards will not necessarily slip if they are taught gatka. As others have mentioned the sangat will have a positive impact on them and as we know many decide to follow Sikhi for this very reason. Many Gurdwaras with free Gyms attract youth who would not normally attend. Just through the affect of good sangat their karams can change.khalistan Thi Adheeka · 22 Aug 2005
lets look at it this way. Two schools of thought. 1) sikhi rehat = everything remains Gupt, ghatka, naam, banis, techniques, other vidias, 2) bhai rama singh n co in southall start nam simran programmes for all = let others feel the fragrance of nam, other akharas offer protective vidia for bibia, including ayurvedic herbal remedies. btoh schools will have advantages. school one advantages - no outside inteference - mona exclusion zone with the mistaken belief this means more purity with only khalsa bearded lions, whoile most bearded lions themselves have mone in their own families and will never understand this logic. - strict standards retained with the belief this will create some kind of pure example hopefully leading to a mammoth predicted spread of khalsa once we become pure. school two advantages - sikhi reaching out to the community empowering it. -creating unity amongst our own peoples - creating awareness and knowledge - exposure to naam simran programmes means many others are beiong drawn closer to sikhi. -exposure to ghatka has actually led former mone and even kesdari wanderers towards sikhi, therefore ghatka itself has become like a spiritual road towards sikhi , this also includes one muslim becoming a sikh that i am aware of with thanks to a chardi kala sevedar. conclusion = school one is hopeful, high standards and believes in propehcies that its strictness will born rekindle sikhism through its very strict regime of exclusiveness. It has produced some amazing sikhs but is not reaching out community wide because of the approach structure homogenising within selected fews. school two has a prooven track record of working developing and growing in the last 10 years within tyhe siikh community working for it which is what most sikhs need and want. I feel we should all now stick our hands out join up and put our energies together and develop upon what we have. If you consider your own community as your enemy then ask yourself what community role you have to play in the lives of others? you could utilise some of your time for seva which means giving part of yourself or continue making walls up high and stand on the tower.sort it out boyz · 22 Aug 2005
we have too many divisions in the sikh world which i dont think many would aproove me mentioning. to cut off monei from sikhi is like saying if we were to face a jang and we the khalsa werfe the first batch of warriors to lay our lives then we have not prepared the path for a fresh batch. the aftermath of 1984 led to a huge surge of mone coming into sikhi this kept the movement alive. the argument is tact or ego. tact would be to bring monei into the panth and train them so one day they can pas sthis on become inspired to sikhi if we had to die for this. Thew ego way out is keep it to yourself and no one else will know, youi die as the legacy. this is where the rajputs screwed up. They had the best systems of the world kept it to themselves , got too cosy with life, mansions, women, fancy bling bling, they couldnt die for what their fathers died for.their convictions died out. Their knowledge became nothing and they lost everything. Is this the road you wantr us to walk on? we need tacticians war generals warriors with warrior minds that want and desire to spread the eagles of the khalsa all over the world. to start with see everyone as the same.ns · 22 Aug 2005
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ke Fateh Dear "khalistan Thi Adheeka" You're correct 100% spot on may I also conclude that there is a definite split in the AKJ with both of these school of thougts. In the olden days late 80,s or so this wasn't the case, what a sad state of affairs we 're in at present , detoriting by day.splitting further and further..may Guru Ji gives us some kind of enlightement to get over the quibbling and get on with the job of being a SIKH.We don't need TALIBANISM in Sikhsfatjoe · 22 Aug 2005
mona doing gatka is an insult if really wants to learn guru sahibs martial arts he should first have to listen to the guru and keep is hair other wise he should just go learn karate or somthinSinghavelli · 22 Aug 2005
As a Kashmiri Sikh.....i can tell u the statements by Kulbir Singh are NOT true........there are monay.......and trimming of the beard is becoming a fashion amongst kashmiris.......many kashmiri sikhs are infact falling victim to the corrupted present punjabi culture of drugs and alcohol...... ....and to add gatka is a martial art.....for self defence and protection of the weak and oppressed........now tellin an individual they dont have the right to self defense techniques is ludacris.......gatka is a gift to the oppressed given to the oppressed......not only sikhs........the Gurus fought for humanity......not sikhs.....gatka is for humanity.....not sikhs.....u need to grow upHari Singh · 22 Aug 2005
>>> creating unity amongst our own peoples - creating awareness and knowledge >>> Veer jee, let me ask you this ... who qualify as our people? Punjabi's? brown skinned people? Who? As far as am I'm concerned, our people are those who are sehajdhari and those who are amritdhari. Sehajdhari is anyone who is preparing for amrit. Whether they are brown, black, white, yellow, pink .. if they are making an effort to move closer to guru then they are our people. I think the early 80 and 90's are very explicit in highlighting that just because someone is a keshadhari doesn't mean that they are "our people". Our people means that they have to be actively preparing to take amrit. And such people can be taught gatka. Otherwise, if you consider brown colored people to be apne, then you'd have to allow all RSS, Shiv Sena people into the akhara as well. A gatka Akhara isn't some martial arts dojo where you go spend an hour doing exercise and come home. It is also a place where Singhs discuss the current situation with the Sikh panth, and analyze whatever the latest issue has risen within the panth. It is a place which is exclusive to those who have given their heads or are willing to give their heads. A gatka akhara runs with the blessing of guru and as with all things in Sikhi, we must remember, "REHIT PYAREEE MUKH KO". Do not be mistaken, "our people" are those who are sehajdhari or amritdhari... none else. To think so otherwise shows that you've not learned to look beyond the color of someone's skin. To simply call someone "apna" because he has the same skin tone is wrong. Having said that, Sikhi has always preached with love, and that is why its foundation is so strong. Just becuase certains things within the amritdhari world are exclusive doesn't mean that amritdhari's are somehow elitist. A lot of amritdharis were monay at one time or another. Including admin of this site, Kulbir Singh. The simple fact is that you've certain rights, duties and priviliges once your amritdhari. Its like being accepted into a Uni, if you aren't a student, you can't expect to have access to the same resources. Sikhi has always been preached with prem bani. The lives of great gurmukhs like Baba Ajit Singh, Baba Deep Singh, Bhai RAndhir Singh are like beacons of light in the stormy and dark water of kalyug, those who are seeking truth are irrestibily drawn to gurmukhs. If you are relaxing the rehit in hopes of attracting more people, then I hope you remember guru sahib's words. "Khalsa mero roop hair khaas" "Jab lag Khalsa rahay niaraa, tab lug tej dio mai sara" "Rehit Pyaree Mukh ko" waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji kee fatehSad Singh · 23 Aug 2005
I would pick a "Mona" who shows love for humanity over any so-called "Gursikh" who is full of hankaar and looks down on all others. These people give Sikhs a bad name. This is not how we are supposed to be. Weren't Sikhs created in the image of Guru Gobing Singh Ji? Appearance mean nothing - there has to be substance behind it too.Admin · 23 Aug 2005
Both sides of the argument are present in this thread. The topic is now locked.