Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Pictorial: Sikhs Get Hindustani Justice!

Pictorial: Sikhs Get Hindustani Justice!

Balpreet Singh · 10 Aug 2005

I just saw the following pictures from the Associated Press. [i]Protesters face water cannon as Sikhs demonstrate against the Indian government's refusal to prosecute a federal minister implicated in the killings of thousands of Sikhs following the 1984 assassination of Prime Minister Indira Gandhi by the recently released report of Nanavati Commission, in New Delhi, India, Wednesday Aug. 10, 2005. The ninth such commission constituted to comment upon the riots of 1984 that targeted the Sikh community found there was credible evidence that Jagdish Tytler, the current minister in charge of nonresident Indian affairs, was 'very probably' involved in organizing attacks on Sikhs in New Delhi. (AP Photo/Saurabh Das) [/i] This is Indian justice. A Commission reports that ruling politicians are responsible for an organized massacre of the Sikhs, and the Sikhs protesting this are the ones who face a crack down and prosecution. This is Hindustani justice. When dogs ate Sikh bodies and murderous mobs ran wild through the streets of Delhi, where were the water canons then? Should the Sikhs forget the days when dogs ate their dead? Here are some more examples of Sikh protestors getting a taste of Hindustani justice. This is Indian Democracy for Sikhs: This young Singh died of a crushed skull. Time after time this scene has been repeated. When will the Sikh community realise that Khalsa Raj is the only solution?

Re: Pictorial: Sikhs Get Hindustani Justice!

... · 10 Aug 2005

I hope our India-fan Sikhs will remember these images when they're waving the flag and dancing the bhangra on August 15th. Think of these pictures when you're proudly shouting "Hindustan Zindabad!"

Re: Pictorial: Sikhs Get Hindustani Justice!

A S · 10 Aug 2005

Those pictures send shivers down my spine. People say we should still hold a grudge against Aurangzeb and the Mughals for what they did. Mughal Raaj is long over but have Sikhs gotten the freedom they deserve or are they still hunted down in this so called "democracy"...just have a look at the pictures and decide for yourself. But that's okay, Khalsa isn't afraid of death. Khalsa was sawn in half, Khalsa was crushed on a spiked wheel, Khalsa was set ablaze yet they never loss faith in the Guru then and they sure as hell won't lose their faith in the Guru now. "Physical death I do not fear . Death of the conscience is a sure death" -Sant-Siphai Jarnail Singh Ji Khalsa Bhindranwale Degh Tegh Fateh Raj Karega Khalsa

Re: Pictorial: Sikhs Get Hindustani Justice!

JS · 10 Aug 2005

Sikhs should now press international human rights organisations to press charges. The UK has set up a law that a person responsible for murder and torture can be convicted in the UK. An Afghan was imprisoned just recently

Re: Pictorial: Sikhs Get Hindustani Justice!

**- · 10 Aug 2005

JS, The UK can't do anything. Nobody respects the Bristish anymore - they are just lame ducks. Britain can't tell India to do anything and you better believe it. India is an economic super power and it is Britains interests to maintain a good relationship with India. Don't rely on gorey to sought your problems out because they probably don't care, they are now more concerned about eliminating Islamic terrorism and ending world poverty. Sorry if this sounds harsh and blunt, but as a management consultant I work with a lot of professional gorey and this is the 'view on the street'. Regards Sitara [%sig%]

Re: Pictorial: Sikhs Get Hindustani Justice!

JS · 10 Aug 2005

So what do suggest to deal with injustice in India. You have seen what you get from India. Actually a lot of human rights violators are scared to go abroad, Modi skipped coming to the UK because an arrest warrant was going to be issued.

Re: Pictorial: Sikhs Get Hindustani Justice!

news · 10 Aug 2005

Re: Pictorial: Sikhs Get Hindustani Justice!

**- · 11 Aug 2005

Veer JS, The main reason Modi skipped coming to Britain was because of the threats from Islamic extremeists. About seeking justice from India, I would (as 'A Singh' suggested in another post) learn a lesson or two from the Jewish community. You are not going to get anywhere shouting "Khalistan Zindabaad" and burning flags - it just looks barbaric and unsophisticated. You should also take into consideration the current demographic and socio-political situation at the moment. Whether you believe it or not, the vast majority of Sikhs in India are well respected and well-to-do. Currently their is a Sikh prime minister [Manmohan Singh] a Sikh Army chief [J J Singh] and a Sikh commerce minister [Montek Singh Ahluwalia]. The wider community will find it hard to reconcile your claims with that of the current situation in India. The way in which you tackle these issues is something the Sikh community has to decide for themseleves. Nobody else is going to help you out since these days everybody looks out for their own. Kind Regards Sitara [%sig%]

Re: Pictorial: Sikhs Get Hindustani Justice!

Singh · 11 Aug 2005

The first step is what we are seeing. We are talking about the issues surrounding Khalistan more than ever. I firmly believe communication in our own community is very important. If we all create a single stance, which will ultimately take time (but things are already in motion) we really do not need any external help, whilst we should utilise lobbying and creating awareness. The Sikh’s have a long history of taking on superpowers, hence we need to all get on board and be patient for the long haul. Rome wasn’t built in a day, one step at a time.

Re: Pictorial: Sikhs Get Hindustani Justice!

Bhopinder Singh · 11 Aug 2005

Sitara ji The demographic is changing the Afghanistan factor is that sooner rather than later it is going to be democratic and than it will have good relations with pakistan and China is bent upon improving relations with Iran via Pakistan. The resistant in Iraq by islamists and the victory of theirs against USSR the strongest land forces on earth gives moslem nations a new factor defiance and that adds to their stratgic depth and will help them in Kashmir and other places So it is too soon to celebrate on the other hand the situation looks quite grim for your hindu nation I wonder the communal decision of Hindu supreme court of dubbing Sikhs and Jainis as Hindus will come back to haunt them and i think they got blown over by the air of partner ship comming from US.

Re: Pictorial: Sikhs Get Hindustani Justice!

A Singh · 11 Aug 2005

Sitara, I am glad you could you understand my point of view - I, as any self-respecting Sikh, despise the events of 1984, having lost family in the carnage myself it's all the more personal, however "shouting Khalistan Zindabad" has achieved next to nothing over the past 21 years - not even unite the Sikhs under one banner. Democracy, as the learned Sirdar Kapur Singh, put it is simply power to the numerical majority, which is why Sikhs in India or the entire world are not going to get anywhere if we keep this a strictly "sikh-only" issue and alienate the world, particularly in India - this anti-Hindu attitude is not going to get us anywhere, what is needed is a vehicle from a cohesive Sikh stance, where people can rise above petty squables about colour of clothing, style of dastaar, how one cooks or eats their food etc etc and compell the world audience abuot the 84 holocaust. The Jewish success with this matter has occurred on this basis, granted they had their fair share of 'blood for blood' seeking, but the overwhelming part of their success did not come from 'drawing the sword' and holding online petitions or physical protests. Let's get savvy with things and really put the pressure on and choose the right weapons for the job. Gur Fateh! A Singh.

Re: Pictorial: Sikhs Get Hindustani Justice!

Nishant · 13 Aug 2005

What never fails to amuse me is how the khalistanis refer to jarnail singh bhindranwale as "Sant Sipahi Sant Jarnail Singh Khalsa Bhindranwale ji" Poor chap would be turning in his grave particularly since he mentioned tens of times that he was not a sant or nething. Just a sevak of the panth. Whether he was a terrorist into all of this for his own gains or was a martyr for the sikh cause, is for intellectuals to debate. All i know is that the vast majority of sikhs enjoy a standard of living at par with the rest of the indians. Maybe even more as they are hard working and intelligent. Believe in education and not terrorism. And I hope it stays that way. Peace Nishant

Re: Pictorial: Sikhs Get Hindustani Justice!

search for tat · 13 Aug 2005

But you canot deny that sikhs in delhi have not seen any prosecutions of any of these Congress riot leaders. Neither have sikhs seen any of these punjab police guys who brought genocide, rape and pillageing to Punjab aswell. There crimes are well documented. Sikh have always wanted to be part of India, since 1947. But the Hindu agenda by Congress, and openly by BJP has no future for Sikhs, and any minorities, even Hindu Dalits are treated like Scum.

Re: Pictorial: Sikhs Get Hindustani Justice!

A S · 13 Aug 2005

Hey Nishant, our Guru prompted anyone who is to be called His Khalsa to become a Sant-Siphai.

Re: Pictorial: Sikhs Get Hindustani Justice!

**- · 13 Aug 2005

Bhopinder Singh Ji Are we cool with each other now? You said: --- So it is too soon to celebrate on the other hand the situation looks quite grim for your hindu nation --- Bhaiji I am not celibrating at all. I personally think India has sold its soul by aping the west. Anyway I was just stating a matter of fact. However Indias' success can easily be taken away in a second. Anyway if the situation looks grim for my Hindu nation it looks even grimmer for your Sikh nation. Face facts; if Sunnis are willing to slaughter Shi'a Muslims and the peoples of the book (Jews and Christians), what are they capable of doing to Sikhs. At the moment they are amicable with Sikhs due to their hatred for India but this is only for convinience. If India was a Sikh majority state, the situation would be reversed. Only 0.0000001% of Muslims truely respect Sikhs, Sikhi and the Guru Sahibaan. Sitara

Re: Pictorial: Sikhs Get Hindustani Justice!

Singh · 13 Aug 2005

"All i know is that the vast majority of sikhs enjoy a standard of living at par with the rest of the indians. Maybe even more as they are hard working and intelligent. Believe in education and not terrorism." Most Punjabi Sikhs, whether they openly say it or not, somewhere deep down are burning up. You people keep pointing to the high standard of living of sikhs, etc. Well, Sikhs have always had a higher standard of living than the rest of India. This is nothing new and is definitely not as a result of anything India has given them. They are hard working people, always have been, and have earned this standard of living. Once again, it's nothing new. Don't expect to see Sikhs doing cartwheels to celebrate this fact. I understand that bhukay nagay would find great joy in suddenly having a high standard of living and would forget everything else, but not the Sikhs. We aren't blinded so easily. It's called 'anakh.' India has butchered hundereds of thousands, raped countless women and tried to wipe out our faith. You expect people to forget that so easily? Don't fool yourselves. It burns deep down in all of us and is just waiting for the opportunity to burst forth. By the way, if anything, our standard of living has been held back due to India. India has been nothing but a burden for the Sikhs.

Re: Pictorial: Sikhs Get Hindustani Justice!

RoopKaur · 13 Aug 2005

>Poor chap would be turning in his grave particularly since he mentioned tens of times that he was not a sant or nething. Just a sevak of the panth.< The reason he is called a sant sipahi is because he was exactly that. He followed Sikh rehat and did immense bhagti, fulfilling the sant part, and he also fought for the panth with his tan and man, and urged others to do so as well, fullfilling the sipahi part. I do not imagine that he would go around telling people to call him sant sipahi as this would be against gurmat, which is what he stood for. >Whether he was a terrorist into all of this for his own gains or was a martyr for the sikh cause, is for intellectuals to debate.< THere is nothing that intellectual about that debate. A terrorist is someone who employs violence, terrror and fear in order to manipulate the other group. A freedom fighter is somone who takes part in rebellion against oppression and discrimination. Obviously Sant Jarnail Singh Bhinderawaley fit the description of the freedom fighter, while the Indian government sounds more like the first description.

Re: Pictorial: Sikhs Get Hindustani Justice!

Siddharth · 13 Aug 2005

<> Oh really??? This is an argument given by several western Sikhs. Tell me this. If we are holding you back, then how come Hindus do as well, if not better than Sikhs in western countries? The rules are equal here, right? How come most doctors, engineers, scientists etc. are Hindus? There are communities doing better than Punjabis, i.e., Gujaratis and now, with the influx of software engineers (like me) in the west, there are several people from South India as well. Do you mean to say they are not hardworking? Again - arbitrary remarks, just to flatter yourself and put down the Hindus. Wake up to reality, dude. Regards, Sid.

Re: Pictorial: Sikhs Get Hindustani Justice!

Bhopinder Singh · 14 Aug 2005

Sitara ji While respecting you I still believe we are two different people on two different sides.We are people fighting and struggling to be free nation like you and Pakistan.

Re: Pictorial: Sikhs Get Hindustani Justice!

Singh · 14 Aug 2005

Siddharth, go back to India and take a look at your country. It's shameful. As far as Hindus doing as well as sikhs in the west, I will agree that there are many hardworking and very intelligent Hindus. But buddy, take a step back and look at the big picture. There are 600 or 700 million of you back in India. That's a pretty damn big pool to pick some doctors and engineers out of. Sikhs, not even 19 million. Yet, at the very least, we're matching your success (if not outright leaving you in the dust) in the West. Now, I'm not blaming the average Hindu for this. It's not their fault. It's the way their society has been formed and the way it runs. They've had to put up with such limitations as the caste system. This has left large sections of Hindu society demoralised and broken (although some sikhs may still practice the caste system, it's nowhere close to what it's like in some Hindu states). These same issues have ended up affecting all of India. Look, I'm not trying to be offensive, but face reality. Punjab and Haryana are pretty similar. Yet Punjab is much ahead of Haryana, despite everything that has happened to Punjab. What's the reason for this? Simple. One state has a majority Sikh population, the other doesn't. In fact, where-ever in India that Sikhs have settled, they have thrived, especially in comparison to the other inhabitants.

Re: Pictorial: Sikhs Get Hindustani Justice!

Siddharth · 15 Aug 2005

<> That is true. My point was that in the west, where the rules are equal, if 100 Hindus and 100 sikhs come to make a living, chances are that, ten years down the line, Hindus will have the same, if not better, standard of living than the Sikhs. Why? Because the rules are even for all to succeed (not withstanding the gora racism). I agree when you say that the same 200 people, if in India would have a much lower standard of living. Also, I never said that India does not have its problems and I think our politicians have a great deal to do with this and yes, the caste system, to this day, remains the heaviest shackle for us Indians. Hope we can throw out this sytem in the next 50-100 years. Best regards, Sid.

Re: Pictorial: Sikhs Get Hindustani Justice!

virdee · 15 Aug 2005

can anybody tell me where i can get a tract or book about ragmalla. because i don't think it is gurbani i want to find out more. i think it was written by a hindu poet "aalim" any help "please"

Re: Pictorial: Sikhs Get Hindustani Justice!

**- · 15 Aug 2005

---- Look, I'm not trying to be offensive, but face reality. Punjab and Haryana are pretty similar. Yet Punjab is much ahead of Haryana, despite everything that has happened to Punjab. What's the reason for this? Simple. One state has a majority Sikh population, the other doesn't. In fact, where-ever in India that Sikhs have settled, they have thrived, especially in comparison to the other inhabitants. ---- By using this logic, we can therefore conclude that the female infanticde problem in Punjab is due to the majority Sikh population as well? You will probably reply that it is due to Punjabi culture - but how come Hindu Punjabis do not face this type of problem of having to marry Hindu women outside Punjab like the Sikhs have to? [%sig%]

Re: Pictorial: Sikhs Get Hindustani Justice!

Singh · 15 Aug 2005

Sitara, I knew one of you would bring this up. We talk about the economic success of the Sikhs as compared with the rest of Indians, and you, being unable to face this reality, bring in some other completely unrelated issue. Well, no problem. We can talk about infanticide if you want. You're right, it is a bigger problem in punjab than in many other places. (Although there are places in Rajistan and other states where they predict that eventually several guys will be married to a single women). The issue here is that the 'sikhs' have lost their sikhi. If they had remained committed sikhs, we wouldn't see this problem. We would also see even greater economic success. Because the truth of the matter is, Punjab isn't doing as well economically as it could be. The average people are worse off than they were a couple of decades ago (although still much better than non-sikh Indians). Due to reasons that can be discussed in some other thread (such as genocide), Sikhs are losing their sikhi. They are becoming like typical Indians and are even outdoing Indians. They are taking on Bipran kee reet. Guru Gobind Singh Jee told us that if we give up the way of the Khalsa and become like you, we will fall hard. That's what you're seeing today in Punjab. The secret behind the success of punjab was sikhi. Not the people we call 'sikhs' but the sikhi being followed by these people. If these people start losing sikhi, they will lose everything and become typical Indians. The silver lining here is, that there is hope not only for Punjab but for all of India. If it's Sikhi that is behind the success of Punjab, than this Sikhi can make all of India successful. If someday the Indian people wake up and gain some common sense, they'll give up their useless lifestyles and get on the path of Guru Nanak Dev Jee. Then, you'll see real success.

Re: Pictorial: Sikhs Get Hindustani Justice!

**- · 16 Aug 2005

Singh ji, I didn't mean to bring this up in order to upset you, but rather to highlight futility of assigning material success or failiure to religion - this is what Semitic religions always do. When I was young I used to think like this but one thing life has taught me is that not everything in life - or the world - is 'black and white'. Material success, on an individual level, is more to do with ones karma - this is what Sikhi stresses. Also I think Sikhi is more lofty in that it goes beyond and above worldly persuits. As a Hindu myself, I readily admit that Gurmat encourages gender equality more so than Hinduism does. I also agree with you that if Sikhs in Punjab followed Gurmat properly they would not experience shortages of Sikh females. Regarding your concluding comments; as I said material success cannot be assigned to a particular religion. Look at the huge disparity of wealth and standard of living one can see accross the Islamic world. Hope you have no hard feelings God bless you, Sitara [%sig%]