Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

"Lakhriya" or "Rakhriya" in Sikhi

"Lakhriya" or "Rakhriya" in Sikhi

Question Singh · 10 Aug 2005

Could some1 explain whether Sikhs should tie "Lakhriya" - when the sisters tie them on the brothers or is this a Hindu tradition. Some ppl say that Guru Nanak Dev Ji's sister Bibi Nanaki used to tie a Lakhri on Guru Nanak Dev Ji, is this true?? Also, after the "miya" at a wedding, many sikh families tie these red strings on every1's wrists there - whats that about - is it real sikh wedding tradition or another Hindu one mixed into Sikh weddings?? What are the Sikh views on these traditions and what facts r there to back up ur views? thanks wjkk wjkf [%sig%]

Re: "Lakhriya" or "Rakhriya" in Sikhi

charanjeev singh · 10 Aug 2005

Singhs have nothing to do with strings. Period.

Re: "Lakhriya" or "Rakhriya" in Sikhi

**- · 10 Aug 2005

I agree with Charanjeev Singh's stance on Rakhri. Sikhs should refrain from this Hindu celebration if they are sincere in maintaining their distinctiveness. This is the first step and the rest will follow; hopefully in time Hindus will respect the independance of the Sikh quom and we can all live in peace with each other. Regards Sitara [%sig%]

Re: "Lakhriya" or "Rakhriya" in Sikhi

Question Singh · 11 Aug 2005

But DID Guru Nanak Dev Ji's Sister tie a rakhri on Guru Ji, or is this a made up story with all them pictures of it aswell.......................and what is all the wedding miya red strings about?? wjkk wjkf

Re: "Lakhriya" or "Rakhriya" in Sikhi

sahibzaadiyan dee prerna · 11 Aug 2005

Shame on us being Sikhs and shame on the gurdwara commitees who even let the people tie Rakhrees on the legs of guru granth sahib ji's manjee and the pillars around. Gurdwara comittees duty to stop and guide saadh sungut

Re: "Lakhriya" or "Rakhriya" in Sikhi

ssingh · 11 Aug 2005

"But DID Guru Nanak Dev Ji's Sister tie a rakhri on Guru Ji, or is this a made up story with all them pictures of it as well.......................and what is all the wedding miya red strings about??" There are no "facts" of the type you seek; anyone can make up whatever sort of story they want to believe in and draw pictures of it, and they do. Therefore "stories" can not be used as fact, and offering up one as evidence is meaningless. People, not just "Hindus/RSS", will put all efforts to legitimize their lifestyle, practices; evidence is the plethora types of Sikhs, many claiming contrary truths. In Guru Granth Sahib you'll see that familial bonds, etc. are described as fake, temporary, etc. (you will find plenty phonies claiming that this is not interpreted in proper "context") and stress is on recognizing them as so; therefore tying a string to show the strength of these ties is hypocritical. hypocrisy and duality is also condemned. For those who will argue, the gatra is a string, hair is like nails - dead, and kachhera is a cloth - if we don't wear one string/cloth, why substitue with another ? Same basic idea, just in a different form (typical wimpy Sikh style). In the context of the previous paragraph, you're attempts at shirking these necessary features of a Sikh as Extremist Ignorant fundamentalism only highlights your phoniness.

Re: "Lakhriya" or "Rakhriya" in Sikhi

Kaur · 11 Aug 2005

http://www.sikhwomen.com/equality/social/IndianTraditions.htm Traditions can be healthy and give us a sense of stability and belonging in our communities and society. On the other hand, unhealthy traditions and rituals such as Rakhee, Lohri, Kurva Chauth, dowry etc... while may be acceptable to some cultures, they are not in concert with the Sikh way of life. Those traditions that glorify male gender preference or encourage female neglect and perpetuate the view of a woman, a wife, a mother, a daughter as a liability are not in keeping with the Sikh teachings. The Sikh Gurus encouraged women to be independent and share social and religious responsibilities rather than be subservient, docile or dependent. "Rituals without understanding is idolatry. Rituals themselves are not bad, lack of one's quest behind one is" -Anonymous Naam, the name of God is above all religious rituals, good deeds, or worship. Guru Arjan, Page 405, line 9 Those who are faithful do not follow empty religious rituals. Guru Nanak Page 3, line 9 Pilgrimages, fasts, rituals, religious ceremonies or empty worship are all in vain. Salvation is achieved only by devoting worship to God. Guru Nanak, Page 75, Line Those who engage in empty rituals will never be free of the cycle of reincarnation. Guru Arjan, Page 297, line 16. Many engaging in ceremonial rituals and mislead others. This lack of true understanding distants one from God and brings about suffering and pain. Guru Nanak, Page 1332, line 6 Rakhee Tying a rakhee (rakhri) is implying that a female cannot fend for herself and is dependent upon her brother to protect her and implying that she is weak and incapable of being independent. Could the one who endures hours of labor pain and overcomes a lifetime of financial, academic, social challenges to raise and sustain her family be weak? Not by any means. Once could argue that a lovely gesture it would be for a brother to tie a rakhee to his sister to acknowledge her significance in his life. However, that too would be against Sikh way of life since tying threads or any ritual that does not glorify the Lord is discouraged. In this case two wrongs would not make a right. [%sig%]

Re: "Lakhriya" or "Rakhriya" in Sikhi

--Guest-- · 13 Aug 2005

I think its Rakriya this Friday 19th August 05. Thought i'd mention that lol.