Jagdish Tytler resigns as Union Minister
Bhopinder Singh · 10 Aug 2005
Jagdish Tytler resigns as Union Minister
Press Trust of India
New Delhi, August 10, 2005
»
Union minister Jagdish Tytler on Wednesday resigned from the Union Cabinet.
He met Congress President Sonia Gandhi and submitted his resignation which he requested her to forward to Prime Minister Manmohan Singh.
Tytler said he had met the Prime Minister and had told him that he would be meeting Gandhi.
"Why I should put the party in trouble. I want my name to be cleared expeditiously," Tytler said adding he was not doing it under pressure but on his own.
He also said he was not claiming any high moral bound by taking this decision.
Asked whether he felt the party had not backed him, the minister said "the party has backed me 100 per cent."
"Then why are you resigning," he was asked. "I want my name to be cleared," he shot back.
Tytler said "nobody has put pressure on me. I did it on my own".
He said "I am part of the Congress party. I am an MP. I will have to look after my constituency. I will now have more time to do this".
Tytler accused the media of "hyping up" the issue and pronouncing him guilty without going into all aspects.
The minister hoped that an inquiry is held at the earliest.
The defeat of the Opposition-sponsored adjournment motion in the Lok Sabha has clearly exposed them. They lost by a big margin, 254 going against them and only 128 voting in its favour, he said.
Government ready to reopen 1984 Sikh riots case
The Opposition-sponsored adjournment motion on Nanavati Commission's report on 1984 anti-Sikh violence was on Wednesday night defeated in the Lok Sabha as Prime Minister Manmohan Singh promised that Government will take steps for reopening and reexamining specific cases referred to in the probe report.
In a division, the motion was defeated by 254 members voting against it and 128 in its favour with one abstention. The allied Left parties, which had joined the Opposition in demanding action against those named in the Commission's report, voted against the motion.
Union Minister Jagdish Tytler and Lok Sabha member Sajjan Kumar, both named in the report, entered the House just ahead of the voting. NDA Chairperson Atal Bihari Vajpayee was conspicuous by his absence during the voting, participated in by UPA Chairperson Sonia Gandhi, Leader of the House Pranab Mukherjee and Leader of the Opposition LK Advani.
In his intervention in the debate on the motion, the Prime Minister did not make any specific reference to Union Minister Jagdish Tytler or Congress MP Sajjan Kumar and other party leaders against whom the Nanavati Commission had made recommendations for action, a demand strongly voiced by the Opposition and allies the including Left parties.
"Wherever the Commission has named any specific individuals as needing further examination or specific cases needing reopening and reexamination, the Government will take all possible steps to do so within the ambit of law.
"This is a solemn promise and solemn commitment to this House," Singh said in an emotional speech during a debate on the Opposition adjournment motion on Government's "inaction" on the report of the Commission that went into the anti-Sikh violence in the capital in 1984.
The Prime Minister noted that the Commission had also observed that "there is absolutely no evidence that Rajiv Gandhi or any other high-ranking Congress leaders had suggested or organised attacks" on Sikhs in the wake of Prime Minister Indira Gandhi's assassination.
Replying to the debate, Shiromani Akali Dal leader SS Dhindsa said that if Government was sincere about meting out justice, it should take back the Action Taken Report (ATR) on the Commission's report and set up fast-track courts to try Tytler and others named by the probe panel in a time-bound manner.
SGPC chief demands PM's resignation
SGPC President Jagir Kaur on Wednesday demanded resignation of Prime Minister Manmohan Singh for his "failure" to take action against the guilty Congress leaders "involved" in the 1984 anti-Sikh riots.
"If he (Manmohan Singh) has conscience he should either resign or take action against the guilty Congress leaders", she told reporters after addressing the protest rally in the wake of tabling of the Nanavati Commission's report and the Government's Action Taken Report on it.
Replying to a question regarding issue of notices to her and other functionaries of the Sikh Gurdwara Parbandhak Committee by the Sikh Judicial Commission (SJC) for alleged misappropriation of funds to the tune of Rs 70 crore, she said it was a "conspiracy hatched by the Congress government" in Punjab to "malign the image of the Sikh institution."
She accused the SJC of acting at the behest of congress government to tarnish the image of SGPC.
She also said that action would be taken against students of medical colleges run by SGPC if they did not pay their dues within a fortnight. The SGPC President, however, did not clarify on what step would be taken against the defaulting students in the NRI quota.
Earlier addressing the rally against the Centre, Jagir Kaur appealed the Sikhs "unite and teach a lesson to Congress.
[%sig%]
Re: Jagdish Tytler resigns as Union Minister
Bhopinder Singh · 10 Aug 2005
NO it doesn't
AT the same time he resigned because BJP would have put pressure on US to refuse him entry
Just like MODI he is implicated but not charged (FIR)
Also he was incharge of NRI affairs
Congress is not strong in centre it is supported by left parties
Re: Jagdish Tytler resigns as Union Minister
Kulbir Singh · 10 Aug 2005
Why two Sikh cops were shunted out on Nov 1
Sidharth Mishra / New Delhi
Though under much fire for downplaying the role of the Congress leadership in the 1984 carnage of Sikhs, the Nanavati Commission report has tell-tale signs of the involvement of the Government of the day in the planned pogrom. The report points out that Sikh officials were removed from strategic position soon after the death of Prime Minister Indira Gandhi and replaced with officers who are facing charges of facilitating the massacre that followed.
1984 anti-Sikh pogrom
The voluminous report in its Part III titled Evidences, mentions the case of Subzi Mandi police station of north district. The area falls under the Sadar parliamentary constituency which was then and now represented by Mr Jagdish Tytler. This area was under the charge of Inspector Gurmel Singh, who was the Station House Officer (SHO), and overall supervision of Assistant Commissioner of Police (ACP) Kewal Singh.
Both these officials were removed from their charge on the morning of November 1, 1984. Raghbir Singh Malik and Jai Bhagwan Malik were directed to take charge of the area as the ACP and SHO. The commission report on page 53 mentions:
"Another incident in which 10 Sikhs were killed in Kabir Basti deserves to be noted. They were burnt alive and according to Smt Pritam Kaur, her husband and son were dragged out of the house and burnt alive. All this had happened in presence of ACP Raghbir Singh Malik and Station House Officer Jai Bhagwan Malik. She has also stated that instead of preventing the mob from doing so, they were telling it, 'Do not spare anyone. Do not leave any evidence.'
Smt Balwinder Kaur, widow of Lakhbir Singh, Smt Balwinder Kaur, widow of Jagjit Singh, Smt Swaran Jeet, widow of Balbir Singh, Smt Inder Jeet Kaur, widow of Jaswant Singh, and Smt Lajwanti Kaur, widow of Darshan Singh, have also filed affidavits and supported what Pritam Kaur stated. An FIR in respect of this incident was registered but it did not mention that so many Sikhs were killed."
It would be pertinent to mention here that the transfer of officers of the rank of assistant commissioners of police is notified only after an approval on the proposal by the Lieutenant-Governor. Therefore, then Lt-Governor PG Gavai cannot absolve himself of his complicity, which has been rightly pointed out by the commission.
It may also be mentioned that the Delhi Police functions directly under the command and control of the Ministry of Home Affairs of the Union Government. The Commissioner of Delhi Police reports to this Ministry on a daily basis on the law and order situation of the Capital.
Re: Jagdish Tytler resigns as Union Minister
Kulbir Singh · 10 Aug 2005
Manmohan talk behind Tytler walk out of govt
Nanavati report: Even before he buried ATR and announced fresh line of action, Prime Minister had asked Tytler to quit
EXPRESS NEWS SERVICE
Posted online: Thursday, August 11, 2005 at 0231 hours IST
NEW DELHI, AUGUST 10: Even before intervening in the Lok Sabha debate on the 1984 anti-Sikh riots, Prime Minister Manmohan Singh had made up his mind on Union Minister of State for NRI Affairs Jagdish Tytler. And by the time he buried the ATR to unspool a fresh line of action, Singh had already asked Tytler to quit, making him the first Congress minister to be removed from the UPA Government.
Soon after the House rejected — 254 to 128 — the Opposition-sponsored adjournment motion, Tytler met Congress president Sonia Gandhi and handed over his ‘‘voluntary resignation’’. But his fate had been sealed during a meeting with the Prime Minister at 2.30 pm.
Faced with a tough call to combat the Opposition and Left criticism and protect Congress’ credibility among the Sikhs, the Prime Minister had told Tytler to resign.
The Nanavati Commission had recommended necessary action against Tytler, arguing there was ‘‘credible’’ evidence against him and he ‘‘very probably’’ had a hand in the anti-Sikh violence.
Trying to make a virtue of a compulsion, Tytler later told reporters: ‘‘Does it look good to say that I will stick to my post and face the inquiry?’’
Only yesterday, a defiant Tytler had told the media: ‘‘Why should I resign? The party and the Government are fully with me.’’
Today, a chastened Tytler even offered an explanation, ‘‘Since the media and the Opposition have created a perception to the whole world that we have done something fishy, I think what the Prime Minister has done (by offering a fresh probe) is right.’’
Reaching out to the Sikh community, which backed the Congress only recently after years of alienation, the Prime Minister has declared that ‘‘wherever the commission has named any specific individuals as needing further examination or specific cases needing re-opening and re-examination, the government will take all possible steps to do so within the ambit of law.’’ A re-examination implies a fresh inquiry into Tytler’s role and re-opening of cases against Sajjan Kumar.
Singh has made two more promises — action against erring government and police officials and rehabilitation of riot-victims. He said the government will try to book the guilty officials ‘‘to the maximum extent possible.’’ This would bring the role of the then Police Commissioner S.C. Tandon under a scanner. The PM said ‘‘it may be considered late in the day’’ to talk of rehabilitation of families of victims, but the Government ‘‘will try to ensure that the widows and children of those who suffered in this tragedy are enabled to lead a life of dignity and self-respect.’’
The PM, who described himself as a ‘‘student of politics’’, displayed immense finesse in balancing his loyalty to the Nehru-Gandhi family with the efforts to touch an emotional chord with the Sikhs. He referred to the assassination of Indira Gandhi, ‘‘a great national leader’’, ‘‘in her own courtyard,’’ the contribution made by Jawaharlal Nehru in Punjab’s development and Rajiv Gandhi’s role in restoring peace in the state through an accord with Sant H.S. Longowal. Along side, he cautioned Akalis against fanning ‘‘discontent’’ among the youth in Punjab and said: ‘‘Punjab is again on the move’’ and ‘‘we have an obligation to contribute to that process.
Re: Jagdish Tytler resigns as Union Minister
Amandeep Madra · 11 Aug 2005
If the Express story is true and Tytler was pushed by Manmohan Singh then that is a small silver lining to this very dark cloud.
Singh has provaricated and dithered on this issue -politics in India is pretty brutal and he would have had prior knowledge of the Nanavati findings, he shoudl have had Tytler resign immeditely on its publication and should now be prosecuting him and others who were named whatever their age and health state. Even that response is mild justice in comparison to what happened in Delhi in 1984. Announcing possible further investigations and reports simply wont do anymore.
Advani's passionate pleas for justice was laughable yesterday - this from the man and the party that sat in power (with an Akali coalition) and did absolutely nothing.
Re: Jagdish Tytler resigns as Union Minister
search for tat · 11 Aug 2005
is just a resignation enough? we need to push for a prosecution!!