Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Dalit - Jat Conflict in Punjab

Dalit - Jat Conflict in Punjab

Jagraj Singh · 09 Aug 2005

This is the first part in a series of articles at this website called tehelka. ++++++++ The Dalit Voice Part I Conflict Zone Desraj Kali Journalist If we want to understand the dalit scenario in Punjab, then we must explore all the dimensions of the recent Talhan conflicts in the state, in which there was an intense landlord-dalit conflict. This is because this issue highlights the social, economic and political situation of dalits in Punjab, which has a huge dalit population. In the backdrop of this issue we must not ignore the fact that during and after the 1857 mutiny, elite Sikhs proved to be useful for the British. Under the 1901 Punjab Land Alienation Act, and till about 1940, around 40 lakh acres of land was given as property to landlords, mostly Jat Sikhs, but agricultural labourers did not get any such benefit. If we want to see the oppression of dalits and the domination of landlords vividly, this historical aspect should not be ignored. The Talhan issue highlights this important shift: according to the 2001 census the population of dalits in Punjab was 30 percent, in Talhan itself it was as high as 63 percent. Besides, dalits here are economically stronger and their economic self-reliance was not dependent on agriculture. Most of them are NRIs or they work in cities. The green revolution in Punjab had, in its wake, created several economic and social contradictions which created deep conflicts between dalits and Jat Sikhs. For instance, during this phase, in the Doab area, land price shot up massively. The landlords started capturing panchayati land also. Community spaces, garbage area for dalits, even land meant for public toilets was being captured. So much so, land allotted for dalits to build houses, or the houses allotted to them under the Indira Awas Yojana, was also being snatched from them, and this process continued. This is how in the name of Sikh faith, dalit spaces and the places of worship of minorities were either being captured or their symbols destroyed and the dominant religion’s symbols or religious buildings were imposed. The writer works with Navan Zamana, Jalandhar http://www.tehelka.com/story_main13.asp?filename=Cr081305Shadow_Lines.asp

Re: Dalit - Jat Conflict in Punjab

Talhan Sikh supporter · 09 Aug 2005

How typical, always blame the Jat. The author of the article tries to portray the Jats as if they had it easy and land was given to them on a silver platter. On the contrary, the Jats worked hard for their land, and land was only awarded to them when Sikh soldiers were allotted land in west Punjab (baar) areas of Lyalpur, Sargodha, Mintgumary(Sahiwal) etc as a means of payment to the soldiers. They did not receive it for free, but received it as a payment for their service in the military. The Baar area was a harsh dry wilderness before the Sikh farmers arrived there. Only with the hard work of those Sikh farmers did they turn that wilderness into the most productive area in all of Punjab. In 1947 those Sikh farmers did not even receive half of the land they lost during partition. After independence the congress awarded land to Chamars of doaba in order to secure Dalit votes. BTW, the above stated article is about Jat-Chamar conflict in doaba. When the Chamars were allotted the land in doaba, they did not know how to farm, and as a result sold the land they received for free from the Congress to the Jats at market price. How is this the fault of the Jats of Doaba if the Chamars are now landless? The Talhan incident was very cunningly misinterpreted by the English media of India. They made it into an inter-caste issue. On the contrary, it was a religious issue between Sikhs and Hindus of Talhan. The Sikhs being the Jats and the Hindus being the Chamars. The Hindus(Chamars) of Talhan all of whom are MONNAY(hair cutters) and believed in Bhagat Ravidas Jee as “Guru Ravidas” wanted to become committee members of the Talhan Gurdwara which earns an estimate 5 crore rupees a year. The committee refused on the grounds that far from being Sikhs, none were even Keshadaris. The Chamars who numbered more than 2/3 of Talhan decided to gather in number and invade the Gurdwara and take control of it forcibly. The Sikhs who number at just 10% of the village heroically defended the Gurdwara from the invading Hindu Chamar gang and even gave them a beating. After their humiliating defeat from a hand full of Sikhs, the Chamars of Talhan got the chamar political party BSP of Kanshi Ram involved and tried to portray the issue as being a Jat discrimination against the poor Chamars which was a total lie. The English media which craves for such stories decided to go with the Chamar version of the story. Adding a bit more their own ‘Masala’ to the already one sided twisted version of the story, the media portrayed the Jats as the villains and oppressors. [%sig%]

Re: Dalit - Jat Conflict in Punjab

Jagraj Singh · 09 Aug 2005

In my experience, Jat hatred and caste superiority towards dalits is widespread.

Re: Dalit - Jat Conflict in Punjab

singh · 09 Aug 2005

Dalits suffer widespread hate from all castes. It wouldn't be a problem if people didn't recognize caste in the first place. By labelling it a Jat problem won't do it justice. If tomorrow all who call themselves Jats ceased to exist, caste superiority would still be widespread. I think its a problem of the entire society bar none in India. Sikhs can learn a lot from the Dalit community. They have their own media and aren't afraid speaking out when injustices occur. They have written quite a bit about human rights in Punjab in the Dalit Voice and other publications.

Re: Dalit - Jat Conflict in Punjab

j · 09 Aug 2005

"Tali ik hath naal nahi vajdi" im sure both are at fault, jatts and dalits. Few years ago i was in Panjab and when we were picked up at the airport the drivers had kirpans hidden, and a relative of mine had a long kirpan because it was common that dalits would see cars of NRI's and then pass on the info ahead, then they would surround the cars and rob the passengers.

Re: Dalit - Jat Conflict in Punjab

Pardeep Singh Bilga · 09 Aug 2005

Yes- don't blame Jatts for anything and everything that goes wrong- face it, without the Jatts, Panjab would not be a productive as it is and there would probably be a wheat shortage in India.

Re: Dalit - Jat Conflict in Punjab

mussapuria · 10 Aug 2005

why do punjabis and sikhs believe in caste in the first place? dalits may have a point but they put jatts into the same category as oppressive brahmins, but its not that bad. The truth is there is perhaps not a hatred but a superior social heirarchical outlook where everyone has this notion its almost a tradition to look down on chammars. But the reality is chammars are doing very well in todays commerical sense, not as bad as the papers say. I think we all owe it to the motherland of punjab to not look down on each other, that in turn may breed some sort of fraternal feelings into chammars who are 30% of punjab. If both sides make no efforts what use is divide and rule?

Re: Dalit - Jat Conflict in Punjab

mussapuria · 10 Aug 2005

J ji how did your uncle know they were dalits? could they noty have been migrants from other states?

Re: Dalit - Jat Conflict in Punjab

saran · 10 Aug 2005

one thing i find hard to digest. caste seems to embedd hindu society more in Guru jis time in hindus and now its more in sikhs. Like where did it come from how comes it has such a big holdon us now that grown men fight over it? when you look at paratan texts they point to sikhs from different areas malwa majha kabal delhi rajistan. At least 40 50% of ruling jatt clans in malwa claim a rajput ancestry with a definitive social patterns that resemble rajput culture ie dhadi vars, dress, weopons, including many clan names. It looks to me like wealth has spoild sikhs anbd set them against each other. When our old were poor we were one.

Re: Dalit - Jat Conflict in Punjab

S Singh · 10 Aug 2005

There was more to the Talhan clashed than has been reported. I know a few people form Talhan and they said the clashes started when "dalit" youths verbally abused some "jat" girls. After the jat kicked off the dalits turned it into a caste based incident and conveniently forgot the abuse of the girls.

Re: Dalit - Jat Conflict in Punjab

Talhan Sikh supporter · 10 Aug 2005

The Talhan incident was NOT an inter-caste issue as the Indian English media made it out to be. It was a religious issue between the Sikh and Hindus of Talhan. The Chamars of Talhan are NOT Sikhs, in fact they are not even Keshadharis. They are Hindus, which is quite evident from the fact that they identify themselves as ‘Hindus’ in the Indian census, they don’t even have Sikh names for God sake! Yet they have the audacity to demand membership in Talhans Sikh Gurdwara committee. After the refusal of the committee and their attempted forcible take over of the Gurdwara by a large Hindu chamar gang failed miserably, they twisted the story by turning it into an inter-caste conflict. Take a look at the two pictures below to see the two opposing sides. The first picture is of the Hindu Chamars of Talhan and the second one is of the Sikhs of Talhan with DDT activists: Hindu Chamar riotors. Do these look like Sikhs or Hindus to you? Talhan Sikhs along with DDT activists at the village Talhan. These people are clearly very identifiable as Sikhs. Admin jee, please don’t block this post from going through. It is very important for this discussion. [%sig%]

Re: Dalit - Jat Conflict in Punjab

j · 10 Aug 2005

J ji how did your uncle know they were dalits? could they noty have been migrants from other states? ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------- No mussapuria, it was definitley Dalits/Chamars whatever you want to call them, it was around the same time there were curfews being imposed in Jallandher, due to the rioting between them and Jats. People from his pind had been attacked and robbed prior to this, hence this time they were armed. On a side note, are the 'Ravidasis' also Dalits?

Re: Dalit - Jat Conflict in Punjab

Singh di Anakh · 10 Mar 2006

I agree with ‘Talhan Sikh supporter’. Most people here are under the false impression that Chamars in the Talhan incident were Sikhs. Anyone who comes from Janadhar-Hushiarpur area knows full well that Chamars are NOT Sikhs. They are Hindu, have hindu names, practice Hindu customs. Their only link with the Sikhs is that they read Bhagat Ravidas's bani. But they also try to portray him as a Guru. That's why they call him 'Guru Ravidas Dev Jee' and worship his pictures which they tried to install at the Talhan Gurdwara parallel to Guru Granth Sahib Jee. The Sikhs of Talhan could not tolerate this blasphemy. I think that people need to read more Punjabi news papers rather than relying on the leftist pro-Dalit/Chamar English propaganda. They are politically motivated. Their leader Kanshi Raam took a stand against the Sikhs of Talhan and supported the Hindu Chamars while they tried their best to force their blasphemous will over the Sikhs using hooliganistic tactics like their badly failed attempt to take over the Talhan Gurdwara, then many of their youths even harassed a young Sikh girl because of which the brothers of the Sikh girl gave them a beating they will never forget! Kanshi Ram also supported Mayavati (another Chamar leader) of UP when she tried her best to seize farm lands away from the Sikhs of UP. These people are no friends of the Sikh nation. [%sig%]

Re: Dalit - Jat Conflict in Punjab

caste will go · 11 Mar 2006

the caste system of india itself is the ultimate root of the problem. to a nam reciting bani reading sikh there should be no jatt or chamar otherwise they conflict with the bani they c onsider God on earth right now. when Real nam rassieyeh khalsa rule under sikh theology every1 should be equal, land should be distributed equally and people should breathe freely with the same chances out away of poverty. Maharaja ranjit singh was a don in sikh history, but land was also snatched away from ie ramgharias land was annexed by ranjit singh and handed out to some landless jatts on other missals. Its strange how under the so called sikh empire ranjit singh time political power was even distributed to high caste hindus ie rajputs, khatris dogars, and muslims yet the same power or uplitfment wass not evident among chamars, dhobbis, weavers, washermen, jeers, nais, terkans, surely they were not all hindus? if they were hindus why did the khatris and rajputs gain land they too were hindus? fighting over land will make sikhs fight like dogs. The point should never be jatts or chammars are the trouble makers, but as to where the problem starts and and how things should be sorted sikh khalsa style not punjabi style cos that may too conflict with what Guru Gobind singh was trying to create on earth Total equality and love for man with no labels. of course snatching land from sikhs be they jatt tirkan by chammars whether sikh or hindu is wrong, but the issue may erhaps be caste and not religion. The state of india fails to protect the hard working jat because chamars are slowly becoming majority. The chammar has also suffered, the real problem is the caste system which needsa to be abolished for the safety of india or india may become divided with a 300 million majority discontent, thats bigger than even the muslim majority. Once the dalits decide they are no longer hindus, carve themselves out of poverty with a religion thats the end of india if it continues with the caste system. The ramifications of the past are present dividing man from man. The future lies in development hopefully where india is heading, lets hope technology increases, with that education chances to break out of poverty. Po verty itself is no excuse to grab anothers right. as far as i am aware some ravidasis in england are sikh others may be christians buddhists and few may be hindu, i have no idea if ravidasis are the same thing as dalits. maybe someone else can enlighten us. Land grabbing is very common in india chammars are not the only ones who do it. My grandfather has been double crossed ouit of land in south delhi case is going on now , and we even have our own grandfathers brother trying to take over my grandads share in the ancestral plot in bara pehnd guraiyah punjab. so like who do you blame? i am confident caste will go, the world is becoming globalised, the west is investing heavily in india and the impoverished are increasingly becoming empowered. Lets not use religion to divide man but to unite man, be hopeful of resolution. I too was a khattar castist till i saw how poor sikhs with full uncut kes dastars in south india struggled against all odds while i had cut hair drank water free and ate and lived under a warm house. They still held onto sikhi, how could they be any different to me? in fact it is they who are higher my heart bows to the jot of their jeevans which is illumined million times brighter than mine and can hopefully jaggah my soul more. i hope we can imbibe the spirit of chardi kala raj karega khalsa for future comings and base our decisions thoughts and answers on the reality propounded by Guru Gobind singh ji rather than give in to stereotypes created by maya. How beautiful Guru jis words are how wonderful His ideals are that if we once agree with them and feel the beauty the reality begins to open before our eyes. God made man from one soil mitti. We have one destination to go to, our house is Anandpur sahib, our mother and father is Guru Gobind Singh the panth is our family, the hand of friendship is open to all mankind whosoever recieves. Under the theology of sikhi all man is equal and so should their chances in life and being a gurmat site we should continously promote what Guru sahb himself promoted through ten mehels throughout to the khalsa baptism and after. The khalsa bought man from 5 castes to one. The problem lies only in ourselves, God is ocean of mercy if we even begin the path to spirituality today from manmukhi ideas God will welcome us, and khalsa raj will move closer to those who will be ready to die for it and establish a caste free pure land on earth. i may have gone a bit tip top but Sikhi is just tooooooooooo beautiful that with this caste crap we are missing the wonderful colours and ras between. We are all destined to be one again, so let us brothers and sisters rejoice in khalsa union under the canopy of God creation. SatSriAkalSahaiKhalistanzindabad.

Re: Dalit - Jat Conflict in Punjab

Singha Dhi Shaan · 11 Mar 2006

'Caste will go' jee, I think that you are confusing Ramgaria misl with the Tarkhan caste. They are not the same. This is a common misconception amongst the Tarkhans. First of all, the Ramgaria Misl was created by a Jatt. Jassa Singh Ramgaria was the second cheif of that misl. Not all the Sikh warriors in that misl were Tarkhans. Just because a leader of a misl is a Tarkhan does not mean the whole misl automatically became Tarkhan. It was a mix of Jatts, Tarkhans, Khatris, Mazbis just like the make up of other misls. Furthermore, Raja Ranjit Singh did not distribute Ramgaria land to landless Jats. You are acting as if all that land belonged to the Tarkhans. But that can't be because most of the Sikhs warriors in the Ragmaria misl themselves were of Jatt background. Furthermore, farming is not a Tarkhan profession. Farming in Punjab was traditionally done by the Jatts and Rajputs. The man who distribuded Land to the landless Jats was non other than Banda Singh Bahadur. Baba Banda Singh Bahadur seized land away from the Nawabs, Pathans, and Rangars and gave it to the poor Sikhs who worked on it. Baba Banda Singh Bahadur is a hero that the Sikhs will never forget. As for the Talhan incident, this was NOT a Jatt vs Chamar issue. This is a HUGE lie spread by the leftist Dalit propaganda machine to twist this story into something it was not. Truth of the matter is, this incident was a Hindu vs Sikh issue. The Hindus being Chamar, and the Sikhs being the Jats. The Chamars do not have Sikh names, don’t believe in keeping Kesh, and even identify themselves as “Hindu” in the Indian census, yet they wanted control over the Talhan Gurdwara. The Sikh committee refused ont eh grounds that far from being Amritdharis, you guys are not even Sikhs. Then the Chamars tried to forcibly take over the Gurdwara. Since they were more than 3/4 of the entire Talhan population, and the Jatts were just 10% of the population, the Chamars thought why not invade the Gurdwara and take control of it by force. The committee members were just a few Amritdhari men, but they were ready to die defending the Gurdwara against the invading Chamar militia. When the Chamars gathered in large numbers attempted to take control, they were beaten back by a hand full of Amritdhari Singhs armed with Kirpan. The Singhs faught with an iron will and proved the old saying “Sava laakh say ek larao” when they beat back the Hindu Chamar whose numbers were many times larger than the Amritdhari Sikhs defending the Gurdwara. After suffering from this humiliating defeat, the Chamars decided to harass a young Sikh girl. When the brothers of that girl found out, they gave another beating to the Hindu Chamars who had harassed their sister. Then these Chamars decided to start riots in Jalandhar city, where very few Jatts reside. This time they had the help of their friend and fellow Chamar, Kanshi Ram of the Bahujan Samaj Party. This is same Kanshi Ram who tried his best to seize land away from the hard working Sikhs of UP and distribute it for free to the Chamars of UP. The spineless media, just twisted this whole Talhan incident into something it was not. This was a Sikh vs Hindu conflict. Just take a look at the pictures posted by “Talhan Sikh supporter”. Do those Chamars in that picture even look like Sikhs to you? [%sig%]

Re: Dalit - Jat Conflict in Punjab

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 12 Mar 2006

Always "read between the lines"........look "under" the carpet...and "behind" the News....dont take everything as it is...lols.. Sikhs have many enemies...of all sorts , colours, and races...castes and such. If a person is a DALIT...then he is NOt an Amrtidharee and has his own agenda which may or may not be pro sikh....most probably not pro sikh. If a DALIT is pro sikh..he will become a SIKH and shed his DALITNESS....and then He is MOST WELCOME in a Sikh gurdawra MANAGEMENT... Kashi Raam and his Dalits were under the impression that the AKALIS won the elections due to DALIT SUPPORT..he soon found out the TRUTH when his BSP lost all their deposits in Punjab....one or two Dalits can win if they catch hold of the poochh of the Akali or Congress...but if like Kanshi raam they think they are the ELEPHANT.... they will find out they are just ANTS..a MILLION ANTS..and a million DALITS..same thing ALL DALITS should becoem AMRITDHAREES...and turn into Bhai Bachittar Singh Jis...who even put the ELEPHANTS to flight...

Re: Dalit - Jat Conflict in Punjab

caste will definatly go jio · 12 Mar 2006

dear singha di shaan i apologise for the misconception held by me and thank you for correcting me bhai sahib. due to my lack of knowledge on the issue of talhan and the area itself i cannot say anything to that effect. However having associated with certain singhs in akhand kirtan jatha in the uk who came from the jhajaru period i was fortunate to have met a few singhs and here i mean amritdhari singhs kes, dastar, panj kakars who took part in the struggle witnessed directly shaheed singhs we see on websites with limbs torn off and sewn back together, burnt on boiling cauldrons, eyes gauged out, salt poured on wounds, feet and hands chopped off, while the shaheed singhs under interrogation still were alive reciting nam simran, one of the surviving singhs who made it out of the trio from interrogation by Guru jis kirpa used to be what some of us call from chammar caste. the sangats within are well aware of who the kurbani giving singhs are. I was further shown pictures of shaheed parivars which the jatha has looked after where sons of hindus decided to become singhs in the movement and payed with shahadat, again these hindus were from the lower castes. Some jatha singhs in the uk constantly do parchar and have struggled to keep sikhi with their entire families disowning them yet with kirpa from Guru ji these singhs went to greater heights to develop the understanding of sikhi amongst the youth. Again these singhs came from chammars but upon taking amrit they are singhs and singhanis. If you wish you can attend rehsnbhai or samagam if in england and we can introduce you to singhs and singhania who are married with children that belong to no caste. perhaps in punjab you will have a greater insight than myself, all i know is that exposure to sikhi, gurbani, sangat, laha of kirtan, and Dasam patshahs jis hukam and the love singhs and singhanis in the panth have is at a different wavelentgh like a spiritual frequency transcending everything. perhaps my question should have been why did rajputs, khattris dogars all hindu upper class and muslims do better under the raj of raja ranjit singh than other man made castes? From my understanding the caste system itself is a big failure, and punjab can only rise out of such a pit when development is allowed so we do not rely on one or two industries. but opportunities open for men and women from all classes instead of like now migrating to dubai living 5 years away from wife and kids to find a job and make ends meet. Imagine myself and yourself working and living away from our wife and children for two rotis. Punjab needs development and sikh parchar. Ardas recited = sarbat da bhalla This world has enough division, west east, black white, indian pakistani, this is all contrary to gurmat and dasam patshahs bani which declares all man is one from the same source. In the realms of spirit their is no caste bhai. The world is a dream the reality is when we wake up on death. That moment there is no jatt or chammar. I attended a number of times sangat with ajit singh swindon, due to a few differences myself i no longer attend. Some of the guns i saw in being put into practice were every fortnight sangat met ajit singh constantly drilled into the sangat parchar on the five vices irkha and jaat paat and how we claim to be casteless yet recite ik oankar satnaam karta purakh on the other hand. He also promoted mone to attend sangat and for amritdharis to help support mone so we have no divisions. There were other areas where i did not agree on which is why i left, but the few guns i saw i believe should be constantly drilled out to drive jaat paat out and establish unity with all, even mone may one day enter sikhi. I have constantly seen repeated attempts by a few on divisions of caste within sikhs. I would like to say even the soho rd sants all 3 were different castes. One of these sants had recited 40 day 40 night simran with an ex panj pyara of the akj who has added rehits ontop of sarbloh. Singh on the level opf spirit there is no caste , grpups are transcended with love and naam . gurbani mentions how mankind looses its natural state by forming divisions and arguments. Therefore we have a problem on the ground in punjab, but what is the answer? i have met chammars who are sikh, some may be hindu. If jobs and industries are becoming outdated outsourced what should be done for the future? a realistic answer, development, like we have in the west, introduction of IT created jobs, increased population drives demands for other sectors. This is where punjab needs to pick up so all men and women get a chance to move forward and no irkha exists. if we continuesly live and then die with irkha what will we gain? will God be happy with us? with our lack of enthusiasm to solve affairs? I have deep respect for pakistani jatts i have met who display a brotherlike affection for sikhs. Whether they were chammars or jaat bhaiyeh aka chaudharis maliks etc makes no difference to myself, They have values to which they keep, family strentgh, women keep kes at least, chunnis, and still speak punjabi, i pray Guru ji may forever protect all our bhais and bhens. The jaats in hariana too complain about the brahmin bania nexus using politics to push them down, the jatts in rajistan or maybe jaats are having trouble with rajputs, if religion does not divide man then caste does divide and rule. but where will that road lead mankind? our shaheeds did not die for us to fall into another pit, we have to rise ourself, and help others rise and be victorious, and at the same time encourage sikh rehat and work towards khalsa raj where no caste will ever exist where all man will become one and take amrit from same bhatta no caste no group just one! I do not perhaps understand too much about lefties, i think mayb e you mean communism right? While i agree sikhi and communism fundamentally are incompatible on the basis of freedom, would there not be a few areas to which they are matched? ie equality, distribution of resources amongst all, etc. Not sure if bhai rama singhs book mentions it, but those around bhai sahib when he was in mortal frame would have heard about the visions of khalsa raj, the same vision seen by other gursikhs still alive. At the time bhai sahib had came across a central authority under khalsa raj which distributed on equal basis and parivars then spent time working a lesser part of the day we now work and more time with family.

Re: Dalit - Jat Conflict in Punjab

Dalbir · 12 Mar 2006

Same old....same old..... Jatts ARE responsible for bringing serious Hinduistic practices (via Maharajah Ranjit Singh) and seriously compromising the egalitarian basis of the Khalsa. Sometimes it seems as if we have replaced Brahmin nonsense in the Punjab with a Jatt equivalent. Nowerdays Sikh jatts are more caste conscious than the average Hindu. Yes, jatts have contributed lots to the Sikh cause but clowns like Brar (attacking the Golden Temple), and KPS Gill (Jatt who could give Mughal oppressors of Singhs a run for their money) leave a lot to be desired. Even in early Khalsa history many jatt tribes fought against the nascent Khalsa panth. If any jatt tells me that in general their community does not hold other 'castes' in contempt, he would either be naive or lying. For most jatts their religion is really landownership and showmanship rather than any Sikh ideology. They really are majorly responsible for ensuring that we do not see each other above our tribal consciousness and it makes me laugh how they fall over themselves to make excuses and defend themselves for doing this withoput even trying to change. Please try to remember Sikhism doesn't just belong to jatts...but to humanity. Over the years the foulness I have heard by jatts towards churay, chamars, tarkhans and bhatray is enough to make one sick. Just stop making excuses for your behaviour please and convert to Islam like many of your fellow jatt brothers did......or if u love caste so much stay in Hinduism. It's pretty difficult to tell people in the west about Sikhism and then have to explain why we still have caste although our Gurus condemned it.....thanks for keeping our society held back........

dalits conflict

caste free zone · 13 Mar 2006

please bhai sahib blaming anyone leads to the same road that castists want to promote, the same road parents have drilled into innocent children to divide them from other children pitting pure and innocent life force agaianst life force, the same road bjps and rss walked on to divide mankind on basis of caste. We all have to let go of caste sooner or later as the world breaks into new time conditions. the aim is to walk away from the road of caste. By reciprocating same feeling with feeling false impressions can be assumed giving credence to one of the biggest evils in the world. Guru sahib was a genius who took away false practices, we too must follow the footsteps of Our Spiritual Father, this was to eradicate the evil, spread goodness on earth, unite brothers and sisters from all areas tribes and races. There will come a time in future when sikhi will be welcome all over the world, a time when sikhs will be born outside punjabi castes and tribes. sikhism by nature unites all, the journey on rehat brings brothers together shoulder to shoulder, i would appeal to all our castist veers no matter what caste please attend any rensbhai kirtan samagam there you shall meet singhs and singhanis from various pathways who come onto the platform of sikhi and therafter their caste is no more, please ask these sikhs how they see each other? what they feel on the path to sikhism? different castes melted into one khalsa brothers one light, same thing in out. There is no jatt or chammar its all in your head, reality is only Guru, "pavanGurupanipittamatadharatmahat" we have to submit ourselves with love to the feet of God. here is an exerpt of a letter of two sikh martyrs bhai shaheed jinda and sukha ji, i hope our castist veers will listen to the message and adopt the strategy of khalsa with the interests of entire welfare of creation. It matters not if one is jatt anti jatt white brown or black let us break the shackles of man made divisions and rejoice in union under sikh spirit. The life giver sends us energy, we will never be at shortage under the mighty arms of the Protector, therefore we should have no fears, and walk on the path that will increase our community brotherhood whether kurbania are requiered or not, the mission will continue by Guru sahib kirpa, what has been started from Guru Nanak to Guru Gobind singh ji to rid the world of division will never die or lie totally dormant, singhs will one way or another take it higher, forward or else our existance becomes meaningless ritual. for now khalistani shaheed singhs qouted "Through you we also wish to transmit this message that we harbor no enmity towards the great people and land of India. We are not touched even a bit by hatred for the people of India. Not only to embrace our people, we are restless to embrace the whole of the earth and the sky. We intoxicatedly remember the entire cosmos and worship the life that vibrates in it. The Khalsa is inseparably and lovingly related to the people of India: the millions of Dalits, the workers who earn their living through honest labor, the Muslims and other minorities, and all those homeless and destitute who have remained oppressed and eloited by Brahmanism for centuries. They are all our kith and kin. Our Master Rider f the blue horse (Guru Gobind Singh) recognized them much earlier. All those termed by he proud Brahmin the lowly, scavengers, shoemakers, meanprofessioned, became the eloved sons of our Tenth Father. They rose to Generalships in the army of the Khalsa. hrones and honors kissed them. Without fantasizing, we are declaring in the midst of history that our gurus loved the meta-poetry (bani) of those divine souls drenched with a passion for the Dalit brotherhood. The gurus bestowed the highest honors on them and included their (bani) along with their own in the Guru Granth Sahib. The spirit of the Dalits and their pain are aspects of our own anguish. We are touched by the warmth of their door. There is hardly any Agro Industry in the Punjab. Heavy industry is totally non-existent. We want to keep our capital safe for our development, but you are exploiting us as if we are your colony. " shaheeds bhai sahibs jinda and sukha ji bhai brotherhood is for all man, we have a journey towards khalsa raj from kal yug. We have a sacred mission in front of us, there are no man made messiahs to lead us we have to take the torch from one century to the next. This torch does not begin or end in punjab india or with any tribe. Land is given by the Benefactor Himself, we must learn to walk in unison, raise our awareness, and do what must be done for the greater good for the future, if that so conflicts with our inbuilt prides prejudices cultures then such vair irkha zaat paat exists only in our minds limited to our lifecycles and affects no one but individual self while the world as per Akaal will constantly move on, where no being can escape the result of time. If i wanted i could have talked about womanising bullying issues that take place in many places, what will we ever gain? the panth has been forced to its knees, will one day gather pace, with determination and move ahead. bhai where is the caste? God bought you to the physical plane and gave you a coat to wear, the vesture will be taken from you after a few breathes. Thereis no special heaven or place for each specific caste,and whoesoever stands in the way of khalsa rss bjps indra ghandis kps gills ajit sandhus gobind rams kanshi rams aurangas abdalis will meet their fate, the khalsa will move in motion and finally become the only victor. the same khalsa under whos bbrotherhood no caste is permitted. Our destination is the same both in terms of spirit and what is required on planet earth, therefore there should be no line or division.

Re: Dalit - Jat Conflict in Punjab

Singha Dhi Shaan · 13 Mar 2006

Dalbir Singh, did anyone here say that Jats are better or higher than anyone else? This thread is about the lies spread about the incident that happened at Talhan by the leftist pro Dalit/Communist English media in India. It was the Hindu Dalits that were the aggressors against the minority Sikhs of Talhan. Yet gullible Sikhs who read only the English media just swallow whatever is fed to them by the leftist English media. You need to read Punjabi media to get the real story. It was a Hindu vs Sikh issue. Take a look at the following picture Dalbir Singh: Dalbir Singh do these ‘exploited’ Hindu Dalits armed with sticks (like the 84 Hindu rioters!) to use against Sikhs look like Hindu or Sikh to you? Would you want these Hindu chamars who beat Sikhs with such weapons to take over our Gurdwaras? I don’t know about you, but I would not want such people who don’t even want to keep Guru Jee’s mohar Kesh to take over our Gurdwaras. The committee of a Gurdwara should only comprise of Amritdhari Singhs, not Mona-Ghonas like these who beat Sikhs with weapons. Casteism is a social evil and needs to be eradicated. But at the same time we need to read all perspectives and not just one side of the story. Sikhs seem to have a really bad Bimaari (illness) that they will believe a non-Sikh over a Sikh. For example, if a Buddhist or Yogi says one thing about a spiritual matter they will swallow it immediately, but if a Chardi Kala Singh like Bhai Randhir Singh says the exact same thing, they will not believe it. This Bimaari also seems effect Sikhs who swallow what ever is spoon fed to them by the leftist pro Dalit/Communist English media. My views about casteism is that it should be finished. If a Sikh discriminates based on caste, then that Sikh needs to either stop calling himself a Sikh or just convert to another religion because caste based discrimination has no place for a Sikh. [%sig%]

dalits conflict

caste free zone · 13 Mar 2006

please bhai sahib blaming anyone leads to the same road that castists want to promote, the same road parents have drilled into innocent children to divide them from other children pitting pure and innocent life force agaianst life force, the same road bjps and rss walked on to divide mankind on basis of caste. We all have to let go of caste sooner or later as the world breaks into new time conditions. the aim is to walk away from the road of caste. By reciprocating same feeling with feeling false impressions can be assumed giving credence to one of the biggest evils in the world. Guru sahib was a genius who took away false practices, we too must follow the footsteps of Our Spiritual Father, this was to eradicate the evil, spread goodness on earth, unite brothers and sisters from all areas tribes and races. There will come a time in future when sikhi will be welcome all over the world, a time when sikhs will be born outside punjabi castes and tribes. sikhism by nature unites all, the journey on rehat brings brothers together shoulder to shoulder, i would appeal to all our castist veers no matter what caste please attend any rensbhai kirtan samagam there you shall meet singhs and singhanis from various pathways who come onto the platform of sikhi and therafter their caste is no more, please ask these sikhs how they see each other? what they feel on the path to sikhism? different castes melted into one khalsa brothers one light, same thing in out. There is no jatt or chammar its all in your head, reality is only Guru, "pavanGurupanipittamatadharatmahat" we have to submit ourselves with love to the feet of God. here is an exerpt of a letter of two sikh martyrs bhai shaheed jinda and sukha ji, i hope our castist veers will listen to the message and adopt the strategy of khalsa with the interests of entire welfare of creation. It matters not if one is jatt anti jatt white brown or black let us break the shackles of man made divisions and rejoice in union under sikh spirit. The life giver sends us energy, we will never be at shortage under the mighty arms of the Protector, therefore we should have no fears, and walk on the path that will increase our community brotherhood whether kurbania are requiered or not, the mission will continue by Guru sahib kirpa, what has been started from Guru Nanak to Guru Gobind singh ji to rid the world of division will never die or lie totally dormant, singhs will one way or another take it higher, forward or else our existance becomes meaningless ritual. for now khalistani shaheed singhs qouted "Through you we also wish to transmit this message that we harbor no enmity towards the great people and land of India. We are not touched even a bit by hatred for the people of India. Not only to embrace our people, we are restless to embrace the whole of the earth and the sky. We intoxicatedly remember the entire cosmos and worship the life that vibrates in it. The Khalsa is inseparably and lovingly related to the people of India: the millions of Dalits, the workers who earn their living through honest labor, the Muslims and other minorities, and all those homeless and destitute who have remained oppressed and eloited by Brahmanism for centuries. They are all our kith and kin. Our Master Rider f the blue horse (Guru Gobind Singh) recognized them much earlier. All those termed by he proud Brahmin the lowly, scavengers, shoemakers, meanprofessioned, became the eloved sons of our Tenth Father. They rose to Generalships in the army of the Khalsa. hrones and honors kissed them. Without fantasizing, we are declaring in the midst of history that our gurus loved the meta-poetry (bani) of those divine souls drenched with a passion for the Dalit brotherhood. The gurus bestowed the highest honors on them and included their (bani) along with their own in the Guru Granth Sahib. The spirit of the Dalits and their pain are aspects of our own anguish. We are touched by the warmth of their door. There is hardly any Agro Industry in the Punjab. Heavy industry is totally non-existent. We want to keep our capital safe for our development, but you are exploiting us as if we are your colony. " shaheeds bhai sahibs jinda and sukha ji bhai brotherhood is for all man, we have a journey towards khalsa raj from kal yug. We have a sacred mission in front of us, there are no man made messiahs to lead us we have to take the torch from one century to the next. This torch does not begin or end in punjab india or with any tribe. Land is given by the Benefactor Himself, we must learn to walk in unison, raise our awareness, and do what must be done for the greater good for the future, if that so conflicts with our inbuilt prides prejudices cultures then such vair irkha zaat paat exists only in our minds limited to our lifecycles and affects no one but individual self while the world as per Akaal will constantly move on, where no being can escape the result of time. If i wanted i could have talked about womanising bullying issues that take place in many places, what will we ever gain? the panth has been forced to its knees, will one day gather pace, with determination and move ahead. bhai where is the caste? God bought you to the physical plane and gave you a coat to wear, the vesture will be taken from you after a few breathes. Thereis no special heaven or place for each specific caste,and whoesoever stands in the way of khalsa rss bjps indra ghandis kps gills ajit sandhus gobind rams kanshi rams aurangas abdalis will meet their fate, the khalsa will move in motion and finally become the only victor. the same khalsa under whos bbrotherhood no caste is permitted. Our destination is the same both in terms of spirit and what is required on planet earth, therefore there should be no line or division. [%sig%]

Re: Dalit - Jat Conflict in Punjab

caste free zone · 13 Mar 2006

to clear any issues only first line of my request is aimed towards bhai dalbir singh.

Re: Dalit - Jat Conflict in Punjab

caste free zone · 13 Mar 2006

dearest singha di shaan i am not sure if you maybe aware of what bhai sahib sukhbir singh ji uncovered in the 1990s with interviews and photos of martyred sikhs, these were later plastered onto gurdwara noticeboards, the site was taken down by the government of india, i am not sure if singhs or singhnia copied some of the contents as they were invaluable. One of the articles by this sikh journalist were about dalit sikhs who were murdered in 1984 in delhi . Of course sikhs were sikhs and targetted, but bhai sukhbir singh ji payed attension to the fact many of the victims were dalits, and may have been targetted for the very caste they were by higher caste hindus. One sikh bibi witnessed helplessly all 3 of her children burnt and tortured to death, one by electric currents beatings torture and finally having a burning torch shoved into his mouth. sikh shaheed brother. these were dalits before they came to the path of sikh rehat who were sikhs but were murdered in cold blood, such kurbania and here we are on computer screens sitting warm. Bhai sukhbir singh ossan was a gursikh journalist who uncovered facts that are only slowly being unravelled till recent by other parties. He died mysteriously aged 32 after informing sikhs that he is under watch, having mailed opened and dealing with court orders. So this may bring us to another issue about some dalits may be sikh while others may be hindu, to which the khalsa there is no confusion.

Re: Dalit - Jat Conflict in Punjab

bezti · 13 Mar 2006

the oppression according to you then is hinduism and not chammarism bro. in that case you should say hindus, because there are loads of chammars who are sikhs, every paati on the tabia at ravidas place on grove rd birmingham is kesdhari amritdhari and there is even a sign stopping sants from coming to stage, in other places they lapse out of rehat agreed. we have loads of goondas pulling hairs out on elections jatt v jatt you might have heard of the case singh v singh in california where a singh was shot and kidnapped by money ghoney jatts, where money was used from pakistan and vancouver in a drugs triangle to fund bussinesses by criminals. that does not mean 1 10 100 200 or even 2000 jatts give all jatts a bad name i do not know why people are fascinated by castes for.

Re: Dalit - Jat Conflict in Punjab

Singha Dhi Shaan · 13 Mar 2006

Vah Jee Vah Bezti Jee, So you consider the Paati at the Ravidasi Gurdwara to be an 'Amritdhari'? even though they consider Bhagat Ravidas Jee as "Guru Ravidas Jee"? Even though these Ravidasis also lay claim that Guru Nanak Dev Jee received Naam from "Guru Ravidas Jee"? so in other words, they claim that Bhagat Ravidas Jee was the Guru of Guru Nanak Dev Jee! I dont know about you, but anyone with such blasphemous views is no Amritdhari Khalsa Sikh. Our first Guru was Guru Nanak Dev Jee, NOT Bhagat Ravidas Jee. We respect Bhagat Ravidas Jee as he was a Brahmgiani whose bani is in Guru Granth Sahib Jee, but he was NOT the Guru of Guru Nanak Dev Jee. The Chamars have done a disservice to the memory of Bhagat Ravidas Jee by turning him into the Guru. The same mistake Namdharis did when they started to turn a pious Sikh like Baba Ram Singh Jee into a Guru. Also, the Talhan Sikhs told the Hindu Chamars of Talhan that if they want to get into the Gurdwara committee then they will have to take Amrit like all the other committee members. They will not be able to become a committee member and remain a Mona-Ghona at the same time. I dont even know why you why you are calling the Talhan Hindus as "Sikhs". Just because they are ‘Dalit’ does not automatically mean they are right and everyone else is wrong. They are not Sikhs. They dont have Sikh names. Their names end with 'Chand', 'ram' or 'kumar'. They identify themselves as "Hindu" in the Indian census. So how the heck are they Sikh for God Sake? Should we now have non Sikhs into our Sikh Gurdwara committees? Because a person is a Dalit, he does not have to take Amrit? Are Dalits now beyond Amrit? Wow! Have you even looked at the picture of the Hindu rioters armed with sticks? These remind me of the 84 rioters who were killing Sikhs all over India. Do you want these rioting Hindus to become members in our committees? Kum Akl is a Bimaari in our people. The only people I see here who have given good input to this are Arshi Jee and 'caste free zone' jee. The rest need to read more Punjabi newspapers and stop relying on the English Media for all their info. We need to use our Akl and Syaanap, not moorakhta when it comes to religious and political issues. Seems to me alot of people don’t know much about this issue. Most of you are still confusing this issue as a 'caste' war between the Chamars and Jatts, just what the English Media fed you. This I repeat for the umpteenth time is a religious conflict between the Hindus and Sikhs, and NOT a Chamar vs Jatt issue. GO AKL GO!!! DOWN WITH MOORAKHTAA!!! DOWN WITH JAHILTAA!!!

Re: Dalit - Jat Conflict in Punjab

Singha Dhi Shaan · 13 Mar 2006

caste free zone Jee, I remember Sukhbir Singh Ossan from his site burningpunjab.com. His site was the best panthic site on the net. He did great seva while alive, and is missed by the panth. Though it is surprising that he died so young.

Re: Dalit - Jat Conflict in Punjab

teek taak · 14 Mar 2006

why are you nitpicking one caste? all punjabis who believe in castes have the rog. A jatt drinking and smoking is no different to a chammar smoking or drinking so both b ad for committees. If one has name sandhu other has name raj rampal whatever they are whats the difference. most committees are run by monhe shrabi kebabi singh sabha ramgharia across board , but your point makes sense that there should be amritdharis running guru ghar that includes all. I would like to go to a point you raised earlier, the nephew of a very famous shaheed singh from 1984 became involved in the khalistan movement, and left punjab in 1993 and arrived in this country on an onion truck. His own father was shaheed by shredding in amritsar, this guy was not amritdhari and now has cut kes, in my clubbing days he would often boast about how after blowing up a few dushts he and his cousin brothers randomly went into pinds and raped chammar girls at night. The same guy could never tolerate the sight of chammars in the club we used to frequent, instantly he would say khalistan zindabad and putt jatta de. I have seen hatred against my own chammar friends in college its nothing new nor are there reasons for it we have been drummed the wrong way i am glad in the jatha it does not have a major problem like the mainstream people. Singh shaan where you do you live? in uk we have singhs from all castes in the jatha. One of our school sp buddies warned us before he went to jail about caste divisions. There used to be a movement called the holy smoke in southall which emerged as a punjabi front to combat the threat of national front ( equivelent of kkk skinheads) in the 1980s. One evening a gathering of smokes in which 2 of the main heads broke into a fight nephew and dads brother. The nephew argued about how jatts make better sikhs. The dads brother warned him if you say such things you will divide the smokes. The nephew continued, the result was the dads brother walked out and formed a rival group, toottee nungz which contained more terkaans and chammars while smokes became jatt centralised. They lost their ultimate truth strentgh unity, and finally became a lost cause becoming caste based and doing manmut things. Prior to that their successes included driving out racist attacks from southall, racists were forced to leave, and respect was given back to the punjabi people who were once spat on, and knifed. Once they divided, they lost their vision, now southall is a pit. The youth after relapsing more out of sikhi, then to castist ideas then to distorted ideas of punjabisms are now stuck in class a drugs refujee crap and divided if not caste on region, or sect loads of radaswamis n crap poppin up. Similar things can be seen amongst castes, their existance sends out the wrong message, then one opens a gurdwara on their own name distortion. before long relapses into hinduism. or in the case of smokes and nungs outdated. So therefore what about sikh parchar in talhan? if some hindus keep some form of sikhi isnt that at least a step in the right direction? isnt that better than being totally absent from gurbani? maybe you can do parchar in talhan to help them understand what amrit ki daat is. Maybe if we take the care to show brotherly affec tion they may reciprocate. if some smoke or drink, or pulled a singhs kes out and have no respect then you have my full backing for that particular place and time where that occured, but surely that does not mean all chammars entertain such hatred towards sikhi. If they did then why would they have backed ambedkars call to embrace sikhism at a time when chammars could not even enter a gurdwara. Guru Nanak opened gurdwarey with 4 doors yet chammars were not allowed early last century to even go to a gurdwara on basis of their caste. the way forward as bhai kulbir singh pointed out before is there would be no such thing as hindu punjabis if they all came became sikh. So if they at least have guru ji and bowing to that in their temple then is it not the duty of a khalsa sikh to do parchar of the khalsa way of life in that situation which will bring ekta increase sikh parchar and hopefully more will become amritdhari. its a singh who was a hindu chammar before he took amrit that inspired me to grow my kes in the first place, to read gurbani and gave me tapes of kirtan, i owe those singhs a lot who took me out of a cesspit of nark where i used to be involved on dark side. So why cant we reciprocate to the poor villagers? whats stopping us?

Re: Dalit - Jat Conflict in Punjab

Singha Dhi Shaan · 14 Mar 2006

Teek Taak Jee and others, I don’t know how many more times I will have to repeat myself before everyone here understand what I am saying. I will write my views in point form so it will be easier for people to comprehend what I am saying because it seems people still think it is a Jat vs Chamar issue: -I am not saying Jats are better or higher than anyone here. In my opinion, Jaat Paat is a social evil and needs to be eradicated as soon as possible. -But Talhan incident was NOT, I repeat NOT a Jaat paat issue as the pro Dalit English twisted it to be. -This incident was conflict between Sikhs and Hindus of Talhan. The pro Dalit media portrayed this as a caste based issue because the Sikhs in this case happen to be mostly Jats, and the Hindus in this case happen to be Chamars. But it was not a Jaat paat issue. -Issue here was that the Hindus wanted to control the Talhan Gurdwara which grossed an annual 5 crore ruppees a year. The Chamars wanted control and share of this huge amount of money. -The Hindu Chamars of the village decided to also add some Hindu practices into the Gurdwara, in total disregard of the Maryadha. Forexample, they installed a picture of Bhagat Ravidas Jee paralell to Guru Granth Sahib Jee, and began to worship it like Hindus do. They began to openly refer to Bhagat Ravidas Jee as "Guru Ravidas Jee" in front of Guru Granth Sahib Jee. Besides of which they were all Monai (hair cutters). They all had Hindu names which end with 'Lal', 'Chand', 'Ram', 'Kumar'. Non had Sikh names, non practice Sikhi, non kept Kesh, all identify themselves as "Hindu' in the Indian census. What more proof do you need for them being Hindu? -The committee members all of whom were Amritdharis said to the Chamars that if you want to become committee members then you will have to take Amrit. But the Chamars said no, we don’t have to keep Kesh, we don’t have to follow Sikhi, we should be allowed to follow our Hindu customs and still become committee members of this Sikh Gurdwara. -The Amritdhari members of the Gurdwara refused, saying that you will have to take amrit to become committee members, no compromises will be made on this issue. -The Chamars who numbered more than 3/4 of the village then decided to form into a large gang and planned to invade the Gurdwara and control it by force. -The Amritdhari committee members were very few, but were strong willed and decided to defend the Gurdwara from the large Hindu Chamar militia. So in the tradition of puraatan Singhs, the Amritdhari Singhs of Talhan armed with kirpans defended Gurdwara from this forcible take over by Hindus and successfully beat back the Hindu Chamar militia which numbered many times larger than the defending Sikh party. -After suffering from this crushing and humiliating defeat from a relatively smaller Amritdhari group of Amritdhari men, the Hindu Chamars still did not learn their lesson. -Then there was a case of a group of young Hindu Chamar youth who were loitering the streets of this village. A young Sikh girl was walking by and she was harassed by this Hindu Chamar youth group. When the brothers of this Sikh girl found out, then decided to teach a lesson to the Hindu Chamar youth and again beat them. -The Hindu Chamars of Talhan then contacted the Hindu Chamar leader Kanshi Ram of the Bahujan Samaj Party for help. Kanshi Ram and his Hindu party members came in force to help to Jalandhar and started rioting all over the city. They would catch and beat any Sikh who looked like Jatts. I hope that my point form format is a little more easier for people to understand. Now please explain to me how is this a Jaat Paat issue? This is clearly a religious conflict. Just because a person is a Dalit, does that mean they are automatically right and everyone else is wrong? Does being a Dalit mean that you do not have to keep Kesh or even take Amrit? Are Dalits now beyond Amrit? Should people who identify themselves as "Hindu" in the Indian census be allowed to control our Gurdwaras? And please for God sake people, please please please read my messages carefully and stop calling this a ‘caste based problem’. I know that there are caste based problems, but this particular one was NOT a caste based problem. This was clearly a religious conflict between Amritdhari Singhs and Hindus of Talhan. [%sig%]

Re: Dalit - Jat Conflict in Punjab

Singha Dhi Shaan · 14 Mar 2006

Also Teek Taak Jee, I would like to add that I would have absolutely no problem if the Chamars in this case were Sikhs. But they were not Sikhs. They were Hindus, identify themselves as Hindu. Keep Hindu Names. Practice Hinduism. I really dont know how else to convince people here that they were NOT Sikhs, but Hindus to the core. Please dont be fooled by the pro-Dalit/communist Enlgish media. They will always do parchar against Sikhs and even twist stories to make Sikhs look bad. These same people during the 1980's were the first to be against Sant Jernail Singh Bhindrawalay and the Jujharoo Singhs. Chamars that are Sikhs are perfectly alright. They are panthic Singhs. But 95% of the Punjabi Chamar population are Hindus.

Re: Dalit - Jat Conflict in Punjab

agreed · 15 Mar 2006

singha di shaan bhai again i apologise for my mistakes please forgive. i understand your points, and in that case agree with you. But i am not too sure about the last one you made. It would be panthic singhs present at the time themselves who could perhaps explain the picture better in 1984 onwards, or someone with official stats at the time of 1984 which is not really nessacary. I speak of those ex militants who turned into monai ghonai, basically the elements that never took amrit on board and their perception of chammars. Jatha singhs had noted that due to the laxity of rehat entry by other groups into the movement some excesses had been caused which would inevitably give the movement a bad name. . again the jatha singhs in the movement from what i saw didnt appear to have this problem as the entry level requirement was amrit, one bana,etc. The jaat paat issues seemed more aroun some mainstream groups it would not be right to name which ones, as it does no justice to the glorious shaheeds who fought under those banners or the more good deeds done in spirit of defence of the qoam. Therefore evertything else i agree with you on. and finally sikh parchar is required in all qauerters of punjab to rescue it from lapsing into hinduism.