Re: Simran or Husband?
Kulbir Singh · 09 Aug 2005
I think I have had a very brief darshan of this Bibi jee in Ludhiana when two gursikhs from Tapoban Sahib got married.
Please confirm if I am right.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: Simran or Husband?
Kulbir Singh · 09 Aug 2005
One more thing. This story begs an answer to this riddle. What should this Bibi jee have done? Did she do the right thing? What would you do?
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: Simran or Husband?
charanjeev singh · 10 Aug 2005
Bhai Kulbir Singh,
you are happily married and with children, what would you have done veerji? This would definately be the truest test if one was infact indifferent to the attachments of this world or not.
I am not married, so i would definately ask for simran.
Re: Simran or Husband?
Kulbir Singh · 10 Aug 2005
-------------
Bhai Kulbir Singh,
you are happily married and with children, what would you have done veerji? This would definately be the truest test if one was infact indifferent to the attachments of this world or not.
--------------
If I choose Simran over my spouse, it would seem to me that I am sacrificing her for my own benefit. She would lose her human form so that I can get simran. If the choice was between simran and something else that would not affect another living entity, then the choice would obviously be simran.
On the other hand if I choose my spouse over simran, I would feel guilty all my life for letting go a golden opportunity to be one with Vaheguru.
It is a predicament and I don’t have the answer to this. Perhaps the best answer would be to let Guru Sahib do his hukam and not make any choice.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: Simran or Husband?
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 10 Aug 2005
Kulbir Singh Ji..I agree with you...Thats the "Dilemma" i too faced when i read this story.
Why did GURU JI give such a choice to this lady ?? I feel GURU JI would NOT give such a choice..its wrong.
In Sikh History everytime GURU JI is Tuttheh or Kirpa Drisht and asks his Sikh to ASK anything..there is NO "choice"... ASK "this" or "This"...IF you ask "this" then "That" will die etc..its just not right and doesnt fit into Guru Ji's known Profile.
Jarnail singh
Re: Simran or Husband?
Bhopinder Singh · 11 Aug 2005
IN Gurbani it says
tuj no savy tujh kya devai mangey rahe thir nahi|| too data jian sabna ka jia ander jio too hee
and the shabad is
Prani eko naam dheavo apni pat seti ghar javo
The gursikhs on this forum are more learned and I think they could translate it and post it in gurmukhi font
I think it tells us that what we ask from god never stays for ever and further goes on to say jia ander jeo to he
Re: Simran or Husband?
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 11 Aug 2005
Dear ggg Jio,
Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji KI fateh.
You too use the "IF" a lot...so you are not that sure also.
I dont know what happened to this Bibi....BUT so far from all the Life Histories I have read about our GURU SAHIBS...I havent yet come across any single incident where GURU JI gave anyone such a "tough choice" either OR question. It has NEVER happened.
Every single time Guur Ji asked His Sikh to ASK....it was up to him/her to ask whatever..never a "This or That" choice. And almost everybody chose MUKTEE/Charan Dhoorr/Naam... a few did ask Guru Ji for a "son" ( like the lady who got SEVEN SONS...because Guru Ji's HORSE shook His Hand while writing ONE..it became SEVEN )..imagine Guru Ji saying..Oh my......mistake...now choose which ones are going to die because you only asked for ONE and it has become seven ?? That sceanrio also didnt happen.
Anyway just for Arguments sake... HOW LONG can ones SPOUSE LIVE on this EARTH ( IF we asked GURU JI for his LIFE !!)..Remember Even GURU JI themselves LIVED ONLY the Span of TIME allotted for a normal Human beings..Ten Guur Sahibaans from 1469- 1708 have a total Life span of only about 239 Years ONLY !! One of these days a human life will come to an END..as compared to SIMRAN which is EVERLASTING. Personally when my dad passed away suddenly in my absence 22 years ago i was devastated.. on so many ocassions I PRAYED to Guru Ji that I would Give anything IF He would just let me have my dad back for a while... I was prepared to give my arm, my leg, my eyes...anything !! Then my Simran and Naam japp kicked in...and I realised i was asking for the impossible..it wouldnt happen and never did..and just IF..JUST IF Guru Ji had somehow "revived" my dad...could he live FOREVER or would he have died once again ?? Just show me any such "living" person !! and I will stop LAUGHING.
Dont get me wrong..I am NOT doubting GURU JI...in any way or that he "cannot" do such or anything like that... What i am saying is based on my understanding of GURBANI..GURU JI would NEVER interfere wth Waheguru's HUKM/NATURAL LAWS. They never did and never would and wont in the future. We MUST all live in HUKM..hukme ander sabh ko baher hukm na koi.