‘Patka’ in France
Bhopinder Singh · 04 Aug 2005
‘Patka’ in France Paris moves in the right direction THE French authorities have rightly taken a positive step in allowing Sikh students to wear ‘patkas’ or under-turbans while at school. It is evident now that a certain behind-the-scenes intervention by the Government of India, along with the efforts of the community in France and in the European Union, helped in bringing about a change. The present controversy owes its origins to a rather strict interpretation of the principle of ‘laicite’ or secularism that calls for the separation of the Church and the State. The French introduced a secularism law in September last year, under which all school children in government-funded institutions were banned from wearing visible religious symbols. Thus, Christian students could not wear a big cross, Jews had to do without their religious caps and Muslim girls came without traditional headscarves. Evidently, when the law was proposed the Sikhs and the turbans were not considered. However, when the law came into effect, Sikh students were told to either attend school without turbans, or leave. This became a big issue for the Sikhs Wearing a turban is integral to Sikh identity, and a turban is not just a religious symbol. The Sikhs have successfully fought legally in many countries for their right to wear the turban proudly. Trying to ban the wearing of a turban also denied students, French citizens and others alike, of their right to education. The First Protocol of the European Convention on Human Rights, to which France is a party, states: “No person shall be denied the right to education.” Clearly, the French rule banning turbaned children from attending school violates this protocol, as it does Article 18 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights which maintains that everyone has the right to freedom of thought, conscience and religion, and to manifest his religion or belief in teaching, worship and observance. It is hoped that the heads of all schools where Sikh children study would take cognisance of the change in the attitude of the French authorities, and allow Sikh children in France to study even as they wear their ‘patkas’ to school. Having taken this important first step, the French authorities should now go the whole hog and allow the Sikhs to wear turbans, while at school or at work. The next step should not take long. [%sig%]