Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Some questions about Bhai Gurdas Ji

Some questions about Bhai Gurdas Ji

ASengh · 25 Jul 2005

WJKK WJF Satsangat Ji, I am really confused about Bhai Sahib Bhai Gurdas Ji. If we look at the shabad in Bhai Gurdas Ji's vaars: [gurbani]pIE pwhul KMfDwr hoie jnm suhylw][/gurbani] This is how it is spelt in Bhai Gurdas Ji's vaars according to Sikhitothemax. But on Sikhitothemax it also has the same shabad but from the Amrit Kirtan Pothi, and is spelt like this: [gurbani]pIvhu pwhul KMfyDwr hoie jnm suhylw [[/gurbani] Why is one shabad spelt differently in 2 different pothis. Obviously it could be a spelling mistake but which one is the right one? I have heard Kirtanis singing the second one more. Another thing that has puzzled me is that Bhai Gurdas Ji was born in the year 1551 and left for gurpuri on 1636, but he wrties this shabad in his vaars: [gurbani]bolxw BweI gurdws kw] hir scy qKq rcwieAw siq sMgiq mylw] nwnk inrBau inrMkwr ivic isDW Kylw] guru dws mnweI kwlkw KMfy kI vylw] pIE pwhul KMfDwr hoie jnm suhylw] sMgiq kInI Kwlsw mnmuKI duhylw] vwh vwh goibMd isMG Awpy guru cylw ]ñ][/gurbani] Bhai Sahib talks about the Khalsa, he talks about Khanda da pohul, he even praises Guru Gobind Singh in this verse, but what I don't get is that Bhai Sahib went for Gurpuri on 1636 and Guru gobind Singh was pragat (born) on 1666, 30 years after Bhai Sahib had left his body and went for Gurpuri. My question is that, how did Bhai Sahib know about the khalsa, the khanda bata da amrit, and Guru Gobind Singh when he had left the earth 30 years before the Khalsa was even made. Can someone please share some knowlege about this. [%sig%]

Re: Some questions about Bhai Gurdas Ji

... · 25 Jul 2005

Weren't there 2 diff Bhai Gurdas'? One around Guru Arjan Dev Jee's time and the other around Guru Gobind Singh Jee's time?

Re: Some questions about Bhai Gurdas Ji

MOW · 25 Jul 2005

dear A some sections of bhai gurdas's bani are written by bhai gurdas singh (different bhai gurdas who lived in 10th gurus times) that is why it talks about 10th guru sahib. the first part of your question, im not sure. the other not so graet thing is that someone has decided to smash loads of bindian (making shashas and zazzas) in bhai gurdass varan when there werent any written in originally.

Re: Some questions about Bhai Gurdas Ji

Kulbir Singh · 25 Jul 2005

In the first part, the correct spelling of Peevho is the second pankiti. This word "Peevho" is a Hukami Kiriya word (verb in imperative case) and thus it is more appropriate to have it in the "peevho" form as opposed to "peevo". This quoted pauri is written by Bhai Gurdas who was from Siri Guru Gobind Singh jee's time and not the original Bhai Gurdas jee. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Some questions about Bhai Gurdas Ji

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 25 Jul 2005

imho...The correct spelling is.. [gurbani]pIvhu pwhul KMfDwr hoie jnm suhylw [/gurbani] There is NO LAAM on KHAND...it is KHANDHAAR and NOT KHANDEDHAAR. Veer Ji kulbir Singh ji ?? any comments ?? Thansk jarnail singh. [%sig%]

Re: Some questions about Bhai Gurdas Ji

Lionking · 26 Jul 2005

More specifically it si the 41 Vaar, 40 first Vaars are of BHai GUrdas ji of GUru Arjan Dev ji's time and the last one is what some call "Bhai Gurdas dooja" (second)