Forum
British sikhs MUST be loyal to BRITAIN
British sikhs MUST be loyal to BRITAIN
Dr Gurcharan Singh Kulim; · 24 Jul 2005
IN RETROSPECT, there were already hints of the thrusts of the poor image Sikh gurduara parbandhaks were potraying to the communities at large in this country long before the recent events,including even within the Sikh community.
Articles both in Punjabi and English had appeared for sometime now asking these parbandhaks to wake up.But there was no response form the people who mattered, as many of them are even not aware what an internet really is.
They were not populist or feel-good articles, because virtually all of them dared the parbandhaks to try harder, to not be satisfied with being second or third rate organisations of their own communities and Gurduaras, and to work for the success of Sikh communities , rather than ther own glory.
The write ups challenged them to feel ashamed about failing the community collectively, and the inability to link in with other local groups,and not to expect others to carry on, their baggage
The many articles aimed at these parbandhaks took by the horns these and other even thornier issues affecting the Sikh communities, and especially the Gurduara parbandhaks and their lack of involvement in affairs of local communities.
However,many of these great parbandhaks, unable to speak or read English would not have even understood the “tough messages” were aimmed at them.
Many may not have understood the rhetoric and could have not understood the Government's objectives in a way that many others could relate to, and understand them
Many of us here have spoken of the need to set an exemplry role on the Brtitish stage and the need for more earlier participation of Sikh organisation in the affairs of the country.
Of late, many events happening,has led sikhs at grassroots to express reservations about these parbandhaks' mental capacity to understand the events of the 21 st century in a language they have not bothered to learn.
Sikhs who understand these issues evidently must set their mind on pushing the silent paper weight strong sikh parbandhaks towards a more level playing ground.
Sometimes,I feel could have played the populist and pandered to the gallery in waiting with their titles and organsiations , but I have stood my ground .I spurn the calls for a continuation of desi politics in this land; and Sikh mentality with the absence of nationalism to this country and its flag.
The land of Britain has given many including Sikhs what I call call “a new lease of life” but many had abused and poorly implemented their own faculties, to accept the laws that go with this land.
We have to be honest in admitting that many beneficiaries of this land had abused the system, preferring to be benefit seekers and "bed hoppers" rather than be genuine british subjects and citizens.
Another community have travelled down that road more rapidly , and found their young feeling detached and unpart of the British sytem, and today playing the deadly game of suicide bombing.
As such, and unlike the other backward community,we must move the Sikh parbandhaks and leaders of Gurduaras, to enable to progress at par with the standards of this country;it would not only be done by plugging the shortcomings but also by training these parbandhakhs to adopt a new mindset that valued know-ledge, skills and hard work, and commitment to local Sikh communities initially and nationally secondarily, finally the law of this land.
We need to want the Sikhs to grow without excessive reliance on the Government and desi politics, but with self progress and increasing presence within the government and places where it matters most, as an independent ethnic group.
In this country the strength of the Sikh community should not be built on falsity and shallowness ,but on an approach of sincere understanding of the Sikh needs realating to reallity.Some may not be popular with many but as British Sikhs we must choose the right path.
We have today reached the point where we have to call a spade a spade, and those parbandhaks who are not bothered, must wake up.
We need to motivate ourselves as Sikhs, as British Sikhs , and need to impress our concerns as British Sikhs, without any divided loyalties to another country.
I am sure this would not sit easy on everyone of the Sikhs.Mindsets cannot change overnight or even in the matter of a few years or decade. But it has to begin somewhere, however painful or unpopular.
We need to set our ideas for the BRITISH SIKH more clearly than ever before.We need to speak for our selves as British sikhs, who are proud of this country, not worried to death with the problems of another third world country, that we continue to call mother country,even though for generations we are born overseas.
I have also a penny of advice for those who claim they are Sikhs and live in Britrain, but think fluttering the national of flag of this great country ammounts to hiding behind it and sikhs as lions must not do that.What a load of cobblers brains!
These people seem very happy to be living of the benefits of this country like hand outs, social services,the education and the benfits that come with this country in all aspects of life,but suddenly when asked to stand as british they are such hypocrites, and refuse to stand under the Union jack.The Union jack is the flag of this country and should be respected for so.
We can be Sikhs, and standing along with the flag of THIS country does not erode being a Sikh.In fact this country gives one MOPRE rights to be a Sikhs than any other....when these unloyal and confused Brit Sikhs are challeged, they lower their mentality to threats ....they than smell no different from the fanatical muslims who are to kill Humanity...
Gurcharan SINGH Kulim
Re: British sikhs MUST be loyal to BRITAIN
Dr Gurcharan Singh Kulim; · 26 Jul 2005
The old saying Sikhs and democracy do not mix well, is very true to its sense.When Sikhs are in politics, and one Sikh looses a point over another then they revert to name calling like one Ravinder Singh recently resigned himself to do with me.After claiming to write in English , he could not read simple Kulim , and suggested it be Julum- makes one wonder then what exactly a character like him was able to say to the MPs during the lobby day!!Or was he at all able to speak English the british style?Or did he sway his hands like SS Maan does his sword when faced with frustrations?I say thanks to characters like Ravinder Sinh Sikhs are still not getting the coverage Sikhs should have in these times.
Reverting back to the point, Sikhs tend to equate democracy with danda politics, gutter language, abuse and airy threats, that they cannot accomodate within their own sandals!
Any time a view is expressed to move sikh thought mentality into the 21st century politics,Sikhs like Ravinder SINH feel threatened and weakened, then they begin to sing in chorus that democracy and sikhi is in danger or on the verge of collapse due to the new thoughts put forward, or even the intellectuals moving in!
This pattern started by master Tara Singh has been displayed over and over again and tends to play in this generation of Sikhs in this country too, many of whom while keen to live off the benefits of this nation, i.e.citizenship, education and quality of life for which many discard their basic identity of sikhi, are not keen to stand under the british flag to be called BRITISH Sikhs, while pining as the shers of gurduara politics!!
I often wonder if the survival of democracy hinges just on one such type person,or one party or one religious fanatic fundamentalist then what type of democracy are we talking about , and what type of democracy is really in danger from such daddoos in the well mentality?
Such a polity is rather called stalinist one, or dictatorship with inherrant exclusionary paranoia.Sounding alarm bells of democracy in danger or secularism in danger or the Panth is in danger, any time a viable alternative posese the slightest challenge to the entrenched power base and opportunists (who do not master enough language to understand the ettiquette o dressing appropriately for the appropriate times!)smack of stanlinist paranoia.
Just as the fanatical mullahs cry out that Islam is in danger from satan america( for which there would probably be 5 million muslims queing up in any muslim country should USA ofer 500,00 free green cards) any time their own personal ambitions or hold becomes threatened by the new ideas or suggestions.There is never ...okay..let us look from that perspective and see if it looks any better or different.
Just look at the kind of practicing ideology the Sikhs have adopted, despite the message from the Gurus being very clear and boldly spelt out.
With Akalis on one side, the phobia of being sidelined one side, Kala Afgahan supporters , SS MAAN supporters, The Gurduara pardhaans and skatters, the BSCF, the NSO etc etc on every other side,is there any wonder why the Sikhs are simply undemocratic; and or over democratic irresponsibly ?We cannot overlook that the relationship of Sikhs to their just as many organisations, their overtly outdated mentality in terms of singular coporate image just does not measure up to the norms of democracy as the English man sees it.Even the Blacks in this country have learnt to master that and present their presence effectivly, but the Sikhs have failed.
The Sikh mentality of many organisations is proving to disintegrate the Sikh view point nationally,cleanse off those who could make the points( the gurduara poltics are a good example of this reference to study)or are seen as a voice of dissent of 'their politics',stiffle the the assertive make sense voices by name calling, as reflective of their own poverty ridden intellignce, but continue to ensure they have the Sikh panth in total parasitic dependance upon themselves, with total subserviency.
Because of such self suppression of voices within the Sikhs by the Sikhs ,a close ideological synthesis has developed among the Sikhs, who think their own mere presense at lobbies and marches makes the differences, sikhs are rapidly going dowm the path of institutional suppression of democracy, inflicting damage upon the sikh thought and masses without any realisation, as they are living within such closed fundamentalist regime themselves.they perceive anything Indian as alien enemy, anything british as foreign, and anything Sikh, they do not accept as hindu infiltration.
Sikhs sadly are fast becomming antithical to democracy and synonymous with an enclosed beseiged mentality of self destruction, in other words sikhs too are not far from becaooming those fanatical fundamnetalists as islam appears to have produced unbeknown to most of its leaders and other 'peace loving 'adherants as we are led to day to beleive.
We need to be BRITISH SIKHS, to get British rights.Abandon the desi politics and mentality.Thge desi birti will drown us back into some disused tube well!
Gurcharan SINGH kulim
Re: British sikhs MUST be loyal to BRITAIN
Pakistani · 26 Jul 2005
the only problem i have with this is if this nation bombed with the help of another bomd out gurdwaras in the land of amritsar killing innocents what would sikhs do? sacred masjids have been bombed out in what is holy territory in arab lands and muslims have been massacred in faluja palestine and many other countries.
What we hear on the news is not even close to the truth just as much as it was with sikhs in india . No parralels drawn, you gave your own problems we have ours. Suicide bombings are no answer there is no justification for it.
Yes there are nutters out there i am not ashamed to admit that in our midst inside our own communities.
Before sikhs try to adress the muslim world please understand the backdrop and try not to sling mud at us or buy what the papers say. Only some years ago the daily mail writer spoke of "ridiculous claims by sikh militants of human rights abuses by indian authorities " on the lines of 250 000 bloodbath of sikhs. So whatever sikhs do back they were terrorists in the eyes of the newspapers.
While i absolutley condemn terrorism especially 9 11 07 07 all i ask in return is please research the problems better to avoid falling for the british media thinktank which is essentially racist and very cunningly writes articles to form stereotypes of muslims and sikhs yet favours hindus. The media is the only source of global information if it is biased we should be careful in what conclusions we draw of entire communities.
Re: British sikhs MUST be loyal to BRITAIN
Siddharth · 26 Jul 2005
Mr. Pakistani -
<>
Can you please let me know which British writer favours Hindus? Which British writer stereotypes Sikhs? Stereotyping and blaming entire communities for the actions of a few is terrible but something must be wrong if every major attack in the world has a Pakistani imprint on it. Even the recent attack in Egypt has been conducted by Pakistani and who says this? NOT the "racist" British media but the "Muslim" Egyptian media.
Regards, Sid.
Re: British sikhs MUST be loyal to BRITAIN
Bhudysut · 26 Jul 2005
Vahiguru Ji Ka Khalsa
Vahiguru Ji Ki Fateh
Dear Siddharth Ji,
It is only until recently that I feel Sikh's have been getting fair representation in the UK's press. As a resident of both the UK and Canada, I have been totally surprised to see what certain sections in the UK media have been allowed to get away with (especially when commenting on the Sikh's).
Hindu's have always (and continue) to be looked on favourably in the UK's spotlight. Also in the recent past Hindu writers have written some rather derogatory articles about Sikh's (RE: Madness Under A Turban by Amit Roy of the Telegraph). I remember a time whenever there was some kind of 'incident' in India or related to the Indian Sub-Continent, the first names that were brandished were Sikh ones. Unfortunately, due to recent events, Sikh names have been relaced by Muslim ones.
Bhul Chuk Marf Karna Ji
Dass
Akaal Sahai Singh
Re: British sikhs MUST be loyal to BRITAIN
Bhopinder Singh · 26 Jul 2005
Siddharth
Egypt has denied any Pakistani link
Re: British sikhs MUST be loyal to BRITAIN
Virender · 26 Jul 2005
I'm a British Sikh and let me tell you Dr. that I don't live off benefit- I work my ass off thank you very much. It seems to me that you have been brainwashed by the goray.
If you remember - it was the Union Jack that massacred many Sikhs at Jallianwala Bagh and the British are still yet to apologise for this. The queen handed out awards to the strategists of the massacre.
Let me tell you 1 more thing. If a goray sees you walking down the street he sees you and me as the same as Hindus/Muslims and classify us as 'Pakis' despite what they say yo your face.
So when you say unloyal Sikhs, I say it is you whom are the unloyal Sikh forgetting your motherland and kissing the gorays arse.
Also I would never have been in this country if they hadn't invaded India and stole our riches.
I have no hate for the British but I will not try to make out that I am something which I quite clearly am not and never will be - unlike some.
p.s. Read up on history. For example on how the British manipulated a child Dilip Singh, son of the Great Maharaja Ranjit Singh. Also Jallianwala Bagh and how they massacred innocent women and children and were extremely proud of themselves for this.
Re: British sikhs MUST be loyal to BRITAIN
Bhopinder Singh · 26 Jul 2005
Virender
it was the Union Jack that massacred many Sikhs at Jallianwala Bagh and the British are still yet to apologise for this.
Indian army did the same Indian govt did the same in mass murder and genocide of Sikhs in 1984 in Amritsar and Delhi
The thing is we should look for our own interest and for British Sikhs it lies in being loyal to the govt as of today we have no conflict with them so no reason for not being loyal it is their motherland hundreds of thousands of our ancestors died defending England and its interests worldwide and yes they have defended ours
Queen has`visited Darbar sahib although Indian govt opposed tooth and nail and she never bugged.
Re: British sikhs MUST be loyal to BRITAIN
charanjeev singh · 26 Jul 2005
There is no such thing as a british sikh, a canadian sikh, a malaysian sikh, an african sikh, an indian sikh; a sikh is a sikh is a sikh is a sikh. He/she owes no alleigance to any country, state, government, nobody. The alleigance is to Waheguruu and Guruu, the owners of All including this earth. His flag is the Nishaan Sahib. His government is Sri Akaal Takhat. His governing body is Panj Pyareh. His King is Guru Granth Sahib Jee.
You might hate me for my next statement, but i do not care. This entire earth must be what is referred to as 'khalistan', not only a specific small piece of mata dharat. This earth will only have peace and prosperity for all human beings irrespective of cast, religion, sex or anything, when the Khalsa armies the earth. Under the watch of the Khalsa no innocent will be harmed; the principles of love and compassion wll be the guiding rule. The entire earth will be the stan of Khalsa. Country of the pure; satjug.
Re: British sikhs MUST be loyal to BRITAIN
Virender · 26 Jul 2005
Yes she did visit but did not apologise which is think is very arrogant and reflects their true beliefs as a nation. If someone murdered your whole family and refused to apologise but wished to visit the crime scene (ie your home) would you allow them to or would you oppose?
My granfather was one of many who fought for Britain during WWII and the reason is because that was the only way India could gain freedom. We sacrificed many Sikh lives just to get back what was rightfully ours. Could you also explain to me how they defended our interests worldwide - they split our huge and powerful country through the most productive state with the prime intent of weakening us?
I know the Indian govt. did the same in 1984 but we were armed in that situation and although outnumbered we did have a chance to protect ourselves. Jallianwala Bagh was masterminded to terrorise the Indian people especially the Sikhs as it was on the fateful Baisakhi day, April 13, 1919 where the British fired upon thousands in a peaceful assembly many of whom many were women and children.
Shaheed Udham Singh was on the lookout for an opportunity to avenge the Jallianwala Bagh massacre and he waited till March 13, 1940. During the trial, Shaheed Udham Singh had made a request that his ashes be sent back to his country, but this was not allowed.
It really disappoints me when Sikhs like Bhopinder Singh Dr Kulim fail to realise the sacrifices our people went through to recieve what was rightfully ours. Our mothers, sisters, daughters etc. were raped and killed and would still be today if they could get away with it.
I'm not dis-loyal but I will never be as loyal to a flag and country that has committed such atrocities and fails to apologise for them as I would for my motherland.
If anyone is dis-loyal it is you.
REMEMBER there were so-called Sikh soldiers on that fateful Baisakhi day who fired upon the innocents and you people are more like them than Shahedd Udham Singh.
Re: British sikhs MUST be loyal to BRITAIN
Virender · 26 Jul 2005
well said Charanjeev Singh - A Sikh should always be loyal to a righteous cause regardless of the country.
Re: British sikhs MUST be loyal to BRITAIN
Dr Gurcharan Singh Kulim; · 26 Jul 2005
I have found the imbecellic brains of Virender very enlightening, and his language very informative for his parents mentality and ettiquette.
People living in a never ending history of killing are the real culprits.If that flag is so repulsive, why are you in UK living under the flag of that country and carrying the passport.
People work off their POSTERIOR, for better word in any country.But it is people as such that are good fertile ground for breeding terrorist, as the muslims who never live at peace with their neighbours have found out.Of course not all are killers.But the killers are and islam is the name they use...for every problem of theirs.if they were not fighting anyone else, they would be killing their own>there are many examples.
Re: British sikhs MUST be loyal to BRITAIN
Prem Singh · 26 Jul 2005
I agree with Dr Gurcharan Singh - as Sikhs we should contribute to our society and make it sweeter so that we give love and beauty to others - so that they know Sikhs are servants of Love and God. I am happy to be British, it is a good country, a good society, I love my country.
Re: British sikhs MUST be loyal to BRITAIN
Bhopinder Singh · 26 Jul 2005
Virender tout ji
Did Indian govt appologize for 1984 no
__________________________________________________________
My granfather was one of many who fought for Britain during WWII and the reason is because that was the only way India could gain freedom. We sacrificed many Sikh lives just to get back what was rightfully ours. Could you also explain to me how they defended our interests worldwide - they split our huge and powerful country through the most productive state with the prime intent of weakening us?
_________________________________________________________
What INDIA are you talking about there was no such thing untill it was put up by British whome you hate so much
Even your PM has thanked them for it
Who split your country
The power struggle between nehru and jinah and nehru didnt gave a inch if the mighty brits had the idea believe me their would have been 20 divisions and Khalistan would have been created
15 crore muslims in PAK and 18 crore in India 12 crore in Bangladesh growth rate of 35% who would be the PM
Re: British sikhs MUST be loyal to BRITAIN
Virender · 26 Jul 2005
I have nothing more to say but this.
Your title is British sikhs MUST be loyal to BRITAIN
IF you are a doctor which I highly doubt (unless you have a doctrate it stupidity) you would realise that I do not find the flag repulsive just that I will always remember what that flag did to innocents in a country across the other side of the world. If the country was not so arrogant and apologised for this massacre maybe they would gain my respect.
As I say again it is people like you whom allowed the British to do such a thing and not once have I heard you condemming the British for this but instead condeming me for saying that I would not fight for a country who continues to follow unjust causes.
Your ancestors would be ASHAMED of you.
Re: British sikhs MUST be loyal to BRITAIN
Sardar · 26 Jul 2005
I think you need to READ these 2 points again
1) Jallianwala Bagh was masterminded to terrorise the Indian people especially the Sikhs as it was on the fateful BAISAKHI day, April 13, 1919 where the British fired upon thousands in a peaceful assembly many of whom many were women and children.
Yes what day did the attck occur. A very holy day. Also Virender Jee failed to mention that the British blocked the entrances to maximise casulties.
Michael O Dwyer and General Dyer were praised and awarded for their acts by British royalty. They have never been condemned and I doubt that they ever will be.
2)They forced Sikh soldiers to fight for them in THEIR war after treating our people so poorly.
But you all stand proud in favour of the country who fails to acknowledge a civilian massacre at a religious gathering. Surely our Gurus would also condemn this evil act?
Re: British sikhs MUST be loyal to BRITAIN
charanjeev singh · 26 Jul 2005
Dr. Kulim, you have mentioned in your thesis, if i may call it so, that agendas in policies and norms must be changed to stroll alongside the british population more smoothly, ammalgamate seems to be the proper term. I kindly ask you to please outline a few policies and shifts in mentality that need to be addressed as per your views? You have mentioned speech, dress, parbhantak committees, and socio-political affairs. Could you please provide specific examples of each of how they should be altered to change with the times and place (paraphrasing your thoughts). I am keen on your answer on dress especially; please also address Kesh including the open daara of a Sikh.
I am also keen to know, are you writing as a Practicing Amritdhaari Singh? No judgement intended, it only gives us a better understanding of the principles that you adhere too.
Thanking you in advance
Re: British sikhs MUST be loyal to BRITAIN
Nav · 27 Jul 2005
Well written article Sardar Kulim ji. Its encouraging to see there are some out there who are challenging the authority of the mediocre kleptocrats running Sikh institutions. Sikhs living in the West need to shake of some of these backwoods desi habits: zaat-paat, fighting with dangs in gurudwaras, nepotism etc. The political system in the West is very different and we need a different approach from the one taken by our self proclaimed pardhaans. Most of our "pardhaans" have nothing more than a rudimentary knowledge of the Western world and the English language. They bring the politics of their pind to Western countries and have hurt the Sikh cause more than any outsider could.
Re: British sikhs MUST be loyal to BRITAIN
amar · 27 Jul 2005
keI koit Bey AiBmwnI ]
ka-ee kot bha-ay abhimaanee.
Many millions become self-centered.
keI koit AMD AigAwnI ]
ka-ee kot anDh agi-aanee.
Many millions are blinded by ignorance.
keI koit ikrpn kTor ]
ka-ee kot kirpan kathor.
Many millions are stone-hearted misers.
keI koit AiBg Awqm inkor ]
ka-ee kot abhig aatam nikor.
Many millions are heartless, with dry, withered souls.
keI koit pr drb kau ihrih ]
ka-ee kot par darab ka-o hireh.
Many millions steal the wealth of others.
keI koit pr dUKnw krih ]
ka-ee kot par dookhnaa karahi.
Many millions slander others.
keI koit mwieAw sRm mwih ]
ka-ee kot maa-i-aa saram maahi.
Many millions struggle in Maya.
keI koit prdys BRmwih ]
ka-ee kot pardays bharmaahi.
MANY MILLIONS WANDER IN FOREIGN LANDS.
ijqu ijqu lwvhu iqqu iqqu lgnw ]
jit jit laavhu tit tit lagnaa.
Whatever God attaches them to - with that they are engaged.
nwnk krqy kI jwnY krqw rcnw ]2]
naanak kartay kee jaanai kartaa rachnaa. ||2||
O Nanak, the Creator alone knows the workings of His creation. ||2||
MANY MILLIONS WANDER IN FOREIGN LANDS. this occurs where the millions of BAD things are being described, therrefore shud stay in homeland
Question 4 Dr Kulim
Avtar · 27 Jul 2005
I would like to address Dr Kulim and ask him to emphasize on how British Sikhs are NOT being loyal to Britain.
Just because we are classed in the same group as Muslims as being Asian does not mean we have to defend ourselves or prove our loyalty as theirs is being questioned.
You should read Charanjeev's first post again as I feel it is very true.
I quote Charanjeev Singh:
"A Sikh is a Sikh. He/she owes no alleigance to any country, state, government, nobody. The alleigance is to Waheguruu and Guruu, the owners of All including this earth. His flag is the Nishaan Sahib. His government is Sri Akaal Takhat. His governing body is Panj Pyareh. His King is Guru Granth Sahib Jee"
Are you a insecure person Dr Kulim - one who needs to reiterate that he is not a terrorist to goray as it appears to me that you are so. Be proud of your origins and you do not need to prove your loyalty to any person or country on earth. Only prove your loyalty to Waheguru Jee.
Are you a Practicing Amritdhaari Singh or just one who was born from Sikh parents(one is not born into Sikhism, one takes a decision in his life to become Sikhi by following the true path which was layed out by our Guru's).
Also I feel you are very wrong in insulting Virender and his/her parents in your post dated 07-26-05 13:51. This forum is for debate and there is no need for insults this also applies to Virender. His/her parents having nothing to do with the posts and have not insulted you in any way. They could be five times greater person then you will ever be!
In your same post I failed to understand the relevance of your last paragraph. What has British Sikhs loyalty got to do with Islamic terrorists?
I look forward to hearing your response.
Thank You.
Re: British sikhs MUST be loyal to BRITAIN
Immortal · 27 Jul 2005
how bout British Sikhs should be loyal to the Guru Granth Sahib rather than anything else.
yes/no?
how are Sikhs not being loyal to Britain?
how has Britain showed loyalty to British Sikhs? Respect works both ways!
shouldn't the British apologise to the Sikhs for the massacre?
Re: British sikhs MUST be loyal to BRITAIN
Desi · 27 Jul 2005
Read a book called - A History of India by an English author, John Keay.
Let me take some extracts from it.
page 475-477
'and many of the several thousands in the Bagh are thought to have been villagers from outside Amritsar who had come into the city to celebrate this popular spring festival......immediately ordered them to fire into the crowd. He gave the order to cease firing only when their ammunition was exhausted......the crowd had offered no threat, Dyer had given no warning; communication was by bullet alone. Because Dyer's men were occupying the main exit, the crowd obligingly formed a dense scrum round the only other way out. It was impossible for the troops to miss; nor did they. The wounded were left untended, the dead uncounted. Dyer simply drove away, mission completed.
'The official enquiry would later conclude that 1650 rounds had been fired inside the Jallianwala Bagh.......when later questioned, Dyer seemed if anything proud of his action. His intention, he said, had been to exact revenge for the previous killings and to make an EXAMPLE which would deter further defiance anywhere in the PANJAB. To this end he also had prisoners beaten, sometimes in public and had male Indians CRAWL the street where an English missionary lady had been attacked. Equally provocative methods were employed in Lahore. At Gujranwala Governor O'Dwyer had simply ordered up aircraft and had the city BOMBED...... Moreover it soon became apparent that MANY OTHER BRITISH PEOPLE FELT THE SAME WAY. Although relieved of his command, Dyer was never formally punished. On the contary, in England he was REWARDED. As the "Saviour of Panjab" a Morning Post subscription was raised on his behalf; it realised £26 000. Designated "Defender of the Empire" he was presented with a gilt sword.'
Also read up on the anglo-Sikh wars in the book(page 423) on how the British killed over 10,000 Sikhs in the second war. They only warred with us after Maharaja Ranjit Singh died.
Also on how the Treaty of Lahore, 29 March 1849 (signed by a child Dhilip Singh) stated that the Koh-i-noor shall be surrenderd to the QUEEN OF ENGLAND.
There is so much more but I'll be here forever so best thing is you get the book and read it yourselves. It is by an English author-John Keay and therefore is not biased towards us.
Gain knowledge on history before you preach to others. There is a saying that HISTORY REPEATS ITSELF therefore we should record it and learn from it.
Re: British sikhs MUST be loyal to BRITAIN
Dr Gurcharan Singh Kulim; · 27 Jul 2005
I am amused by the mentality.Guru
Gobind Singh ji baptised FIVE people from different parts of India, to bring humanity together and show the Sikh path.but these people ingrained with the simpleton mentality of HATREd do not see the way forward.Strangley they will NOt tell us, why they hold British passports of the country they hate so much.having and living OFF the benfits seem to be the norm of the recent TERRORIST BOMBERS, applies to these poeple easily.
These merchants of hate are so two tongued when they call Bharat mata , yet they have fortgotten 1984,but blame the british fro all their failures.sad merchants of hate and they call that Sikhi.
I have read the HISTORY of Inida UK and MANY OTHER COUNTRIES including speaking 11 languages.
Yes I am a practising sikh and amritdhari, with out any problem in this land, and
You can DOUBT even your mother's sincerity to your daddy , that makes no difference.Dont worry about my title , worry about your ability to stand tall among the goray in your SIKH Looks like you do have a complex.
Being a british loyal Sikh does NOT mean you shed your dress and culture.IN fact THIS country GIVES you that RIGHT-should someone deny you that in ignorance you also have the law of the nation to fight against it and uphold your rights.
Was it in the land of your musim brothers that MURDERED and TORTURED inhumanely millions, and that many of you are run to today , and if I rememer rightly many call them our punjabi brothers, despite hundereds of years of torture of sikhs.
Any conflict has to end at the table.Germans , japanese the Brits and many others are today best of allies.
With a mentality of arrogance and insular looking HATRED AMONG MANY of you ,is it any wonder that people like have sikh nation wrapped into a ball of boiling hatred even among your selves.It just reflects an immatured understanding from amny of these goray haters!Is it because you cannot stand proudly with your bana and Sikh roop among the goray proudly ?Is that a inferiority complex you have ?
Inhumanity and killings went on among all in history, but people unlike your small scale menality do not stand still in that warped time era.Thay have moved on.
Of course what happend in Jllian Wala bagh was NOT RIGHT, but it was also a Sikh of the warped mentality that gave O'Der a siropa in the Harmnder sahib.
I think apart from a few far thinking individuals, the rest are just children....I am sorry I wasted my THESISI as one simpletomn called, was indeed a waste!!!
May be the trash mentality of of Osama Bin laden would have driven the message home better to these sad hate filled , angry and complexed individuals!!What a laugh, you do not look any different from those sword waving akalis and their mentality.Any wonder?
Of course Sikhi is the religion of the world,but was that the subject we were talking about ???No , may be this THESIS was TOO hard after all for these little brains!
Re: British sikhs MUST be loyal to BRITAIN
TUF · 27 Jul 2005
I think the British flag deserves to be walked upon under foot.
Sikhs and other minorities are secondary citizens in the UK.
NO SIKH should ever forget how the British treated us during the 'raj'.
I have been to the UK many times and have been very surprised at how racist the general public "goray" can be. I've heard them mocking minorities on national TV (the BBC).
They even have a major political party, the British National Front which openly bashes minorities and immigrants.
And the SIkh community in the UK seems to be terrified of the goray... "what will the neighbours think???" Women are too afraid to wear salwar kameez in local malls for fear of being mocked or being called a 'paki' or 'wog'.
My cousins have often been called 'paki' walking down the street in their own neighbourhood.
Tell me this Dr. Kulim... with so many asian youth, why are almost no asian soccer players??? Why are their so few asian politicians??? Why do gursikhs face a glass ceiling in their workplaces??? These are all major complaints I hear from British Sikhs who've moved from England to Canada.
Any country that openly shows racism deserves no respect. Here in Canada, this does not occur openly, and I'll even say that it rarely occurs openly in the US. Of course it exists everywhere, but for racism to be openly allowed with no rebutting... thats just not right.
No, I'm sorry, I don't think the British deserve any respect and British Sikhs do not have to be loyal to the British Government, or tony blair, or the Queen or Camilla Parker, or who ever is running that country nowadays.
Re: British sikhs MUST be loyal to BRITAIN
charanjeev singh · 27 Jul 2005
First of all, its spelt thesis, not thesisi, and simpleton, not simpletomn. I appologize for going to your level.
But apart for this, I would like to further say, that a sikh pays no obedience to any country, including india. His country is Sachkhand, and he/she lives in this country within himself, no matter where his physical body might reside. His/her allegiance is to the practice of Truth and Humility, and not to crowns and positions. His/her currency is compassion, righteousness, effort, unmovable faith, and nobleness. He/she does not bow to any other flag other than the the Nishaan of Waheguruu. While living in any country, his/her behaviour must compliment the techings of the Guru, and he/she MUST be an example for other communities, and not follow the communities in which they are surrounded by.
As for parbhandaks; its is very sad that in todays world, we have people who live contrary to the principles of the Guru, in positions such as committees in the Gurus' House. These fake opportunists will be punished for their back talk in action against the Guru. These fake sikhs have no place in the Gurus' House as committee members. But the Guru is very compassionate; may the Guru also bless these fake parbhandhaks with Wisdom.
Bowing to the flag of england, is bowing to Aurangzeb if i may say so. We must not bow to any flag; but bow to virtues that form an example for those who have not been blessed with True Wisdom. We have a duty not to only better ourselves; but to show others the way of True Living.
Your subject or thesis was in relation, and i quote your title 'British Sikhs MUST be loyal to Britain'. In the very title; many double standards have been implied.
1. British Sikhs. There is no such thing as a British Sikh.
2. MUST. A sikh MUST NOT EVER bow to any rules and standards of ANYBODY except the rules of His Creator.
3. to BRITAIN. Britain was made by robbery and treachery. Mass murders, not only in india, but everywhere they laid foot. The empire was made by tyrant behaviours, the very behaviour that our Guru stood up against.
As for representations made by community leaders, yes if they are not presenting behaviours in motion with Sikhi Principles; absolutely it is the right, no, the duty of a Sikh to correct this. A true sikh never shows anger out of intollerance, but only brings out the sword to protect Humanity.
I only recommend that people do not follow customs of land they are from; example india, england, canada, malaysia, australia, africa, america, wherever. That all sikhs follow the principles of Sikhi in the land that they live in, and under no circumstance bow to land of their residence. Only bow to the principles of the the Path laid by our Gurus' and understand that this land belongs to God, and the the rules that must be adhered to must be that of God as well.
Be it britain, or anywhere else. The sikhs have a duty to represent the sikhs as Living Examples of Sikhs; and not political communities. And if parbhandakhs or any other community leaders have failed to represent the sikhs as the true Character of tollerance, compassion, and absolute tranquility; then it is our duty to correct this as well. For the Sikhs represent the Guru; and misrepresentation is a great sin.
Dear veerji, Dr. Gurcharan Singh Jee Kulim. If i have said anything wrong, i do appologize.
Great scholars such as yourself certainly will benefit the panth as a whole.
waheguruujikakhalsa waheguruujikifateh
[%sig%]
Re: British sikhs MUST be loyal to BRITAIN
Dr Gurcharan Singh Kulim; · 27 Jul 2005
Oh really a spelling lesson? is that all you are good for ?Now having paid you to do that job,let us move on.
I think you REALLY NEED TO GROW/
People like with tons hatred and excuses are no better than the paki benefit seekers!
"My cousins have often been called 'paki' walking down the street in their own neighbourhood."
That is very simple Mr TUF, because they have been living like pakis, and the way you and charanjeev describes you must be living like pakis -so be deserved to be called pakis.
Looks like charanjeev is only one step behind the likes of osama bin laden ....arm chair warriors on key boards.
I know how to spell, but looks like you do not like facts, and getting UP to my levek wil be a life long drea that you will beat about for like your peasants. ahh , one poor sikh looking to be football player,or a politician...you know why , because these sikhs in UK have been too long looking back to your mother india for too long than to live in todays britain.
The day they start living in todays britain and wake to reallity they will go places.
So they can go places in canada?Like killing their own in drug warfares?Like na ghar de na ghaat de.
grow up.
Re: British sikhs MUST be loyal to BRITAIN
BRITISH SIKH AND PROUD · 27 Jul 2005
Dr Gurcharan Great Job.These are just frustrated like charanjeev and varinder and the rest.They live off gurduaras , with cousins who are druggies etc.Looks like they live in unreal world.
Everybody is proud of their countries, but these wets see hatred in every thing western ---like the muslims.
It is easy for them to critisize, anyone else.Looks like a few have been whacked by gorays that they have frustrations oozing out of their eyes , ears and mouths and not to mention arse!
Victory for Britain
Re: British sikhs MUST be loyal to BRITAIN
Dr Gurcharan SINGH Kulim · 27 Jul 2005
First and foremost it must have burned your posterior to have attempted to reached UP to my level.I apologise your hard attempt.
Fuirst formost, there was no issue of the loyalty of a sikh to to sikhi.The trouble is LEARNED ONES LIKE YOU have habitually run in another direction when met with intelligence,therefore I can forgive your poor understanding.
I wonder if you carry a SIKH passport or canadian for convenience?Ver good many double standards from you and your preaching.Sikhs like you could do with many more like you.
I am glad, that you recognise MANY like yourself in the gurduara parbandhak committees.Now you are trying to preach to others, we could surely do with less like your brains.
Borrowing the passport of Canada is not bowing to Auranzeb?Or is it bowing to Indira Gandhi?
Strangley, speaking and writing in the language of England does not make you Jahangir but Churchill I suppose!
Dear Veer Chanarjeev ji, I am so sorry if I have said anything to tipple your mental intelligence which you surely seem to be lacking in.I recommend that you do not share with anyone else.
Dear Charanjeev ji,Great writers like yourselrf will surley benefit the parbandaks and those like who live in the shadows of hartred.
My apologies if I have pointed out you are indeed a misrepresentation of Guru Gobind Singh's message when he says ..recognise all as one human race...haters and preachers of hatred like you are indeed a bonus to the likes of you.
What double standards are you playing when you take oath under the canadian flag, and carry the canadin passport?From what I have heard all your preaching is producing is druggies and murderers in the sikh youth in Canada!You must be veruy low down there that you cannot see.
My sincere apologies if I have in any way upset your idealist world which is far from what you practice.
If you have any further spellings to correct ...I shall ask you start with your own, as I cannot lower to your level.
Re: British sikhs MUST be loyal to BRITAIN
charanjeev singh · 27 Jul 2005
Dr. Kulim,
I have no idea what you are on about...Honestly, nobody cares. As for me being a parbhandhak, hahahah..yeah right....
Hatred? I do not hate anybody, believe me when i say this...i have set my life to help the less fortunate; my life is based around animals to tell you the truth. My business and life is set around saving lives of animals and teaching compassion to people. And to be honest i do not care about your doctorates, and phds, however, i am educated at the same time..and very very more well travelled than you, i am confident in this. But mr. kulim, you and your other british lovers whom seem to share your love for the queen, can do this. Set up an appointment with the queen, and each of you can kiss her cheeks; and i aint referring to her face.
Until then. Have a good life. You hide behind big words, and calling yourself dr. you are a simpleton.
you are a waste of time.
[%sig%]
Re: British sikhs MUST be loyal to BRITAIN
Nav · 27 Jul 2005
I don't the logic of people here. Before ranting and raving about Jallianwalla Bagh, why don't we rant and rave about more recent events like Bluestar and the recent attempt to annhilate Sikh identity. Whatever racism Sikhs face in England is NOTHING compared to the state sponsored genocide that occured in India. Like it or not, the UK is a tolerant free society and you don't have to worry about being killed in a police encounter and left in a ditch. If anything Sikhs in UK should thank God for having the privilege to live in a free society that gives humans dignity UNLIKE India.
Sardar Kulim you are spot on. Our people our caught up in bhed chaal and too much desi baggage.
Re: British sikhs MUST be loyal to BRITAIN
Dr Gurcharan SINGH Kulim · 28 Jul 2005
Dear Moorakh andha di Tookri wala Charan jeev,
I really feel sorry for one who loves animals,you cannot love the land that feeds you.For such a person you are waste of space and mothers time...probably dads.
It is sad I fell for a simpleton like you and tried to educate you ...into enlightenment,
an andha like you will forever use others and blame them for your own sad mentality.
For an ignorant rat will always question others , but whne he is questioned he will ask why what are the rsons...that explains...the amount of space and time you have watsed on this argument rather than concetrate of getting ouyt of your grandoise delusions that you live to preach.
Poor sad man !get a life.
I am so sorry ...that you have no life than to argue around !!
Re: British sikhs MUST be loyal to BRITAIN
Bhola · 28 Jul 2005
sikhs are at a crossroads. while firecely exclaiming independance by khalsa nature and Guru Gobind Singhs call. The khalsa litany itself and the whole khalsa institution is a nation itself and has its first most duty towards the khalsa nation. The khalsa cannot be under any other banner than the nishan sahib. If for example sakes he fights to the death for british intrests because he livs on this land. His own ideals of the khalsa most likely woul conflict with the battle reality of fighting for the british intersts. The british will undoubtedly exclaim "fight for the right/loyalty/ justice blah blah" when in fact the real battle is over resources, land, control and domination.
then on other hand there is no other than the khalsa who have shown unparralelled loyalty in the lands in which they lived. Who knows what is to be from here as nationalism is slowly dieing with the new threats of global terrorism we may find a global answer instead of a narrow nationalised one.
So both arguments need to be carefully analysed in grater detail before sikhs walk ahead.
Re: British sikhs MUST be loyal to BRITAIN
khalsa_force · 28 Jul 2005
who the hell is the KULIM?
he pretends to be a scholar but acts like a class 5 student, so immature and foolish.
and this article of urs is CRAP.
i dont know wht u wana prove.
If one country is not loyal to a community how can u ask community to be loyal.
and may i know on wht basis u say tht SIKHS r NOT loyal to britian?
i dont c any reason...
Re: British sikhs MUST be loyal to BRITAIN
Ravinder Singh, UK · 28 Jul 2005
Dr Kulim,
A few months ago, I posted a question on this forum re: tying up my beard to be in the British Police.
I was in training school to be a PCSO and was being pressured by the trainer to tie up my free-flowing beard.
Your reply to me was to tie up my beard because we must "follow the rules of the country we live in."
Well let me tell you what happened..
I refused to compromise my free-flowing beard and told West Yorkshire Police that the ball was in their court.
After a week, the Superintendent of the Training school called me to his office and apologised whole heartedly and stated that I could keep my beard in its natural state.
I am now 4 months into my role as a Police Community Support Officer for West Yorkshire Police with a dumalla and free-flowing beard, by Guru ji's apaar kirpa.
To you Dr.,
am I just "living like a paki?" or..
"only one step behind the likes of osama bin laden" or maybe I just..
"do not look any different from those sword waving akalis and their mentality."
Re: British sikhs MUST be loyal to BRITAIN
PUNJABI EZINE KHALISTAN · 28 Jul 2005
i also find british chittahr licking articles distasteful.
bezti to the pagh sengh sort it out.
Fact BRITISH NEWSPAPERS CLUB INDIANS PAKISTANIS SIKHS HINDUS MUSLIMS TOGETHER AS ASIANS. A RACIAL TERM FOR BROWN SKINND PEOPLE WHO WHITE MASSES ARE NOT EVEN FULLY INFORMED OF DUE TO GHETTOE ENGINEERED POLITICS DIVIDE AND RULE.
FACT 1984 THE GHANDI VERSION WAS BOUGHT OUT AND STUCK TO AS A BIBLE TO THIS DAY.
FACT SIKH HOLOCAUST BRITAIN SILENT.
FACT BEZATI ISSUE SIKHS MADE TO LOOK LIKE FANATICS.
FACT WE WORK OUR ARSES OFF IN WHITE MANS LAND PAYING 17.5% VALUE TAX ON EVERYTHING EVEN YOUR SHAMPOO AND SOAP IS NOT SPARED. IN ADDITION TO INCOM TAX 1 THIRD OF YOUR WAGE GONE.
FACT BRITISH MEDIA AND THE GOV DELIBERATLY ENGINERED RACISM IN BRITAIN TO INCREASE TO SET WHITES APART FROM COLOURED PEOPLE CAUSING A WAR ZON EFFCT IN THE 1980S.
FACT GURDWARAS ARE ATTACKED BY WHITES BRAINASHED BY THE BRITISH MEDIA INTO THINKING ASIANS ARE ONE.
FACT SIKHS MAY B IN GOOD JOBS ONLY AT THE COST OF WORKING TWICE HARDER THAN WHITE COUNTERPARTS LIK MACHINS.
sO IN EFFCT WHY LICK THE GORAS CHITTZ? BEZTI SINGH HAVE SOM SARDARI IZZAT FOR YOUSELF BOW TO NONE. ESTABLISH KHALISTAN KHALSA YA BHAGGI.THERE IS NO OTHER WAY LIVE WITH RSPECT AND WARRIOR SPIRIT. SINGH SOORMEY KISSE DE NEI CHAMCHEY SADE NASSALA VICH SHERA DHA KHOON BHAGDA WE DEMAND KHALISTAN AND WILL NVER LICK ANYONS BACKSIDE. oUR JIND BOWS ONLY TO THE TIMELESS SPIRIT AND THE KHALSA SANT SIPAHI SADH SANGAT.
WHILE WE NO APOLOGIST FOR MUSLIMS IF THIS LAND HAD EQUAL TRATMENT FROM TH START WELCOMD MINORITIES AMONGST WHITES, WE WOULD HAVE BEEN A MULTIRACIAL SOCIETY. tHEY THEMSELVES THE WHIT STABLISHMENT NEED TO RETHINK ABOUT THE WAY THEY TREAT COLOURED PEOPLE WHAT LESSONS DID THEY LARN FROM RACE RIOTS FROM SOUTHALL, BIRMINGHAM, BRIXTON, THESE INVOLVD ALL COLOURED PEOPLES. SO WHERE DID THE PROBLEM LIE? WHY DO ALL COLOUED PEOPLE HAVE A PROBLEM?
KHALISTAN JINDABAD
Re: British sikhs MUST be loyal to BRITAIN
Dr Gurcharan Singh kuil · 28 Jul 2005
Dear ravinder singh ji,
You are right.I based my suggestion on existing law.By going one step forward you have proved another acheivement.That is great achivement.What I did not ask you to do is start hating the british and bombing which is almost what many of these individuals are asking to do.But quite happy to live off the state.that is all.
but as is usual gutter language , and foul mouths of the fanatics and extremists take over, and rule and shout the loudest.
I recall one in the service one Sikh asked me to ensure I always tied my beard.I followed that, but soon also began going in without tying, soon it was quite a norm to do that.
What I did not do is shout rant, and do danda politicing, or saying good bye to the service.
Mr bhola understands what I have tried to say.All i have said be loyal to the nation that feeds us, and allows us to flourish.
I am sure you must also know that it is only in this land of britain one can pracyice freely what one wants.
these punjabi khalsiatni and so called khals foos are just little people who cordinate the gurduara politics and miond sets that Sikhs often find themselves in the middle of unwittingly.
Re: British sikhs MUST be loyal to BRITAIN
TUF · 28 Jul 2005
Balle Balle Dr. Kulim,
You are quite a character. Thank you for putting up a post that is creating such a controversy.
Face the facts, Britain is a racist society. Drive out of Birmingham, or London or Manchester to some smaller towns and watch how the goray stare at your pugh and dhaari, and snicker behind your back. You are a second-class citizen in your own country... face it my friend.
And to follow the white-man, to do as he does... I won't be surprised if your children leave Sikhi and convert to Christianity, because that is the next logical step in your 'progression'.
Sorry, I'm proud of Sikhism, I'm proud of my culture, and here in Canada, my country is proud of my culture. We are not a melting pot like the UK, instead multiculturalism is encouraged.
Come visit Toronto or Vancouver and you will see the huge difference in the attitudes of the people. Here the white youth try to copy us... they try to learn our language and dance to our music and play our kabaddi.
Stop your childish mockery and state some decent facts my friend.
Re: British sikhs MUST be loyal to BRITAIN
kulbir singh uk wala · 28 Jul 2005
BRITISH BORN AND BRED! RIGHT??
I have been living in Canada for over a decade now, thought I am born and brought up in the UK.
I chose to leave Britain because I always felt inferior, I think growing up in the heart of the black country did not help, yet I chose to leave and make Canada my home, were quite frankly speaking, I feel that I am treated as an equal!
I say to those of you who are sitting/living in the UK. and trashing it. Referencing the history from the Raj, and attitudes towards us a being 'pakis', I say this. Either shut up or get out. That’s it quite simple. I agree with Dr. kulim that if you want to suck the life out of Britain at least stand proud as a British Sikh, for if not, what is your real home called (lets not go into dream phase now about khalistan, because that’s not happening, sorry to burst your bubbles!)
The UK. is no greater monster to Sikhs than India, so were do you call home/ or do you continue to trash every country/people?
Like I stated earlier, I chose to leave... some of you may want to do the same.
LETS NOT JUDGE A PEOPLE BASED UPON THE POLITICAL ACTIONS OF THEIR ANCESTORS...SIKHI IS BIGGER/GREATER THAN THIS, AND LETS STOP WITH THE HATING. YOU PEOPLE WILL GET NOWHERE.
IMHO.
Re: British sikhs MUST be loyal to BRITAIN
gabbar parmar · 28 Jul 2005
veh kulim sio
Uk is free society? are you sure?
so why are we getting stereotyped because of the acts of 4 brown skinned bombers? Why do the countless thousands and hundreds of whites we encounter everyday not look past our skin?
how many white sikhs get the same treatment?
you have to bend your arse down backwards and give up your values even then your lucky if you will be accepted. Bottom line your a paki to them face what you are. Your words do not rub your mukh chittah. Be proud of your desi roots. Gurdwara politics are the extreme fringe minority example we have much to be proud of. What about coconuts lost their identity?
Nav you are not familiar with hat went on here. These basterds did not do an 84 they e....d us up slowly and stabbed us in the back at every opportunity. The only reason we have even the right to wear a kara is because we had to go to courts to fight for it. There were days when these white dogs never gave jobs to coloured people. This is not their country now. We have built on top of it after the second world war with our sweat and labour taxation. These white dogs just control the seat of power.
These kuttey will never respect or give us equal rights in reality its just bullshyte on paper. Ask the england sikhs more so youth to get the real picture.
The gorey kuttey used to harrass sikhs comin home beating our bazurg up. The police used to stand by and watch them. When racist attacks occured the police would intimidate the ethnics as though the ku klux klan was itself infilitrated in the police. It is only after years of racial backlash they are trying to undo their hidden white evil agenda. It cannot wash so easily, they playd with fire, now th very people they made suffer have a big wall of silence to the white man.
the brit kuttey told us where we stand many yars ago. Their posture remained final, now it is set in concrete. keep them their valus on their side we have our own.
anothr twist these gorey never officially leaked in their kalyug racist newspapers these asian riots actually started with bnp activists running down asian streets across northern towns. Knocking breaking entries through premises, stabbing people at random including bazurgi lokh. The police were informed and did nothing to stop it nor did the papers report it. As far as people were concerned they were under threat for their livs with no protection.
Now you tell me when where thse gorey racist kuttey ever give assali rspect to singhs not this british empire type connection i mean real rspect. Your just a brown paki in a turban to them thats why.
we have no compassion or party with evil deeds.
This is not their country, they took 180 years of our desi wealth at the annual of 160 million a years as per madan dhingras shaheedi khatt. Our forefathers foughht and died for this kutta nation. Our parents and we worked hard sweating day and night to build these industries becausethe white man sat on his arse so the brown labour came in. The youth are here this is our land.
All the sikhs selling out think how your folks were spat on by the national front. Ho cn you change? death to imperialism.
kulim go and meet the youth ask them what affects them dont hide behind scholar . Come meet us dildara.
our heads are never loyal to no one, we are our own makers sher sipahi with our own road to march down when the time is right.
DOWN DOWN DOWN WITH IMPERIALISTS
[%sig%]
Re: British sikhs MUST be loyal to BRITAIN
TUF · 28 Jul 2005
Gabbar Parmar... I agree with you 100%. Well said.
Re: British sikhs MUST be loyal to BRITAIN
Summary · 28 Jul 2005
wow busy post.
let me summarise.
kulim is insecure about being asian in UK as muslims have tarnished asians reputation.
so his response is to suck up to the english in hope to gain a bit of respect.
others remember the crimes the british commited world-wide and their policy of divide and conquer.
kulim then retaliates by calling all people with a different opinion terrorists or stupid or backwards etc...
desi posted a extraodinary extract from an english book on india. on how british public loved dyer's killings and awarded him as if he was a saint.
tuf asks why no Sikh politicians and kulim replies cuz Sikhs look back on India and act like pakis.
he then calls all people who debate arm chair warriors on key boards.
It appears to me kulim is a stubborn and unreasoning person who would be capable of being in charge of the BNP.
Re: British sikhs MUST be loyal to BRITAIN
anonymous · 28 Jul 2005
why r all who disagree with kulim branded as terrorists. this is typical goray attitude.
surely you have to terrorise to become terrorist. what happened to freedom of speech
is kulim a doctor of worshipping the english. well done if so you passed with flying colours.
how many FAKE Sikhs does it take to clean an english persons bottom?
just the one - kulim will do it! lol!
Re: British sikhs MUST be loyal to BRITAIN
desi · 28 Jul 2005
This needs to be read so I post again.
'and many of the several thousands in the Bagh are thought to have been villagers from outside Amritsar who had come into the city to celebrate this popular spring festival......immediately ordered them to fire into the crowd. He gave the order to cease firing only when their ammunition was exhausted......the crowd had offered no threat, Dyer had given no warning; communication was by bullet alone. Because Dyer's men were occupying the main exit, the crowd obligingly formed a dense scrum round the only other way out. It was impossible for the troops to miss; nor did they. The wounded were left untended, the dead uncounted. Dyer simply drove away, mission completed.
'The official enquiry would later conclude that 1650 rounds had been fired inside the Jallianwala Bagh.......when later questioned, Dyer seemed if anything proud of his action. His intention, he said, had been to exact revenge for the previous killings and to make an EXAMPLE which would deter further defiance anywhere in the PANJAB. To this end he also had prisoners beaten, sometimes in public and had male Indians CRAWL the street where an English missionary lady had been attacked. Equally provocative methods were employed in Lahore. At Gujranwala Governor O'Dwyer had simply ordered up aircraft and had the city BOMBED...... Moreover it soon became apparent that MANY OTHER BRITISH PEOPLE FELT THE SAME WAY. Although relieved of his command, Dyer was never formally punished. On the contary, in England he was REWARDED. As the "Saviour of Panjab" a Morning Post subscription was raised on his behalf; it realised £26 000. Designated "Defender of the Empire" he was presented with a gilt sword.'
Re: British sikhs MUST be loyal to BRITAIN
Dr Gurcharan Singh kuil · 28 Jul 2005
sad mental freaks of left over politics from pendu punjuab
oye gabbri giddar param maa !!
very sad goonda gardi road sweepers oye !!
Re: British sikhs MUST be loyal to BRITAIN
desi · 28 Jul 2005
Questions for kulim and people who agree with him.
1) why won't queen apologise for Bagh massacre?
2) am I terrorist if I do not wish to pledge allegiance to killing people in
Britans name?
3) what are the policies of BNP(BRITISH NATIONAL PARTY - if you did not
know)?
4) 10,000+ Sikh brothers died in anglo-Sikh war. why?
5) was the anglo-Sikh war(the war was in Panjab so Sikhs only defended their homes) started by British or Sikhs?
6) why was general dyer given £26,000 by british public?
7) why was he presented with a gilt sword for his massacre?
8) how should british Sikhs show loyalty to britain?
9) Bhopinder says brits did a favour by dividing Bhart. couldn't we have done this ourselves at the cost of less lives?
10) why were Sikh brothers forced to crawl our own streets in our own country by british commanders?
11) why do Sikhs get killed/attacked for LOOKING LIKE bin laden in this country?
12) what are you a doctor of/in?
please reply to ALL these questions Dr and show this wisdom which you claim to have while stating others have very little or none.
feel free to ask me any of your questions also regarding the matter.
Re: British sikhs MUST be loyal to BRITAIN
what? · 28 Jul 2005
kulim talks of Guru Gobind Singh Jee. does he know that even the Guru Jee said there comes a time when one must, as a last resort, pick up the sword to defend yourself, the weak, the righteous and Waheguru's cause.
Britain is a country not a person. A country who invaded Bharat stole all it's jewels and riches and then divided it to weaken it before leaving.
A country who invaded Africa and stole all it's riches and then divided it to weaken it before leaving.
Britain stole the strongest and cleverest Africans to use as slaves in Britain to build houses, roads, railways, industries etc. all at the cost of nothing.
while India/Bharat paid civilians to build and construct, Britain got this done for free from slavery.
I put money on it that Dr Kulims ancestors were raped and killed by the same country he is now so loyal to. Congratulations Dr Kulim - bow to your queen while I bow to the Guru Granth Sahib!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Re: British sikhs MUST be loyal to BRITAIN
ashamed? · 28 Jul 2005
where did Kulim get his doctrate?
you try to opinionate with him and he throws insults at you and your beliefs
are you ashamed of your heritage?
in his defence he has got a point though, Sikhs must respect the country they live in and the people they live with in that country. we must not hate anyone. we must strive to improve the societies we live in.
however Dr Kulim you must understand not all British Sikhs are treated with the same amount of respect as you seem to be by Britains.
My friend's mum was walking through a park with her other son (aged 11) when 4 english youths (aged 16-18) shouted abuse at them and behaved very aggresively towards them and stole his cap. Remember these youths probably gained that attitude through their parents as you have been so quick to judge Sikh parents for instilling hatred when they are merely stating what happened during the british raj in modern India.
Re: British sikhs MUST be loyal to BRITAIN
khalsa_force · 29 Jul 2005
then i guess KULIM wont hv any problem with French bann on turban.
Re: British sikhs MUST be loyal to BRITAIN
Ravinder Singh, UK · 29 Jul 2005
Dr Kulim,
You stated..
>What I did not ask you to do is start hating the british and bombing which is almost what many of these individuals are asking to do.<
You are right.. we should not start hating the british. As Guru day Sikh we should not hate anybody. But I don't think any of these individuals are advocating hating or bombing the british, they are just frustrated and rightly so.. We should never forget our history but we should also live in the present.
Yes, there is subtle racism everywhere in Britain and the media never portrays Sikhs in a positive light but that doesn't mean we should stand on the sidelines and hate. We should play our full part in this worldly drama and show the world Sikhi.
The Khalsa thrives on opposition.
From this opposition we will gain STRENGTH. Only by swimming against the tide do we gain STRENGTH. Stength of mind and character.
If we swim with the tide we will only get weaker and feel inferior in society.
If we have given our heads to Satguru, then our loyalty and allegiance is with Guru ji and SACH alone. This will make us the perfect citizens of not only Britain but the whole world.
Please read the following from Charanjeev once again:
>There is no such thing as a british sikh, a canadian sikh, a malaysian sikh, an african sikh, an indian sikh; a sikh is a sikh is a sikh is a sikh. He/she owes no alleigance to any country, state, government, nobody. The alleigance is to Waheguruu and Guruu, the owners of All including this earth. His flag is the Nishaan Sahib. His government is Sri Akaal Takhat. His governing body is Panj Pyareh. His King is Guru Granth Sahib Jee.<
Ravinder Singh
Re: British sikhs MUST be loyal to BRITAIN
khaler · 29 Jul 2005
i was 1 minute away from a much biggr bomb blast which caused more structural damage than any one of th train bombs 4 years ago. the bomber decided to blow up brick lane an asian area and had intended to set bombs off in southall bradfod and birmingham with the intent to kill ethnic people and gays to demonstrate his hatrd for multi cultural britain. the bomber was white and a bnp activist.
I could have ben killd by a supremacist bomber. london being 45% of ethnic composition including myself did not go round casting evil eyes on white people on the account of one supremacist bomber. neither were any churches attacked, nor were whits attackd for it, in fact it pulled ethnic people closer together and learn from it.
We did not find whites writing apologetic essays to suck up to us. This does define colour attitudes, it is stirred at a bigger level. the government on white paper pretends to be multi cultural to attract global invstors and liven up its image. The truth is intrnal politics and its media ar are good at dividing different races into ghettoes. How can on explain 250 000 muslims in manchster, 250 000 blacks in brixton, 80 000 sikhs in west london? the majority of whits live outside well away from coloued people in home counties.
Dr Kulim ji instead of dividing sikhs apart from other religions and nationalities we should clarify our disgust towards trrorism but understand our problems essentially are no different from any othr coloured minority here. Its also a bit harsh to lay blame on muslims i man like 4 guys?
the gov first let extremist muslims come from th middle east after arabs kicked them out. then the extremists took over mosques and brainwashed loads of youth to fanatic islam. The muslim community then approached the police, and gov authorities to deal with it to stop it getting bigger. the gov allowed it to carry on.
muslims themselvs tried to fight them off and have kicked some of these fanatic groups out of their mosques. the media again are picking up muslims random and only showing the ons using iraq as an excuse. real test ask a coupl of muslims anywhere what they think of thse bombings and how it affects them. trust m you will find they hate the bombers because now it has made thir lives hell and have to live with being stereotyped and not even openly declare themselvs as muslims.
So its not fair to say things that just blankt out muslims.
Re: British sikhs MUST be loyal to BRITAIN
sikh beerah · 31 Jul 2005
this is a blatent fact, in london mosques most of th xtremists are out with the exception of the hamza case which also moderate muslims finally overturned him out rslting in a greater numbr of worshippers . Its easy to look at islami bana and judge muslims as much as sikhs get judged. You do not know what goes on behind the newspaper reports and our own rumours and suspicions. Good muslims are working at stopping fanatics
.
The northern muslim extremists claim london mosques are government mouthpieces. The north essentially is where the problems are surprisingly with decline of industries, lack of employment, racism, dictated parental cultural/tribal rules here come th xtremists empowering the youth with fanatic islam to define their identity both in terms socially with an islamic social system, and at home how to deal islamically with clashing tribal and religious rules.
Kulim jio please do some rsearch it is totally unjust to paint muslims in a bad light.
Consider sikhs if they were to throw gurdwara politics into the slaughtering media machine in front of the world, its like showing everyone in the world our dirty washing right in the limelight.
Obviously the issue of the suicie bombers has gaind huge publicity and this dirty washing is coming out anyway. But thre are two sides to every story, refrain kindly from judgin badly.
You as a siana sikh should dialogue with young muslims and get them to speak out and understand them rathr than cuss their whole community. As a sikh i would like the world to understand our problems and not cxall us terrorists, murderers from indian newspaper reports too.
May Guru Ji do kirpa on you bhai sahib
Re: British sikhs MUST be loyal to BRITAIN
Pardeep Singh Bilga · 31 Jul 2005
Can I just jump in here and ask a couple of questions re Dr. Kulim:
Is the Dr. really a patriotic Brit, or an Indian Govt agent, trying to make the Sikh youth firstly to forget their Panjabi roots (no offence to the non-Panjabi Sikh brothers and sisters, but lets face it, most of us do originate from that land) and then to think they are just typical goray, who have to "accept the law of the land" (as in the beard tying advice). Where does this end- tomorrow the main political parties may suggest that all minorities should FULLY integrate and take the appearance of typical Brits- do we then accept this and shave off our kes?
What are the Dr's views on 1984/Sant Bhindranwale/Sikh shaheeds? He rarely seems to comment on these kind of subjects- is he a Mahatma Gandhi type - non-violent- WHATEVER happens?
Re: British sikhs MUST be loyal to BRITAIN
Hramander singh · 31 Jul 2005
A prime exmaple of the hatred the so called sikhs on this net are showing under their presumed Sikhi.This is the way these simpletons, and failed individuals of sikhs will be going.Their klanguage on this forum sjohows when an argument is lost , name calling becomes the mothers nature.
when they cant rsie to be someone calling names becomes their habit.These "sikhs" are insular looking individuals who under the garb of Sikhi want to drive the Sikhs to the fanaticism seen in muslims, as highlighted by this article.
being a Sikh does nots top one from being loyal to their own countries, amazing when they want benefits these individuals will falsh their passports, and some still call Bharat mata , after having their daughters and sisters raped and mollested.if only some inch of brains were apparent ....
A fatal failure to identify with this nation or the country of their parents turns young Muslims to Islamic extremism, writes Aatish Taseer
It is not hard to imagine what the Leeds suburb of Beeston was like before it became known that three of London’s Tube bombers worked or lived there. For someone like me — a Punjabi with parents from each side of the India-Pakistan border — the streets here reveal a pre-partition mixture of Punjabi Muslims and Sikhs.
Men in shalwar kurta (traditional dress from the subcontinent) stand on street corners chatting as if in a bazaar in Lahore. They oppose Britain’s involvement in the Iraq war, they “hate” America, they might even think the West has united in a fight against Muslims; but these are not the faces of extremism. Their involvement in 7/7 is a generational one: they have raised the young men who are the genus most susceptible to Islamic extremism in this country — the second- generation British Pakistanis.
One appears next to his father on a street corner. Unlike his father there is nothing about his appearance that indicates he is a Punjabi Muslim. An Arabisation has occurred: he is wearing long Arab robes and keeps a beard cut to Islamic specification. I ask him why he is dressed that way.
“It’s my traditional dress,” he says in English.
“Isn’t your father in traditional dress?” I ask.
“Yes, but this is Islamic dress,” he clarifies. His father looks embarrassed. A man standing next to me jokes of how he complained to his neighbour that his son never did any work and the neighbour said: “You think that’s bad, mine’s grown a beard and become a bloody maulvi (priest).”
As a half-Indian, half-Pakistani with British citizenship, I have observed the gulf between what it means to be British Pakistani and British Indian. To be Indian is to come from a safe, ancient country and, more recently, from an emerging power. In contrast, to be Pakistani is to begin with a depleted idea of nationhood. In the almost 58 years that Pakistan has been a country, it has been a dangerous, violent place defined by hatred of the other — India. Its national image has been tarnished.
For young British Muslims, if Pakistan was not the place to look for an identity, being second-generation British was less inspiring. While their parents were pioneers, leaving Pakistan in search of economic opportunities, the second generation’s experience has been one of drudgery and confusion.
The owner of a convenience store on Stratford Street in Beeston, who knew the bombers, said: “They were born and raised here, we did the work and these kids grew up and they haven’t had a day’s worry. They’re bored, they don’t do any work, they have no sense of honour or belonging.”
While their parents’ generation was consumed with the challenge of building a life from scratch in Britain, they had far more time to consider and eventually doubt its purpose.
When our Tube bombers were growing up, any notion that an idea of Britishness should be imposed on minorities was seen as offensive. Unlike in America, where minorities wear their acquired national identity with great pride, Britons were having a hard time believing in Britishness.
If you denigrate your culture you face the risk of your newer arrivals looking for one elsewhere. So far afield in this case that for many second-generation British Pakistanis the desert culture of the Arabs held more appeal than either British or subcontinental culture. Three times removed from a durable sense of identity, the energised extra-national world view of radical Islam became one available identity for second-generation Pakistanis. The few who took it did so with the convert’s zeal.
The older generation of Beeston is mystified as to where some of their children found this identity. By all accounts it was not in the mosque. I met Maulana Munir of the Stratford Street mosque which, according to some newspapers, was attended by the London bombers. A small, soft-spoken man, he said he had never known them.
“This younger generation,” he said, “are owners of their own will. They come when they like, they don’t when they don’t like. The mosque is not responsible for these people.”
Hassan Butt, the young British Pakistani who was a spokesman for the extremist group Al-Muhajiroun and active in recruiting people to fight in Afghanistan, embodies this journey from frustration and rootlessness to radical Islam. What he found has made him an ardent supporter of “martyrdom actions” and he is a martyr aspirant himself.
The world Butt describes before he was approached, at the age of 17, by members of the Islamic group Hizbut Tahrir, was one in which “hot-headedness” was leading people around him “down a path of destruction” involving drugs, crime and prostitution. It was a world out of order, lacking prescriptive force of any kind. Islam reinstated a social equilibrium in his life.
The radicalised version of Islam that Butt found filled the vacuum that the absence of national identity had left. He was no longer part of the condition he described when he said: “The majority who I know of Pakistani descent are really fed up with the British way of life, British standards. They are even fed up with the Pakistani culture and traditions that are un-Islamic.”
The resulting antipathy for nationhood was immense. He parted ways with Omar Sheikh Bakri and Al-Muhajiroun because they supported the Islamic idea of a “covenant of security”, by which Muslims in Britain are forbidden from any type of military action in Britain. The principle behind the covenant is that if a country plays host to you, it is un-Islamic to strike against it.
While Butt believed that military action against Britain would be unwise for the practical reason that it would jeopardise the protection that Londonistan was offering radical Muslims, he could not tolerate the position that it was un-Islamic.
“Especially now,” he told me. “With Afghanistan gone, the Muslims don’t really have a place where they can come back to, regroup and have time to think and relax without the authorities breathing down their necks.”
He felt that the covenant did not apply to British Muslims as they were born here and did not enter by any choice of their own into a pact: “I am not in favour of military action in Britain, but if somebody did do it who was British, I would not have any trouble with it. Islamically it would be my duty to support and praise their action.”
So great was Butt’s antipathy for nationhood that even the fact of his British citizenship was an encumbrance rather than a privilege. “My allegiance is to Allah,” he said, “his sharia, his way of life. Whatever he dictates as good is good, whatever he dictates as bad is bad.”
These diktats are not simply a matter of private belief, they pave the way for a new extra-national identity with political ambitions. Hizbut Tahrir made no secret of the fact that its goal was the re- establishment of the caliphate, or a central Islamic order in Muslim countries. For Butt, however, this was not enough. Once he had accepted Islam into his life, his ambition for it was limitless.
“Fourteen hundred years ago,” he told me, “you had a small city state in Medina and within 10 years of the prophet it spread to Egypt and all the way into Persia. I don’t see why the rest of the world, the White House, 10 Downing Street, shouldn’t come under the banner of Islam.”
I was reminded of Butt’s cold hatred for Britain when a colleague of mine said that in her conversations with members of Beeston’s younger generation barely a week after the London bombings they were saying, “Well, what is the difference between Al-Qaeda and MI5 anyway?” and “It’s sad that people have died, but what about the ones who died in Iraq?”
There it was again, the great extra-national sentiment where no nation matters save the Islamic nation and its Arab culture.
What worried me when I went to Beeston and met some of its youth was that although they formed a small section even of Pakistani society, they were so susceptible to the advances of groups such as Hizbut Tahrir.
A shopkeeper cited a government-funded youth centre as a place where “something underground was going on”. He meant the Hamara youth centre, which the Beeston bombers attended. With Butt’s story in my head, the format was familiar. The first meetings of angry youth with almost definitely an outside organisation, the extra-national glue of Islam to bind the group together, the ever-expanding sense of grievance inflamed with propaganda, the inevitable decision to act. It could happen to youth anywhere, but the risk is greatest where the national identity is eroded, the challenges of life unrewarding and the doctrine all encompassing.
The kids I met in Beeston were not in the mood to ask questions. Their rage came first. They bandied around words such as Iraq and Palestine, but were often badly informed and felt no kinship with other non-Muslim Britons who were also angry about these issues. It suited them better to think of it as a unified attack on Islam linking unconnected conflicts ranging from Kashmir to Palestine. The version of Islam they had found did not allow for much questioning.
In a climate where so many aspects of identity have been thrown into doubt, those who find radical Islam must be relieved that it leaves so few of them room for questions; it is part of its completeness. When I asked Butt about a moderate view of Islam, he said triumphantly: “You’ve hit the nail on its head. If somebody believes that it’s the incontestable word of Allah, how can he then take a moderate view?”
Radical Islam is a global phenomenon drawing recruits from all varieties of desperate conditions and last week’s events have shown Somali and Eritrean communities to be vulnerable to its appeal, too. However, British second-generation Pakistanis, because of their sheer numbers and singular estrangement, are most vulnerable. They have been hardest hit by the great population changes of the past 50 years and the alienation that came with them.
They have rallied behind a banner and created a fantastic sense of grievance. As long as it exists they can channel all their anger and frustration into it. When they are done chasing absurd dreams of restored caliphates, there is always martyrdom.
“For me there is nothing bigger,” said Butt, “if somebody goes out there militarily and fights for the sake of Allah and kills for the sake of Allah and is killed for the sake of Allah — nothing bigger any Muslim can do.” In Beeston I met many with his makings: small, uprooted lives after bigger things.
This article is extracted from an in-depth interview with Hassan Butt in the latest issue of Prospect
Re: British sikhs MUST be loyal to BRITAIN
Ghamman · 01 Aug 2005
this is utter lies by agents like kushwant singh.
The hatred for india is over kashmir where millions of muslims suffer under indian occupation, loss of their eastern territory by indra ghandis fauj, a huge massacre of muslims 3 times the number of sikhs murdered iun partition.
How many assali anakhi singhs would you find really liking or hating india for 84?
Secondly britain is bloody racist whether you admit it or not. This is not apparent in souithall or gravejunt where sikhs make a big majority.
Try to migrate to any area outside london in the black country ( so called rural enbglish middle england). Sikhs who have tried have come ouit victimised. Just the otyher day a black teeneger was axed to death in liverpool for being with a white gf. What wiull be the justice procedure? same as s lawrence? free the guilty.
We have been through many race riots involving most minorities blacks sikhs muslims whatever is left. Racism is still rife 30 years on.
To understand and grasp ion the brain that level of racism, imagine person after person calling you a paki nigger bunhead giving you glares, thnrowing bottles at you stones through your window, treating you as you are there as a sitting duck. people just looking at you, goiung bright red and lashing at you for this skin colkour.
Your emotions, sense of belonging will break down first, then yoiuy will become cold, then you will slowly become stirred and rise up to what you are facing. Your nice side will fade, yoiu will want changes but see none, ytear after year decade after decade. What are you? a slave. so how do you change this prison without walls? how do you break free from this? you start first rejecting whats around you as false.
Now you will never understand nor will that agent waht generation of race victims went through, or how the cycle changes until you start dialogue with the people. Until then these agents will keep on blaming and never look at the bottom root of the problem which can be best answered by the government and its electronic marketing machinery.
We used to face hell everyday on london streets some 10 years ago. The white extremists moved out to cheaper areas up north where they continued thgeir race hate in softer forms in white areas.
lewts see how many sikhs will move into whiote areas without being harrassed. oneof my brothers anb amritdhari singh moved on the edge of perry bar inside birmingham itself in the white area. Since moving there his vehicles had been set on fire each time he had a better one. With the birth of his baby son he had to move for security purposes.
I can list a few hundred inciodents. These happened before sep 11 and after. Terroprism has nothbing to do with it. Terrorism is just an excuse to attack colopuired people.
Now you go for a job, your coplour is always against you. The aristocratic english class is always against you. you will always be second class they thrive in creating this inferior image for you. protest against it and they will find ways to get you out. The police will not give a crap if your injured or hurt. Look at the chauhaun guy in cranford who was killed by gorey. the police thought dodgy asian bussinessman and never touched the case until his wifes brother took it up from new zealand. being a coloured person you will always come second.
To all you saying we complain, all i say to you is the day you go through what we went through, you will never say that again. Count yourself lucky you grew up in southall and not some national front terror zone.
Now i ask youy why is the national front and bnp not branbded a terrosist organiosation? we were terrorised for decades everyday no one heard us.
[%sig%]
Re: British sikhs MUST be loyal to BRITAIN
Ghamman · 01 Aug 2005
so round and round we go. If they do not want any changes, what can anyone else do?
Think of it another way, last 50 years, india and pak divided by brit, punjab to be finished with that dividing line. Muslim lands were divided up the same way as punjab, pathans were divided through the middle into pak and afghanistan by a brit. The same occured in kurdistan which was split by brits into different countries. Then came the "round table convention" british convention which supported sa mandate for a seperate jewish land. Israeal was not created by jewish hardiness or democracy, iut was created by british support at the cost oif millions of muslims being uprooted from their homes. Kashmir also went. In all these lands millions were killed and suffered by british policies. After 50 years 4 suicide bom,bers emerge, it takes all that for 4 guys to do that.
Does that not tell the world there is a problem created by somebody? if it were other way round would anyone else take so much?
now they have not only caste the first stone, buit thrown more, nevr ending, as trhough we are born to be targets.
We can modernise mosques, stop arabs, but the bottom problem will alaways be there until both sides take responsibility, that is muslims themselves and most importantly the instigators the establishment in whose hands the power lies to create fresh air and change.
Finally anyoine using pretence go back if not happy. Where is home? we are ali8ens as mnuch as anyone else wherever we go.
Without looking at it from someones shoes you will only hate and blame others. This is about unfair policies.
Re: British sikhs MUST be loyal to BRITAIN
singh soorma · 01 Aug 2005
this is how i see it. Kesdhari sikhs will probably feel the backlash a lot becauseof how they look. In turn they will be angry at what the 7/7 bombers did under religion, question it and feel outraged at muslims.
But most monei are in the same boat as muslims in this country. They do not sympathise with terrorism, but discretely feel the farangis had it coming. Th british did not make democracy we helped them achieve it and what did they do? they cordoned brighton off after the second world war victory, to stop natives seeing punjabi heroes. There is nothing here to "milk". They pay you 50 quid a week for benefits how far will that get you?
Most sikhs are izzatdhar and work hard, they are not dole bound.
There are problems that have not been accounted.
This is not about pakistan, beeston, leeds or mirpuris. there is a wider growing resentment at how ethnic people are treated in society. In brixton alone every 3rd of a mile there is a masjid dedicated to reforming black society towards nation of islam (yes lious farrakhan style). For those who know what this means these problems are not restricted to pakistanis or islam.
If noi increases and itsvoice becomes more vocal there will be fireworks another clash of civilisations thsi time east and west and black and white.
It has taken root amongst carribean community and others like a vacuam. We were supposed to be equal citizens with equal chances in a democracy empowering us with rights and ability to reach high and live with pride.
Somebody must account for the mess.
Re: British sikhs MUST be loyal to BRITAIN
Gurcharan Singh Kulim · 01 Aug 2005
If every body speoke with rationality and sense then there would be no need for the likes of ANONYMOUS to be hiding under the BOTTOM of a Gora.
Staying loyal to a country is not selling one's Sikh values.The trouble is there are many here who would sell their mothers and sisters to the indian government but call themselves Indians and carry Indian passports.Some would benefit from all western and still act like the terrorists.Others who are indian fake agents are busy calling others indian, and I am NOT even born in india but a fourth generation overseas born sikh who proudly carries my Sikh faith.Britain has NOT erased my faith ...BUT strenghtened it to be a Sikh and British sikh.
There is a threat to the nation, and calling british Sikhs to stand strong to the nation has been made to look like selling one faith.
Hatred has been expressed, but then these people would hate their own fathers and fellow khlistanis.The Khlaistani struggle did not fail because of outside forces , but we have such doubled standards people who dont know what they are themselves , but to call another a name is their posterial birth right it seems.
learn a lesson, but these people cannot because it is thanks to people with such mentality that even their own homeland Punjab has been turned into a land where sikhi is dead and going day by day.The asisans in Uganda did not hold any loyalties , they soon kicked out.Indians in malaysia,including Sikhs who did not stay loyal to their nation were kicked out.YET THE MALAYSIAN SIKHS ARE THRIVING AND ENJOYING LIFE AS PROPER MALYSIANS, because these people identified their loyalties to the nation.
being loon harami to the land and claiming we are loyal Sikhs does not go together-there is a conflict in their minds and their mentality.
I just called terrorists, but are you blind when there people saying loocha, arse licker , exact ..obviously you only see WHAT you WANT TO SEE...biased and blind.But the irony is these fellows have no other thiong to say.It does not matter where I got my doctorate from, I know I did not get it from the fathers and decendents of these mentally distablised so called sikhs.We know how they have got theirs?DONATIONS AND BRIBERY from their BHARAT MATA which they nbever tire to leave as soon is possible.
SAD people. and sad ...yes when I do get rewarded these are the popel I will first kick out of my country.
Re: British sikhs MUST be loyal to BRITAIN
freshi bandukz · 02 Aug 2005
the british themselves created this threat and never dealt with it.
The muslim community openly challanged muslim fanatics, when they knew they were up against military trained warriors from the east they knew it was out of their control and turned to the police and government to stop fanaticism growing.
What did the government do? It not only allowed fundamentalism to grow, it encouraged fanaticism by allowing more extermists to settle and let 3 fanatic groups get away with murder while banning bk and isyf.
Shere Panjab monthly in its 1996 edition warned sikhs not to encounter the growing fanatical elements in the midlands as far from the start of the problem which used to involve routine skirmishes between sikh and muslim gangs involving weopons and a few numbers suddenly started to take a new shape wqhich the sp recognised as military trained tactics which was out of their capacity to deal with . At this point the sp too had informed the relevant gov authorities they should recognise the threat and deal with it before it grows.
The warning again came from a top cop in the bradford riot, what they saw were not a riot, but organised to militrary scale tactics like strategtic movements , sequince of bottle bombings at police, then the line dissapears behind trees, and a fresh batch appears and hides and then more surprise turns in which the police were not trained to deal with.
The government stood still when sikhs were killed, battered , by fanatic gangs. Almost monthly or few we used to read of a sikh being battered or killed. Yet it took 50 random brits most white for the government to do something. This makes our blood boil, sikhs were cheap numbers when its white britons the pattern repeats do something about it.
The finsbury park mosque was taken kabzza by abu hamza during which barely 60 worshippers attended the mosque which accomodate usually 1800 people. Since abu group has been expelled there are now 800 worshippers already regular.
The big burning qwuestion why did the british governemtn let this grow knowingly for 15 years after 3 known warnings ? what is its real agenda?
This country has a lot of hidden aims ansd agendas itself. dont be fooled by its colourful face. One day they will wage a war there will be rivers of blood as their icon predicted. This evil does not carry on forever.
Re: British sikhs MUST be loyal to BRITAIN
sssssss · 03 Aug 2005
british sikhs must not be loyal to britain.
Britain has done jack tatti for sikhs in punjab after 1984. All sikh strongholds have been left in a sorry state with no growth financing by gov agencies. No grants for development youth projects. Instead they dump somalians and refujees into sikh areas and allow drug peddlers to keep our youth in a constant state of anarchy. Who controls the poppy fields in afghanistan/panama and columbia? brits and cia.
pablo escobar gone! someone somewhere is making the big bucks at the expense of our youth frieing their brains.
Sikhs should be loyal to Guru Granth Sahib the only brigade and beacon of hope, torch in kal yug.
Sikhs are not loon harami. Nationalism is haram for singhs, for sikhs are universal and bow only to the flag of Nishan sahib and Akaal Sahai republic of Khalistan. We pay our taxes to a nation that eats half of our earnings. Sikhs should strive for a pure khalistan. To first strive for unity and khalsa gearing masses.
Re: British sikhs MUST be loyal to BRITAIN
amar · 03 Aug 2005
i cant b bovad to read the hole of this thread it seems 2 boooooooooooorin, but i conclude that sikhs shud NOT be loyal to britain
Re: British sikhs MUST be loyal to BRITAIN
Gurcharan Singh Kulim · 03 Aug 2005
It is interesting when one reads this subject which has been hijecked by little self bred intellectuals,they do not want to be loyal to a country they live in.They misuse Sikh religion to misrepresent the Sikh version of loyalty to a place of residence, even thought that place encourages their growth and sustainanace.They express HATRED about Britian in this instance.On the other hand these same people claim hatred against Hindus.Then they say sikh religion is universal, but CONVENIENTLY they forget the Sikh religion also preaches love.
Hile they press for UNIVERSALISM which not an issue, they rub off the love part of Sikhism and preach hatred!!Then they claim they are SIKHS!!!self made sikhs!!!!!1
Funnily as much hatred they show Britain and the west, (which the muslims used to do not too long ago and now have become terrorists).these "sikhs" are NEVER TIRED OF USING WESTERN Groups to gain support for their hatred against hindus.....funny how these fools hate britain but seek the british support (then they forget what they claim the british did to them).... in punjabi such are loon haramis!!!
Instead of learning the britishtactiocs and strenghtening sikhs, they reject the bristish and have ZERO else to offer either!!Stupidity or mentally retarded, either way they are such losers no wonder all these while!!
Re: British sikhs MUST be loyal to BRITAIN
loyal to ONLY Guru Sahib · 03 Aug 2005
Gursikhs need ONLY to be loyal to WAHEGURU and NO ONE ELSE
Re: British sikhs MUST be loyal to BRITAIN
Pardeep Singh Bilga · 03 Aug 2005
what I wrote earlier, has been confirmed with the "Dr's" latest post above....
Can I just jump in here and ask a couple of questions re Dr. Kulim:
Is the Dr. really a patriotic Brit, or an Indian Govt agent, trying to make the Sikh youth firstly to forget their Panjabi roots (no offence to the non-Panjabi Sikh brothers and sisters, but lets face it, most of us do originate from that land) and then to think they are just typical goray, who have to "accept the law of the land" (as in the beard tying advice). Where does this end- tomorrow the main political parties may suggest that all minorities should FULLY integrate and take the appearance of typical Brits- do we then accept this and shave off our kes?
What are the Dr's views on 1984/Sant Bhindranwale/Sikh shaheeds? He rarely seems to comment on these kind of subjects- is he a Mahatma Gandhi type - non-violent- WHATEVER happens?
Re: British sikhs MUST be loyal to BRITAIN
sadi jind jaan sadda khalistan · 04 Aug 2005
go to southall handsworth or gravensed and you show me where the growth is? sikhs traditionbally filling labour job roles made jobless with increased service sector and lesser manufacture are struggling to find jobs, and having to settle for lower wage jobs often runnign two to make ends meet. Sikhs and others usually have to sustain themselves, this place rips us in taxes yt gives us back noweher near wha we put in. This is a joke, instead sikhs arnd in fact most coloured people exept for the token of esteem are out there struggling twice harder than white folk.
This country has not made us, we have made it from a bombed out dump.
kulim get it through ya head bro we dont care about britain or its loyalty.
This country is a white mans land. We just have british passports and a british birth certificate. We are not treated as british citizens or accepted as such by mainstream.
White people think they can trash over us out there. So why should i be loyal to it or its people? My loyalty will only come for khalistan my sikh homeland.
Now looking at this thread its obvious how britain and its mainstream treats non english peoples on its territory. People miss the point, today its islam yesterday it was communism tomorow it will be something else someone else who brings forward a social solution into society to remedy the race epedemic. Canadians and americans may find it harder to understand where we come from, equal rights are only on paper not socially in real life. Everywhere we go white people always judge us before or after terror attacks. Now they are creating even more problems by hating us, because non english non white people will start to understand they never have a place in british society. So goes the white man agenda again.
so kulim you understand why no non white person will hardly ever be loyal to this country that rips us apart from each other? most of us have grown up in national front era we are socially concious of our position in society. You can pretend to live in upper class cuckoo land.
Of course if this country, this life we experience gives us no equality no justice no real happiness in life and tries to fill us with negative experiences then we will question who and what we are, and end up trieing to find social solutions for sikhs we strive in sikhi muslims to islam. The growth of islam is phenominal because of native hate for colours. How else can one understand the huge growth of militant islam in the blacks and asians here yet absent in america and canada? america only till slavery was abolished before that even there nation of islam and black panthers were huge. This is a reaction to the white establishment and will never end, today its islam tomorow some other social revolution to right what is wrong.
hindus got jack to do wid it kulimz, stop using different agendas and stick to one. you asked us to be loyal to britain we ask you why should we? dont give us paper tiger claims that this country helps us, it doesnt do anything for us, yet amongst others drive its economy waking odd hours to do shifts whites dont want to do. So ask yourself where does your own loyalty lie in sikhi or false loyalty which has no justification. Sikhi helps us to grow in our confidence and recognise what is wrong, so that is what we do. So why should we be anyones chuhei chamchey chitter choongan waley??
if you treat me as inferior and someone asks me to be loyal to you why should i be? use logic bro.
kulimz your talking to younger people than yourself, you lost your own debate you started , logic defeated you and now you call them fools and other insults. apply sense bro and tell me why should i be loyal to britain?
Wat has britain done for me that i should be loyal to it tooth and nail? My loyalties are only to the khalsa. i am accountable only to God. I can in no way serve queen and honour british interests for they may conflict with sikh values. So my own conciousness has to judge where my own loyalties should go.
True khalistanis need no ones help except for Akal Purkhs maha kirpa. You are judging all khalistani singhs with the same brush, some might go and get british support but i can tell you most will not lose their izzat asking gorei when the gore already told us where to go.
how do british tactics strengthen sikhs? define british tactics? divide and rule?
sikhs have not only offered their lives to britain in world war after the next, but have contribiuted to this countries bread basket, industries, taxe revenues, with a number of other contributiions. Some may hae made it only due to their own hard work.
ok consider we are retarded stupid and mental all 3 in one. Now you are the one trieing to convert us into british chuhey chittar choongan waley chamchey after we weer never welcomed to this land and have struggled to keep our sikhi on the line, sikhs can almost never be welcomed into non white areas to live in, sikhs and other ethnics will have to proove themselves much harder than white counterparts in job roles and further have thrir own growth retarded in work politics with white prejudices aainst them stalling them from management positions, take a trip to southall its a dump, where is the government grants for jobs? training growth? . Apply your own common sense and tell us? dont come back with answers like what do you expect them to do? this is a white mans country for the white man. the banner of rebbelion is rising in coloured people demanding social equality.
Re: British sikhs MUST be loyal to BRITAIN
Soooorbeeerahhhhhhh · 04 Aug 2005
loon haramis are those who stand by on This khand with power in their hands and silently watch mass genocides, make the poor poorer and rich richer.
True rightful citizens are they who stand up for their voice, for others ever ready to help mankind, never bowing their honour.
May waheguru shower kirpa on you bhai gurcharn singh ji
Re: British sikhs MUST be loyal to BRITAIN
sIkhS AnAkh Is PriCeLeSs · 04 Aug 2005
Singh ask yourself how can you be loyal to a country where a 16 year old black schoolchild innocent devout christian is hacked to death with an axe by white males in todays world? someons skin makes them a target for a killing? this is a scene out of kkk deep south, no it happned last week in north england.
how can you be loyal to a country that allowed 5 white males caught on camera doing mock dummy stabbings on a black figure then actually murdreing a 17 year old black student barbarically? witness statements, physical evidence was no enough apparently to convict the 5 white males of the racist slaying. The problem hgere was the justice system, and senior inspectors allowed a loophole for racists to escape murders. 5 white men are free to kill again. This is the country you want me to be loyal to in which coloured men are murdered while government authorities look on in glee?
Gurcharan singhthink aboutthis. My interaction with english people is not good. It is filled with odd looks, dirty stares, remarks, sneers, jibes, thratening behaviour, non co operation, they try to make you feel like you do not exist.
They want you to feel low or fight back to incrase th cycle of hate. Is this nice? does this breed loyal behaviour into me?
This goes on from year to another, unlss you live in an ethnic ghettoe. So being ethnic you have no choice but to live and work in ghettoes unlss you rally sell your values. Yet chitta skin whether one be irish or european are welcome anywhere eventhough they have lived here after us.
now i go home, i have to find th strentgh in my own sanctity to forgive forget move on and understand this battle of life.
I find your original article insulting towards sikhs, it belittles what we have faced.
How do you think millions of others lik me will react? not everyone has the kirpa of understanding from sikhi perspective. basically whatever we disagree with on muslims islam, their religion is easily justified what their books say about devils shaitans, kaffrs, jinn possessions, can easily be reflectd back through instituinalised racism embedded nationwide. This is how hatred can find a space out of nowhere.
As far as i am aware sikhs are hard working people and tolerant peace lovers. But if they are as you decribed dole spongers, then let us compare their experiences to sikhs in canada? sikhs are welcome in one country notin another but greeted wiyth hatred which gets worse. If you are prevented from reaching your goals careerwise or socially because you are born with a yellow tan yet your white counterpart makes it with open arms then how can you blame the unemployd youth?
The labour government needs to get off its arse show loyalty to its subjects talking to sikhs helping them to grow confidently in todays job market.
If sikhs are speaking rough against britain then britain again needs to show its loyalty towards sikhs and ask us how things can be made better and why things are rough?
I try to be understanding but from what i see, there will be a cycle of his hate leading to violence that will never be put down. Some people have anakh othrs have extrme racial hatred. the two cannot co exist. Somethin will change or die doing so.
Re: British sikhs MUST be loyal to BRITAIN
Gurcharan Singh Kulim · 06 Aug 2005
But tell me where is this anakh when one carries the passport of UK, and lives here, then talks of nakh?Oh comeone , no socity is perfect, but at least in this society you can beherad and knock on the doors of the law and get justice.
In the land of the nakah India .1984 came and went twenty two years ago, the dropped anakh is nowhere.
if that empty anakh means so much then stay out of this land/
A Sikh with anakh will not be loon harami, there ar eno erfections in anll lands, but there some lands with near perfection and more than others and this is one such land.
this land offers opportunities, and if one does not want to be a labourer, then get on academically.but domt come with some grown certificates or back streets diplomas and expect to be given jobs with glory.
I came to this country to do O levels and today, I manage three hundered Gores without a whimper , and mY FULL SIKH SAROOP.That is anakh.Not fooki hollow anakh.and moans. Use brains stand with the land, and the land will reap you benefits, dont expect the land to do all that you feel is wrong and then say i will be good.Dont expect what they can do for you, do what you can and they will follow you,that is what a Sikh and Sikhi is all about.
It is very simple to sit here and MOAN and mOAN ,do something to show so that the land will beobliged to do it all for you.
i am sorry, I smell the rat of gurduara politiocan enclosed within their old walls and akali mentality of Shouting the loudest and getting the least!!
Re: British sikhs MUST be loyal to BRITAIN
vAlaItI vIPaR mURDabAd · 08 Aug 2005
gurcharan most sikhs rsponding here are probably third generation with british passports because they are born here. Singh use another argument we arent freshie boys.
Sikhs are heard? So what happened after 1984 through the 1990s holocaust by the indian gov which succeeded in killing more sikhs than the moghuls how were sikhs heard? they were instead branded terrorists and killers? The beazziti issue sikhs were again portrayed as savages muzzling a womans voice. The issue of Guru Granth Sahib ji and hotels was blown out "sikh gangs hijck wedding". The truth was manipulated twisted with utter lies being fed to the british public.
There are however many pseudo sikhs promoting their own crap which is usually anti gurmat. So how were sikhs heard? This is a lie.
be specific when you talk about justice, many will disagree with you from black asian and minority forums. Stephen lawrence, rohit duggal, ricky reel, the list is endless, no killers have been put behind bars. Yet a satpal ram is rewarded a life sentance for defending himself from being killed by 3 white burly men holding him down leaving him with a last resort to pull out his stanley. Manjit kaur babaysitter recieved no assistance from any british agency or gov yet miss louise woodward a white british female in a sim9ilar case enjoyed mdia publicity, funds and gov help wehen both faced manslaughter charges in america. Justice? balbir singh bains? justice?
Please tell us more about this justice?
india and britain both have a poor record of treating minorities which amnesty itself held britain accountable.
India means nothing to me, or most sikhs we are only born here as a result of our parents migrating . This is no big deal special status to be british. We are not white and do not enjoy the same treatment as our white counterparts.
Lol your doctorate amazes me, stay out of this land? this is the land our sikh babey fought died for, the same land where billions are stolen from brown skinned civilisation into white hands. The same land where our own parents slaved for to make the industries bigger and better transforming tyhem from a bombed out second world war dump. We deserve this equality you talk about, yet it is not there.
Sikhs do not believe in nations, sikhs are universal.
Nationalism is haram.
Who are you to tell singhs where to go?
This asmaan, the dharti belongs to God not to you, not to a white man, not to any government, The akali soorma walks anywhere he wants and speaks what resonates from his spirit. If you do not like that then doctor sahib the problem is yours.
Soorbeerah gave you a perfect defintiion of a loon harami. To call singhs loon haramis doctor sahib your putting posion into your own mouth. Sikhs bow only to Akaal never to a nationalist agendas.
Which near perfection? Ethnic ghettoes are perfection for you? wah doctor sahib. Perhaps you mean technological #advancement well who financed that? the sweat of brown/black labour and stolen wealth from other parts of the world.
singh jio I do not do labour, but i am proud of my parents humble roots. I work for an overseas merchant bank. I merely mentioned labour as a background to the history of manipulation of coloured people. When this was a bombed out war site, they cried for coloured people, when their economy was built, they call us asians, pakis, get out. Use your intelligence singh.
Lol trieing to convert sikhs to be bumlickers of britain a country that stood by while sikhs were killd in india you call yourself anakhi? singh do you even know what anakh means? th heads of singhs never lie low to anyone. You might have 300 gorei under your belt, obviously thats their mazboori, when your gone you wont leave any markl behind. You have your agenda to convert sikhs here, obviously you will say anything. Now you come and ask sikhs youth, or hold a survey and ask how the youth feel. The very reaction you generated tells us most youth will not back britain ask your british arse why?
Hundreds of thousands of sikhs not only servd britain, stoopd loyal, they risked their livs and many became martyured for it, what recognition did they get in british society? your just a paki to them now use your brain singh.
sikhs have been down the road defending others, they got nowhere. Your asking us to take the same road for another round of manipulation.
Who are you to tell me what sikhi is about when you gfo round telkling singhs to tie their beards up hiding their gursikh saroop?
you obvioysly do not understand when people moan its usually because there is a reason to moan and sikhs have every haq to moan against injustice anywhere.
You smell as many rats as you want, SIKHS WILL NEVER BE LOYAL TO BRITAIN, WE ARE UNIVERSAL SPIRITS BOWING ONLY TO FLAG WAHEGURU BESTWOED US WITH.
[%sig%]
Re: British sikhs MUST be loyal to BRITAIN
mirza knight · 08 Aug 2005
gurcharan singh you began with an essay hoping to persuade people. It did not work, all your arguments have been exhausted , please kindly offer us something new.
Sikhs should remain loyal to each other and to their sikh rehat. No World sarkar cares about minorities we have to look after ourselves.
Re: British sikhs MUST be loyal to BRITAIN
warrior prince · 09 Aug 2005
kiddah prince kulim
i think we need you to come become a pendu, give up your posh shoes stick some mojei or chappala on.
take th fishing net off your beard let your thara flow freely may your rom rom kes be free .
curl your moucha up high use badam rogan let the gorei smell it in the office
leave behind the veggie burgers and cheese salad sandwiches take in some aloo matter paneer to the office.
common shera bring back some proper punjabi vibes into your heart n soul.
serious gap shap now. Your argument is sikhs came here foreign land, they should do more to fit in and be more loyal.
The reality argument on the street is most sikhs actually cut their hair off to fit in, acted like brits, talked like them, gave up on traditional punjabi family values. Sikhs served the british empire well and truly hard. They and you would want us to do more to fit in and be loyal? just how much more loyalty could there be from any minority than that? sikhs have just about outdone everyone on loyalty to britain.
Re: British sikhs MUST be loyal to BRITAIN
waheguruji....... · 10 Aug 2005
waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh everyone. this is my first time posting a comment here but i have been reading and following what ever Dr.kulim have been saying. as we al can remember, the previous comment that he posted abt the vasakhi open hse organised by SNSM and the dataran prog organised by the Niketans, he was not a doctor yet. i am suprised that he got his dr title in a matter of few months. why didn't you use the title then? and to be very frank, you sound like an educated man ( theoritically) and you claim to have so much of knowledge and able to speak 11 languages,but how come i cant see your involvement in your local gurdwara? how come the granthis came and left? why can't any granthi stay longer than 6 months? i think we should look at our own back yard before looking into ppl's affairs. your own local gurdwara politics is never ending and your are talking until britain. c'mon man,grow up. i am starting to have doubts that you are from kulim as your claim to be.if you are an amritdhari and you do your nitnem daily without fail and you have faith in Guruji then you should know that there is no other supreme leader in this world besides Guru Granth Sahib Ji and we should only bow to Him not to any union jack flag or etc. "Sab sikhan ko hukam heh guru manio granth". if you are a real true guru da sikh you will sure remember about the 84 attack,sant jernail singh bhindrawale's sacrifice,the saheeds but instead your are supporting the british on what they did. if you like britain that much,why dont you just leave malaysia and leave in britain then you can call yourself british sikh. i am really suprised what kind of doc are you? why you never answered any questions posted by my brothers when they ask you what kind of doc are you? why each time they ask you a question you just brush the matter away? i really think that you are hiding from something and your are really insecure. why you have to hide your identity if you are proud of yourself? well...maybe you will also classify me the same category as charanjeev rite,but i dont mind because you are the only person educated here unlike the rest of us. waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh.
Re: British sikhs MUST be loyal to BRITAIN
babbar sher singha di quam · 10 Aug 2005
kulim sahib what you forget is people are not just sikhs. We have punjab bloodlines that simply take no crap, a very rich culture warrior pepple in most part of history. It is not in the nature of any punjabi singh at least to be loyal to anyone other than God Himself.
It will be hard for people like you to understand the rich medieval heritage sikhs have been blessed with which saw our forefathers long before sikhi fighting and dieing on battlefields against islam when ghauri came. Sikhi has strengthened the identity and boldened what is today sikhs and punjabis.
The day is destined where sikhs will rule.
Think about this khalsa bhagi ya badshah.
many times immortal shaheeds have echoed how The sikh nation is infused into The Guru Granth Sahib. We are a nation without borders that will eventually take control. One day Waheguru willingbritain itself will bow to khalsa raj.
Re: British sikhs MUST be loyal to BRITAIN
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 10 Aug 2005
Just a clarification for waheguru ji....above..
1. a Person enters Kindergarten at age five.... Can He start writing himslef as Form Six pass from DAY ONE..or will he only write himself as passed Form Six on the DAY he gets his HSC/STPM/A Levels Certificate from Cambridge University...12 YEARS Later
2. A "Medical Student enters MBBS School BUT CANNOT write himself as DOCTOR from DAY ONE !!! Only an UTTER FOOL will do that and it is ILLEGAL as well. BUT SIX YEARS later when the University passes him..and gives him the Certiificate..he can Write Doctor MBBS after his name.
Now can we Turn around adn tell the Kindergarten fellow..HEY man..all thsi while for 12 YEARS...you NEVER told us you ahd passed Form Six/A levels...Now suddenly in a matter of DAYS...you tell us you are a Form Six Graduate ?? How come Man ??
Then we turn to the Newly graduated Doctor...HEY Man for the past six OR SEVEN years...YOU WERE not A doctor....AND now JUST IN A WEEK YOU OPENED UP A clinic AND CALL YOURSELF DOCTOR M.B.B.S.?? ARE yOU joking mAN ??
Simple isnt it.... ??? NOBODY can be a DOCTOR" from DAY ONE in KINDERGARTEN.... it takes time and years of study.... BUT once we have got a certificate... we CAN be a "ordinary joe" on MONDAY..and a DOCTOR on TUESDAY !@!! 24 HOURS ..man ???
I think DR. KULIM is a PHD ( He is NOT going to INJECT YOU !!!)....now i hope you dont go off on this "PHD thing" what is it ?? and all that ?? how can one day NO PHD and the Next day got PHD etc etc // blah blah blah.. SAME explanation as in 1 and 2 above ...I have tried to make as simple as i can.
Re: British sikhs MUST be loyal to BRITAIN
mr singh · 11 Aug 2005
Khalistan is inevitable vitally required to secure sikh interests. It is here loyalty will pay off when they are safe in their own land.
We could be kicked out of here anytime. Kulim if you have a few spare bob build yourself a mansion in punjab now, if the bnp come to power at least you will havea place to go to.
Who knows when our time will come.
It does not befit your proffesional stature to make unjust accusations, infact you yourself need to further justify why you feel sikhs must be loyal to britain?
To vilify muslims as suicide bombers you yourself are stirring hatred.
Britain steals th wealth of the poor, so who is the biggest sponger of the earth?
Re: British sikhs MUST be loyal to BRITAIN
Ravinder Singh · 12 Aug 2005
Jarnail Singh Gyani Arshi..
You've written a lot to explain how Dr.Kulim may have a PHD, but you haven't contributed to the subject at all.
Do you agree with what your friend Dr. Kulim is saying?
Re: British sikhs MUST be loyal to BRITAIN
... · 12 Aug 2005
look its as simple as this, the british hang me if you want mnore correctly white native british are heavily racist in nature. The bombings have increased racism so much that now we are recieving the backlash to an extent where we first ask ourselves
how can any sane human being start hating you for the colour of your skin because 3 asian skinned bombers and one jamaican went on a killing spree in the name of jihad?
Most white people i see now hate the sight of asian skinned people no longer bother to hide it. Why are we trieing to find excuses for their own failure to see beyond the race issue? ira bombings were much more deadlier but the huge irish population in england never got it this bad because they stand up fight back so do blacks and pakistanis. So why are we constantly filled with scholars licking british boots trying to lead us?
If someone wants to kick your head in for being tanned putg your degrees, phds, masters, posh doctorates careers big houses flashy cars aside and tellme what you will do? this affects your family and you.
There is no amount of appeasing british white people, the majorioty of sikhs who act british will realise now what they sold out to.
Nobody supports bombings or killings here but if they hate you for who you are and try to make you feel it then we can see why radical islam has taken root in britain but not in america, canada, europe, australia, india, africa.
They want race wars to kick off and slowly start get rid of us. We are going toi be treated the way blacks were in the 1980s. The very strange thing is blacks reciprocate with sympathy for the backlash we suffer yet the gore want this race problem to get worse.
If you are prevented from living with self respect, decency and prevented from being religious then what surprise is it that men will be ready to blow themselves up in the name of warped cause. Those 4 men could have become dedicated brits through employment, joining the forces but they did not.
So letr us ask ourselves why do young men become drawn to extremism?
How do you deal with racism? what else will it breed if not counter hate?
The media have jumped at every chance to screw up asians good name in society, now they are responsible for what the majority of british people are reading when the british public start to attack and target asians.
Why are we as sikhs who duly recognise with bibek so tame on the problems we face, and others around us face?
gurcharan i know you will ask why moan go somewhere else? find me a home where i will be accepted i will gladly leave this dump called britain anyday. the home will be khalistan and when it comes khalistan will take over britain for all its lies, dishonours, subjogating territory and resources britain will be nothing before mighty khalsa raj all will come under the canopy of khalsa the righteous owner.
Re: British sikhs MUST be loyal to BRITAIN
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 12 Aug 2005
Author: Ravinder Singh
Date: 08-12-05 02:20
Jarnail Singh Gyani Arshi..
You've written a lot to explain how Dr.Kulim may have a PHD, but you haven't contributed to the subject at all.
Do you agree with what your friend Dr. Kulim is saying?
___________________________________________________
1. I have a right to write or dont write . Freedom of Speech.
In this case i saw your friend waheguruji..making a lot of WRONG ASSUMPTIONS...and corrected these... i still left the one about "kulim" not being from KULIM...because that one is too ****** even for me to comment. Sometime ago these same type of Comments were made about me..do I "really exist"..am i a Genuine malaysian or "illegal Indian desi hiding from the immigration..blah blah blah....have i been deported ?/ etc..not worth commenting about mostly.
2. Regarding your assumption that "kulim" is "MY FRIEND?? What evidence do you have ?? Does anyone whose "IDEAS".... i "support" in my mails become "MY FRIEND"..and anyone whose "IDEAS".. i "OPPOSE" become MY ENEMY?? this is a very simplistic thinking..we are bound to have differences of OPINIONS...just because I support YOU on the Parkashwaan Dharra principle..doesnt necessarily make me YOUR FRIEND ??..and in the same way i am "waheguruji's enemy " ?? I hope NOT.
________________________________________________
ref" your Beard post. I NEVER had to tie my beard... I worked 25 years in Singapore Govt Service as a Teacher and no one ever asked me or commented on my appearance.Maybe I was lucky or GURU JI had His KIRPA on me..I dotn know...BUT I FULLY SUPPORT YOUR STAND on this. A SINGH with his dharra TIED UP...is only Half a Singh. ( anybody can make any excuse/bahanna whatever..this is MY OPINION.) GOOD fro YOU that you have won this battle to have PARKASHWAAN DHARRA. MY CONGRATS.
On the FLAG question... ALL Sikh gurdawras in MALAYSIA/SINGAPORE FLY their NATIONAL FLAGS on a different lower Flagpole..and the Nishan Sahib Flies on a HIGHER pole. I have no reason to go against this..as malaysia is my HOME and I am NO AKIRTGHAN...I accord the Honour the malaysian Flag deserves from a CITIZEN...and I accord the HONOUR the NISHAN SAHIB deserves from a SIKH..there is NO CONFLICT.
IF "waheguru Ji or any other "Malaysian" ??? disagrees. then he should be brave enough to come out with his real name and address..and garner SUPPORT to REMOVE the Malaysian Flag from any GURDWARAS in malaysia. I support the Govt of MY Country heart and soul. I dont beleive that makes me any LESS SINGH.
That should answer your doubts if any.
Re: British sikhs MUST be loyal to BRITAIN
Ravinder Singh · 12 Aug 2005
>Regarding your assumption that "kulim" is "MY FRIEND?? What evidence do you have ?? Does anyone whose "IDEAS".... i "support" in my mails become "MY FRIEND"..and anyone whose "IDEAS".. i "OPPOSE" become MY ENEMY?? this is a very simplistic thinking..we are bound to have differences of OPINIONS...just because I support YOU on the Parkashwaan Dharra principle..doesnt necessarily make me YOUR FRIEND ??..and in the same way i am "waheguruji's enemy " ?? I hope NOT.<<
I referred to Dr. Kulim as your friend, not out of assumptions that you may support his views, but because I simply thought that you had referred to him in a previous post as being a friend of yours. I don't remember (or care to remember) exactly which post. If i am wrong on this then I apologise.
>I support the Govt of MY Country heart and soul. I dont beleive that makes me any LESS SINGH.<
Good for you. I don't know anything about the Malaysian Govt and it is not MY Country, so I have no view on this.
Similarily, if you feel that way towards Britain, then thats fine.
Re: British sikhs MUST be loyal to BRITAIN
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 12 Aug 2005
Ravinder Singh Ji..Correct on both counts. Keep Your Dharra parkashwaan and be a MODEL Singh as well as Model British Citizen..whatever it takes.
Charrdeekalla always..forever.