Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

bhangra and sikhi

bhangra and sikhi

bhaji · 15 Jul 2005

waheguru ji ka khalsa, waheguru ji ki fateh i know that listening to lustful music is against sikhi, but i recently saw a few videos of 3HO sikhs doing bhangra and to be honest they looked abit silly dancing around in a bana. i was wondering if to do bhangra is right. i know that it can considered bad as you may be dancing to lustful tunes. but these 3HO sikhs consider bhangra to be an exercise, similar to gatka. please could you give me some feedback on this? waheguru ji ka khalsa, waheguru ji ki fateh bhul chuk maaf [%sig%]

Re: bhangra and sikhi

ssingh · 15 Jul 2005

can you imagine Guru Gobind Singh ji, and the panj piaray dancing to bhangra, and having their daughters participate too? Why do you think the day of vaisakhi, the central day that "jatts"/"punjabi's" celebrate this (purported central aspects of their) "culture", was selected to form the khalsa, thereby forcing people to miss/neglect and dissociate from this "culture"?

Re: bhangra and sikhi

ekta · 15 Jul 2005

no bhangra is a sin, a cardinal sin. sarcasim. the reason 2days youth say its a sin, is cause its a major part of the "non sikh, sikh familly wallaye" life. But how is it wrong? i fail 2 understand, youth say its wrong 2day because they want to be as hardcore as they can, want to act as desensitised to culture, and non-sikhi life as much, when infact they're full of garbage.

Re: bhangra and sikhi

ASengh · 16 Jul 2005

Yeh I have also seen pictures of white Sikhs doing bhangra, it looks pretty stupid, the white sikhs need to sort them selves out. I also seen one of the white Singhs wearing socks whilst doing Gurdev - Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji's seva, this is a beadibi. [gurbani]nic nic hsih clih sy roie ] [%sig%]

Re: bhangra and sikhi

taran · 16 Jul 2005

[gurbani]nic nic hsih clih sy roie ][/gurbani] asengh's been doin loads of asa di vaars as usual ;-) his rite in wat he sed in his previous post

Re: bhangra and sikhi

kkaur123 · 16 Jul 2005

ekta ji nothing wrong with trying to be a better sikh....or is there??? the word hardcore is just opinion. u can dance if u want...but what are you dancing to??? in my experience bhangra is full of dirty lyrics in the songs....or have they started singing clean songs???? most of these songs are very damaging to our people. lyrics that say we should have 'home-made alcohol' in Panjab with a bit of roti can only send our youth in the wrong direction....lyrics that encourage caste can only be detremental to our unity.......songs which depict our girls in mini-skirts can only encourage our young sisters to try and look like them.....songs which show 1 girl and 20 men around her are hardly sending out the right message.....or am i being tooo hardcore???

Re: bhangra and sikhi

h singh · 17 Jul 2005

pen ji you are spot on. we are influenced by all around us, and young people are easily led, they look for role models and find them in these bhangra singers/dancers/djs etc etc. i heard a song on radio today where the singer was commenting on a woman and how her backside looks good when it moves left to right. i would say this is GARBAGE.

Re: bhangra and sikhi

Sumanjeet Kaur · 17 Jul 2005

Ekta bhenji/veerji, Please DON'T say that today's youth that is trying be "hardcore" in sikhi is "GARBAGE." How can you say that to the youth that is trying their best to live up to the principles of sikhi? How in the world is it ok for sikhs to be doing bhangra, and in baana?? Goodness sakes, what more beadbi can you do of Guru Sahib's given baana? Did we run out of appropriate forms of exercises (gym,sports,gatka), that we go on to adopt this punjabi culture "bhangra"????

Re: bhangra and sikhi

Not too religious · 24 Dec 2005

These have to be some of the most idiotic comments I've ever read. Instead of you people acknowlegding and being proud of the fact that a person of a non-indian background is actually embracing your religion, you are all lashing out on them. And considering what times are like for sikhs post 9-11 you dont see them going and cutting their hair and hiding. For the little "bhangra" they did to celebrate their union, you should forgive them for that. For "God's Sake" it is a joyous occasion NOT someone's funeral. I was born in a sikh household, but unlike a lot of you on this messageboard I'm not a turbaned sikh, and yes I do drink and yes I do dance to bhangra. I'm pretty sure right now you are all saying "it figures". Now my comments hold no wieght. To say that you have never seen a sikh man/woman kiss, that is just absurd. may God help you all.

Re: bhangra and sikhi

gareeb_SIKH · 24 Dec 2005

It just shows what Mr.Harbhan Singh Yogi was.I am not trying to do NINDaa.The reality is that many people who achieve bit of peace in their mind(but are still far from reaching God)act as Saints. This life is tough,slogging everyday for money,family problems,other problems etc. So by becoming Saints,they make their life easy.Plus they also do some good by trying to promote sikhi.Thats what has happened with 3HO people. Sikhs of Sant Ranjit Singh Dadrian wale should be of the same category. Seeing all this, I SALUTE SANT JARNAIL SINGH BHINDRAWALE. He was A JEWEL. KHALISTAN ZINDABAD

Re: bhangra and sikhi

6 pac singh · 24 Dec 2005

bhangra is good 4 my abs.... believe me....

Re: bhangra and sikhi

. · 25 Dec 2005

dance is an excellent way to be happy, one of the best ways to honour your creator, better than being depressed and pretending to be religious

Re: bhangra and sikhi

fly fast · 25 Dec 2005

"one of the best ways to honour your creator, " How is dancing one of the best ways to honour your creater? that dobnt nmake sense. as for punjabi sikhs putting down 3ho sikhs, yes that happens , i think its dpwn to jealousy, ive seen more hardcore gurbani educated "goray" sikhs then ive seen punjabi "indo persian" sikhs (shows how bad the punjabi problem is. the jealousy is down to ego and pride and im sure all who indulge init will be punishd by akal purakh. i urge all non punjabi nationalities who are taking intrest in the supreme religion sikhi, to not be offended by some biggoted remarks by some punjabi So called sikhs as at heart most ovem arnt even gurmukhs, but manmukhs who take the image of khalsa (we got akot of them in the panth unfortunatly) thank you.

Re: bhangra and sikhi

Jaspal Kaur · 25 Dec 2005

vaheguru ji ka khalsa vaheguru ji ki fatehji . veerji/penji, it's your way of finding happiness through dancing and honouring your creator. Will you pls tell me who that specific creator is? The true creator shabad Guru does not mention even once that human beings will find bliss or celestial peace through dancing or so on. From the first ang of Guru Granth Sahib ji to the last, the only most hukam you will find is that by reading gurbani doing keertan and doing seva one will find 'happiness'. I have heard various people make the comment that sikhi kind of seems depressing beacuse some people tend to look sad or depressed. Veerji/penji only a person who has guru jis kirpa on them and is blessed to read gurbani, listen to kirtan or do seva will only know what they are feeling. Although, many like you said, may 'pretend' to be religious, but if that was the case with all then may be sikhi would have had a different form altogether by now. Can you deny that all the gursikhs who have been shaheed in the past like Bhai Sahib bhai Fauja singh ji, bhai Anokh singh ji, bhai sukhdev singh ji and the list can go on, were all pretendents towards their sikhi. They were happy and in bairag, but tell me, if they were happy was it because of dancing or something else or If they were in bairag was it because they were depressed or something else? vaheguru ji ka khalsa vaheguru ji ki fateh ji

Re: bhangra and sikhi

Makhan Ram · 27 Dec 2005

It is funny how people try to defend there passions. Slowly sikhi is being watered down. Look in our history bhangra and sikhi don't mix. Why is it that Sant Jarnail Singh condemed bhangra saying it was not in our culture, but in the culture of Musalman. No where in our history is bhangra. Keertan was created to stir people's heads away from songs to the true path. Little by little we keep watering down our religion just because of worldly needs.

Re: bhangra and sikhi

Be practical · 27 Dec 2005

There is nothing wrong wiith dancing. If one is going to be lustful they may be so even while sitting in the temple and pretending to act holy. For alot of people its just fun and great exercise. Yes the lyrics of some songs arent on par with gurmat but its not to say all songs are bad. dont be OTT!

Re: bhangra and sikhi

d · 28 Dec 2005

u dnt need to dance too keep fit.its just nt necessary. gatka is better than dancing.i mean what would u prefer?- being able to defend urself orrr..hmm...what use does dancing ACTUALLY have? :-) "There is nothing wrong wiith dancing. If one is going to be lustful they may be so even while sitting in the temple and pretending to act holy." i agree but most people dnt jus dance at home on their own..usualy in clubs, which is where the kaam comes into it

Re: bhangra and sikhi

Have u noticed... · 28 Dec 2005

typical... most ppl in support of dancing aren't even responding to arguements from ppl against. Why don't you actually READ and TAKE IN whats being said! Comments like "dont be OTT" or "hardcore" is plain pathetic and shows your lack of discussion skills. SO! ppl in favour of dancing go back up and READ the other side...

Re: bhangra and sikhi

Vastoo · 28 Dec 2005

Its not an issue of whether dancing/music etc is right or wrong. What we should ask ourselves is whether this behaviour increases or decreases our focus on Naam. Therein lies the answer. [%sig%]

Re: bhangra and sikhi

Harcharan Singh · 28 Dec 2005

Waheguru ji Khalsa Waheguru ji ki Fateh, To get back to the original topic, Bhangra has absolutely nothing to do with Sikhi, full stop. If people choose to dance to bhangra and racist, caste promoting, lustful, ego-pride boosting, sexist lyrics, that is your choice. If you want to allow your daughters/sisters to dress scantily and to dance in front of unfamiliar drunk men at parties and weddings, your choice. As for non-gurmat music Guru nanak Dev Ji says: ਗੁਰਮੁਖਿ ਰਾਗ ਸੁਆਦ ਅਨ ਤਿਆਗੇ ॥ गुरमुखि राग सुआद अन तिआगे ॥ gurmukh raag su-aad an ti-aagay. The Gurmukh renounces other songs and tastes. ਗੁਰਮੁਖਿ ਇਹੁ ਮਨੁ ਭਗਤੀ ਜਾਗੇ ॥ गुरमुखि इहु मनु भगती जागे ॥ gurmukh ih man bhagtee jaagay. The mind of the Gurmukh is awakened to devotion. ਅਨਹਦ ਸੁਣਿ ਮਾਨਿਆ ਸਬਦੁ ਵੀਚਾਰੀ ॥ अनहद सुणि मानिआ सबदु वीचारी ॥ anhad sun maani-aa sabad veechaaree. Hearing the unstruck music of the sound current, this mind contemplates the Shabad, and accepts it. Everyone is entitled to do what they like, it is not for us to pass judgement on them, but it is for us to defend Sikhi when people try and justify their own manmat lifestyle by saying Sikhi allows it. Satnaam Harcharan Singh

Re: bhangra and sikhi

amarjeet singh · 28 Dec 2005

the way to honour your creator is through naam and gurbani

Re: bhangra and sikhi

K · 29 Dec 2005

Well said last 5 posters!!!

Re: bhangra and sikhi

. · 30 Dec 2005

what is naam