Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Discussion on Udasis

Discussion on Udasis

A Singh · 15 Jul 2005

Udasis We have heard much of the 4 sampradhas in recent years from the revivalist neo-nihang sanatan sikhi movement in the UK. This thread is not intending to discuss Nihangs, Niddar Singh or the Buddha Dal, but take a look at Udasis. There appears to be two sides to this argument that Udasis are Sikhs –one being the pseudo-historical stance made by historians based on information surrounding practices in vogue during the 19th century (surely it would be sensible to look as far back as possible to authenticate valid from presumed practices?) and the other being the stance taken by the SGPC in the past decade declaring Udasis as Sikhs. The second is perhaps not too difficult to reconcile, as the fall of the Singh Sabha movement into mere agricultural-class inspired politics is well known over the past 60 or so years. With this, has come the hunger for land wealth as is the case with most rural inspired politic, so naturally declaration of Udasis as Sikhs is simply a means to capture their properties under the continued control of the Mahants. Looking at the historical / pseudo-scholastic arguments, it appears that in the pro-Udasi case (i.e. Baba Sri Chand was forgiven and subsequently respected by all the Gurus and conferred blessings onto Baba Gurditta, s/o of Guru Hargobind Sahib etc etc) conveniently misses many simple conflicting points: 1. How and when did this conference of Guruship (Udasi) from Baba Sri Chand to Baba Gurditta occur? Why speculate, well, have a look at Mahan Kosh and other textual references, old and new and one will find that Baba Sri Chand’s date of passing away (that too at a very old age) actually occurs almost a decade before Baba Gurditta is believed to have been born!!! 2. Why, if Bhai Gurdas Ji’s varan extend far enough to include the history of Guru Har Gobind Sahib, does he not make mention of this conference of Guruship from Baba Sri Chand to Baba Gurditta –surely this is a key historic event in the house of the Guru?. Also, the much famed episode by pro-Udasi supporters that Baba Sri Chand helped Guru Arjan Dev Ji with the composition of the Sukhmani Sahib (re: the “Aad Sach Jugad Sach..” salok) is missing! Instead what we do find is references from Bhai Gurdas Ji that Baba Sri Chand and his brother were disobedient from the teachings of Guru Nanak –surely, if one is to be considered Sikh, then at the very least the teachings of Guru Nanak are the basic foundations before we get started on the Khalsa insignia even (which of course we know Udasis do not follow). Finally, if Udasis are actually a sampradha blessed by Guru Gobind Singh, as suggested by the neo-Nihangs and neo-sikh scholars then why do we not find any references to this event in any of the puratan texts? To the contrary what we can find are clear references in the puratan Rehitnamas that the Khalsa is not to have sangat with Udasis. I have asked various pro-udasi supporters on these points, however the response I tend to get is no different to that which one gets when asking challenging questions to the anti-Nihang elements, which frequently just results in name calling (usually “Nang this and Nang that”) likewise, with the Neo-Nihangs and Sanatan Sikhs, one tends to get termed a SGPC supporter or a Neo-Sikh/ “Modern day British influenced Sikh blah blah” –funnily, no one, despite the claims to being scholars with lineage of this and that can actually answer these basic questions! If its not insults then one receives throw away comments that the puratan texts are written by “Bahmans” and they didn’t like the Khatri and Jat Udasis (funny that when the AKJ or Taksal make issue of Brahmin influence in the same text concerning matters such as Devi-puja etc, this is rejected by the Sanatanists!), the other response is that the dates are wrong because Singh Sabha scholars were mistaken, yet no re-assessment of the dates are provided to provide a tangible disqualification, in short, within the terms of the Tark-Shastar (Logic), none of these responses are acceptable albeit they may come from “scholars”, so the questions still stand as above – what really qualifies Udasis as Sikhs? A Singh

Re: Discussion on Udasis

Kublir Singh · 15 Jul 2005

Excellent points. I think we should have a constructive debate on this Samprada. Kulbir Singh

Re: Discussion on Udasis

A Singh · 15 Jul 2005

Thank you Veer Kulbir Singh, I do hope that the Sangat will ensure to observe your wise words for this to be a "constructive debate" and not have this dilute into name-calling and accusations.

Re: Discussion on Udasis

**- · 15 Jul 2005

A Singh On initial inspection I think it is pretty obvious that Udasis cannot be termed as being Sikhs. From what I have read, Baba Sri Chand Ji was rejected by his father - Guru Nanak - and so he started is own path. I have been to Udasi ashrams in India and they still very much revere the Guru Sahibaan but at the same time they also pray to Hindu demigods etc. According to the Sanatan Sikhi websites, they have been the most effective medium in spreading the message of Gurbani to the Hindu masses. However I think their siddhanta (conclusion) on the philosophy of Gurmat weans very strongly towards Hinduism rather than that of the SGPC, AKJ and the DDT. This is the reason that they have been successful in disseminating the message of Sikhi to the Hindu world. They also regularly attend almost all Hindu gatherings as well. [%sig%]

Re: Discussion on Udasis

ksingh · 15 Jul 2005

waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh baba srichand was rejected by guru nanak for guruship but all the expenses of the udasis were bore by gurughar.once baba srichand went to the guru ramdas for taking the expenses.after seeing guru ramdas he asked smilingly so long beard. guru ramdas replied this long beard is to clean the feet of sants like you and then guru jee started cleaning the feet of baba srichand with his beard.so there was a lot of respect for udasis by the sikh gurus. bhul chuk maaf [%sig%]

Re: Discussion on Udasis

Singh · 15 Jul 2005

ksingh, respect yes, but were they a Guru-ordaned Samprada as the Sanatanists claim? The conclusion I came to is that no group other than Khalsa Panth was set up and the Rehat given was very simple, orally transmitted and based mostly on what the Panj told the seeker individually at the Amrit Sanchar. The general structure of the Khalsa Panth was very flexible and free to allow for whatever the circumstances. With the set up later of the Buddha Dal/Tarna Dal (along with Misls prior to this), other groups, I believe this was an attempt by Sikhs to bring more structure to the Panth. There is nothing wrong with this; but Sikhs should be pragmatic and rather than clinging on to past structures (where is the Misl system now?) they should be constantly dissolving and creating organisations and structures appropriate for the time. An example now is that the SGPC really just needs to be totally reformed from the ground up. Once such groups attempt to trace lineages back to Guru Sahib to give more credibility, more problems arise as people believe that these groups are mutually exclusive (DDT etc). Just my 2 cents.