Re: Bhai Gurdas ji's Vaars
JSGyani "Arshi" · 12 Jul 2005
I dont understand the "Question" ? Why are we assuming that the Vaars were "completed" before being bestowed the title Gurbani dee kunji ?? Bhai Gurdass Ji was perfectly able/willing/and allowed to write as much bani as he wanted to..as long as he could... Why are we assuming that he was "stopped" by guru Ji at any time ???
Even the Aad Granth Ji was NOT COMPLETED in guru Arjun Sahib Jis' time...Guru Gobind Singh ji completed the Bir later on by adding Guru Teg bahadur Jis Gurbani.
imho all this is idle speculation. the only thing conslcuive is that Bhai gurdass Ji's vaars cOULD be ADULTERATED by others...these writings were NOT PROTECTED like the AAD Granth Ji.
Re: Bhai Gurdas ji's Vaars
JSGyani "Arshi" · 12 Jul 2005
I would find that very logical....as Guru Arjun Ji sahib had been martyred...and GURU HARGOBIND SAHIB JI had been bestowed Gurgadhi but the Mughal Goovt impriosned Him in Gwalior....and it was left to the Stalwart SIKHS like Bhai Buddha Ji, Bhai Gurdass Ji and a few others to keep the Spirits of the Sikhs up.
One way of doing that would be to write a new shabad about the GURUSHIP/GURTA of GURU HARGOBIND SAHIB JEE...and put it at the Beginning !!!
I see no reason for Bhai gurdass Ji to suddenly stop writing just because Guur Arjun Ji sahib had been martyred although that was a monumental event in Sikh history. Some people "blame" Bhai gurdass Ji for not wriitng a vaar about the martyrdom....and suggest he was "frightened"..this is also speculation. Bhai Gurdass Ji and the other Sikhs (Modhee sikhs) held the Sikh Sangat together in the absence of Guru hargobid Sahib jee and worked for Guru Ji's release..by organising Jathas of Sikhs to go visit Gwalior Fort..and also running Guur Ji s Household in Amritsar...Prithiya and gang must have been very disappointed....after all he had been given ALL of Guur Jis Property and etc etc BUt he didnt get his wish to be "guru"...
Re: Bhai Gurdas ji's Vaars
JSGyani "Arshi" · 13 Jul 2005
Dear Singh Jio,
Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji ki fateh.
Yes veer the 41st vaar is accepted by many scholars to be a clever attempt at addition...there are ample proofs that this vaar couldnt have been written bY Bhai gurdass Ji who wrote the first 40 vaars. This vaar si now accepted to be written bya Bhai gurdass "SINGH" or Bhai gurdass the Second..and that he is actually a Brahmin pandit going under an assumed name. Some of this information is available on the Lekh section of this Forum.( lekh on Raagmaala).
Bhai gurdass Ji was elder to Guur Arjun ji Sahib and a well established writer...who wrote his poetry all along. Then Guru Arjun Ji Sahib appointed him official SCRIBE to write down GURBANI as Guur Ji dictated to him.
A sakhi relates that Bhai Sahib had great "ideas" about his own poetry ( which writer worth his salt is not "proud" of his own creations and creativity !!)..well according to thsi story, Bhai Gurdass Ji went o have his Ishnaan at the 84 lakh Jaap wallee Baoli Sahib at Goindwaall..and as he did ishnaan..instead of reciting Japji Sahib..he began to recite HIS OWN VAARS...and Lo and behold..He began to SINK like a stone...Bhai Sahib PANICKED and imm ediately he began to recite JAPJI SAHIB....and he began to FLOAT once more. Thus when He came back to SCRIBING Gurbani from Guru Arjun ji Sahib, Janni jaan Guru Ji asked him....Bhai Sahib Jee Tuhaadee bani vee granth ji wich chhrrraaa diyeaah ?? And Bhai Sahib replied..No GURU JI..my bani is NOT gurbani standard. Thus GURU JI was pleased and bestowed the title of GUrbani dee kunji on Bhai Sahib's writings...saying that if anyoe wants to really understand GURBANI..he must forst of all read and understand Bhai gurdass Ji's writings.
Re: Bhai Gurdas ji's Vaars
kar kirpaa sabh rayN thheevaa · 14 Jul 2005
[gurbani]vwhigurU jI kw Kwlsw ]
vwihgurU jI kI Pqih ] [/gurbani]
i have to agree with lionking
i have no faith in that sakhi and could not imagine bhai gurdas ji imagining such a thing and having any haumai
read his vaars
read "mayree khalo(n) maujaRay"
there is more nimarta in bhai sahib than i could have in 10 lifetimes
[gurbani]vwhigurU jI kw Kwlsw ]
vwihgurU jI kI Pqih ] [/gurbani]
Re: Bhai Gurdas ji's Vaars
JSGyani "Arshi" · 14 Jul 2005
Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji ki fateh.
Dear Lionking and others..MY Humblest apologies.. I should have stated that I personally DONT BELIEVE in this and SIMILAR "SAKHIS". It was given as an illustration...I heard it on a katha on Raagmaala posted ona well known Pro-Raagmaala website..supposedly promoting GURMAT-VICHAAR ???? Inadvertantly I left out this Disclaimer at the end of the sakhi.
1. Why i dotn beleive in this sakhi...obviously..as Veer Kirpa has said..Bhai gurdass Ji is one of the greatest SIKHS of GURU JI...and thats why GURU JI gave him the Supreme Honour of Scribing Holy Gurbani...and AAd Granth ji Sahib is entirely written in Bhai Ji's Hand.
2. Reading through Bhai Sahib Jis writings conveys his great humility.... a man so close to Guru Amardass Ji, Guru Ram Dass Ji and Guru Arjun Ji..CANNOT have any haumaii...because all these three GURU SAHIBAANS were the very Epitom,e of HUMILITY/SEWA themselves. After having wittnessed the horrifying martyrdom of Guru Arjun Ji at such a yong age..and Guru hargobind Ji just a vhild who was subsequently impriosned by jehangir, while the Entire HOUSEHOLD..Maal Asbaab..meaning ENTIRE PROPERTY of Guru Ji was CONFISCATED and handed over to Prithiya, by the Govt...it was left to Bhai gurdass Ji, Bhai Buddha Ji and a few other staunch Sikhs to HOLD GURU JI's SIKHS together and in High Hopes. All this management and sewa can only be doen by a BHAI GURDASS JI type of humble nimanna sikh. ( IF accordign tot he sakhi types he ahd been ful of haumaii..he would have grabbed the opportunity to become GURU..after all he was Guru Ji's mama Ji, had written so much bani, was scribe of Aad Granth Ji..etc etc and well respected Sikh..BUT he didnt do that but worked tirelkessly for GURU JI HARGOBIND SAHIB JEE ONLY.
So again my most humble apologies for any msiunderstandings.
Jarnail Singh
Hope humble apologies accepted.