Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Benares?

Benares?

Amarjeet Singh · 07 Jul 2005

i was listening to this sabad the other day and i looked up the meanings on sikhitothemax. [gurbani]Awsw ] gj swFy qY qY DoqIAw iqhry pwiein qg ] glI ijn@w jpmwlIAw loty hiQ inbg ] Eie hir ky sMq n AwKIAih bwnwris ky Tg ]1] AYsy sMq n mo kau Bwvih ] fwlw isau pyfw gtkwvih ]1] rhwau ] bwsn mWij crwvih aUpir kwTI Doie jlwvih ] bsuDw Koid krih duie cUly@ swry mwxs Kwvih ]2] Eie pwpI sdw iPrih AprwDI muKhu Aprs khwvih ] sdw sdw iPrih AiBmwnI sgl kutMb fubwvih ]3] ijqu ko lwieAw iqq hI lwgw qYsy krm kmwvY ] khu kbIr ijsu siqguru BytY punrip jnim n AwvY ]4]2][/gurbani] Aasaa: They wear loin cloths, three and a half yards long, and triple-wound sacred threads. They have rosaries around their necks, and they carry glittering jugs in their hands. They are not called Saints of the Lord - they are thugs of Benares. ||1|| Such 'saints' are not pleasing to me; they eat the trees along with the branches. ||1||Pause|| They wash their pots and pans before putting them on the stove, and they wash the wood before lighting it. They dig up the earth and make two fireplaces, but they eat the whole person! ||2|| Those sinners continually wander in evil deeds, while they call themselves touch-nothing saints. They wander around forever and ever in their self-conceit, and all their families are drowned. ||3|| He is attached to that, to which the Lord has attached him, and he acts accordingly. Says Kabeer, one who meets the True Guru, is not reincarnated again. ||4||2|| i was wondering when it says "they are the thugs of Benares" what is "Benares"? vahigurujikakhalsavahigurujikifateh

Re: Benares?

Me · 07 Jul 2005

I suppose it was a town in India where there was a large population of people posing to be Saints. Interesting how you came across this shabad at the same time sant bashers are having the time of their life on this forum.

Re: Benares?

JSGyani "Arshi" · 07 Jul 2005

I was trying to re-post veer amarjeet singh jis post due to his gurbani not appearing normally....but the Forum went down for a few minutes and when it reappered..viola the GURBANI was Correct. ( he forgot to remove the "quote commas from "gurbani"...) ME..the million dollar question really is WHY is this and Similar shabads from GURU GRANTH JI SAHIB...completley IGNORED by the "sants"...BUT 'SRI SUKHMANI SAHIB" is highly recommended all the time... NOW THAT would be really "interesting" ??? dont you think ?? You are right..Benaras was the HEADQUARTERS of Hinduism those days ( it still is)...where SAADHS and SANTS gathered by the THOUSANDS. in fact it was preached by these thugghs that to die in Benares/Kanshi was enough t o take one straight to HEAVEN....but anyone who dies in "Magh-har" would go straight to hell or become a DONKEY JUNE....So Bhagat kabeer Ji left Benares and went to LIve in this "Magh-har" to die...to PROVE that it is all a lie. The death place is not what determines ones heaven or hell or june but KARAMS/Naam kamaii/Simran etc. There are over 40 Gurdwaras, associated with Guru teg bahadur Ji and Guru Gobind Singh Ji in this town.

Re: Benares?

Kulbir Singh · 07 Jul 2005

Talking about Banaras or Kashi, we visited this city last year, on our way to Patna Sahib. We (about 30-35 of us Singhs) were coming from Hazoor Sahib and using the Nagpur route, we arrived at Banaras in the early hours. I was totally shocked to see how dirty this city was. I can’t write how dirty it was. It is a shame that the holiest city of Hindus is kept in such a bad shape. I had expected this city to be a very clean city but I was greatly disappointed. By great fortune, we had darshan of about 3 Gurdwara Sahibaans in this city. While going to one of the Gurdwara Sahib, we had to cross a very dangerous floating bridge, made of wood and supported by old truck tires. We were crossing ocean like river Ganga. I have never seen a greater river than this one. It was full of water and Ganga seemed like an ocean. It was huge. As our 5 SUVs were crossing over, I was wondering about the potency of the bridge to hold them. I got the feel of the city by walking through the crowded part of the city. People were staring at us as if they had never seen Singhs. It was fun. Kulbir Singh

Re: Benares?

Me · 07 Jul 2005

>>ME..the million dollar question really is WHY is this and Similar shabads from GURU GRANTH JI SAHIB...completley IGNORED by the "sants"...BUT 'SRI SUKHMANI SAHIB" is highly recommended all the time... NOW THAT would be really "interesting" ??? dont you think ??<< Arshi I generally ignore all your hatred for sants filled posts these days, but I'd like to respond to this one, maybe it's your lucky day. I don't think Sants ignore any shabads in the Gurbani, but you're reading the Sukhmani and ignoring it at the same time, which is worse?

Re: Benares?

Singh · 07 Jul 2005

benaras is an area of india, its also assocated with a specific style of tabla, benaras gharana...

Re: Benares?

JSGyani "Arshi" · 07 Jul 2005

ME, I have YET to hear a"sant" do katha of this and similar shabads in any diwan/samagam. Its NOT found on any sant related website. If you have such katha on the internet..gurmatveechar.com etc please do point me to the link...or admit that the sants do IGNORE these sections of Gurbani. I will await the links.....take your time and good luck finding them. The point about Sri Sukhmani Sahib....nothing for me to ignore as I dont beleive in humans.

Re: Benares?

Me · 08 Jul 2005

I wasnt talking about humans. Why should I help you with your research? You're a gyani, go look it up yourself. Also, there is no need to do any extensive katha, Guru Sahib mentioned fake Sants, well there are fake Sants and fake Gyanis along with real ones out there, do you need any other extensive explanation?

Re: Benares?

singh concerned · 08 Jul 2005

Veer Gyani Ji, Again you hit the damn nail right on its head...Good swing. To my veer/sister 'Me' - I am know talking from vast/past experience, spending time with the best of the best sants, the kings of santhood, the real-deal baba's, the 'God on earth' folk, the i am form Guru Gobind singh lineage, the i am a reincarnation of Guru Nanak, as per sakhi's for nearly a decade, until all my worst nightmares were in fact shown to me to be reality, that all these men wearing white, and claiming to be Gods messengers, are in fact sikh entrepreneurs. They have identified a market; the gullible type in the sanghat, made a pitch, and the service is being distributed throughout the world, with a marketing slogan of " We can be cross-referenced in the Siri Sukhmani Sahib" Then there volunteers/chele, for free stand and defend them. And when some of them find out that my personal baba/sant/guru is a fake, instead of doing a service to the panth by publicly condoning them, the vast majority of them put the tail between there legs and go underground... They come across as real....do not let that fool you! 'Banares ke dhag' is what they most definitely are...ALL OF THEM. See it’s an easy formula. Sant with title = fake sant. IMHO...

Re: Benares?

Singh · 08 Jul 2005

Gyani Ji, I would like to understand your point about Sant/Baba's some more. What is it exactly that you are against? Do you view all "Sant's" as fake? What is it about the definition of a "Brahmgiani" or "Sant" that you don't agree with?

Re: Benares?

The Apprentice · 08 Jul 2005

What is IMHO?

Re: Benares?

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 09 Jul 2005

I(n) M(y) H(umble) O(pinion)...IMHO - In My Humble Opinion. Note sometimes to people (who dont like you.) ...this may sound as "hypocracy" but use it anyway. Singh Ji, In my take on Sants/babas/Brahmgianis...I am SIMPLY going by the QUALIFICATIONS of such as given by GURU JI in GURBANI. 1. As per those Qualifications...IT is 100% certain that all the 10 GURU SAHIBAANS, the BHAGATS SAHIBAANS....and EACH contributor that has GURBANI enshrined in the GURU GRANTH JI SAHIB is a SANT/Brahmgiani. It is also Certain that WAHEGURU is THE pooran sant/brahmgiani... It is also certain that GURU GRANTH SAHIB JEE as the Successor of the GURU SAHIBAANS is THE pooran Sant/Brahmgiani.. It is also certain that when the PANJ get together as the GURU KHALSA PANTH under the Chhattar Chaiyah of GURU GRANTH JI SAHIB...THEY are Pooran SANT/BRAHMGIANI as GURU JI di kala wartidee hai. Guru Arjun Ji Sahib at the age of Five writes..Bhaag hoa gur sant milaya [gurbani]Bwg hoAw gursMq imlwieAw[/gurbani]...and this referecne is to GURU RAAMDASS JI in particular and to WAHEGURU JI in general. The implication is clear..any human who wnats or desires to be callaed - GUR/SANT/Brahmgiani..should be as "qualified" as GURU RAAMDASS JI 2. NO ONE PERSON.... This MUST be stressed until everybody gets it thoroughly...NO ONE PERSON..from the Heights of Gurmukhta as Baba Buddha Ji, Bhai Gurdass Ji,....and THOUSANDS of their "standard" and "qualifications" were ever addressed as "SANT/BRAHMGIANI" Far from it that anyone fo them ever had sangats matha teking at their feet. Sikh History is very clear on this. 3. This trend continued until the 20 th Century. Hundreds of thousands of Gurmukhs, and Shaheeds....but NO SANTS and NO BRAHMGIANIS. 4. After 1935 onwards..it is a different question alltogether. Thats all. I have NOTHING against anyone personally...I dont even "know" the many thousands of sants and brahmgianis in Punjab and overseas...for me as LONG as I CANNOT "KNOW" The GURSANT Parkash in my own home...GURU GRANTH JI SAHIB...as much as I want to "KNOW" HIm....whats the point of running after and matha teking to others. My argument is..IF GURU JI WANTED us sikhs to "learn/follow/ humans saadhs/sants/brahmgianis...etc ettc as was in VOGUE during GURU JI's TIME ( you will NOTICE that GURU NANAK JI made a special effort of FOUR UDASSIS to go MEET some of the THOUSANDS of SIDDHS, SANTS, FAKIRS, MIRS, SHEIKHS, YOGIS...ALL the TOP RELIGIOUS LEADERS of His time...and then WROTE GURBANI such as Siddh Ghost, Raamkali Oankar, Asa Ki Vaar...to ESTABLISH the TRUTH...the USELESSNESS of following such HUMANS as opposed to GURBANI. IF such "holy persons" are needed for us to establish a connection to GURU JI....as intermediaries, guru de larr laon layee...then GURU JI wouldnt have written GURBANI...Sikhs would have carried on depending on the Siddhs, Yogis and saadhs etc who have been "leading" the religious from time immemorial...Hindus have been matha Teking to these siddhs and sants, sadhus, holy men, brahmins, brahmgianis,. pandits...feeding them saradhs, giving them clothes, donating them cows and gold etc etc...there is absolutley NO NEED for GURBANI ??? The Hindus have the Vedas...BUT they STILL "need" these sadhs, holymen ??.. to interpret the vedas for them ?? These "sants/brahmgianis" are taking on this ROLE and trying to sell us the idea that we NEED them to...Guru de larr laon waste, gurbani samjhaoun wasteh, dharam da rastaa dikhaoun waste....blah blah blah. GURU JI and GURBANI has LIBERATED US from this JOOLA...GURBANI is UNIVERSAL TRUTH..every SIKH is COMMANDED to LEARN it FOR HIMSELF...AAP GURU DE LARR LAGGOH. The sant followers frequently defend their stand by saying our sant Ji sanoo guru de larr laonde ne, BUT then they will turn around and say..AAseen Falane SANT JI ton AMrit Chhakiyyah hai...assen falane sant ji de jatha memeber haan......WHEN the AMRIT is Daat of GURU JI given through GURU KHALSA PANTH- the PANJ ONLY....so the "cat" is out of the bag..these are NOT Sikhs but Followers of SANT JI...they prefer to "honour" the "TEACHER..path shower...the rasta dikhaoun walah..rather than the DESTINATION. Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji ki fateh.

Re: Benares?

Rajashekaran Iyer · 09 Jul 2005

IMHO is an acronym for In My Humble Opinion.

Re: Benares?

Taran · 09 Jul 2005

IMHO means "in my honest opinion"

Re: Benares?

Manjit kaur · 10 Jul 2005

Satgur Sri guru Amardass Ji DECLARES... Satgur Bina Hor KACHI BANI...kehndeh KACHEH, Sundeh KACHEH, Kacheean aakh vikhaannee... SANT JI SRI 1008 Ranjit Singh Dadriwalah declares even more emphatically.. THERE IS NO SUCH THING as KACHI BANI..ALL Bani is PAKKII...ALL bani is SACHEE...listen to a MP3 of his diwan promoted by Lord Singh on this and other Forums under the title: There is NO KACHI BANI.. How can "Bnai" be kachi ?? ASK SATGURU JI ?? But then our Holyness has NOT read GURBANI at all..thats why he calls his dhaarnas Paki bani.... Decide who is telling the TRUTH. Benares ke Thugghs have Changed to Sants of Punjab

Re: Benares?

gupt singh · 12 Jul 2005

Waheguru ji ka Khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh looks like some people like to be selective in the shabads they read/quote as well http://www.sikhitothemax.com/Page.asp?SourceID=G&PageNo=&ShabadID=3254&Format=2 Bhagat Kabir ji is referred to as a sant in Gurbani.

Re: Benares?

A Singh · 12 Jul 2005

Benares Gharana is a style of tabla from Varanasi currently headed up by Pandit Sharda Sahai. Many Singhs in the UK who play tabla are also from this gharana and mistakenly believe it to be the very best and orginal (which it is not). One Singh from Soho Road Gurdwara even claimed that this Gharana is the only one with the Hathalee stoke -absolute nonsense!!! Whilst each Gharana has its own traditions, one cannot claim Benares to be superior at any rate. Punjab and Lucknow have much older roots and Delhi are the founders of the Kaida systems, Farukhabad has produced giants such as Ustad Amhedjaan Thirkwa Sahib -possibly the greatest Tabla player ever -funny how the Singh and his supporters from Soho Road hadn't even heard of him!!!

Re: Benares?

Dandilion · 12 Jul 2005

Gianu Ji I think you are getting confused in your old age, you seem to be mix’n’matching things in your own merry way. <<< The sant followers frequently defend their stand by saying our sant Ji sanoo guru de larr laonde ne, BUT then they will turn around and say..AAseen Falane SANT JI ton AMrit Chhakiyyah hai >>> Sant followers do say that Sant Ji sanoo guru de larr laayaa, this is true, but <<< Falane SANT JI ton AMrit Chhakiyyah hai >>> is rubbish, as we all know Amrit is Guru Ka, the same argument could be aimed at AKJ, taksali etc. <<< "TEACHER..path shower...the rasta dikhaoun walah..rather than the DESTINATION. >>> There is a shabad by Kabir Ji where he asks if your Guru and God is stood before you who do you mathatake first? You mathatake your Guru first BECAUSE HE HAS SHOWN YOU THE PATH TO GOD. Manjit Kaur Ji, you can twist everything the way you like. Baba Ji was saying that if it is Gurus Bani then how can it be katchi ? Benji, calling Guru dhay piyaray Thags is not going to hold you in good stead when you face the might of DharamRaja. You may say that you are Gurus Singhani and the Guru will protect you but at that time Guru Ji will turn his back on you. [%sig%]

Re: Benares?

...... · 12 Jul 2005

thats why he calls his dhaarnas Paki bani.... no he doesnt. Clearly you should listen to it again as he claims in many of his diwaans that dhaarna is not bani, he also explains what kachi bani is. All this is that many other types of jatha cant handle the fact that when a sant comes along the gurdwaras are packed to the max why? because when a devotee of guru ji is in town guru ji calls everyone to take laha.

Re: Benares?

singh · 12 Jul 2005

WJKK WJKF I am in no way against sants, I do believe bani clearly says a human can attain that level. Their are obviously A LOT of fakes but I still think their are a few out there. However, trust me on this dadrainwale aint no sant, and I give respect for everything hes doing he is someone who has let this fame get to him. I will not say anything else but all I can say is just trust me on that. I do get dissipointed when Gyani Arshi Ji says their is no such thing as a human brahmgyani or sant, I believe this contradicts gurbani ( personal belief) I like the stance of not following sants, because their are jsut too many fakes. But I see no problem in believing in the words of REAL sants ( the very few who are out there) I see this no different than how akj so firmly believes everything Bhai Randhir Singh preached. I dont see how its wrong.

Re: Benares?

Dandilion · 12 Jul 2005

Nice one ...... [%sig%]

Re: Benares?

Sehajvirsingh · 12 Jul 2005

I don't get it. I wish we would spend at least HALF the time we do arguing over these issues doing simran. I mean why no try to attain akaal purakh first and then give ur opinions. I mean if so and so says this yet so and so says that who do u believe. I believe u should follow what ur heart says. The more bani you do the more you should trust your inner feeling. I suggest we stop listening to to people's opinions about sants and do some serious naam abhiyaas then when u meet these sants apnay aap pata lagjao ga. As for manjit kaurs post. Bhenji why do you twists the words so much. I mean if you do have an opinion why not represent the truth instead of twisting it so your point will come across. I mean this is very dishonest. Think about it rss does this do they not. Take our mahan sikhi and twist it to suit themselves. I am referring to your post about Baba ranjit singh saying that no bani can be kachi. Baba ji has never stated that his dharnas are pakay. He said to even say that it is Kachi Bani is a paap. Meaning that his dharnas are not even close to bani. He was refferring to no way gurus bani can be kachi. It is just a way to do parchar like parcharaks use words that they devise from the mind that comes out of their mouth to describe bani. Are we saying that parcharaks are doing kachi bani because after all for them to describe a shabad they are going to have to use their own words. Just like sant ji using his words to create dharnas that are catchy and are understandable to the main stream sangat. I believe its pretty much the same thing as dhadi varaan. And people might be like we don't need sants to help us reach guru. Give me a break who says u need anyone to reach the guru. You only need urself to be committed to him, but some people do not know much about sikhi and this is the way that they are realizing the greatness of our mahan gurus. WE ARE not all at the same level giani arshi ji. We can't be like will all i need is guru granth sahib ji and that is all everyone else needs. This is a true statement however some people such as urself have found him and others are searching around in the dark. And some true guru's devotees can bring that light to u that this is what the guru is why don't u follow his teachings and experience his greatness. When i was in grade ten i had no interest in sikhi i was forced to keep my hair. I had no sangat where I lived and my parents were typical just do paath quickly to keep guru ji happy. It is only after i started watching a certain "sants" videos that i started to fall deeply in love with sikhi. His explanations were in simple punjabi so i could understand and the sakhis used to make me cry. I had no idea that the guru's were that great and i probably would have went the other way had i not stumbled across this tape. I used to watch it every night over and over again. However i'm not saying that we should get attached to these sants or worship them like so many fools are doing. And i do disagree with sants letting this happen something should be done. And majority of sants are pakhandi maha paapis who should be boiled alive. I am saying that i am living proof that a "sants" vichaars got ME closer to my guru which changed my life in unimaginable ways. So how can this be wrong. Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh

Re: Benares?

Search For tat · 12 Jul 2005

If you read Bhai sahibs books then you will realise they are purely Gurbani based. Apart from the jail Chittian and Rangley Sajjan, the rest are technical books on aspects of Gurbani. So are you believing Bhai Sahib, or Gurbani? I think you are believing in Gurbani! Sants do stories about sants. This sants said this, and he did this and then that happened, bollo Waheguru!. In contrast Bhai Sahibs books are Gurbani based. There is a BIG difference! Singh wrote:- I see this no different than how akj so firmly believes everything Bhai Randhir Singh preached. I dont see how its wrong.

Re: Benares?

JSGyani "Arshi" · 12 Jul 2005

gupt singh : <<< looks like some people like to be selective in the shabads they read/quote as well http://www.sikhitothemax.com/Page.asp?SourceID=G&PageNo=&ShabadID=3254&Format=2 Bhagat Kabir ji is referred to as a "sant" in Gurbani. <<<< You are mistaken gupt jio.... BHAGAT KABIR JI IS GURU...ALL SIKHS EVERYWHERE MATHA TEK TO HIM ....are you forgetting Bhagat kabir Ji is IN GURU GRANTH JI SAHIB MAHARAJ.... Dhan Dhan Guru Ji GURU NANAK KI SAHIB took him in his Pyaar Bharee Galwakrree...and placed him on His Side....The GURBANI of Bhagat Kabir is MOST PROLIFIC of the Bhagats... YOU have MADE the POINT I have been trying to MAKE..ONLY "GURBANI"...GURU GRANTH JI MAHARAJ is the TRUE SANT/GURU/PARMESHAR/WAHEGURU....in this WORLD .... No need to be "selective"..gupt...whatever...GURBANI is plain GLORIOUS in full splendour for all to see

Re: Benares?

Jasvir Kaur Thind · 17 Jul 2005

Singh wrote:- I see this no different than how akj so firmly believes everything Bhai Randhir Singh preached. I dont see how its wrong. This is where most people are wrong. The books of Bhai sahib ji are PURELY gurbani VICHAAR....not kacheeean storiayan, kahannian, or wadho ghatoo gallan. Some of the books are so heavy and technical...that one has to have alot of Gyan/Naam bahiyass even before we can barely begin to understand the aspects of what Bhai Ji explains... Beleive me..I have bought a few of these books and havent yet completley finished a single one...BUT the STACK of "SAnt JEEWANEES" of various sants like Sant attar singh Ji, Sant Isher Singh Ji, etc are stories ABOUT the SANT rather than GURBANI...story after story of what this sant did to that sant and what happened to this sewak and that sewak....something akin to the Bhai Bala Janamsakhi...Now if Someone were to compare "Janamsakhi" to GURU GRANTH JI....he would know the difference...the SANT BIOGRAPHIES are "janamsakhis" of the sants....whereas Bhai Sahib Bhai randheer Singh ji tackles the SERIOUS GURBANI Vichaars and doesnt relate Stories about HIMSELF or his sewaks if any.

Re: Benares?

A Singh · 18 Jul 2005

How about the feeding each other in the fields story?

Re: Benares?

Singh · 18 Jul 2005

I visited this link a few days ago and asked Gyani Ji to clarify his stand on "sants." I read his clarification and I 100% agree with what hes saying. Those happen to be my beliefs too. The only problem I have with these anti-sant sermons is that he goes after Taksal (i.e. referring to gurmatveechar, etc.) but fails to mention anything about AKJ and their devotion to Bhai Randhir Singh. Maybe I'm wrong (and I say this with all sincerity) but isn't this a bit hypocritical. I believe, like how Gyani Ji says, that all of us are given amrit by Guru Khalsa Panth and not by any particular group. I have as much loyalty to Taksal as I do to AKJ (which is zero) so I don't have an agenda here. But in the spirit of calling a "spade-a-spade", like how Gyani Ji likes to say, all the points argued against sants are are equally as true to AKJ (especially the last paragraph of 7-09-05). My question is, what is the difference between how a Taksali, when questioned about his beliefs ALWAYS refer back to how their sant said or did this and how an AKJ always refer back to thier Bhai and say Bhai sahib said or did this? The only difference I see is that the title of "Bhai" is interchangable with "Sant Brahmgiani." Or is that the issue? Jasvir Kaur Thind, Have you not heard of read Jail Chittian? Because that book falls into the same category as the books you criticize. Please correct me if i'm wrong. [%sig%]

Re: Benares?

Jasvir Kaur Thind · 19 Jul 2005

Yes I have read that book of Bhai Sahib Jee..its the first one i read and also read by almost everyone i met who is now a ardent "fan" of Bhai Sahib jee..but that is an autobiography..HISTORY..with "HIS + STORY "" get it. I am talking about the more than two DOZEN other deep Books on GURBANI VICHAAR.....Has any "SANT" written even 10% of this number and as deep as that on Gurbani Vichaar. In fact Bhai Sahib Ji is one fo the MOST PROLIFIC writers on GURBANI and SPIRITUALITY..And Most Importantly like the GURU SAHIBAANS..these Books are written BY BHAI SAHIB JI himself..not by some chela shardhaloo of his...like "sant" Teja Singh did for "sant" attar singh ji. I read Both books on sant attar singh ji at one reading..just simple storytelling of his life by an obviously enthralled shardhaloo chela..any gurbani vichaar is fine tuned to show incidents in attar singh jis life...as if trying to prove gurbani through his life incidents...

Re: Benares?

Singh · 20 Jul 2005

Jasvir Kaur Thind, First of all, I asked a simple question, which I think is valid and appropriate. If you want others to look in the mirror than you have to be willing to look in it yourself. Now, according to you, someone who is of a high avasta (someone who is referred to as a "sant", "Bhai", etc.) has to write books in order to be accepted as a true avasta vala Gursikh. Why are the books considered so wonderful and prolific? Its because they answer questions about Sikhi and give the every man an insight into Gurbani, and most people who read them are changed for the better. If you read about people who met Sant Attar Singh Ji you'll see that he had the same affect. Just because he didn't meet you (whether personally or through something he's written) and didn't have an affect on you doesn't mean he was any less of a Gursikh than Bhai Sahib. People refer to Sant Attar Singh Ji as a Sant to signify that he was a high avasta vala Gursikh. This is the same reason why people refer to Bhai Sahib as Bhai Sahib. Others even give him the double bhai, Bhai Sahib Bhai Randhir Singh. Whats the difference between "Sant" and "Bhai." You have to take all these biography books for what they're worth. I personally know people whose lives have changed because they read Bhai Sahib's autobiography. I also personally know people who have read Sant Attar Singh's biography and have changed. I've also met people who weren't affected by either or by one or the other, and talk negatively about the ones they didn't like. I don't completely disagree with you in your last paragraph but I can't completely agree with you either. The problem I have is how you wrote that paragraph. You are putting down another "Sant" to show the superiority of your "Sant." Are you not? Sant Attar Singh's mission, Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh's mission, Sant Teja Singh's mission are all the same-to join people with Gurbani. Each goes about it in the way that Vaheguru wanted them to. I've read those books as well as Jail Chittian, and they're not as sinister in their agenda as you try to make it out. Sant Attar Singh never was a self appointed Sant. Nor was Sant Teja Singh. In those books, it is overwhelmingly OBVIOUS that Sant Teja Singh is trying to join people with Gurbani through the way he joined with Gurbani, and that was through Sant Attar Singh. He is not trying to make Sant Attar Singh out to be someone who is to be worshipped and matha tek to, but rather hes trying to show people that you too can be like him and achieve a high avasta. In Jail Chittian, Bhai Sahib is doing the exact same thing. He knew he shouldn't be writing about his own avasta and experiences (he mentions this in his first letters) but does it anyway at the expense of his own progress to inspire someone else to follow the path of Sikhi. When you put someone else down in order to raise the status of someone you believe to be better, it has very divisive affects on the Panth and this is very bad.

Re: Benares?

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 20 Jul 2005

Singh Ji, I agree with you. Those who "JOIN US TO GURU JI"...are worth emulating... Sometimes people get too carried away with their own point of view....