Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Multiple IDs/Sant Bashing

Multiple IDs/Sant Bashing

Singhani · 05 Jul 2005

Firstly, one person on this forum posts under all these fake ID's. Someone who is so terrified with titles but uses one themselves and reminds people of it. Its annoying to see the same font type, writing, english style, sant bashing lingo by about 6 IDS by the SAME person. If you have to bash these mahapurush by doing something so low, you obviously have no truth in your fake allegations. Secondly, it has been proved Sant Jarnail Singh Bhindrawale sang the same dharna as another Sant being bashed on this forum, why are the sant bashers quiet? Are you going to bash Sant Jarnail Singh Ji for this too? because by your own theory and token, you already have.

Re: Multiple IDs/Sant Bashing

Iminder Singh · 05 Jul 2005

Vaheguroo Jee Ka Khalsa! Vaheguroo Jee Ki Fateh! Bhenji, Just a question - are you a moderator? If not, how do you know one person is sant bashing under multiple IDs? Please don't get offended, its just a question. Vaheguroo Jee Ka Khalsa! Vaheguroo Jee Ki Fatehh!

Re: Multiple IDs/Sant Bashing

singh · 05 Jul 2005

because we can tell when the person repeatedly uses the same style of english and repeatedly types CERTAIN words in caps which nobody else on the forum does and also uses some of the exact same spellings for words which are unique to that person. it's very easy to tell.

Re: Multiple IDs/Sant Bashing

Singhani · 05 Jul 2005

The writing style of these people, using caps..and the same points being repeated in EVERY thread, are clues.

Re: Multiple IDs/Sant Bashing

Dandilion · 05 Jul 2005

Iminder Singh, sorry to offend, but can't you read ? Bhenji has just told you <<< Its annoying to see the same font type, writing, english style, sant bashing lingo by about 6 IDS by the SAME person. >>> [%sig%]

Re: Multiple IDs/Sant Bashing

JSGyani "Arshi" · 05 Jul 2005

Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji kI fateh. ALL DHAARNA is WRONG..no matter who does it. NO ONE is ABOVE GURU JI/GURBANI/KIRTAN and GURBANI RAAGS Jarnail Singh Khalsa has the unique distinction of having been a PROVEN SANT-SIPAHI...who was True to his Bachan/Ardass/lived his life according to His PRINCIPLES and MOST IMPORTANTLY SACRIFICED himself in the TRue tradition of The Guru Khalsa Panth...all these points set him MILES AWAY from all other just "sants" who sing dhaarnas and nothing else. IT is a proven FACT and well known to many that wehn Jarnail Singh Ji Khalsa had complete control of both Akal Takhat and Harmandar Sahib Complex, and no one dared to disobey his smallest wish...Jarnail Singh Ji NEVER attempted to Change or Modify the MARYADA at these Apex Bodies to His Own Damdami Taksaal Maryada ( He could have done so from day one....BUT he strictly FORBADE IT saying this is GURU KHALSA PANTH Maryada and Mine is Damdami taksaal maryada) THAT shows strength of Character.....others "Change" your maryada FIRST before they admit you into their group...and the moment they get half a chance..they will FORCE a CHANGE as the Rode Jathedar subsequently did. The difference between me and the others is that they pick the "BEST" sant (Jarnail singh Khalsa) to be their Champion.( and completley ignore the rest full of khameean and shortcomings as big as elephants)...I pick the worst of these "sants" to sant-bash.( maybe i too ignore some of their "good points"...but then I am as HUMAN as these Sants....ONLY GURU JI is ABHULL. ) In this modern Era post 1984...Jarnail Singh ji Khalsa is the BEST example of a Pooran Sant Sipahi and i will never raise my pen against him - how can i as I have about ten of his portraits in all the rooms of my house as an inspiration to my Gurbani Classes...He is the ONE that led to the success of the other GREAT ones like Manochahl, Babar Jarnails, the Panjwarrrs, and hundreds who gave their Today for OUR tomorrow. Name me any other "SANT" of the stature of this SANT-SIPAHI and I will honour him too.

Re: Multiple IDs/Sant Bashing

amorphous_singh · 05 Jul 2005

> The writing style of these people, using caps..and the same > points being repeated in EVERY thread, are clues. ----- Begin feeble attempt at copying someone else's 'style' ----- BUT ... if the writing style is so OBVIOUS ... then anyone can copy it..etc. IMHO some else could easily pretend to ... be SOMEBODY ELSE!!! ===== End of feeble attempt ===== Oh sure the IP's are logged but thats not visible to the casual user and they might not even reliase the significance of IPs. Also not everyone has static IP's. One logical solution is to have user logins but that might not be to everyone's liking; especially as there are times that some people might want to remain gupt; but the solution to the latter is to then send in such posts via the admins and seeing as they already have the admin burden it's not such a big deal (from where I'm sitting - the admins might see it differently). Apologies to anyone who feels I might have copied their writing style above; it was just a general example based on the descriptions of styles mentioned in posts in this thread.

Re: Multiple IDs/Sant Bashing

Lord Singh · 05 Jul 2005

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa, Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh!!! SANT Jarnail Singh Ji Khalsa Bhindranwale is the name that people call him - those who respect him - don't try to be clever now by missing out the SANT in the name - How dare you??? If one cannot even respect what Sant Bhindranwale DID, what they stood for, then he has no chance at all to understand, only Waheguru can bless him to come to his senses. Sant Bhindranwale were too great to mention in words, but surely Sants that influenece so many people to give up drinking, smoking and follow the Sikh way of life and to take Amrit Paan are also mahaan in the Panth to do such respectable things!!! - Anything said against them IS NOT RIGHT UNDER ANY CIRCUMSTANCE!!! THESE KIND OF PEOPLE SHOULD BE IGNORED AND HAVE NOTHING TO DO WITH!!! Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa, Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh!!! "Bhindranwale Sant Sipahi, Jihna Suthi Kaum Juagee"

Re: Multiple IDs/Sant Bashing

JSGyani "Arshi" · 05 Jul 2005

Dear Lord Singh ji, You may call anyone whatever you wish. It dosent change an iota for me...or diminish in me in anyway the respect I have for anyone i chose to respect...A "huge lot of people" call many others.... SANT...(like Man Singh for example)..i dont give two hoots.... as to multiple IDs.... I ususally dont give two hoots to the "poster"...my first instinct is to ge READ THE MESSAGE and see if I agree or disagree with what he/she is trying to say.....and then I reply to the MESSAGE. I only "reply to the PERSON" if my reply must address the PERSON..like the reply to Lord Singh above....as he "replied to ME..rather than to my message. IDs dont mean two bit....imagine me spending sleepless nights wondering..if this "LordSingh" is really a LORD ??? Oh my God i have offended a real British LORD..should i have called him SIR..will the Queen now come after my head ?? he he he he...DREAM ON ...multiple ID detectives..go on wasting your time.

Re: Multiple IDs/Sant Bashing

Vaheguru's princess · 05 Jul 2005

Dear Arshi A true giani don't do this. True Giani are the person full with respect and love. Because without the respect and love how can a giani do gurumaharajji's sewa. as what Lord Singh says "Sant Bhindranwale were too great to mention in words" and sant ji are still too great. SO next time when came to SANT JARNAIL SINGH JI please respect it.

Re: Multiple IDs/Sant Bashing

NaamRas · 05 Jul 2005

Waheguroo Jee Ka Khalsa! Waheguroo Jee Kee Fateh!! Arshi Jee ... you are showing an inconsistency in the line of your thinking. On the one hand you say that you will never raise your pen against Sant Jarnail Singh Jee, but on the other hand you say that ALL Dhaarna is wrong. Since Sant Jarnail Singh Jee sang in Dhaarna, you are by implication saying that he must be wrong, if all Dhaarna are wrong. You can't have it both ways ... either ALL Dhaarna are wrong, whoever they are sung by, OR there is nothing wrong with Dhaarna. If all Dhaarna are wrong, then no doubt you are raising your pen against Sant Jarnail Singh Jee. Bhul Chuk Maaf Waheguroo

Re: Multiple IDs/Sant Bashing

Iminder Singh · 06 Jul 2005

Vaheguroo Jee Ka Khalsa! Vaheguroo Jee Ki Fatehh! Dandilion Jee, Looks like I can't read afterall. NO offence taken at all. :) Vaheguroo Jee Ka Khalsa! Vaheguroo Jee Ki Fateh! [%sig%]

Re: Multiple IDs/Sant Bashing

Raag Keertan=Gurmat Keertan · 06 Jul 2005

All Keertan in Raag no exception get rid of po. no kachi bani no nothing, nirol Raag kirtan/kath/or path nothing else. No bollywood. No going to smagams to hear Bhai manpreet or Bhai Tajinderpal, or a SANT. go to rainsbhai/keertan darbar for Guroo Jee and Bani not voices, not tunes. Learn Raag!! get up u lazzy ......... Wake up stop the P.O. Bring Back Raag, Bring Back Pratan Rehit!

Re: Multiple IDs/Sant Bashing

Lord Singh · 06 Jul 2005

LOL - I don't agree with some of your posts "Arshi" Ji - personal opinion at the end of the day - But the "Lord" thing was Funny - LOL - I give you that!!! Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa, Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh!!! "Bhindranwale Sant Siphai, Jihna Suthi Kaum Jugaee" [%sig%]

Re: Multiple IDs/Sant Bashing

Gursikh · 06 Jul 2005

Arshi ji, Please respect Sant Baba Jarnail Singh Ji Khalsa Bhindrawale........ If you want sangat on the forum respect you man...... Mind your language............. A person is not a Gyani by putting his/her title behind the name..... Must do a lot of Bagtee and Kamayi as how Sant Baba Jarnail Singh Ji Khalsa Bhindrawale did not by bashing sant or mahapurk... Phul Chuk Maf... Gursikh

Re: Multiple IDs/Sant Bashing

Singh concerned · 06 Jul 2005

The issue is not the performance that a sant puts in front of the sanghat, the issue is the way in which we, the sanghat start to 'worship' these so-called sants. This so-called chela business is instigated by the sant and, making sanghat members become chele, thus the extorsion, demands begin... Baba jarnail singh did what he did for the panth, good on him. whether his title was sant or not (most probably, seeing most of the taksal use this title!) the panth seems to agree that he was a mahan surma... Then we read about the attar singhs and isher singhs, and nand singhs from recent history, and of the fables/miracles they performed. And guess who usually tells these stories, those sants professing to be from there group!! why? for there own personal gain... Mann of pehowa was seen as a great sant of the 1990's... rocked the world (and stages) yet in a flash the truth came out, and now he plans his trips in secret (his next trip to the UK, August 2005) Ranjit singh, the boy sant... says one thing on stage, just like mann of pehowa, who he copied, and does something else. (he can be found standing on a table, with a large barrel next to him, to catch the rupee's in, at his dhera. The table standing is so that sanghat can touch his feet!! Ask these sants, and the sant samarj to tackle horrific issues such as the Nurmahali cult leader who dis-respects Siri Guru Granth Sahib Jee, to help rid the drug/HIV issue in india....this they cannot do, why, because the pound is stronger than the rupee, plain and simple

Re: Multiple IDs/Sant Bashing

Niranjan Singh · 06 Jul 2005

So Arshi Ji called "Baba Jarnail Singh" : Jarnail Singh Ji Khalsa What is wrong with that ? When Baba Jarnail Singh took amrit his name was simply "Jarnail Singh". Are you denying that was NOT his real name ? Are far as respect you can add a millions of sant-baba-brahmangyani-10000000008-108-108, titles, but in Gurmat they mean nothing. Irnicaly we refer to our First Guru Sahib Ji, Baba Nanak (ie: Dera Baba Nanak). How about "Wah-Wah Gobind Singh, Appay Gur Chela..." I have never heard any outrage regarding the use of the above names. Is Jarnail Singh Ji much more special than Guru Nanak Dev Ji, or Dassam Patshah that he deserved a bigger title? What about Sukha Singh Mehtab Singh Bota Singh Garja Singh ? Where are their titles ? Whose Sikhs are we ? Of our Guru ? Or of Jarnail Singh Ji ? The only requirement in Gurmat is that we always use SINGH and KAUR with a GurSikh's name. Everthing else is optional. [%sig%]

Re: Multiple IDs/Sant Bashing

Hari Singh · 06 Jul 2005

Baba Jorawar Singh, Baba Buddha jee, Baba Deep Singh, Bhai Randhir Singh ... BUT you people are insisting on calling Baba Jarnail Singh,... SANT BABA JARNAIL SINGH JEE KHASLA BHINDRAWALE... You need to open your eyes. You people are so blind to what true respect is.

Re: Multiple IDs/Sant Bashing

Dandilion · 06 Jul 2005

<<< Then we read about the attar singhs and isher singhs, and nand singhs from recent history, and of the fables/miracles they performed. And guess who usually tells these stories, those sants professing to be from there group!! why? for there own personal gain... >>> Firstly Concerned Singh you need to learn some respect. Why are you bashers so hell bent on the notion about personal gain ? Cannot someone do perchar or sewa for the sake of perchar or sewa ? You are so cynical that you cannot see the wood from the trees. <<< Mann of pehowa was seen as a great sant of the 1990's... rocked the world (and stages) yet in a flash the truth came out, and now he plans his trips in secret (his next trip to the UK, August 2005) >> Erm, I don’t see any charges brought against him, which is what you conveniently forget, and how long has it been,2 years, 3 years? I know it take a while to do things in India but this is ridiculous. Or maybe the allegations are unfounded ! <<< Ranjit singh, the boy sant... says one thing on stage, just like mann of pehowa, who he copied, and does something else. (he can be found standing on a table, with a large barrel next to him, to catch the rupee's in, at his dhera. The table standing is so that sanghat can touch his feet!! >>> You need to learn some respect. What you say is a total lie. As we have seen in the last few weeks you bashers have gone into overdrive with your LIES and innuendos, you really should stop all this nindhia. Baba Ji has NEVER EVER asked for any money EVER. They have said so on stage infron of the sangat and said that if anybody can say otherwise they will stop perchar straight away, and idiots like you spread thes vicious LIES. <<<<>>> Again, you have to start thinking outside the box mate! What do you think the amirt sanchars are for ? Those fortunate souls who take amrit give up drugs and alcohol. [%sig%]

Re: Multiple IDs/Sant Bashing

chuckles · 06 Jul 2005

i always thought that the sangat gave the status of a sant so if god is within the sangat and the sangat represent god etc then isnt it god giving the "sant" a sant status ? just a thought :)

Re: Multiple IDs/Sant Bashing

khalsa_force · 06 Jul 2005

some real 007 on this site, they feel so unsecure tht they r sleuthing now. concentrate on topics guys.

Re: Multiple IDs/Sant Bashing

l Singh · 06 Jul 2005

Doesnt Manvir Kaur , have any input on this??!?

Re: Multiple IDs/Sant Bashing

JSGyani "Arshi" · 06 Jul 2005

Dear Naam Rass jio, you write: <<

Re: Multiple IDs/Sant Bashing

JSGyani "Arshi" · 06 Jul 2005

Author: l Singh Date: 07-06-05 16:08 Doesnt Manvir Kaur , have any input on this??!? >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> just who is Manvir Kaur ? I have missed all her posts.....although i take cre to read almost all the posts daily.... This is the First time i am hearing this name . 1 Singh Ji ?? point me to some posts of her...What I do is i cut and paste each person's posts in a folder...topic wise...easier for me to Search/Sort etc. Thus I have created a folder for manvir Kaur but at the moment it is empty. I dont want to miss some fantastic posts... THANK YOU IN ADVANCE 1 SINGH JI.

Re: Multiple IDs/Sant Bashing

confused · 06 Jul 2005

you know what i would like to seee....some framed pictures in gurdwara sahibs of shaheeds like bhai fauja singh and other shaheeds from 78 and other times and of bhai sahib bhai veer singh jee and bhai randheer singh jee

Re: Multiple IDs/Sant Bashing

vaheguru' s princess · 06 Jul 2005

Arshi, wah wah arshi, tussi tha kemall kithi. u really have two colours. IF u want to live in guruji's arms then 1st of all have some respect. [%sig%]

Re: Multiple IDs/Sant Bashing

NaamRas · 07 Jul 2005

Waheguroo Jee Ka Khalsa! Waheguroo Jee Kee Fateh!! Thanks Gyani Arshi Jee for clarifying your stance. I agree with you that only our Guru Sahib, Guru Maharaaj is ABHULL. He is THE greatest Guru. He is the most wonderful Guru for all humanity. With regards to Dhaarna and why great souls of the Khalsa Panth have reverted to using them, I cannot answer for them (i.e., Sant Jarnail Singh, Sant Attar Singh, Sant Isher Singh, etc). My Bhagti, Naam and Kamaaye are nowhere near as these great souls. But I can only imagine that they used it as a means of Parchaar, and how successful they were in their mission. Literally, they inspired hundreds of thousands to be Guru Wale. I don't believe that these souls, having attained such glory in their spiritual journey and in the Khalsa Panth, would do Beadbi of Gurbani and their Guru. I also thank those great souls who did Dhaarna, as it was through these great souls' inspiration, that my family attached to SatGur, Siri Guru Granth Sahib Jee Maharaaj. This does not mean I treat Dhaarna as Bani. Indeed I believe it is not even Bani. Bani is our Guru, Bani is Nirankaar. I believe a Dhaarna is just a Dhaarna - a simple but effective means of Parchaar. But regarding this Kachi Bani and Dhaarna issue, I am willing to have an open-mind. To this effect, I hope to start a more systematic thread in a few days time (when I will have more time) where hopefully you and Kulbir Singh Jee may be able to persuade me otherwise and answer questions that I may have directly. Lastly, I apologise for any feisty or sarcastic remarks I have made towards anyone in the last few days with regard to Kachi Bani/Dhaarna. This can be quite an emotive issue for me, and at times I have used language not befitting of an aspiring Gursikh. Bhul Chuk Maaf Waheguroo

Re: Multiple IDs/Sant Bashing

Singh concerned · 07 Jul 2005

Veer Arshi ji, Could you please put the author and title of the book, re. 'sant ke kautak' up again please. He, the author, was currently shown being interviewed on Canadian T.V. Form what he says, it looks like his team have really put the whole 'sant' thing under the spot light.... Much appreciated. Gurfateh. [%sig%]

Re: Multiple IDs/Sant Bashing

JSGyani "Arshi" · 07 Jul 2005

Dear Singh Concerned jio, Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji ki Fateh. That item appeared on Sikhsydney@Yahoo. com/[address removed] quite some time ago. I will try my best to get the info. Meanwhile if any other reader has it ?? Its on one of the messages on this Forum as well. At that time also it was reported that due to the "truths" in the book his life was THREATENED ( by those who are themselves threatened by the TRUTHS)

Re: Multiple IDs/Sant Bashing

1 Singh · 07 Jul 2005

sorry I meant to say Manjit Kaur. Im sure you have read and are familiar all of her wonderful posts. I'd like to hear some input from her on this topic... how about you Gyani Arshi Jee?

Re: Multiple IDs/Sant Bashing

JSGyani "Arshi" · 07 Jul 2005

Dear I singh ji, I have written about 5 FIVE posts already on this Topic.....see above ? So what more input do you want from me ?? Anything specific....just ask...but GENERALLY I have about said it all i want to say... unless i missed something and you know about it. In that case you only have to ask and i will reply suitably to the query. Manjit Kaur Sidhu is a good poster and i have read all her posts...her folder is quite full. Write to her email address if you want any special input.

Re: Multiple IDs/Sant Bashing

Vaheguru's princess · 07 Jul 2005

Don't anyone think that Manjit Kaur Sidhu have same thinking like how Arshi had. sound funny rite, thats my opinion. Hope all got the point here. It can be................ [%sig%]

Re: Multiple IDs/Sant Bashing

Sikh in the West · 08 Jul 2005

Well said, Concerned Singh, I couldn't have said it better. These so called sants drive around in Mercedes and Safaris obviously the pound is stronger than the rupee, they loot the western innocent sikhs!!!

Re: Multiple IDs/Sant Bashing

((((:>>>> · 08 Jul 2005

sorry, but I think true respect would have been writing SHAHEED SANT JARNAIL SINGH BHINRAWALE Even more respect would have been accepting that 20 years ago!!!! Hari Singh wrote: > Baba Jorawar Singh, Baba Buddha jee, Baba Deep Singh, Bhai > Randhir Singh ... > > BUT you people are insisting on calling Baba Jarnail Singh,... > > SANT BABA JARNAIL SINGH JEE KHASLA BHINDRAWALE... > > You need to open your eyes. You people are so blind to what > true respect is.

Re: Multiple IDs/Sant Bashing

- · 08 Jul 2005

I cant belive JSGyani "Arshi" - You have the nearve to call yourself "Gyani" yet you show no respect for Sant Baba Gyani Jarnail Singh Khalsa - you call him simply "Jarnail Singh" how much ego do you have!?! its disgusting! Please have some respect, if you dont want to call Sant Ji a Sant, at least refer to him as Baba ji or Gyani ji!

Re: Multiple IDs/Sant Bashing

S Singh · 08 Jul 2005

JS Gyani has explained on more than one occassion why he uses the tag Gyani. I suggest you read up. Also about Shaheed Baba Jarnail Singh Ji. I suggest you listen to his speaches as on more than one occassion he tells people off for calling him a Sant. Is it not disrespect to disobey this ?

Re: Multiple IDs/Sant Bashing

singh · 08 Jul 2005

Gyani ji, some of the posters here seem to be suggesting that you use multiple IDs to post on this forum and one of those ID is Manjit Kaur Sidhu? This can not be true, is it! I remember you writing a while back that you only use your real name as oppose to some people who use aliases to conceal their identities.

Re: Multiple IDs/Sant Bashing

- · 08 Jul 2005

with respect S Singh, if Baba Takhur Singh Ji called him a sant, does that make him wrong too? I've heard many other gursikhs of the panth refer to him as a sant also.

Re: Multiple IDs/Sant Bashing

1 Singh · 08 Jul 2005

JS Gyani do you post under the name Manjit Kaur to back up your views?

Re: Multiple IDs/Sant Bashing

Hari Singh · 08 Jul 2005

Yes, Thakur Singh is wrong in calling Baba Jarnail Singh a sant.

Re: Multiple IDs/Sant Bashing

S Singh · 08 Jul 2005

author, I knew someone would bring up what Baba Takhur Singh Ji said, with respect I trust what Shaheed Baba Jarnail Singh Ji told us as far as it comes to his status and I accept him as Shaheed Baba Jarnail Singh Ji.

Re: Multiple IDs/Sant Bashing

Admin · 08 Jul 2005

Topic locked Admin