Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Raag

Raag

...... · 05 Jul 2005

We are supposed to follow Sri Guru Grant Sahib Ji Maharaaj word for word. We live by Guru Ji SO............ If Shabds in Gurbani are written in Raag.... is it not MANMAT to sing OUT of Raag.... For why has Guru Ji put Title Raag on Shabds Are we not challenging Guru Ji..... we're right..n Guru Ji ur wrong... dnt get me wrong iv herd sum beautiful keertan thats not raag.. n i feel if u truly sing a Shabd (non-raag) from heart u'v made it... Most people Know little about Raag and thats not their fault n Guru Ji knows.. but we do know NOW Shouldn't we atleast TRY to preserve the heritage of Gurmat sangeet (Raag Kirtan).. Guru Nanak Dev Ji always sang in Raag n NO matter how great a Spiritual being...NO ONE wil compare to Guru Nanak Dev Ji... was Guru Ji wrong..was Guru Arjan Dev ji & Guru Gobind Singh Ji wrong... Im not saying complete change over night but lets incorporate Raag b4 we completely loose it

Re: Raag

Raagi · 05 Jul 2005

Well, here we have something in common between the Sants and those who do not sing in Raag. I suppose thats why the normal Sant bashers are quiet and made no comments

Re: Raag

charanjeev singh · 05 Jul 2005

wahguruujikakhalsa waheguruujikifateh i absolutely agree that all keertan should be sung in the measures prescibed by Guru Sahib (Raag) waheguruujikakhalsa waheguruujikifateh

Re: Raag

Raagi · 06 Jul 2005

Some people have called Dharnas as Kachi Bani because it is not in Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji By the same token, should non-Raag be refered to as Kachi-Tarj (or Kachi-Tune) because it does not follow the tune or taal indicated in Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji.

Re: Raag

~~po punisher~~ · 06 Jul 2005

gurbani is about pyaar not musical measures, raag rass is manmat , amrit rass is gurmat and this is acheived through the words not the music

Re: Raag

Dandilion · 06 Jul 2005

<<<< gurbani is about pyaar not musical measures, raag rass is manmat >>>> so why did Guru Sahibs compose in Raag measures ??? There was a reason. The bani is enhanced when sung in the correct measure that it was written in.

Re: Raag

Gurus Son · 06 Jul 2005

Wjkk WJkf This is so right raag is Gurmat! Po punisher - if your one of my or MOWS lads u are wrong, if that was the case why did mahraj use these instruments and sing in raag, mahraj even got muslims to sing these raags, but why wat has raag got in der? Simple reason is that mahraj has a tune set for each raag meaning emotions for each raag, some are sad some are happy etc, this just gets us in to the shabad try it, it really works! The fact is our mahraj is all raag so no one can say nutin bad bout raag or mahraj will deal with u, BUT that does not mean raag is the only way no mahraj gave us the free will to do things that set us, but out of piyar! Some just bow there heads but others lie there whole body so wat is the difrence, just its out of piyar, piyar is the main thing in sikhi! With out nimrta - piyar u are not a tru gursikh! Now if u say bhai sahib didnt do raag or said dis and dat so wat, we wanna look at wat mahraj says! What do u no wat bhai sahib attentions were or wat eva. I think raag maala got sumit to do with this, I might be WRONG! Im just guessing I have a feeling people dont lyk raag, because of the raag mala. Im anti raag maala but I love raag - to a limit! pul chuk Maf Wjkk WJKf

Re: Raag

~~po punisher~~ · 06 Jul 2005

My dear bro's i didn't say raag was manmat what i said was" raag rass is manmat " the difference being peopel get all cauhgt up withthe soudn they hear they love the ding a ling a ling of the music and miss the beauty of the shabad

Re: Raag

...... · 06 Jul 2005

Who created the 'Saranda'..... Guru Arjan Dev Ji Maharaj (pls note this is different 2 Sarangi) Who created the 'Taus' from scratch... Guru Gobind Singh Ji our GREAT GURU JI's have given alot of status to Raag... plz lets not loose this heritage completely... sum say what is the need for Raag...let me elaborate if ur mum left a note on the fridge saying 'Clean Your Room'.. when you get to see it.. you may wonder is she saying it with love, anger, frustration, annoiyance etc..... each gives different implications.. with love you may do it tomorrow, with anger and you will do it straight away now the above note maybe written 2hrs prior to reading it... our Guru Ji's wrote Gurbani 400+ yrs ago... the language is completely different, we can loose the actual concept of the message, many interpretations come from one line..... Thats when Raag comes to play Raag is not only for singing Shabds BUT it will actually helps you better understand gurbani... the title Raag enables one to get a better feel by reading and understandind but most importantly via emotions... yes that leads us back to pyaar.. for pyaar is an emotion raag = emotions pyaar is an emotion im not here to say ppl who dnt sing in raag are wrong.. but lets not forget this vidya.. ppl learn gatka to not forget this art and to feel closer to Guru Ji... But remember "Kalyug meh keertan pardhana" - In this age of darkness(Kalyug), keertan is to be given precidence/importance... What better way to get the blessings of our Guru Ji's than to sing Shabds the way Guru Ji did... wen it comes to ppl sayin all you need it pyaar.. yeh your right.. but why did Guru ji deem it necessary to sing in Raag themselves.. are you telling me my Guru Ji had no pyaar... For no-one in history can come close to Guru Ji in, any aspect. Why do we wear Damala's, big Kara's, nice Kirpan's, have beautiful Dhari's because we want to imitate Guru Ji.. inorder to become closer to Guru ji.. we also learn gatka.. but keertan will always come first (look above paragraph) Did you know that sum with no prior experience of vaja can be on the stage in 2months but will require years to be at the same level with raag string instruments and vocal training.. hmmm... makes you think do people challenge Raag because it actually takes effort.. raag keertan is a slow progression, it takes great discipline just like the Khalsa lifestyle does.... DISCIPLINE IS OF KEY!!

Re: Raag

Raag Naad Sabh Sach Hai · 06 Jul 2005

sabhanaa raagaa(n) vich so bhalaa bhaaee jith vasiaa man aae || Among all Ragas, that one is sublime, O Siblings of Destiny, by which the Lord comes to abide in the mind. raag naadh sabh sach hai keemath kehee n jaae || Those Ragas which are in the Sound-current of the Naad are totally true; their value cannot be expressed. raagai naadhai baaharaa einee hukam n boojhiaa jaae || Those Ragas which are not in the Sound-current of the Naad - by these, the Lord's Will cannot be understood. naanak hukamai boojhai thinaa raas hoe sathigur thae sojhee paae || O Nanak, they alone are right, who understand the Will of the True Guru. sabh kishh this thae hoeiaa jio thisai dhee rajaae ||24|| Everything happens as He wills. ||24||. This Shabad is by Guru Amar Daas Ji in Siree Raag on Pannaa 83 raagaa vich sreeraag hai jae sach dhharae piaar || Among the ragas, Siree Raag is the best, if it inspires you to enshrine love for the True Lord. This Shabad is by Guru Raam Daas Ji in Raag Bilaaval on Pannaa 849 har outham har prabh gaaviaa kar naadh bilaaval raag || I sing of the sublime Lord, the Lord God, in the melody of Raag Bilaaval. '''''My dear bro's i didn't say raag was manmat what i said was" raag rass is manmat " the difference being peopel get all cauhgt up withthe soudn they hear they love the ding a ling a ling of the music and miss the beauty of the shabad''' I agree, we shud want to sing the raag after being affected by the shabad!!!

Re: Raag

Hari Singh · 06 Jul 2005

Is Gurbani lacking something which raag's make up for? I agree singing gurbani is amazingly uplifting but to say that raag's add something to bani doesn't make sense. Singing in simple tunes is just as good. Besides aren't some raags dependent on the time of the day, seasons etc... so now you can't do certain shabads during certain times of the day/year? bani won't be as effective in the summer as it is during the rainy season??? Bani contains naam that's why its bani. Raag's are just tools. keertan is pardhana and keertan can be sung banging together your handcuffs you don't have to be a mahir of the sarangi. And besides, Didn't guru arjun dev ji change the raag for asa kee vaar?? But gurmat sangeet as in use of stringed instruments, and doing keertan in raag is very nice and the art shouldn't be forgotten, we should preserve sikhi culture in this sense.

Re: Raag

/\ · 06 Jul 2005

"Singing in simple tunes is just as good." I don't understand. On one hand we stand up and say Guru Sahib gave us laridar and so it can't be changed and changing it is manmat. But on the other, we say it doesn't matter what raag Guru Sahib told us a shabad is in. No big deal. If it wasn't a big deal, why did Guru Sahib write a raag with the shabad? He could have easily just not have given one. (This is exactly the same argument as laridar). "Didn't guru arjun dev ji change the raag for asa kee vaar??" I'm not sure what you're referring to here? "doing keertan in raag is very nice and the art shouldn't be forgotten" I'm glad you agree. But even your own post shows lack of knowledge. A sarangi isn't a very common or usual main instrument in Gurmat sangeet. Singing in raag is gurmat. If someone doesn't know raag or is alone with no instruments then sure, handcuffs or anything else will do. But what's our excuse when we have the time and ability to learn and sing in the raag Guru Sahib gave?

Re: Raag

selfish · 06 Jul 2005

I do believe that Guru Sahib intended for us to recite bani in raags otherwise there is isn't any point in putting them in Guru Granth Sahib, if Guru ji wanted us to recite the way we want to (using manmatt) he wouldn't have associated raags to any bani......... I agree that gurmat keertan = raag keertan (as clasified in SGGS ji)

Re: Raag

Hari Singh · 06 Jul 2005

It must be nice living in your world where you pick and choose the sentence you want to respond to while ignoring the context. This is what I said. >>> Is Gurbani lacking something which raag's make up for? I agree singing gurbani is amazingly uplifting but to say that raag's add something to bani doesn't make sense. Singing in simple tunes is just as good. >>> So what I'm saying is that singing in simple tunes is just as good because it is the Gurbani which is imbued with naam not the music. Answer this question: Why doesn't Japji sahib have a raag? Is it somehow lacking? If I were to sing the salok in japji sahib after keertan.. am I then going against guru sahib's hukam because japji doesn't have a raag assigned to it? You say shabads can only be sung in raag that are assigned to it... so it would be wrong to sing the salok of japji sahib right because no raag was assigned.. And also please answer the question I posed before. "aren't some raags dependent on the time of the day, seasons etc... so now you can't do certain shabads during certain times of the day/year? bani won't be as effective in the summer as it is during the rainy season???" Extending your logic, because guru sahib has noted a certain raag for a certain bani means that we can't sing that bani at any other time besides the time that suits the raag. Meaning certain shabads can only be sung during the monsoon season. This is not right as per gurmat. >>> one hand we stand up and say Guru Sahib gave us laridar and so it can't be changed and changing it is manmat. But on the other, we say it doesn't matter what raag Guru Sahib told us a shabad is in. No big deal. >>> As far as I am able to tell, Raag's are used as a tool to sing gurbani. They do not actually make gurbani better or more effective. This is because all bani is one and some bani's don't have any raag assigned to it. >>> But even your own post shows lack of knowledge. A sarangi isn't a very common or usual main instrument in Gurmat sangeet. >>> I used sarangi as the example because the person who started this thread signed off as "Sarangi Singh".

Re: Raag

/\ · 06 Jul 2005

My world's ok. Japji Sahib doesn't have a raag because Guru Sahib didn't give it a raag. It was his choice. If you want to sing it, then who's stopping you? Guru Sahib didn't say to not sing it. There are no instructions. But where Guru Sahib gave a raag (clear instructions), isn't it a hukam to sing it in that way? Guru Sahib gave the raags where he wanted and it must have a reason. Or was Guru Sahib wasting his time when he carefully categorized the shabads according to raag? Was he bored when he wrote the exact taal and measure? You're beating around the bush. Bani can be sung at any time. But Guru Sahib has told us the way in which a shabad should be sung and when it should be sung. At Sri Darbar Sahib, this tradition of singing keertan at the right time is still practiced. In fact, even at Jatha programs, I've seen chardi kala Singhs get annoyed when an evening raag shabad is sung during Asa Ki Vaar. you wrote, "Extending your logic, because guru sahib has noted a certain raag for a certain bani means that we can't sing that bani at any other time besides the time that suits the raag. Meaning certain shabads can only be sung during the monsoon season. " See, again, you're talking out of ignorance of raag. There is no raag which is set ONLY for a season. Basant has a season, but it also has a time of day. Every raag has a time of day and some have an additional time of year as well, but the primary settting is time of day so it can be sung any time of the year. Is it so shocking that a shabad would have a time of the day? Don't we have set times to do our nitnem? We don't do Sohila Sahib early in the day to get our daily nitnem done with. We could do it at that time, and it wouldn't be 'wrong', but it has a set time. And did you ever notice that Rehraas Sahib and Sohila Sahib all use the appropriate raags for the times those bani are meant to be read? Doesn't that hint that raags have a meaning? Guru Sahib didn't mix and match the raags when composing a bani for a given time, so why should we? you wrote: "As far as I am able to tell, Raag's are used as a tool to sing gurbani. They do not actually make gurbani better or more effective. This is because all bani is one and some bani's don't have any raag assigned to it." As far as YOU are able to tell. But that's irrelevant isn't it? It's about Guru Sahib. How do you know for certain that the raag Guru Sahib wrote won't make the bani enter our consciousness easier? How do you know that Guru Sahib, being the greatest scientist, didn't write the bani for different times knowing that it will effect us more at the time he has written it for? As I said before, Guru Sahib clearly wasn't wasting his time categorizing all the shabads so carefully and even writing taals for them. Guru Sahib gave a raag with each shabad, so why wouldn't you sing it in that raag? Finally, "I used sarangi as the example because the person who started this thread signed off as "Sarangi Singh"." I can't find any Sarangi Singh in this thread. You still haven't told me how Guru Arjan changed the raag for Asa Ki Vaar? It was written Asa M: 1, so how is it changed?

Re: Raag

selfish · 06 Jul 2005

Music is not necessary to sing in raag

Re: Raag

...... · 06 Jul 2005

If Guru Dev Ji maharaj spent so much time assigning Raag to Shabds.... Who are we to challenge Guru Ji To challenge Guru Ji's hukam is manmat.. accepting Guru Ji's hukam is Gurmat

Re: Raag

manjit kaur · 06 Jul 2005

"And besides, Didn't guru arjun dev ji change the raag for asa kee vaar??" ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Hari singh I dont think you know what your talking about, Hence ASA ki vaar It means it has to be sung in ASA, no where is the raag changed, can you explain what your talking about? A vaar within a raag still uses the same musical scale for the prescribed raag, nothing is changed except the arrangement, A "vaar" or a "dhuni" is sung without repetition, ( without repeating a chorus like you would, when singing a shabad) , but again in the same scale.

Re: Raag

charanjeev singh · 06 Jul 2005

The Raags are absolutely intertwined with the Gurbaani. They cannot be seperated. If one is to say that the Raag is not important, then they should also agree that there is no need so sing the Gurbaani, but only need to recite it. Guru Sahib knows what the human body is made of, and Guru Sahib knows the depth of the Mann and everything else. Guru Sahib knows the Naad, and Guru Sahib knows why the Raag. We must do what the Guru says to enjoy the bliss that Guru Sahib wants us to have. The prescribed Raag is a must. bhul chuk mauf waheguruujikakhalsa waheguruujikifateh

Re: Raag

Raag Naad Sabh Sach Hai · 07 Jul 2005

asrajay ki dhuni is the composition of the raag, within each raag, there are various notes u have to use...and as u can imagine many dhunis can be created from those notes....and guru ji said to sing it in asrajay's dhuni

Re: Raag

Hari Singh · 07 Jul 2005

I must admit that I have a definite lack of knowledge when it comes to raag. So I ask the following questions: 1) Can a raag be played in different tunes? 2) If so then does guru sahib specify a tune as well? 3) If two different people can play the same raag in different ways then which one is right? But please consider what I've written carefully before replying because I think many of you have failed to understand my point. To say that Gurbani keertan isn't sampooran unless sung in raags seems wrong to me because their have been many many chardi kala walay gursikhs in the last century who did amazing keertan but not always in raag. Did they willingly not follow this rehit of guru sahib? Did guru sahib only give this sojhi to the few of you who are posting on this forum? Was the keertan done by Singhs not acceptable to guru sahib? I think not. Everyone keeps saying that because guru sahib has written a raag that it must be sung and it is wrong to sing in any other tune. But consider that guru sahib has also numbered the pauris. Guru sahib has also numbered the ashtpadi's has he not? Then our paath isn't acceptable to guru sahib unless we yell out numbers of the pauris as we're doing paath. By your logic the paath isn't complete. My understanding leads me to belive that raags were used as an organizational tool just as numbers of pauris and ashtpadi's. Just like it is noted which guru or bhagat has written the bani. As far as the "Sarangi Singh" issue... I confused two different threads. "Sarangi Singh" posted under another thread. My apologies for the confusion.

Re: Raag

/\ · 07 Jul 2005

Hari Singh, it seems like a case of "mai na manoo" to me. Firstly, a raag specifies a set of notes and there is some flexibility in how that can be applied, but the base of the raag stays the same. Tune can vary somewhat, but the "ingredients" if you were, remain the same. Guru Sahib has given the ingredients of the raag and how to play it. Your comparison between singing a raag specified by Guru Sahib and shouting out the Pauris is laughable and I think even you recognise how flawed that comparison is. The Pauri is a numbering system. It is not an instruction in any way. The Raag is an instruction on how to play the notes and with the Ghar, how to play the tabla. It is an instruction vs. a numbering system....where do you see the comparison? If the raags were only "organizational tools" then why did Guru Sahib bother giving ghars and specifying different sub-categories of the raag? Like Poorbee or Deepkee? What was the need if it was just organizational? Again, are you suggesting he was wasting his time taking such meticulous detail in writing the different raags and sub-raags? How do you know Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh didn't sing in raag? How do you know his tunes weren't based on the appropriate raags? In one of Bhai Sahib's books, he writes how he wasn't trained in raag, but once when a tabalchi who did know about this stuff came to play with him, he complimented Bhai Sahib on playing the shabads in the right raag and even the right time of day. So doesn't that suggest to you that Guru Sahib automatically gave this gift to Bhai Sahib knowing that it is important to recite the shabad in the right raag and right time of day? Bhai Sahib himself used to invite the father of Bhai Avtar Singh Ragi to listen to his keertan. He used to spend so much time in Darbar Sahib listening to keertan (then it was in proper raag). Raag is Gurmat. If a Singh does not know raag and wants to do keertan, then by all means he should sing as he knows. I won't say he's anti-Gurmat. But Raag is the right way to do it. To belittle Raag as an ordering system or unnecessary seems an insult to our Guru Sahib who took so much time on it and even created his own raags for Bani. I have heard from Singhs that to debate is not against Gurmat, but to then debate for debating's sake, knowing your points are invalid is definitely against Gurmat. I hope you're not doing the same.

Re: Raag

JSGyani "Arshi" · 07 Jul 2005

i was just listening to a katha and B hai harjinder Singh was saying Guur Ji listed 84 raags in raagmaala BECAUSE Guru ji wanted His sikhs to sing in OTHER raags besides the 31 written in Guru granth ji sahib...akheyh Guur Ji was worried other raagees would say..Guru Ji ONLY KNOWS 31 raags...so to "show" them that Guru Ji does indeed know many more...than just 31...... raagmala has 84 listed !!! THis Kathakaar readily encourages Sikhs to SING OUTSIDE the Raag stated by Guru Ji ( This "argument" is to justify the extra raaags in raagmaala) Since my "take" on Raags is ZERO... this is only a general comment and i request the veers to NOT draw it away from Raags to "raagmaaala". The raagmaala is just mentioned for the sake of explaining the extra raags and why they are used to justify singing OUT of RAAGS prescribed By Guru Ji. Thnaks in advance. Please do continue this excellent thread.

Re: Raag

Hari Singh · 08 Jul 2005

>>> Your comparison between singing a raag specified by Guru Sahib and shouting out the Pauris is laughable >>> I was simply highlighting the point that following guru's hukam doesn't mean we should discard common sense. >>> and I think even you recognise how flawed that comparison is. The Pauri is a numbering system. It is not an instruction in any way. The Raag is an instruction on how to play the notes and with the Ghar, how to play the tabla. It is an instruction vs. a numbering system....where do you see the comparison? >>> Your saying that raags are explicit instructions and by the same token I said that the numbering of pauri's etc. is also part of gurbani and who are you to reject it??? Guru sahib went through so much effort in organizing Sukhmani sahib with 24 ashtpadi's which further break down into 8 stanzas. How can you reject it when guru sahib is so consitent with this system throughout gurbani. Name one bani which doesn't have the numbering system but I can definitely give you banis which don't have a raaga assigned. Guru sahib is the greatest scientist and how do you know that by not shouting out the pauri numbers you aren't missing out on great laha? Are you so wise that you can decide what part of gurbani to read and what to reject? I think you should definitely yell out each pauri number because why would guru sahib go through so much effort of putting it there unless you were meant to read it??? hmm... >>> Again, are you suggesting he was wasting his time taking such meticulous detail in writing the different raags and sub-raags? >>> Are you suggesting guru sahib was wasting time writing in the pauri numbers? According to your logic then, your paath isn't complete unless your read the pauri numbers. >>> How do you know Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh didn't sing in raag? How do you know his tunes weren't based on the appropriate raags? >>> Well I personally know a tune which Bhai Sahib used to do on the shabad "har har naam apar amole" and Bhai Jeeven Singh has recorded many of Bhai SAhib's tunes and some of them aren't in raag as you claim. >>> In one of Bhai Sahib's books, he writes how he wasn't trained in raag, but once when a tabalchi who did know about this stuff came to play with him, he complimented Bhai Sahib on playing the shabads in the right raag and even the right time of day. >>> Your wrong. The story is as follows. Bhai SAhib was playing keertan and some ragi came who thought himself to be a master of raagas and Bhai Sahib knew of him coming and played Raag Basant (If I recall the story correctly) and the Tablachi who was playing with him was really good. Afterwards the ragi Singh complimented Bhai Sahib on playing such perfect raag and he even said that he didn't know Jatah Singhs could do raag so well and Bhai Sahib shrugged his shoulders and simply said he didn't even know he was playing raag. >>> So doesn't that suggest to you that Guru Sahib automatically gave this gift to Bhai Sahib knowing that it is important to recite the shabad in the right raag and right time of day? >>> I think Bhai SAhib knew very well which raag he was playing ... I think he just wanted to bring down the ragi Singh's ego down a notch. >>> Raag is Gurmat. If a Singh does not know raag and wants to do keertan, then by all means he should sing as he knows. I won't say he's anti-Gurmat. But Raag is the right way to do it. To belittle Raag as an ordering system or unnecessary seems an insult to our Guru Sahib who took so much time on it and even created his own raags for Bani. >>> To not yell out pauri numbers is to belittle gurbani because guru sahib spent so much time organizing bani by pauris' and ashtpadi's etc. >>> I have heard from Singhs that to debate is not against Gurmat, but to then debate for debating's sake, knowing your points are invalid is definitely against Gurmat. I hope you're not doing the same. >>> In making this statment you sound sure of yourself. You seem to have the opinion that guru sahib has blessed you with sojhi of gurmat and you are now doing the sangat a favour by telling us and we should accept you at your word. Not likely brother. Gurmat veechar not gurmat dictation is the key... You continously make the point that the raag's are instructions. That the shabad should be sang in the raag that guru sahib wrote. Well if the raag's are instructions than reading bani is wrong isn't it? Because if guru sahib has given a clear instruction by assigning raag's to shabads(meaning bani is to be sung), then according to your logic, it is against gurmat to even read bani as we don't read in raag. Infact this makes doing an akhand paath manmat...and anand sahib is never sung in raag during an amrit sanchar so now the amrit is lacking because anand sahib wasn't read in raag??? According to your logic if raag's are instructions then that means that everytime we simply read paath (nitnem) we are going against guru sahib's hukam because we don't sing the nitnem in raag. we simply read it and guru sahib's instruction, according to you, is to ONLY use the ASSIGNED RAAG for a shabad. Guru sahib hukams don't vary. meaning that if raag's were instructions then we could only ever sing bani and never simply read it. And there are no exceptions when it comes to hukam of guru. you do as ur told, always. This leads me to believe that keertan sang in tunes other then raag is parvan just as reading paath is parvaan. waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji kee fateh

Re: Raag

Hari Singh · 08 Jul 2005

I forgot to mention that Kulbir Singh mentioned on another post that When we do keertan for asa ki vaar the raag assigned is asa but then guru sahib goes on to say "tunday asraajay key dhuni" which is a dhadi reet (tune) and not a raag. This is the point I was trying to make jee.

Re: Raag

Rupinder Singh · 08 Jul 2005

WaheGuru Jee Ka Khalsa WaheGuru Jee Kee Fateh, >>>>"asa ki vaar the raag assigned is asa but then guru sahib goes on to say "tunday asraajay key dhuni" which is a dhadi reet (tune) and not a raag" Veerjeo, when Guru Sahib says something it is absolute, its just our meager minds that try to justify our short comings. "Tunday Asraajay Kee Dhuni" is a dhadi reet, but that reet is to be sung in Raag Asaa. We have all heard that dhuni, Where raagi's go "Whaa Whaa" during the Asaa di Vaar, that is Tunde Asraajay kee Dhuni. There are various other dhuni's in Guru Granth Saheb jee; e.g Mussa kee dhuni etc. They are all to be sung in the prescribed raags but in the instructed dhuni's. Unfortunately, we are loosing our heritage due to our short sightedness. We have every excuse in the world to over look the very important pillar of sikhi. WaheGuru Jee Ka Khalsa WaheGuru Jee Kee Fateh

Re: Raag

/\ · 08 Jul 2005

Hari Singh, you say: "I was simply highlighting the point that following guru's hukam doesn't mean we should discard common sense." So for you, it is common sense to read out pauri numbers? A raag can be sung, reading out the numbers doesn't make any sense. In the past, Singhs used to sing keertan in raags they were written. It is a fact. Have you ever heard of some Singhs reading out the pauri numbers as they did paath? You are being silly. Where Guru Sahib wanted us to read the numbers, he made it abundantly clear. How? If you look at Guru Granth Sahib, you'll see that in most places it says "Mahalaa 1" or some other number. As we don't normally read the numbers, maybe someone might not have read this. So to make sure these were read, Guru Sahib also wrote out "pehlaa" in a number of places like at the start of Sri Rag to show that the number has to be read. At other places where the total of shabads is to be read, it is not in numerical form, the total that is to be read out is in gurmukhi akhars, spelled out. Guru Sahib made it clear where to read the numbers and where not. Where they are to be read, they are spelled out. You say, "I think you should definitely yell out each pauri number because why would guru sahib go through so much effort of putting it there unless you were meant to read it??? " Since you have written this, if you wish to be called an honest person, I think you better be doing as you are saying. If my argument above has changed your mind, then you may of course see the error of your ways and stop. You claim Bhai Sahib had non-raag tunes. Do you recognise what raags are? I don't know what raag that tune is in. But do you know that all tunes are in a raag? I'm growing tired of your ignorance. Often when something is sung in the proper raag, most people don't even know it or notice it. Do you know what raag that tune is in? If not, why are you commenting on it? You wrote, "Well if the raag's are instructions than reading bani is wrong isn't it?" No. When you're reading bani, you're doing just that. Reading. When you're singing it, it's a different thing. This has been a tradition from the very start. Singhs in the past, used tantee saaj to sing in raag for sangat. When reading paath, they of course just read it. When singing the shabad, it is most appropriate to sing it in the raag Guru Sahib has assigned it. This has been a tradition in the Panth, to read bani but when singing in keertan to follow the raag. Regarding the story, you wrote: "Your wrong. The story is as follows. " No Hari Singh, you are wrong. Check the book Gurmat Lekh. A blind Tabla player came and started to play with the Singhs, and Bhai Sahib admits that none of them had raag training. The tabla player then says to Bhai Sahib that he sang Bilaval raag perfectly and at the right time of day and it was amazing. Bhai Sahib started to laugh because this tabla player was so amazed and thought the entire jatha was trained in raags. They were given the gift of keertan by Guru Sahib and how did Guru Sahib give it? In raag and that too at the right time of day. Check the book before commenting further. Raag was sung in the panth up to a century or so ago. Singhs in the past did so. This is not an attempt to start some new practice. If Guru Sahib has given a tune for a shabad, are you going to say "No Guru Sahib. I don't like the tune you gave, I'll make my own" Doesn't that seem like manmat to you? It's another if someone doesn't know the raag but feels like doing keertan. They should of course do so. But every Singh/Kaur who has the chance should learn raag because it's very important and hukam of Guru Sahib.

Re: Raag

/\ · 08 Jul 2005

I was also wondering if you could explain if a Sikh should consider the following hukams of Guru Sahib when singing the shabads or what? Doesn't seem like classification, but Guru Sahib telling his Sikh how to sing the shabad with very specific instructions: [gurbani]vwr mwJ kI qQw slok mhlw 1 mlk murId qQw cMdRhVw sohIAw kI DunI gwvxI ] [/gurbani] Now take this example: [gurbani]isrIrwgu kbIr jIau kw ] eyku suAwnu kY Gir gwvxw[/gurbani] This refers to the Shabad by Guru Nanak Dev jee in Sree Raag as well that begins, [gurbani]eyku suAwnu duie suAwnI nwil ] [/gurbani] or was Guru Sahib just "classifying" here too when he tells us to sing the same Ghar as "Pheray" shabads that come before this: [gurbani]sRIrwg bwxI Bgq byxI jIau kI ] phirAw kY Gir gwvxw ][/gurbani] The instructions at the top of a shabad still seem like classification now? Or does it more seem like Guru Sahib telling how to sing (hukam)?

Re: Raag

Hari Singh · 08 Jul 2005

I agree that the Khalsa tradition allows for us to read Gurbani, but then this begs the question, if we can read it without raag then why can't we sing it without raag? Because if bani with raag has more effect then why don't they sing anand sahib in raag during the amritsanchar, because like someone mentioned, raags can be done without instruments. Gurmat asools are the same in any situation you see. That's what sach is, something that doesn't change. And if it was truly guru sahib's hukam to sing in raag then reading bani would be outside the question. Because there are no compromises on such princples of gurmat. If raags are a hukam as you say then that would mean that bani is depdent on raags. Which can't be true, because bani is sach khandi where as raags are not. In anycase, you fail to see the point that I've been trying to make. It is not such a hard concept to grasp. Please think about it. If raags were a hukam as you say, then they'd be a part of gurbani. Meaning they wouldn't be tools, rather they'd be something gurbani is dependent on. I don't know how else to explain it. This is the best I can do. But I would be satisfied if you asked a puraatan singh if bhai sahib always did keertan in raag that was assigned to shabads. I think you'll have ur answer then. Ask bhai jeeven Singh. Consider this... is paath any less effective when done without raags if so then explain why panj don't do anand sahib in raag... thanks.

Re: Raag

/\ · 08 Jul 2005

You haven't addressed any of my points, so I'll number them. 1) Do you now see why your point about reading the numbers is not right. I have shown that when there is a number to be read, Guru Sahib has spelled it. Like when reading out the totals of shabads at the ends of certain sections. 2) Bhai Sahib and the Jatha weren't trained in raags, but according to Bhai Sahib himself in Gurmat Lekh, he was given the gift of raag and even had the [gurbani]ieSwrw[/gurbani] from Guru Sahib to sing it at the right time. So much so, that a trained ragi was amazed and thought the entire Jatha had been trained in raag, when it was not. So Guru Sahib himself thought it was important to give his Chardi Kala Singhs the gift of raag. 3) Guru Sahib couldn't have written the raags as just classification, because he put so much effort into identifying subcategories of raags and their Ghars. If raags were just classification, why did Guru Sahib make his own raags up? Why did he create entire raags? What was the need? In the post above I've even shown where Guru Sahib has given HUKAM to his Sikhs to sing the shabad in a certain way. Why? There is no explanation but that Guru Sahib expected and wanted his Sikhs to sing in raag. You haven't given me any explanation why Guru Sahib would have said [gurbani]"gwvxw"[/gurbani]. This word is a hukam/order. It is a command. NOt a suggestion, but a COMMAND. Explain why? Seeing all this information, justify now your belief that raags are just classification systems. Please do address this point before moving on further. 4) I have explained the difference between personal paath and keertan. There is a world of difference between the two. When doing keertan, we repeat a verse as the chorus over and over. We do not do paath like this. We sing keertan with instruments. Paath is not done like this. When doing keertan, Guru Sahib expects us to use the raag he has written. When doing paath, it is a completely different situation. To corroborate this, Singhs in the past used to sing in raag and read paath. I am not advocating starting something new, but a return to puraatan ways. Follow what old Singhs did. Paath can be read and has always been read. In the past, keertan was done in raag. Follow the old example. It's not a question of "asools". You yourself are putting this limitation that it's either always sung in raag or its not necessary. You yourself are putting your black/white standard and then judging using this standard. I'm saying look at what was done in puraatan times and repeat it. What's so hard to understand about that? Singhs in the past used only raag for keertan. They read paath. Copy that. Don't complicate the issue with false dillemmas. To say that gurbani is just as parvaan out of raag has some merit. Gurbani is always parvaan. You can't stop that. But if we take your argument further, is it parvaan when it is sung in Filmy tunes? It's still bani right? Yeah, but it's not as effective. You wrote: "If raags are a hukam as you say then that would mean that bani is depdent on raags. Which can't be true, because bani is sach khandi where as raags are not." Bani is not dependent on raags. But these raags are what help make it reside in our consciousness. These raags were tools given to us just like kakaars and other rehits. They are important tools that make the bani have more of an impact on us. Furthermore, these raags ARE sachkhandi! Vahguru Akaal Purakh sent Guru Sahib this bani in these raags. These raags were sent specfically with each shabad by Vahiguru. They are certainly sachkhandi. Why are you insulting these raags sent by Vaheguru so badly? Guru Ram Das tells us that these raags of Gurbani are SACH because they contain truth. [gurbani] sBnw rwgW ivic so Blw BweI ijqu visAw min Awie ] rwgu nwdu sBu scu hY kImiq khI n jwie ] rwgY nwdY bwhrw ienI hukmu n bUiJAw jwie ] nwnk hukmY bUJY iqnw rwis hoie siqgur qy soJI pwie ] sBu ikCu iqs qy hoieAw ijau iqsY dI rjwie ]24] [/gurbani] Guru Sahib wrote a raag. Vaheguru sent that raag himself. So ignoring that is it justified to make our own tune? Are we smarter than Guru Sahib? I'm not saying that people that don't raag should never do keertan. I'm saying that learning these raags shouldn't be optional, but a must. It is Gurmat. I think it is a rehit even. Before you move on to post anything else, I ask that you reply to my questions in this post. If you cannot answer them, then its time to move on and let the sangat decide which view is correct.

Re: Raag

singh · 08 Jul 2005

I completely agree with "/", I have been folowing this discussion for a few days now. I would aslo like to say hari singh seem to be a moorakh to the truth why are you being so ignorant, you just basicialy said that everything in our present Guru is not sachkhandi, i think you really need to go for pesh. Hari singh you seem like onee of thosee R.S.S guys just out to mess sikhi up. How dare you question guru sahib!!!

Re: Raag

Manjit kaur · 08 Jul 2005

Dear "/" ji "I'm not saying that people that don't raag should never do keertan. I'm saying that learning these raags shouldn't be optional, but a must. It is Gurmat. I think it is a rehit even." ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------- You are completely right, take for an example of a Gursikh who doesn't keep sabrbloh and eats in steel, for whatever reason he hasn't kept sarbloh yet, now does that mean he should stop eating! (haha). Of course not, eating is a must. But when it comes to Gurmat that Gursikh should strive to keep sarbloh, because it is guru jis's matt. And the same thing with keertan, a gursikh should'nt simply stop dooing keertan because he doesn't know Gurmat sangeet. But again definitely means he should strive to learn Gurmatt sangeet, If he had the time to learn other sangeet, why not take a little more time and learn Gurus way. Guru sahib ney mor laathee kay keertan Raagan dhay vich honna zaroori hai, Thodee point fail ah Hair singh.........

Re: Raag

rsingh · 09 Jul 2005

Waheguroo Jee Ka Khalsa! Waheguroo Jee Kee Fateh!! http://panthic.org/news/124/ARTICLE/1238/2005-04-17.html Raj Academy UK presents the first ever educational camp targeting Sikh music and the tradition of Gurmat Kirtan Join us for a weekend of insightful lectures and workshops aiming to help you understand how to play stringed instruments and establish the missing link of title raag and Shabads in true Gurmat Sangeet tradition. The camp is will focus on original styles of singing with traditional Sikh instruments such as Dilruba, Sarangi, Saranda and Taus etc Structure: 3 Shabads of Rag Asa and Bilawal in traditional styles. Along side the Basic training in handling and playing chosen instrument. The structure of the camp has been designed in a unique way to provide each student with their own personal mentor who will guide them throughout the camp. There are over 50 members of teaching staff specially trained in the instruments stated, who are on hand and ready to provide assistance to students as and when required. Each mentor is responsible for two applicants according to the vocal and instrumental speciality. Lectures: The camp will be structured in the form of music workshops, practice sessions and a series of lectures held in aim to provide a historical background to the fundamentals of Kirtan. Lectures will be held on basics of music, vanishing traditions, Gurus’ instruments, and making your own music. By the end of the camp, you will have a thorough understanding of the origins of Sikh music and the ways in which you can revive it today, and you will have the opportunity to carry on your study of this art by continuing classes and keeping in touch with your teachers. The camp aims to provide an outlet for you to express yourselves and learn how to reap the benefits that Sikh music can offer. Lunch and afternoon tea will be provided. Date: 29, 30, 31 July Time: 9am-5pm (Registration 9am) Venue: Dominion Arts Centre, The Green Southall, Middlesex UK Limited spaces of 100 applicants: Ages 8-14 (15 seats), 14-19 (50 seats) and 19+ (35 Seats). Entry requirements - £30 including instrument training, refreshments and full information packs. (No accommodation provided however assistance can be given for applicants travelling from afar). To apply, fill out registration form online at www.rajacademy.com Payment – cheques payable to Raj Academy of Asian Music including a Stamped addressed envelope Contact: Visit www.rajacademy.com Waheguroo Jee Ka Khalsa! Waheguroo Jee Kee Fateh!! http://forums.waheguroo.com/index.php?showtopic=11617&pid=100283&st=0&#entry100283 [img]http://forums.waheguroo.com/index.php?act=Attach&type=post&id=1347[/img]

Re: Raag

Sharan Kaur · 09 Jul 2005

Arshee jee, for once understand that............RAGMALA IS NOT GURBANEE!!!!!!

Re: Raag

Manjit kaur · 11 Jul 2005

Hari singh we still haven't heard from you, and we would definitely like to hear from bhai kulbir singh on this subject

Re: Raag

ssinghuk · 11 Jul 2005

<> SRI RAAGMALA IS BANI!!!!!!!!!

Re: Raag

Hari Singh · 11 Jul 2005

been busy... will now repond to earlier queries. >>> 1) Do you now see why your point about reading the numbers is not right. I have shown that when there is a number to be read, Guru Sahib has spelled it. Like when reading out the totals of shabads at the ends of certain sections. >>> My point was simply that we shouldn't take everything too literally. I'll explalin later when I explain why raags aren't from sach khand. >>> 2) Bhai Sahib and the Jatha weren't trained in raags, but according to Bhai Sahib himself in Gurmat Lekh, he was given the gift of raag and even had the ieSwrw from Guru Sahib to sing it at the right time. So much so, that a trained ragi was amazed and thought the entire Jatha had been trained in raag, when it was not. So Guru Sahib himself thought it was important to give his Chardi Kala Singhs the gift of raag. >>> Many non-Sikhs, who are drunks etc. etc. also do amazing raags. >>> 3) Guru Sahib couldn't have written the raags as just classification, because he put so much effort into identifying subcategories of raags and their Ghars. >>> This doesn't prove anything. If it truly was dhur it bani, their would have been no effort required for categorizing etc. because it would have flowed from sach khand in the exact order. For example Guru ARjun Dev Jee felt no need to rearrange Japji sahib did he? >>> If raags were just classification, why did Guru Sahib make his own raags up? Why did he create entire raags? What was the need? >>> Because music is wonderful and there is nothing like keertan. Guru sahib gave us a wonderful gift by doing this. >>> In the post above I've even shown where Guru Sahib has given HUKAM to his Sikhs to sing the shabad in a certain way. Why? There is no explanation but that Guru Sahib expected and wanted his Sikhs to sing in raag. You haven't given me any explanation why Guru Sahib would have said "gwvxw". >>> Then why give the hukam for only once shabad and even then not in the beginning of the Guru Granth Sahib. >>> Seeing all this information, justify now your belief that raags are just classification systems. Please do address this point before moving on further. >>> Well Guru Granth Sahib jee is organized by raags. no? >>> 4) I have explained the difference between personal paath and keertan. There is a world of difference between the two. >>> Well, you are right ofcourse. But you fail to understand my point but it will be clear later on when I give my reasoning as to why raags are not from sach khand. >>> Bani is not dependent on raags. But these raags are what help make it reside in our consciousness. These raags were tools given to us just like kakaars and other rehits. They are important tools that make the bani have more of an impact on us. >>> I agree that doing keertan helps bani reside in our consciousness. Although not just raag keertan. >>> Furthermore, these raags ARE sachkhandi! Vahguru Akaal Purakh sent Guru Sahib this bani in these raags. These raags were sent specfically with each shabad by Vahiguru. They are certainly sachkhandi. Why are you insulting these raags sent by Vaheguru so badly? Guru Ram Das tells us that these raags of Gurbani are SACH because they contain truth. >>> This I believe is totally wrong. Bani is sach khandi because it contains naam. Doing Gurbani paath gives us shakti to do naam simran. Even if you were to repeat one pankti over and over again (b/c that's all you had memorized) it would give you shakti to do more simran. IF raags are from sach khand, then my brother, only listening to raags should give us shakti to do naam simran. And belive me when I tell you that you can listen to raags all day and it won't instill naam inside of you. It is the gurbani that has the shakti. "Which bani amrit saray" "bani guru guru hai bani" In the book, lagan matran, Bhai Sahib has done arth (meaning) of the shabad you used, and he says that in this pankti when guru sahib says, raag naad, he means naam. Because only naam and bani truly fit the description of "keemat kahe na jaiee". I will make an effort to translate what bhai sahib has said and post it at a later time. Coming back to raags. The crux of your argument is that raags are from sach khand. But I think I've proved how they're not, but are tools. However, to take the point further, think of this: When different people play raags, do they not vary from person to person. Who is correct, b/c bani is one, naam is one, and if something is from sach khand, it can't change depending on the perspective of person. Now before you go on and start talking about larivaar saroop and how reading from guru mahajraj is dependent on a person's understanding, well keep in mind that gurbani has viakaran (grammar), meaning there is only one meaning to gurbani. Though bani is endless. But the same can not be said for raags. How do you know how guru sahib wants the raags to be played, if the music is so important, how do you know how to play and what to play? Because as you said before, "it can vary somewhat". looking forward to your response. I haven't enjoyed a debate so much in a long time. I'll try to be more articulate in my posts, before I was just writing away without much thought.

Re: Raag

* · 11 Jul 2005

Hari Singh Jee, the point at the end of your post about how a single raag can vary so much is totally off and while you've made that same point before, with all due respect, it only shows that you don't know what you're talking about. A single raag could have a million variations and they can all be 100% correct as long as you stay within the constraints of the raag. The constraints of a raag are defined by the Aroh, Avrohi and Pakar which tell you the exact structure and flow/chaal of the raag. A raag isn't just drawn out of thin air. Each one has specific rules defining it and its use, and even specific notes (Vadhi/Samvadhi) which tell you what notes must be prevalent or held longer than the others in the tune. Every raag also has specific notes which indicate what time of day the raag is to be sung, and certain notes become increasingly prevalent as the day passes. Despite all these rules and aspects defining each raag, you can still create any number of variations to a single raag. Take any raag and it's easy to come up with various tunes which are all still 100% pure in the raag's formation. Think of paRtaal shabads -- shabads where Guru Sahib has specified the use of different taals. Each line will be in a different taal (beat cycle) and thus, the tune for each line will be different. Despite the difference in tunes however, the entire shabad should still be in the correct raag, regardless of the different tunes and even different taals. There are many many aspects of raags which you don't seem to be aware of, but if you were to take a moment to read up on the structure of raags, you'd see that most of your points are completely invalid and you're not giving raags nearly as much appreciation as they deserve. A raag isn't just a title given to a tune. It has numerous aspects and rules attached which make a raag all that it is. Using all the rules of flow and structure assigned to a raag, you could create any number of bandishes/tunes and they can all be 100% correct and 100% in the right raag. Guru Sahib wants the raag played as per the rules of that raag. You know how to play and what to play because each raag has a set of instructions that must be followed like a recipe.

Re: Raag

/\ · 11 Jul 2005

You wrote: “Many non-Sikhs, who are drunks etc. etc. also do amazing raags.” How does this refute my point at all? I said that Guru Sahib described his ability to do keertan as a gift from Vaheguru. Vaheguru gave this gift in raag and at the right time. Read the lekh for crying out loud! Your point makes no sense and is neither here nor there. The raags are sachkhandi because the Gurus heard these raags and were given these raags from sachkhand. These are the raags that are there as well. As Guru Sahib heard them, he wrote them down. Something that comes from Sachkhand, is therefore Sachkhandi. Or will you now argue that no, Guru Sahib didn’t here these raags from Sachkhand and that part of bani is made up? Like I asked before, was Guru Sahib just wasting his time writing down Ghars and tunes and different subcategories? You continue to highlight your woeful ignorance of raags when you say: “When different people play raags, do they not vary from person to person?” I already told you, that the ingredients of the raag ie. Notes do not vary. How someone works with those notes can. The raag does not change. If you don't understand what I'm saying, its due to your utter ignorance on this subject. The raag doesn't change from person to person. You said in regards to my question whether the raags were just classification tools like you said before:, “Well Guru Granth Sahib jee is organized by raags. no?” That doesn’t make them JUST classification tools. Otherwise there was no need for Ghars or subcategories. And no need to make new raags. Finally, you still haven’t explained why Guru Sahib would give such specific orders as “Gavana” for some shabads? Do they still have the option to be sung in some other way? Overall this “debate” seems finished to me. Your post contained no real points or information. You insist on claiming that the raags Guru Sahib made a point of putting in Guru Granth Sahib are minor details and not that important. You have no points and won’t refute mine. I don’t think this debate can continue any further.

Re: Raag

manjit kaur · 11 Jul 2005

Hari singh take this bani in to factor: This Shabad is by Guru Arjan Dev Ji in Raag Raamkalee on Pannaa 958 dhha(n)n so raag sura(n)garrae aalaapath sabh thikh jaae || This Shabad is by Guru Arjan Dev Ji in Raag Bilaaval on Pannaa 821 gun govi(n)dh gaavahu sabh har jan raag rathan rasanaa aalaap ||

Re: Raag

Amardeep Singh · 11 Jul 2005

Understanding the Musical Framework of Guru Granth Sahib "What does Guru Granth Sahib, our eternal Guru command us on the subject of Keertan?" "Why is it that the Gurus chose raags to classify Gurbani?" "What is the relation between Shabad and raag?" "Do we need the aid of experimental music to propagate the message of Guru Granth Sahib?" "Have our Keertanias experimented with the vastness of raags and taals as prescribed by Gurus?" "What impact will experimentation have on our future generations?" Keertan today has been commercialized to such an extent that barring a few, most Keertanias are only concerned with making quick money. Their limitations to experiment with the prescribed vastness of Guru Granth Sahib always gets camouflaged in the excuse that the Sangat does not prefer to listen to Keertan as prescribed by the Gurus. Gurus wrote Shabads in poetical- metric forms and then associated them with raags and ghars (beats/taals). Does this mean that Gurus have left no scope for experimentation with music? The indication of raag and ghar (beat) with every Shabad implies that Gurus had a definite motive behind fixing a framework. This framework was not set to limit the ability of the human mind to experiment with music but to act as an aid in spiritual development. A simple mathematical permutation and combination on notes of any raag will indicate that each raag offers thousands of tunes to experiment with. Poetry (the form in which Gurbani is written) and music (raags) are two sides of the same coin. They are independent but yet complement each other. Music versifies and provides melody, uniformity and cadence to poetry. The factor that binds music and poetry is their metrical- form (ghar or beat). Music (Raag) is based on sound (swar - notes) and a combination of notes produce distinct musical effects. Poetry is determined by Word (Shabad), which communicates a message. Music (Raag) on the other hand conveys a feeling to the heart and is therefore universal. Spirituality, after all, is striking the right balance between mind and heart. Therefore, when Gurbani (poetry) is complemented with raag (music) and bound by ghar (beat), the resulting effect on mind and body can become the catalyst for change. As explained earlier, raag conveys a feeling and Shabad a message. A raag is capable of touching the heart with feelings like joy, sorrow, detachment, etc. Upon studying the structure of Guru Granth Sahib it can be seen that Shabads relating to common themes are generally placed under each raag. When the broad themes of Shabads are overlaid with feelings conveyed by raags, there emerges a reason behind classification of Shabads under a broad classification of thirty-one raags. Common Themes of Shabads placed under Raags of Guru Granth Sahib 1. Soohi - Being away from home. The soul being away from the House of Lord and the joy of meeting the true husband. 2. Bilaaval - beautification of soul, happiness. 3. Gaund - Separation, union, surprise. 4. Sri - Maya and detachment 5. Maajh - yearning to merge with Lord, giving up of negative values. 6. Gauri - Principles, serious, thoughtfulness, composed 7. Aasa - Hope 8. Gujri - Prayer (Pooja) 9. Devgandhari - Merging with spouse, self - realization 10. Bihaagra - Yearning due to separation of soul and happiness due to meeting the Lord. 11. Sorath - Merits of God 12. Dhanasari - Mixed theme 13. Jaitsree - Stability 14. Todi - Maya, separation 15. Bairagi - motivation to sing praises of Lord 16. Tilang - many words from the vocabulary of Islamic origins are used, sadness, beautification. 17. Raamkali - to give up the life of a wandering Jogi. 18. Nat Narayan - Joy of meeting the Lord 19. Maali Gaura - Happiness 20. Maaru - Bravery 21. Tukhari - Separation and union with Lord 22. Kedara - Love 23. Bhairav - Man's state of hell 24. Basant - Happiness 25. Sarang - Thirst to meet God 26. Malaar - State of separated and united soul 27. Jaijawanti - Vairaag (Detachment) 28. Kalyaan - Bhakti (Prayer) Ras 29. Vadhans - Vairaag (Detachment) 30. Parbhati - Bhakti (Prayer) 31. Kaanra - Bhakti (Prayer) Feelings communicated by the music of Raags 1. Soohi - joy and separation 2. Bilaaval - happiness 3. Gaund - strangeness, surprise, beauty 4. Sri - satisfaction and balance 5. Maajh - loss, beautification 6. Gauri - seriousness 7. Aasa - making effort 8. Gujri - satisfaction, softness of heart, sadness 9. Devgandhari - no specific feeling but the Raag has a softness 10. Bihaagra - beautification 11. Sorath - motivation 12. Dhanasari - inspiration, motivation 13. Jaitsree - softness, satisfaction, sadness 14, Todi - this being a flexible Raag it is apt for communicating many feelings 15. Bhairaagi - sadness, (Gurus have, however, used it for the message of Bhakti) 16. Tilang - this is a favourite Raag of Muslims. It denotes feeling of beautification and yearning. 17. Raamkali - calmness 18. Nat Narayan - happiness 19. Maali Gaura - happiness 20. Maaru - giving up of cowardice 21. Tukhari - beautification 22. Kedara - love and beautification 23. Bhairav - seriousness, brings stability of mind 24. Basant - happiness 25. Sarang - sadness 26. Malaar - separation 27. Jaijawanti - viraag 28. Kalyaan - Bhakti Ras 29. Vadhans - vairaag, loss (that is why Alahniya is sung in this Raag when someone passes away) 30. Parbhati - Bhakti and seriousness 31. Kaanra - Bhakti and seriousness It's clear that the Gurus used raags to increase the delivery power of shabad to our mind by invoking complementary feelings in our hearts through the usage of the prescribed raags. Another interesting aspect of raag and Gurbani classification is understood by studying daily time-cycles. A raag has a preferred timing associated with it. There are some morning raags, evening raags, afternoon raags, etc. The human mind and heart also undergo varying degrees of mood change during a twenty-four hour time cycle. Upon classification of thirty-one main raags used in Guru Granth Sahib based on the prescribed raag timings, we find that no raags fall under the time zone 12 AM - 3 AM. Normally one would sleep between 10PM - 4AM. Timings of Raags 6 AM - 9AM: Bhairaagi, Devgandhari 9 AM - 12 PM: Saarang, Suhi, Bilaaval, Gujri, Gond, Todi 12 PM - 3 PM: Vadhans, Maru, Dhanasari 3 PM - 6 PM: Maanjh, Gauri, Tilang, Tukhari 6 PM - 9 PM: Sri, Basant, Maali Gaura, Jaitsree, Kedara, Kalyaan 9 PM - 12 AM: Bihaagra, Nat Narayan, Sorath, Malaar, Kaanra, Jaijawanti 12 AM - 3 AM: --------No Raags from Guru Granth Sahib--------- 3AM - 6AM: Aasa, Raamkali, Bhairav, Parbhati Some raags also have seasons associated with them as seasons also denote feelings. Seasonality of Raags 1. Basant raag can be sung at any time in Basant season. Shabads with the theme of happiness are clustered under this raag in Guru Granth Sahib. 2. Malaar raag can be sung at any time in the rainy season. Shabads with the theme of separation are clustered under this raag in Guru Granth Sahib. The Gurus have also indicated the beats associated with the poetry of every Shabad. In Guru Granth Sahib seventeen ghars (taal - beat) are mentioned. These seventeen ghars denote the following beats: GHAR 1 - DADRA TAAL (There are 1 Taalis and the Beat has 6 Maatraas) GHAR 2 - RUPAK TAAL (There are 2 Taalis and the Beat has 7 Maatraas) GHAR 3 - TEEN TAAL (There 3 Taalis and the Beat has 16 Maatraas) GHAR 4 - CHAAR TAAL (There are 4 Taalis and the Beat has 12 Maatraas) GHAR 5 - PUNJ TAAL (There are 5 Taalis and the Beat has 15 Maatraas) GHAR 6 - KHUT TAAL (There are 6 Taalis and the Beat has 18 Maatraas) GHAR 7 - MUT TAAL (There are 7 Taalis and the Beat has 21 Maatraas) GHAR 8 - ASHT MANGAL TAAL (There are 8 Taalis and the Beat has 22 Maatraas) GHAR 9 - MOHINI TAAL (There are 9 Taalis and the Beat has 23 Maatraas) GHAR 10 - BRAHAM TAAL (There are 10 Taalis and the Beat has 28 Maatraas) GHAR 11 - RUDRA TAAL (There are 11 Taalis and the Beat has 32 Maatraas) GHAR 12 - VISHNU TAAL (There are 12 Taalis and the Beat has 36 Maatraas) GHAR 13 - MUCHKUND TAAL (There are 13 Taalis and the Beat has 34 Maatraas) GHAR 14 - MAHASHANI TAAL (There are 14 Taalis and the Beat has 42 Maatraas) GHAR 15 - MISHR BARAN TAAL (There are 15 Taalis and the Beat has 47 Maatraas) GHAR 16 - KUL TAAL (There are 16 Taalis and the Beat has 42 Maatraas) GHAR 17 - CHRCHARI TAAL (There are 17 Taalis and the Beat has 40 Maatraas) Within the rules of Indian Classical Music, uncountable raags can be created. In fact any form of music (non-Indian and non-classical) can be classified under some form of raag. Hence it is a misconception that raags are something highly classical and beyond the realm of the common man's understanding. In fact, any form of music is raag. But in Guru Granth Sahib, the Gurus have gone into depths of poetry, music and metrical forms to lay the framework that is best suited to convey the feeling and message of the Shabad simultaneously to the human mind and heart. When each of the prescribed raags offers uncountable permutations and combinations of musical compositions, then why is it that modern Keertanias are not experimenting within the prescribed framework of the Gurus?

Re: Raag

manjit kaur · 12 Jul 2005

Hari singh, do you agree with this: Take for an example of a Gursikh who doesn't keep sabrbloh and eats in steel, for whatever reason he hasn't kept sarbloh yet, now does that mean he should stop eating!. Of course not, eating is a must. But when it comes to Gurmat that Gursikh should strive to keep sarbloh, because it is guru jis's matt. And the same thing with keertan, a gursikh should'nt simply stop dooing keertan because he doesn't know Gurmat sangeet. But again definitely means he should strive to learn Gurmatt sangeet, If he had the time to learn other sangeet, why not take a little more time and learn Gurus way.

Re: Raag

Kulbir Singh · 12 Jul 2005

Someone gave me hukam to express my views on this issue. In my opinion, baani written in a certain Raag means that originally Guru Sahib sang that shabad in that Raag but it does not mean that all shabads classified in a certain Raag have to be sung in that Raag only. A perfect example of this is Siri Asa kee Vaar. This Vaar was originally sung in Raag Asa but as per hukam of Siri Guru Arjun Dev jee, this Vaar should be sung in “Tunday Assraajay kee Dhuni”. This Dhuni is certainly not in Raag Asa i.e. the Aaroh, Avroh and especially the pakaR of this dhuni is certainly not in Raag Asa. The dhuni of Asraaj is similar to Dhaadee tunes. So this proves that we don’t have to sing all shabads in Raags only. They should be sung but they don’t have to be sung only in the 31 Raags of Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee. No Raagi does that. I have never heard of any Raagi, who has not sung any other Raag, other than the 31 Raags of Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee. Raag is good. It is melodious but by the same token, I have not heard Rang Ratiya kirtan by a classical singer. If there is any, please do inform. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Raag

/\ · 12 Jul 2005

Kulbir Singh, it's already been discussed that Asa Kee Vaar although sung in Tunday As Rajay Kee Dhuni, is still Raag Asaa. As for "Rang Ratiya kirtan by a classical singer", I'm not sure where you've been looking or what qualities you look for to make it "rang ratiya". But just because you haven't seen it, doesn't mean it doesn't exist and God forbid, that they can't exist at the same time together.

Re: Raag

manjit kaur · 13 Jul 2005

Hari Singh Said, >>> If raags were just classification, why did Guru Sahib make his own raags up? Why did he create entire raags? What was the need? >>> Because music is wonderful and there is nothing like keertan. Guru sahib gave us a wonderful gift by doing this. -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- If Guru sahib composed the raags, Doesnt that mean they are from sachkhand, think about it.......? In the book, lagan matran, Bhai Sahib has done arth (meaning) of the shabad you used, and he says that in this pankti when guru sahib says, raag naad, he means naam. Because only naam and bani truly fit the description of "keemat kahe na jaiee". I will make an effort to translate what bhai sahib has said and post it at a later time. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Can you please translate?, Im very keen to hear this

Re: Raag

fool · 13 Jul 2005

i have been reading this post over the last hour and looking at everyones views. i think that discussions like this should be encouraged. however one i thing i do not agree with is the way you are saying to hari singh that he is a moorakh and does not know what he is talking about. knowledge is my opinion is a vidhya. just because hari singh says something you do not believe in i dont think that should reduce him to a moorakh. use your knowledge to show other people that something he is saying is wrong dont just resort to name calling. another point i would like to make is that i was told that guru ji wrote the raag based on how he felt at the time. no one on earth is as high as guru ji so how can we feel the same thing guru ji felt? i am not discouraging raag i happen to enjoy listening to raag but i think that raag is not as necessary in sikhi as gettin naam ras out of bani and naam simran. so if someone happens to be getting this ras out of kirtan not sung in raag then let them i dont think they should be stopped because they arent singing in raag. if you however do get ras out of raag then i am pleased for you it is something to be encouraged. bhul chuk maaf this is the first time ive written on this site and i hope i havnt offended anyone with my point of view

Re: Raag

concerned sikh · 13 Jul 2005

Sardar Kulbir Singh ji, merely stating the fact that your opinion is that guru sahib only mentioned the raag in which guru sahib had just sung the baani seems quite insufficient. Why didn't guru sahib note the time, date and location where he sung the baani? This arguement is quite rubbish. It's so black and white. We have ppl who are totally for raag and those who are against it. Why are we not understanding liberalism? Just sing the raags they're written in, for heaven sakes. If you don't know how then sing in tunes. Maryada at Harmandar Sahib used to be, to first have the Shaan or Layraa, followed by Alaap, dandot and then a vaday taal the shabad in gurmat sangeet bandash, after that it's whatever as long as you end in pauree (the grand finale). We're so caught up to adhere to the ideals of what our "sect" thinks (payd chaal) ie, I'm Akj so I don't think Raagmaalaa is bani or I'm taksaali therefore Baba Jarnail Singh Ji's alive. Let's examine Gursikhi. Raags are there for us to learn and sing, sing it, Baani is there to read, read it. Waheguru JI Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh

Re: Raag

/\ · 13 Jul 2005

Concerned Singh, To be clear, I am a Jatha Singh, and go to AKJ programs and believe in that rehit. I don't think your comment is correct.

Re: Raag

Hari Singh · 13 Jul 2005

The point of the tunday ass rajay kee dhunee... It is written that tunday ass rajay kee dhunee is clearly a dhadee vaar, thus meaning that it was sung for vaars by dhadee's. I would assume that dhadee's made the tune up. But if you belive that all musical measured in bani are from sach khand then the dhadee vaar is also from sach khand. Meaning that someone aside from the guru's had access to sach khand. Also, raags existed before guru sahib, then how do explain that? BTW, I have nothing against raags, and truly belive that Gurmat Sangeet is something to be preserved. But I also belive that saying that keertan other then raag keertan is a dhil in rehit is wrong. I still don't feel that raags are from sach khand as per my reasoning that raags alone (music) can't help you jap naam. where as reading bani alone can. and before someone says that rehit helps jap naam... well my reasoning is quite simple, guru sahib gave us outer and many inner rehits as a direct order, then why not give us order for raags. meaning rehits about adultery, eating meat, tobacco, cutting hair are easily deduced from bani, but are also told in amrit sanchar... then why not rehit for raag keertan??? When I first started reading the thread, I must admit that I was vary that this might be some twisted way of trying to prove raag mala is bani by saying that raag's are from sach khand. since this is not the case, i will say that in spirit of perserving gurmat sangeet, we should all make an effort to learn raags. waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji kee fateh

Re: Raag

charanjeev singh · 13 Jul 2005

Dear Hari Singh, this is not gurmat sangeet, this is Guru's Baani, this is keertan, this is maryada. 'Logh Janai Eh Geet Hai Eheh Toh Brahm Bheechar' I ask you to do one thing; for a second; pretend you have never been to any samagam, havn't read any books, do not know the lives of any Gursikhs, all you have is your Guru. From your Guru you are to obtain all the answers. So you begin to jap. As you are japping Gurbaani, you are learning that singing Gurbaani is essential and the path of Bliss. Then you ask yourself; how do i sing this baani? The answer you will get is the Raag prescibed for that Shabad. bhul chuk mauf waheguruujikakhalsa waheguruujikifateh [%sig%]

Re: Raag

Concerned Sikh · 22 Jul 2005

Nicely put Charanjeev Singh. Sounds good, simple and sufficient. Maybe this seems so difficult because for the fact it is so simple.

Re: Raag

.....? · 27 Jul 2005

It's funny how old this thread gets in a matter of days, nobody really cares about important stuff, everyone's worried about all the karam kaands.

Re: Raag

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 27 Jul 2005

Gurbani is ILAHEE....BUT Raag was already there. Guru Ji wrote GURBANI for ALL OCASSIONS... thats why we have Ghorrian, lavaan, Alahannian, sadd, Anand Sahib...GURU JI wanted us to STOP singing those "Geets" from OUTSIDE and SING GURBANI instead. Now it is entirely possible that since Ghorree waleh LOK GEET were sung as they are sung today....and GURU JI Specially wrote GHORRIAN to let the people know that you need not resort to lok geet..here is a perfect Gurbani for the ocassion. Similarly the Dhadee Dhuna are from thsoe POPULAR LOK VAARS of the time...Vaars that nearly everybody would have memeorised and sung at all times... so GURU JI wrote GURBANI Vaars and told the people to sing these GURBANI to the TUNE of the Popular vaars. just my thoughts..Bhul chuk maaf

Re: Raag

Lionking · 28 Jul 2005

Similarly the Dhadee Dhuna are from thsoe POPULAR LOK VAARS of the time...Vaars that nearly everybody would have memeorised and sung at all times... so GURU JI wrote GURBANI Vaars and told the people to sing these GURBANI to the TUNE of the Popular vaars. ___________________________________ Could you please post historical reference to Guru ji asking that dhadhis to Singh Gurbani to the Tune of Vaara. ____________________________ Gurbani is ILAHEE....BUT Raag was already there. _______________________________________ But the fact that Guru ji used it must have some significance, orelse he wouldn't be bothered to spend time writing up which raag it is, putting Rehraas Sahib in raag and Japji Sahib without raag must have some significance ( meaning that there are some pauris in Japji Shib and Rehras Sahib are very similar, but the fact thta Rehras SAhib ji is in RAAG tells us that Maharaj ji wanted us to feel something different than when doing Japji ) just a few thoughts.. I mean otherwise if it didn't have anything to do with feelings both would be raagless or with raag, but here one is in Raag one is without, which tells us Maharaj ji wanted us to have different emotions doing Rehraas Sahib to doing Japji Sahib i.e "so dar tera Kha So ghar keha" very similar, but i one case in Raag, and in one case without Raag. Are we saying that Maharaj sat uselessly writing in Raag? I myself am guilty of not knowing Raag Kirtan, but am desperate to learn it, but where we live theres no-one to teach so in the meanwhile until i actually learn it, no1s asking me NOT TO DO KIRTAN. KIRTAN KARO, but when you CAN do it- you should. We should atleast make an effort, where we make efforts to keep kakkar and stuff it's fundamental to also learn Raag Kirtan, as that's the way Mahraj ji decided to compose Bani BCM!