Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

disrespecting the khanda???

disrespecting the khanda???

Khalsa47 · 30 Jun 2005

*****I had posted this under another thread (beautiful guruji, beautiful gursikh *dont' wreck this thread*), but I think it should have its own thread. I have pasted what I have written below. What does sangat think about this?***** What does everyone think about the lion on the Khanda. I personally find this wrong. I mean why would you add something to the Khanda? The khanda is suppose to have two kirpans, one chakar, and one khanda in the middle. We are not allow to add anything to the khanda, as it is suppose to be left the way guru ji has given it to us. This is my personal opinion. What does everyone else think?

Re: disrespecting the khanda???

Sister · 30 Jun 2005

I have read on a previous thread that its okay to add other shastars to the khanda.....i'm not so sure about a lions head

Re: disrespecting the khanda???

S Singh · 30 Jun 2005

The current "Khanda" design was not around until probably the 20th century so what the problem with changing it ? If someone wants to add a lion to it then I can not see anything wrong with it.

Re: disrespecting the khanda???

geez · 30 Jun 2005

the lions head is a moulding and it is not "added to the khanda" baba deep singh jee's chakar had gurbani on it many puratan shasters like sri sahibs had eagles or hawks or lions engraved into them and anyway the khanda emblem is not a puratan emlblem khalsa47 THAINOO HOR KOEE KAMM NAEE ??

Re: disrespecting the khanda???

Harsimrat Kaur · 30 Jun 2005

waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ke fateh! personally, i think that we should not alter one part of what guru ji says or has done. We should treasure it and ahow it. Not alter it to our liking! We should be happy about how guru ji has made it and never want to change anything guru ji has made!! Sorry if i offeneded anyone! Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ke fateh!

Re: disrespecting the khanda???

Gurus Son · 30 Jun 2005

Wjkk WJkf Its tru the khanda was created after mahraj and I heard it was created by the british I could b wrong, anyway I dont feel there is nutin wrong in it, because there intentions are not bad! If anything is done out of piyar then wats the harm in that! Wjkk WJkf

Re: disrespecting the khanda???

Dandilion · 30 Jun 2005

The Khanda was NOT around three hundred years ago. There are pictures of Guru Gobind Singh Ji with a khanda on his dastaa, this is not correct as the symbol is a recent thing, so to add a lion on it is no big thing.

Re: disrespecting the khanda???

S Singh · 01 Jul 2005

Harsimrat Kaur, Read what geez wrote the "...khanda emblem is not a puratan emblem". This is right. If you look at flags of the old Sikh forces the Khanda they use is different to the current modern Khanda. The modern Khanda is not what Guru Ji gave us. It has developed over the year. Take a lok at the Khanda the Nihangs us eon their dastaar it is very different from what is perceived by many as being the Khanda. If anyone wants to add lions, guns etc etc then there is nothing wrong with this.

Re: disrespecting the khanda???

A Singh · 01 Jul 2005

Guru Jee didn't invent the Khanda!

Re: disrespecting the khanda???

R singh · 02 Jul 2005

The khanda is desrespected by punjbai artists. As you see people like sukhshinder shinda have a khanda in the backround and you see girls dancing! These people think the khanda is a punjbai symbol. The khanda is a symbol of the sikh relgion not the punjabi culture. I don't understand how these punjabi artists have the right to have the khanda around there knecks as well. As u see someone like jazzy b is mona and looks like an idiot and has a khanda around his necks. If you were to ask himn what he was representing with the khanda he would say ppunjabi not sikhs. The khanda has been changed in the eyes of the world. As it is not porraied as a sikh symbol. Bhul Chuk Maf Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh

Re: disrespecting the khanda???

Your Name:Author · 04 Jul 2005

something that many of you people did not talk about was also The Punjabi Jatt story. many stupid people think that a khanda is symbol of a Jatt...symbol of a Punjabi. i mean yo its a disgrace. you see many punjabi munde in their sportscars they have cut hair and they hang a big shiny or maybe silver in their car. they wear khanda chains. yo they think it makes you look tough its jjust so stupid and a BIG disgrace at the same time. yo what is this???????? i mean its okay to wear a khanda on your paag but around your neck??????? okay there buddy.....