Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

I hate Punjabi Sikhs: a non-Punjabi Sikh

I hate Punjabi Sikhs: a non-Punjabi Sikh

Kulbir Singh · 29 Jun 2005

Day before yesterday, I was walking back home after an interesting day at work. As I was walking a cab approached me. I noticed a Sikh person sitting in there. He accosted me and said fateh to me. I respectfully returned his fateh. He said that he just wanted to say fateh since he just loves the Sikhi saroop. As he said this, he got very emotional. I too shared his emotions and he turned off the ignition of his car. At this I knew that a long conversation was to ensue. He started the conversation as follows: Sikh Driver: I am really happy to see Sikhi saroop. I came from India about 3 years ago and I am greatly disappointed to see how many patits are here. Daas: You are right veer jeeo. There are quite a few monnay, who have disowned Sikhi by cutting their hair. Sikh Driver: I greatly regret that all my life, I fought with the Jaats of Haryana and other Hindus in Delhi while defending the Punjabi Sikhs but if I knew that the Punjabi Sikhs would disgrace Sikhi like this, I would have never defended them. Daas: How did you defend the Punjabi Sikhs and when did you do that? Sikh Driver: During the eighties, when the Punjabi Sikhs were fighting in Punjab, the Sikhs in Delhi and Haryana fully supported them and many times we had fights with Jaats of Haryana, who used to severely slander the Punjabi Sikhs. Now I think I was stupid for defending the Punjabi Sikhs. I noticed that he was very bitter about Punjabis and I wanted to find out what the reason was. So I asked him as follows: Daas: Where are you from and why do you hate the Punjabi Sikhs so much. What bad did they do to you? Sikh Driver: I am from Kashmir and I am a Muzaffarabaadi i.e. from the Muzaffarbad district of Kashmir. Now we are settled in Jammu and after partition we left our district Muzaffarabad. As for why I hate the Punjabi Sikhs, I don’t have any personal vendetta against them. I dislike them because Punjabi Sikhs are the worse offenders of Sikhi principles. In Jammu and Kashmir, Sikhs never cut their hair. We are very strict in keeping our hair and I noticed that in Delhi too Sikhs are very strict about keeping hair. But Punjab, where Sikhi was born, where all our Guru Sahibaan lived, is totally empty of Sikhi. Majority of Sikhs there are patits i.e. they cut their hair. What he was saying was so true. I could not do or say anything to defend the Punjabi Sikhs. What was I supposed to say? Daas: Haanji Veer jeeo, the situation is very bad. Sikh Driver: In Delhi, where I used to live, one young Sikh became a patit by cutting his hair. You won't believe how big of a storm came after that. In the end, he retracted his mistake and kept hair. In Punjab you all cut hair and not a feather moves. I hope you don’t mind and I believe you too are from Punjab but I will say this even if it hurts you. It is Punjabis in general and Jatts in particular who have destroyed Sikhi. I know you will be upset as you seem to be a Jatt yourself but this is what the truth is. I recently read Sangat Singh’s book and I share his belief that it is possible that Sikhi like Buddhism will get eradicated from its place of birth and flourish in the rest of the world. Daas: I am not one bit offended by any of your comments. I know what you are saying is with good intentions. Sikh Driver: (now he openly said it) Jatts have destroyed Sikhi here. I have never seen anything like this as in Toronto. They claim to be Sikhs but they are clean-shaven. They drink in the night and they never do paath. On top of that, they call me Bhaapa on my back. How dare they do that? They think I am a coward. I have fixed a few of them and will fix as many as required. They think we are cowards but they don’t know that the Kashmiri Sikhs are the most brave people on the face of Earth. A Sikh general in 1947 had said that all he needs is the armed Kashmiri Sikhs to fight off the tribal forces who attacked Kashmir. By now he was very sentimental. Then he went on to tell me something so emotionally that his eyes filled with a mixed emotion of rage and love. He continued: Sikh Driver: I will tell you something. The most precious worldly possessions for me are my two sons. I love my sons so much that I cannot describe in words. One day I called both of my sons to my side and said to them. “Puttar, you know how much you mean to me and how much I love you. Rabb na karae, if anything happens to you and you die, I may some how endure it and absorb the sorrow. But if any of you ever cut your hair from any part of your body, that day will be the last day of my life. I will die before I you bring shame to the Kashmiri Sikhs. What face will I show to sangat in Jammu, if they find out that my sons have cut hair? Sikhi is the dearest thing for me.” As he said this, his eyes became watery and also red with josh (rage). He told me that his sons are now going to University and both are proud of their appearance. They have had problems but they have stood firm in their resolution to keep kesh at all cost. Daas: You are right Bhaji. We must keep kesh at all cost. Imagine if all the so called Sikhs kept kesh, how easy it would be for everyone to keep kesh then. I think these monnay are a disgrace to Sikhi. “DON’T CALL THEM MONNAY”, he roared. They are not monnay but they are Patits. Call them Patits. You know what a patit means, right? Patit means extremely filthy. They are extremely filthy. They have disowned their Guru. I hate them”. I asked him, “Well, one thing is for sure. You are not very fond of Patits. But what do you go when you go to Gurdwaras and you see monnay doing sewa in langar? Do you accept langar from patits?” He smiled. His smile was that of a winner. He proudly said, “For this reason, I never go to Gurdwaras. I cannot bear the sight of Patits controlling Gurdwaras. I have parkash of Guru Sahib at home and I know Guru Sahib knows my emotions. I hope he excuses me for not going to Gurdwaras run by patits”. As we were talking he got a call from his dispatcher to pick up a fare. I was surprised, how he heard his name being called out, when he was so engrossed in talking to me. He said fateh and promised to meet me again. He left, and I was left thinking about what a guy he was. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: I hate Punjabi Sikhs: a non-Punjabi Sikh

A Singh · 29 Jun 2005

This driver clearly has a lot of issues from his time back in Kashmir, however he fails to note that despite the issues surrounding the rising Jatt politics and issues within the Panth, there are couple of points to note (a) on the Jaat-paat issue, namely we have many examples of non-Jatt figures who have failed to side appropriately with the Panth or lead the Panth in dire times (e.g. Gyani Zail Singh and Master Tara Singh, who both proved to be too timid in the face of Hindu Politics, in the case of the former, downright pathetic when it came to the hour of need, Harjot Oberoi and his controversial musings etc etc) and (b) this type of anti-Punjabi attitudes are often also found amongst the 3HO Sikhs who regard all things Punjabi as backwards, yet are keen to wear Moje, Kurtas and do Bhangra! The point we cannot forget is Punjabi Sikhs have written their history with their own blood and sweat and we have a long list of shaheeds to ascertain that, but the same token, those who cannot keep Kesh, should look into the sacrifices for us today made up those who suffered to much for keeping their Kesh.

Re: I hate Punjabi Sikhs: a non-Punjabi Sikh

Hari Singh · 29 Jun 2005

I just hope a mona never ends up in this guys cab.

Re: I hate Punjabi Sikhs: a non-Punjabi Sikh

Singh · 29 Jun 2005

>>>>>>>I just hope a mona never ends up in this guys cab. hahhahahahahahhahaha! He would eat the mona raw.

Re: I hate Punjabi Sikhs: a non-Punjabi Sikh

dusty chappal · 29 Jun 2005

afghani singhs say the same thing about punjabi sikhs in southall very divisive! it is a beautiful scene to see singhs with their kes in tact in delhi, and then ludhiana singhs in bana some of them glow like mobbatiya. jamu singhs castist attitude was distasteful as much as jatt boastings this is the thing that splits sikhs up into i am this you are that. We are one! he fought for sikh rights not for punjabi jatt sikhs unless he beleives such a thing exists that splits up sikhs into states and castes rather than be a spiritual sikh nation. He did what guru ji would have wanted him to do. he shud not feel bitter now. If anyone is being harrassed its a haq to help them. I think the guy was very passionate about sikhi and prolly had a go at a couple of monei for having bakri cut face and they prolly called him a papa and his josh went up and developed anger for monei and jatts. Its a case of a singhs warrior side and josh he develops and looks down on a mona instead of using that josh in a positive way. But the jatt thinks who is this papa does he not know my jatt ancestry, the blood in my veins, the lion personality we have? both are wrong in looking down at each other. Both believe in divisiion. But singh ji has a greater responsibility as he is in a sikh roop to open the bridge of love and let it flow like a nalkah. Go gurdwara and meet these young lads interact with them, give them sakhia of 84, so next time they get pissed and emtional they will remember, who knows a change might occur but its better than looking down on them. But this is how this sectarian stuff starts. He should ignore monei and just do more paat and be like an ambassador for sikhi turn his gussa into love for monei and use the sikhi hes got in a positive way to influence them towards sikhi. even if he gets one out of 8 its worth it ke nehi.

Re: I hate Punjabi Sikhs: a non-Punjabi Sikh

.. · 29 Jun 2005

this is a classic sign of a singhs frustration with monei. there is no way anyone can turn a mona into a singh with harsh words, anger, or violence. Best way is to be more sociable, attend social places. You will come across loads of monei, most will be these stubborn types but then you will find drifters, soul searchers, people who do want a change to themselves. they will ask questions. Then you do it bit by bit, talk about how it feels to experience happiness and joy inside. the kinbd that no gf can give where your blooming. You have goals and many reasons to live for. Then build friendships and the person sees a different kind of friend. This friend does not steal from me, he is not being faitha khaddan wala friend, he gives sound advice, stands by me. Then you develop a gfood connection to the person. Then they will ask themselves something what makes this person tick?slowly you can introduce them to bani, and explain how it feels to get the connection when meat and shraab is stopped. When you introduce these people to bani, that is the Guru. The Guru is going to help guide them as long as they stop meat shraab and gf bfs. If they establish a set discipline from bani, the time will come when their soul starts saying these hairs? thats just part of me what the heck let it grow its so natural that its a gift and not a burden. let Guru ji in gurbani persuade the monei to keep kes. We need to get people to reassess their goals where they are going in life and what they want out of it first long term. [%sig%]

Re: I hate Punjabi Sikhs: a non-Punjabi Sikh

Vahegurooo · 29 Jun 2005

what an inspiring man, he's so right. http://mistakesingh.blogspot.com

Re: I hate Punjabi Sikhs: a non-Punjabi Sikh

ssingh · 29 Jun 2005

http://www.sikhnet.com/Sikhnet/news.nsf/SikhNetHPNewsHTML/3A7ED86CAD8BC7028725701F006CFDCF?OpenDocument "does he not know my jatt ancestry, the blood in my veins, the lion personality we have? both are wrong in looking down at each other. Both believe in divisiion. But singh ji has a greater responsibility as he is in a sikh roop to open the bridge of love and let it flow like a nalkah. Go gurdwara and meet these young lads interact with them, give them sakhia of 84, so next time they get pissed and emtional they will remember, who knows a change might occur but its better than looking down on them. "Best way is to be more sociable, attend social places." Here's the place to start. (I had posted this before, but) I think this is the best place to start. All the akj, nihang, taksal, and frustrated bhapa's should attend this event. The group that can socialize the most gets the most points and wins. I think it most effective to form an Akali giddha team to impress these jatt lions

Re: I hate Punjabi Sikhs: a non-Punjabi Sikh

Bhopinder Singh · 29 Jun 2005

A Sikh general in 1947 had said that all he needs is the armed Kashmiri Sikhs to fight off the tribal forces who attacked Kashmir. ____________________________________________________________ well that is a good line to show how brave we are.Why should we fight people fighting for their own freedom, kashmir,naxlite,assamese,nagas,tamils in lanka why should we become gun powder for Indians and then boast it. As`ourselves we are not free.I think it is hight of foolishness. Kashmir is nearing independence and we should not repeat the mistake of 1947 ie we should not choose sides.Lots of sikhs in kashmir.We should instead wait for the winning side and then look for our own benefit and then make such comments.Why should we choose sides , that to indian. Indian withdrawl from siachin is a big step for free Kashmir.It could have never happened and is the first sign of kashmere freedom.

Re: I hate Punjabi Sikhs: a non-Punjabi Sikh

beatbox · 29 Jun 2005

i think a good way is to start at our very own gurdwaras s singh and unis colleg, in our areas people we already know. sikhs share a lot . Their legendary feats are attributed only to the spirit born sikhi but because we are forgetful we are now attributing these feats to our mundane bodies and places of residence. Be that chaar sahibzadey, akali phula singh, , hari singh nalwa, general arora, , surinder singh sodhi, sant jarnail singh shaheed sukhdev singh, mai bhago, mata sundri list goes on all these great sikhs were great because of the input they put into sikhi not of any caste. Compare these legends to people noit exposed to sikhi there is no example. Everything is directly on kirpa of Mahraj. even monei who read bani who do not smoke eat meat or have sexual relations will be in a far better position to understand caste at its material element position than being pigeon holed as patits. Without inspiration i am afraid no progress. Whether one is a jat bhapa mona kesdari these bodies are not superhuman, they are prone to diseases, we all have to eat, sweat and release waste. I see nothing to be proud about. This body will go one day after a life of 40 50 years it is not invincible. Who leads the world? militarily financially, sports? america, made use of its cross gene structures mixing nordic, celt germanic, franco, semite, afro, latin bloodlines. who has the most developed success outside the pales of religion? whether exploration on earth? moon? science? a mix of different european bloodlines that were essentially never the same. Who created the worlds largest empire? william orange III after mixing all different royal european bloodlines. What do we have? giddah, shraab, sweaty freshies, womanising, im a put of so and so back to medieval times. the whole world has moved on.

Re: I hate Punjabi Sikhs: a non-Punjabi Sikh

long live kashmir · 29 Jun 2005

if kashmir does become independant in its current state of affairs it will be at the cost of kashmir itself being split. The problems there have made buddhist valley kashmiris move into ladak which is now a buddhist kashmir bordering china. Sikh and hindus for the large part migrated to jammu what used to be the summer capital of kashmir. It was better when kashmir was one country. The kashmiris had a lot of regard for each other. The hurriyat would be facing an impossible task against segregation. It is highly unlikely it could relocate millions of kashmiris to their original homes which in turn means kashmir remains bitterly divided.

Re: I hate Punjabi Sikhs: a non-Punjabi Sikh

singh · 29 Jun 2005

why are u supporting this guys lunatic anger towards monay, from the looks of your convo seems like u support him kulbir singh

Re: I hate Punjabi Sikhs: a non-Punjabi Sikh

A Singh · 30 Jun 2005

I concur that shouting at clean shaven Sikhs is not going to turn them into Singhs overnight, however I can sympathise with this guy to some extent when those from the Punjab seems to regard themselves as Singhs and Sardars nonetheless and look down upon non-punjabis despite them being Singhs proper.

Re: I hate Punjabi Sikhs: a non-Punjabi Sikh

spartan souljah · 30 Jun 2005

You cannot walk upto a random jatt and give attitude, big fiery red eyes steaming in some attempt to scare them into growing their hair. These people may respect sikhi, but also very independant in character, if another 84 came, these cleanshavers at least have some bond to their history some backdrop some shelter. Amritdharis are already disliked by indian propaganda, sep 11 we do not want a situation growing where our own people turn their back on us. We have to be a bit flexi. I meet a lot of my jatt brethren very dissolutioned with gurdwaras and sikhi now. no one likes to be put down. cults around us are growing that accept monei while our own lack of acceptance is seeing a decline in our very own people. i think its imoportant to keep unity . Not many years ago we used to be two sides of the same coin. If a singh was attacked on a street 10 monei would jump to help. Now i clearly remember balbir singh bains stall leafletting in gurdwara on basakhi day, absolutly no monei were interested, like there was a huge invisible wall in front of amritdhari singhs and the masses. One even had the audacity to say something horrible. here was us expecting support from sikh community. Yet on this basakhi day the masses sit in hundreds listening to a brahmin on stage from a travel company advertsiing himself as a future mp. there is too big a gap that requires a bond. It is very very sad a lot of our mundei who have fought on the front line struggles against muslim fundamentalists are blanked out by sikhs in gurdwaras and outside for struggles that were essentially sikh. Then on the rebound do the same back. We should not confuse apney lok more by making boundaries. A singh has a connection through bani. Monei have no connection other than memories, what held them together and seeing a singh. If singhs are going to cause bad vibes then we are driving our mundei away. The candle is inside each of our brothers if we take initiative to light the lamp. If the candle wants to stay dormant one day when darkness comes it will seek ignition.

Re: I hate Punjabi Sikhs: a non-Punjabi Sikh

Pardeep Singh Bilga · 30 Jun 2005

OH PLEASE!!!....why do Jatts ALWAYS get the blame for abandoning Sikhi?? Yes, the majority of Sikhs are Jatt- therefore if we look at it like this (in a proportionate way): Say 70 out of 100 of Sikhs are Jatts- you are more likely to see more monay from the Jatt background than say Tarkhaan, who make up 12%? Anyway, the difference with Tarkhaans and Jatts is really this: Tarkhaans rarely cut their hair on the HEAD...hence lots are sardars but with pencil-line goatee style beards, Jatts who are not sardar are monay- so it looks worse at first impression, but most of the non-amritdharee Tarkhaans do drink/smoke etc etc as well as the Jatts! I've said again and again- IT IS NOT THE JATTS who build separate temples- Ravidas/Ramgharhia etc etc.... There have been many Sikhs from the Jatt background who have given so much to the religion- Sant Bhindranwale for example. Please don't let this escalate into some kind of caste argument as I do not believe in caste issues for amritdharee Gursikhs, but think Jatts are always getting the stick for anything that goes wrong.

Re: I hate Punjabi Sikhs: a non-Punjabi Sikh

spartan souljah · 30 Jun 2005

These caste gurdwarey were created because sikhs felt discriminated against. I think the way punjabi society is as i have seen i kind of understand that even i do not agree with their rehet. the jatts who became rehetvan singhs it is unfair to attribute caste to them. If you were to talk to them their souls are at such a level they know these bodies are coats we come we go. there is hence no jatt no terkaan but only issues of rehat. However not everyone reaches for higher levels thats why we end up stuck thinking caste is a socio religious reality when its only as real as the mirage of maya. the trim singhs are actually no better than mone rightly said. it is frankly obvuious my kids and your kids will not care about caste it is going hence the noise. There will only be sikhi left those that come to it are saved those who dont will be lost in kal yug waves, culture does not last forever it changes to new environment. The sarkars have such a grip over people god onyl save them.

Re: I hate Punjabi Sikhs: a non-Punjabi Sikh

gabroo · 30 Jun 2005

it was quite pleasing to read some of the unifying comments here. but then i read ssingh's giddha response. what a joke. pardeep singh jee, if you were not believing in castism, you would not take it so personally if and when jatts are cussed. other than that, i really appreciated reading the plight of this singh and the comments by gursikhs after. waheguru Waheguru

Re: I hate Punjabi Sikhs: a non-Punjabi Sikh

ex jatt now singh · 30 Jun 2005

pardeep singh jio perhaps read between the lines. Maybe that singh was in a jatt dominated area where they might have rinsed him for being a bhupa. If somebody rinses you on a personal point, like your short, tall, birthmark, or pagh or equaiting besan bread brown skin to offensive racial terms will you forget them? he might have felt bhupa to be offensive. Imagine a singh trying to a rinse a mona for no kes that mona is like wtf you dumb bhupa? singh is shocked mona has this himmat and takes it so personally that it has jolted his dil. Now i understand the pain in your dhil about this singhs claim, you are right in your own way. Its different from uk where we have a mixed proprtion of everything. If that part of canada is mostly jatt perhaps thats what singh saw and made the comment. But it is true that in canada in such a country its easy to practice sikhi, while this singh has been through 84. non punjabi sikhs had a much harder time preserving sikhi than canadians or valaitis with hindus intimidating them, jadu tooney, tryint to convert and lure them and fighting against hindu extrermists in some places. So you have to see the world in his eyes first. They still kept their kes in tact and it is true they do not cut their hair so they have preserved sikhi but they should not compare themselves or feel emotional about jatts but perhaps rephrase it to desi canadians. I agree with you its not just jatts cutting kes , but its also the truth if all jatts were singhs in canada i think the sikh community would really rock in C. If sikh jatts around the world followed sikhi hell singh thats 70% of sikhs. . so why not see the positive instead of take it as a jibe? In fact i think bhai kulbir singh should invite this singh to tapoban gurdwara and show the xample of singhs teahcing monai kids gurbani paat, so maybe the singhs dil will change. If he is as passionate of sikhi as he appears to be maybe he would also do the same. But in any case instead of feeling blame or taking it personally perhaps you should try to understand this singh saw things from a smoked screen, instead we should pray for him that he sees beyond the thari and caste of a person so he may one day be caste free just like you are pardeep singh ji. It is a shame because a passonate singh like that could work alongside monei committees and then inflience the decision making and bring more singhs in. [%sig%]

Re: I hate Punjabi Sikhs: a non-Punjabi Sikh

xyz · 30 Jun 2005

FACT: 10 out of the 12 Sikh Misls were led and sustained by Jatts. Fast forward to recent times... FACT: 80%+ of Khalistani militants were of Jatt ancestory. Enough said.

Re: I hate Punjabi Sikhs: a non-Punjabi Sikh

Bhopinder Singh · 30 Jun 2005

long live kashmir Date: 06-29-05 22:51 if kashmir does become independant in its current state of affairs it will be at the cost of kashmir itself being split. The problems there have made buddhist valley kashmiris move into ladak which is now a buddhist kashmir bordering china. Sikh and hindus for the large part migrated to jammu what used to be the summer capital of kashmir. It was better when kashmir was one country. The kashmiris had a lot of regard for each other. The hurriyat would be facing an impossible task against segregation. It is highly unlikely it could relocate millions of kashmiris to their original homes which in turn means kashmir remains bitterly divided. ___________________________________________________________ Sikh and hindus for the large part migrated to jammu what used to be the summer capital of kashmir. _______________________________________________________ could you please explain the organised voilence of hindus against sikhs in jammu not one but hundereds Please explain the armys help in organising functions of radhasoamis in gurudwaras. No kashmere freedom fighter was doing any harm to sikhs, it was for stupid actions of kps gill type sikhs in the indian army openly boasting killing moslems although they were doing it with the weapons and blessing of mother india and most of the work was done by the hindus in a hidden way ,to be boasted by the sikhs like jj singh.Who even forgot to look after their own flock and the impact of their foolish actions on fellow kashmere sikhs S.S. maan has personly told me that kashmere women have shown him private parts bitten by sikhs(sorry) like kps and jj singh. My own father in law was posted in kashmere,One day while coming back from bazar they were ambushed by kashmere freedom fighters .He took shelter besides a wall and slowly moved towards a shop with him were one chapli the sikh and one hindu army officer the millitants won the fight and soon cornered them when all were arrested by the millitants ,the commander of the millitant group asked the three what they were doing chapli tha sikh said we want KHALISTAN and you want kashmere ,it is a fact he released both of them and killed the hindu army official.

Re: I hate Punjabi Sikhs: a non-Punjabi Sikh

def jam · 30 Jun 2005

good point xyz so is it the jatt dna inside the person or the amrit and sikhi that kept the khalistan movement and the misals going? to elaborate this further is there any other jatt tribe or jatt grouping that has had similar success in terms of measure in warfare (sava lakh se ek larao) with such a deadly blow as the k movement and the missals of yesterday gave?? i see no comparison in muslim jatts or hindu jatts in the whole of their history. Yet sikhi seems to be full to the brim of such courage. Another noteworthy point Two sahibjadey fought sava lakh each, can you? so what ancestry was inside them? hindu jatts and their wannabee bhaiya jaats come across as weak and timid and very two faced with sikhs. aazaad kashmiri and west punjabi jatts ( mirza, chima, n co ) i have met are basically no better they work in a unit of 10 15 and jump english and sikh schoolboys. Basically sikh jatts seem to be known for anakh, truthful living, warrior spirit that seems to be manifest brightly which i can only put down to their fathers totally rejecting hinduism and following sikhi in the past. But why do i not see this in non sikh jatts? i live in a punjabi muslim area.

Re: I hate Punjabi Sikhs: a non-Punjabi Sikh

casteless sikh society · 30 Jun 2005

if bilga and this jammu singh were in one room together there would definatly be some mad giddah and fullchariah.

Re: I hate Punjabi Sikhs: a non-Punjabi Sikh

putt singha da balonda jakare · 30 Jun 2005

basically 50 singhs took on the indian army in 1984. whether they were jatt or not has any group of 50 jatts ever been able to achieve this without sikhi? i have no idea how many singhs were in chamkaur i think 30 40 but i am told the muslim army was 1 million something. Now again whether these singhs were jatt or not has any jatt repeated this without sikhi? so what is it that made those singhs rock the nation? jatts who came under satguru became changey singhs. Those who turned against like kps gill,sp khalon, sp ajit sandhu, genral brar, badal, and these corrupt police officers tried to wipe the sikh movement out using state machinery. Jatts basically are the biggest number and most noticeable. Once they took amrit on the path of sikhi they dont go round calling themselves putt jatta dey. asali singhs whatever caste they came from before their spiritual rebirth try to live like singhs on a spiritrual journey back home to sach khand where they shall be greeted with other singhs from different castes we dont have special khetta up there, our jots dont have these big chests and dholei up there its just you God and the sangat which essentially has no jaat paat. [%sig%]

Re: I hate Punjabi Sikhs: a non-Punjabi Sikh

jagdish singh CA · 30 Jun 2005

if you hate anyone beside one's merrit. You are a loser and you have not understood Guru and His Bannee: read this below, how foolish we are some time. Our own personal pattiness takes one's away from GUR-SIKHI. pattiness has no place in SIKHISM. This beautiful story came this morning on a Naam net site: Waheguruji ka khalsa waheguruji ki fateh I am also a scientist and met Mr. Vasudev Bardwaj at Chandigarh. I have seen the photograph of Gurujot in possession with him. It is a great moment of my life to see that photograph. There are many incidence of life which I have experienced and which cannot be explained by just reasoning or intellect. I have practiced little bit simran in the morning and observed following facts which I am not able to explain with the help of my scientific knowledge. May be I donot know much science but I am scientist with aptitude and by profession, The facts are as following: 1. some time I cry and sometime I laugh without any reason during simran and I donot why 2. if I concentrate at Dhuni during simran as advocated by Maskeenji, then some force give me a heavy jerk from the place wherever I am sitting. 3 if I concentrate simran close to throat(kundh) or at the tongue then momentarily whatever I say comes to be truth and that happens. 4 if I concentrate at the forhead then momentarily I can see what will happen in the future 5 when I sleep by reciting waheguru with mind absorbed in the waheguru then I donot have any dream that night and I could hear singing of birds at 4:00 clock in the morning when all the birds are still sleeping. I could hear the sound even with closed doors. Sometime I feel I could hear whispers a few km away from my place. 6 sometime I experience that there three rhythms going simultaneously in the body one is heart beat, breathing and third is some invisible force/energy which moves from lower part of the body and goes up to the head and then comes back and it is so periodic that sometimes it moves with the period of breathing and sometimes with the heartbeat and sometimes independently. I donnot do anything but just observe. these are my experiences which have forced me think that there is something which scientist like me could not enterpret and I confess I donot know anything. Waheguru or the whatsever called as Almighty or hidden force or universal energy is there in our body and outside. I am convinced any one can experience waheguru who follows Such Hove ta Such payia( If we practice purity in life we will become one with the eternal PURE.) Finally I will like to conclude that God or waheguru is there who believe that He is there and who are one personality that the same from inside and outside could experience Him much easier and earlier. And who have duality in their mind keep on guessing whether HE is there or not. Every body picks up map daily to find God I mean recite or read Nitnam or Japji Sahib or some other holy verses but donot start moving on to that path. Next day again open the map and close it. So for the whole life we keep on asking ourselves and others is any God is there and where is it? I confess that I have yet not met Him but I have experienced that he is there everywhere. Mr. Vasudev Bardwaj has met him. Manpreet Singh Dy Director Photonic Division TBRL, Min of Defence Sector-30, Chandigarh India-160020 -----Original Message----- >"Dilmohan Singh [IMPALA]" wrote: > >FYI. In reply to original questions as below by Sardar Gurmit Singh >(Justice of Peace Australia). > >Questions as below: 1. When this incident has happened - day, date and time ? >5.MAY.2002 , the Akhand Path was kept at 8.30am but the incident of >jyot/light appearance occurred when Sukhmani sahib started from first >"panna" 262. Vasuji does not remember time bcoz he was not wearing a watch >& moreover he was SPELLBOUND alongwith everyone assembled over there.Such >was the MAGICSPELL that while this operation took place for around 8 >min.(as said by witnessers) even Granthi Ji reciting the path kept on >reciting the path in a spell while witnessing the "prakash of Gurbani" >before his eyes. You can make out that this incident may have occurred at >around 3.30pm to 4.00pm bcoz Sukhmani sahib comes after 7 hours continuos >recitation of Guru Granth Sahib ji. 2. When Akhand Paath started and in which room/floor of Darbaar Sahib? >The cabin allotted to Mr.Vasu was the just on the front-left side of Sri >Akal Takht Sahib. The cabin has been named after the famous martyr of Army >S. Vikram Singh (Hero of Ladakh) who died fighting on 22.Nov.1963.I have >witnessed this room alongwith Mr. Vasu & it is hardly 50 sq.feet. with just >a place of 2/3 persons to fit alongside of the Diwan/Bed hosting Guru >Granth Sahib Ji. 3. Whether Scientist Wasu Bhardwaj lying on a stretcher was brought before >starting Akhand Paath and continuously remained there with other attendees? >Mr.Vasu Bharadwaj was brought on a stretcher but he had such a great >respect for Guruji that he disliked to lie on stretcher & listen to >Gurbani. His Doctors had strictly instructed him to lie down till death or >he would collapse if stood upright. With such great confidence on our >Guruji as (Jeewan Daataa & Mukti Daataa) he sat down aside the bed hosting >Guru Granth sahib ji with folded legs. Mr. Vasu listened to the entire >recitation of Guru Granth Sahib ji till 48 hours as he had also restricted >everyone not to disturb him & instructed to have just a spoon ful of >sweetened lemon water in case he arises a thirst of 5 glasses of water.His >respect , love & concentration towards Gurbani paid him with the new Life >which is a live example for all of us in this Scientific age. 4. What is his current health condition and where he has been living now? >One fact I want to clear to you that why he remained quiet till 2 years >after getting fit in MAY 2002. Mr. Vasu being a talented researcher himself >knew the fact that Cancer of any kind returns back after 6 months to 1 year >span & if this happens then Guruji's name might get bad in the minds of his >Non Sikh knowers. Though he also knows a fact that the last stage cancer >has no way to go out from your body after boring in your bones & >contamining your entire blood cells & viscosity.But Vasuji had the respect >for the name of Guruji & for that he kept quite. In 2004 late Sant Singh ji >Maskin persuaded him to come forward & tell his anecdote to all the Sikhs & >Non Sikhs. Currently he is letting the cancer specialists examine his >cancer in the recurring period of three months so that the doctors maintain >their belief on Guru Granth Sahib Ji after finding that Mr. Vasu is still >Cancer free & his bones & blood is all new. I have seen his one month past >medical report in whuch he free from > Mylloma & his blood is normal in Viscosity. I was also astonished to hear >that after he returned from Harmandir Sahib he had to go for a Stencil >transplant which means the entire change of body blood. But Mr. Vasu's >blood was all new & fresh. Bones were sturdy & without the pores. >He is living at Surat. I had mailed you all his address & nos. earlier. He >visits Harmandir sahib every 03 months in thanx to his fresh medical >reports that reminds him the end towards his tragic life. He delivers his >lectures in India & it is Guruji's grace on me that I accompany him on his >demand to be with him. Being with him I get many opportunities to explore >his personal feelings & sensations since the Jyot traversed & resided in >his body. 5. Whether he continues to recite Gurbani enshrined in the Guru Granth >Sahib or he listens from other family members or friends? >He has the volumes of English translated Guru Granth Sahib ji at his home & >from which he keeps on picking the pearls. He has learnt quite a no. of >Gurbani stanzas which helps him proving his anecdote. His family members do >not know Gurbani but all of the major input comes through his old friend >Sardar Kesar Singh at Surat who is the man behind luring him to Harmandir >Sahib. We keep on gifting him with the choicest stanzas of Gurbani which >gives him a framework of Guru Nanak's ideology. he listens to Gurbani >cassettes ^ pens down every Gurbani wordings in his personal diary. His >speech is the real experience to hear. He has that convincing power which >obsess the sangat to start reciting Gurbani. Due to thsi incident I have >noticed a large no. of non sikhs in Punjab & Delhi have started pinning >their hopes on Guru Granth Sahib ji for all cures. They love Vasu but Vasu >puts them in feet of Guru Granth Sahib ji. "Dilmohan Singh [IMPALA]" ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ * WaheGuru WaheGuru WaheGuru WaheGuru WaheGuru WaheGuru WaheGuru * ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ N A A M - N E T Dedicated to Gurmat & Naam Simran http://www.panthkhalsa.org/naamnet Posting address : [address removed] Administrative address : [address removed] To Subscribe : [address removed]

Re: I hate Punjabi Sikhs: a non-Punjabi Sikh

sikh komb di shan sengha · 30 Jun 2005

xyz paaji can you please tell us why pratan sikhs were not known by their genetic blood surnames? but as singh or kaur

Re: I hate Punjabi Sikhs: a non-Punjabi Sikh

singh · 30 Jun 2005

way i see it the khalistani singhs were singhs in belief having shed their caste mentality at amrit sinchar, and not jatts . This very belief of jhajarus was manifest in such a way between relations with each other which contradicts what we see in normal punjabi households. I have not seen punjabi jatts majbis patrey mixing together on the same level as i have seen ex jhajaru families from entirely different castes at entirely different financial statuses in the new world some from bungalows going into the smaller humble cottages of other singhs embracing each other, sitting on the floor, the whole aura and energy changes as they are not seperate but part of the same mould. They vibrate on the same density. The kind of bonds that exist between them, are inexplainable but such a yari exists that knew no limits that does not even exist today and i certainly do not see that in todays jatt youth which is why i think religion can serve as a central platform substitute. on a practial daily level khalistanis came into direct clash against jatt customs like bhungra, folk singing dancing, drinking, peg sheg lohna, meat, liberal outlook on religion, whereas khalistan was about placing punjab with gurmat under the panthic programme. Whatever the position of sohn singh if punjab had a revival panth programe right now we would not have sant dehre, drug and alcohol abuse, women being used as sex objects, brides for dowry, clubs, corruption. On a spiritual and physical level sikhs are given hukam about jaat paats from the day they reborn as singhs their birthplace is anandpur sahib not dosaanjh kala, sandal baar gondal baar. Their surname is singh, Guru sahib is forthright about caste and both race he issued us to become one in every way. I can see the spiritual reasons why he asked us to become one, the social reasons why, and also from a health aspect i have noticed our cross gened human colleagues are scientifically prooven to perform better ie americans, europeans entire different european bloodlines racial mixing, whereas those nations stuck on selective gene groups seem to have turned back the clock on themselves namely india and pakistan and formed a culture pot that has pushed them into an abyss. This abyss cesspit also stalls religion from growing with arms around it in the form of folk culture. picture an american 6 foot 4 quarter afro, quarter portugeuse, part german part italian now what comparison is the average desi to that? what use will his martial ancestry be? If we made use of that in sikhi we would wipe out a system made of barriers. A lot of caste mentality people especially on these jatt sikh sites and i say jatt sikh because to date i have not found any other religion making caste to be such a big thing. feel the only people talking about this whole unity to a greater level are inferior are ugly looking and want jatt genetics. I can only say one thing today we have a situation where jatts are being judged as bilga said because they are noticeable but that doesnt mean all jatts are the same. The very same is reverse for other castes this trademark stereotype we make a terkan is only some skinny dark kid with tram lines on his beard and a long chin or a chamar to be likened only to being small and dark. this stereotype others have of us we also have of them. bilgas is a typical response do we want a nation or generation of such a type that classes sikhs into categories of i am this you are that? let us keep it that way. This so defies what guru ji states again and again. The present state of affairs like it or not most sikhs outside the pale of jathebandis are split ionto castes and caste gurdwaras. I would encourage sikhs to visit different caste gurdwaras and see for themselves at a singh sabha, at a ramgharia gurdwara and a ravidasia gurdwara if they can spot the difference in 60% of the people they come across? i have been to singh sabha and jatts i come across 40% do not look jatts mde out to be on the internet, especially the fresh from india, at nanak nishkam gurdwara about a good 60% i came across looked very punjabi to me and when their in full sikhi saroop they look no different to these racial characteristics stated by some castists attributing to themselves. Over 50% of chammars i came across were neither skinny or small. So why is it that we from different castes say let us unite into one? we do not need anyones genetics, as we are already making money, and marrying smart looking people and coming out with degrees. But we sure know that it will break down barriers, stop the lid over the whole community expand its base, and enforce a complete a spread it has to be better than where we are today, with bilgas typical response, now i know he and his likes are not kids. Now if they are not kids but grown ups it shows that mentality stops progress, and mental growth and recognition of reality. So where do we want this religion to go if we are not willing to take the front seat with the steering wheel in our hands? What is the future of this religion if we keep the caste system alive? how will we sustain the growth of religion alongside caste? let us take for example jatts are the numerical majority, should we hence rely that this religion shall rest solely on the hands of majority? What if jatts outside sikhism have no interest in sikhism? or what if jatt sikhs themselves develop a broader outlook on religion? so the only conclusion i can arise to is sikhism interests certain categories of people from different castes and races that is becoming significantly lesser, so we cannot keep this satt tradition alive as we get lesser. If 84 comes again we cannot afford this time to say i am a jatt khalistani you are a trkan khalistani as much as we can see this jatt terkan choora rubbish does not work in england or india no more.