Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

chalisa

chalisa

.:...:. · 26 Jun 2005

wjkk wjkf , i just wanted to ask if anybody here knows what is the true maryada of doing a sava lakh jaap of mool mantar ( chalisa or shila ) ? fateh

Re: chalisa

JSGyani "Arshi" · 27 Jun 2005

THIS IS NOT GURMATT. GURBANI roundly condemns such MANMATT. Sava Lakh Jaaps of Mool mantar is a Good thing..do more if you can....BUT as a JANTAR-MANTAR thingy to "get soemthing"....force Guru Ji to GIVE YOU soemthing.... is ANTI-GURMATT and a FRAUDULENT PRACTISE and MISUSE of GURBANI.

Re: chalisa

* · 27 Jun 2005

Gyani Jee, what makes it anti-Gurmat/fradulent/a misuse of Gurbani? It isn't forcing Guru Sahib to give you anything; it's dedicating a lot of time and effort to Guru Sahib by reciting a lot of paath in order to try to become worthy of receiving that which you ask for. Nothing wrong with that as far as I can see. To the original poster, I don't know about "maryada" for this type of thing (I think it's called a Chaleehaa), but you could do ardaas at the start, then do a set amount, or more, of the same baani everyday until you reach sava lakh paaths. Do ardaas at the start and finish every day.

Re: chalisa

JSGyani "Arshi" · 27 Jun 2005

Dear Author * veer jio, the very act of CHALISA ( it is drawn from HANUMAN CHALISA..and is a Pre-set maryada to get Hanuman to Give you soemthing..vaar etc ) is anti gurmatt. WHY ?? Because GURBANI is meant as swaas grass... why set time limits such as 40 days. Recently such a Chalisa was Performed at damdami taksaal mehta chowk... to FORCE a DECISION on the Shahedee of Baba Jarnail singh Bhinderawalah..a Paath was done for 40 DAYS...at end of which Jarnail singh was asked to APPEAR if he was alive or he would be declared Shaheed if he failed to appear. Incidentlaly a havan was also there. This is an UNNECESSARY PAKHAND. IF you want to do Sava lakh paaths/or even a KROR paaths...do it...as and when you can and with Guru's Kirpa you will succeed. RITUALS are manmatt..and chalisa is a RITUAL..BIG TIME. Also falling into this same category are..Saptahak paaths...where a path has to be completed in 7 days, vidhee paath..where the paath has to be completed by mid day each day to a certain aang, in another paath a certain shabad has to be INSERTED after every Aang...blah blah blah..AL these are RITUALS and PAKHAANDS. And the "PAKHANDEES" want to RETAIN CONTROL over the Paath process..so they pretend these are very complicated maryadas..blah blah and only WE can do it properly.... SO JUST PAY US..and we will do it all correctly.... Get it .... BRAHMINS in the DISGUISE of SIKHS trying to hoodwink and cheat the ordinary SIKHS.

Re: chalisa

Dogma · 27 Jun 2005

Gyani Jee, first off, how's it going? It's been a long time since I replied to one of your posts. :) Hope everything is rajee kushee. Okay then.. Here is my question. If Chaleesai are ritualistic based on the time limit of 40 days, why is an Akhaand Paaht NOT ritualistic as well? An Akhand Paaht has to be finished completely without any rest. And almost EVERY Jatha does Akhaand Paahts when: a beloved Gursikh passes, a memorable anniversary in the Panth occurs, etc. What seperates the two? Waheguru Jee Ka Khalsa Waheguru Jee Kee Fateh.

Re: chalisa

N Singh · 27 Jun 2005

I agree with Arshi jee on this. This hole Jantar Mantar stuff seems like Bipran Kee Reet.

Re: chalisa

A Singh · 27 Jun 2005

Gyani Jee, I surprised you drawn the term Chalisa so narrowly and are keen to adopt it to Hindu thinking! In actuality the concept of 40 days is nothing Sanatan in the slightest, but more Semetic (hence the same practice being even more prevalent amongst Muslims, Christians and Jews). The real, but now largely lost, Hindu pratice is consistent of groups of 3 (days, months or years), with 3 numerologically being the first number of form, hence the numerous trinities one finds in religious literature. This is still evident amongt Buddhists and Jains. In any event, with the exception of Tantra Vidya or Hanuman Chalisa, which is a means to seek ridhia-sidhia, the idea of doing paath for 40 days is actually called a Chaliha (from the term 40 -Chali) and simply serves to focus the mind and help build up focus over that period (to then proceed to higher levels of maintenance and practice). This is not necessarily anti-Gurmat, let's not take thinsg at face value alone.

Re: chalisa

JSGyani "Arshi" · 27 Jun 2005

Dogma jio, Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji ki fateh. Guru ji dee apaar kirpa naal Sabh charrdeekalla hai. On the question of Akhand Paath, I have always maintained ( and the Sikh rehat maryada backs me up on this 100%), that TOO MUCH ATTENTION is needlessly paid to TIME..and thus GURBANI is insulted by the Pathees going at Super Train Speeds..so that not a single word is heard or understood by anyone...its all a kind of "background" noise..on the mike while everyone goes about eating/talking/networking/socialising...whatever... The RITUALISTICS..are always on tenterhooks....looking at the clock..checking the Aangs....whispering..paath late hai jee jara tej raakhnaa..paath tej hai jee jara ko slow karna.. SO WHAT if the 48 Hour LIMIT is passed by an HOUR ?? Is the sky going to fall down ?? Is GURU JI going to be so displeased that He will NOT BLESS us ?? OR alternatively If the Paath completes one hour early ?? Sikh Rehat maryada clearly says that GURBANI MUST be read SLOWLY and CLEARLY.. spasht ate shudh. NO attempt must be made to HURRY up artifiically. Now to other BEADBEE of "Akahnd Paaths" by the ritualistics... UP to 50 or even 101 SIMULTANEOUS akhand paaths held at One Dera/gurdwara. Other Programmes such as Kirtan darbars/Kavee darbars etc held simultaneously to akhand paaths.. The absence of even ONE listener at times...with ONLy the Pathee doing the paath all by himself..especially at NIGHT. Daytime..the family more interested in serving the "guests"..sangat...instead of listening to gurbani.. I am sure you would agree with me on these points. It is very very seldom that you come across a properly done akhand paath...many are just PAID Pathees, who change duties and do as they wish....I have participated in many such AP's.... some paathees will say they have other programmes to attend and so they want to "finish" all my raols in the first day..instaed of waiting their time... etc..some pathees are FAMOUS as ..100 aangee, 200 aangee, that is they can READ 100 aanga per Raol..and these are paid as per "specialists"..at such speed gurbani cannot be pronounced properly and is just a ritual. Gurbani is NOT that weak that it can be BROKEN....people treating it like a BATON in a Relay race...where the baton has to be passed to the next runner without fall in pace and at proper speed, and not allowed to fall..are actually doing it an injustice. Gurbani must be read slowly and with Pyaar..and there is absolutley no need to race, beat the clock, swallow words, etc etc and FINISH the race in Record...stipulated time. MY family has always had a Sampooran Paathi jatha ( in fact in the good old times when parents were alive and we were all living together we had TWO FULL Jathas of PANJ SINGHS ) and we always DO all our Akhand Paaths OURSELVES....and we have NEVER stuck to any 48 hour limit..we read and ENJOY GURBANI to the LIMIT...one (Brother)paathi may do one hour..another ( Myself) may do FIVE HOURS.....and a third ( sister) may just do half hour...and ALL our AP have been accepted in SachKhand.( my personal opinion - no arguments on this) Hope this satisfactorily answers your queries.

Re: chalisa

Straight Arrow · 27 Jun 2005

Gyani Jee, What do you have against Brahmins? Pakhandis are "Brahmins in disguise of Sikhs"? Each and every religion has pakhandis - Mullahs in Islam, Priests in Christianity who are paedophiles and yes, there are Sikhs who are bad and they are Sikhs (not Brahmins in disguise), also, if you mean PANDITS, please say Pandits and not BRAHMINS. Not everything is black and white. A person is not bad because he is a Brahmin but yes there are PANDITS (priests) who happen to be Brahmins and are bad.

Re: chalisa

Dogma · 27 Jun 2005

Gyani Jee, I agree with you on the whole 48 hour limit thing. I believe there is a Sakhi of Baba Harnaam Singh Jee (Rampur Kheray) who had darshan of Guru Gobind Singh Jee and asked Guru Sahib about the whole "48 hour" time limit. I believe Guru Sahib said that the Akhaand Paaht was a practice implemented by Singhs and not by any Guru Sahibaan. Therefore, there is no real RULE about an Akhaand Paaht having to be completed in a 48 hour span. However, based on the Western work week the 48 hour time limit must be followed in order for everyone to able to attend the bhog of the Akhaand Paaht. I have YET to see an Akhaand Paaht done at a slow, understandable, loving pace with NO regard to the 48 hour time limit. This is one thing I would personally love to see/hear. And yes veerji, my queries have been answered... Waheguru Jee Ka Khalsa Waheguru Jee Kee Fateh.

Re: chalisa

JSGyani "Arshi" · 28 Jun 2005

Dear Straight arrow jee, In GURBANI..Brahmin/Pandit are used interchangeably.....Guru Ji says Jhooth na bol Pandey... and Bhagat kabir Ji asks the Brahmin...OH BRAHMIN how are you different from me IF you too came the SAME WAY that i did to enter this World ?? I am NOT referring to malign the entire Brahmin Community..of course GURU JI also knew that there are good Brahmins and not so good ones..but "Brahmin" in Gurbani and my posts refers to "CHARACTER" acharan and not to particular brahmin humans. Double edged Khanda. Dear dogma Jio, I too would love to attend Akhand Paaths that are more on Akhaand PYAAR than Akhaand "speed" and akhand ritual...and even worse just plain "pakhandee ceremony" The 48 Hr limit is self set and self perpetuating....makhee te makhee maarnee..no one wants to upset the apple cart. Educated and discernign people like your good self can begin this transition if we all insist on HEARING the Paath instead of just letting it all under the granthis to do as they wish. With so much Bani khanth and read so amny paaths... I have to admit I hardly "understand" more than a few words here and there wehn i sit through an Akhand Paath....only when I come to a very well memorised shabd can i keep up witht he pathee.. I wonder what the Sangat sitting there make out of all this ??? How many in the sangat are really FAMILIAR with GURBANI to be able to follow the pathee ?? We must take the initiative to RETAKE CONTROL of our ceremonies...insist on LISTENING and taking active part....and not just be passive Money payers only. A long time ago during my school days i was part time granthi at a small town called Batang Berjunta... a mining village. There Akhand paaths would begin at 10.30 and bhog would also be 10.30. From 8.00 pm to next 10am..it would be just pathee+ Guru ji. In MY very FIRST Akahnd paath there when I took over raol at 6am the paath was at 1408 aang with just 21 aangs and 2-1/2 hours to go. The pathee passed over to me whispered slowwwww rakhna ji. As slowwwwwwww as i could go i found the BHOG coming around 8.15... I decided to read the BHOG, did the Ardass,Hukmnama, Kirpan Bhet the degh and put the Rumaal and went home. Imagine the shock when the first sangat arrived at 10.30 as ususal hoping to hear Slok Varaan te vadheek.....and found the paath already BHOG...they still remember me as the muchh futt chhokra who taught them a lesson....that unlike the saying Time and Tide waits for No man..in this case it was GURU JI MUST NOT be KEPT WAITING by his Sikhs...

Re: chalisa

Premi · 28 Jun 2005

I really don't think the chalisa it is a big deal. Do you really think you can force Guru or God to give us something cause you sat for 40 days? Get serious!! God is all-Doing and knowing. Nobody can force him only do a bentee. Why is it every thing is linked back to Brahmins and how they have "infiltrated" us. They do something so we shouldn't. They pray so we shouldn't either? They use a Chaur on there statues so we shouldn't either?? There are millions of similarities between religions, that is just life. So you want to spend a dedicated 40 days on a certain Paat or Mool-MANTAR hey that is great news. What a gift in this time of Kaljug to be able to commit to this shabad or banee. I mean do we not in times of Happiness or Sadness do a Sehaj/Akhand Paat or other shabads, is it not the same idea. A committed time for banee for a certain period of time. Whether it be 48, 49, 52 hours or whatever. So do it for 40 days or 60 or 41 or 43, it really does not matter. Stop getting so stuck on on the small details of days or times, look at the effort of the person coming towards banee. The time constraint I would say is just to control the mind that "I have to do it for a minimum # of days", don't look to deep into it. So what if they are asking for something - Did not Bh.S.Bh Randheer Singh start doing Japjee sahib for his Exams??? It was Paat for a certain gift from God, but look where that Paat took his life, and look how that paat changed many of our lives. GOD blesses everyone. It is a well-known fact that many of the Singhs with Sant Bhindrawale that were shaheed in Harmander Sahib did do many Chaleesaa's at Rampur Khera before there shaheedie's. So what is the maryada? Well like everything in Sikhi, you must start with a heart-felt ardaas for the blessings of the Lord. Then start your Mool Mantar Jaap. He will show you the way, no doubts about it. I have personally done many Shilaa's. I find it a great addition to the regular Nitnem Banee's. I usually keep one going all the time. It is great abihaas. If you don't believe in it or have doubts on its worth, hey that is fine. Not everybody is going to learn the same way. Guru keeps us where he sees fit . Premi

Re: chalisa

A Singh · 28 Jun 2005

Gyani Jee, Again we have you seeking to use the Brahmin word so loosely, it has been shown on a number of occasions on this forums that many times, the historical events that have gone astray to Sikh principles and blamed on Brahmins are in fact that works of non-Brahmins such as Jats and this has also been shown to be a characteristic (archaran) of this group of people rather than just particular Jat Humans. Of course, this gets everyone upset, but then the truth hurts.

Re: chalisa

JSGyani "Arshi" · 28 Jun 2005

A Singh Ji, imho you are too hung up on this Jatt thingy....you seem to see a "jatt" under every stone...and seek to blame the Jatts for any and everything wrong you see. imho you should come clean and tell us all what harm any so called Jatt did to you and why you hate jatts so much and love Tarkhaans so much. Yes the TRUTH hurts..BUT keeping it bottled up inside you hurts you a lot more than it hurts us. I am referring to GURBANI and IN GURBANI...ONLY the "religious Characters" are mentioned because these were the Ones MISLEADING the people. Those mentioned are the Brahmins, the Pandits, the Kazis, Mullahs, the Benaras Ke Thugghs, . These self proclaimed Dharam De rakhwaleh were sucking the blood of the innocent people and robbing them blind under the guise of "religion". The other "characters" Gurbani addresses are the RAJEH sheehn Mukaddam Kutteh...the Ruling Class, the Nobles who were supposed to Protect the people but who were killing, looting, and robbing the very people they swore to Protect. The Gurbani also mentions Jaat-Paat as of NO SIGNIFICANCE whatsoever, as compared to the Brahmin held view that it is VERY VERY IMPORTANT..because the entire Brahmin Edifice of CHEATING and LOOTING was based on this false Premise. Hence we have Bhagat ravidass the Chamaar proudly proclaiming he is a chmaar, Bhagat kabeer is saying that he is a neech Julaha...and GURU Arjun Ji tells us that these "two kaodee they lok" (due to their allegedly low caste status imposed by the high class Brahmin) had instead become BHAGATS of World wide Fame..due to the NAAM BHAGTEE...adn their Bani has got them a Status so HIGH that millions of Sikhs worldwide BOW daily to them ( jatts are also included among those who BOW to these allegedly low caste bhagats... I am a Dhillon jatt and I BOW to these BHAGATS four or five times a day as I read Paath from Guru Ji parkash in my home)...I would trade in my jattpunna in a split second if GURU JI gives me a chance glance/kirpa on me.. And lastly frankly i dont get what the heck you are trying to say in the above message...jatts and nonbrahmins and all etc etc. I am only guessing based on your previous Anti-Jatt outbursts on soem threads on this Forum. Frankly i gave them only a passing glance as all this jaatpaat thing holds no water for me...i regard my birth just as natural order of things...for all i know in my previous jun i could have been a tarkhaan like you...or maybe even a Brahmin!!! bhul Chuk maaf.

Re: chalisa

A Singh · 29 Jun 2005

Gyani Jee, I'm glad you responded to this, for the record I don't actually believe their to be a Jatt under every stone. My posts were simply to highlight how far fetched one can take things, and in this case, with the common argument that there seems to be a "brahmin under every stone" when certain issues in texts or historical sites don't match up or fit with everyone's understanding. Examples of this include the 6 puratan rehitnamas, the hukamnamas from the Guru Sahibs Wives, the twisting of truths concerning Banda Singh Bahadur and more recently events during the 1980s, we seem to be keen to blame everything 110% squarely on Brahmins in their dhotis! For the record, I have no hang ups about Jatts, I have family roots into and out of Jatt rishtidhari. I am in fact not a Tarkhan as you have sought to assume, but chullo that's not the point here.

Re: chalisa

JSGyani "Arshi" · 29 Jun 2005

S Singh Ji, Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji kI Fateh. Its settled then. MY apologies if i wrote anything that hurt you....not intentional. Stay in Charrdeekalla.