Re: Bhangra banned for Sikh women in Jamshedpur
Harjinder Singh · 10 Apr 2003
what is this, who cares
Re: Bhangra banned for Sikh women in Jamshedpur
Kulbir Singh · 11 Apr 2003
Vaheguru jee kaa Khalsa Vaheguru jee kee fateh!
I think what we need is parchaar and not decree of this kind. We all know that bhangra is not according to Sikhi but to ban bhangra will not work. How is the committee going to monitor this? What happens if some ladies are found to be doing bhangra? What are they going to do about it? Fine them? How will the enforce it?
We don’t need Muslim kind of Fatwas but what we need is good solid parchaar done by Gurmukhs who have a practical Sikhi jeevan. I do agree that to some extent code of conduct should be enforced especially when it comes to the code of conduct to be followed at the Gurdwara Sahib. A few years ago, Delhi Gurdwara Parbandhak Committee, did a mataa (resolution or faislaa) to ask Sikh women not to wear skirts and pants when coming to the Gurdwara Sahibs in Delhi. This was not applicable on non-Sikh women. I fully agree with this decision of committee.
In the eighties, when the Sikh freedom movement was at it’s zenith, some Sikh organizations burned the barber shops and meat shops in Punjab. Most of the youth at that time had long flowing beards but they did not change from heart. It was a terrible time because you would see a person, with a full beard and dastaara but acting like a manmukh i.e. going after girls and drinking etc. It had become hard to distinguish between an amritdhari person and an ordinary person. Then when the Sikh freedom movement was quelled by the military, all those persons who had kept kesh and beard out of fear, shaved and removed their turbans.
In the light of the above stated facts, I believe that instead of issuing such meaningless decrees, solid parchaar should be done. Another flaw in this decree is that it only bans women from doing bhangra. What about men? I fully agree that Sikhs should not do bhangra but I don’t think this is the way we can stop it. It will not work. Something solid like changing one’s mind should be done.
Daas,
Re: Bhangra banned for Sikh women in Jamshedpur
Khalsa Soulja · 12 Apr 2003
yep, i agree, if u wanna teach people somethings wrong u dont just ban it, its just like prohibition in america - the problem will get worse.......all we need is more PREACHERS......guru arjun made enuf of em......look how big islam is now because of them.......sikhi has no preachers thats why we dont have a massive following, and even the people we do have, the majority are monneh who couldnt care less bout sikhi.
Re: Bhangra banned for Sikh women in Jamshedpur
GABROO KHALISTAN DAH · 12 Apr 2003
Waheguru jee kaa khalsa!!
Waheguru jee kee fateh!!
sikhs are'nt allowed 2 have fun?
Waheguru jee kaa khalsa!!
Waheguru jee kee fateh!!
Re: Bhangra banned for Sikh women in Jamshedpur
Sarbloh Badman · 19 Apr 2003
u just need people to PREACH. forget bans and stuff.
back in 82 to 84, alcohol consumption in punjab was virtually non existant. people like bhindrenwale made people forget vice and sikhi flourished to an extent. now alcohol is rampant, even if it was banned u think people would stop?
bhangra is wrong but banning it isnt the way to stop it.