Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Dated 1673 AD Adi Granth

Dated 1673 AD Adi Granth

singhdicate · 23 Jun 2005

i was going to post this on the Kartarpur saroop thread, but the thread has lost focus. my family has been blessed to have in our possession a dated 1673 AD Adi Granth, that's only 70 years after the original Bir was completed by Guru Arjun. I'm sure this purattan bir offers a wealth of insight, given my embarrassingly limited knowledge of gurmukhi a have relied on the expertise of others to help translate. here's what i've come up with so far: 1.) It is my understanding that this Adi Granth is the oldest saroop outside of India, i believe it is older then the one found at the British Library as this is dated. It was actually completed during Guru Teg Bahadur's time. 2.) of incrediable importance is a Mool Mantar written by Guru Teg Bahadur at the begining of the Adi Granth, right before Japji sahib. ( i don't know how to post pics, you can email me if you require any pics). it is actually documented in the table of contents 3.) the table of contents also states that the Japji Sahib has been transcibed from the 3 copy of Guru Ram Das's personal copy. 4.) Raagmala is present, i would like to express that this research is a work in process ( might have been put in at a later date or not, cross reference with table of content listings is needed) i have barely scratched the surface of the table of contents, if anyone could direct me to someone who has expertise in researching purattan birs i would be greatful. Singhdicate

Re: Dated 1673 AD Adi Granth

vivek · 23 Jun 2005

note - always say Guru Arjan DEV JI.

Re: Dated 1673 AD Adi Granth

Balpreet Singh · 23 Jun 2005

if you could take a photograph of the tatkaraa, it would be good. You can send all pictures to me at [address removed] and I will put them up. Where did your family find this saroop or has it been passed down in your family?

Re: Dated 1673 AD Adi Granth

rambo · 23 Jun 2005

I was wondering if raagmala appears to be added like a different style of writing or anything that appears out of teh normal. Or is it the same.

Re: Dated 1673 AD Adi Granth

Kulbir Singh · 23 Jun 2005

Where are you from Singhdicate jeeo?

Re: Dated 1673 AD Adi Granth

singhdicate · 23 Jun 2005

i have emailed the pics to "m_singh", who said he can download them into this forum for everyone to enjoy.(1 of 4 pics). all i want to say is i live just north of Toronto, the family doesn't know that i'm doing this, as everyone involved is quite protective of the saroop. singhdicate

Re: Dated 1673 AD Adi Granth

Balpreet Singh · 23 Jun 2005

veer jee has sent me the following pictures: [img]http://groups.msn.com/_Secure/0XgDrAmYa9JkqKNrlIcgUyZnLYXR2tdpqY!*9tPt7h7JfwI49viG4*WujAI9BWo6jgB68SXI!dtu*!1ERkZ1ot8qKqrrBDEtIyPFoD2rBnI6vBLtPwaHO1X7OE7Z38m7kqZp4Klfg0b0/ADI%20GRANTH%201673%20AD%20004.jpg?dc=4675527900756557597[/img] [img]http://groups.msn.com/_Secure/0XgAAAGgacpoqKNrlIcgUyZnLYXR2tdpqY!*9tPt7h7L61XmOp!ZWtqo8zpqob22atxdki0arDRHI9YsQMTv1Z4TXS7USK8h!0fp9aXRQdebqILMJR*XfGQVLuUKDAC4f3Mhix70F9Rs/ADI%20GRANTH%201673%20AD%20006.jpg?dc=4675527900785838139[/img] [img]http://groups.msn.com/_Secure/0XgABGGYa9ZkqKNrlIcgUyZnLYXR2tdpqY!*9tPt7h7IwUB6JEoBdbjlBNrbTn0a7FUm30!VjqZg!ScWsybXV8MxjjQEZEiLSjoa70iGMC47wea9AyvqJHKBpX*u6NDaaVIFRmdj9sRs/ADI%20GRANTH%201673%20AD%20013.jpg?dc=4675527900814121294[/img] [img]http://groups.msn.com/_Secure/0XgD7AmcaNJoqKNrlIcgUyZnLYXR2tdpqY!*9tPt7h7IevxYV2*EHZLwgFh1iHe2PBLb2WKX*ZKQJHRaU610ufpZpyfkazxJNcs9QtF!KyyhyNNJVMg4SJjfGeIR8Ecs3egy4LpsmsjA/ADI%20GRANTH%201673%20AD%20014.jpg?dc=4675527900843677032[/img] [img]http://groups.msn.com/_Secure/0XgD7Amgac5oqKNrlIcgUyZnLYXR2tdpqY!*9tPt7h7KTtohsz!SIMc3DtxWezsGHO!4UQL2zcTX8gE8J9*HH9B6X4piA14RTLygSee2OrXuJNw41oAaZOwvt27lRxG5wOtujrzdrotw/ADI%20GRANTH%201673%20AD%20015.jpg?dc=4675527900874993706[/img]

Re: Dated 1673 AD Adi Granth

singh · 23 Jun 2005

from the table of contents it can be seen that Ragmala comes after compositions like Ratanmala and Hakikat Rajay Shivnabh Kee. If Ragmala is bani, then the stuff before it has to be too.

Re: Dated 1673 AD Adi Granth

N Singh · 23 Jun 2005

wow, that is amazing! It looks very nice. The writing is so clean and neat. WOW!

Re: Dated 1673 AD Adi Granth

Manjit kaur · 23 Jun 2005

AND he MOOLMANTAR is clearly up to GURPARSAAD ONLY...as has been PROVEN correct according to Gurbani viakran(Grammar)...but the main na manuuusjust wont give up what their sant ji maharaj said so..Black is White !!!

Re: Dated 1673 AD Adi Granth

Singh · 23 Jun 2005

What a beautiful Saroop. I notice the additional Kachi Bani in the Tatkara (not just Ragmala but more, and also preceding it!) . Do you think the handwriting changes for this Kachi Bani at the end or was it copied from a previous Saroop along with all other real Bani? Also notice the beautiful Mool Mantar written by Guru Sahib, from Ik Oankar to GURRRPARSAD! Some of the old Birs are written so ornately with such attention to caligraphy and illustrations, such a contrast to our modern printed Saroops!

Re: Dated 1673 AD Adi Granth

seek · 24 Jun 2005

singhdicate verr ji thank you for sharing this with sangat

Re: Dated 1673 AD Adi Granth

............... · 24 Jun 2005

mool manter is conclusive. When will sants and taksal accept mool manter is only up to gurprasad? This will be another thing gone that divides the panth, just like sant jis shaheedi?

Re: Dated 1673 AD Adi Granth

cybersingh · 24 Jun 2005

>>mool manter is conclusive. When will sants and taksal accept mool manter is only up to gurprasad? This will be another thing gone that divides the panth, just like sant jis shaheedi?<< OH NO! how horrible that some people think mool mantar goes up to 'nanak hosee bhi sach'. who do these ppl think they are doing EXTRA bani with mool mantar! DAMN now they will never reach sachkhand!!!!!!!! sarcasm aside, the divisions come not from differing beliefs but from LACK OF RESPECT AND UNDERSTANDING FOR SOMEONE ELSE'S BELIEFS. people have good reasons for and against mool mantar going to nanak hosee bhi sach. but seriously, doing it up to gurparsaad or all the way up to nanak hosee bhi sach doesn't change the meaning and it doesn't matter--it is just technical information that has little or no impact in day to day practice and life bhai randhir singh ji didn't believe in raagmala where as Sant jarnail singh ji did......BOTH REACHED AKAAL PURAKH!! like wise, bhai randhir singh ji must have believe moolmantar to Gurparsaad only, where as Jarnail singh ji recited up to nanak hosee bhi sach. BOTH REACHED AKAAL PURAKH!! again, divides DO NOT come from differeing beliefs, but from lack of understanding and respect for someone else's beliefs [karma in the end] people need to be more tolerant and not so rigid and narrow minded as to think that 'their specific rehat/sikhi is the only true sikhi'

Re: Dated 1673 AD Adi Granth

Jugraj Singh · 24 Jun 2005

>>> the divisions come not from differing beliefs but from LACK OF RESPECT AND UNDERSTANDING FOR SOMEONE ELSE'S BELIEFS. people have good reasons for and against mool mantar going to nanak hosee bhi sach. but seriously, doing it up to gurparsaad or all the way up to nanak hosee bhi sach doesn't change the meaning and it doesn't matter--it is just technical information that has little or no impact in day to day practice and life >>> Veerji, it does matter what the mool mantra is, as do all things in Gurbani. It is not merely technical information but confirming that mool mantra is up to Gurparsaad also supports certain rules of viakaran that many Singhs tend to ignore. No one is going to stop you from doing mool mantra as you want to... you can read all of japji sahib and call it mool mantra but the point is to recognize that according to guru sahib the mool mantra is only upto gurparsaad. Also, whatever good reasons that you mentioned people had for believing mool mantra is upto hose bhee sach, are obviously wrong, and now those people are better of knowing that their understanding of bani was wrong and can work towards improving their knowledge. The whole point is to delve deeper and deeper into bani. Please don't just pass of gurbani vichaar as technical details. It is our guru we're talking about, not some text book. Referring to gurbani vichaar as technical details is very disrespectful and shows arrogance on your part. I think you should do ardaas to apologize to guru sahib and post a message asking readers for forgiveness as well.

Re: Dated 1673 AD Adi Granth

..... · 24 Jun 2005

When viewing the word ragmala in the index you can see that the letter 'lalla' is written differently to the ones that appear in the Jap Jee Sahib page.

Re: Dated 1673 AD Adi Granth

Manjit kaur · 24 Jun 2005

IF "they" accept that Mool mantar is ONLy up to Gurparsaad... then They have to accept that the next part is a SLOK....and then their argument about Japji Sahib having [1] here and there just like raagmalla has goes out the window.. Also that Since Guru Granth ji maharaj BEGINS with a SLOK..GURU GRANTH JI also ENDS with a SLOK...PERFECT SYMETTREY as always is with GURBANI..and then they cant argue that how can a Slok come after Mundawni...and then raagmala argument also goes out the window.. They obvioulsy cant RISK all that..,so they keep stuck to moolmantar is up to Nanak hosee bhee sach..blah blah blah..TOO MUCH TO LOSE. ( and then some bygone sant may come back and sya he diditn get salvation due to the pathee not reading moolmantar up to hosee bhee sach !!!)he he he

Re: Dated 1673 AD Adi Granth

N Singh · 24 Jun 2005

Manjit Kaur Jee, why do you have to always bring in controversial subjects and ruin a thread? WHY?

Re: Dated 1673 AD Adi Granth

wonderer · 24 Jun 2005

"BOTH REACHED AKAAL PURAKH!!" how do you know they both reached akal purakh?

Re: Dated 1673 AD Adi Granth

J Singh · 24 Jun 2005

Valid deduction on your part Manjir Kaur. However, I would have though it simply a matter of ego.

Re: Dated 1673 AD Adi Granth

Singh · 24 Jun 2005

I noticed the Lallas as well but I'm not sure. I'm assuming the Tatkara would be written once the entire Saroop was finished? I noticed that Siahi Ki Bidhi was added in the Tatkara as another piece of Kachi Bani/recipie for ink. Why would a scribe need to write down a recipie for ink if he was the sole writer? Why would he need to write down the process of how he made that particular colour ink, if he had finished writing that Saroop? Why would anyone else want to add anything? Maybe someone can explain the purpose to me since this comes in some other Saroops too.

Re: Dated 1673 AD Adi Granth

singhdicate · 24 Jun 2005

you are correct, there is a "recipe for ink" in one of the last pages of the saroop. its quite a detailed list....about half a page of detailed instructions(raw materials, measuring instructions) as i recall their was actually instructions for "GOLD" to be added to the ink..... simply amazing. singhdicate

Re: Dated 1673 AD Adi Granth

cybersingh · 24 Jun 2005

>>> jugraj singh said: "I think you should do ardaas to apologize to guru sahib and post a message asking readers for forgiveness as well." <<< no disrespect intended, i apologize. [%sig%]

Re: Dated 1673 AD Adi Granth

Jugraj Singh · 24 Jun 2005

I'm humbled by the grace by which cybersingh has acted.

Re: Dated 1673 AD Adi Granth

anon · 24 Jun 2005

WJKK WJKF We have so many things in common, yet these message boards and suprisingly mainly youth continue to make these small issues into something really big on msg boards. Which always turn into huge arguments and Singhs hating other Singhs. Before these message boards i remember there was alot of unity between jathas because the few people whho make these small differences into a hugee argument would never be heard. Arguments that have been debated at the highest levels of our panth, and on a daily basis these boards continue to act as solutions to the panths problems, but they just increase the hatred. I dont think anybody can argue the fact that there is a lot of hatred on these msg boards. What makes you think your gona change someones mind about ragmala or mool mantr, and what does it matter if you do? Our side got another person who doesnt believe in ragmala!! is that what you think. Just sit back and look at this thread, beautiful pictures have been posted and look at the arguments that have come about. And dont give the innocent routine of "ohh were just making sure everybody has the right information, these arent arguments" I disagree because i see a lot of hatred and you can tell just by the way things are said. >>mool manter is conclusive. When will sants and taksal accept mool manter is only up to gurprasad? This will be another thing gone that divides the panth, just like sant jis shaheedi?<< How is a statement like that gona further unity between jathas? Taksal is not going to except ragmala is not bani, and wont except mool mantr is up to gurprasad. So what is the point of making these small differences into such a huge thing on a message board which many impressionable sikh youth will read. From reading these boards I use to think mannn were like christians, we claim to be sikh but there are so many different groups which believe in different things. At one point I was stuck on the decision of which side to follow, and i blame that on these boards. But this is not the case at all, most jathas believe in almost the same thing, ther is always going to be some differences. Sorry if i have said anything wrong. WJKK WJKF

Re: Dated 1673 AD Adi Granth

Can't think of a name.. · 25 Jun 2005

Respect @ 'anon'

Re: Dated 1673 AD Adi Granth

Mkhalsa · 25 Jun 2005

anon, great message.. but.. >>>Taksal is not going to except ragmala is not bani, and wont except mool mantr is up to gurprasad.<<< A couple months ago I would have SWORN that taksal would NEVER declare sant jee shaheed, I figured I would be an old man before a single taksali even considered it... Point is, god can surprise you...

Re: Dated 1673 AD Adi Granth

JSGyani "Arshi" · 25 Jun 2005

anon jio, dont shoot the messenger. The Msg boards are just that..message boards. A Message Board is just as "big an influence" as the NUMBER of people who READ it....and judging from the messages that "attack" Msg Boards for dividing, etc etc it seems that a LOT of people read them and a lot of people DONT LIKE the effects these Boards are having.... a LOT of "people" DONT LIKE the Newspapers, radio, tv, Media as well and would LOVE to SHUT THEM ALL DOWN. A LOT of PEOPLE have always wanted to GET MATTERS OFF THEIR CHESTS..in the Past as well as Present... Msg Boards and the Net forums give them their MEDIUM. Just because they "kept quiet" in the PAST doesnt mean they had NOTHING TO SAY !!! WHy do you "see" HATRED" ?? Its just OPINIONS..and opinions NEVER agree 100%. I used to sit in the Sangat and be forced to hear the Sant Baba tell tall tales, FAKE SAKHIS etc which made a mockery of GURU Ji and GURBANI....so I found a way to begin writing to the PUNJABI PRESS about these...and from the MAILS i got each week from all over, i realised many many in the sangats also felt the same way but couldnt do anything. WHO WANTS to go up to the GURDWARA STAGE grab the MIKE and make a scene about a Total nonsence Joke of Itihass the sant ji/Kathakar.raagi just blah blah to the sangat. The Computer age and the Internet has been a GURU SEND for all these suppressed souls.... just look at the EXPLOSION of memberships of these Internet Forums....and the "backward" main na manoos are feeling the HEAT. On what basis can the Taksaal still deny that GURBANI has TARTEEB, GRAMMAR, Symettery, Fantastic Tamper free Numbering system, pirate proof-plagiarism free editing by guru arjun ji sahib. Their only and ONE defence is SANT JI said SO...This doesnt cut any ice wth reasonable and educated youth..hence the ANGER at MESSAGE BOARDS,INTERNET FORUMS.... accusations that these cause divisions, hatred, disunity..while on the Contrary these Boards are the Spearhead of EDUCATION of the MASSES..cheap and world wide dissemination of education and KNOWLEDGE that EMPOWERS the YOUTH...This is what actually SCARES the living daylights out of the "backard night owls" who beleive only their won Sant Jis....DAYLIGHT is COMING and they must retreat into their own deras !!! IF...just ...IF these message Boards were spreading hatred/divisions etc... I wouldnt be getting SO MANY APPRECIATIVE MAILS from all over the world regarding what I Write on them daily.... THANKS to GOOGLE MAIL which provides 2GB of space for each Account..I can NOW safely keep all these for future reference..as of last week this mail count is past 3GB and counting.. YES KNOWLEDGE is EMPOWERING the YOUTH.. FACTS matter MORE than what the "sant thinks or says"...and GURBANI is ALL PURE FACT.

Re: Dated 1673 AD Adi Granth

charanjeev singh · 25 Jun 2005

Sadh Sangat Jee, please understand the function of the Mool Mantar; and do not quarrel about the technicalities of it; which only show ones very low understanding of Gurmat. The Mool Mantar is instilled by the Punj Pyareh, in which you focus your attention by the Grace of the Guru during your entire lifetime with every breath. Focusing on the the Mool Mantar is focusing on the Guru's Message. If you focus on the Gurus Mantar from 'Ik Oangkaar to Gur Parshad'; or if you focus on the Guru's Mantar till 'Nanak Hosee Bhee Sach'; you are still focusing attuning your mind to the Shabad of Nirankaar. If Gursikhs focus their attention from 'Ik Oangkaar to Gurparshad', or to 'Nanak Hosee Bhee Sach'; they are both still Gursikhs focusing and attuning their minds to the Shabad of the Guru. When 5 Rehitvaans Gursikhs who focus attune their mind to the Guru's Shabad get together as Panj Pyareh, they bestow the Guru's Shabad to you, and now you can attune your mind to the Guru's Shabad. The Path of Gurmat is a direct Path of your 'Liv', your focus on the Shabad from 'within', where one does not preach to others; but directly converses with Waheguruu. Focusing your attention on the Mool Mantar whether it be from 'Ik Oankaar to Gurparshad', or to 'Nanak Hosee Bhee Sach', is your 'liv' directly conversing with Waheguruu by the Grace of the Panj Pyareh and Compassion of the Guru. When the Panj Pyareh bestow the Shabad upon the Sikh; that shabad is imprinted within the heart by the Grace of the Guru. If one has 'Ik Oankaar to Gurparhaad' inprinted; or whether one has 'Ik Oankaar to Nanak Hosee Bhee Sach' inprinted; nonetheless the 'Mohar' of Guru's Shabad has been inprinted upon that Gursikh.

Re: Dated 1673 AD Adi Granth

N Singh · 26 Jun 2005

Mkhalsa Jee that was a very good point!

Re: Dated 1673 AD Adi Granth

khalistani · 26 Jun 2005

taksal has not accepted sant jes shaheedi a man with 30 men cannot just dismay wat baba je said their ENTIRE life it wil never hapen, and hasnt happened dhumma has not taksal over 90 percent of taksal belives in wat baba je has said so please get facts straight dhumma only got 30 men and people like jasbir singh je rode who helped vote him out have seen the dark side of dhumma and turned AGASINT HIM mokhum sing has always been gov and said sant je is shaheed, even since baba jes times, and is known to be a gov mole baba jes bachans are coming tru before own very eyes eveb if u cant see soon allt he bachans wil showthemselves to b tru nanak daas mukh thai jo bolai ehaa ohaa sach hovai sorry for disturibing the topic, just wanted to add that in cause people seem to b a bit confused on this bhula chuka maf

Re: Dated 1673 AD Adi Granth

JagjeetSingh · 26 Jun 2005

Charanjeev jee, The Guru Fateh is olso instilled by the Punj Pyareh. Your post instill some truth about "Guru Khalsa Panth" And truthfully...gurfateh. WahegurujiKaKhalsa WaheGuruJiKiFateh WahegurujiKaKhalsa WaheGuruJiKiFateh WahegurujiKaKhalsa WaheGuruJiKiFateh WahegurujiKaKhalsa WaheGuruJiKiFateh WahegurujiKaKhalsa WaheGuruJiKiFateh

Wake Khalistani Jeo, Admit the truth or verify your facts. Please ..............

Singh · 26 Jun 2005

Khalistani Bhai Sahib jeo Wake up and Please verify your facts or correct your statement if you by mistake wrote Baba Harnam Singh has 30 men instead of 30 organizations behind him which is fact on his Dastarbandi. I am not convinced that even now Taksal is free from the responsibility of the damage done by it to the cause of Sikh Nation by misguiding the Guru Khalsa Panth about the Saheedi of panthic saheed Baba Jarnail Singh Ji but Baba Harnam Singh has taken a first step towards this and although he has to do a lot more to get back the respect and honour of Taksal but History will remember him for taking at least this first step to admit the truth at the cost of very high risk of consequences of disobeying the wrong belief of Baba Thakur Singh Ji. Wake up Khalsa Ji. Singhs of 18th Century did not give up their spirit after the death of our last human form Guru Sahib and showed so much Chardikala that within couple of years took control of Panjab under the command of Baba Banda Singh Bahadur. Even after Vadda Khalughara when almost all Guru Khalsa took Saheedee, Just two Singhs (Grand father and Grandson) put a naka (barrier) on the highway and started collecting tax from Mugals to show that Guru Khalsa Panth is still alive, in full Chardikala and in full command. If we cannot face truth or cannot realize our responsibility for the cause of Sikh Nation, we should admit our weakness but it is Ghor Bayeemani ( utmost dishonesty ) to mislead the Guru Khalsa Panth specially to this extent. khalistani wrote: Re: Dated 1673 AD Adi Granth Author: khalistani Date: 06-26-05 11:59 > taksal has not accepted sant jes shaheedi > a man with 30 men cannot just dismay wat baba je said their > ENTIRE life > it wil never hapen, and hasnt happened > dhumma has > not taksal > over 90 percent of taksal belives in wat baba je has said > so please get facts straight > dhumma only got 30 men > and people like jasbir singh je rode who helped vote him out > have seen the dark side of dhumma and turned AGASINT HIM > mokhum sing has always been gov and said sant je is shaheed, > even since baba jes times, and is known to be a gov mole > baba jes bachans are coming tru before own very eyes > eveb if u cant see > soon allt he bachans wil showthemselves to b tru > nanak daas mukh thai jo bolai ehaa ohaa sach hovai > sorry for disturibing the topic, just wanted to add that in > cause people seem to b a bit confused on this > bhula chuka maf

Re: Dated 1673 AD Adi Granth

JSGyani "Arshi" · 27 Jun 2005

khalistani veer.... these bachans coming true are called.. "SELF PROVING...facts..." I TOLD YOU SO !!! types. If a person is extending his hand towards a fire....and the babaji makes a Bachan....Bachke singh ji, tuhaada haath sarr jayega... but the singh ji continues to move towards the fire....and then shouts mera haath sarr giyah.... Baba ji's bachan has COME TRUE !!! Similarly the "fights" the multiple jathedars, the troubles...are all SELF PROVING BACHANS.... bound to happen one fine day..sooner or later..IF a LEGITIMATE SHAHEED is NOT declared shaheed, His LEGITIMATE SUCCESSOR is not chosen..and the "acting" jathedar dies INTESTATE ( without appointing the NEXT jathedar)...who will beleive there will be NO FIGHTS/ MULTIPLE JATHEDARS and dharras etc. The sad truth is the "acting" jathedar kept the MYTH of "shaheed alive" so that NO ONE would CHALLENGE him for the Post...that was his stretegy to PASS THE TIME....and he knew all hell will break loose once he died...and hence his PROPHETIC BACHANS of mayhem and infighting... Bhulla chuka maaf..no offense just facts as i see it.

Re: Dated 1673 AD Adi Granth

Dogma · 27 Jun 2005

"The sad truth is the "acting" jathedar kept the MYTH of "shaheed alive" so that NO ONE would CHALLENGE him for the Post" Gyani Jee, I believe you are implying that Baba Takhur Singh Jee only said that Sant Jee is NOT shaheed because he wished to retain the 'post' of Acting Jathedar. I think it's important to note on your part that Baba Takhur Singh Jee did not even ask for this post in the beginning and openly refused to take it even when Sant Jee had offered it to him. I personally don't think of Baba Takhur Singh Jee as the power-hungry politically motivated person as you think he is/was. How can a person who openly refused this post, as offered by Sant Jee, be turned into some power-hungry man?

Re: Dated 1673 AD Adi Granth

khalistani · 27 Jun 2005

veer jes in terms of the taksalles that used to LIVE IN METHA, dhumma only has around 30 singhs with him 90 percent havre left and belive in baba jes bachans and many people supported dhumma in the beginning because he had not done anythingbad yet, but the moment he completly went agasint taksal and baba je, he showed his tru desires for jathedareee, and many went agsint him and i u trulu belive baba thakur singh je was a liar, i feel sorry for u and it doesnt matter wat anyone really says, even dhumma or raam singh, sant jes arrival will silence these lies and jarnail singh jee i can see ure point but it is no mere coinidcence that exactly wat baba je said is happening and baab je is not the type to mislead and trick the sangats they are not like the sants that bhagat kabeers je describes as thugs they were the sants that guru je describes as beautiful,a nd come into this world for the betterment of mankind baba je was not a trickster, or liar there bachans will come tru and the pakhandees and there lies will be revealed naanak daas mukh thai jo bolai ehaa ohaa sach hovai baba je was a gursikh of the highest avasthas no one can doubt this there bachans will not prove to b lies time will show everything and reveal the lies and paklhandees and baba je was no power hungry person for jathedaree they NEVER CLAIMED the postition of jathedaree the actual story is, even when raam singh he is jathedar when baba je is alive, baba je said i was never givent he dastaarof taksal, how can i give it to someone else, adn they sant je has the dastaar of taksal and will give the seva to someone when they return baba je never claimed to b jathedar of taksal they did seva and kept taksal going, kept on giving people shudh santhia, teaching people kirtan, katha, gatka, etc. now if u really think u were higher than baba thakur singh je, that is ur choice to think that i cannot stop u from thinking that but i know this baba je was truthful gursikh, who did not lie, and did not have hankaar, they were at the highest avasthas and that if u wish to accept sant je as a shaheed, that is ure choice but no one has any right to bring taksal into this, baba jes bachans are wat taksal wil run on, dhumma HAS no authority to say sant je is shaheed thas like someone randomly from tapoban or akj just says raag maala is not banee, and then the whole panth says yep, akj has finnally admitted the truth or like me getting up and calling myself jathedar of taksal and start saying sant jarnail singh je was a terroorist that wud b stupid dhumma does not, did not, never will, same with raam singh, have the authoirrty to do thjis u can think taksal is wrong, no one can change that cept guru je, but u cant sayt aksal has said this, that is a lie dhumma has not taksal and i know time wil show the truth to everyone bhula chuka maf

Re: Dated 1673 AD Adi Granth

JSGyani "Arshi" · 28 Jun 2005

Dear dogma Jio, Sant Ji was the DEFACTO Jathedar of DT....how could he offer this to another.. Baba Thakur Ji is reported to have told sant ji that Sant Ji didnt have enough Bhagtee to sustain his fight..Sant ji never listened and went ahead anyway....the Result ?? everybody knows...( implication..NEVER DISOBEY a Brahmgiani) Baba Thakur Singh gave "the jathedari" to baba raam Singh ji and then Withdrew it due to pressure from the so called Govt agents/moles like Mohkam singh rode tetc..who wanted this for themselves. Everybody is entitled to his own opinions... imho baba thakur Singh was not that transparent as you imply. People "refuse" posts..yet apply backdoor pressure to get them that why they are called KINGMAKERS...a famous Kingmaker is Comrade Surjit CPI Marxist....he has never been offered or accepted the post of PM of India..YEt He is the one who CONTROLS each PM...including the present one Manmohan singh. For 21 years DT declared Sant ji alive..Now they Gave a Bhai todar mall Award to the policeman who cremated Sant ji in 1984..this man has been declaring since 1984..I CREMATED sant Ji....but DT said he is LYING..Now he deserves a AWARD ( for telling the TRUTH for 24 years) imho this si a gross INSULT to Todar mall Jis memeory. no offense to anyone. My personal opinions.

Re: Dated 1673 AD Adi Granth

khalistani · 28 Jun 2005

veer jarnail singh je the point that raam singh was given jathedaree is a complete lie we all remeber when it happened the newpapers said he was jathedar because first hi family started sayig it, then he too became weak to hankaar pure evidence that he wasnever made jathedar is in baba jes letter, and in a video showing raam singh very upset, yelling, pure krode, and baba je in shaantee, showing wat a tru gursikh is like, just sitting, syauing nothing pure shaant on one side, gurmukh jeevan, and anger and rage ont he other side, angry b ecause he didnt get jathedaree im sure many have watched this video already and as for baba je saying that to sant je, i have nevr heard that, im not sayuing u are lying, but perhaps the origin of that stroy are wrong but i am cannot say ANYTHING ON THIS, becayse this is first tim iheard it, but i doubt it happened perhaps some videos, letters, eye witness accounts by trustable people something like that and like i said before veer je very clearly, dhumma is not taksal even if u dont thnk taksal is right, no one on this forum has the right to say wat taksal thinks not even dhumma and his little gang of 30 people and neither raam singh has that authority thas like a random member of akj saying raag maala is not anee, and then everyone whops pro raag maala sayuing see there u go, akj finally admits it it doesnt work that way baba jes bachans are wat taksal will run by even if u think this is wrong even a third pary person can see that dhumma is going agsint taksal, and so is raam singh, ive asked thir party, aka no jatha singhs and they agree its obvious, just by useing common knowledge baba jes bachans will showthemselves to be tru and if anyone on this forum or in the world belive baba je to b a trickster or liar, or anything along those sorts, i feel deeply sorry for u i guess we can just let time show who is right and who is wrong bhula chuka maf

Re: Dated 1673 AD Adi Granth

((((:>>>> · 29 Jun 2005

This thread should not become a khalistani vs giani thread. Khalistani, you need to chill. You always act as though you are he vioce of Taksaal, but everyone in Taksaal does the complete opposite to what you say! The bottom line is there is so much evidence that Mool mantar is up to Gurprasad, why are Taksaal and sants falsely cliaming something else? As a result they are creating unnecessary divisions in the Panth.

Re: Dated 1673 AD Adi Granth

khalistani · 29 Jun 2005

ya i do need to chill sometimes go overboard sometimes i never said im voice of taksal, and i dont claim to be and noone is versing anyone here jarnail singh je and others put there views down and im putting my views down if u got beef wit my views, i cant do nothing about tha if u want me to start acceptin moolmnatar up to gurprasad and accept baba je as a liar, that aint ever gonna happen y dont u go to bhagath je about mool mantar or check out some katha on gurmatveechar.com before u talk about proof baba deep singh jes chakars also have mool manatar up to hai bhee sach nanak hosee bhee sach but someone who can explain better than me, is katha on gurmatveechar i think its there or best of all, u shud ask bhagath je bhula chuka maf

Re: Dated 1673 AD Adi Granth

so sad · 29 Jun 2005

I've just witnessed ANOTHER really fine example of 'a thread gone bad'. One where it starts so beautifully and then takes a detour into the realms of arguments. Is it just me, or can others hear the sound of steel clashing, sparks flying, egos bashing and tempers rising. I suppose there is some truth in the saying "two lions can't live happily in the same jungle". I beg you (I really do!) to check your attitude and think with a peaceful mind before ruining a beautiful thread like this one. May Vaheguru ji bless you with Santokh.

Re: Dated 1673 AD Adi Granth

Singh · 29 Jun 2005

I agree with 'so sad' jee. It is sad to see such a good thread turning into a bad argument.

Re: Dated 1673 AD Adi Granth

JSGyani "Arshi" · 29 Jun 2005

i suppose a really "GOOD THREAD" would be poster after poster..say about 100..saying.. WOW.. WONDERFUL... FANTASTIC... SO BEAUTIFUL... Amaaaaaaaazzing......... "******^^^^^&&&&&&..." There are Threads like that.... and IF..just IF someone notices soemthing "wrong" or anti gurmatt and points it out..it becomes a BAD THREAD.. Picture says a thousand WORDS....and when I LOOK at a Picture..(like that one in Beautiful Guru Ji and Beautiful Sikhs..." the THOUSAND WORDS that describe its beauty are already in my mind.....scrolling down through WOW...Beautiful...Amazing etc etc is duplicatory..I LEARN nothing except that a few posters AGREE with me that it is a beautiful picture....obvioulsy this Forum is not about that but to learn about Gurmatt...differing viewpoints notwithstanding....suffice to say i visit the Forum daily just to read those who "differ"..who knows ...they may have a point i may have missed...I have never seen anyone as an "opponent"....or hear swords clashing ( THAT i hear when I read Dasam Pita Jis Banee...if anyone can make WORDS "CLASH so realistically" it is GURU JI Dhan Dhan Guru Gobind Singh ji..) We are all Sikhs of Guru Ji attempting to learn, re-learn and un-learn..as we go along this path which we will pass only once..make good use of the opportunity. Bhulla Chuka Maaf.

Re: Dated 1673 AD Adi Granth

noone · 29 Jun 2005

One morning accompanied by Mardana, Guru Nanak Dev Ji went to the river Bain for his bath. After going into the river for his bath, Guru Sahib didn't come out for three days. During that three day span Guru Sahib met with Akaal Purkh. Akaal Purkh recited...Ik Oankar Satinaamu Kartaa Purakhu Nirbhau Nirvairu Akaal Moorati Ajoonee Saibhang Gurprasadi....meanwhile Guru Nanak Dev Ji was sitting in samadhi. Akal Purakh asked Guru Sahib what he was doing. Then Guru Sahib started reciting.....Japu Aadi Sachu Jugaadi Sachu Hai Bhee Sachu Nanak Hosee Bhee Sachu.

Re: Dated 1673 AD Adi Granth

raj · 01 Jul 2005

Let me tell you something about Harnam singh dhumma. Harnam was given to panth after his birth by his family in Dhumma village and he has given all his life to panth. He is not married and will never marry, unlike other leaders. He was with bhindranwale at the time of bluestar and bhindranwale himself asked him and some other followers to leave for safety as he knew what was coming. Police didnt allow his family to grow crops, and his family had to suffer a lot at police hands. You can point finger at people like badal, tohra etc but not at people like Harnam who have given their life to panth.