Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Validity of 5 K's

Validity of 5 K's

Khalsa Singh · 21 Jun 2005

Wahiguru Ji Ka Khalsa Sri Wahiguru Ji Ki Fthe. I was wondering if someone could help me... I go to Stanford University and one of my "non-beleiver" Sikh friends asked me why I wear the 5 K's. I had no response to that question, however he went on to say that "If Guru Nanak Dev Ji didn't want to wear a Janeu, why should we wear a Kashara or other outward symbols?" I don't know much about history, but he has studied Sikh history a lot and I didn't know how to answer his questions. He beleives in Satguru Sri Guru Granth Sahib Jee but does not beleive in our Sikh traditions. Could anyone help me find shabads from Satguru to show him that he is wrong? I fear that he will try to talk other people into becoming "non-beleivers". Wahiguru Ji Ka Khalsa Sri Wahiguru Ji Ki Fthe. Bhul Chuk Muaff Guru Ka Daas Khalsa Singh University Student

Re: Validity of 5 K's

singh · 21 Jun 2005

The janeeau was a thread given to high caste Hindus (kashatriyas and brahmins). Being born into that caste was qualification for the thread. The kakaars, most importantly are given by Guru Gobind Singh and all Sikhs were ordered to wear them. If your friend has proof to the contrary, ask him to produce it. Kakaars are not given based on birth, they are gifts given by the Guru to a Sikh who has given his head and received amrit. Anyone in the world can offer their head, regardless of birth, caste or gender. This is very different from something like the janeeau. The Gurus were not against symbolism or even ritual. They were against empty rituals and the belief that rituals in themselves will lead to God. If they were against rituals, they would not have had an initiation (charan pahul) nor a marriage ceremony nor would they have used a coconut and 5 paisey when appointing a new Guru.

Re: Validity of 5 K's

charanjeev singh · 21 Jun 2005

Tell him that the path set by Guru Gobind Singh jee is the same path set by Guru Nanak Dev Jee. The principles of the 5 kakaars are external methods of imposing internal realities. The Kesh is of spiritual significance externally which signifies the devotion of God and the acceptance of His will internally. The Kanga is a wooden comb externally that signifies that removal of bad thoughts and inclinations internally as one combs his Kesh and Kesh come out with the Kanga in the same way bad inclinations from within are removed. The Sarbloh Kara is an external Kakaar that reminds us that we are born in the Iron Age of Kaliyug and reminds us to be cautious of our actions at all times while remembering the Creator who has nor beginning nor end. The Kirpaan is an external sword that signifies the internal fire which with the Kirpa of the Guru and Dignity of His teachings shall not be used in an offensive method but a defensive way to uphold righteousnous. It is only by Great blessings that one is blessed with the Kirpaan of the Guru. The Kacheraa singnifies the internal desire of lust; and by donning the external Kacheraa of the Guru one is constantly reminded to abstain from lustful thoughts and actions. The reasons of the Kakaars are beant and cannot be put to words. Tell him that it is most important to keep the Kakaars because the Guru said so; and that is what makes a Sikh. Tell him that he may do a lot of paath; but what makes a Sikh is by doing what the Guru Says. And by doing that you have the right to call yourself a Sikh of the Guru, and more importantly the son of The Guru, and that is why you share the same last name as your Father; Singh.

Re: Validity of 5 K's

Satpurakh Niranjan · 22 Jun 2005

The 5Ks are not symbols, they are practical gifts. There is a huge difference between symbols and practical gifts. The Satguru gives these 5Ks and tells His Sikh to never be without them. The Janeu is a thread which signifies a Brahmin. Whoever wears such a thread was/is considered by Hindus as someone very close to God. However, this is not true in reality. Hence this empty symbolism of Janeu is meaningless and a million miles away from the 5Ks.

Re: Validity of 5 K's

Tee · 22 Jun 2005

eerm charanjeev singh, u accidentally put kes a kakar insted of keski ;-)

Re: Validity of 5 K's

charanjeev singh · 22 Jun 2005

eerm Tee..it was not an accident ;)

Re: Validity of 5 K's

ManjitSingh · 22 Jun 2005

and they are 5 in number not 4 as is given at some of the Amrit Sanchars.

Re: Validity of 5 K's

Hari Singh · 22 Jun 2005

Tell your friend that during an amrit sanchar the panj pyare (who speak for guru) give you direct hukam/order to never be without the 5 kakkar. -keskee -kara -kirpan -kacchehra -kanga The panj pyare are a fundamental part of Sikhi and if your friend rejects their authority then he isn't a Sikh.

Re: Validity of 5 K's

Amarjeet Singh · 22 Jun 2005

charanjeev im afraid you are mistaken the 5th k is keski. firstly if kes is the 5th kakaar y do we have to go pesh if we remove our kes but the removal of any ova 4 kakaars is forgiven by an ardaas. kes is god given we are given kes naturally, the 5 kakaars are man made and put on externally as part of rehit. guru nanak dev ji told us to keep our hair 200 hundred years before guru gobind singh ji gave the 5 kakaars:kanga, kirpan, kara, kachera, and keski, wat woiuld there to be gain by making it a kakaar when it is alredy forbidden to remove ur hair

Re: Validity of 5 K's

!! · 22 Jun 2005

Amarjeet Singh and others OK kes are given naturally then what about the nails ? Can any of you explain this to Me ?

Re: Validity of 5 K's

Singh · 22 Jun 2005

Kesh on the head grows to a long length naturally so it can be tied as a tress knot on the dasam duar. Ask anyone who does Bhagti, if the Kesh is an aid to Bhagti or not. Kesh is "alive" so to speak as it is pigmented, and the roots will secrete oils etc to keep it in good condition. One strand of hair is much stronger than the same strand of steel (fact) Nails are essentially dead. The living part of our nail provides support to the end of our fingertips. The dead part at the end is hard and brittle, and will break off if not cut during day to day tasks of manual labour. Guru Ji has never stressed the importance of nails, and nails are not documented as to be kept in any Puratan Granths (please correct me if I am wrong). However from the conception of Sikhi when Guru Nanak gave "Charan Amrit", one of the commandments always given was, "do not cut your Kesh". This is shown in the Janam Sakhis and other sources. Kesh is and always will be the central external symbol to the Sikh faith. It is blessed by Guru at birth on all human beings. It is much more important than any of the 5 Ks. We will remove our Kirpan on an aeroplane but will we remove our Kesh? We are given a Body Temple at birth and when we are ready we take Amrit and Guru Sahib allows us to adorn our Body Temple with the 5 Ks which serve to help us on the spiritual path.

Re: Validity of 5 K's

akjgreat · 22 Jun 2005

what did guru nanak tell us to keep nails???? is it a bujjar kurehit to cut nails???? hair is natural form of a sikh person........from the second sikhism started on this planet kesh was fundamental - fundamentals of sikhi for '!!' - must not REMOVE HAIR - must not EAT MEAT - must not TAKE INTOXICANTS - must not COMMIT ADULTERY these are bujjar kurehits, one must not commit these cardinal sins whether one is amritdhari or not, they apply to ALL SIKHS, even BEFORE TAKING AMRIT.

Re: Validity of 5 K's

uk singh · 22 Jun 2005

The Khalsa is also known as Akaal Purakh Ki Fauj. Every Amry has a uniform. Just as armies recognise each other from their uniforms, Amritdhari adherents are visible through the Panj Kakaars. Secondly, all armies have strict rules and regulations. For us, we have the Sikh Rehat Maryada - and if we do not follow this conduct we must own up and face the court of Punj Piyare rather than a judicial court. After the Martyrdom of Guru Tegh Bahadur Ji, Guru Gobind Singh Ji decided that no Sikh of his should ever hide from righteousness - this was achieved by giving them a unique identity and spirit. Consequently the Amrit Sanchar was established and all baptised Sikhs were given these gifts - 5 Kakkars.

Re: Validity of 5 K's

vichar · 23 Jun 2005

amarjeet singh said - wat woiuld there to be gain by making it a kakaar when it is alredy forbidden to remove ur hair very good point, i totally agree, kesh is fundamental in sikhi sikhs kept kesh from the very beginning in guru nanak dev ji's time people have to forget about pride they have for 'their jatha' and what their jatha says..........just look at the LOGIC accept KESKI is the KAKKAR stop trying to go around the point by saying stuff like "kesh is the kakkar but singhnee's should still wear a keski" you have admitted singhnees should wear keski, why cant you admitt that keski is the kakkar??

Re: Validity of 5 K's

RoopKaur · 23 Jun 2005

Bhaji, you said >He beleives in Satguru Sri Guru Granth Sahib Jee but does not beleive in our Sikh traditions.< This is impossible to do. Our traditions and rehits were given to us by Sri Guru Gobind SIngh Ji when they established the Khalsa in 1699. Sri GUru Granth Sahib Ji is the jot of the ten guru sahibans, including Sri Guru Gobind SIngh Ji. If he does not beleive in Dashmesh pita ji's rehit, than he does not believe in Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji. There are no specific references in gurbani for rules of rehit, however there are many references where it says we have to follow guru jis hukam and keep rehit, such as naam japnaa, to not indulge in lust etc. Bani also tells us bhagtaa ki chaal niraali. How will our chaal be niraali if we start following others instead of our guru ji? Guru Gobind Singh Ji has written a lot of bani on rehit, and has also said, rehit pyaree mujh ko, Sikh pyaara nahi. This shows that a person can be as good as they want at heart, until they start following guru jis hukam, including wearing the five kakaars, they are adhoorey. As mentioned before, our kakaars have specific purposes. In the case of Hindus what good does their janeoo really do them, besides distinguishing them from the other jaats? It has no spiritual significance as far as I know. But each one of our kakaars serves a practical as well as a spiritual role. A kanga keeps the hair tidy and knotless and removes dead hair. A keskee keeps our kes covered from dust and protects our head. A kirpan is our shaster, since we are soldiers, just like all worldy soldiers and police officers have weapons on them. A kachereaa is for hygeinic purposes and a karaa is a shaster, as well it reminds us that we are the cheley of Guru Sahib, they are our hathkurreaa to guru ji and should stop us from doing anything wrong. They all aid in our spirituality as well, through sarbloh and the magnetic balance from the wood in our kangha. Although I do not know the full extent of their spiritual influence, I know for sure that they do have special spiritual powers. I am sure that even if a non amritdharee kept the five kakaars, they would feel spiritual upliftment. But if a non high caste hindu wore a string around their body, would it really benefit them in any way? As for hair and nails. When we cut nails, we are simply removing the dead part of the nail. We do the same thing with our hair, when we comb it twice a day, we are removing the dead hairs that have fallen off. Obviously we cannot take the dead nail off by combing it, so we must cut that dead part off. Just as we take dead skin cells off our body by bathing sukeshi ishnaan everyday.

Re: Validity of 5 K's

http://mistakesingh.blogspot.c · 23 Jun 2005

if a person is going to wear a keski all the time anyway, why be pedantic and split the already torn panth by insisting it's a kakaar/not a kakaar. Every amrit dharee person should wear a keski of some sort, to ensure their head is always covered but getting into the whole keski argument is just creating divides when they aren't needed. http://mistakesingh.blogspot.com

Re: Validity of 5 K's

Erm · 23 Jun 2005

But Mistakesingh, what if through historical evidence it was revealed that not a single Puratan source mentioned Kes as a Kakkar, yet more than one revealed that Keski was? Given the fact that Kes as a Kakkar came in the last quarter of the 19th century, is it not wrong just to stop being padantic and "just accept Kes as the Kakkar"

Re: Validity of 5 K's

Kakar Singh · 23 Jun 2005

Wahiguru ji ka khalsa, Wahiguru ji ki fteh I beleive Veer Kalsa Singh Jee was looking for lines from gurbani to prove the usefulness of the five k's. I don't think the history behind them is relevant to this discussion. Thanks, Wahiguru ji ka khalsa, Wahiguru ji ki fteh

Re: Validity of 5 K's

vivek · 23 Jun 2005

Guru Gobind Singh told his sikhs KARA, KIRPAN, KACHERE, KANGHA KESKI, are the 5 kakkars to be worn at all times EVERYONE SHOULD KNOW THIS TRUTH, and over time many people through CORRUPT PRACTICES have brought CHANGES to the FORM OF SIKHI LEFT BY DASM PATSAH there arent any arguments to say kesh is the kakkaar, people should accept the truth leave manmat behind, accept gurmat.