Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Second Golden Temple in the making

Second Golden Temple in the making

@@@ · 21 Jun 2005

Second Golden Temple in the making Within the next three years, Gurdwara Sachkhand Shri Hazur Abchalnagar Sahib will be completely covered with gold -- making it the second Golden Temple of Sikhs, after Harmandir Sahib, in Amritsar. ``At an initial cost of Rs 65 crore, our Board has decided to add over 1000 kgs of gold to the gurUdwara,'' informed president of the Board, Sher Singh Fouji. He said that a UK-based NRI Sikh, Bhai Mahendra Singh, is one of the chief donors who has already flown down to Nanded along with 122 international craftsmen for the `golden' job.

Re: Second Golden Temple in the making

Amandeep Madra · 21 Jun 2005

This is being carried out by the same Birmingham based jatha that bodged the "gold" seva at the Darbar sahib. Given their attitude towards fixing the problems there I doubt that this effrot will be any less controversial or damaging to the original structure. 1000kgs of gold woudl buy a great deal of very necessary restoration and conservation on the crumbling sikh material heritaeg around india and pakistan - its a shame that these people cant think beyond almost literally "guilding the lilly" aman

Re: Second Golden Temple in the making

Raam Singh · 21 Jun 2005

they could better spend that money on making a proper Gurmat school and doing parchAr in order to counter the alarming rate of patitism and abortions ect. going on in punjab...but of course making the gold Gurdwara would mean more tourism and visitors (i.e more money for the Gurdwara). in the end seems like a selfish thing to do. they only seem to spend this kind of money when they know they will get it back. what ever happened to niskhAm seva? :(

Re: Second Golden Temple in the making

Hari Singh · 21 Jun 2005

I'm trying to write a post on how radiculous this is and finding it very difficult because I'm having trouble articulating the senslessness of the whole project. We are so lost as a kaum... guru sahib kirpa karan. We have made ourselves equivalent to bastard children.

Re: Second Golden Temple in the making

Heera Singh · 21 Jun 2005

... whats the point??... all that money can be used for USEFUL things... such as making hospitals, schools etc... in towns n cities.... why not put the money to good use??

Re: Second Golden Temple in the making

BS Ghuman · 21 Jun 2005

Sikh's are unable to provide Sikh children with any proper Sikh School, Sikhs have failed to take care of Shaheed families, and Sikh's are in turmoil sate at present. Looking at these things, I beleive that the 65 Crore rupees can be better spent. (if this post by @@@ is true)

Re: Second Golden Temple in the making

ANNONYMOUS · 21 Jun 2005

Money could be spent on something worth while for children, or for many other people that are suffering in India. It' s about time that money is put in good use and not to build another gudwara, we have lots of those.

Re: Second Golden Temple in the making

::: · 21 Jun 2005

someone write up a protest

Re: Second Golden Temple in the making

jkaur · 21 Jun 2005

http://www.petitiononline.com/create_petition.html I would do it but my English is not too good.

Re: Second Golden Temple in the making

Mkhalsa · 21 Jun 2005

Does nobody remember what happened to raja ranjit singh?

Re: Second Golden Temple in the making

Gurcharan SINGH Kulim · 21 Jun 2005

This is the most insensible and ignomiusly stupid idea.Building these Gurduaras and beautifying themn with Gold is nothing more than an open declaration of Sikh bankruptcy spiritually. They do not seem to be concernd about the thousands of Sikhs converting to other religions or the needs of the growing future generations, but bent on spending on Gurduaras. This must be stopped.The money used for real useful projects that will increase the meaning of Sikhi and its numbers. That is why I have written elswhere ...the Sikhs are totally confused and LOST kaum.

Re: Second Golden Temple in the making

@@@ · 22 Jun 2005

I visited Taran Tarn sahib a short while back and that to was being gold leafed from top to bottom , tarn tarn looks like harmandar sahib just that the actual gurudwara is on the edge of the sarovar rather thatn the middle. Tarn tarn sahib now looks just like harmandar sahib !!!!!!! we have truely lost the plot , when will we learn , once again the lions are asleep and it is enivitable that as soon as you forget your history it repats itself, with the increased push by RSS and shiv sena in punajba and with the GOI starting to revert back to the dark days of the 80-90's are we to blind to see that we are slipping back in to the trap.

Re: Second Golden Temple in the making

S Singh · 22 Jun 2005

>>He said that a UK-based NRI Sikh, Bhai Mahendra Singh, is one of the chief donors who has already flown down to Nanded along with 122 international craftsmen for the `golden' job. I expect it is the same team who did the bodge up at the Darbar Sahib. The Soho Road wale are intent on creating/cementing a legacy for themselves by trying to compare themselves with Maharaja Ranjit Singh Ji. If this means destroying our heritage then so be it as long as they can boast about having done the "seva".

Re: Second Golden Temple in the making

Dandilion · 22 Jun 2005

As normal people are getting hot under the collar with misinformation. The Kar sewa of Haruz Sahib is not starting, it was completed in 2003. There is no gold gilding done on the outside of the Gurdwara. The inside, where there was already gold gilding, this has had restoration done on it. As with the Harmindar Sahib sewa, no ‘bodge job’ was done, if there had there would a public outcry For those of you who have been to Harmindar sahib since, you can see for yourself that there is no bodge job. It is only the overseas fools who have some sort of grudge who get on the band wagon. [%sig%]

Re: Second Golden Temple in the making

S Singh · 22 Jun 2005

Dandilion Firstly the story states the outside is going to be covered with gold. This has nothing to do with the interior plating which was done years ago. I suggest you consult with experts. There was an outcry and there has even been a radio program on the BBC which highlighted the damage. It is not overseas fools who found the plating was a bodge up. Many of those who alerted the world to the bodge up are Punjabis who live in Punjab, many of these people are experts in their fields (conservation, preserving heritage etc etc) unlike the rent a bodger builders who undertook the gold plating job.

Re: Second Golden Temple in the making

Amandeep Madra · 22 Jun 2005

There was an outcry by experts in Punjab. Peopl who are word experts in concservation and achritectural historians. People like Patwant Singh tried extremely hard to get the GNNSJ to see that while the seva was welcome it shoudl be doen properly. Peter Poppham an incredibly well respected journalist from the Independant wrote a 1/2 page articel in 1999 titled "Brummies bodge Sikhs’ holy shrine" Peter Popham, 25 September 1999, The Independent. The BBC even carried an investigative piece on the contgroversy titled Gold Service with Dalji Dhaliwal. Its the GNNSJ that is being pig-headed in not accepting that it is totally unnacceptable to remove the original plates whcih were crafted by Ranjit Singh's expert craftsmen and replace them with shoddy copies and it is not acceptable to plaster over centuries old wall paintings and it is not acceptable to leave the Darbar sahib with a really serious case of rising damp and it is not acceptable to put a 21st century rubber membrane on the roof of the builfding (not letting itr breathe and become increasingly damp) like it was some kind of dodgy indian extension in handsworth. aman

Re: Second Golden Temple in the making

.............. · 22 Jun 2005

no one can build a harmandar sahib as Guru Ram das ji did......

Re: Second Golden Temple in the making

ns · 22 Jun 2005

Amandeep Jioo Beutifully said, when will these baba and the sikhs follwoing will get a grip??

Re: Second Golden Temple in the making

JSGyani "Arshi" · 25 Jun 2005

OUR Selayang Gurdwara roof is leaking.... we badly need a BABA JI to come here and Cover it all up with GOLD.... any takers ?? Our gurdwara will be first in malaysia to be Golden Gurdwara ???