Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Caste reforms? What about reforms for that benefit sikhs?

Caste reforms? What about reforms for that benefit sikhs?

kaur · 04 Sep 2003

looks like theres more unity for reform amongst caste than religion. Jats: Trading Caste Status for Empowerment Nonica Datta Economic and Political Weekly FOR well over a century, the Jats of north India have been engaged in two parallel processes. They have, via the Arya Samaj movement, clamoured for Kshatriya status, which was denied to them by the forward castes as well as the colonial authorities. At the same time, they have persistently appealed for reservations and fought for their status, in colonial India, as an agricultural caste. The All-India Jat Mahasabha founded in 1905, forcefully expressed these two demands. The sole spokesman of this demand, in the 1920s and 30s, was Sir Chhotu Ram, the Jat supremo in Punjab. More than two decades later, Charan Singh followed in his footsteps. Yet his principal concern was to build a coalition of Ahirs, Jats, Gujars and Rajputs (AJGR). Today the Jat communities do not have a leader of their stature, but the Jat Mahasabha, with its trans-regional networks, has emerged as a strong body with an impressive following in Haryana, western Uttar Pradesh and Rajasthan. This is illustrated by the enthusiasm generated by its campaign, mounted initially in Rajasthan for grant of OBC (Other Backward Classes) status to Jats. The strategy of the newly emergent Jat leadership has changed from the days of Chhotu Ram. Today the Jat Mahasabha is no longer interested, as was the case earlier, in asserting the Kshatriya status of its followers. Its chief concern, one that is not so often aired in public, is to access state resources, homogenise Jat society vis-a-vis the others in the scramble for power and influence, and restore the political and social equilibrium that was partially disturbed by Mandalisation. No wonder, the demand for reservations has gathered momentum, while the earlier clamour for Kshatriya status has been relegated to the 'private sphere'. Two reasons explain this reordering of priorities. First, everybody recognises that Mandalisation is a fact of life and cannot be rolled back. If nothing else, it provides a convenient reference point to various castes and communities, not just the OBCs, to stake their claims in the urban and rural power structures. Second, the reservation issue has gained, quite predictably, much salience in electoral politics. Such is the caste arithmetic and political parties ? from the left to the right ? can ill-afford to ignore it. Jat votes matter in several parliamentary and assembly constituencies. (At least in Rajasthan, it is believed, the Jats significantly influenced the outcome of the parliamentary elections.) This has vastly enhanced the bargaining power of the Jat Mahasabha and other Jat outfits. The Jat demand will not add up to very much in terms of government employment. But what is at stake for their leaders is not the percentage of jobs but political and social empowerment. So the issue is not whether they are entitled to reservations or not, but their perception of their future role in their strongholds. On this point, there is a remarkable consensus among the Jat leadership. They will not give up what they think is theirs. In the political market-place, there are enough parties, the BJP being the most recent, to go along with them. It suits them to do so. Yet the central question is this: why has the BJP, having brought down the VP Singh government on the Mandal issue, executed a volte face on the reservation issue? The explanation is not far to seek. The BJP, under Atal Behari Vajpayee's leadership, has made systematic efforts to change its image of a forward caste party and wean away those castes which had, in the past, rallied around the Congress banner. This strategy worked in Uttar Pradesh some time back, and more recently in Rajasthan. Yet the issue confronting the BJP leadership is whether such support structures can be sustained through reservations alone. Doubts may arise after Laloo Prasad Yadav?s relative political eclipse, and the political turmoil that has rocked Lucknow after the general elections. Some reports suggest that sections within the amorphous OBC category, having linked their fortune with the BJP, are n ow beginning to consider alternative political strategies. If so, much would depend on Kalyan Singh's fate in the weeks to come. If he is dislodged, there may well be a major reconfiguration of caste alignments in UP. This may not be to the BJP's advantage. Even if such things do not merit consideration in the world of realpolitik, the fact is that Jats cannot be categorised, objectively speaking, as a unified and homogeneous entity. They are an internally differentiated community. What must also be considered is the experience of UP and Bihar, where reservation has become the weapon of the strong. As a result, the original meaning of affirmative action has been lost. In other words, reservation cannot be a substitute for tangible economic measures that alone can bridge the gulf separating the prosperous Jat peasantry and the landless. Unless some corrective measures are taken at the earliest, the BJP's recent moves may well backfire. In most states, the forward castes will not relish the prospect of the limited jobs that remain being distributed further for newer groups joining the OBC category. Already angry Rajput and Brahmin groups are beginning to flex their muscles. This may not be good news for a party that is so dependent on their goodwill and electoral support. http://www.sikhnet.com/sikhnet/discussion.nsf/3d8d6eacce83bad8872564280070c2b3/1