Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Ponts which prove Operation Bluestar was wrong

Ponts which prove Operation Bluestar was wrong

Singh · 07 Jun 2005

1/ Jarnail Singh Bhinderwale had been arrested and was in government custody months before the attack. How can the attack be justified on the grounds that the government had to arrest Jarnail Singh Bhinderwale when he was already in their custody month before, and was released by the Indian Government without any charges? 2/ Further more Jarnail Singh and the 29 other so called militants the government uses as an excuse for the attack did not remain in the Temple complex 24 hours a day, but freely roamed Punjab and the surrounding areas on a daily basis. If these people needed to be captured why did the army with all its weapons of destruction have to go into the Golden Temple killing worshippers in the cross fire when they could have easily assassinated or arrested these people at any time outside the Temple complex? 3/ The SGCP management of the Golden Temple desperately asked the government on a number of occasions to produce a list of those people they wanted to capture so that the management could take action and prevent any army intervention. However the Indian authorities refused and failed to do this despite it being an option to prevent an assault, why? 4/ In April 1984 a few weeks before the armed attack the Indian Government sent Proffesor Mehar-Chan Bharadwaj and another MP along with other government investigators into the Golden Temple. On return Proffesor Mehar-Chan Bharadwaj reported in the Indian Parliament that “there are no terrosrits in the Golden Temple”, and warned against attacking the holy shrine. Why did the government blatantly ignore its own officials and seemingly without a care for the results of their own inquiry attack the Golden Temple? 5/ Why did the army only negotiate a peaceful resolution for a few hours. Recently the Israeli army waited for over a month using diplomacy and negotiations to get over 200 fully armed Palestinian Militants peacefully out of the Church of Nativity. Why was no such diplomacy used by the Indian Government to secure a peaceful resolve to the stand off, taking into account thousands of innocent pilgrims were caught inside the complex. The Indian army only followed a half hearted attempt to negotiate a peaceful settlement for a few hours and begun the assault with scores of heavy artillery rounds being blasted into the holy shrine. It appears especially when we consider how other Governments have dealt with such situations that the Indian Government was bent on the attack and preferred a settlement conflict rather than diplomacy. 6/ If the government was forced with its back against the wall to storm the holiest of shrines for Sikhs in order to capture 30 militants as a last resort why had it been preparing for the attack years before. Retired Lt-General S.K Sinha a directly involved and high ranking army leader of the time reported in the Spokesman newspaper (June 1984 pge28-29) how “ The army action was not a last resort as Prime Minster Indira Ghandi would have us believe. It had been in her mind for more than 18 months. The army had begun rehearsals of a commando attack near Chakrata Cantonment in the Doon Valley, where a complete replica of the Golden Temple complex had been built”. How can the violent military strike be justified on the grounds that militants were present in the Temple, when all the facts even from high ranking Indian Army officials show how an attack was being planed since 1982, when Jarnail Singh Bhinderwale or no other so called militants had even got inside the complex. It must be stressed that the Indian Government while suppressing unbiased international Journalists or Human rights groups like Amnesty International from investigating Operation Blue Star unleashed a river of false propaganda and lies that Militants inside had a formidable arsenal of weaponry. Without any independent proof of these claims apart from the Indian Governments claims desperate to justify the attack such allegations can not be taken seriously. However factual evidence exists of the army itself planting weapons to make it appear that the Sikhs had heavy modern weapons. “Before the President of India visited the Golden Temple the army brought a loaded truck or weapons into the complex so that it would give the impression that the militants had so many foreign weapons” H.S Bhanwar (Diary De Panne p66) 7/ If the attack was to break the back of militancy in Punjab of all days to assault the Temple why did the Indian army commence a full scale military attack with heavy artillery and tanks on a Sikhs religious festival day, when thousands of pilgrims were attending the Temple from across the World to commemorate the martyrdom anniversary of the 5th Sikh Guru. It makes no logical sense if ones intentions are only to arrest 30 militants to storm the Temple when it is packed out with innocent worshippers who would ultimately get killed and wounded in the cross fire. 8/ Why did the Government calling itself the “Worlds biggest democracy” hold a complete media blackout across the Punjab to coincide with the attack. All national and international reporters were thrown out of Punjab and prevented from reporting the truth about the attack. Only a hand full of Indian Government Journalists were allowed into the complex to produce propaganda and fabrications about the attack, and downplay the huge loss of life and destruction caused. Why would a government with nothing to hide ban unbiased international reporters from reporting news concerning an army operation. The truth is that the army attack was a massacre of innocent worshipers in cold blood which the Indian Goverment did not want the World to know about. The cold blooded genocide of men woman and children in the Temple can be seen by the independent reports below: A doctor drafted in by the army to conducted examinations reported how “Sikhs had been shot at point blank range with their hands tied behind their backs with their turban. It was a virtual massacre with a large number of woman, children and pilgrims being gunned down” The Guardian, 14th June 1984. “On Sunday, Medical workers in Amritsar said Soldiers had threatened to shoot them if they gave food or water to dying Sikh pilgrims wounded in the assault lying in the hospital” Christian Science Monitor, 8th June 1984. “On 4th June, when thousands of Sikhs had gathered at the Golden Temple, army tanks moved into the Temple complex, smashing into the sanctum and shooting everyone in sight. Many wounded were left to bleed to death and when they begged for water soldiers told them to drink the mixture of blood and urine on the floor.” (Amrit Wilson: New Statesman 16th Nov 1984). 9/ Numerous credible eye witness accounts of the attack hold testimony that after the army had killed those they were supposedly after they turned their attention on innocent pilgrims, lining them up against the Temple walls and shooting them in cold blood. If the army action was to capture or kill militants in the Temple why did the army kill so many innocent people after they had secured the Temple Complex? 10/ During British rule in India the Golden Temple was a base of resistance and from where the struggle for independence was organised, years before Ghandi even came on the independence scene. Thousands of Sikhs would leave from the Darbar Sahib after doing Ardas at Akal Takt for morchas across Panjab. However the British being the strongest power of the time never felt an attack would be justified, despite the Golden Temple being a major hub of resistance for almost 100 years. Thus how can the Indian government justify the attack with Bhinderwale only being there since late 1983. 11/ The Sikh reference library was purposely ransacked and deliberately set on fire by the army. Irreplaceable Sikh literature and items invaluable to the Sikh religion were carried away in trucks by army soldiers. Archives of documents from every period of Sikh history and artifacts from the lives of the Guru’s were stolen or burnt by army troops. Recently the Indian Minster for Defense expressed how these items will be returned to the Sikh’s but why were they taken from the Golden Temple in the first place if the attack was not against the Sikh religion but against militants harboring inside. 20 years on and these artifacts have still not been returned, why has the Indian government stolen such items invaluable to the Sikh religion if the attack was only supposed to capture 30 militants, and why even to this day have they not been returned? 12/ The government maintains that Bhinderwale had to be arrested, however the attack coincided with 37 other Gurdwara’s being attacked at the same time. If the Government wanted Bhinderwale and in their terms his tiny band of followers captured why did they attack 37 other holy shrines when Bhinderwale was known to only be at the Golden Temple. The above questions require answering and to me prove how Operation Blue Star was in fact an inevitable attack on the Sikh people. Jarnail Singh Bhinderwale was used as an excuse to justify a wide scale clamp down on Sikhs and human rites abuses across Punjab. The reclaimed academic Joyce Pettrigrew from her research into Operation Blue Star described the assault as “not on a political figure or movement but to suppress a religion (Sikhs), to attack their heart, to strike a blow at their spirit and self confidence”

Re: Ponts which prove Operation Bluestar was wrong

anon · 07 Jun 2005

of course the government wanted to cause as much damage as possible, kill as many sikhs as possible NOTE - they didnt attack golden temple complex when bhindrenwala was out with the 29 other singhs you were on about. bhindrenwala gave the government a perfect opportunity to invade golden temple kill hundreds of innocents, blow the complex to pieces bhindrenwala gave them a cover story, so india could just say they were after terrorists if bhindrenwala never set up base in the golden temple, even if the army invaded hundreds of sikhs would not hav been killed, and the temple wouldnt have been desicrated. it would have been wiser to setup base elsewhere, after all you cannot protect a structure if you are behind its walls and yo cannot protect innocent people if you are situated among them.

Re: Ponts which prove Operation Bluestar was wrong

Bhopinder singh · 07 Jun 2005

first of all commenting on such event one should always write the name in other words respect the shaeeds not writing a name is a mischief and should be avoided

Re: Ponts which prove Operation Bluestar was wrong

Dogma · 07 Jun 2005

Bhopinder Singh I agree with you. For us Sikhs it is absolutely necessary that we address our shaheeds with the utmost satkaar. However, in terms of releasing posts as above to email mailing lists, newspapers, and others it is necessary to maintain a certain amount of objectivity. If the author had used "Sant Jarnail Singh Jee Khalsa..." it is quite possible that his whole post could be ignored as nothing more than a "Khalistani" spreading propoganda.. Waheguru Jee Ka Khalsa Waheguru Jee Kee Fateh.

Re: Ponts which prove Operation Bluestar was wrong

RoopKaur · 07 Jun 2005

Why couldnt Sant Bhinderawaley stay at Darbar Sahib? It is not up to the GOI to dictate who can and cannot stay there. Any one can find refuge in The House of Akaal Purkh, or Harimander Sahib. The Indian Gov't would have killed as many Sikhs as possible even if they were not there. THey would have lied about them being there, just like they lied about the weapons they found. I do not think you understand the amount of hatred the GOI had for the SIkhs, and that is why you make a comment like that. ANd why should Sant Bhinderawaley be treated like a criminal when they did nothing wrong, while the real paapis and murders ran loose and enjoyed all freedom?

Re: Ponts which prove Operation Bluestar was wrong

ssingh · 07 Jun 2005

the usual, more "befitting", answer to the questions/points you raise above is that Indira Ghandi's re-election was uncertain, therefore their strategy was to singlehandedly create communalist conflict and be successful in defeating the crazy guys that are threatening the lives of the majority. therefore sant jarnail singh ji khalsa bhinderawalay was given covert support + overt harrassment allowing the ability to do as please with seemingly courageous personality leading to massive popularity. This threat-to-hindu personality plays both sides, acting the courageous protector of hindus + freedom fighter to sikhs, and lets off an understandable-to-sikhs, yet telling-to-hindu statements of killing 10,000 hindus. the majority populace, once frustrated with the government, feels desperately threatened and will feel so good about whoever will relieve this threaet. So gandhi concots well in advance a bluestar-end-of-road-battle-proving-gandhi-govt-importance-to-the-people. So everyone sees proof the govt will do anything necessary, so the people can trust it = wins the hearts of the people. this is the argument I believe S.K Sinha and others make.

Re: Ponts which prove Operation Bluestar was wrong

Fact Singh · 07 Jun 2005

I believe the matter of the fact is as follows: 1. Indira Gandhi wanted to take revenge from Sikhs for their leading role in the agitation against 1977 Emergency under the leadership of Sant Harchand Singh Longowal, the head of Akali Dal, the party representing the majority of Sikhs at that time. 2. Indira Gandhi made a plan to finish the Akali Dal, the political stronghold of Sikhs. For this, she chose Sant Jarnail Singh Jee to establish a parallel and stronger leader than Sant Harchand Singh Longowal among Sikhs. She promoted him to sky in a very short span with the very prominent help of Giani Jail Singh, one of her main confidant throughout his life. (I want to make it crystal clear that Sant Jarnail Singh Jee was utmost honest and sincere Gursikh Saint Soldier and he was not having a clue of this game plan of Indira Gandhi) 3. The anger of Indira Gandhi continued to increase with the stunning success of Dharam Yud Morcha going on under the leadership of Sant Longowal. Even though she was somewhat successful in creating a rift between two great leaders but she was not able to throw away Sant Longowal. 4. Indira Gandhi created the situation very intelligently through her intelligence agencies that she made Sant Jarnail Singh to become her case for her final game to finish the political stronghold of Sikhs in Punjab to take revenge of 1977 emergency. So my conclusion is that Sant Jarnail Singh Jee was not the actual reason for the attack. The actual reason was to finish the power base of Sikhs, the Akali Dal. Unfortunately Sant Jarnail Singh was made just the mohra, the planned cooked reason to invade Sri Harmandir Sahib. Sant Jarnail Singh Jee was very clean heart straight forward and was not crook to understand this game . The result was that we lost Sant Jarnail Singh Jee and our many other great warriors and Indira Gandhi was finally successful when she also got Sant Harchand Singh Longowal killed with the hands of Sikhs. In my humble opinion that the death of Sant Harchand Singh Longowal was one of the most invaluable dream fulfilled for Mrs Indira Gandhi. We are now dreaming for a leader for last 20 years who can successfully lead Sikh masses once again in a non-violent overwhelming mass-struggle. We must never forget 1978, 1984 and all what happened for 27 years and is still continuing to happen in one way or the other against Guru Panth Khalsa I pay tribute to both great leaders Sant Jarnail Singh Jee and Sant Harchand Singh Jee whom we have not been able to replace so far. I further salute all those who laid down their lives in last 27 years since Baisakhi 1978 for the glory of Sikh Nation. May Guru Jee do kirpa on his Khalsa Panth to learn from the mistakes of the past and build the future with strong GURMAT base and joining all hands together so that we can pay real tribute to all our lost heros in last over 2.5 decades by making a place in this world where Khlasa can flourish freely. Raj Karega Khalsa Khalsa Parnaam Shaheedaaan Noo *Please forgive me for any unintentional mistake and I do not anticipate everyone to agree with me. I just honestly presented what I have learnt with my own eyes and ears in last 30 years. I also have same pain in my heart as all the other Panth dardi Sikhs [%sig%]