Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

hunting

hunting

hunter_jatt · 04 Jun 2005

Dear sadh sangat, I ws wondering if you could shower me with your views on hunting, please try and focus on both the positive and negative aspects. Gurfateh [%sig%]

Re: hunting

charanjeev singh · 04 Jun 2005

If you were a deer going around finding food to produce milk for your kids, would you want to be shot?

Re: hunting

hunt ? · 04 Jun 2005

anti-gurmat except for huntin down of criminal and evil doers

Re: hunting

Waheguru · 04 Jun 2005

i dont think its right. The guru's hunted, but they had the 'power' to bless people with life and take it away. Hunting animals when we dont eat meat is meaningless murder. Unless you hunt and then free the animal without it being harmed, but your causing it distress which we'll have to re-live ourselves in another life.

Re: hunting

. · 05 Jun 2005

This Shabad is by Guru Arjan Dev Ji in Raag Gauree on Pannaa 201 gauVI mhlw 5 ] gourree mehalaa 5 || Gauree, Fifth Mehl: DoqI Koil ivCwey hyiT ] dhhothee khol vishhaaeae haet(h) || He opens his loin-cloth, and spreads it out beneath him. grDp vWgU lwhy pyit ]1] garadhhap vaa(n)goo laahae paett ||1|| Like a donkey, he gulps down all that comes his way. ||1|| ibnu krqUqI mukiq n pweIAY ] bin karathoothee mukath n paaeeai || Without good deeds, liberation is not obtained. mukiq pdwrQu nwmu iDAweIAY ]1] rhwau ] mukath padhaarathh naam dhhiaaeeai ||1|| rehaao || The wealth of liberation is only obtained by meditating on the Naam, the Name of the Lord. ||1||Pause|| pUjw iqlk krq iesnwnW ] poojaa thilak karath eisanaanaa(n) || He performs worship ceremonies, applies the ceremonial tilak mark to his forehead, and takes his ritual cleansing baths; CurI kwiF lyvY hiQ dwnw ]2] shhuree kaadt laevai hathh dhaanaa ||2|| he pulls out his knife, and demands donations. ||2|| bydu pVY muiK mITI bwxI ] baedh parrai mukh meet(h)ee baanee || With his mouth, he recites the Vedas in sweet musical measures, jIAW kuhq n sMgY prwxI ]3] jeeaaa(n) kuhath n sa(n)gai paraanee ||3|| and yet he does not hesitate to take the lives of others. ||3|| khu nwnk ijsu ikrpw DwrY ] kahu naanak jis kirapaa dhhaarai || Says Nanak, when God showers His Mercy, ihrdw suDu bRhmu bIcwrY ]4]107] hiradhaa sudhh breham beechaarai ||4||107|| even his heart becomes pure, and he contemplates God. ||4||107||

Re: hunting

singh · 06 Jun 2005

If you are a true warrior and need to hone your senses - then hunting should be acceptable. However, hunting should be perfomed using speed and physical prowess. Shooting an animal from a distance is not really acceptable. Shooting practice can be undertaken at a range. In order to heighten our senses and prove our bahadari there is no better way than to hunt. I am against Chatka on a goat with its legs as this requires little skill.

Re: hunting

haldi raam · 06 Jun 2005

Hunting is wrong. If you want to prove your bahadari go fight in a full contact tournament. If you want to hone your skills ... practice ... repetition is key. do gatka. don't kill innocent animals.

Re: hunting

Vahegurooooo · 06 Jun 2005

so it's ok to cut off its head

Re: hunting

ekta · 06 Jun 2005

killing a defense less animal is not bahadari j.... there is no acceptable reason 2 hunt unless you are in jung and need food.

Re: hunting

Roopkaur · 06 Jun 2005

>there is no acceptable reason 2 hunt unless you are in jung and need food.< Even this is not acceptable because a Sikh keeps his or her SIkhi to their last breath, no matter what the external circumstances are.

Re: hunting

Sister · 06 Jun 2005

Hunting is wrong, please don't do it, imagine your defenseless child being hunted down.....

Re: hunting

Vahegurooooo · 06 Jun 2005

agree with roop kaur. if sikhs wouldnt cut off a single hair to break their God given rehit, how is it acceptable to eat a goat/lamb/dog It just doesnt make sense.

Re: hunting

singh · 08 Jun 2005

According to Giani Takhur Singh ji, the Singhs during Guru Sahib's time didn't eat meat except during times of jung when they had nothing else to eat. Even in that case, they ate meat after going hungry for quite awhile in order to fight Dharm Yuddh. bhul chuk maaf.

Re: hunting

cybersingh · 08 Jun 2005

hunting is NOT wrong if it has purpose. it is maryada for every gurdwara to have a ranjit nagara, which is made from the skin of a dead animal. it is impossible that all drums are made from naturally dead animals. moreover, how can we say hunting is wrong when almost everyone accepts that a tabla is okay. if hunting is wrong, then playing a tabla is worng too. and i would like to point out that many sikhs had shields made out of rhino and camel skin. no one eats these animals, but clearly they have been specifically hunted for the use of shields. historically, there is solid evidence that many singhs hunted. everyone knows Guru ji hunted. of course ppl will twist this in their own way and give some far out answer. for ppl who say that Guru ji is different and a special case ...well: Guru ji had rehit too. whatever was against gurmat, Guru Sahib himself would not do. Aapai Gur Chela... so if hunting was against Gurmat, then Guru Sahib himself would not do this. Furthere more, in Sri Dasam Granth, Guru Ji describes how he went hunting and talks about HOW HE ENJOYED THE EXPEDITION!!! eating meat is one thing but hunting is totally differentt. hunting is suppose to have purpose though. its not about going out with the boys and killing something. its about using natural resources to survive. [%sig%]

Re: hunting

jagdish singh CA · 08 Jun 2005

Waheguru ji ka Khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh Roopkaur jee, Guru's spirit lives in all livings being including animals, birds, reptiles, ocean creatures insect and eggs etc. How can a SIKH, who believes in a Satguru, can hurt any of these creatures for his self-interest. As you have suggested that if you are in jungle and need a food. In old times guru's sikh used to live jungles and ate tree leaves, fruits and tree's burk to fill-filled their hunger. There is no need to kill totally innocent animal for self-satisfection quest. Remember that, if you kill living tiny animal just out of fun. You will be held responsible for your karmic account. Sikh has a kindest eye, he see His image in every's one even that heppens to be a animal.

Re: hunting

cybersingh · 08 Jun 2005

jagdish singh CA said: Guru's spirit lives in all livings being including animals, birds, reptiles, ocean creatures insect and eggs etc. How can a SIKH, who believes in a Satguru, can hurt any of these creatures for his self-interest. As you have suggested that if you are in jungle and need a food." note: Akaal purakhs jot is even in plants, which by the tone of your post, u don't consider 'alive'. then eating vegetarian is wrong too b/c it is killing life to satisfy your own 'selfish' need to live.... and fyi: an egg is not alive because it is not fertilized. there is more 'life' in a plant.

Re: hunting

Redwhiteandblue Kaur · 08 Jun 2005

I find the practice of vegetarianism that I read about here is an honest one and a moderate one. It is not as liberal as some paths...but nowhere near as strict as the vegans. With the recipe for karah prashad spelled out in Sri Guru Granth Sahib ji, I can understand why it is impossible for rehatdhari Sikhs to be vegans. I'm just curious as to how we came about the balance that is currently practiced today...and why? Why...out of all the ways that our Gurus had to sharpen their battle skills...why did they hunt? Why did they publically go on hunting expeditions? Why did our gurus sing praises to Waheguruji by playing instruments with animal skin heads and animal gut strings? Why is it that now...in modern times where synthetic alternatives are easily found...that no one notices when animal shearings (wool blankets), or animal skins (leather wallets, goatskin tablas) are brought in to a gurdwara and kept there? Don't take this as me questioning the worthiness of vegetarianism...I most certainly am not. I'm just curious as to how we got here.

Re: hunting

singh · 08 Jun 2005

an egg is a dirty substance. We don't eat meat or eggs because of the effect they have on us. Vegetarianism was not something that we "got to", it was somethign taught by the Gurus. Gurus did go hunting, but in Bachitar Natak it says that they hunted predatory animals that were a threat to setllements like bears, tigers, etc.

Re: hunting

hunter_jatt · 09 Jun 2005

Sadh Sangat Ji Gurfateh! I was wondering if anybody has actually been hunting, and what their state of mind was before and now. Its very easy to give an armchair analysis on any situation but how many of you have experienced what you write of. Gurfateh.

Re: hunting

cybersingh · 09 Jun 2005

singh said: "Gurus did go hunting, but in Bachitar Natak it says that they hunted predatory animals that were a threat to setllements like bears, tigers, etc." this is not true, b/c as i understand it, in Dasam Granth Guru ji mentions hunting deer.

Re: hunting

A Singh · 10 Jun 2005

I am a vegetarian, however I will happily accept that Hunting was practised by the Gurus and Singhs of old and now. The examples given above about jot being in all and we should be compassionate sound very much like attempts to reconcile Sikhi with Buddhist or Jain thought. We have no need to do this, Sikhi is Sikhi. Hunting, as stated as to have a purpose and not simply a bunch of "hoo haa henries" out for a day on the pigs.

Re: hunting

Hari Singh · 10 Jun 2005

RedWhiteandBlue, Please refer to the following pankti.. "naru maray nar kaam na avai, pashu maray dus kaj savaray, apne karam key gath mai kya janoo mai kya janoo baba ray..." Ang. 870 (SSGS)

Re: hunting

Redwhiteandblue Kaur · 10 Jun 2005

Hari Singh ji, I'm a moorakh when it comes to Panjabi, and many other things. What am I missing? I looked up an online reference and was not able to find that particular line...at least, not on Ang 870.

Re: hunting

Roopkaur · 10 Jun 2005

Guru ji had the power to put life back into a dead jeev. We all know this, not only from the sakhi of Vasakhi 1699, but because this everytime there is an amrit sanchaar and abhilakhees get initiated and instilled with the true life of an amritdhaaree. Bani also has many references where it is said that guru ji can give life. When they took a life, they could also give a life. Do we as normal human beings have this capability? If you agree that we do not have this capalibility or right to give life, than what on earth gives you the right to take a life of a defenceless animal?

Re: hunting

Hari Singh · 10 Jun 2005

Redwhiteandblue Kaur jee, http://www.gurugranthdarpan.com/0870.html It is the second paragraph in red. In my limited understanding, the message is that we should not have maan (be proudy) over the body because when we die our body is of no use but when an animal dies, 10 kaj (tasks) are completed. So, it would be a logical conclusion to assume that guru sahib views a dead body as simply another material thing... equivalent to say a rock. And the fact that the animal skins are used to make instruments is merely because they are fit for the purpose and not for any other reason. If say a vine was more suitable then the vine would be used ... as is the case with a sitar where I belive the large base is made from a large hollowed out kaddu. To repond to your query about sharpening battle skills through hunting... I'm not too sure that is the reason guru sahib hunted. I think battle skills where honed through abhyiaas of shaster vidiya (practicing gatka). Though it is recorded that guru sahib took Singhs (Sikhs pre-Guru Gobind Singh Jee) on hunting expeditions, it is impossible to say what Guru sahib's reasoning was for doing so. My personal belief is that Gurus sahib was living like a king and took Singhs along with him b/c Kings travelled with a large escort and Guru sahib hunted only to give mukti. To further speculate I think that such events led to Sikhs seeing themselves as one group/nation/people rather then invidual seekers. There are recorded sakhis of Singhs who killed lions but all of them show Singhs to be either defending themselves or someone else from an attack. Guru sahib gives us clear hukams in many panktis' to have daya and their are clear hukams to not eat meat ... so I don't think Singhs killed for sport or food. Doesn't seem right.

Re: hunting

Akaal · 10 Jun 2005

Meat ain't banned. Brahmanism came into Sikhism and banned it. It is just dumb. Milk and egg are same according to science. Only difference is milk has calcium mixed while egg has it on the outside. How is egg dirty? How is meat dirty? Read bani Aang 1288 on to Aang 1290. Slowly read and comtemplate. Don't rush. Take your time. Guru Nanak Ji cooked deer at kurukshater. Guru Hargobind Sahib Ji went hunting. Guru Aangad Ji made it in langar (Bhai Veer Singh). Guru Gobind Singh Ji cooked it many times. E.g. At Anandpur, at Madho Dass dera. Up until the end of Khalsa Raaj, Sikhs always ate meat. It was no issue. Then brahman and snaatanism came to Sikhism to divide us and lead us to wrong path. THey said meat is banned. Mhaparsaade Zindabad!

Re: hunting

Khalsa · 10 Jun 2005

To Akaal, You are definately a nut. You never understood Guru nanak nor guru gobind singh.

Re: hunting

lol sort it PLZ · 10 Jun 2005

dont listen to Akaal he probably cant handle the fact WE CANT EAT MEAT.

Re: hunting

everpresentdevils · 10 Jun 2005

"ITS A FREE HUNTING WORLD" everpresent devil no.1: in the old days : when some warriors r hungry ....they go hunting in jungles for 'free' animals when some warriors r hungry ... they go hunting for free fishing in rivers when some warriors are thirsty..., they go hunting for 'free' fruits trees everpresent devil no.2: in the modern days: when some warriors r hungry... they go gurdwara hunting for free langgar! when i am hungry for music... i go hunting for best ragi jatha ' free' kirtan everything is free in this world, free music, free kirtan, free langgar, free animals in jungles, free fruit trees, free milk from cows, free butter from milk, free eggs from chicken, free boys to chit-chat at rahensabhai at kirtan, free sewa, free pocket $$ from mummydaddy, free hunting and shooting down others opinion at this message board....i juz came back from the Himalayan mountains..and hey!! everthing is free up there...!! everpresent devil no.3 is away on a free vacation, will comment later. vjkkvjkffromtheeverpresentdevilsfreely seeking freshbloods of ' free' victims at midnight!! :)

Re: hunting

singh · 11 Jun 2005

But why did our Gurus hunt if we cannot eat meat? >>Guru ji had rehit too. whatever was against gurmat, Guru Sahib himself would not do. Aapai Gur Chela... so if hunting was against Gurmat, then Guru Sahib himself would not do this.<< Can anyone make a good argument against that? I do not eat meat and would never hunt because morally it just seems wrong. And sikhi follows all basic morals a human being can have. But if hunting was wrong than I just dont think our Gurus would do it. Or maybe im missing something.

Re: hunting

. · 11 Jun 2005

Guru Sahib Can Give either jeevan muktee(Through Naam Khanda(Shabad Gurmanter)) or maran muktee (Through Shaster) according to what is needed for the individual soul(Human,Animal etc.)

Re: hunting

uk singh · 12 Jun 2005

hunter_jatt - you will be hard pushed to find anyone who has hunted with skill in modern times. Punjab is not the land it used to be and opportunites for a hunt are limited if not nil. Many people have mentioned the Guru Ji hunted to liberate souls. I cannot dispute or verify this statement. This does not explain why history is littered with quotes of Singhs joining Guru Sahib on hunting expeditions and cooking maas over open fires. The latter may be an invention of the British; some say nirmalas pushed vegetarianism. Sikhs were hunting when they captured a Shahjehans Royal Hawk - this prompted the Battle of Amrtisar.

Re: hunting

hunter_jatt · 13 Jun 2005

Gurfateh UK Singh regarding your statement, "hunter_jatt - you will be hard pushed to find anyone who has hunted with skill in modern times" And why is this? Let me give my reasoning as to why this statement rings so true. It is because we have distanced ourselves from death, the act of killing has become horrific and any association with killing or violence is now seen as anti-sikh or undharmic. However the real reason for this distance lies in a deep rooted feeling of cowardice. Hunting places you in precarious situations whereby your life and the comforts of your pathetically weak capitalist world are endangered. You learn to respect your own life, you gain confidence from your pursuit and the constant strive for survival of the prey. You become categorically desensitized to killing, something that all the armies in the world attempt to achieve for their soldiers, for when one is desensitized it is only then that a soldier has become efficient. And we are the army of Akaal Purakh, an army of religious warriors who have long been in a slumber. It is time to wake up and re-ignite the warrior spirit that is in each and every one of you. Gurfateh

Re: hunting

Bundha · 13 Jun 2005

Here is my two pennies worth. We try to bring Guru Sahib Ji down to our level. If we cannot do something then Guru Ji cannot, if we are not allowed to do something then Guru Ji is not allowed. This, in my view is incorrect. Guru Ji was/is Akaal Saroop, lord of the universe, the malik of all things living and none living, we cannot equate Guru Ji to ourselves. Guru Sahib Ji ‘vaare’d’ his who family – chaar sahbizady, his father, mother – for us, could we do this ??? then why do we always regard your Guru as just like us? Guru Sahib Ji lived like Kings and had all the trappings and regalia of Kings, royal kalgi, takhat, armed guards, baaj, and hunting also came into this and when Kings presented themselves infront of Guru Ji would take them hunting also. If Guru Sahib Ji hunted, and there is no reason why they should not. Anyway who are we to question our Guru Ji anyway? (there are many types of questions, those that are asked to gain knowledge and understanding and those that we ask with an accusing finger) If Guru Ji hunted then it was to liberate the souls trapped in the animals, Guru Ji for sure could recognise the soul in the animal. There are many sakhis linked to this. Guru Sahib Ji would not go hunting alone, there would always be a jatha of Sikhs accompanying Guru Ji, as a hunting party and also as an armed guard as is proper with all royals. These accounts of maas being cooked on open fires are pure invention. For example in a book Sikh and Sikhism we have "The game would have been cooked and put to good use, to throw it away would have been an awful waste." As can be seen it is just the authors thoughts, nothing else. Or we get statements like this, H.S Singhs in his Mini Encyclopaedia of Sikhism .'Guru Amar Das Ji ate only rice and lentils but this abstention cannot be regarded as evidence of vegetarianism, only of simple living.' Why not ? Whenever Guru Sahib Ji has cooked meat it has been for the specific purpose of illustrating a point. When Guru Nanak Dev Ji asked Bhai Mardana to cook meat at Krukshaster it was to prove to the Brahmins that their faith and pride in being vaishnav was not enough to bring them mukhti, that as a pure ritual this was meaningless, what was needed with it was true devotion, love, remembrance and aradhana of Akal Purkh. It is a short step by many writers to twist this incident. As for Guru Gobind Singh Ji asking his Sikhs to slaughter Madho Das’s cattle in his asharam, again it was to hammer home a point, a point once realised by Madho Das, he submitted his whole self to Guru Sahib Ji. When Madho Das complained that his asharam had been desecrated due to the blood of the cattle, Guru Ji said “ If the blood of this buffalo has desecrated your abode then what of the rivers of the blood of innocents that is flowing in your dhase, does that desecrate you? When this realisation dawned on Madho Das he placed his head at Guru Sahib Ji’s feet. Meat stimulates your 'lower nature' making it impossible to achieve a meditative spiritual mind set, try sitting down and clearing your mind to meditate after comsuming meat, it cannot be done. If you want to evolve spiritually , open up the capacity for meditative comprehension of higher truths, gain inner peace of which you have never known before, then the karmic and polluting nature of meat cannot be ignored. [%sig%]

Re: hunting

common sense · 13 Jun 2005

"""Do we as normal human beings have this capability? If you agree that we do not have this capability or right to give life, than what on earth gives you the right to take a life of a defenseless animal?""" Roopkaur, *****admin cut for personal attack*****!! Do you have any idea how much life is killed to put food on your plate? If you don't see it with your naked eye, doesn't mean that it's not happening. Don't all the life forms that gets killed to produce veggies, fruits, honey, milk etc feel pain and don't they all have SOULs? They do suffer. You just don't see it. I am compassionate and I hate to see any life form suffer but that's the law of nature. By your logic, nature is most cruel and merciless of them all as it kills billions of life form every season to make ways for others. Man has been hunting from his cave and neanderthal days. We are called Singhs (lions) not goats and Sher doesn't eat grass. Bundha Wrote: Meat stimulates your 'lower nature' making it impossible to achieve a meditative spiritual mind set, try sitting down and clearing your mind to meditate after comsuming meat, it cannot be done. If you want to evolve spiritually , open up the capacity for meditative comprehension of higher truths, gain inner peace of which you have never known before, then the karmic and polluting nature of meat cannot be ignored. You seems to be speaking from experience. Were you a meat eater before and were unable to evolve spiritually? I assume now you have evolved spiritually, have opened up the capacity for meditative comprehension of higher truth, and have gained inner peace.

Re: hunting

Bundha · 13 Jun 2005

(Un)common Sense <<< Man has been hunting from his cave and neanderthal days >>> If you want to remain a neanderthal then carry on with eating meat. <<< I assume now you have evolved spiritually, have opened up the capacity for meditative comprehension of higher truth, and have gained inner peace. >>> If I have Veer Ji I wouldn't go about broadcasting it on the net, but alas I am a mere moorakh. But a moorakh who has come a long way. [%sig%]

Re: hunting

uk singh · 14 Jun 2005

'It is because we have distanced ourselves from death, the act of killing has become horrific and any association with killing or violence is now seen as anti-sikh or undharmic. However the real reason for this distance lies in a deep rooted feeling of cowardice.' Methods employed in war in modern times, allows one to become distanced from the blood and guts soldiers faced daily in bygone wars. This is true with hunting also. Wealthy punters from the world over arrive in African reserves to shoot game at close range. With warships, planes and laser guided missiles the US managed to destroy Iraq. The military in modern wars has changed to some extent and they only have to view the aftermath - hundreds of dead corpses and flattened towns and cities. Kharkoos in their consistent struggles managed to kill many dhushts of the Panth. Most if not all of these encounters would have involved explosives or killing from a distance using AK47s and RPGs. The bravery, mindset and physical fitness of the Khalsa during the end of the Mughal era is incomparable to the Sikhs now. Today we are afraid to squat flies and most of us have bellies to be ashamed of.