Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Sikh Woman Refuses to Leave Everest!

Sikh Woman Refuses to Leave Everest!

odd... · 02 Jun 2005

this is almost comical...I'm still not sure it's a real news story its so ridiculous... Sikh woman vows summit or death on Everest IANS[ THURSDAY, JUNE 02, 2005 01:16:07 PM ] KATHMANDU: A top Everest climber says an Indian family is pushing their daughter to her death on Mt Everest for family prestige. Duncan Chessell, who became the first South Australian to scale Mt Everest in 2001, is desperately sending out an SOS to save the life of Sukhinder aka Sukhi, an Indian woman from Muktsar in Punjab, who has been floundering above 7,000 m on the mountain for the last five days. According to Chessell, Sukhi arrived in Kathmandu with nothing except the money for the expedition. Moved by her determination, Jamie McGuinness, the expedition manager and an Everester himself, provided half of her gear. As the team headed towards the peak around May 27, it became clear Sukhi was not going to make it to the top. Yet she is refusing to come down, apparently for fear of her family's anger. Sukhi had teamed up with Project Himalaya, a 14-member international expedition to summit the 8,848 m peak in March-April. Little is known about her except that she raised part of the money with the help of a support team and her family. In frantic appeals posted on the expedition's web site, Chessell has been urging Sukhi's family to let her come down. In a dispatch Tuesday titled "Kamikaze - Indian Woman Sukhi vows 'Summit or Death'", Chessell wrote, "She is totally out of her depth - not sufficient climbing... ... experience to summit, no stamina, no speed, no skills, no balance, SHE IS THE WORST CLIMBER ON THE MOUNTAIN." A furious Chessell, who had to abandon his climb due to bronchitis, wrote from the advanced base camp at 6,600 m: "This is a dispatch that shouldn't have been posted." "But Sukhi has not given us any phone numbers or contact details, so this is in the ugly public forum." "She now realises she can't make it any higher, she has tried to move above 7,700 m twice on the rock ridge, but each time she crawls about 50 m with her Sherpa, then back again over about two hours like the most pathetic climber ever." On Wednesday, Sukhi reportedly rang up her family, asking if she could come down. In answer, Chessell says, Sukhi's sister called up the group's trekking agent, saying they would pay more if Sukhi was taken upward as "it is very important for her family's prestige". "You told her to push up - this is wrong, the situation is critical: life and death," Chessell has warned the Indian's sister. "You and you father have been totally irresponsible in pushing her on like this. Sukhi is in such a mentally controlled state by your family that she cannot reason any longer. You do not care about her, only about your family name, which is going to be put into the newspapers of India as to how you killed your daughter any day now." On Tuesday, when the team was told they had two chances to make a push for the top, Sukhi refused to budge, saying, "I will never come down without climbing the summit; if I die I will be at peace with my gods." At the last count, the Sherpas have been sent up to her with batteries for the satellite phone, so that she can call up her family once last time and ask for permission to come back. Chessell said in the over 35 expeditions he has led so far, he has never seen anything like this. "It is a cultural fatalism that I don't understand," he said.

Re: Sikh Woman Refuses to Leave Mountain!

Redwhiteandblue Kaur · 02 Jun 2005

I'm not sure if I find it comical. I find it thoroughly disgusting that Panjabis see a female life to be disposable when it suits a cultural indulgence. Panjabi Sikhs are responsible for the worst female to male ratio in the world, according to the Irish Times as well as other sources.

Re: Sikh Woman Refuses to Leave Everest!

Mr. Singh · 02 Jun 2005

>>> Panjabi Sikhs >>> Just because your a Punjabi doesn't make you a Sikh. A kurimaar is no Sikh. A lot of people claim to be Sikhs but that doesn't make them so.

Re: Sikh Woman Refuses to Leave Everest!

panjabi females jindabad · 02 Jun 2005

no wonder panjabi gurls are leaving home in big droves this is how they are treated a commodity of family name nothing else matters the life is meaningless. the day is dawning upon us in one or two generations panjabi men will feel the pinch of the panjabi women ratio heading down , ones left will move away from this kind of barbaric treatment away to other cultures. Sikhi is the only thing that can repair the damage if we get our acts together quick time. Let it slip and we will die out.

Re: Sikh Woman Refuses to Leave Everest!

no one · 02 Jun 2005

I don't think her family is pushing her and don't care if she dies because she is a girl. I've heard of many men commiting suicide because they felt they had failed their family. The issue here is that this girl completely relies on her family to make important decisions for her probably because she was never allowed to make a decision all her life and she feels guilty and wrong now to do so. The parents or a parent are most likely control freaks and stubborn and will do anything to earn false honour, no matter what happens to their daughter.

Re: Sikh Woman Refuses to Leave Everest!

Lol · 02 Jun 2005

I know Sikhs are generally poor swimmers but are they poor climbers too???

Re: Sikh Woman Refuses to Leave Everest!

news · 02 Jun 2005

So near, yet so far Stuck short of Everest, its do or die for her Tribune News Service Muktsar, June 2 Family members of Sukhwinder Kaur Sukhi, a local mountaineer on an expedition to the Mount Everest without oxygen, are worried after the news spread that Sukhi got stuck 800 metres short of the peak due to inclement weather conditions. The stubborn mountaineer has reportedly refused to return without completing her expedition. Sources said a Kathmandu-based agency, which was helping her in her expedition, had appealed her to come back, but she didn’t pay heed. A resident spoke to her over the phone and urged her to return, but she termed it as a “do-or-die” expedition for her. She asked them to persuade the agency to facilitate her way to the peak. Sukhi’s friend, Paramjit Kaur Pammi, who has accompanied her on many expeditions, received a call from an office-bearer of the agency, who told her about the threat to Sukhi’s life if she didn’t return within 24 hours. A sherpa is also accompanying her. Sukhi left for the expedition in the first week of April and was supposed to scale the keep on May 31. The International Adventure and Sports Helpline, a local club, had collected Rs 7 lakh for her expedition without any government aid. Her father, Jagat Singh, is a carpenter. Her parents are praying for her well being.