Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Animal Testing

Animal Testing

Indy · 26 Aug 2003

Can an Amritdhari Sikh study/work within Pharmacological Sciences? If indeed they can, are they cruel and/or unsympathetic? The reason I pose this question is that, Physicians, Pharmacologists and researchers in the Pharmaceutical Industry regularly test or have tested drugs on animals in vivo. Obviously, I am not an anti-vivisectionist and have no issues with the development of safe drugs. Before I moved into IT, I had completed a science degree, where tesing on Guinea Pigs was a compulsory aspect of the course. Species differences are taken into account within the design of research projects and the results of testing a new drug, for example, on animals can often be used to predict the effect on humans. Before animals are used, they will also have been subjected to a variety of other screening processes including the use of computer models, cell cultures and other non-animal tests. The simple fact is that biological science is not exact. However, until other suitable alternatives are developed, animal tests will continue to play an important part in minimising the adverse effects to humans caused by unexpected reactions during clinical trials and use.

Re: Animal Testing

Gabroo Khalistan Dah · 27 Aug 2003

vivsectionisim is the most mess'd up thing ever remmber that that animal has the same athma as u, to cause it pain is worse then 2 eat it how can u stand there and watch it suffer for ur gain???

Re: Animal Testing

Indy · 01 Sep 2003

"how can u stand there and watch it suffer for ur gain???" Have you ever consumed Aspirin, Cough Linctus, or any other man-made medicines? If so, each and every drug under these categories would have been tested extensively on animals. In addition, household products, pesticides and food additives are all tested. Would you rather have these tested on Humans, would you volunteer? The safety testing of chemicals and consumer products probably accounts for only about 10 to 20 percent of the use of animals in laboratories. The remaining 80 to 90 percent, are used in basic and applied research, education, and other arenas.

Re: Animal Testing

Gabroo Khalistan Dah · 05 Sep 2003

so indy i'm gonna ask u another qustion 2 counter u quiestions are all those things needed? asprin or ne other drugs pestacides etc. how can one have faith in god and torture his children?

Re: Animal Testing

Indy · 05 Sep 2003

As you may or may not know, I have no problems with people who eat meat, although I do not consume it myself. Saying this though, I would not hesitate for a second to appease my appetite if I had to - with or without meat. So, I guess we are looking at the whole situation from opposite ends of the pole. I do not view animal testing as torture but as a means to advance our knowledge of science for the betterment of Man and reap benefits derived from research. Most of modern day's medical marvels (such as vaccines, surgical procedures, etc.) would not have been possible without animal experimentation. Is there is a natural order to life that all living things exist at the expense of other living things and the human being is at the top order? There are instances within the Bible that show that animals were sacrificed for the good of man/woman... The history of the benefits of animal research is marked by dramatic breakthroughs. Without animal research, doctors would have no chemotherapy to save the 70% of children who now survive acute lymphocytic leukaemia. From your response, I guess you only consume herbal remedies? This is exactly what the Nihangs did when they were in battle. Cannabis was taken in various quantities as an analgesic depending on the nature of battle wounds. In certain cases, the Nihang foot soldiers were topped up in order to strike against Mughal Cavalry.

Re: Animal Testing

Gabroo Khalistan Dah · 05 Sep 2003

first of all indy paji, i dont' know how u know i've ever b'n sick or in need of medication.... i dont' really care what the bible says as i am not christian, rather i care about maharaj siri guru granth sahib ji, in which it says clearly that we are not to benifit from the blood of other living creatures u dont' view it as torture? what is extreem pain given to a living creature without a care about its living? TORTURE

Re: Animal Testing

mikka · 06 Sep 2003

gabru khalistan da "what is extreem pain given to a living creature without a care about its living?" a question just came to my mind, what about horses used? arent thbey whipped in order to make them travel? werent they used by singhs? or do they move by themselves? same for camels. if we dont whip them they wont move, hence how wud we have travelled in old days? on foot? wudnt it be cruel to sit in a tangevala vehicle in the old times if the animal was being whipped to move? also i was in a dilemna one year ago. we had a rat in the kitchen, i was faced with the issue of having to kill it or let it live and breed under my floorboards. what was i meant to do? what r we supposed to do? luckily it didnt breed and died by itself because it cudnt come out, i didnt call in the pest control. but the stench was crazy, also about 30 flies somehow came from the floorboards and filled the kitchen. now u can imagine what wud happen if i had children here.

Re: Animal Testing

Gabroo Khalistan Dah · 06 Sep 2003

mikka look at ur arguement are'nt horses whipped, how hard is a horse whipped, is it whipped to the point where its passign out in paint, its very insiginificant pain and ur rat deellima faces u with a direct threat... soooo

Re: Animal Testing

mikka · 06 Sep 2003

how do you know how significant or insignificant it is? ur not a horse to know da pain bhai sahib gabru ji, you can only judge from a human body how much u think it is with your own matt, but the truth is you dont know. rat thing bhai sahib was hygeine, but still it wud have ment taking a life in order for that hygeine. a life.

Re: Animal Testing

Gabroo Khalistan Dah · 07 Sep 2003

mikka, u can tell levels of pain, take a horse for example, when it is burnt with an iron inorder to mark it, it "hinaks" (punjabi term for the noise a horse makes) and it bucks, to show pain, but when whipped it does ntn more then run which is tought to do, that is proof look at the obvious said paji. u have a rat living in ur house, soon if u dont' take care of the rodent problem they're gonna infest ur whole house making it impossible to live within...

Re: Animal Testing

uk crew · 08 Sep 2003

During the race itself, horses are pushed to their limits, suffering consequent exhaustion and physical distress. Increased heartbeat: Horses' heartbeats can increase ten-fold during a race, from a relaxed 25 beats per minute to an excessive 250 beats, leading to potential collapse and, sometimes, to a heart attack. Bleeding lungs: 55% of flat racehorses and 82% of older horses suffer from exercise induced pulmonary haemorrhage (EIPH), whereby regular and severe bleeding from the lungs occurs during and after a race. A paper published in November 1999 in the Journal of Comparative Pathology examined racehorses performing low-intensity exercise on a track at running speeds of up to 8.5 metres per second, and found that more than three-quarters of the horses suffered haemorrhaging into their lungs. 8.5 meters per second is around 19 miles per hour. In race conditions, horses may frequently be required to achieve speeds in excess of 35 miles per hour. Bone damage: The bones of horses contain a spongy, honeycomb section inside, which acts as a shock absorber. When galloping at speed, the force on the lead foreleg, as it hits the ground, is 1.7 times the total bodyweight of the horse. The force is considerably greater when landing after a jump. Some of the shock of the hooves hitting the ground is absorbed by the spongy bone, which is compressed in this process. Dr Thomas Tobin of the Department of Veterinary Science at the University of Kentucky has shown that horses' bones actually become weaker during the course of the race as a result of this micro-crushing. He says: 'To break a normal cannon bone at the start of a race it takes about 16,000 foot-pounds of force, but the amount of micro-crushing which can take place in a race can reduce this force [needed to cause a break] to about 9000 pounds'. This signifies a reduction in bone strength during the race of more than 40%. Although technology has advanced greatly, and a broken leg does not always mean the end of a horse's career, they are notoriously difficult animals to keep still for any length of time. It also takes weeks for a major fracture to mend so, unless the animal is a winning stallion or a mare who can be used for breeding, a seriously injured horse is regarded simply as a financial burden. Ulcerated stomachs: A 1996 article in the Equine Veterinary Journal reported gastric ulcers were found in 93% of horses in training. Amongst horses who had actually raced, the incidence was 100%. Another study in the same journal found that stomach lesions appeared to progress chronically during training, but regressed if the horse was retired. Drug-related injuries: Some drugs are allowed to be administered during training. Painkillers can be used so that earlier injuries don't affect the horse's performance. This can mean that horses push themselves harder than they would have done without the drugs and risk further injury. Racehorses are normally taken out twice daily for training but are often stabled for up to 20 hours a day. Margi Stickney lectures on horse psychology and behaviour at the Kentucky Horse Park in Lexington, USA. She notes: 'Everything we have done to horses is unnatural to them. Nothing we make them do relates to what they were meant to be, a continuously grazing, moving animal... After horses come to racetracks, you see a change in their personalities. You've built this machine to perform, but you keep it restrained for most of the time... We've essentially put them in jail.' (The Observer, July 27, 1997)

Re: Animal Testing

Singh · 08 Sep 2003

I don't think Gabroo was talking about race horses.

Re: Animal Testing

pardeep kaur · 08 Sep 2003

whether a horse is in a race or used for wars in previous times and in some parts of the world today it wud be travelling at great speeds under body stress for great distances after being whipped.

Re: Animal Testing

Gabroo Khalistan Dah · 10 Sep 2003

thnx singh, iw uz talking about horses in general, i wuz'nt even talking about horses lol