Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

need clarification

need clarification

Confused Kaur · 31 May 2005

Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ke fateh, one of my relatives were having a go at me about getting into religion and then said that Siri Guru Gobind Singh Ji had 4 wives......i couldn't believe what i waas hearing... most of the family that was there said it was true....but i don't believe it..... Is it true or false?????? I'll thank you all in advance.... Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ke fateh.

Re: need clarification

Kulbir Singh · 31 May 2005

Guru Sahib had only one marriage. As was the tradition in those days, after marriage, the bride was given a new name by the inlaws. Even as late as our grandparents generation this tradition continued. Guru Sahib's Mehal's(wife) name before marriage was Jeetho jee and after marriage her name was changed to Mata Sundri jee. Guru Sahib had only one wife. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: need clarification

Bundha · 31 May 2005

I beg to differ, Guru Sahib Ji had three Mahals. It has nothing to do with changing names after marriage, there is no confusion here. Marriage with Mata Jeeto Ji July, 1677 Marriage to Mata Sundri Ji May, 1685 Birth of S. Ajit Singh Ji to Mata Sundri Ji Birth of S. Jujhar Singh Ji to Mata Jeeto ji Koaara Dhola of Mata Sahib Kaur Ji. Birth of S. Zorawar Singh Ji to mata Jeeto Ji 1697 Birth of S. Fateh Singh Ji to Mata Jeeto Ji 1699

Re: need clarification

stranger · 31 May 2005

Agree with what 'Bunda' says. Even Guru Hargobind Sahib Ji had more than one Mahal.

Re: need clarification

Dogma · 31 May 2005

Bundha Jeeo, where are these dates from? Could you provide some links or evidence as to what research supports your position that Guru Gobind Singh Jee had 3 wives? Thank you kindly jeeo.. Waheguru Jee Ka Khalsa Waheguru Jee Kee Fateh!

Re: need clarification

?????~~~~~~~ · 31 May 2005

what is Mahal??????????

Re: need clarification

Akaal · 31 May 2005

The only place where it is written that Guru Ji's had more than one wife is in the brahmnical granths. Guru Hargobind Sahib Ji having 3 wives is written in Gurbilass Paatshahi 6. Guru Gobind Singh Ji had only 1 wife. Mata Jeeto Ji was Guru Ji's wife. She was renamed Mata Sundri Ji due to the beauty. Mata Gujri Ji said she is Sundri (beautiful). There are smaadhs erected for Guru Mahals. First of all, erecting smaads is remembrance is also against Sikhism. SIkhs went in jungles and brahman took every advantage, it could. Brahmans wrote these so-called historical granths and make up false sakhis to justify themselves. People like kavi santokh singh, rattan singh bhangu, etc. were educated under brahman influence. They din find anything wroong in these sakis and wrote whatever they were told. We have to reply on Gurbani. If Gurbani says only 1 wife then only 1 wife. Guru Ji didn't preach something and do something else. As for Guru Hargobind Sahib Ji, it is said that 1st 2 marriages took place right after the martyrdom of Guru Arjan Ji and Guru Ji was 9 years old when 1st marriage took place. This is not realy reliable. As for the Paatshai 6 granth, it is a brahmnical philosophy based granth. It says Vishnu first got Darbar Sahib built from Guru Arjan Ji then he got Akaal Bunga built from Guru Hargobind Sahib Ji. It also says that Guru Arjan Ji's family went to Seetla temple when Guru Hargobind Sahib Ji had small pox. There is other brahmnical cntent there. So we can't reply on these brahmanified granths. Only sants and mahapurakhs and brahmgianis rely on that. We base our gian on Gurbani. Some sant mahapurakh brahmgiani also do parchaar that Guru Har Rai Ji had 8 wives. We can't just use historical granths and agree with them.

Re: need clarification

Princess · 31 May 2005

All Guru Sahiban were married just once. That's all brahman parchaar and it's sad when we trust brahmans more than Gursikhs. Our Gurus were not kaamee, why would they have more than one wives? If it was so, it would have been mentioned in our rehat-maryada, rehatnaame or Gurbani. In Gurbani, none of our Guru Sahib jee mentioned multiple wives when they explained husband-wife relationship(to explain Waheguru and Gursikh relationship) and Gurbani is full of examples of this relationship. //////what is Mahal??????????///// Mehal means wife of Guru jee. Due to respect for Guru jee's wife sikhs always use "mehal" word instead of "wife".

Re: need clarification

Lord Singh · 31 May 2005

Below is an article I found a few months ago, which I personally agree with: The Myth Of Guru Gobind Singh Having More Than One Wife "Why did Guru Gobind Singh have more than one wife? How many marriages did Guru Gobind Singh have? The wrong impression that the Guru had more than one wife was created by those writers who were ignorant of punjabi culture. Later authors accepted those writings regarding more than one marriage of the Guru and presented other important people usually had more than one wife as a symbol of their being great and superior to the common man. Guru Gobind Singh, being a true king, was justified in their eyes to have more than one wife. This is actually incorrect. In the Punjab, there are two and sometimes three big functions connected with a marriage, i.e., engagement, wedding and Muklawa. Big gatherings and singings are held at all these three functions. In many cases, engagements were held as soon as one had passed the baby stage. Even today, engagements at 8-12 years age are not uncommon in some interior parts of the country. The wedding is performed a couple of years after the engagement. After the wedding, it takes another couple of years for the bride to move in with her in-laws and live there. This is called Muklawa. Dowry and other gifts to the bride are usually given at the time of this ceremony to help her to establish a new home. A big befitting function and other joyful activities were held at Anandpur, according to the customs, at the time of the engagement of the Guru. The bride, Mata Jeeto Ji, resided in Lahore which was the capital of the Mughal rulers, who were not on good terms with the Gurus. When the time for the marriage ceremony came, it was not considered desirable for the Guru to go to Lahore along with Sikhs in large numbers. Furthermore, it would involve a lot of inconvenience to the Sangat, young and old, who wished to witness the marriage of the Guru. Therefore, as mentioned in the Sikh chronicles, Lahore was 'brought' to Anandpur Sahib for the marriage instead of the Guru going to Lahore. A scenic place, a couple of miles to the north of Anandpur was developed into a nice camp for the marriage. This place was named Guru Ka Lahore. People going to Anandpur visit this place as well. The bride was brought to this place by her parents and the marriage was celebrated with a very huge gathering attending the ceremony. The two elaborate functions, one at the time of engagement and the other at the time of the marriage of the Guru, gave the outside observers the impression of two marriages. They had the reason to feel like that because a second name was also there, i.e., Mata Sundari Ji. After the marriage, there is a custom in the Punjab to give a new affectionate name to the bride by her in-laws. Mata Jeeto Ji because of her fine features and good looks, was named Sundari (beautiful) by the Guru's mother. The two names and two functions gave a cause to the outsiders to believe that the Guru had two wives. In fact, the Guru had one wife with two names as explained above. There is one more very important function in the life of the Guru and the Sikhs. It took place in 1699 when the Guru founded the Khalsa Panth. For preparation of Amrit, he took a Khanda and a Bata (bowl) and asked Mata Sahib Kaur to bring Patasas (puffed sugar) for adding to the water in the Bata. Thus, Guru Gobind Singh and Mata Sahib Kaur jointly particpated in preparing Amrit. Alongwith firmness like steel, weetness is another great character of the Khalsa, gifted respectively by Guru Gobind Singh and Mata Sahib Kaur to them. Whereas Guru Gobind Singh is recognized as the spiritual father of the Khalsa, Mata Sahib Kaur is recognized as the spiritual mother of the Khalsa. Again, people not conversant with the Amrit ceremony mistakenly assume that Mata Sahib Kaur was the wife of Guru Gobind Singh. As Guru Gobind Singh is the spiritual father but not hte physical father of the khalsa, Mata Sahib Kaur is the spiritual mother of the Khalsa but not the physical wife of the Guru Gobind Singh. Because of their ignorance of the Punjabi culture and the Amrit ceremony, some writers mistook these three names of hte women in the life of Guru Gobind Singh as the names of three wives. Another reason for this misunderstanding is that the parents of Mata Sahib Kaur had decided to marry her to Guru Gobind Singh. When the proposal was brought for discussion at Anandpur, the Guru said that he could not have another wife because he was allready married. The dilemma before the parents of the girl was that, the proposal having become public, no Sikh would be willing to marry her. The Guru agreed for her stay at Anandpur but without accepting her as is wife. The question arose, as every woman desires to have a child, how she could have one without being married. The Guru said, "She will be the mother of a great son who will live forever and be known all over the world." The people understood the hidden meaning of his statement only after the Guru associated Mata Sahib Kaur with preparing Amrit by bringing Patasas. It is, therefore, ignorant to consider Mata Sahib Kaur as the worldly wife of Guru Gobind Singh." Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa, Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh!!! "Bhindranwale Sant Sipahi, Jihna Suthi Kaum Jugaee"

Re: need clarification

^ · 01 Jun 2005

kaaya kirdaar aurat zakeena || rung tamaashae maan hakeena || naapaak paak kar hadhoor hadeesa saabat soorat dastaar siraa ||12|| (Siri Guru Granth Sahib Jee- 1084)

Re: need clarification

Bundha · 01 Jun 2005

<<<<< Our Gurus were not kaamee, why would they have more than one wives? >>>> It is we who are Kamee. It is we who look upon this with our Kamee eyes. We Kamee's see things that are not there. Guru Sahib Ji was beyond Kaam but it is US who cannot handle the fact that Guru Sahib Ji had three Mahals because we look upon this with our filth ridden eyes. The truth is we cannot handle it, and it is sad that we as Gursikhs will then start to concoct these theories of Brahmincal infiltration and all the rest of it. If you want to believe that Guru Ji had one Mahal then believe it but it is not the truth.

Re: need clarification

Manjit kaur Sidhu · 01 Jun 2005

Dear Bundha veer jio, you DID NOT PROVIDE PROOF of all those dates as requested by veer Dogma Ji ... Please provide the Proofs as soon as possible. The mail above is NOT PROOF but just your own OPINION. GURU JI would NOT Go AGAINST GURBANI under any circumstances...kaamee or not is not the question here BUT GURBANI says one thing and how can GURU JI do another. By saying GURU JI is going against GURBANI is a insult that only a BRAHMIN/BIPPAR can do..a SINGH wouldnt even think about it...I am surprised ??? What is there to HANDLE ? Our GURUS were Bachana de Pooreh..and meant what they said...no IFs and No buts. The "fantastic" accounts in Gurbilas Patshai chheveen and Gurbilas Patshhi Dasween are all Brahmin influenced..and an attempt to make these two Guurs "copy cats" of Krishan Ji and Raam Chander Ji. Some of these are downright INSULTING to our GURU Jis. About Kamee... Gandhi used to sleep naked with his daughters/young women..ostensibly to PROVE thta he had his Kaam under control..these hindus will come out with funny notions..Krishan had 16000 wives and obviously he wasnt kamee either...he just married for fun ?? BUT the Four Wives tall tale has been used by the Patna Sahjib jathedar to marry a second wife while his first is still his wife ( He insists he is NOT KAMEE either) and it must be Gursikhs' FILTHY MINDS eh ?? We MUST get away from these WRONG so called historical accounts..makhee te makhee maree janee is not correct. No offense meant or taken.

Re: need clarification

Bundha · 01 Jun 2005

No offence taken Bhenji. The above dates can be found in The life of Guru Gobind Singh by Kohli and is also mentioned in Safarnama and Zafarnama by Giani Ishar Singh. Bhenji, have some respect, it’s Bhagwan Krishan Ji, and yes they did have 16000 gopies but again if you want to look at this with Kaam – eyes then that is your problem, the so called Brahmincal influences are your interpretation. Guru Gobind Singh Ji first came to this world as Dusht Daman after defeating the dhents – fantastical or not ? They did tapasia for thousands of years – fantastical or not ? are these all Brahmin influences ? Gurbilas Patshai chheveen changed by Brhamins, Gurbilas Patshhi Dasween changed by Brahmins, Raagmala added by Brahmins, we sure are getting very paranoid. If we see something we cannot understand, rather then admitting that we do not have the spiritual level to understand, rather then having pooran faith in Guru Sahib Ji, we say oh it must have been added by the Brahmins. Baba Deep Singh Ji carried on fighting after his head was separated from his body – fantastical or not, another Brahminical influence ??? Guru and Gurbani and one and the same, there is no contradiction, please show us the gurbani which is contradictory?

Re: need clarification

' · 01 Jun 2005

kaaya kirdaar aurat zakeena || rung tamaashae maan hakeena || naapaak paak kar hadhoor hadeesa saabat soorat dastaar siraa ||12|| (Siri Guru Granth Sahib Jee- 1084) kaaya = human body kirdaar = of good character aurat = one wife zakeena = belief in