Re: How My Kirpan Saved Me in Delhi
Kulbir Singh · 31 May 2005
Veer BS Goraya jeeo,
You have made us all proud. You showed real guts by slapping that Bhaiya and it is pretty disgusting that other passengers on the bus did not immediately snub that bhaiya for making such racial and communal remarks but instead held you responsible for slapping that bhaiya.
Once again Shabaash to you!
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: How My Kirpan Saved Me in Delhi
Can't think of a name.. · 31 May 2005
On a side note to any youngsters reading this, don’t be inspired by this to the extent that you lash out at someone who comments on you as a Sikh.
In western countries you won’t get away with slapping someone as far as the Law is concerned and pulling out your Kirpan may result in a major backlash for the whole Sikh Community.
Though this incident may be inspiring, don’t be hasty in dishing out the same kind of treatment to those around you unless you are in a situation where you have no choice and have to as a last resort.
Think before you act, as violence is the resort.
Re: How My Kirpan Saved Me in Delhi
Can't think of a name.. · 31 May 2005
Think before you act, as violence is the LAST* resort.
Re: How My Kirpan Saved Me in Delhi
Redwhiteandblue Kaur · 31 May 2005
In many places, particularly the West, there are Sikhs of many races and backgrounds that are quietly and selflessly giving up part of their life to combat the notion that the Sikh turban (and/or beard) means that Sikhs are violent people.
Is that seva done in vain?
Re: How My Kirpan Saved Me in Delhi
Bhopinder singh · 31 May 2005
Their is a difference in west and India here you can call the police or sue the person also people are more litterate they will become witness to the act of verbal violence and therefore you are well protected on the other hand in India your argument is totally absurd and nonsense. What the singh did was justified
I dont think he should have turned the other cheek because that would only mean he joined the smoker .
After getting their womenfolk raped and paraded naked in Delhi Sikhs were murdered in thousands not one person executed or killed in fake encounter to this day YES LIFTING OF SWORD IS JUSTIFIED IRAQ VIETNAM AFGHANISTAN stand as monuments to the concept of no superpower in conventional terms
Re: How My Kirpan Saved Me in Delhi
./././././././././././././ · 31 May 2005
sum guy at my skool made fun of another kesdharis kes, wud it b ok if a bunch of us jumped him?
Re: How My Kirpan Saved Me in Delhi
Can't think of a name.. · 01 Jun 2005
Author: Bhopinder singh
Date: 05-31-05 16:05
Their is a difference in west and India here you can call the police or sue the person also people are more litterate they will become witness to the act of verbal violence and therefore you are well protected on the other hand in India your argument is totally absurd and nonsense. What the singh did was justified
I dont think he should have turned the other cheek because that would only mean he joined the smoker .
After getting their womenfolk raped and paraded naked in Delhi Sikhs were murdered in thousands not one person executed or killed in fake encounter to this day YES LIFTING OF SWORD IS JUSTIFIED IRAQ VIETNAM AFGHANISTAN stand as monuments to the concept of no superpower in conventional terms
*****
I don’t know if your post is aimed directly at me or not, but if you reread what I originally said I think you’ll find that I am not arguing against what happened and nor am I saying the person ‘should have turned the other cheek’. I have not commented on the actions of the person involved or stated whether I think what they did is justified or not.
I have simply stated that physically hitting someone in a western country for whatever reason can easily result in the Law getting involved. Also taking out your Kirpan in a public place like a bus could result in a major backlash for the whole Sikh Community.
If as a last resort this needs to be done then that’s what we carry a shastar for; to be able to defend ourselves and others, but with that comes responsibility.
Re: How My Kirpan Saved Me in Delhi
Bhopinder singh · 01 Jun 2005
At the same time he was talking of a different senario there was no need to compare with the west
Re: How My Kirpan Saved Me in Delhi
Bhopinder singh · 01 Jun 2005
At the same time Sikhs 90% of them would have turned the other cheak in the present India for what the bhia did ( smoke) and what he said catogorically refering to the genocide and the response of the onlooker also joining him to scare the singh
He basically merely defended himself as they could have harmed him seriously
Re: How My Kirpan Saved Me in Delhi
Can't think of a name.. · 01 Jun 2005
Author: Bhopinder singh
Date: 06-01-05 10:02
At the same time he was talking of a different senario there was no need to compare with the west
*****
Well considering a large number of people from the West happen to visit this forum I don’t see why it can’t be related to the West.
Fact of the matter is youngsters visit this forum and may well be inspired from the story and there is nothing wrong with that, though if they were to do the same where they are situated they may end up in a fair amount of trouble (as I have mentioned in my posts above).
Re: How My Kirpan Saved Me in Delhi
Bhopinder singh · 01 Jun 2005
The word Delhi in the heading is sufficient infact the western kids were learning about Delhi it was a learning event or shall i say preparing them for the harsh reaility the Sikhs are facing and living in DELHI. That was all i meant