Inside the Tamboo
Question Bhai · 29 May 2005
Did Guru Gobind Singh Ji "kill" the Panj ? And then they came out from the tamboo "alive" ?
Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton
ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥
Question Bhai · 29 May 2005
Did Guru Gobind Singh Ji "kill" the Panj ? And then they came out from the tamboo "alive" ?^ · 30 May 2005
sathigur maeraa sarab prathipaalai || My True Guru is the Sustainer and Cherisher of all. sathigur maeraa maar jeevaalai || My True Guru kills and revives. sathigur maerae kee vaddiaaee || pragatt bhee hai sabhanee thhaaee ||2|| The glorious greatness of my True Guru has become manifest everywhere. ||2|| (Siri Guru Granth Sahib Jee - 1142)Seeker · 30 May 2005
I don't think so....he did not kill anybody inside the Tamboo....that is a made up story to create sensation^ · 30 May 2005
This Shabad is by Guru Arjan Dev Ji in Raag Gauree on Pannaa 283 mirathak ko jeevaalanehaar || He infuses life back into the dead. bhookhae ko dhaevath adhhaar || He gives food to the hungry. sarab nidhhaan jaa kee dhrisattee maahi || All treasures are within His Glance of Grace. purab likhae kaa lehanaa paahi || People obtain that which they are pre-ordained to receive. sabh kishh this kaa ouhu karanai jog || All things are His; He is the Doer of all. this bin dhoosar hoaa n hog || Other than Him, there has never been any other, and there shall never be. jap jan sadhaa sadhaa dhin rainee || Meditate on Him forever and ever, day and night. sabh thae ooch niramal eih karanee || This way of life is exalted and immaculate. kar kirapaa jis ko naam dheeaa || One whom the Lord, in His Grace, blesses with His Name naanak so jan niramal thheeaa ||7|| - O Nanak, that person becomes immaculate and pure. ||7|| (Siri Guru Granth Sahib Jee)Mehtab Singh · 30 May 2005
So u think Gurujee didn't have samratha do bring back dead to life ? People have made up stories that Gurujee beheaded goats, dunno where they got that idea from! ps : and why goats? LOLekta · 30 May 2005
then plz expalin what guru ji did inside the tamboo that magnificent day of April 14th, 1699.S Singh · 30 May 2005
Interesting what you say Seeker as if you say that to many others they are ready to bit your head off. But if we look back into history and read the sakhi about Baba Gurditta and how he had to give up his life after bringing a cow to life and Baba Atal Rai giving up his life after bringing his friend to life we can see that Guru Hargobind Sahib was against showing such miracles as they interfered with the way of nature.Question Bhai · 30 May 2005
Dear Seeker Jio There are only two thoughts: (1) The Panj were killed and brought back to life or (2) There were "Bakaray" in the Tamboo I don't believe in (2) but would like to know why (1) was so necessary ?Manjit Kaur Sidhu · 30 May 2005
[gurbani] <>vwihgurU jI kI Piqh ][/gurbani] NO dear question Bhai jio, NOT just two thoughts ??? Why not "three thoughts"??? Now that we are at it eh... WHY the need to have LIVE Bakrays ?? Couldnt we just put a bucket full of fresh blood for Guru ji to just dip his sword in ?? Or it was just some Tomato Ketchup/red ink.... like in the Movies ( THAT would FIT in very well with a VEGETARIAN GURU Ji/no cruelty/killing of innocent animals also ?? yes ?? no ??) ALL this MENTAL CALISNETHICS ( acobatic Gymanastics ??) is a SHEER WASTE of our time...and an INSULT to GURU JI.....which no SINGH of GURU JI would indulge in. IF GURU JI wanted everyone to Wittness everything..there would have been NO Tamboo ?? Or Guru Ji would have called in Wittnesses...or do a THOUSAND other things ??? Yes ?? No ?? IDLE SPECULATION....a complete waste of precious time. The PANJ PIYARE were CHOSEN by EACH GURU SAHIB..right from GURU NANAK JI SAHIB onwards...Panch Parwaan panch Pardhaan..Pancheh Paveh Dargeh maan. Sometimes in History all five are mentioned soemtimes not..BUT EACH GURU JI had FIVE PIYARAS. [gurbani] <>vwihgurU jI kI Piqh ][/gurbani]singh · 30 May 2005
>>(1) The Panj were killed and brought back to life or (2) There were "Bakaray" in the Tamboo<< WJKK WJKF I think number 1 also, and there is a reason behind that. Guru ji wanted to show that by cutting there heads they will have a new life in khalsa panth when they take amrit, there is a reason behind everything lets not go that low and start saying guru ji was cuting goats heads... why wud guru call 5 people up take them to a tent and then start cutting goats heads lol. Also the guru placed the heads on different bodies just to show equality.. i think guru ji wanted to show when u becomes khalsa we all are equal... SATGUR AGAI SIS BHET DHEO WJKK WJKFS Singh · 31 May 2005
singh, Excuse my ignorance but if what you are saying about head transplants is true then would that not be a miracle ? Would that not go against what Guru Hargobind Ji taught in the case of Baba Gurditta and Baba Atal Rai ?Bundha · 31 May 2005
In my humble opinion it was definitely the heads being separated and then joined again. It is totally different if something is done by Guru Ji or it is done by someone else. That someone else may be very closely related to Guru Ji or of a high avasta, but he is not the Guru so you cannot compare the two. Guru Sahib Ji was one with God, so whatever they did was totally in tune with the will of God. This was a most momentous occasion, the birth of the Khalsa, it needed a most amazing act, one that would be remembered in the annals of time. The panj piyaray were tested to the full, not just that they were prepared to give their heads but to see if they actually could/would give their heads, they passed the test. From time to time Guru Sahib Ji have shown karamaats. Is anyone going to deny that Guru Nanak Dev Ji did not squeeze the roti of Malik Bhago and Bhai Lalo ji? What about the punja at Punja Sahib ? what about the stream that flowed crystal clear water when Guru Ji lifted a slab of rock for Mardana Ji to take a drink? What about the water the flows at Trabaini Sahib near Anandpur Sahib where Guru Gobind Singh Ji struck the ground three times and water sprung up? What about Putthi Sahib where Guru Gobind Singh Ji made the kiln cold in an instant (whereas normally it takes a week for a kiln to cool down) and spent the night in it? What about when Bhai Biddhi Chand took the name of Guru Hargobind Sahib Ji and jumped into a kiln, and all the heat started to transfer to Guru Ji? What about when Guru Harkrishan Ji touched a peasant and he started to recite the translations of the Vedas? Are our ‘modern’ Sikhs going to reject all these as made up stories ? On a side note, if we take the time when Guru Sahib Ji left this world at Nanded, 1708, we as Sikhs take it ‘matter-of-fact’ that Guru Ji was seen afterwards when He rescued some Sikhs from a jail and told another to tell the Sikh sangats that Guru Ji would be with them for always, it is no big deal to us as we know that Guru Ji is with us for always. Yet in Christianity it is the corner stone of their faith, that Jesus rose from the dead, if this fact does not exist their whole faith falls apart.Princess · 31 May 2005
S. Singh jee, what about eighth Guru sahib jee's miracle when he made one of his sikhs named Chajju jheer who was even goonga, uchaar Bhagvati Geeta? ////(1) The Panj were killed and brought back to life////// # 1 is right because Guru Sahib jee is not a cheater or lier, He did what He said. "Satgur mera vad samratha"Irrelevant. · 31 May 2005
It is irrelevant whether or not the Panj Pyare were beheaded. They were willing to give their head to the Guru and it would have made no differnece to them whether they lived or died. They had already done their Kurbani by reaching the Avastha they did, thus the Khalsa was set upon the fact that these 5 Singhs were already dead (Jeevan Mukat).AmrikSingh · 31 May 2005
Bundha.... u r wrong the khalsa wasnt born, what is born dies, a baby is born and 1 day it dies. The khalsa was never born, its sad seeing even granthis and other people saying "khalsa panth da janam" it isnt janam it is prakash!Princess · 31 May 2005
I agree with veer Amriksingh jee 100%. [gurbani]"jo jnmY so jwnhu mUAw ]" [/gurbani]S Singh · 31 May 2005
Bundha >>It is totally different if something is done by Guru Ji or it is done by someone else. That someone else may be very closely related to Guru Ji or of a high avasta, but he is not the Guru so you cannot compare the two. I am not comparing the two. I am looking at the reasoning and the lesson given by Guru Hargobind Ji. Our Guru Ji led by example and as such why would Guru Hargobind Ji's own children end their lives if miracle making was ok ? Many stories have become corrupted over the years. For example Shaheed Baba Deep Singh Ji is sometimes said to have carried his head on his hand whilst fighting. Again this goes against what Guru Hargobind Ji taught as by doing so is a miracle and against nature.Bundha · 31 May 2005
S Singh Ji, What the children did went against God’s will so they had to take the consequences, Guru Sahib Ji was one with God, although they refrained from any miracles but from time to time they did use their shakti. If not, then all the incidents listed above would have to be dismissed as corrupted stories, which I for one am not prepared to do. The incident Baba Deep Singhs shadeedi I believe firmly to be that the Baba Ji was spiritually at a very high level and whatever they uttered came true, they had said that they would fall in the parkarma of Harmindar Sahib and so their bachaan had to come true. Hence, even though their head had been separated from their body they picked up their head and carried on fighting, true to their word their head landed on the parkarma and Baba Ji breathed his last and ascended to Satch Khand.