Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Sant Jarnail Singh Declared Shaheed by Taksal

Sant Jarnail Singh Declared Shaheed by Taksal

Jo Sonihal · 25 May 2005

Sant Ji was finally declared shaheed by taksal. This should rest all claims to him being alive. [url]http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/articleshow/1121826.cms[/url] Bhinderanwalae declared martyr after 21 yrs YUDHVIR RANA TIMES NEWS NETWORK[ WEDNESDAY, MAY 25, 2005 07:40:46 PM ] Surf 'N' Earn -Sign innow AMRITSAR: After consecutively maintaining for nearly 21 years that Sant Jarnail Singh Bhinderanwalae, 14th chief of Damdami Taksal and vanguard of Khalistan movement was in high esteem ( chardi kalan ), the acting chief of Damdami Taksal, (Jatha Bhindran) Giani Harnam Singh Khalsa Bhinderanwale on Wednesday finally declared Jarnail Singh Bhinderanwalae as martyr in the presence of Singhs of Taksal, Pritam Kaur and Inderjit Singh wife and son of Jarnail Singh Bhinderanwale respectively at Taksals headquarters at Gurdwara Gurdarshan Parkash, Mehta about 45 kilometers from Amritsar. Ishar Singh , another son of Jarnail Singh Bhinderanwale who was presented siropa by Jathedar of Akal Takht Giani Joginder Singh Vedanti while declaring Jarnail Singh Bhinderanwale a martyr on June 6,2003 was not present at Damdami Taksal. The breakaway faction of Damdami Taksal led by Baba Ram Singh having its head quarters at Gurdwara Gurshabad Parkash , Sangari near Batala had already announced Jarnail Singh Bhinderanwale as martyr. Harnam Singh declared that Jarnail Singh Bhinderanwale was martyred at 8.45 am on June 6, 1984 while fighting with the Indian army at Akal Takht. However Harnam Singh as well as other Singhs of Taksal declined to give any reason as to why Taksal maintained for more than two decades that Jarnail Singh Bhinderanwale was in chardi kalan and would appear at right time. He said "with the declaration of Sant Jarnail Singh Bhinderanwale as martyr by Taksal I hope that all the queries regarding martyrdom of Jarnail Singh would finish". Pritam Kaur and Inderjit Singh both approved the decision taken by Damdami Taksal while parried giving any reply to media queries. Giani Harnam Singh was later presented dastar (turban) by five Singhs of Taksal and declared full-fledged chief of Damdami Taksal instead of acting chief. Giani Harnam Singh said that martyrdom day would be observed on June 12. It is believed that Taksal could also announce its future programme for the cause of Panth.

Re: Sant Jarnal Singh Declared Shaheed by Taksal

gupt · 25 May 2005

Before Sant Thakur Singh Jee left for Sach Khand, he said a number of things would happen before Sant Jarnail Singh Jee returned, and one of those was that they would declare shaheedi of Sant Jee at Mehta.

Re: Sant Jarnal Singh Declared Shaheed by Taksal

! · 25 May 2005

Let's be completely honest now. Both factions of Taksal have accepted that Sant Jarnail Singh is no more. His closest companions like Baba Gurbachan Singh Manochahal accepted it many years ago. So who's left in the believer category? All these new stories about Baba Thakur Singh making predictions before his leaving his body are being made up on the spot. None of the Singhs present at his final moments have said anything about these predictions and I'm sure some young people will now make a long list of them. In the book "Shahid Bilas Sant Jarnail Singh" the story is clear: the Government of India did not want Taskal to have a new Jathedar who could lead the Panth. Some Sikh soldiers were sent to Mehta after June 84 before the bhog for the shahids was going to take place. These soldiers told Baba ji that they had escorted Sant ji out of Darbar Sahib and he was fine. Baba ji accepted their word and since then the confusion has continued. Imagine what might have been accomplished if Sikhs had a leader instead of waiting for one to return and lead them later? It was all a big ploy by GOI that has gone even beyond THEIR wildest imaginations and hopes. Sant ji is shahid. Everyone admits it now. Damage has been done. Story is over.

Re: Sant Jarnal Singh Declared Shaheed by Taksal

URM · 25 May 2005

NO "GUPT" BABA TAKHUR SINGH SAID ABSOLUTELY NOTHING OF THE KIND, DO YOU GUYS EVER TAKE A REST? SANT JI IS SHAHEED GET OVER IT...GET ON WITH YOUR LIFE AND CONCENTRATE ON BRINGING A NEW SINGH TO PANJAB WHO WAS OF THE CALIBRE OF SANT JI... THE WAY PEOPLE CAN LIE IS JUST DISGUSTING...SANT JI IS SHAHEED END OF THAT...NO ONE SAYS HE IS ALIVE NOW EXCEPT A FEW FANATICS IN THE WESTERN. HOW CAN YOU EXPECT A SIKH TO REACH THE ULTIMATE TRUTH IF YOU CANNOT BE EVEN TRUTHFUL TO YOURSELVES

Re: Sant Jarnal Singh Declared Shaheed by Taksal

gupt · 25 May 2005

"urm" what makes you think you're being 'truthful' to yourself. And Baba Jee sure did say that, not at his final moments, but it was mentioned. You can cry/argue all you want, but it won't change nothing.

Re: Sant Jarnal Singh Declared Shaheed by Taksal

Kulbir Singh · 25 May 2005

This is a good news. Finally Harnam Singh Dhumma has accepted the shaheedi of Sant Bhindranwale. It is a shame that Panth was misled for so many years. I think those culprits who misled the Panth should be punished at Akal Takhat. Anyone who shed tears at the desecration of Sant jee's martyrdom was threatened, abused and what not. Today those individuals need to reflect on their deeds and not only seek forgiveness from Guru Sahib but also from Sangat. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Sant Jarnail Singh Declared Shaheed by Taksal

anonsingh · 25 May 2005

I still do not understand why people praise his actions,which risked desicration of darbar sahib and endangered lives of innocent sikhs.

Re: Sant Jarnail Singh Declared Shaheed by Taksal

Sony · 25 May 2005

endangered lives of innocent sikhs? u dont think their lives were already at risk? men who started cutting their hair cus they were afraid of what the government.. the police would do if they saw them..... thats not endangerment of innocent lives? look at the bigger picture please.... And about Sant Ji, he was a great figure in Sikhi, however, the fate of Sikhi does not rest on one human, and therefore instead of worrying if he is alive or if he has left us, why not listen to what he had told us and follow that path? repsect him for who he was...

Re: Sant Jarnail Singh Declared Shaheed by Taksal

S!kh · 25 May 2005

anonsingh, People with your mentality make any well-meaning Gursikhs SICK. You make us want to throw up. You make us want to cry. Blame the Gursikhs before you blame GOI...... great.

Re: Sant Jarnail Singh Declared Shaheed by Taksal

indy · 25 May 2005

vaheguru ji ka khalsa vaheguru ji ki fateh i for one plus many others are staying with the bachan of Sant Gyani Jarnail Singh Ji Khalsa Bhindranwale that listen only to Baba Takhur Singh Ji what Baba Ji said in the presence of our Beloved Guru ji is that Sant Gyani Jarnail Singh Ji khalsa is ALIVE and will RETURN when Vaheguru gives him the order too. As for harnam and ram they will get the just rewards. the video of Baba Ji giving this bachan in front of Guru ji will be shown soon i wud rather believe Baba Ji than some internet warrior or anyone else being them taksaali or not time will tell who carries on the mission ram has already said Sant Ji does not want Khalistan which we know is a lie one gone the other one harnam will go too gurbar akaaal

Re: Sant Jarnail Singh Declared Shaheed by Taksal

kharkoo singhnee · 25 May 2005

first of all thank you to the admins of tapoban.org for putting up both sides and not being biased second of all, anon "singh" please ... i think even people who believe sant ji is shaheed will agree that was sucha stupid thing to say third of all, "!" whats your problem? left it... i wont even bother commenting on you

Re: Sant Jarnail Singh Declared Shaheed by Taksal

Shaheed · 25 May 2005

To be honest all the Kharkoo Singhs said Sant Ji was Shaheed. And with the levels of intelligence and information they had, they are in the best position to say. Anyone who is truly associated with the movement and is in the know as to what really goes on, knows Sant Ji is Shaheed. All the groups - BKI, KCF, KZF, BTF, all say Sant Ji is Shaheed. Nihangs say Sant Ji is Shaheed. Akal Takht says Sant Ji is Shaheed. AKJ says Sant Ji is Shaheed. Now both branches of Taksal say Sant Ji is Shaheed. The only people who say Sant Ji is not Shaheed are the Naujawan outside of India. To all the Naujawan who read this, when you are fully grown adults and still there is no change, the movement has come to a complete stand still and as the UN reports and studies suggests, by 2025 Punjab is officially classed as a desert, and only 1% of Punjab is Amritdhari, will you accept Sant Ji is Shaheed? Or will you be saying the same thing, blissfully ignorant and detached, thousands of miles away, in your comfy western homes, saying Sant Ji will return and start the movement again?

Re: Sant Jarnail Singh Declared Shaheed by Taksal

truth of the matter is .. · 25 May 2005

this is all a joke people should just sit quiet and wait until times turn and things start happening

Re: Sant Jarnail Singh Declared Shaheed by Taksal

peeded of singh · 25 May 2005

Lets face the fact, baba takhur singh was a nice old man, did alot of paht, but was clueless regarding the truth. they themselves promoted, or atleast managed to keep this fire buring, why? In the face of the announcment, the question has to asked. Is the taksal linked in some fashion to GOI? hen i say taksal i mean the leaders, not these wannabe youth dresing up like its fancy dress. I am extremely upset at this truth that some of us have been saying, but noone wants to hear. My veer kulbir singh said those involved should be punished at akal takht. Veer Kulbir singh, the holiest of places is only a dream. Niether those controlling it or running it are true to sikhi. Again sikhs will be made a laughing stock of the world, becasue these sants want to make up stories for there own benefit.

Re: Sant Jarnail Singh Declared Shaheed by Taksal

kharkoo singhnee · 25 May 2005

HOW DARE YOU CALL BABA JI A NICE OLD MAN... dont you have ANY respect? WHATS WRONG WITH YOU???????????????????? who are YOU to call BABA JI clueless?

Re: Sant Jarnail Singh Declared Shaheed by Taksal

peeded off singh · 25 May 2005

There we go. Utter ignorance. Who am i to call them a 'nice old man', What since when was that a negative? Mr. Kharkoo singh, who has probably only visited india three times, born in the west..., living as a wannabe, you sound as if you may know what baba Takhur singh had been saying for over two decades, that Jarnail singh is alive....so cluess does describe there attitude. Again i ask the question, WHAT IS THE TAKSALS RELATIONSHIP WITH THE GOI? WHY HAVE SIKHS LOST A COMPLETE GENERATION BECAUSE OF A LIE? NO LEADER WAS EVER ALOUD TO COME FORWARD, BECAUSE SANT JI WAS COMING ANY MOMENT! Enough said, the damage has been done, and thousands of innocent lost there lives, because of a lie, face the facts.... I'm just waiting for the next spin to come out of taksal. Serious questions should be asked of them. IMHO Gurfateh.

Re: Sant Jarnail Singh Declared Shaheed by Taksal

Khalistani · 25 May 2005

BabaJi was of a high avastha. BrahmGian. They knew that the best means to the end would be patience. This kaum has gupt forces that work unseen. Giani Takhur Singh said in katha, if you do 25 JapJi Sahib Paats in 14 years that will be enuff to save your generations or something like that... (not so sure of the numbers though)

Re: Sant Jarnail Singh Declared Shaheed by Taksal

Mkhalsa · 25 May 2005

indy, you will stay with the bachans of baba thakur singh? I am not suggesting anything here.. but did he not say that if baba jee does not come back before he dies you can pull his dhari?

Re: Sant Jarnail Singh Declared Shaheed by Taksal

Kuljot Singh · 25 May 2005

I agree with Dhumma that Baba Ji is a shaheed but anyone can see that he declared this because he only wanted to stabilize his own jathedaari. I am not really all that impressed... -kuljot singh

Re: Sant Jarnail Singh Declared Shaheed by Taksal

dassandas · 25 May 2005

Sant baba Thakur Singh = Sewa of 4 Mukhis of Taksal 24/7 simran 24/7 bani langer sewa Nimarta Respect of bani Harnam Singh = ******Admin Cut: Baseless allegations will not be allowed********** So who would you beleive ?

Re: Sant Jarnail Singh Declared Shaheed by Taksal

Sony · 25 May 2005

admin can u not put my last post thank u *****Admin Note: Done as per your request******

Re: Sant Jarnail Singh Declared Shaheed by Taksal

kharkoo singhnee · 25 May 2005

if doing nindya helps you sleep better at night, then congratulations... you shall sleep in peace

Re: Sant Jarnail Singh Declared Shaheed by Taksal

Ghuman · 25 May 2005

I believe that it is in the best interest of Sikh's that Giani Harnam Singh Khalsa Bhinderanwale have declared Sant Ji as a martyr.

Re: Sant Jarnail Singh Declared Shaheed by Taksal

Tribune · 25 May 2005

Dhuma declared Jathedar of Damdami Taksal Bhinderanwale no more, declares Taksal Varinder Walia Tribune News Service Chowk Mehta, May 25 In a swift development that antagonised a section of the Damdami Taksal, Baba Harnam Singh Dhuma, acting Jathedar, was declared 16th chief of the already fractured taksal here this afternoon. The “dastarbandi” of Baba Dhuma, was performed in a hush hush manner at Gurdwara Gurdarshan Parkash here which followed the announcement that Sant Jarnail Singh Bhinderanwale was killed on June 6, 1984, during Operation Blue Star. The announcement has come after 21 years of white lie that Sant Bhinderanwale was alive and would return to take over the charge anytime. The statement of Baba Dhuma has made it clear that his predecessor, Baba Thakur Singh, who died about three months ago and had been telling the Sikh Panth that Sant Bhinderanwale was in ‘chardi kala’ (in high spirits) for the last 21 years. However, Damdami Taksal chief said that Baba Thakur Singh might have concealed the death of Sant Bhinderanwale for the reasons best known to him. Bhai refused to entertain any query from the mediapersons. Instead, he issued a statement in which Baba Thakur Singh was described as great religious leader who took over the command of taksal in the most trying period following the Army operation. Earlier, Akal Takht and the SGPC had refused to give recognition to Baba Dhuma as Jathedar of Taksal as he had not declared Sant Bhinderanwale as dead. Instead, both Akal Takht and the SGPC had given recognition to Bhai Ram Singh as Jathedar of the parallel taksal who had accepted that Sant Bhinderanwale was killed during the Army operation in 1984. Both the Sikh supreme bodies had already declared Bhinderanwale as “dead” two years ago. The 21-year silence of Damdami Taksal was broken today under pressure from various Sikh organisations, including the Shiromani Khalsa Dal, led by Bhai Daljit Singh Bittu, the Dal Khalsa, the American Sikh Gurdwara Parbandhak Committee, Sikh factions from different countries, the SGPC and Akal Takht. Bibi Pritam Kaur and Bhai Inderjit Singh, widow and son, respectively, of Sant Bhinderanwale were present when he was declared ‘martyr’ by Baba Dhuma. Interestingly, the press conference was delayed for more than two hours as they wanted to rope in Bhai Mohkam Singh, spokesman for Damdami Taksal. However, Bhai Mohkam Singh, Bhai Malkit Singh and senior functionaries of the taksal were not taken into confidence before the ‘dastarbandi’ of Bhai Dhuma . So much so Bhai Jasbir Singh Rode , a former Jathedar Akal Takht , who had been opposing any move to declare Sant Bhinderanwale as ‘Shaheed’, Bhai Ajaib Singh Abhinasi and Bhai Ujjal Singh were conspicuous by their absence. During discussions, Baba Dhuma refused to accept any logic of a section of the taksal who wanted to encash from the legacy of keeping Bhinderanwale “alive”. Earlier, Bhai Rode was instrumental in installing Bhai Dhuma as acting Jathedar of the Taksal but he reportedly turned his back when he (Bhai Dhuma) insisted in declaring Sant Bhinderanwale as ‘dead’. Bhai Dhuma checkmated his opponents within the taksal by keeping his “dastarbandi” as top secret. The Damdami Taksal announced that the ‘shaheedi divas’ of Sant Bhinderanwale would be held here on June 12.

Re: Sant Jarnail Singh Declared Shaheed by Taksal

singh · 25 May 2005

from what i have heard it wasnt even baba takhur singh who first said sant jarnail singh is shaheed it was rode and rode's people who bounced him into it and then later it was too late to go back so the lie was maintained. is this true?

Re: Sant Jarnail Singh Declared Shaheed by Taksal

78 · 25 May 2005

About Time, there are 2 mny Singhs saying they are alive, this should hopefully calm these Singhs down, w.j.k.k, w.j.k.f

Re: Sant Jarnail Singh Declared Shaheed by Taksal

gupt singh · 25 May 2005

yea we will c wot hapens this should not effect our sikhi but we will c wot hapens in the future, how can u ppl base ur facts on things u have hurd or read i think more emphasis on sikhi should b made by us sikh's, instead of these discusions and unnecesary gossip, that goes 4 most of the threads on this forum. personally i beleive sant ji is alive and only time will tell.

Re: Sant Jarnail Singh Declared Shaheed by Taksal

Harnam Singh · 25 May 2005

Whether it is a lie or not, only God knows or the people involved. But the one thing that is definite and something that Sant Jarnail Singh themself used to say is that the truth is Ttos/Brave/Stable.

Re: Sant Jarnail Singh Declared Shaheed by Taksal

kharkoo singhnee II · 26 May 2005

no disrespect for baba takhur singh, but dont you think that what hes been saying for the past god knows how many years has been nothing but misleading??? my goodness piaryo, he first said that he would not leave this world until baba jarnail singh came back......then his time came and he left this world...but yet no baba jarnail singh... hmmmmmmmmm its amazing how baba takhur singh was labelled a braham giani when alllllllllll this time this one contervery split the panth, literally in half.... theres a faction between the youth......the youth that live everyday for baba takhur singh, placing him on the same 'seat' as Guru Granth Sahib, literally sitting him down on a special manji ...(when in essence they should be living for their guru) and then theres the youth that openly discuss the logic behind baba takhur singhs statements, only to be called horrible names and looked down upon.... thinking that a little butt kicking would shut a person up...... well, here it is....... BABA JARNAIL SINGH.........AMAR SHAHEED!

Re: Sant Jarnail Singh Declared Shaheed by Taksal

taksali101 · 26 May 2005

u forgot the 3rd faction of damdami taksal THE ANTI-DHUMMA AND ANTI RAM SINGH. we still thin sant je is in chardee kalaa u will c baba ji sed dat things that we never even imagined would happen b4 sant je came bak. and we cant say that baba ji is lieing either bcus "BRAHMGIANI AAP PARMAYSUR" and if anybody wants 2 say anything against baba ji being a brahmgiani than b my guest "santa ko maat koee nindo sant raam hai ekho"-----"mohe kalaay tina nindaka" things that were supposed 2 hapen frum baba jis buchan 1)baba ji wud hav nindia of dem dun alottt 2)sant je wud b declared shaheed at mehta 3)brothers wud b at eachothas throats jatha wud have problems.

Re: Sant Jarnail Singh Declared Shaheed by Taksal

ssingh · 26 May 2005

no one here has a jeevan that can even stand close to the example of Mahapurakh baba Thakur Singh ji. That's really all that matters for condition of the panth - swar your on jeevan

Re: Sant Jarnail Singh Declared Shaheed by Taksal

Bijla Singh · 26 May 2005

Why people still believe we need to keep these jathas that do not serve any purpose, I wonder? Guru Rakha. Sat Kartar

Re: Sant Jarnail Singh Declared Shaheed by Taksal

Jaspal Singh · 26 May 2005

Got the pic off the histor channel documentry on saintsolders.net, they may nto be that clear but one that that stands out as solid proof is Baba Jee's Revolver Case that is laying beside him, whihc can also be seen in all of his other pictures U cannot deny the fact that it is infact his gun case beside him [IMG]http://photos.waheguroo.com/data/media/51/phug.jpg[/IMG] [IMG]http://jaspalbal.tripod.com/s1.jpg[/IMG] [IMG]http://jaspalbal.tripod.com/s2.jpg[/IMG] Dhan Shaheed Baba Jarnail Singh Khalsa, woke up a sleeping kaum

Re: Sant Jarnail Singh Declared Shaheed by Taksal

Jarnail Singh "Gyani "Arshi" · 26 May 2005

[gurbani] <>vwihgurU jI kI Piqh ][/gurbani] My comments here are only addressed to INDY Ji. I am distressed to see Brahmgiani Harnam Singh Ji and Brahmgiani Raam Singh ji addressed as "just ram and harnam" in your post. Surely they DESERVE the name SINGH...at the very least...not just ram/harnam ?? a Baenti..dont let our personal "anger" get in the way of addressing GURU JI given SINGH/KAUR As to all the rest hulla gullaa everyone already knows what i think...no need to waste time and space. [gurbani] <>vwihgurU jI kI Piqh ][/gurbani]

Re: Sant Jarnail Singh Declared Shaheed by Taksal

jss · 26 May 2005

bijla singh..what do you mean no purpose? have you been to akj rehnsabaies?...do hundreds of gursikhs not get together to do sadh sangat?...isn't that the highest purpose??? Mil sadh sangat bhaj keval naam?? have you seen the kids who learn paath at taksaal do paath?...i used to think santhiya doesn't matter...but having heard recently the kids doing paath from taksaal...listening to such shud paath is a beautiful experience......but all that is of no purpose? have you been to a sadh sangat samagam ?...once again bringing people together to do seva, simran, and sangat...changing the lives of soo many people...once again..no purpose? have you been to raraa sahib? nanaksar taath? dude ALL these jathas were started by puran gurmukhs and do serve a purpose...do they have problems ? YES...are they perfect? NO... but we as individuals should use our bibek buddhi and see where the problem lies...the problem does not lie in any of the institutions..rather in the haumai of people...people who go around saying we're right, you're wrong...that's where the problem lies...the problem lies in people not having respect for each other, brotherly love...the problem lies when people use these jathas for the wrong purposes, instead of using them for their spiritual upliftment, they try to use them for social status upliftment.. hence, it's not the jathas that need sorting out...it's the people within all the jathas having to take a good look at themselves and changing their approach when doing sangat of any of the jathas..

Re: Sant Jarnail Singh Declared Shaheed by Taksal

Seeker · 26 May 2005

As "singh" have mentioned earlier, it seems that no one in this message board have payed attention to, what he said that Rode was the one who started the false information about Sant Ji being alive and Baba Takhur Singh Ji probably came under pressure and said what he said as we don't know what were the circumstances at the time. Jasbir Singh Rodea wanted to be the next Jathedar of Dam Dami Taksal this time but decided to stay away for unknown reasons. All this was started by him. We need to think with intelligence and understand the tricks and dirty politics of some of our Sikh's who are using Sant Ji's name to get what ever power then can.

Re: Sant Jarnail Singh Declared Shaheed by Taksal

kharkoo singhnee · 26 May 2005

kharkoo singhnee II change your name. with all that hatred in you and all that nindya done by you, you aint no kharkoo singhnee

Re: Sant Jarnail Singh Declared Shaheed by Taksal

fdfd · 26 May 2005

to all these people who get so defensive....why? people have a right to be a little suspicious and a little skeptical. taksal is not the guru, and no man is guru. why should we be so ignorant to believe that some man is coming back to life, or that hes been hiding? if you are so confident hes coming back, then show us some actual proof. show us this video, and tell us why baba takhur singh went against his word with sant ji coming back and with bhai ram singh being jathedar. a brahm giani says his word once, he doesnt retract statements left and right. i respect baba ji, but lets start going by waht bani says, not people. bani doesnt tell us to wait for the return of people, or to cling on to make believe things, or to leave the matters of the panth alone because sants jis going to fix it anyway. bani tells us to make the most of our time here, and sant bhindranwale doesnt have a direct effect on my soul, only i do and with gurus kirpa i can make the most of it. who cares. we got bigger issues then to wait around for someone. if he comes good, if he doesnt, then the panth must move forward without him. hes not our god, nor is he our guru. we have everything we need within the ang of SGGS to guide us. why do these taksalis think everyone is anti panthic or a paapi for thinking sant ji is not coming back??? hanging on to an issue like this is anything BUT sikhi.

Re: Sant Jarnail Singh Declared Shaheed by Taksal

ekta · 26 May 2005

u know what, i used 2 believe sant ji is shaheed, then went to jinda, and now dunno. But i for 1 can't stand harnaam he has done havaans and fasting so what ever.. i like baba ram singh, he is greedy but he is still the most hard-core we'll find..besides greed he's quite the sikh. But one thing i'm glad in this convo...is that it does show some level of one-ness in the panth...that every1 respects and loves SANT BABA JARNAIL SINGH JI KHALSA. This alone shows that hope is not lost in re-joining all jathebandiya of the panth.

Re: Sant Jarnail Singh Declared Shaheed by Taksal

london singh · 26 May 2005

WJKK WJKF Lets look at this rationally When a lie is told and constantly repeated then in assumes a life of its own. The lie told about Santji being alive and well has outlived those who started it as well as many who repeated it. The lie was started to maintain unity within the Taksaal but it split the Panth. Some of the youth who seem to be making up statements about Baba Thakur Singh predicted this and that will happen were probably not even born when the lie was first started. I remember that rumours about Santji surviving started straight after Bluestar. Most Sikhs then were critical of the rumours because they rightly said that Santji had made statements before Bluestar that in case of an attack he and his followers would give their lives to defend the sanctity of Harmandir Sahib. The rumour mongers started to make up stories of how Santji was commanded by his followers to leave the complex and to continue the struggle from outside. The used the story of Guru Gobind Singh being commanded to leave Garhi Chamkaur by the Khalsa as support for their rumours. If Santji was commanded to leave then he would like Guruji did have shown himself to his enemies to let them know that he was still alive. If Santji is still alive then his best time to have led the struggle was directly after Bluestar, when the whole Panth barring a few traitors would have been behind him.

Re: Sant Jarnail Singh Declared Shaheed by Taksal

Search For TAT · 26 May 2005

How can taksal be trusted on anything ever again? 21 years of lies?????? My bhramgiani says this and that????? When they cannot even get the shahhedi of their jathedar right, how can they be trusted on any maryada issues??? Basically Taksal hasve disgraced their greatest sevdaar, Sant Ji???? They could not even accept his shaheedi?? Even worse, some still cannot!!!

Re: Sant Jarnail Singh Declared Shaheed by Taksal

Search For TAT · 26 May 2005

"One lies leads to a thousand lies!"

Re: Sant Jarnail Singh Declared Shaheed by Taksal

Search For TAT · 26 May 2005

It does not matter how high your jeevan. You must tell the truth! 21 years of lies!! Not beat people up in birmingham when they challenge your lies! This is paap! Will the birmingham taksalis now apologise to that singh they beat up in birmingham?? ssingh wrote: > no one here has a jeevan that can even stand close to the > example of Mahapurakh baba Thakur Singh ji. That's really all > that matters for condition of the panth - swar your on jeevan

Re: Sant Jarnail Singh Declared Shaheed by Taksal

OK · 26 May 2005

OK give evidence of when Baba Takhur Singh gave those 3 Bachans: 1)baba ji wud hav nindia of dem dun alottt 2)sant je wud b declared shaheed at mehta 3)brothers wud b at eachothas throats jatha wud have problems. When was this said? Who heard it? Are there any recordings? You need to substantiate these rumours.

Re: Sant Jarnail Singh Declared Shaheed by Taksal

anonsingh · 26 May 2005

sony said - endangered lives of innocent sikhs? u dont think their lives were already at risk? men who started cutting their hair cus they were afraid of what the government.. the police would do if they saw them..... thats not endangerment of innocent lives? look at the bigger picture please.... yes sikhs were being oppressed, other militant groups caused much more damage, killed more corrupt police and did justice for many crimes, yet DID NOT MAKE SIRI DARBAR SAHIB INTO THEIR OWN BASE. Becuase of his actions the golden temple complex was brought to rubble Tanks firing shells aimed at him were the cause of destruction of our holiest shrine Bullets aimed at the militants were intercepted by women and children. Other shaheeds such as bhai sukhdev singh did just as much seva to the panth without putting darbar sahib/ innocents at risk.

Re: Sant Jarnail Singh Declared Shaheed by Taksal

peeded off singh · 26 May 2005

"Baba Takhur Singh gave those 3 Bachans: 1)baba ji wud hav nindia of dem dun alottt 2)sant je wud b declared shaheed at mehta 3)brothers wud b at eachothas throats jatha wud have problems." Any simple-minded person, who has lied for over two decades, knows what state he/she will leave there house in....thus the comments/prophecy by Baba takhur singh...no need to be a brhamgaini for this one. I still have not heard a reply to the previously asked question: due to the lies/deception that panth has been given by taksal, due to the great loss of life of youth up until 1989...due to sikhism at a all time low in punjab today, what is the relationship between the taksal and the GOI? I personally think that dam dami taksal should be extracted from the panth. Punishment for the greatest lie ever told in sikhi... TO ALL THE YOUTH OUT THERE. DO NOT GET TANGLED UP IN JATHE-BANDHI'S. THIS MARG IS FOR YOU AS AN INDIVIDUAL, SEE WHAT HAPPENS WHEN YOU GET TOO INVOLVED, YOU TOO BEGIN TO THINK A LIE IS THE WORD OF GOD!

Re: Sant Jarnail Singh Declared Shaheed by Taksal

Princess · 26 May 2005

Kharkoo Singhnee ll has great post. A kharkoo means fighting for truth not being follower. Baba jee used to do a lot of paath but it's not always necessary to label all leaders/sikhs "Brahmgyani" even if they are not. And, kharkoo Singhnee jee, calling baba jee nice old sikh is not disrespect for him. He was not superior than Baba Budha jee. All Guru Sahiban and panth called him Baba budha jee then what's wrong with 'nice old sikh' title? //////////// As "singh" have mentioned earlier, it seems that no one in this message board have payed attention to, what he said that Rode was the one who started the false information about Sant Ji being alive and Baba Takhur Singh Ji probably came under pressure and said what he said as we don't know what were the circumstances at the time. //////////// Brahmgyanies never come under pressure. Don't mix up two things here. If he came under pressure then he was not Brahmgyani. If he was right then he never came under pressure and we all should start looking for sant jee, he must be back according to baba jee's bachans.

Re: Sant Jarnail Singh Declared Shaheed by Taksal

................ · 26 May 2005

these are no predictions for the future. Alot of this was happening even when baba ji was alive. OK wrote: > OK give evidence of when Baba Takhur Singh gave those 3 > Bachans: > > 1)baba ji wud hav nindia of dem dun alottt > 2)sant je wud b declared shaheed at mehta > 3)brothers wud b at eachothas throats jatha wud have problems. > > When was this said? > > Who heard it? > > Are there any recordings? > > You need to substantiate these rumours.

Re: Sant Jarnail Singh Declared Shaheed by Taksal

Think! · 26 May 2005

To the first "Kharkoo Singhnee" if you are who I think you are, do you think Sant Jarnail Singh would have promoted Amritdhari girls who wear dastar and promote Khalistan and the Kharkoos to smoke cigarettes? If not, I don't think you are in a position to speak until you sort out your own Jeevan.

Re: Sant Jarnail Singh Declared Shaheed by Taksal

gupt · 26 May 2005

"we got bigger issues then to wait around for someone. if he comes good, if he doesnt, then the panth must move forward without him. hes not our god, nor is he our guru. we have everything we need within the ang of SGGS to guide us." Who is stopping you or anyone else from moving forward? No one has ever claimed Sant Jee as our guru. Only people like you who have nothing better to do than argue make up these lies to make your side look better. If you (in general) believe Sant Jee is shaheed, then so be it. You are wasting your own time as well as everyone elses arguing that Sant Jee is shaheed. And for the ones who believe Sant Jee is still alive, we will continue to wait while still doing what we have to do. It is not us that keeps bringing this issue into the light. It's the faithless that want to keep talking the good stuff. Newsflash: We dont care. Drop it. What either side says won't change anyones beliefs. And, no, Rode was NOT the first to say Sant Jee wasn't shaheed. And, no, Baba Jee was NOT under any pressure to also do so. 21 years of lies? What makes today any different than two days ago? Just because Dhumma said it? Someone said that Baba Jee said this to hold his position in the jathedari. Realize this, Baba Jee had the choice of who to make the next jathedar and he chose Sant Jee over himself. Never has Baba Jee claimed himself to be the jathedar of Taksal. If anything, Dhumma wants to secure his position in Taksal by declaring Sant Jee shaheed. Unfortunately, for him, it won't last long. And for those of you who believe this has kept the Panth from moving forward....PUHLEASE!!! Buy it or sell it, doesn't matter. These are my finals words on the issue as I do not feel the need to waste my time nor anyone elses. I suggest everyone else do the same.

Re: Sant Jarnail Singh Declared Shaheed by Taksal

kharkoo singhnee · 26 May 2005

To "Think": you got the wrong person

Re: Sant Jarnail Singh Declared Shaheed by Taksal

Jindo · 26 May 2005

As far as I am and most people are concerned Sant Jarnail Singh is shaheed, and a great maha Singh and Das of the Panth. May Akal Purkh bless the Panth with more selfless Sant Siphai Leaders in this corrupt and dark time.

Re: Sant Jarnail Singh Declared Shaheed by Taksal

Tony Benn · 26 May 2005

Uk MP Tony Benn famously once said "Say what you mean, and mean what you say" DT has twisted and turned in every which way it. There is no denying it, this was a cock up, BIG TIME!

Re: Sant Jarnail Singh Declared Shaheed by Taksal

S Singh · 26 May 2005

Some of you people seriously need a reality check. Baba Jarnail Singh Ji is shaheed. You can say what you want, ask Baba Ji's brother who identified his body whether he is shaheed or not. Why is it that his family accept he is shaheed yet all these internet karkoos believe the opposite.

Re: Sant Jarnail Singh Declared Shaheed by Taksal

ekta · 26 May 2005

i dont' care if she's shaheed or not.... we need 2 get along pppl.... ne one dissing taksaal shut up, grab ur tongue..control it..don't be lose...taksaal has done alot for the panth..... thats besides the point..... i thought as a sikh u ppl would want unity and not 2 diss calling baba ji a liar etc. have some garaath, is that all ur mom tought u?

Re: Sant Jarnail Singh Declared Shaheed by Taksal

Admin · 26 May 2005

Unless there is something productive to add, this discussion is closed.