Re: Sant Jarnal Singh Declared Shaheed by Taksal
Kulbir Singh · 25 May 2005
This is a good news. Finally Harnam Singh Dhumma has accepted the shaheedi of Sant Bhindranwale. It is a shame that Panth was misled for so many years. I think those culprits who misled the Panth should be punished at Akal Takhat.
Anyone who shed tears at the desecration of Sant jee's martyrdom was threatened, abused and what not. Today those individuals need to reflect on their deeds and not only seek forgiveness from Guru Sahib but also from Sangat.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: Sant Jarnail Singh Declared Shaheed by Taksal
kharkoo singhnee · 25 May 2005
first of all thank you to the admins of tapoban.org for putting up both sides and not being biased
second of all, anon "singh" please ... i think even people who believe sant ji is shaheed will agree that was sucha stupid thing to say
third of all, "!" whats your problem? left it... i wont even bother commenting on you
Re: Sant Jarnail Singh Declared Shaheed by Taksal
truth of the matter is .. · 25 May 2005
this is all a joke
people should just sit quiet and wait until times turn and things start happening
Re: Sant Jarnail Singh Declared Shaheed by Taksal
peeded of singh · 25 May 2005
Lets face the fact, baba takhur singh was a nice old man, did alot of paht, but was clueless regarding the truth. they themselves promoted, or atleast managed to keep this fire buring, why?
In the face of the announcment, the question has to asked. Is the taksal linked in some fashion to GOI? hen i say taksal i mean the leaders, not these wannabe youth dresing up like its fancy dress.
I am extremely upset at this truth that some of us have been saying, but noone wants to hear. My veer kulbir singh said those involved should be punished at akal takht. Veer Kulbir singh, the holiest of places is only a dream. Niether those controlling it or running it are true to sikhi.
Again sikhs will be made a laughing stock of the world, becasue these sants want to make up stories for there own benefit.
Re: Sant Jarnail Singh Declared Shaheed by Taksal
kharkoo singhnee · 25 May 2005
HOW DARE YOU CALL BABA JI A NICE OLD MAN... dont you have ANY respect? WHATS WRONG WITH YOU???????????????????? who are YOU to call BABA JI clueless?
Re: Sant Jarnail Singh Declared Shaheed by Taksal
peeded off singh · 25 May 2005
There we go. Utter ignorance. Who am i to call them a 'nice old man', What since when was that a negative?
Mr. Kharkoo singh, who has probably only visited india three times, born in the west..., living as a wannabe, you sound as if you may know what baba Takhur singh had been saying for over two decades, that Jarnail singh is alive....so cluess does describe there attitude.
Again i ask the question, WHAT IS THE TAKSALS RELATIONSHIP WITH THE GOI?
WHY HAVE SIKHS LOST A COMPLETE GENERATION BECAUSE OF A LIE?
NO LEADER WAS EVER ALOUD TO COME FORWARD, BECAUSE SANT JI WAS COMING ANY MOMENT!
Enough said, the damage has been done, and thousands of innocent lost there lives, because of a lie, face the facts....
I'm just waiting for the next spin to come out of taksal. Serious questions should be asked of them.
IMHO
Gurfateh.
Re: Sant Jarnail Singh Declared Shaheed by Taksal
Kuljot Singh · 25 May 2005
I agree with Dhumma that Baba Ji is a shaheed but anyone can see that he declared this because he only wanted to stabilize his own jathedaari.
I am not really all that impressed...
-kuljot singh
Re: Sant Jarnail Singh Declared Shaheed by Taksal
kharkoo singhnee · 25 May 2005
if doing nindya helps you sleep better at night, then congratulations... you shall sleep in peace
Re: Sant Jarnail Singh Declared Shaheed by Taksal
Harnam Singh · 25 May 2005
Whether it is a lie or not, only God knows or the people involved. But the one thing that is definite and something that Sant Jarnail Singh themself used to say is that the truth is Ttos/Brave/Stable.
Re: Sant Jarnail Singh Declared Shaheed by Taksal
kharkoo singhnee II · 26 May 2005
no disrespect for baba takhur singh, but dont you think that what hes been saying for the past god knows how many years has been nothing but misleading??? my goodness piaryo, he first said that he would not leave this world until baba jarnail singh came back......then his time came and he left this world...but yet no baba jarnail singh... hmmmmmmmmm
its amazing how baba takhur singh was labelled a braham giani when alllllllllll this time this one contervery split the panth, literally in half.... theres a faction between the youth......the youth that live everyday for baba takhur singh, placing him on the same 'seat' as Guru Granth Sahib, literally sitting him down on a special manji ...(when in essence they should be living for their guru)
and then theres the youth that openly discuss the logic behind baba takhur singhs statements, only to be called horrible names and looked down upon.... thinking that a little butt kicking would shut a person up...... well, here it is.......
BABA JARNAIL SINGH.........AMAR SHAHEED!
Re: Sant Jarnail Singh Declared Shaheed by Taksal
Bijla Singh · 26 May 2005
Why people still believe we need to keep these jathas that do not serve any purpose, I wonder? Guru Rakha. Sat Kartar
Re: Sant Jarnail Singh Declared Shaheed by Taksal
Jaspal Singh · 26 May 2005
Got the pic off the histor channel documentry on saintsolders.net, they may nto be that clear but one that that stands out as solid proof is Baba Jee's Revolver Case that is laying beside him, whihc can also be seen in all of his other pictures
U cannot deny the fact that it is infact his gun case beside him
[IMG]http://photos.waheguroo.com/data/media/51/phug.jpg[/IMG]
[IMG]http://jaspalbal.tripod.com/s1.jpg[/IMG]
[IMG]http://jaspalbal.tripod.com/s2.jpg[/IMG]
Dhan Shaheed Baba Jarnail Singh Khalsa, woke up a sleeping kaum
Re: Sant Jarnail Singh Declared Shaheed by Taksal
Jarnail Singh "Gyani "Arshi" · 26 May 2005
[gurbani] <>vwihgurU jI kI Piqh ][/gurbani]
My comments here are only addressed to INDY Ji.
I am distressed to see Brahmgiani Harnam Singh Ji and Brahmgiani Raam Singh ji addressed as "just ram and harnam" in your post.
Surely they DESERVE the name SINGH...at the very least...not just ram/harnam ??
a Baenti..dont let our personal "anger" get in the way of addressing GURU JI given SINGH/KAUR
As to all the rest hulla gullaa everyone already knows what i think...no need to waste time and space.
[gurbani] <>vwihgurU jI kI Piqh ][/gurbani]
Re: Sant Jarnail Singh Declared Shaheed by Taksal
kharkoo singhnee · 26 May 2005
kharkoo singhnee II change your name. with all that hatred in you and all that nindya done by you, you aint no kharkoo singhnee
Re: Sant Jarnail Singh Declared Shaheed by Taksal
london singh · 26 May 2005
WJKK WJKF
Lets look at this rationally
When a lie is told and constantly repeated then in assumes a life of its own. The lie told about Santji being alive and well has outlived those who started it as well as many who repeated it. The lie was started to maintain unity within the Taksaal but it split the Panth. Some of the youth who seem to be making up statements about Baba Thakur Singh predicted this and that will happen were probably not even born when the lie was first started. I remember that rumours about Santji surviving started straight after Bluestar. Most Sikhs then were critical of the rumours because they rightly said that Santji had made statements before Bluestar that in case of an attack he and his followers would give their lives to defend the sanctity of Harmandir Sahib. The rumour mongers started to make up stories of how Santji was commanded by his followers to leave the complex and to continue the struggle from outside. The used the story of Guru Gobind Singh being commanded to leave Garhi Chamkaur by the Khalsa as support for their rumours. If Santji was commanded to leave then he would like Guruji did have shown himself to his enemies to let them know that he was still alive.
If Santji is still alive then his best time to have led the struggle was directly after Bluestar, when the whole Panth barring a few traitors would have been behind him.
Re: Sant Jarnail Singh Declared Shaheed by Taksal
Search For TAT · 26 May 2005
How can taksal be trusted on anything ever again?
21 years of lies??????
My bhramgiani says this and that?????
When they cannot even get the shahhedi of their jathedar right, how can they be trusted on any maryada issues???
Basically Taksal hasve disgraced their greatest sevdaar, Sant Ji????
They could not even accept his shaheedi??
Even worse, some still cannot!!!
Re: Sant Jarnail Singh Declared Shaheed by Taksal
Search For TAT · 26 May 2005
"One lies leads to a thousand lies!"
Re: Sant Jarnail Singh Declared Shaheed by Taksal
Search For TAT · 26 May 2005
It does not matter how high your jeevan. You must tell the truth! 21 years of lies!! Not beat people up in birmingham when they challenge your lies! This is paap!
Will the birmingham taksalis now apologise to that singh they beat up in birmingham??
ssingh wrote:
> no one here has a jeevan that can even stand close to the
> example of Mahapurakh baba Thakur Singh ji. That's really all
> that matters for condition of the panth - swar your on jeevan
Re: Sant Jarnail Singh Declared Shaheed by Taksal
peeded off singh · 26 May 2005
"Baba Takhur Singh gave those 3 Bachans:
1)baba ji wud hav nindia of dem dun alottt
2)sant je wud b declared shaheed at mehta
3)brothers wud b at eachothas throats jatha wud have problems."
Any simple-minded person, who has lied for over two decades, knows what state he/she will leave there house in....thus the comments/prophecy by Baba takhur singh...no need to be a brhamgaini for this one.
I still have not heard a reply to the previously asked question: due to the lies/deception that panth has been given by taksal, due to the great loss of life of youth up until 1989...due to sikhism at a all time low in punjab today, what is the relationship between the taksal and the GOI?
I personally think that dam dami taksal should be extracted from the panth. Punishment for the greatest lie ever told in sikhi...
TO ALL THE YOUTH OUT THERE. DO NOT GET TANGLED UP IN JATHE-BANDHI'S. THIS MARG IS FOR YOU AS AN INDIVIDUAL, SEE WHAT HAPPENS WHEN YOU GET TOO INVOLVED, YOU TOO BEGIN TO THINK A LIE IS THE WORD OF GOD!
Re: Sant Jarnail Singh Declared Shaheed by Taksal
................ · 26 May 2005
these are no predictions for the future. Alot of this was happening even when baba ji was alive.
OK wrote:
> OK give evidence of when Baba Takhur Singh gave those 3
> Bachans:
>
> 1)baba ji wud hav nindia of dem dun alottt
> 2)sant je wud b declared shaheed at mehta
> 3)brothers wud b at eachothas throats jatha wud have problems.
>
> When was this said?
>
> Who heard it?
>
> Are there any recordings?
>
> You need to substantiate these rumours.
Re: Sant Jarnail Singh Declared Shaheed by Taksal
kharkoo singhnee · 26 May 2005
To "Think":
you got the wrong person