Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Gurbani

Gurbani

moorakh · 21 Aug 2003

Waheguroo ji ka Khalsa Waheguroo ji ki Fateh !! As far as i have understood, Guru Sahib's hukam is **Akhar likhe sayee gavan avar na jaana bani** Then why do some people sing other stuff specially this line i have heard many times "waheguroo waheguroo bol khalsa tera hira janam anmol khalsa" or "waheguroo boliye te kade vi na doliye" and many other like this... Then isn't this a wrong thing and anti gurmat practise... coz if we allow this to be sung, this might result in many other poems and kavita to come in and dilute sikh values. Even i heard some singhs when doing some paaths repeat the line from first shalok after every shaloks as is taught by some sants... why can't we listen what guru sahib teach us, why we have more faith in a sant/baba than Guru Sahib??? Well earlier so called ragi singhs used to do this but now Gursikhs obeying rehat are also heard doing this :-o... and i was shocked... so looking for sangat views on what they think on this? Bhul Chuk di Khima Daas Waheguroo ji ka Khalsa Waheguroo ji ki Fateh !!

Re: Gurbani

RoopKaur khalsa · 21 Aug 2003

VaheguruJiKaKhalsaVaheguruJiKiFateh I totally agree with "moorakh". katchi bani should not be added to bani. Gurbani is already perfect there is no need to add man made stuff to it. Another practice that involves this type of practice is saying "dhan sri guru granth sahib ji" or "dhan sri guru gobid singh ji"in the middle of a shabad. ho are we to break up a shabad and add our own lines in? If one really wants to do ustat of guru jis then they can do keertan of raamkali ki vaar but there is no need to interupt guru ji perfect bani to do so. VaheguruJiKaKhalsaVaheguruJiKiFateh ~RoopKaur Khalsa~

Re: Gurbani

Singh · 22 Aug 2003

Not only is Kachi Bani a problem, but mixing bani within other shabads as well. What right does anyone have to sing peevo pahul khand dhaar hoe janam sohela, in the middle of any given shabad? Then we have dhan guru dhan panj piyare, dhan Guru Gobind Singh Sahib during/between lines of any shabad? what is going on! Anything not written by Guru Sahib and Bhai Gurdas Ji, should not be sung in the devotional sense in a Gurdwara. Dhadhis/Kavishri Jathey are exempt as they do not sing Gurbani.

Re: Gurbani

Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 22 Aug 2003

Waheguru ji ka KHALSA Waheguru ji ki FATEH. IMHO I have to agree completely with MOORAKH JI and Bhen Ji Roop kaur and Singh Ji as well. Gurbani is Dhur Ki Bani Ayeee jin sagli chint mitayee - it is DIVINE and 100%++. The so called ragis have to add their own lines because they DO NOT SING in the ORIGINAL RAAG and their Hindi Bollywood tune adaptation sometimes leaves some sur short so they add their own lines. I also have a score to settle with some so called ragis who interrupt a beautiful shabad and start rambling on and on about some supposed "mahapurakh" sadh sant favourite of theirs and how he said this and said that......all this fairy tale stuff is supposed to go under the name of KATHA. The Sikh rehat maryada clearly stipulates that there should be ONLY ONE thing at any one time _ Akhand Paath/Kirtan/Katha/Jaap/simran. You cannot have an Akhand Paath going on and some people doing simran loudly or Kirtan Darbar at the same time. Similarly have ONLY KIRTAN or KATHA but not both mixed up. If You are explaining the meanings of the Shabad - well and fine - but telling stories and fairy tales etc is definitely OUT. Dassan Daas jarnail singh arshi gyani