Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Re: Baba Ram Singh

Re: Baba Ram Singh

singh · 22 May 2005

bhai sahib bhai randhir singh writes about him in jail chittiyan. baba ram singh was a good gursikh who fought against the british rule in india, his kurbani was great. Its just then that the naamdharis started saying you are our guru and stuff like that, but baba ji sent a letter to the naamdhari sangat saying I AM NOT UR GURU, the naamdharis ignored this and carried on saying that baba ram singh was there guru. I personally asked a naamdhari when i was debateing with him that baba ram singh sed he wasnt guru in jail then why do u still beieve he was the guru? He replied with that NO GURU SED THAT THEY ARE GURUS... what a lame answer. Dont fall in the traps of the naamdhari cult, u mite think they have wiked rehit and are into all this raag and stuff - but truthfully tapoban and india akj are even more strict than the naamdahris, the naamdharis are without a true guru so how can they make any progress? wjkk wjkf

Re: Baba Ram Singh

Jarnail Singh "Gyani "Arshi" · 23 May 2005

[gurbani] <>vwihgurU jI kI Piqh ][/gurbani] The Naamdharees "need" to say baba Raam Singh is GURU...else how to keep this "dukaan" going ?? Just like some Sikhs have to "keep on connecting their Jathedars to Guru Gobind Singh ji"..these naamdharees have to STICK with thier story about Raam singh as 11th GURU..so that they can continue this tale..and have 12th, 13th, 14th, 15th, 16th,17th,18th gurus...etc blah blah.. It si JUST a DUKAAn of Guruship...a fasle one if anyone ever saw one. [gurbani] <>vwihgurU jI kI Piqh ][/gurbani]

Re: Baba Ram Singh

jagjit Singh · 23 May 2005

waheguru ji kekhalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh Pyare jio, I have read Baba Ram singhs life story. At the end of it it had photocopies of his letters from jail just before he passed away. He specifically wrote to his followers telling to follow the Shabad Guru and not consider him as Guru. It was the British who bought out some of his followers who started this whole nonsense. Bhai ram Singh was a very high jeevan wale Gursikh. I believe davinder singh Toronto took that book from me. Possibly he may be able to scan it and put these letters on the messageboard. waheguru ji kekhalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh

Re: Baba Ram Singh

ekta · 23 May 2005

"The Naamdharees "need" to say baba Raam Singh is GURU...else how to keep this "dukaan" going ?? Just like some Sikhs have to "keep on connecting their Jathedars to Guru Gobind Singh ji"..these naamdharees have to STICK with thier story about Raam singh as 11th GURU..so that they can continue this tale..and have 12th, 13th, 14th, 15th, 16th,17th,18th gurus...etc blah blah.. It si JUST a DUKAAn of Guruship...a fasle one if anyone ever saw one." another attack on taksaal by jarnail Singh arashi, arashi why do ignore my posts that point out ur bias against the taksaal or ne other jatha bandi besides akj? u need 2 chill buddy.

Re: Baba Ram Singh

Me · 25 May 2005

Unfortunately some people cant live without taking a dig at someone or the other at least a couple of times a day. They must have done a lot of Naam Kamaee in their life, as they have so much for these things now.

Re: Baba Ram Singh

Search For TAT · 25 May 2005

you can slate Giani ji, but his comments are true!

Re: Baba Ram Singh

Me · 25 May 2005

oh yeah? where's your proof Gyani lover?

Re: Baba Ram Singh

Jarnail Singh "Gyani "Arshi" · 26 May 2005

[gurbani] <>vwihgurU jI kI Piqh ][/gurbani] and where's YOURS..you "gyani" HATER..you. chill out Me....man. Gurbani.Says....Gussah mann na Handeaeah....Heart Attacks are not cheap these days.... Gyani ki nindiya is just as bad...trust me i know. [gurbani] <>vwihgurU jI kI Piqh ][/gurbani]

Re: Baba Ram Singh

ekta · 26 May 2005

Gyani u soooo politley ignore these posts be a man! we must'n c a jathabandai we shoudl see a sikh. we should'nt see small beliefs such as raagmalla or kesi but rehit.

Re: Baba Ram Singh

Search For TAT · 26 May 2005

not a giani ji lover! I just do not accept made up history of Taksal. It was started by Sant Sundar Singh ji. You may doubt it, but who cares. Many of you could not even accept Sant jarnail singh jis shaheedi! "One lies leads to a thousand lies!"

Re: Baba Ram Singh

Jarnail Singh "Gyani "Arshi" · 27 May 2005

since "attack" on IDEAS/FACTS is just not possible under any circumstances...they take the sooooooooo easyyyyyyyyy wayyyy outttttt and start attacking the "person"..HOPING that this will DISCOURAGE him and he will STOP POSTING..Fat Hope. Didint Goebbels PROVE this...TELL a LIE a thousand times and it will begin "looking" like the "truth".... Thats the philosophy behind attaching "lines and lineaologies" to Guru Gobind Singh ji.....and making people you support instant Brahmgianis..but those that you dont support become instant ram/harnaam/dhumma etc. I have read the life of Gyani kartar Singh, Gyani Jarnail Singh Bhinderwalah, Gyani Gurbachan Singh Khalsa.....and find them very different from what these people "preach".... THEY always upheld the Panthic Maryada ( even though they practised their own privately), THEY supported Panthic UNITY and PYAAR, THEY NEVER attacked any other Gurmukh despite holding radically different views ( on ragmaala as an example..) and THEY NEVER NEVER allowed women in "private" sessions..IF nay woman persisted they would just get up and walk away. THats becasue THEY ahd Naam kamaii and strength fo moral character... These modern chelas have none of that and so they rely on the "killa jor" of Background/lineage..whatever to push through ( RAM through) their weird ideas. A THOUSAND LIES just to cover up ONE LIE....in this case a Shaheedee 21 years ago was covered up with 21,000 LIES...and a complete GENERATION of Sikh Leadership Development wasted. This is a common development..look at how Indira "killed" off every capable leader to retain her post, Nehru also did the same thing, Hitler did it, Stalin did it....ONLY a Capable Leader will NURTURE and PROMOTE the NEXT GENERATION Leadership fro smooth transition. But i digress and i am sorry.... but the SAME posters cover all the threads and they have the same stock "theroies" on all threads..

Re: Baba Ram Singh

Me · 27 May 2005

There is a Sakhi of Baba Nand Singh Jee which relates to Baba Ram Singh Jee. Babaji heard that Baba Ram Singh's sewak (Namdharis) used to wave the Chaur over him, and asked a sewadar to go and tell him that the Chaur should only be woven over Maharaj as He is the only one worthy of this honour. Also that it doesnt befit Sikhs to share this honour. Baba Ram Singh sent a message back saying that what can I do? They want to do this sewa, Im not asking them to am I? Baba Nand Singh Jee then said to him personally 'if a King asks his wazirs not to do something, even to stop serving him, they will obey, they wouldnt question, so why cant you tell them yourself?' Sorry for going off topic, but it just came to mind when I read this thread.

Re: Baba Ram Singh

ekta · 28 May 2005

"Thats the philosophy behind attaching "lines and lineaologies" to Guru Gobind Singh ji.....and making people you support instant Brahmgianis..but those that you dont support become instant ram/harnaam/dhumma etc." -agreed i for one never supported either.... what is this overnight crash course in how 2 become a brahmgiani? but the fact of the matter remains paji, u dun like the taksaal, u bash it....we must be panthic.... EFF all the jathabandais...they need 2 be dumped..... and united again under the NIshaan Sahib.

Re: Baba Ram Singh

Jarnail Singh "Gyani "Arshi" · 28 May 2005

dear Me jio, This is the FIRST i am hearing this sakhi. ALL fact based Historical Accounts including Chitthhian of Baba Raam Singh written by him convey that DURING HIS LIFETIME baba Raam Singh Ji was NOT Reverred as Guru Ji. Even the namdharee histories dont contain any such claims of he being CHAURED OVER. baba ji was Not a DANGER to the British as a GURU..they would have ENCOURAGED this as a further DIVISION and Destructive force in Sikhe ( as the Present daty baabs and sants are the Paltoos of the GOI to divide and destroy Sikhe)..Raam Singh Ji was a Danger as a Revolutionary Fighter for INDEPENDENCE and this was why he was Imprisoned SECRETLY and sent off to kala panni..and the Naamdharees were BLOWN away by cannons to DEMONISE them ( as the Kharkoos were demonised and destroyed by the GOI). Babab ji was a TRUE SINGH with BOTH MIRI and PIRI...not a chaur chhulawa "guru" ji of the type depicted in your version of the sakhi. The BRITISH would have loved Baba Raam Singh, Bhai Randheer Singh Ji, Bhai Maharaj Singh..if only they "supported " them and Divided the Sikhs..unfortunately all these Freedom Fighters refused to cooperate with the Briits and were either Banished/killed/jailed..IF these three had set up DERAS and established their own "guruships" they would have received HONOURS...but they couldnt trade their GURU-SIKHE for brit honours..and suffered their fate honourably. IF i am wrong please quote some historical sources for this sakhi.

Re: Baba Ram Singh

Me · 28 May 2005

It is possible what you are saying is right, I have only heard this from someone, have no sources stating this happened. Although it is in line with what Baba Nand Singh Jee advocated, which was to reserve all respect and glory to Guru Sahib. Interesting posts though.

Re: Baba Ram Singh

Khalsa_Force · 28 May 2005

>>>>>>>>Author: Me Date: 05-27-05 10:24 There is a Sakhi of Baba Nand Singh Jee which relates to Baba Ram Singh Jee. Babaji heard that Baba Ram Singh's sewak (Namdharis) used to wave the Chaur over him, and asked a sewadar to go and tell him that the Chaur should only be woven over Maharaj as He is the only one worthy of this honour. Also that it doesnt befit Sikhs to share this honour. Baba Ram Singh sent a message back saying that what can I do? They want to do this sewa, Im not asking them to am I? Baba Nand Singh Jee then said to him personally 'if a King asks his wazirs not to do something, even to stop serving him, they will obey, they wouldnt question, so why cant you tell them yourself?' Sorry for going off topic, but it just came to mind when I read this thread. <<<<<<<<<<<<<<< Any historical reference? i wud love to c it. and btw Nanaksarias LOVE Namdharis. they say they dont c ANY insult if namdharis dont take Sahib SGGS Ji as their guru.even UK-NANGS(sanatanis) have same views, they love Namdharis their RAAG thing and all tht stuff because(i think) their common cause is to defame Sri Akal Takht Sahib and its Maryada.

Re: Baba Ram Singh

Me · 28 May 2005

Khalsa_Force, grow up. I was talking about Baba Nand Singh Jee, if you are referring your comments to them then you seriously need to think about whether you really should post on forums. Also, you give me a historical proof showing Nanaksarias love Namdharis, would love to see it. I already told Jarnail Singh that I dont have a historical proof for that Sakhi but just heard it, do what you want about it.

Re: Baba Ram Singh

Jarnail Singh "Gyani "Arshi" · 28 May 2005

[gurbani] <>vwihgurU jI kI Piqh ][/gurbani] Dear Me jio, Its not myself that is "probably right"...all the FACTS point in that direction. Have you any single record of any so called "GURUS"...like Bedis, Sodhis, Baba Ji's of DERAS, Masands, Mukh-sewadaars of the "Takhats", Historical Gurdwaras..of THOSE TIMES IMPRISONED/JAILED/BANISHED...etc BY the BRITISH ???? Everybody knows very well WHO were the ones that were banished to kala Paani/underground Bhoras in Far away SINGAPORE, locked up and the keys THROWN AWAY, had their Family jaidaads confiscated, Zaddi houses destroyed, ..... these were TRUE to their SIKHE as well their COUNTRY. Then look at the Gurdwara Sudhaar Movement.....how many such "gurus", sants of the Deras, baba Ji's sent JATHAS of 500 Sikhs/sewaks to March along their Sikh brothers at Jaito,..they stood well aside to see the Tamasha..JUST like in 1978-to NOW. ALL these as they are NOW...were AGENTS of the Authorities bent on DESTROYING SIKHE and UNDERMINING MARYADA of GURUSHIP of KHALSA PANTH_GURU GRANTH JI, established by the Sikh GURUS. By the way it is quite common...and "fashionable" to find out something or some fact that no one can argue with...like say..ALL SIKHS MUST have DASWANDH.....and then attach this "FACT" to....Fallaneh baba Ji used to say...this"..... i have heard that Bhai Sahib Bhai Randheer Singh ji even as just a mucchh fut youngster, had the "courage" to sit right at the front of a diwan of Sant Attar Singh ji and SING out a "DHAARNA" that went AGAINST "Dhaarna theory"..this courage was what attracted sant ji to send for Bhai Randheer Singh ji and their friendship began. We all know that for any human to sit higher, or have a chaur over him in the presence of Guru granth ji Sahib is UNACCEPTABLE..and we would tell him off..Baba Nand Singh Ji may well have done this...or its just a sakhi...either way i agree that it is the right thing to say. [gurbani] <>vwihgurU jI kI Piqh ][/gurbani]

Re: Baba Ram Singh

Khalsa_Force · 29 May 2005

>>>>>>>>>>>Khalsa_Force, grow up. I was talking about Baba Nand Singh Jee, if you are referring your comments to them then you seriously need to think about whether you really should post on forums. <<<<<<<<<<<< and u have taken license of putting forward baseless sakhis and all tht stuff u post? tell me, how to apply it.

Re: Baba Ram Singh

sathari singh · 30 May 2005

Namdharis believe that Baba Ram singh is still alive and that he is a reincarnation of Guru Gobind Singh. Guru gobind singh they say said he would live for 250 years upon his return so they understand that Baba Ram singh is thus still alive and will return soon. As he is still alive the present people calling themselves Satgurus are in actual fact joti ka jama the form of the light. Namdharis believe in caste and don't dine with mazabhis and Westerners or forigners sikh or not Sikh. they also don't believe that these people can be saved without being reborn in caste sikh families. for their understanding of the Tenth gurus passing see; http://www.sikh-heritage.co.uk/frame.htm Also see the book Purakh Guru by Mehar Singh. Did anyone see anything avout caste in Baba Ram singh's writings?

Re: Baba Ram Singh

Me · 30 May 2005

Baseless? you call sakhis which give beautiful morals baseless? Dont ask me how to apply it, you dont have the brains obviously to apply anything. Now run off and make useless baseless posts elsewhere. Fool.