Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Re: Should we listen to raag maala?

Re: Should we listen to raag maala?

AK Santalee JR · 23 May 2005

WJKKWJKF!! Well said by my older bro... AK SANTALEE totally ripped it up with his posts! To the Anti-SREE RAAGMAALAA ppls out there, answer these questions... IS GURU SAHIB THE KING OF KINGS? ARE THEY ALL KNOWING AND ALL PREVADING? If your Answer is YES to both questions then do you really believe that the KING OF KINGS the ALL KNOWING and ALL PREVADING SATGURU will allow KACHI "PORNOGRAPHY" to be inserted and read within their Divaan?? DO U HAVE NO FAITH IN YOUR GURU WHATSOEVER?? Get real and start to imbue the Lords Simran and Bani within your hearts you will then understand and realise that Nimrata comes first. Humbly accept SREE RAAGMAALAA and then the World can start to live in peace! WJKKWJKF!! Dhan Dhan Satguru Sahib Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji Maharaj!! Ik Oankar - Atharah Das Bees 4 LYFEEEE!!! :D Bhul chuk maaf, dun mean to offend...plz do Ardas for the World... NANAK NAAM CHARDIKALA TERE BHANE SARBAT DA BHALA!!!!!

Re: Should we listen to raag maala?

NEUTRAL SIKH · 23 May 2005

ragmala is not found in all birs many birs without ragmala in were burnt most puratan birs with ragmala in also contain many other miscelaneous scriptures such as ratanmala if you accept ragmala, do you also accept ratanmala? I have faith that my GURU IS PERFECT , RAGMALA has IMPERFECTIONS - to start with the NUMBERING SYSTEM is completly WRONG. If you had faith that your guru is perfect you cannot accept ragmala.

Re: Should we listen to raag maala?

G · 23 May 2005

Dear AK Santalee JR, You are probably a young Singh full of lots of energy and excitement for Sikhi. It makes us happy to see youth with so much passion for Sikhi. You clearly have a very strong belief on the Raagmala issue amongst many. However, since you have done no research, you are wrong. If you look at old Birs of Guru Granth Sahib Ji, you will find that in many of them, possibly even the majority of them, there is Kachi Bani at the end - even after Raagmala. eg/ Rag Ramkali Ratanmala. Such a composition was unanimously removed by the Sikh Panth in the early to mid 20th century, along with many others. Raagmala is not Pornography but rather is part of an erotic story. Please re read Kulbir Singhs post and answer his question. You claim if we all accept Raagmala we will live in peace. To the contrary, Sikhism has been on a slippery slope downwards ever since Jasbir Singh Rode forced the reading of Raagmala at the Akal Takht. So your argument is invalid. Daas, GSD

Re: Should we listen to raag maala?

Search For TAT · 23 May 2005

Ak SANTALee has only demonstrated his fundmaentalist taksali views. As soon as you start having a sensible conversation, someone comes up with this rubbish. Firstly your whole argument is false. There was kacchi bani considered part of the Guru granth Sahib, and it came before raagmala. It was called rattan mala and other compositions. Even the Taksalee leaders and sants accepted it should be removed and it was! Did they not have faith in Guru ji? So your own so called brahmgianis accept people have tried to manipulate the Guru Granth Sahib. The number system does not allow this, but anyone can add somethinga t the end. The fact that it was before raagmala also questions the validity of raagmala. lastly your arguments about baba Thakur Singh. When people have lost the debate they bring personalities into it. How shameful? Many people do not accept Baba tahkur Singh as a brahmgiani, if they did taksal itself would not be fighting over whether Sant jarnail Singh should be called shaheed or not? So before pointing fingers in outrage about people questioning your brahmgianis views, look inside your own house!

Re: Should we listen to raag maala?

raag maala is not bani · 23 May 2005

xcuse me but wat about rattan mal and recipies for ink, they wer put into the guru grath sahib jee, but they were taken out. so kuchi bani was put into guru granth sahib jee, but THEN IT WAS REMOVED. raag maala is NOT bani. it is beadbi of guru granth sahib jee, to alloe kuchi bani to say in the guru grath sahib jee.

Re: Should we listen to raag maala?

AK Santalee JR · 23 May 2005

WJKKWJKF!! Do you think that we are going to go the rest of our lives with a Guroo that is "KACHI" I dont think so! Wake up! As for your views on Sant Baba Thakur Singh ji thats up to you...no one can change your opinion but EVERY JATHA ACCEPTED THEM AS A SANT all except the "MAN MADE ONES!" WJKKWJKF!!

Re: Should we listen to raag maala?

G · 23 May 2005

Conversely, Mr Santali, how do you think Singhs of the 18th, 19th and early 20th centuries coped with Maharaj's Saroops containing material that even you do not consider as Bani? Please think intellectually for a moment. Rise above the group politics, and use your Guru-given intellect. Daas, GSD

Re: Should we listen to raag maala?

NY Singh · 23 May 2005

AK Santalee jr, Taksal and other groups that claim to have a lineage to Guru Gobind Singh Jee are also man made as SGPC, AKJ, Missionary, and akalis are. Although many groups claim to have lineage dating back to Guru Jee, but none of those lineages are have any hard evidence to be factual enough to be supported by Sikh scholars. They are more fairy tale then fact.

Re: Should we listen to raag maala?

indy · 23 May 2005

kar kirpaa sabh rayN thheevaa best comment came from this singh/singhni. We have no eekta or humility as a panth, how are we going to be strong when we need to be, when we are fighting over petty things like this. However strongly someone feels about Raagmala, the next person will think just as strongly against it. Wait for a decision from the Panth (Sarbat Khalsa) until then we should be more humble and be ready to pick up a Gutka Sahib not a Kirpan. Apologies for any offence to anyone.

Re: Should we listen to raag maala?

Bijla Singh · 24 May 2005

Stop fighting like two cats while a monkey (GOI) is eating up our roots, history, language and culture. If you really care about GuruBani then do something about bhanoo moortee and dehdhari pakhandees. Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh

Re: Should we listen to raag maala?

Admin · 24 May 2005

topic closed.