Panthic News: UK Gurdwara allows meat & sharaab
Manvir Singh · 08 May 2005
shame shame shame! http://www.panthic.org/news/124/ARTICLE/1314/2005-05-08.html
Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton
ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥
Manvir Singh · 08 May 2005
shame shame shame! http://www.panthic.org/news/124/ARTICLE/1314/2005-05-08.htmlPardeep Singh Bilga · 09 May 2005
Well surprise surprise..."Ramgharia" .."Gurdwara"....this is not something new...you can go to almost any Ramgharia, Ravidasia "Temple" in the UK and you will find adjacent community halls that are regularly hired out for parties where alcohol, meat etc is consumed…but, still, we get the “Jatt bashers" always going on about so called "Jatt supremacy" in Sikh Gurdwaray.....how many Sikh (Sikh meaning Singh Sabha, Guru Nanak Gurdwara - proper SIKH Gurdwaray) Gurdwaray do you see that have these type of halls?.......sorry, but don't these people believe in BHAGAT Ravidas as GURU???...don't these "Ramgharias" believe in BABA Ram Singh as GURU???...how can we call these Gurdwaray???...they are not, as they do not even believe in the basic Sikh principles....lets concentrate on making the SIKH Gurdwaray better...why waste time on energy on Ramgharia and Ravidasia TEMPLES....do we start going to Radhasoami deras and Narkdhari Bhawans and trying to install Gurmat ideas there???...wake up everybody and realise that people who go to Ravidas and Ramgharia temples are NOT Sikhs (in the Khalsa sense).Maanas Ki Jaat Eik Hain · 09 May 2005
That's a bit of a stereotype Pardeep Singh Ji. I can't help but agree with you on some points, but the beadbi of today is done is many Gurdwaras. Yesterday over 50 Naujawaan confronted the committee of Gurdwara Singh Sabha East London in Barking (a full "jatt" committee) and believe me, you had to be in the meeting to realise how bad things are at the moment. The modern day Gurdwara committees are the Masands of today.The East London Sangat will tell you more. Unfortunatly Guruji's beadbi seems to be a common practice performed by many Gurdwara Committees, not all of them are from Tarkhaan or Chamar backgrounds, SOME ARE EVEN JATTS. Sorry to break you heart Pardeep Singh Ji. PS Why not try dropping the Bilga and adopt Singh!not film fan · 09 May 2005
ramgarhia slough was slated on Punjab radio this saturday morning for letting Amitabh Bachan and asihwariya rai do a mock wedding in the darbaar sahinb. The gurdwara was packed full of sikh, muslim, and hindu film fans, many with out covering their heads. The director was sitting in his directors chair in the darbaaar. The wedding cinsisted of 4 lawaans. Punjab radio totally slated the Ramgarhia leadership. They guy behind this was their general sec, a dodgy solicitor called Amarjit Baachu.Manjit kaur Sidhu · 09 May 2005
IF I am not wrong, the BIGGEST and OLDEST Gurdwara Sahib in Kuala Lumpur Malaysia....Tatt Khalsa Diwan ( known as the Garrh of the now defunct Panch khalsa Diwan or Bhasaurrias..and mainly MALAWA JATTS) has such a HALL at the back where wedding dinners are held and all is OK (meaning hallal meat and sharaab are allowed to be served) The "Fundamentalist Maryada followers" ( those who hate the sgpc marayda) are holding their GURBANI CLASSES in the Same Building... This Gudwara as recently in the news as the 80th Anniversary dinner had hallal meat/sharaab/and a ex-sikh converted to Islam as its chief Entertainer on Stage to raise Funds for the Building fund.. so not much of a surprise to me.....the rot is sure spreading fast Mkkiran · 09 May 2005
I FEEL PAIN IN MY HEART WHEN EVER I SEE A BOARD SAYING RAMGAHRIA SIKH GURDWARA !!!!!!! WHY CAN'T THEY HAVE JUST SIKH OR GURSIKH GURDWARA [%sig%]Amar Singh · 09 May 2005
Pardeep Singh Bilga, Before going on your pro-Jatt crusade, please note that many "Singh Sabha", or "Proper" Gurdwaras, as you call them, do in fact suffer from the same problem, in fact in some cases even worse, for instance the Gurdwara in Leeds on Chapel Road where during a wedding of a Gursikh couple last year, the night before a party in the hall adjoining the main Gurdwara Building and sharing the same carpark had good old "Put Jatta De" being blasted from inside, that one could hear it across the entire car park and when I parked my car, I was shocked to discover tumblers of half filled booze in the car park (where clearly the 'proper' Gurdwara attendants had been having a good ol'chit chat to get away from the thumping of the bass and dhol inside the hall). What made it even worse, was when I entered the gurdwara building, the Singhs I met inside, despite being adorned in Cholas, Round turbans and taksali kirpans, remained oblivious to the goings on in the car park and their complex and even had the audacity to ask me if I had the right Gurdwara because I was wearing shirt, trousers and of course the good old anti-gurmat folded turban! For the record, no I am not supporting the actions of the above mentioned 'Ramgarhia' Gurdwara, simply challenging this notion of supposed anti-caste behaviour until something wrong is done by another group that when it appears to be fine to bring in such distinctions.Manvir Singh · 09 May 2005
Where ever Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji lives is a Guru-Ghar. Whether it be labelled "Ravidaas" , "Ramgarhia", "Bhatra" or "Baalmik" Gurdwara does not change the fact that Guru Nanak Paatshaah di Jaagdi jyot, Haajraa Hajoor, Boldi Aatma is Baraajmaan on the Takhat Sahib inside the Gurdwara.singh · 09 May 2005
One Gursikh from Leeds described, “In this meeting Jaikaras were sounded in favour of allowing Bujjar Kuraits (consumption of meat and alcohol) on Gurdwara premises.” Eating meat is not a Kurehit as per Akal Takht maryada. Jarnail Singh and Gurcharan Singh can probably tell you that the majority of Sikhs in the Far East conform to this view. It is wrong to make money by throwing parties however, where alcohol is consumed. I am fully aware of the jatha's stance on this issue and will not get involved in a slanging match of who is right or wrong. This is my personal opinion and I stand by it wholeheartedly... · 09 May 2005
same as guru gobing singh gurudwara in bradford and wakfield road gurudwara there halls are just next door why don't people target them atleast the gurudwara in leeds the hall is quite far away like 5 minute walk and the building is completley seprate don't get me wrong im so against it. but these halls in bradford are just next door where regular bhangra partys take place etc why don't you target the more important issues first. im getting annoyed that these gurudwarai in bradford are being ignored when they are much more damaging.Pardeep Singh Bilga · 10 May 2005
Whoa...hold on a minute...I am in NO way promoting Jatts as the best Gursikhs, as many are nowhere near being Sikh at all, but my point is we usually get accused for all sorts like "Jatts have their own Gurdwaray, so we have our own"...who has ever seen a Gurdwara called "Jatt Temple" or similar???.... Also, veer Manvir Singh ji wrote: Whether it be labelled "Ravidaas" , "Ramgarhia", "Bhatra" or "Baalmik" Gurdwara does not change the fact that Guru Nanak Paatshaah di Jaagdi jyot, Haajraa Hajoor, Boldi Aatma is Baraajmaan on the Takhat Sahib inside the Gurdwara....i Is this even the case?...I have heard the Ravidas Temples have a different version of saloks/prayers etc that they read...can this be classed as Guru?....they have monay doing kirtan...is this not beadbi if the true guru is present?Amar Singh · 10 May 2005
What is so painful about names such as Ramgarhia Gurdwara or Ravidasi Gurdwara? For started neither are caste names, but simply titles of Sikh Misls and Bhagats, if they have certain 'communities' present within and are run exclusively by non-Jatts, well then there is a good reason for that too -look at the cause rather than simply shouting at the result of the very questionable actions of others.waheguru · 10 May 2005
This seems to be turning into a slanging match by people associated with various gurdwaras The point there is beadbi happening everywhere and something needs to be doneAmar Singh · 10 May 2005
'waheguru' This is not intended to be a Gurdwara-vs-Gurdwara discussion, Pradeep Singh "Bilga" is the one who could have easily raised the point concerning beadbi without indirectly going into his "Put Jatta Deh" mode, mind he is not alone in such thinking.Akaal · 10 May 2005
1. Brahman 2. Khatri 3. Shoodar (jtts, tarkhan, etc.) 4. Vaish (chooras chammars, etc.) So jatt is low caste. This is hinduism. If you want to follow caste system, might as well join hinduism. There is no caste system in Sikhism. Upmaa Khalsay Jaat Na Khaee.Pardeep Singh Bilga · 11 May 2005
Amar Singh, sorry to offend - obviously in your rulebook, Sikhs should use their surname (got) instead of village name? Pardeep Singh "Sanghera"S Singh · 11 May 2005
Not the "jatts" who go out the way to promote division by naming Gurdwara on a caste basis. We all know who they are. Yet to see a Gurdwara named Jatt Gurdwara, plenty of Ramgharia Gurdwara... · 11 May 2005
can you guys stop discussing caste? this topic is not about caste ! start a new thread Manvir Singh wrote: > shame shame shame! >Gurcharan Singh Kulim · 11 May 2005
Bhai sahibs, Please venture beyond the caste issue, you will see there are greater panthic issues. We all know, it is wrong and improper, and throtllling Sikhi when we do name gurduaras on caste basis. There is just NO justification for that.Sikhi was not to remain within these small circles whther be misl based or caste based. Can you all please return to the issue--the abuse that goes on in GURDUARAS, not display egos, or side track please on to something else. You all on the wrong track, please think what justices are you doing to your own mentality or the Panthic by arguing ? Let us handle the real issues that threaten the kaum, once we have sorted that out, let us see if we can change the names of the Gurduaras to just Singh sabha or the Guru names, or just the Sikh Gurduara, Ilford or New Ham or Penang.TUBBY · 11 May 2005
GOING BACK TO THE ORIGINAL POST , WHAT SHOULD WE DO ABOUT ALL THESE GURUDWARA ??????.. · 11 May 2005
well said gurcharan singhNovtej Singh · 11 May 2005
Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh To my knowledge (which is not much anyway) the nishan sahib is a sign of a Panthic Institution and so whatever goes on in its preimises is wrong whether it be next door to the gurdwara or a '5 minute' walk. It is sad to regret that most of these 'gurdwaras' initially built halls with the intention of allowing the consumption of meat and alcohol thus creating a form of revenue. This gurdwara wants to make it official to allow meat and alcohol to prevent it being disallowed by panthic sevadaars. I guess more people will book their halls for party's and so more £££s for them. Some gurdwaras claim they dont serve meat and alcohol but still blast loud music.... it's still manmat and should be stopped. Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh [%sig%]S Singh · 11 May 2005
We can do nothing until the Jathedar of the Akal Takht makes a stand against these issues. Next time he is in the UK he should be approached and made aware of the need to summon a few of these manmat charlies to the Akal Takht to explain themselves. The reason why such behaviour continues is becasue the Jathedar of the Takht fails to take the initiative and punish a few people.Singh · 11 May 2005
Hows about forceably taking down the nishaan sahib and taking out all GGSJ Saroops. therefore, it isn't a Gurdwara then is it. just a suggestion.ranjabangyajogihonsinghbanu · 11 May 2005
caste is stupid. the real problem is far worse than people imagine, look what happened at the "singh v singh " in west coast america when media reported supposed khalistani singhs were funneling drug money, doing dodgy deals, and creating one man style council actually turned out to be a bunch of monnei criminal bullies from india. Its a drop in the ocean the legacy left behind by the old fauji singhs came abroad to work hard and made gurdwarey outside with their own hands. now society changed more bad elements want control of the gurdwara cos of its daswand.ranjabangyajogihonsinghbanu · 11 May 2005
singh v singh happened in a gurdwara in america where the criminals threatened to kidnap and kill a singh protesting against their bullieing. so it happens in all kinds of gurdwaras not just ramgharia.ns · 11 May 2005
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ke Fateh It's high time there were respresentatives to the AKal Takhat in countries outside India, if that existed then it would contain such stupid committees of Gurdwara's passing such resolutions. The panth really is in dire straits when will authorities such as the Akal Takth realize that it needs reps outside of India so rehat maryada is adhered to stricitly. This one Gurdwara could take lead and provide example to others that have been thinking along the same lines, how many will turn this way till the KHALSA wake up...May Guru Ji help us in somehow catching the falling knife of the Sikh panth and restoring from the gutter which is it in at present.